Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Helping the Overwhelmed Employee Without Micromanaging
Transcript
- Lucas: So you've got an employee who says they're overwhelmed, and you want to help. But every time you offer support, they just nod and come back next week with the same complaint. Sound familiar? Luna: Yeah, that's a classic pattern. You want to be empathetic, but it's hard to tell if it's a workload problem or a prioritization problem. Lucas: Exactly. And if you jump in and start reassigning tasks, you risk taking away their autonomy. They feel like you don't trust them, or worse, they learn that saying 'overwhelmed' gets them out of work. Luna: So what do you do instead? I've seen managers try everything from flexible hours to hiring an intern, but if the root cause isn't addressed, it doesn't stick. Lucas: Right. Let me walk through a case. I worked with a marketing coordinator at a mid-size SaaS company. She was smart, capable, but every Monday she'd tell her manager, 'I'm drowning.' So the manager asked her to keep a time log for one week—every 30 minutes, note what she was doing. Luna: Oh, I like that. It's concrete. Did she actually do it? Lucas: She did. And what came back was pretty revealing. She was spending about 60 percent of her week on tasks like formatting slides, updating a shared calendar, and responding to CC'd emails that didn't require her input. Those are all low-impact activities. Luna: So the busy work was eating her alive. The manager's natural instinct might be to just take those tasks away, but then she'd lose ownership of even the small stuff. Lucas: Exactly. So instead, the manager used the time log as a coaching tool. In their next 1-on-1, they said, 'Let's look at this together. Which of these tasks actually move the needle on your quarterly goals? Which are busywork you could automate, delegate, or drop entirely?' Luna: That shifts the ownership back to her. She's the one deciding, not being told. Lucas: Right. And they came up with a plan: she'd automate the calendar updates using a simple integration, delegate the slide formatting to a junior intern once a week, and stop responding to CC'd emails unless her name was in the 'to' field. That freed up 15 hours a week. Luna: Fifteen hours. That's huge. But I have to think some managers hear that and worry about losing control. How do you maintain visibility without micromanaging? Lucas: That's the key. You set a boundary: I'll trust you to manage your time, but I need one thing—a weekly one-pager. Three bullet points: what you accomplished, what you're stuck on, and what you're prioritizing next. It gives you confidence that they're on track, and it keeps them accountable. Luna: That's a simple tool. So the overwhelmed employee learns to triage their own work, and the manager stays in their lane as a coach, not a dispatcher. Lucas: Exactly. And here's something interesting: after a month, the coordinator actually started coming to her 1-on-1s saying, 'I have too much on my plate, but here's what I'd like to drop.' She went from feeling overwhelmed to feeling in control. Luna: That's the goal. But let's be real—sometimes the employee really is overloaded because the team's just understaffed. How do you distinguish genuine overwork from poor time management? Lucas: Good question. Look for patterns. If they consistently miss deadlines across all types of tasks, including ones they used to handle easily, it's probably genuine. But if they ace the exciting project and let the routine stuff slide, that's a prioritization issue. The time log approach works for both—it surfaces the data. Luna: And if it is understaffing, you can take that data to leadership. 'My team is carrying three extra projects this quarter. Here's the hours log. Something's got to give.' That's powerful. Lucas: Right. So the core move is: don't assume what's going on. Ask the employee to bring the data. Coach them to make the call. And hold them accountable for the plan they create. That builds trust and reduces overwhelm long-term. Luna: And if they keep coming back saying they're overwhelmed even after the plan? Lucas: Then it's a different conversation—about capacity, career fit, or maybe they need help with focus. But at least you have evidence, not guesswork. You can say, 'Here's what we agreed, and here's what happened. Let's figure out what's blocking you.' That's real coaching. Luna: Yeah, it's about building their problem-solving muscle, not just solving it for them. I think that's something every manager can apply this week. Lucas: Absolutely. And on that note—if you've found this kind of practical advice useful, we want to thank the listeners who keep this show ad-free. A small group of you chip in monthly through Buy Me a Coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's what lets us make these episodes for everyone. So if you've gotten value, consider joining them. No pressure, just a note of gratitude. Luna: Yeah, it really helps. Even a few dollars a month goes a long way to keep the lights on here. Lucas: So back to our overwhelmed employee. We've talked about time logs and one-pagers. But what about the manager who's overwhelmed themselves? Sometimes the employee mirrors the leader. Luna: Ooh, that's a good point. If you're constantly saying 'I'm swamped' to your team, they'll feel permission to do the same. Modeling calm prioritization sets the tone. Lucas: Exactly. One senior leader I know literally writes 'buffer time' into his calendar—two hours a day blocked for thinking, not meetings. He tells his team, 'This is when I plan, so I don't react all day.' That small habit trickles down. Luna: So the antidote to overwhelm might be less about doing more and more about choosing what not to do. That's a hard skill to teach, but leading by example helps. Lucas: Yeah. To sum it up: when an employee says they're overwhelmed, resist the urge to rescue. Instead, ask them to track their time for a week. In the next 1-on-1, go through it together and let them identify the low-value tasks. Then agree on a plan and a simple accountability structure—like the one-pager. Over time, they'll build the muscle of prioritization. Luna: And you'll have a team member who owns their workload, not just a manager who assigns it. That's a win-win. Lucas: Exactly. Thanks for joining us on Manager Mondays. We'll be back next week with another real-world leadership challenge.