Latest / Surrounded / Are We Really Going To End All Abortions? | Surrounded Follow-Up w/ Lila Rose
Transcript
- 0:00This is the first episode of the podcast
- 0:02I've recorded since the assassination of Charlie Kirk.
- 0:05He was the first guest ever at the center of Surrounded,
- 0:09and that video today is the most viewed video on Jubilee's channel.
- 0:13We were horrified by his murder,
- 0:16and I was also stunned by the public forgiveness of the man who killed him
- 0:20by his wife Erica Kirk.
- 0:22We need more of that in this world.
- 0:26I've been working with Jubilee for nearly a decade now,
- 0:29and our work has always been mission driven.
- 0:32That's not to say that we haven't drifted from
- 0:34or fallen short of that mission at times because we have
- 0:37and we will.
- 0:38Not all of Jubilee's content
- 0:40presses on identity
- 0:42and politics
- 0:43as urgently as Surrounded does.
- 0:45But the videos that do are important
- 0:47and they're impactful
- 0:49because they are a snapshot of our society.
- 0:52They are part of a practice that we remain committed to,
- 0:55and they are intertwined with core values that Jubilee
- 0:58is founded upon and cannot exist without
- 1:01freedom of thought,
- 1:03freedom of speech,
- 1:04honesty,
- 1:05vulnerability,
- 1:07humanity,
- 1:08and empathy.
- 1:10We reject the violence that was used to silence Charlie Kirk.
- 1:14While his opinions were often controversial,
- 1:16his voicing of them was part of a common project that we share.
- 1:20We believe in a society where people must come together
- 1:23peacefully
- 1:24and use words to address their differences,
- 1:27as challenging as that may be.
- 1:29Our thoughts go out to the family of Charlie Kirk,
- 1:32all of those who loved him,
- 1:34anyone who witnessed his murder,
- 1:36as well as anyone in the world right now whose voice is being silenced,
- 1:39and we ask that our leaders remain committed to an open society
- 1:44that embraces debate and humanity
- 1:46over violence and dehumanization.
- 1:50Thanks for listening.
- 1:51Let's get into today's episode.
- 1:55Our guest today is Lila Grace Rose.
- 1:57She is a pro-life activist who debated 25
- 2:00pro-choice activists earlier this year on Surrounded.
- 2:04We're gonna react to some of the most heated
- 2:05and interesting interactions that occurred in her episode.
- 2:08We discussed the Catholic approach to sex and reproduction,
- 2:12whether or not life begins at conception,
- 2:15as well as her controversial vision of a world without abortions.
- 2:19So without further ado,
- 2:20here's our conversation.
- 2:23Leila,
- 2:24welcome to the Surrounded Follow-up.
- 2:26Uh,
- 2:26I wanna dig into
- 2:28some highlights,
- 2:29um,
- 2:30and some of the discussions from your episode.
- 2:32Your
- 2:33episode of Surrounded,
- 2:35you were one of the first guests.
- 2:36I,
- 2:36I can't remember if you were the second episode,
- 2:38but you were,
- 2:39you were definitely one of the,
- 2:40the earliest episodes,
- 2:41and I'm just curious,
- 2:42you know,
- 2:43there's been some months that have passed,
- 2:44um,
- 2:45since you've done it,
- 2:47and
- 2:48I just kind of wanted to hear from you before we dig into any highlights.
- 2:52What were your thoughts going into it,
- 2:54um,
- 2:54and what have your thoughts been after the experience and just seeing it,
- 2:58um,
- 2:59you know,
- 2:59kind of disseminated across,
- 3:01uh,
- 3:02the,
- 3:02the internet.
- 3:04I thought it was great.
- 3:05I thought it was
- 3:06awesome of Jubilee to put together a group of people
- 3:10who disagreed,
- 3:11but were willing to dialogue with somebody that they disagreed with.
- 3:14I was
- 3:15honored to get to represent the pro-life position and
- 3:19The rights of all human beings,
- 3:21you know,
- 3:21being the person who was surrounded,
- 3:22and,
- 3:23you know,
- 3:24in the aftermath,
- 3:25I was really blown away by how many people came up to me afterwards,
- 3:28uh,
- 3:29people who watched the episode
- 3:31and were encouraged by it.
- 3:33They were inspired
- 3:34by it.
- 3:35They
- 3:36maybe heard the new point of view for the first time on life and.
- 3:39The value of unborn lives and they were very moved.
- 3:43And I remember after the conversation,
- 3:45one of the
- 3:45girls came up to me and said,
- 3:47kind of whispered in my ear,
- 3:48this was one of the women who was at the surrounded um event and she said to me,
- 3:53uh,
- 3:53you know,
- 3:54I actually agree with you.
- 3:55And so I think that was really compelling to that the
- 3:58dialogue that we were able to have helped change your mind
- 4:01on life
- 4:02and,
- 4:02and the value of human life.
- 4:05Mhm
- 4:06Yeah,
- 4:07and um
- 4:08it's obviously
- 4:09uh
- 4:10a divisive issue as far back as I can remember.
- 4:13Um
- 4:14I'm 36 and so,
- 4:17you know,
- 4:17born in '89,
- 4:19I can remember as far as
- 4:21back as my political
- 4:22kind of consciousness goes that abortion has been.
- 4:25Um,
- 4:26divisive and
- 4:28a very complicated and difficult thing to discuss
- 4:31in public,
- 4:33um,
- 4:33but very strongly held beliefs
- 4:36on both sides.
- 4:37And so I,
- 4:38I thought it was very valuable.
- 4:39I,
- 4:40I know there are some moments that everybody has seen from the episode that are,
- 4:44you know,
- 4:45maybe,
- 4:45uh,
- 4:45the spiciest,
- 4:47but I,
- 4:47I thought this discussion had a lot of really interesting nuance to it.
- 4:51Um,
- 4:52and so I want to dig into your claims.
- 4:54This was maybe the most heated moment I can recall,
- 4:57um,
- 4:58but it's really interesting kind of the story,
- 5:00uh,
- 5:00that they share with you.
- 5:01So let's,
- 5:02let's kind of refresh our memories and then we'll react.
- 5:05If I had carried a term,
- 5:06I would be labeled a drug addicted black mother,
- 5:08and if I had kept the baby,
- 5:09I would have been labeled an
- 5:11incompetent single mother.
- 5:14So my question for you is,
- 5:16what is
- 5:17your perception of how I should feel about my abortion?
- 5:20So a couple things.
- 5:21First of all,
- 5:22sometimes a regret happens later in life.
- 5:24It's not within even 5 or 10 years that trauma they feel might
- 5:27come out later when they have their own other children or grandchildren.
- 5:30So every woman,
- 5:31it's going to be different.
- 5:32Sometimes it's immediate,
- 5:33sometimes it takes years.
- 5:35I mean,
- 5:35I think,
- 5:36I think you're amazing.
- 5:37I think if that's what you've overcome in your life,
- 5:38I think that's incredible,
- 5:40and you should be proud of overcoming so many tough things in your life.
- 5:43It does break my heart that if you're sharing you had an abortion,
- 5:46that there could be a child,
- 5:48I don't know how old they'd be,
- 5:4810 years old today,
- 5:49who would be cheering you on,
- 5:50saying,
- 5:51go get him,
- 5:51Mom.
- 5:51You got this.
- 5:52I can promise you that would not be the case because I can
- 5:55almost promise you that would not be the case because I say again,
- 5:58I'm in a domestic violence shelter.
- 5:59I've got a dog.
- 6:01I can barely.
- 6:02Take care of you're expecting,
- 6:03excuse me,
- 6:04you're expecting me to sit here
- 6:06and let you tell me how I'm supposed to feel.
- 6:08You're trying to scare me.
- 6:10I'm not telling you how to feel.
- 6:11Yes,
- 6:11you are.
- 6:11Yes,
- 6:12I'm not telling you how to feel with your statistics,
- 6:13but I am telling you that your baby,
- 6:14your statistics and your information with your statistic
- 6:18and your information had a right to live.
- 6:20You are completely wrong because yes,
- 6:21and I wish someone had been helping you more.
- 6:22Listen,
- 6:23that's the thing,
- 6:23listen,
- 6:23but you deserve more help.
- 6:25Everybody always likes to say,
- 6:26oh,
- 6:26keep the baby,
- 6:27give it up for adoption.
- 6:28I know.
- 6:28Our foster care system is like,
- 6:30when you,
- 6:30but you can't tell me I would have a child
- 6:32cheering me on when you place a child for adoption.
- 6:35Hold on,
- 6:35you're not just going to foster.
- 6:36You don't get to speak for my child.
- 6:38You don't get to speak for my child.
- 6:40Let's start right there.
- 6:42You don't get to speak for my child saying,
- 6:43oh,
- 6:43mommy would be cheering you on and everything like that.
- 6:45You don't know that.
- 6:46You don't know that at all.
- 6:47You don't know what my child would be.
- 6:48I,
- 6:49I may not even have my child
- 6:51because I was so unfit at the time.
- 6:52Drug addiction,
- 6:53sex work,
- 6:54everything like that.
- 6:54Yes,
- 6:55well,
- 6:55I'm a.
- 6:55Proud pro ho.
- 6:56That is exactly what I do.
- 6:58But you're telling me how my child would feel
- 7:01and what gives you the right.
- 7:02What gives you the right?
- 7:04What gives you the right?
- 7:05I would love to respond to you.
- 7:07I would love to respond to you.
- 7:08I think,
- 7:09yes,
- 7:09your,
- 7:09your child had a right to life.
- 7:11And I would say that there are,
- 7:12I wish there were more people helping you at the time.
- 7:14It sounds like you were at a really rough time in your life,
- 7:17and I think that you mattered,
- 7:18that baby mattered,
- 7:19and you both deserved more help.
- 7:21That's what I would say.
- 7:22Jumping right in,
- 7:24a lot to absorb there.
- 7:25Um,
- 7:27what are your thoughts,
- 7:28uh,
- 7:28Lila,
- 7:28just
- 7:29reliving that moment?
- 7:31It's so sad,
- 7:33John.
- 7:33It's so sad because
- 7:35I think a lot of people in the comment section,
- 7:37I remember afterwards was saying,
- 7:38see,
- 7:39they're,
- 7:39they're proving her point that abortion
- 7:41is wounding because of even the emotional responses that,
- 7:45that she is just eliciting people getting so angry or so hurt
- 7:50because
- 7:51that was a life,
- 7:52that was a son or a daughter that is no longer with us.
- 7:55And,
- 7:56you know,
- 7:56I think Jack's prints,
- 7:57like some of her comments about,
- 7:59well,
- 7:59I was going through so horrible,
- 8:02such,
- 8:02such a horrible situation,
- 8:03right?
- 8:03And she was,
- 8:04it sounds like she was going through
- 8:05the worst situation.
- 8:07And I was trying to explain to her,
- 8:08you know,
- 8:08if you felt you were not able to parent.
- 8:11There are
- 8:12truly 2 million couples right now wanting to adopt,
- 8:17you know,
- 8:17the,
- 8:17the numbers say up to 2 million couples,
- 8:19certainly in the hundreds of thousands of couples
- 8:21who would love to adopt a baby.
- 8:23They don't,
- 8:23the babies don't go into foster care.
- 8:24They go to a family and the birth mom can actually pick the family that she wants.
- 8:29She can have
- 8:30as little or as,
- 8:31as,
- 8:31as much interaction as she wants with that family,
- 8:33with that baby in the future based on the parameters she sets,
- 8:36but
- 8:37that,
- 8:37that would have been another option for Jack.
- 8:40And I think the
- 8:43The fact that she didn't.
- 8:45For whatever reasons at the time,
- 8:46she didn't know about that option or she wasn't
- 8:49given enough support to be able to explore
- 8:52that option and instead she chose abortion.
- 8:54It's,
- 8:55it's devastating because a whole person's life was snuffed out.
- 8:58And I do think
- 8:59there is trauma deep down that she is living with.
- 9:03The most important thing is that the child's life was snuffed out,
- 9:05but I do think that it is damaging to women,
- 9:07and I,
- 9:08I think that conversation
- 9:09showed that.
- 9:11Mhm,
- 9:12I definitely felt,
- 9:13um,
- 9:13there was a lot of pain there for sure.
- 9:15It was,
- 9:16um,
- 9:17it was a painful thing to discuss.
- 9:19I
- 9:20and I thought you both were doing your best to
- 9:22handle it sensitively,
- 9:24and I,
- 9:25I appreciated what,
- 9:26um
- 9:28She shared
- 9:29a question I have for you,
- 9:31um,
- 9:33You know,
- 9:33cause I,
- 9:33I,
- 9:34I'm trying to educate myself,
- 9:36um,
- 9:36around the statistics and,
- 9:38and so,
- 9:40yes,
- 9:40there are a lot of parents um who are
- 9:42on waitlists
- 9:43for adoption,
- 9:44and so that's certainly an option for somebody who finds themselves
- 9:48in an unwanted pregnancy,
- 9:50um,
- 9:50in a difficult,
- 9:51in under difficult circumstances.
- 9:53When we think about
- 9:55the scope of
- 9:57You know,
- 9:58I know,
- 9:58I know your mission is to eliminate abortion entirely.
- 10:02And when we think about where unwanted pregnancies occur the most,
- 10:06unfortunately,
- 10:07they do occur,
- 10:08I think,
- 10:09primarily in people who are
- 10:11In lower socioeconomic
- 10:13statuses or circumstances.
- 10:16And so,
- 10:16the reality of eliminating abortion
- 10:19is
- 10:20a lot of babies born into the reality that Jack Prince was describing.
- 10:26And so,
- 10:26when you envision your goal,
- 10:29you know,
- 10:30what,
- 10:30what is your hope?
- 10:31What are,
- 10:32what do you think is necessary if we were to eliminate abortion to
- 10:39Grasp with that reality that so many.
- 10:42Humans would be
- 10:43born into difficult circumstances because I also know that
- 10:47a large percentage of women who do carry children to term
- 10:50choose to keep the child.
- 10:52And so,
- 10:54I think that's something I struggle with is what it,
- 10:57what would need to be done to accommodate,
- 10:59you know,
- 10:59that,
- 11:00that,
- 11:00that population that would be very vulnerable.
- 11:03Yeah,
- 11:03it's a very good question,
- 11:04John,
- 11:05and there's a few things I think.
- 11:06Number one,
- 11:07I do think we need to
- 11:09improve our social safety net and also
- 11:12in a way,
- 11:13market it so people know what exists.
- 11:15I remember doing a debate
- 11:17a couple of years ago now with a woman who had an abortion.
- 11:19She wasn't
- 11:20in the same socioeconomic maybe status as Jack.
- 11:23I think she had gone to college and things like that,
- 11:24but she was really struggling,
- 11:25you know,
- 11:25she was still really struggling.
- 11:27And she didn't know about the pregnancy resource centers that provide
- 11:31free healthcare,
- 11:32free baby resources that can even help with adoption placement,
- 11:35all of these things if that's the choice the mom makes.
- 11:37She didn't even know about that.
- 11:38She said no one was there to help me pay my bills,
- 11:40help me with diapers,
- 11:41and those organizations exist.
- 11:43There are thousands of pregnancy resource centers,
- 11:45more than there are abortion clinics that provide free confidential care
- 11:49to moms and babies in need and give away hundreds of millions of
- 11:51dollars of free supplies every single year to moms and babies in need.
- 11:55So,
- 11:55shoring up that social safety net,
- 11:57making sure moms know it exists,
- 12:00right,
- 12:00is part of the battle.
- 12:02And I do think the government should fund that social safety net more
- 12:06instead of funding abortion clinics,
- 12:07they should fund the social safety net of supporting moms and,
- 12:10and young families who need help with.
- 12:12The Children.
- 12:13I think we need to make birth free.
- 12:14I think we need better child subsidies so that moms are given
- 12:18actual cash from the government to be moms and not have to,
- 12:22you know,
- 12:22go schlep off to a job,
- 12:23but can do the most important work of being there for their kids.
- 12:26So those are all some things on the social safety net front.
- 12:29But here's the other part of this,
- 12:31you know,
- 12:32pregnancy doesn't just happen out of nowhere like
- 12:34you're walking down the street and shoot,
- 12:35you get pregnant,
- 12:36right?
- 12:37Pregnancy happens because of activities that adults choose to enter into,
- 12:40which is sex,
- 12:41right?
- 12:42And I think that that's actually another
- 12:45taboo topic.
- 12:46I think the other message societally that we need to get across,
- 12:49there needs to be a culture shift around sex
- 12:51because I think there since the sexual revolution,
- 12:53since the 19.
- 12:5460s and 70s,
- 12:55there has been this mindset with American adults
- 12:58that sex is something that you get to do on your own terms,
- 13:01as long as it's safe,
- 13:02you know,
- 13:02use a condom or whatever,
- 13:04make sure there's consent,
- 13:04and then you're,
- 13:05it's whatever you want as an adult that you pick your moral code,
- 13:07no big deal.
- 13:09The reality is sex,
- 13:10not every time,
- 13:11but many times,
- 13:12brings new life into the world.
- 13:13The reason we have the abortion issue of a million abortions a
- 13:16year in this country is because adults who are engaging in activities.
- 13:19That can bring life into the world,
- 13:20and they were not ready
- 13:21for the consequences of those activities,
- 13:23which is children,
- 13:23right?
- 13:24And so I think if we shifted our mindset culturally,
- 13:27instead of sex is about my adult pleasure,
- 13:29my experience,
- 13:30whatever I want,
- 13:31and instead it says sex has a moral code that is built in,
- 13:34which has to do with the fact it brings life into the world.
- 13:36Sex should be about commitment.
- 13:38It should be about love,
- 13:39it should be about openness to that child that might come into the world,
- 13:42not every time,
- 13:42but sometimes,
- 13:43right?
- 13:44And if we instead
- 13:45practice more self-control as a society to say,
- 13:47listen,
- 13:47we don't,
- 13:48we don't celebrate sex outside of marriage.
- 13:51We don't celebrate sex,
- 13:52but however we want to do it as adults are,
- 13:54it's all up to me.
- 13:55Instead,
- 13:55we put sex back where it belongs,
- 13:57which is in committed
- 13:59lifelong relationships that are,
- 14:01yes,
- 14:02preparing for the,
- 14:03for the responsibility of children.
- 14:05We would basically eradicate the abortion rate overnight.
- 14:08So I think that's another message.
- 14:10That is very countercultural because a lot of people are like,
- 14:12well,
- 14:12I get to do what I want.
- 14:13Don't tell me what to do.
- 14:14And it's like,
- 14:14it's not so much about telling you what to do
- 14:16as it is about the importance of accepting responsibility for your actions.
- 14:21And you choose what to do,
- 14:22but then accept responsibility for your actions.
- 14:24So I think that's another message
- 14:26that is really important
- 14:28to talk about,
- 14:29and I think that's another cultural shift that needs
- 14:32to happen along with getting moms more help,
- 14:35spreading that message of responsibility
- 14:37for adults.
- 14:39Yeah,
- 14:40I don't think there's anything wrong with the cultural value of um
- 14:44seeing sex as sacred,
- 14:46encouraging people to have sex within marriage.
- 14:49Um,
- 14:50I think the pragmatist inside me though acknowledges that that would be kind of a,
- 14:54a behavior and a,
- 14:55and a value that wouldn't be shared by
- 14:57all Americans.
- 14:58It'd be very unlikely
- 14:59to see all Americans,
- 15:01you know,
- 15:01observe,
- 15:01observe it that way.
- 15:03It used to be much more shared,
- 15:05like,
- 15:05you know,
- 15:0550,
- 15:06so we can't,
- 15:07I mean,
- 15:07the thing is culture changes,
- 15:08right?
- 15:09If enough people
- 15:10stand up and behave a certain way and share that,
- 15:13that,
- 15:13and,
- 15:13and society changes its expectations,
- 15:15we do change behavior,
- 15:17and that's throughout history,
- 15:18you know.
- 15:18So
- 15:19I agree with you right now.
- 15:20We're not there,
- 15:21but that's why I'm talking about it because we,
- 15:22I think we need to get there as a society to be happier and healthier.
- 15:26Yeah,
- 15:26and I know there's lots of people who would,
- 15:28who would agree with you.
- 15:28There's Something I'm curious about,
- 15:30and I can't remember if this came up in the episode.
- 15:32If the goal is preventing abortions,
- 15:34you know,
- 15:35we wanna,
- 15:35we wanna decrease unwanted pregnancies,
- 15:37we wanna,
- 15:38which would ultimately decrease abortions.
- 15:40Um,
- 15:41are you,
- 15:42uh,
- 15:43really supportive of like contraceptives being
- 15:45widely available and accessible as,
- 15:47as a,
- 15:48a means to achieve that?
- 15:49I'm curious what your opinion is on that.
- 15:51It's a very good question,
- 15:52and I think this is another elephant in the room that people have just said,
- 15:55well,
- 15:56just more contraceptives should solve this,
- 15:58right?
- 15:58If adults are not ready for a baby,
- 16:01they should just use contraception,
- 16:02and then we should be OK.
- 16:04The reality is we have more contraceptives than
- 16:07really any other time in human history,
- 16:09right?
- 16:09Tax-funded contraceptives,
- 16:11and
- 16:12they're in every drugstore in America,
- 16:14right?
- 16:15And
- 16:1650% of the women
- 16:18who get abortions right now
- 16:20were on contraceptives the month that they got pregnant.
- 16:23That's a,
- 16:23that's a statistic from Planned Parenthood's research on Guttmacher Institute.
- 16:27A full 50% of the women getting abortions are were on using contraceptives.
- 16:31Contraceptives do not solve the issue of adults.
- 16:37Behaving in a way that doesn't
- 16:39accept responsibility.
- 16:40It doesn't solve for that.
- 16:41It doesn't solve the issue of a mindset shift that needs to be made about sex.
- 16:45If anything,
- 16:45I would argue that contraceptives
- 16:47give us a false sense of security.
- 16:48Truly,
- 16:49they say,
- 16:49well,
- 16:49it makes your,
- 16:50it makes sex safe,
- 16:51uh,
- 16:51safe sex.
- 16:52It makes sex safe.
- 16:53So just use a condom or be on the birth control pill,
- 16:55and then you're being it's actually saying that is responsibility,
- 16:57right?
- 16:58That's not where responsibility is.
- 17:00Responsibility is in treating the person
- 17:02that you are potentially gonna engage in sex with with love,
- 17:05responsibility,
- 17:06and commitment,
- 17:07I would say in a marriage,
- 17:08and then understanding that you might bring life into the world
- 17:11and to be ready to receive that life.
- 17:13And so I think contraceptives have given people a
- 17:15false sense of security that has actually increased abortions.
- 17:18We've had more contraceptives in the last 50 years
- 17:20and more abortions in the last 50 years,
- 17:22and they've,
- 17:22they've gone hand in hand.
- 17:23So I think the solution isn't contraception.
- 17:25I think the solution is.
- 17:27A change in our,
- 17:28in our worldview and our behavior around sex,
- 17:31which I understand it takes,
- 17:32that's going to take some work,
- 17:34but I think it's possible.
- 17:35I think people were made for more,
- 17:37and I think sex should be made sacred again,
- 17:39and that would make everybody happier and our relationship so much healthier,
- 17:43and it would save a tremendous amount of future lives.
- 17:46Mhm.
- 17:47Something,
- 17:48this is a little bit of an aside.
- 17:49I,
- 17:49I come from a,
- 17:50a,
- 17:51a Catholic family,
- 17:52and I,
- 17:53I recall a mindset in older generations being that sex was for procreation.
- 17:58My mom was one of 12
- 18:00children and my dad was one of 8 children,
- 18:02so I,
- 18:03I feel like that was somewhat,
- 18:05uh,
- 18:06it's pretty closely observed by my grandparents.
- 18:08But I'm curious is,
- 18:09um,
- 18:11Is your mindset,
- 18:12uh,
- 18:12aligned with that,
- 18:13or do you believe that,
- 18:14you know,
- 18:15married couples can still have,
- 18:16have sex for pleasure and not in the for the purpose of procreation?
- 18:19Yeah,
- 18:20so
- 18:20first of all,
- 18:21I'll say I'm a realist.
- 18:22I,
- 18:23I look at how sex is actually designed.
- 18:24It's not even a question yet of morality.
- 18:26It's a question of what's of reality.
- 18:28Sex is designed to do two things,
- 18:30largely speaking.
- 18:31It does bring Incredible pleasure and,
- 18:33and it can bring incredible bonding between people,
- 18:35right?
- 18:36So,
- 18:36it is designed for pleasure,
- 18:37obviously,
- 18:38and it's designed for bonding.
- 18:39You know,
- 18:40the hormones that it releases,
- 18:41the connectivity it releases between two people is beautiful,
- 18:44and that is one of the reasons why hookup culture,
- 18:46I think,
- 18:46is so harmful emotionally,
- 18:48not just physically for people,
- 18:50because they're bonding,
- 18:51right?
- 18:51Phys physically,
- 18:52and I believe
- 18:52Even spiritually,
- 18:53and then they're ripping apart from each other,
- 18:55like the one night stand or
- 18:56being together and then separating,
- 18:58it's very painful because there is a spiritual
- 19:00relationship with sex that makes it pleasurable and unifying with another person.
- 19:05Sex is also designed for procreation.
- 19:07Not every sexual act will bring life into the world.
- 19:09Obviously,
- 19:10a woman's fertility window is only a few days a month,
- 19:13right?
- 19:14But it can bring life into the world.
- 19:15So
- 19:16if you look at those two realities about sex,
- 19:18that it's designed for procreation and it's designed for unity,
- 19:21being unitive between two people,
- 19:24then I think those are the two purposes of sex.
- 19:25So I do think sex is designed in part for pleasure,
- 19:28and I think that's a beautiful thing,
- 19:30but not just
- 19:30Pleasure all about what I want,
- 19:31my pleasure.
- 19:32It's designed about pleasure with another person where you're loving them,
- 19:36and it's not just about using them,
- 19:37right?
- 19:38It's not about using them at all.
- 19:39And it's designed to be open to life,
- 19:41where you may receive children from this act,
- 19:44and that should be something you're preparing for,
- 19:46right?
- 19:47So I think it's both.
- 19:49I think that it in a,
- 19:50in a marriage,
- 19:51you should be open to life and you should be as loving and,
- 19:55you know,
- 19:55have the best sex life possible.
- 19:57I think sex is,
- 19:58is amazing,
- 19:59but they have to go together.
- 20:00And
- 20:01one more thing I'll say that doesn't mean every time you have sex,
- 20:03you bring life into the world.
- 20:03I know I've said that multiple times.
- 20:05So you're sometimes are having sex when you're not able
- 20:07to conceive because it's not the woman's fertile window,
- 20:10but that sex is still beautiful because it's bringing two people together.
- 20:13It's a way to show love with one another,
- 20:15but you're still not artificially clamping it down to say,
- 20:17oh,
- 20:18I'm not going to have a baby because it's just not
- 20:19naturally able to have a baby because the woman's not fertile.
- 20:22So already built into a woman's reproductive cycle
- 20:25are periods of time where she's not fertile,
- 20:27where you can still have sex,
- 20:28have pleasure,
- 20:28have amazing experience,
- 20:30love each other,
- 20:31and that's why I'm a big proponent to,
- 20:33proponent,
- 20:34proponent too of fertility awareness
- 20:37or natural family planning.
- 20:39Where you say,
- 20:39listen,
- 20:40if you're,
- 20:40if you're a married couple and you're like,
- 20:41hey,
- 20:42we just had a baby,
- 20:43there's a health issue,
- 20:44or we want to space before the next baby,
- 20:46you know,
- 20:46because we
- 20:47are,
- 20:47you know,
- 20:47figuring out our finances or whatever,
- 20:49and we're gonna,
- 20:49we're going to space 6 months or we're going to space a year,
- 20:52whatever it is,
- 20:53you can use the natural built-in cycles
- 20:55of the woman's body through natural family planning
- 20:57to avoid having sex during the fertile period.
- 20:59Periods and then be together
- 21:01when you're not fertile and that can be a natural way to space children,
- 21:04right,
- 21:05as opposed to again contraception
- 21:07or you know,
- 21:08sex outside of marriage or all the other
- 21:11pathways that our our culture currently
- 21:13advocates for basically
- 21:15mhm
- 21:16yeah,
- 21:16cycle tracking's for sure helpful um
- 21:19I,
- 21:19I was educated,
- 21:20uh,
- 21:21on that,
- 21:21uh,
- 21:22with my wife,
- 21:23but um,
- 21:24that aside,
- 21:25I want to rewind back to Jack's prince a bit,
- 21:27um.
- 21:28You know,
- 21:29a lot of the,
- 21:30the social safety nets that you're advocating for,
- 21:33you know,
- 21:34um,
- 21:34um,
- 21:35money for moms,
- 21:35from the government,
- 21:36just more financial support,
- 21:38more,
- 21:38more resources.
- 21:40And dads,
- 21:41by the way,
- 21:41I should have said that too,
- 21:42moms and dads,
- 21:43so that the child cash credit,
- 21:45I think should be for both,
- 21:46but yeah,
- 21:47yeah,
- 21:48I,
- 21:48you know,
- 21:49rewinding
- 21:50back to,
- 21:50to Jack's Prince's,
- 21:52um,
- 21:53experience and,
- 21:54you know,
- 21:55had they known or had she known about,
- 21:57you know,
- 21:57resources available to her or had she had
- 22:00much more
- 22:01resources available to her,
- 22:03her decision might have been different.
- 22:06We,
- 22:06we don't know that for sure,
- 22:07but just assuming that,
- 22:08that,
- 22:09that could be it,
- 22:09uh,
- 22:10so
- 22:11what is the likelihood that you think this administration or,
- 22:14or
- 22:16a
- 22:16future administration,
- 22:17the near future
- 22:18would pass more,
- 22:20um,
- 22:22I don't know,
- 22:23would,
- 22:24would
- 22:24actually make that a reality where there are more resources available
- 22:27because that's something I hear a lot is that this is,
- 22:29this is a low priority for the government.
- 22:31This is something.
- 22:32That we,
- 22:33we don't usually see prioritized by the US government.
- 22:37Do you have hope or information or knowledge on that?
- 22:40Yeah,
- 22:40I mean,
- 22:41I see,
- 22:41I,
- 22:42I,
- 22:42I think I've seen it on the left,
- 22:43and I definitely see it on the right and advocating for
- 22:48child cash credits.
- 22:49So I do think that could be a bipartisan policy.
- 22:53I think making birth free could also be a bipartisan policy potentially,
- 22:58and I think what would that look like?
- 23:00I think that's where you don't have to pay medical bills for birth,
- 23:03so you make birth free,
- 23:05um,
- 23:06and that's it is a government funded being able to give birth without,
- 23:09you know,
- 23:10going into debt is a government funded,
- 23:12uh,
- 23:12policy.
- 23:13Um,
- 23:14and I think another one that this is maybe something more the right would support,
- 23:17but the left might not support because of politics,
- 23:20which is tragic in my view,
- 23:21is
- 23:21funding pregnancy resource centers.
- 23:24So I think if the government partners with nonprofits that are very
- 23:28based on community that are basically run by the community,
- 23:31and they support those nonprofits,
- 23:33I think instead of supporting
- 23:35abortion clinics,
- 23:36which is what they currently do,
- 23:38so a lot of states fund abortion directly like my state of California.
- 23:42And then Planned Parenthood
- 23:44was receiving,
- 23:45it's still receiving some money,
- 23:46but it was receiving.
- 23:48Over half of a billion dollars from federal taxpayers,
- 23:52uh,
- 23:52federal tax dollars
- 23:53that was just defunded for only 1 year,
- 23:55but they're going to try to get the money back next year.
- 23:57I would say redirect that money instead
- 24:00to pregnancy resource centers.
- 24:04Great.
- 24:04Yeah,
- 24:05I do think it,
- 24:06you know,
- 24:07framing
- 24:08the issue around resources to mothers.
- 24:13And maybe away from
- 24:15abortion
- 24:16like there is probably bipartisan paths there so I appreciate that.
- 24:19I wanna,
- 24:21yeah,
- 24:21I wanna jump to the next clip,
- 24:23um,
- 24:24but thank you for all of that.
- 24:25So this is
- 24:26gonna be with Dana.
- 24:30And Dana,
- 24:30you,
- 24:31you asked Dana to come back at the end of the episode.
- 24:34You had.
- 24:35Um
- 24:38A great conversation with her
- 24:40and this was still,
- 24:42I think this was in the,
- 24:44this was in the
- 24:44context of your claim abortion cannot be justified under any circumstances.
- 24:49And so then the topic of bodily autonomy came up,
- 24:52um,
- 24:53and so we can
- 24:54jump into that after we watch this.
- 24:56Hi,
- 24:57my name is Dana Pellaban.
- 24:58Dana,
- 24:58nice to nice to meet you.
- 25:00Um,
- 25:00so I am the executive director of one of
- 25:02the oldest rape crisis centers here in the nation.
- 25:05And one of the things that I need you to understand
- 25:08is that abortion care is health care for survivors.
- 25:12It also gives them the options
- 25:15that they need in order to move forward
- 25:18after they have had
- 25:19so many choices that have been taken away from them.
- 25:22So let's remind ourselves
- 25:24that most women
- 25:26um who have been um
- 25:28Who have been assaulted know they're assaulters.
- 25:32Um,
- 25:321 in 20 women who have had pregnancies
- 25:36have had pregnancies that result from assault.
- 25:38In addition,
- 25:391 in 4 women have had abortions.
- 25:42Um,
- 25:42so these are women who are making these choices
- 25:45because they need to make these choices.
- 25:47And when you say to someone
- 25:49who has already had choices taken away from them,
- 25:53that in addition
- 25:54to,
- 25:55I have had my body violated,
- 25:57I have had my choices taken from me,
- 26:00that I then have to carry a child
- 26:04to birth
- 26:05and then.
- 26:07Have my life put in danger and reminding ourselves
- 26:11that as a black woman,
- 26:12as a black woman,
- 26:13I have a higher rate of death
- 26:16in our society
- 26:18just by birthing,
- 26:20so I'm putting my life in danger
- 26:22just to
- 26:23carry a child
- 26:25that has resulted from an assault,
- 26:27so you cannot tell me.
- 26:29That
- 26:30there is no circumstance where I don't make that choice for my body
- 26:35and for the tissues that are in my body.
- 26:38There is always a space for me to make a choice for what is going to happen to my body.
- 26:45I'd love to respond,
- 26:46if I may
- 26:471st of all,
- 26:48we are aligned that is absolutely horrific.
- 26:50We're aligned on that,
- 26:51and part of the work at Live Action is we do interview survivors of sexual assault,
- 26:55and we talk to survivors of sexual assault
- 26:57as well as children conceived via sexual assault.
- 27:00That's part of their story.
- 27:01And we're aligned that it's absolutely horrific.
- 27:04Where it sounds like we're not aligned is that I don't believe.
- 27:07That
- 27:08two wrongs make a right,
- 27:09that if there is a horrific act of an assault,
- 27:11if I may just explain my position here,
- 27:13if there's a horrific act of assault,
- 27:16and a pregnancy results and a new life is conceived,
- 27:19that ending that new life,
- 27:20giving that new human being the death penalty for the guy I
- 27:23just finished the death penalty for the crime of the father,
- 27:26that fertilization.
- 27:27There has been a fertilization of an egg.
- 27:29And I think shortly after that
- 27:31flags came up and you guys had to stop that conversation.
- 27:34You picked it back up at the end.
- 27:36And the debate kind of migrated more towards
- 27:40the beginning of life,
- 27:41and I,
- 27:41I wanna get into that,
- 27:42but
- 27:43just with bodily autonomy,
- 27:45um,
- 27:45pregnancies that result from rape,
- 27:47sexual assault,
- 27:49um,
- 27:50This,
- 27:51this is obviously not as common,
- 27:52but it is something that happens,
- 27:54could be tens of thousands of women dealing with reality like this every year.
- 27:58Um.
- 28:00Is that,
- 28:01is that something,
- 28:01do you feel conflicted about um
- 28:07I guess the reality those women would have to face if they all had to carry
- 28:11those pregnancies to term.
- 28:13So it,
- 28:14it rape is devastating.
- 28:16I mean,
- 28:17that I think there's a,
- 28:18we recoil at the very thought of it because it's so just,
- 28:21it's so horrific.
- 28:22And as somebody who survives that,
- 28:23it's,
- 28:24it's devastating for them.
- 28:25It's deeply traumatic and wounding.
- 28:28And
- 28:29the argument here is,
- 28:30OK,
- 28:30well,
- 28:30and,
- 28:31and this is what I hear a lot from people who are saying abortion should be legal.
- 28:33Abortion is,
- 28:34is,
- 28:34is good in some cases,
- 28:36at least,
- 28:37is,
- 28:37well,
- 28:37what about rape?
- 28:38What about incest?
- 28:39And
- 28:40I think the first thing that's so important to say is that
- 28:43just from the woman's vantage point,
- 28:45having an abortion after a rape does not heal you from the trauma of the rape.
- 28:50I think we get really worked up as we should about the evil of rape,
- 28:54but then we sort of put,
- 28:55we're looking for a solution,
- 28:57right?
- 28:57We're looking for somebody
- 28:59to to somehow solve what such a horrible situation.
- 29:02And so we say,
- 29:02well,
- 29:03abortion,
- 29:03abortion can be a solution,
- 29:05right?
- 29:06But it's not a solution.
- 29:07It actually doesn't solve anything.
- 29:09Because what it does is it's another act of violence
- 29:12against a new developing life who was totally innocent.
- 29:15They're not responsible for the crimes of their father.
- 29:17They are a new innocent human life that deserves life.
- 29:21And
- 29:22you're also doing a secondary act of violence against that woman
- 29:26because this idea that abortion is some,
- 29:28you know,
- 29:28you wish the baby away is not true.
- 29:30You have to deliver that baby.
- 29:31An abortion procedure always delivers the baby.
- 29:33It just delivers the baby dead.
- 29:35And so I think what we should instead shift to
- 29:38is how do we help and love and care for that
- 29:41that woman,
- 29:42give her the best support that she can possibly be given,
- 29:45counseling,
- 29:45healthcare,
- 29:47but we don't take out the crime,
- 29:49the punishment for the crime on that baby.
- 29:51We give that baby a chance to live and we accompany that mother
- 29:55as.
- 29:55Best we can
- 29:57through
- 29:58giving that baby enough of a shot at life and maybe
- 30:00there's an early delivery later in order to get that baby,
- 30:03you know,
- 30:04an option to live,
- 30:05but you don't kill the baby.
- 30:07And we interview a lot of women who are
- 30:08survivors and children who are conceived in rape.
- 30:11Rebecca Keisling,
- 30:11I might have mentioned her in the Jubilee interview,
- 30:13I don't remember,
- 30:13but
- 30:14in the surrounded episode,
- 30:15but
- 30:16she was
- 30:17conceived in rape,
- 30:18and her mother tried to abort her.
- 30:20It was a violent
- 30:22rape against her mother.
- 30:23Her mother tried to abort her.
- 30:24Her mother was unable to because it was right before abortion was legal.
- 30:28So she tried to get a back alley abortion.
- 30:29She wasn't able to do it.
- 30:31She ended up delivering Rebecca,
- 30:33and years and placed her for adoption,
- 30:35and years later,
- 30:36she would write a letter to Rebecca saying,
- 30:38I'm so glad that abortion was illegal
- 30:41because as painful as
- 30:42the whole thing was,
- 30:43you know,
- 30:43especially the rape,
- 30:44that's the most devastating thing.
- 30:46You are now given the chance to live.
- 30:48And if,
- 30:48if the law hadn't prevented me,
- 30:50I would have taken,
- 30:51had your life taken,
- 30:52right?
- 30:53We need to change the conversation around this.
- 30:55I think instead of saying,
- 30:56oh,
- 30:56abortion is a rape is a justification for abortion,
- 30:59we should talk about
- 31:00better penalties for rape.
- 31:02Holding rapists accountable,
- 31:04better support for rape survivors and,
- 31:06and,
- 31:07and giving them everything that they could,
- 31:08we can possibly give them,
- 31:10and then protecting this innocent third party,
- 31:13which is the,
- 31:13which is this new human life and not
- 31:15resorting to violence against that new human life
- 31:18to somehow try to solve the original violence of the rape because it doesn't.
- 31:22Abortion does not take away rape.
- 31:23It doesn't solve rape.
- 31:24It doesn't heal trauma.
- 31:25It just adds more trauma on top of the original trauma of the rape.
- 31:30I can completely understand,
- 31:32um.
- 31:33When you
- 31:35If you believe that life begins at conception,
- 31:37that's when a human life begins.
- 31:39I can completely understand
- 31:41that you have to be morally consistent and protect that life.
- 31:44Um,
- 31:44I can also
- 31:46completely understand the mindset around,
- 31:48um,
- 31:49hey,
- 31:50like an abortion is not necessarily going to be a healing experience.
- 31:53It's not going to heal you from the trauma of
- 31:55an already horrible experience.
- 31:57That all makes sense to me,
- 31:59I think when I start to think about this on a more
- 32:01like
- 32:02larger societal scale.
- 32:05You know,
- 32:06If this is a reality where we,
- 32:08we,
- 32:08we outlaw abortions entirely even in these circumstances,
- 32:12that comes with this sort of grim reality that we are forcing
- 32:16young women as,
- 32:17as,
- 32:17as young as 12,
- 32:19if they are saying they don't want to carry this pregnancy to term.
- 32:23We're essentially forcing them to
- 32:26do that.
- 32:27Is that,
- 32:28do you feel any
- 32:29sense of conflict around that?
- 32:31Yeah,
- 32:31I mean,
- 32:32it's,
- 32:32it's devastating,
- 32:33right?
- 32:33The one of the reasons rape is so horrific is that
- 32:36it can bring life into the world and you're doing it
- 32:37in this violent way against a woman against her will.
- 32:40So yeah,
- 32:40I mean,
- 32:40the whole thing is devastating.
- 32:42It's horrible.
- 32:43But again,
- 32:44it's tragic and in horrible tragedies and injustices,
- 32:47right?
- 32:47It's like,
- 32:48what do you do in the aftermath,
- 32:49because there's going to be so much hurt that you have to navigate,
- 32:51so much pain you're navigating.
- 32:53And the aftermath can't be
- 32:56that
- 32:56you take another life
- 32:58that we say as a society,
- 33:00you know,
- 33:00oh,
- 33:00you've suffered this trauma.
- 33:01So it's OK,
- 33:02we're going to be OK with killing this life now because of the trauma you suffered.
- 33:06We got to help her,
- 33:07we got to love her,
- 33:07we got to give her care and counseling.
- 33:09And I do think it's encouraging to note,
- 33:11you know,
- 33:11in the research that I've done,
- 33:12the rape survivors I've talked to,
- 33:14it's the rare 1011,
- 33:1612 year old you talked about these very young victims of who survived horrific,
- 33:20you know,
- 33:20incest,
- 33:21rape,
- 33:21that they wake up and they say the one thing I want is an abortion.
- 33:24Give me an abortion now.
- 33:25Usually abortion isn't even in their vocabulary.
- 33:27They're just incredibly
- 33:29devastated and wounded from this trauma of being assaulted,
- 33:32right?
- 33:33And you navigate them and you help them and you
- 33:34care for them and you give them counseling and support,
- 33:37and we take abortion off the table,
- 33:39say,
- 33:39well,
- 33:40good,
- 33:40there's this little get out of,
- 33:41you know,
- 33:41get out of this pain
- 33:43card.
- 33:43If you just pull this card,
- 33:44abortion,
- 33:44you're gonna be.
- 33:45Better.
- 33:46That's a lie,
- 33:46first of all,
- 33:47to tell a rape survivor she's going to feel better after an abortion is a lie.
- 33:51It's we have no right to say that,
- 33:52first of all.
- 33:53And second of all,
- 33:54to take it off the table instead of as a society saying,
- 33:56oh,
- 33:56rape survivor needs an abortion.
- 33:58Instead,
- 33:58we say rape survivor deserves support,
- 34:00deserves help,
- 34:01deserves counseling,
- 34:02deserves healthcare.
- 34:03This baby also deserves help,
- 34:05deserves support,
- 34:05this new life,
- 34:06and that becomes the conversation.
- 34:08I think we're going to see a lot more healing.
- 34:10Then then we see now around the devastation of rape and sexual abuse.
- 34:14And then I think
- 34:15the other part of it is holding rapists
- 34:18and abusers to
- 34:19giving them more penalties.
- 34:21I think,
- 34:22you know,
- 34:22you,
- 34:23you read these crazy stories of
- 34:25out on bail,
- 34:26or,
- 34:26you know,
- 34:26they get 10 years and then they're out on the streets and they reoffend.
- 34:29I think we do need life sentences
- 34:32for sexual abusers.
- 34:33I don't think we should,
- 34:34you know,
- 34:34I,
- 34:35I do not support the death penalty.
- 34:36I'm opposed to the death penalty penalty.
- 34:39But I,
- 34:39and interestingly,
- 34:40federal law opposes death penalty for rape,
- 34:43which is another reason why it's so crazy we
- 34:44give the death penalty to the unborn baby,
- 34:46right?
- 34:47But I do think we need longer prison sentences for rapists.
- 34:51I want to move on to your next claim,
- 34:53um,
- 34:54and,
- 34:54and
- 34:55this is more around the issue of,
- 34:57you know,
- 34:58where does life begin?
- 34:59There was a lot of debate,
- 35:00you know,
- 35:00you would say that's a baby,
- 35:02they would say,
- 35:02no,
- 35:02that's an embryo or that's a clump of cells.
- 35:05This is,
- 35:05um,
- 35:06A huge part of of the debate and the discussion.
- 35:10I personally feel there's some intellectual dishonesty that I see sometimes here.
- 35:15So I think it's,
- 35:16it's,
- 35:16it's really important to hit on this.
- 35:18So I'm gonna pull up a clip,
- 35:19um,
- 35:19yeah,
- 35:20the claim was every unborn child has a right to life.
- 35:23So I want to be clear with the terms here.
- 35:24When you say they're a human,
- 35:25I'm agreeing that even a fertilized egg is a human is a person that should be given.
- 35:29So are you saying that a person with a brain developmental disorder,
- 35:32like a significant developmental,
- 35:33you're talking about anencephaly,
- 35:34for example,
- 35:35as an example that they would not be a person as I say,
- 35:38it's OK to kill that person.
- 35:39No,
- 35:39that's not what I'm saying.
- 35:40Then what are you saying?
- 35:41As I said earlier,
- 35:41when there's a potential life,
- 35:42a partial life,
- 35:43you still give it some value.
- 35:44You have to take reasonable steps to protect it.
- 35:46If someone's born,
- 35:47what steps would you give it?
- 35:48If someone's born with anencephaly,
- 35:49there's no conflict there between the bodily autonomy
- 35:51of a woman and the person with anencephaly.
- 35:53The reason you do an abortion is not like,
- 35:55oh,
- 35:55I want to kill this fetus for fun.
- 35:57There's a conflict between the woman's bodily autonomy and the fetus developing.
- 36:00If there's some way to resolve that and respect both parties,
- 36:03that would be great,
- 36:04but we don't have that kind of medical technology.
- 36:05So,
- 36:05the,
- 36:06the position is that if you are a human,
- 36:08you have human rights,
- 36:09regardless of
- 36:10how developed your brain might be,
- 36:11because some people have severe.
- 36:13Developmental disabilities,
- 36:14and that doesn't make them less of a human,
- 36:16or they have less that it does.
- 36:18Well,
- 36:18your argument actually infers that it does actually,
- 36:21because it's saying that this particular level
- 36:22of developmental ability that your brain may have
- 36:25gives you,
- 36:26which exists,
- 36:26by the way,
- 36:26in pretty much anyone other than people with an encephaly,
- 36:29and those people usually die in a couple of days.
- 36:32Is it OK to kill that person before they die naturally because of it,
- 36:35because they lack this if they're still in the womb or after birth.
- 36:38If they're,
- 36:38OK,
- 36:38let's,
- 36:39let's take your scenario.
- 36:40What if they're after birth and they lack the specific
- 36:42connections that you're saying defines personhood a brain stem usually,
- 36:45and they're and they're after birth.
- 36:46There's a little boy named Jasper.
- 36:47He lived almost,
- 36:48I think,
- 36:4934 years
- 36:50with a severe
- 36:51condition,
- 36:52a developmental condition in his brain.
- 36:53It's not OK to kill that
- 36:54that.
- 36:54But why would it not be OK to kill them
- 36:56when they lack this specific brain connection that you're saying
- 36:59makes it OK to kill the baby at the reason that it makes the reason it's OK to kill.
- 37:02The fetus prior to 22 weeks is not because it's just good enough itself.
- 37:06It's because it's the only way to resolve the conflict
- 37:09between the bodily autonomy of the woman and the fetus.
- 37:11If someone's born with anencephaly,
- 37:12their existence is not impeding on the bodily autonomy of anyone else.
- 37:16And then you want to take
- 37:17all reasonable steps to help that person,
- 37:18not harm that person.
- 37:19I think we agree on bodily autonomy to a degree,
- 37:22because I agree that I have bodily autonomy,
- 37:24you have bodily autonomy,
- 37:25but I think my bodily autonomy ends
- 37:28when another human being's bodily autonomy begins.
- 37:32So
- 37:33what I liked about.
- 37:35What Adam was bringing to the discussion,
- 37:37I think he was the only person I heard bring up this idea of the conflict between
- 37:42the mother's bodily autonomy and the life of the fetus,
- 37:45and I think this is where there's maybe the most gray area,
- 37:48maybe the most potential for,
- 37:50for compromise is just how we are interpreting.
- 37:54The,
- 37:55the personhood of,
- 37:58of the fetus,
- 37:58the embryo along development.
- 38:01What,
- 38:02um,
- 38:02what's,
- 38:03why do you believe that it begins at conception?
- 38:06What's the source of,
- 38:07of your belief,
- 38:09um?
- 38:10So
- 38:10the
- 38:11life begins,
- 38:12you know,
- 38:12human life begins at the moment of fertilization.
- 38:14It's not my opinion.
- 38:15There are,
- 38:16you know,
- 38:16virtually any biology or,
- 38:18um,
- 38:19you know,
- 38:19science textbook that discusses human development will talk about that moment of
- 38:23fertilization as the moment that a single cell embryo comes into existence.
- 38:27And,
- 38:28you know,
- 38:28we know this sort of and I in our,
- 38:30you know,
- 38:31everyday conversation around fertility and,
- 38:33and life and abortion.
- 38:34If you look at
- 38:35the conversation of IVF,
- 38:36the IVF technician is trying to create what.
- 38:39An embryo,
- 38:40right?
- 38:40Then they go,
- 38:41oh,
- 38:41we've got an embryo.
- 38:42They don't even say fertilized egg.
- 38:43They say it's an embryo.
- 38:44We've got 10 embryos for you,
- 38:46you know,
- 38:46whatever,
- 38:47and they know when life begins,
- 38:48just like the scientists or the human biologist knows when life begins.
- 38:52It begins at sperm egg fusion.
- 38:54And so that's not my opinion.
- 38:55That is an
- 38:57established fact.
- 38:58So then the question becomes,
- 38:59well,
- 38:59is that human
- 39:01embryo worthy of protection,
- 39:03right?
- 39:03That is really the question.
- 39:04And then,
- 39:05you know,
- 39:05Adam got into this a little bit a citizen,
- 39:07you know,
- 39:08yeah,
- 39:08do they have human rights?
- 39:10Should they be protected from the violence of abortion?
- 39:11Really,
- 39:12that's what the conversation's about.
- 39:13Should they be protected from being killed
- 39:15intentionally and directly via an abortion?
- 39:17Of course I say no,
- 39:18that's,
- 39:18that's against their,
- 39:19it violates their fundamental right to exist.
- 39:21But,
- 39:21you know,
- 39:22Adam kind of,
- 39:23it was interesting because he kind of did,
- 39:24was kind of doing two different arguments trying,
- 39:26but they kind of actually um contradicted each other because on the one hand,
- 39:29he's kind of debating,
- 39:30I think,
- 39:31when life begins,
- 39:32but then he's acknowledging that his standard for life,
- 39:34you know,
- 39:35his brain waves or these other standards,
- 39:37he can't really hold consistently because you have
- 39:39a born child that is lacking severe developmental
- 39:42abilities,
- 39:43right,
- 39:44because it has a disability
- 39:45and he's still saying it's not OK to kill that baby.
- 39:47But then he flips over to,
- 39:48well,
- 39:49the burden on the.
- 39:49Mother is less because she's not carrying her in utero,
- 39:52that baby in utero,
- 39:53the baby's ex utero.
- 39:54So,
- 39:55you know,
- 39:56other people could theoretically care for that child.
- 39:57Again,
- 39:58he didn't say all of this,
- 39:58but this is,
- 39:59I think,
- 39:59his,
- 39:59his,
- 40:00his,
- 40:00um,
- 40:00position here.
- 40:01That's why even a human
- 40:03that is very,
- 40:04uh,
- 40:05that has severe developmental disabilities post birth,
- 40:07we still protect that life.
- 40:09But even that,
- 40:10that embryo before birth,
- 40:12because they are,
- 40:13you know,
- 40:13a burden on the mother,
- 40:14the mother has this autonomy,
- 40:15then their rights are in conflict,
- 40:17then it's OK to kill.
- 40:18I bring that up because I think what he is ultimately acknowledging,
- 40:22Adam,
- 40:22even in this conversation effectively,
- 40:24and I think what has to be acknowledged is
- 40:27Humans are humans.
- 40:28There's different levels of development,
- 40:30different levels of brain development,
- 40:32different levels of bodily development,
- 40:33brain activity,
- 40:34etc.
- 40:36But you are a member of the human species.
- 40:38You have human parents.
- 40:39The law of biogenesis states,
- 40:41how do you know what member of a species someone has?
- 40:43You look at who the parents are
- 40:45with an unborn single-cell embryo,
- 40:46you know who the parents were,
- 40:48you know,
- 40:48typically,
- 40:48right,
- 40:48you can say this is a father and a mother has a father and a mother.
- 40:51They are offspring.
- 40:53Fetus means child in Latin,
- 40:55right?
- 40:56So
- 40:56this is a human.
- 40:57It's a human life.
- 40:58They are alive.
- 40:59They are developing.
- 41:00So the question is,
- 41:01should they be protected?
- 41:03And when you get into this question of the mother's rights,
- 41:05I do believe,
- 41:06of course,
- 41:06a mother has rights.
- 41:07All humans have human rights,
- 41:09especially,
- 41:10you know,
- 41:10including women,
- 41:11of course,
- 41:12but I never have the right,
- 41:14even if they are a burden to me.
- 41:16I never have the right
- 41:17as a parent to kill my offspring,
- 41:19even if they're a burden to me.
- 41:21And this is true both before birth and after birth.
- 41:25And I've actually did,
- 41:25I did a debate recently with this,
- 41:27um,
- 41:28Georgetown professor,
- 41:29you know,
- 41:29uh,
- 41:30I think that's she was actually William and Mary.
- 41:32I forget the school,
- 41:33but we were at Georgetown debating.
- 41:34Anyways,
- 41:35she was advocating for abortion,
- 41:37uh,
- 41:38because of women's bodily autonomy.
- 41:40That was her justification.
- 41:41Women have total bodily autonomy,
- 41:43so they should be able to kill
- 41:44the baby whenever they want,
- 41:45abort whenever they want,
- 41:46because they have total bodily autonomy.
- 41:48And we were discussing newborns.
- 41:50And you know,
- 41:51I've had 3 babies.
- 41:52Uh,
- 41:52I've had 3 newborns,
- 41:54and the incredible
- 41:55responsibility a newborn is,
- 41:57right?
- 41:58As a mother,
- 41:58you are 100%
- 42:01being available to that newborn to clothe the newborn,
- 42:03feed the newborn,
- 42:04get the newborn to sleep.
- 42:05You're Using your body,
- 42:06the body,
- 42:07the baby's not connected to you directly,
- 42:09but it kind of is when it's nursing anyways.
- 42:11You're using your body,
- 42:12and in our society we require parents to use their bodies
- 42:16to care for their born children.
- 42:17And if you don't use your body to care for your born child,
- 42:20you can be charged with criminal neglect.
- 42:23And I similarly,
- 42:24I think parents have a responsibility,
- 42:26a mother,
- 42:27especially,
- 42:27you know,
- 42:27in a unique way to use her body when the baby is unborn
- 42:31to allow that baby to be born.
- 42:33And then if she can't take the responsibility post-birth,
- 42:36there's an adoption.
- 42:38She can even drop the baby off in a safe box,
- 42:40you know,
- 42:40at a,
- 42:40at a fire station and have zero responsibility after that.
- 42:44But you at least have the responsibility to not kill that baby
- 42:47and to let that baby have a chance to live.
- 42:50Yeah,
- 42:51anyone who's had a child,
- 42:52you know,
- 42:53knows that really you have very little bodily autonomy after they're born,
- 42:57um,
- 42:58but
- 42:58I guess the reason what was interesting about Adam,
- 43:00and I don't necessarily know if I have the language for this,
- 43:04I,
- 43:04I thought Adam was laying out an interesting argument which was,
- 43:08you know,
- 43:08the conditions of
- 43:11Pregnancy are just unique among all human
- 43:15conditions.
- 43:15It's just,
- 43:15it's,
- 43:16it's an exceptional circumstance,
- 43:19um,
- 43:19where there are,
- 43:20you know,
- 43:21at a certain point the,
- 43:22the,
- 43:22the baby can survive outside of the womb,
- 43:24but in the earlier stages,
- 43:26there is,
- 43:27um,
- 43:28a dependency and,
- 43:29and the mother is a host for this other,
- 43:31um,
- 43:32life form.
- 43:33And so that's where I think
- 43:35it introduces
- 43:36all of these,
- 43:37um,
- 43:38complexities and so.
- 43:40Later on,
- 43:41Evan
- 43:42brought up this argument that if we see all human life,
- 43:44you know,
- 43:45from conception
- 43:46on
- 43:47as equal as,
- 43:49as it all endowed with the rights,
- 43:51you know,
- 43:51to live.
- 43:53He brought up this hypothetical and you conceded to it,
- 43:55and I just thought it was interesting.
- 43:56I wanted to hear more of your thoughts about it.
- 43:58He's like,
- 43:58I have a tray of fetuses,
- 44:00of,
- 44:00of,
- 44:00of frozen fetuses or frozen embryos,
- 44:03um.
- 44:05And then I have a lot,
- 44:06you know,
- 44:06like a born baby,
- 44:08um,
- 44:09and,
- 44:09and somebody's going to shoot that baby.
- 44:10It was,
- 44:11it was a terrible hypothetical,
- 44:13but you know,
- 44:13right,
- 44:14if I want to save in your analogy,
- 44:17this newborn baby from being shot,
- 44:18I think is what your analogy is,
- 44:19which is obviously horr horrible,
- 44:21or save this tray of,
- 44:22um,
- 44:23embryos,
- 44:23human embryos who are in the in vitro fertilization clinic.
- 44:26Yeah,
- 44:26I probably would pick,
- 44:27I would pick that newborn baby.
- 44:28That's not because the,
- 44:29um,
- 44:30embryos are less valuable.
- 44:31So then you've just contradicted yourself because you said that you prefer.
- 44:34A world in which there are less rights violations,
- 44:36but that would be a world in which there
- 44:38are more rights violations under your exact worldview,
- 44:41because you conceded earlier that at the moment of conception,
- 44:44we all have an equal right to life.
- 44:45I thought it was nice that you were honest and answered him.
- 44:48I just wonder if you could expand on that.
- 44:50I'd love to,
- 44:51and,
- 44:51and a couple of things too,
- 44:52you,
- 44:52you said you made a comment,
- 44:53pregnancy is,
- 44:54is,
- 44:54is exceptional,
- 44:55right?
- 44:55It's this very unique relationship.
- 44:57There's nothing else like it in nature,
- 44:59you know,
- 45:00how incredibly.
- 45:01Uh,
- 45:02responsible that mother is for that baby.
- 45:03That baby's using her body to,
- 45:05to exist,
- 45:06to grow,
- 45:06right?
- 45:07That is true.
- 45:07That's a fact.
- 45:09I would say that pregnancy is actually very natural.
- 45:11We all come into the world this way,
- 45:13right?
- 45:13So it's not like,
- 45:14oh,
- 45:14this is this crazy thing that happens.
- 45:16It's,
- 45:16it's,
- 45:16it's everybody's story,
- 45:18and there are responsibilities and rights associated with it.
- 45:22And,
- 45:22and this is why,
- 45:22you know,
- 45:23in our country,
- 45:23and I think this is a good thing,
- 45:25men have to pay child support even for a baby that they didn't choose,
- 45:28they didn't plan,
- 45:29whatever,
- 45:30maybe they would have wanted an abortion,
- 45:31they still pay.
- 45:32Pay child support that is a unique relationship
- 45:34with men having to pay child support
- 45:36because it shows there is a difference.
- 45:38The woman has to carry that child,
- 45:40right?
- 45:40She's actually
- 45:41bringing that child into the world.
- 45:42The man should have a role to play in in providing
- 45:45support and I think child support should actually start in utero.
- 45:48I think it should not start at birth.
- 45:49I think it should start because she is doing full
- 45:52caretaking for that child right before the baby's born,
- 45:55um,
- 45:55but to that scenario.
- 45:57Yeah,
- 45:58I mean it's around the clock,
- 45:59yeah,
- 45:59to the scenario you mentioned though about the,
- 46:01you know,
- 46:01well,
- 46:02if there was a tray of embryos,
- 46:04frozen embryos,
- 46:05right,
- 46:05and then there is this baby who's crying and there's a fire,
- 46:07who do you save?
- 46:08And I said,
- 46:09well,
- 46:09I run to the baby who's crying,
- 46:10and that's not because the babies who are the frozen embryos
- 46:14should be killed.
- 46:15It's not because I want them to die.
- 46:17It's not because they aren't valuable.
- 46:19It's because
- 46:20those,
- 46:20I mean,
- 46:21one argument kind of philosophically,
- 46:22you can make those babies who are
- 46:23in frozen in vitro.
- 46:25They belong to be safe in a mother's body.
- 46:27They don't belong in a deep freeze in a,
- 46:30in a fertility clinic.
- 46:31That's one of the reasons I'm opposed to IVF,
- 46:33by the way,
- 46:33because I think you put babies in very unsafe conditions and you shouldn't do that.
- 46:37It's not,
- 46:37it's not,
- 46:38it's outside of the natural order.
- 46:39There's a lot of other issues with it.
- 46:41But
- 46:41you,
- 46:41I run,
- 46:43yeah,
- 46:43but,
- 46:43and we can talk more about that,
- 46:44but I'd run to the baby because
- 46:46me running to those embryos,
- 46:48I,
- 46:48I'm not in the position to be able to save.
- 46:50Like,
- 46:50even if I grab those embryos,
- 46:52they were frozen,
- 46:53and now are they even in free?
- 46:54Are they going to thaw,
- 46:55you know,
- 46:56they're not in a safe,
- 46:57they're not in a way that I can go,
- 46:58oh,
- 46:58let me take them home and feed them and,
- 47:00you know,
- 47:01change their diaper.
- 47:01Like I,
- 47:02I don't even know if I could save their life even if I got them out of the fire,
- 47:04right?
- 47:05That baby who's crying,
- 47:06I know I can take care of that baby,
- 47:08right?
- 47:08I know I can run to that baby.
- 47:10Similarly,
- 47:11if there was 33 men in the fire and there was a baby crying,
- 47:14and in the moment of decision,
- 47:15I had to pick who do I save those 3 men or the baby,
- 47:18I'd still probably run to the baby.
- 47:20Not because I want 3 men to die,
- 47:22not because I don't value those men's life,
- 47:24not because even the baby is,
- 47:25you know,
- 47:26in terms of a legal system more valuable than the men.
- 47:28It's because that baby is crying and I,
- 47:30and I,
- 47:31I,
- 47:31my instinct is to rush to that baby.
- 47:33So
- 47:33I think that
- 47:34if that question is supposed to illustrate why it's
- 47:37OK to kill some babies who are unborn.
- 47:40It doesn't do that at all.
- 47:41It only accomplishes what our instinct might be in a moment of,
- 47:44of emergency
- 47:46and
- 47:47the,
- 47:47the reality that in a tragedy,
- 47:49you do your best you can,
- 47:50but you can't in this scenario.
- 47:51I'm not allowed to save everybody even though I would try,
- 47:54right?
- 47:54It doesn't say that these men or these,
- 47:57you know,
- 47:58frozen embryos have less value or it's OK to kill them,
- 48:01right?
- 48:01Because the scenario is being used to justify abortion.
- 48:04That's the thing.
- 48:04This isn't a scenario just like for fun,
- 48:06let's talk about a thought experiment.
- 48:07They're using it to say,
- 48:08look,
- 48:08you didn't,
- 48:09you didn't pick the embryos,
- 48:10therefore,
- 48:11it's abortion's OK somehow.
- 48:13No,
- 48:14direct and intentional killing of the men,
- 48:16of the embryos of the baby,
- 48:17of anyone is always wrong.
- 48:19You can give me any scenario you want.
- 48:21I'll try to save all of them,
- 48:22but I mean,
- 48:22my instinct,
- 48:23would I,
- 48:24would I save my child over somebody else's child?
- 48:26Maybe,
- 48:27maybe I,
- 48:27I,
- 48:27you know,
- 48:27I'd probably run to my child first.
- 48:29Does that mean that that person,
- 48:30other person's child isn't as valuable?
- 48:32Of course not,
- 48:33right?
- 48:34So we try to save everybody.
- 48:36I hate these scenarios because I'm always like,
- 48:37I will try to save them all,
- 48:38you know.
- 48:39Nobody likes answering these questions,
- 48:41but,
- 48:41but it doesn't prove abortion's OK.
- 48:43Is a point like they're trying to use it to somehow prove
- 48:46that some of these humans should have less legal status than others,
- 48:49and it doesn't prove that.
- 48:51So
- 48:51I totally hear you,
- 48:52and I,
- 48:53I appreciate your answer to that because that makes sense.
- 48:55I mean,
- 48:55even in the circumstance of like the three men and the crying baby,
- 48:58I think most humans are going to go for the crying baby.
- 49:01Um,
- 49:02there's a sense of innocence there,
- 49:04um,
- 49:05a more visceral sense of helplessness,
- 49:07yeah,
- 49:07um,
- 49:08and so that makes perfect sense.
- 49:10I think something you did bring up though is,
- 49:11you know,
- 49:12no matter what,
- 49:12it's a tragedy,
- 49:13like,
- 49:14it's a tragedy that I'm having to choose,
- 49:15it's a tragedy that these people might die uh versus these,
- 49:18and I'm having to make a difficult choice.
- 49:21Where someone like me who's very in the middle of
- 49:23the road on this issue and honestly subject to change.
- 49:28You know,
- 49:28frequently.
- 49:29I feel
- 49:30like.
- 49:32That when it comes to abortion,
- 49:33that's just sort of.
- 49:35Part of
- 49:36the framing,
- 49:37no matter what,
- 49:38this is a tragic situation,
- 49:40an unfortunate reality
- 49:43of
- 49:44existence,
- 49:45and so we are put in a position to make very,
- 49:47very difficult choices,
- 49:48one of those choices being outlawing
- 49:51it entirely,
- 49:52but then
- 49:54You know,
- 49:54like we talked about earlier,
- 49:56women who are raped,
- 49:57having to carry those
- 49:59pregnancies to term,
- 50:00that's something that's really hard to fathom,
- 50:02at least for me.
- 50:04Um,
- 50:04but then on the flip side,
- 50:07Allowing abortions to be.
- 50:10To casually thought of diminishes kind of the significance of pregnancy or,
- 50:15or even diminishes,
- 50:16I think.
- 50:17A societal um
- 50:20practice of.
- 50:22I think being responsible.
- 50:24And so somewhere I feel like
- 50:26in the middle is probably where I land,
- 50:28where like we need to treat
- 50:30sex
- 50:31seriously,
- 50:32we need to treat human life seriously,
- 50:34but also
- 50:37It feels impossible to eliminate this tragic circumstance of human
- 50:41reality.
- 50:42And so what's the best kind of middle ground,
- 50:45um,
- 50:46that,
- 50:46that as a society,
- 50:47as like a legal society through laws that we can construct
- 50:51to
- 50:53To protect the innocent,
- 50:54but also to not.
- 50:56Condemn the poor and vulnerable to even worse circumstances,
- 51:01um,
- 51:02and so,
- 51:02yeah,
- 51:02I think that analogy kind of brings that up for me where it's like no matter what,
- 51:05abortion doesn't,
- 51:06I don't think.
- 51:08It'd be rare for people to say like I want as many abortions as possible.
- 51:12I think we all,
- 51:14or most people would agree,
- 51:15we want to reduce
- 51:16unwanted pregnancies.
- 51:17We wanna reduce abortions,
- 51:20um,
- 51:21but I have a hard time seeing kind of a solution in the absolutes.
- 51:24Yeah.
- 51:25I totally hear what you're saying.
- 51:26I think the big difference though between that scenario
- 51:29and what you're describing is in an abortion,
- 51:31you don't like,
- 51:32oh,
- 51:32someone's chasing you down to give you an abortion,
- 51:34and you have to heroically stop them from giving you an abortion.
- 51:37You have to go out and get an abortion,
- 51:39and the abortion is direct and intentional killing
- 51:41of that baby and delivering a dead baby.
- 51:44So
- 51:44I think it would be different if like there was
- 51:46coercion and this woman is like fighting off this abortion,
- 51:48and she's like,
- 51:48OK,
- 51:49I'll get it because I'm protecting my life because
- 51:51this guy's trying to kill me or something crazy,
- 51:52right?
- 51:53But no,
- 51:54it's an abortion's about going out and seeking a procedure that
- 51:57intentionally and directly ends the life of a human being.
- 52:00And if you waited a few more months,
- 52:02that baby could live.
- 52:03You would still deliver the baby,
- 52:04like you're delivering the baby in an abortion.
- 52:07The baby's coming out of you the same way the baby.
- 52:09would come out of you if the baby was allowed to be born alive,
- 52:11but you're giving the baby a chance at life.
- 52:14And I,
- 52:14when I,
- 52:14I,
- 52:15I think about middle ground and I think about the importance of principles,
- 52:18we need to be founded on,
- 52:19on,
- 52:20on core values as a society,
- 52:22core rights,
- 52:23human rights.
- 52:24If the human right to life isn't first,
- 52:26what good is any other right?
- 52:28If you and I as innocent human beings,
- 52:30you know,
- 52:30we're not convicted in a court of law and sent off to jail,
- 52:32we are operating our life and someone comes out vigilante justice and says,
- 52:36I want you dead and shoots you,
- 52:37right?
- 52:38We had that right to live.
- 52:39There needs to be consequences that that that that is wrong that that happened to us.
- 52:43It should be wrong to murder you.
- 52:45It should be wrong to murder me.
- 52:47Similarly,
- 52:47even with all of the complications and the challenges
- 52:51that come with bringing life into the world,
- 52:52it should be wrong to murder children
- 52:54inside and outside of the womb.
- 52:57And I fear for our society.
- 52:59I think our society has gotten increasingly violent
- 53:01and callous towards towards human life.
- 53:04I think the killing of
- 53:05Charlie Kirk.
- 53:06The murder last week is an example.
- 53:08I think anytime there's a murder,
- 53:09it shows the callousness of human life that exists in our society.
- 53:13And I think abortion
- 53:14is a core part of that callousness,
- 53:16because instead of treating a new human life with,
- 53:18OK,
- 53:19let's band around and support this mother,
- 53:22help this baby be born,
- 53:24we say,
- 53:24Well,
- 53:24just get an abortion.
- 53:26It's legal.
- 53:26It's your choice.
- 53:27If you want to do that,
- 53:28you should do that.
- 53:28No,
- 53:29no,
- 53:29no issue.
- 53:30And we are treating life as cheap,
- 53:32and we're not respecting that first human right,
- 53:35which is life.
- 53:36And if I think if we want a loving and just society,
- 53:38we have to
- 53:39put our foot down.
- 53:41We have to say,
- 53:42it is never right to intentionally take an innocent human life,
- 53:44no matter the circumstances.
- 53:46It doesn't matter how difficult it is,
- 53:48how frustrated
- 53:49we are,
- 53:50how much in pain we are,
- 53:51we cannot take an innocent human life.
- 53:53That has to be the red line.
- 53:55And that is for children
- 53:56and humans outside of the womb,
- 53:58and it's for humans,
- 53:59children inside of the womb too.
- 54:02Mhm.
- 54:03Yeah,
- 54:03I respect,
- 54:04I respect your opinion on that.
- 54:06And you know,
- 54:06as I think about the future of um procreation.
- 54:11Um,
- 54:13It,
- 54:14it's gonna get pretty crazy.
- 54:15I mean,
- 54:16with some of the medical technology,
- 54:17uh,
- 54:18coming around and so.
- 54:20No matter where the line needs to be or what.
- 54:25Ultimately,
- 54:25we're going to need some sort of framework,
- 54:27I think,
- 54:27to face that future head on,
- 54:29um,
- 54:30because
- 54:31I think these moral
- 54:34Um,
- 54:35dilemmas are going to get much more complex and,
- 54:37and they're gonna,
- 54:38they're going to pop up a lot as we,
- 54:40as we see technology introduce new possibilities for
- 54:43How we're born,
- 54:45I,
- 54:45I agree,
- 54:46and I'll just say really quick on that,
- 54:48I think the moral framework does exist
- 54:50if we're willing to pay attention,
- 54:53and you mentioned,
- 54:53I think you said your parents or your grandparents were raised Catholic,
- 54:56and I actually
- 54:57became Catholic in college.
- 54:59I wasn't raised Catholic,
- 55:00so I never knew what that was like,
- 55:01but
- 55:02I started to study what the church teaches on human rights,
- 55:04human dignity,
- 55:06sexual,
- 55:07uh,
- 55:07morality,
- 55:08and it was all not some burden of some like,
- 55:10oh,
- 55:10it's trying to be,
- 55:11you know,
- 55:12wave its finger at people,
- 55:13but it was all designed for human flourishing
- 55:15and for building harmony in human relationships.
- 55:18And so the Catholic Church does have teaching on
- 55:20what to do with all of these reproductive technologies,
- 55:23and they're constantly developing more teaching
- 55:25as the reproductive technologies evolve,
- 55:27and I think that teaching is more important than ever.
- 55:30Because where are we going to draw the line,
- 55:31right?
- 55:31If you can create a baby
- 55:33in a test tube and then create it,
- 55:34put a baby in a surrogate womb in like a,
- 55:36in like a,
- 55:37you know,
- 55:38a robot womb,
- 55:39right?
- 55:39And then you can harvest that baby's organs
- 55:42in order to live longer,
- 55:44because unborn babies don't have a right.
- 55:45So why can't we do that,
- 55:46right?
- 55:47Where,
- 55:47where are we going to go as a society?
- 55:49It's going to become incredibly
- 55:50brutal and lawless and the strong dominating the weak.
- 55:54So we need a moral framework that isn't going to stand the test of time.
- 55:59And that moral framework,
- 56:00I believe has to include human life is sacred.
- 56:02You cannot kill it,
- 56:04innocent human life,
- 56:04you cannot kill it under any circumstances,
- 56:06and you cannot exploit it or dominate it,
- 56:09just because you're powerful and you might want to or you think it's best for you.
- 56:13And,
- 56:13and that's the fundamental pro-life position.
- 56:17I appreciate it,
- 56:17Lila.
- 56:18Um,
- 56:19last thing I would just say to you,
- 56:20not,
- 56:21not to open up the discussion anymore,
- 56:22but,
- 56:23um,
- 56:24I think a lot of the women expressed in the episode,
- 56:27a frustration,
- 56:28um,
- 56:28of either having experienced judgment from people who are,
- 56:32um,
- 56:32strongly pro-life,
- 56:34um,
- 56:34or the fear of being judged if they were to get an abortion.
- 56:38I feel like you're approaching these conversations with
- 56:41Um,
- 56:42a lot of respect towards the people you're talking to,
- 56:44and I think that's the way it has to be done,
- 56:46um,
- 56:47to approach some sort of agreed shared upon framework for the issue.
- 56:51So,
- 56:51I applaud you for how you're approaching this issue.
- 56:54And on behalf of Jubilee,
- 56:55you know,
- 56:56thanks for being in surrounded and,
- 56:58and,
- 56:58and,
- 56:58you know,
- 56:59doing this difficult task of,
- 57:01of debating a room full of,
- 57:03of people
- 57:04from the opposition.
- 57:12If you want to see more follow-up episodes of Surrounded,
- 57:14be sure to like,
- 57:15comment,
- 57:16subscribe,
- 57:17leave us a positive rating and review.
- 57:19If you want to see the video versions,
- 57:20you can watch them on Jubilee's second channel,
- 57:23Tubile.
- 57:24If you want to hear audio-only versions,
- 57:26you can follow the podcast wherever you get your podcasts.
- 57:29If you want to hear more from me,
- 57:30you can find me online,
- 57:31John Regalado on X or YouTube.
- 57:34Thanks so much for listening.
- 57:34Remember,
- 57:35you could be wrong,
- 57:36so could I.
- 57:37Keep your mind open
- 57:38until next time.