Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP310: What Shopify’s OpenAI Checkout Integration Means For Ecommerce Brands
Transcript
- 0:00But Google search is still growing.
- 0:02Google are also adapting their experience.
- 0:05They've also introduced AI mode in UK recently.
- 0:07It's been in the US for a long time.
- 0:09Percentage of traffic with AI inputs or percentage of searches
- 0:13AI inputs is growing massively. You're listening to Inside
- 0:18Commerce, a weekly ecom strategy, technology and CX
- 0:20focus podcast hosted by experienced digital consultants
- 0:23and re platform specialist James Get and Paul Rogers.
- 0:25Get insights into ecom strategy, leading brands, hear from
- 0:28industry thought leaders and leading tech vendors with
- 0:30practical advice to help you improve your online CX.
- 0:35This episode is sponsored by Shopify and rather amusingly we
- 0:38talk about a big announcement that concerns Shopify this week,
- 0:41which is the impact of like Open AI Checkout and Agentic Commerce
- 0:45and ecom brands. Unless you are hiding away from
- 0:49LinkedIn, you will have seen a story or a post comments about
- 0:53this during the week. It's created quite a buzz in in
- 0:57social media and we want to pull apart what this means.
- 1:00The practice is buying it and trying to spell some of the hype
- 1:03because there is a lot of inevitably when big new tech
- 1:05announcements come out, the hype begins and we want to focus on
- 1:08what this really means, where it's heading, the realities
- 1:11because nobody knows defensively where agentic commerce ends up
- 1:14in the next three to five years. Although there is a direction of
- 1:17travel. We've got alongside myself and
- 1:19Paul today we've got 2 highly experienced people in the
- 1:23industry who are heavily involved in leading agencies and
- 1:26who put a lot of really useful content out around this kind of
- 1:29like technology evolution on LinkedIn.
- 1:32So first one, welcome to Chris Marshall who's Co founder
- 1:34Onstate, a leading Shopify agency.
- 1:38Thanks, James. Yeah, yeah, thanks for everyone.
- 1:40Podcast, long time listener, but yeah, first time on here
- 1:44obviously. So yeah, just a little bit about
- 1:47on state, we're a Shopify Premier Partner based up in
- 1:51Leeds. Myself before starting the
- 1:54business, I worked client side. I was head of e-commerce for
- 1:58High Street fashion retailer. Prior to that, I work for Sky
- 2:00Sports and we are, yeah, we, we, we've, we've worked on a number
- 2:05of platforms over the years. About five years ago, we decided
- 2:08to go all in on Shopify, having worked with Magento Salesforce
- 2:11previously. For most of the last couple of
- 2:13years, I've been very preoccupied by the subject of
- 2:16AII, arrived at first from a sense of existential dread
- 2:21because, you know, we sell knowledge and we sell code, and
- 2:24all of a sudden there's this technology there which promises
- 2:26to do both. So I was very, very interested
- 2:29when 3.5 first came out to explore it.
- 2:32And yeah, I've immersed myself in it, and I think it's really
- 2:34interesting, But a very interesting point right now,
- 2:37like with announcements this week about, yeah, we see AI
- 2:41finally beginning to have an impact on e-commerce, and it's
- 2:43really interesting to ponder and think about where that might go.
- 2:47Thanks and yeah, thank, thanks for joining us on the podcast.
- 2:49Glad to have you on and warm welcome to Liam.
- 2:51Liam's come out. This might be your third podcast
- 2:53now with us, Sir. So Liam was previously of Avon
- 2:57and an independent technology consultant is now Director of
- 3:00innovation at another well known ecom agency Visual Soft.
- 3:03So Liam, do you want to give give people who might not have
- 3:06come across you a bit of a phase of who you are and what you do?
- 3:09Yeah, thanks Sir. Thanks for having me back on.
- 3:11So yeah, I worked with Paul for. 5 or so years.
- 3:15Across, so my background was more Shopify focused, but tech
- 3:20focused essentially. So across a range of platforms
- 3:24sort of when part time to focus more on some of the AI and
- 3:30innovation stuff that had been going on in the ecosystem.
- 3:34And then, yeah, the last two or three months sort of taken that
- 3:39to Visual Soft, who've moved from being their own platforms
- 3:43and sort of tech focused company to being Shopify only focused.
- 3:49So yeah, trying to take what I've learned in those roles and
- 3:52build out a soft innovation and tech arm within.
- 3:56Visual soft cool. So let's get stuck into, so
- 4:01before we start recording, we're all talking about the fact that
- 4:03there are, there are always self-interest elements with,
- 4:06with new tech trying to push it, trying to, I guess, create buzz
- 4:09that you have to completely change your ways of work and you
- 4:12need to invest loads. You need to bring in lots of
- 4:14consultants to, to nail the latest tech and, and use it
- 4:17within the business. And we always try and urge
- 4:20people not to make knee jerk reactions because you can end up
- 4:23burning a lot of money making poor decisions.
- 4:24So, but we want to, we want to challenge that.
- 4:26We want to look at what, what this announcement means, what
- 4:30the practicality are, what the, what the potential of it is,
- 4:33what the potential issues and, and weaknesses and limitations
- 4:36are and where we see this heading.
- 4:37So we'll start with like a general perception of, of what
- 4:40this announcement made. And so Chris, do you want to do
- 4:42you want to kick us off? Like what are your, what are
- 4:43your first thoughts when Shopify and open AII made the
- 4:47announcement? And we know it's not a sequel.
- 4:48We know that that this has been worked towards for a while now.
- 4:52Yeah. And we know that Shopify is, you
- 4:54know, is very much embracing AI and becoming an AI centred
- 4:58company. So this is, they've announced a
- 5:01few things this year. There was, there's the catalog
- 5:04API, which basically is a, is a product feed for, for LMS.
- 5:08Essentially, if we're to distill it down to something very, very
- 5:09simple, there's the knowledge base as well, which is another
- 5:13way for Shopify brands to Shopify merchants to make
- 5:17content available to inform these decision making engines.
- 5:20And this sort of closes the loop really.
- 5:22This is this is the check out part of it.
- 5:24I think, you know, it does raise some really interesting
- 5:27questions that like you say, there's a lot of hype, There's a
- 5:29lot of people out, you know, saying this is it, you know,
- 5:31cropping has changed forever. You know, my personal opinion is
- 5:35that this is the the difficulty is that there's lots of hype,
- 5:39but actually behind the hype, there is some very, very useful
- 5:41technology here. So it's, it's trying to find the
- 5:44signal in the noise. My, my own, my own opinion is
- 5:48that this is an interesting new channel and it's obviously
- 5:50growing very quickly. It, you know, by, by the, the
- 5:53numbers that you know, like open AI themselves publish, you know,
- 5:56they've, they've looked into how people are using the platform.
- 5:59They've determined that a lot of activity is what they call
- 6:03purchase adjacent. So it's, you know, people
- 6:05researching things. And obviously, you know, they
- 6:08say there's 700 million users on the platform as of July this
- 6:10year. You know, it's, it's an
- 6:11opportunity that that can't be ignored, but I think we just
- 6:14need to take step back and think, no, it's not everybody's
- 6:17just going to start shopping like this.
- 6:18You know, this is going to be part of the mix along with your
- 6:21existing channels. But I think, you know, to talk
- 6:23about it, it throws up some really interesting questions
- 6:26about the technology, but also shopper behaviour.
- 6:29Yeah, I like that the finding the signal and the noise, which
- 6:32I've now adopted for the the part of the title of this
- 6:35podcast where that I think that's a great segue Liam and
- 6:39Paul, you guys to build on that finding the signal noise.
- 6:41I think it's quite a nice way of framing this.
- 6:44Yeah, I thought, I thought I was actually surprised by the amount
- 6:48of hype just because it feels like there's a few parts of it
- 6:51have already been sort of announced and and released in
- 6:55the last few months. So it shouldn't have been that
- 6:58much of a surprise. I think it's really exciting for
- 7:01some of the long term possibilities that it opens up.
- 7:06So it's like, yeah, a few. So yeah, I think the shopping
- 7:10has changed forever. Maybe in the long term some of
- 7:13the things that opens up is, is along that route.
- 7:16But in the short term there's opportunity, but but maybe not
- 7:20game changing opportunity immediately for brands is
- 7:23probably my initial reaction. Yeah.
- 7:26I think adding to your first point, I think everyone expected
- 7:29this. I think.
- 7:30Yeah, I'd heard the shop by integration was coming.
- 7:34I think makes complete sense for Open AI to go with Etsy and
- 7:37Shopify to get a level of volume early on.
- 7:40But from what I've heard, they're also talking to all the
- 7:43other platforms. I do think similarly to Tick
- 7:46Tock Shop, there's like a big advantage with shop fire because
- 7:50of how clean they're kind of I assume, or a lot of people
- 7:54assume it'll be a sales channel, may not be.
- 7:57But if it is, you know, it's a very clean way of kind of
- 8:00managing the integration into ChatGPT versus other platforms
- 8:05where you'll your Ivy is a third party or you'll have a more
- 8:08bespoke connector. So I think there is competitive
- 8:12advantage there. But to be honest, yeah, I agree
- 8:14very little yeah, what expected it.
- 8:18But the bigger thing is the strike piece because there are a
- 8:21lot of rumours that shot the fire.
- 8:23We're going to power check out. And so I think that's actually
- 8:26the bigger piece. And I thought it could well be
- 8:28Stripe because check out solution would be grow massively
- 8:33it I think it'd be a lot more cost effective than if you were
- 8:36to use someone like Shopify. But yeah, I think that's a
- 8:40pretty big, that's probably the bigger piece for me is like the
- 8:43involvement of Stripe and how like, yeah, intertwined striper
- 8:48with all the agentic stuff. What do Mattel, Victoria,
- 8:54Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier all have in common?
- 8:59They power their businesses with Shopify.
- 9:03Shopify is the most innovative and scaled commerce platform on
- 9:06the planet. It also happens to have the best
- 9:10converting check out on the planet Shopify, Powering the
- 9:15future of Enterprise commerce. Find out more at
- 9:18shopify.com/enterprise. I, I find this really
- 9:23interesting because we, we've been here before cyclically and
- 9:25we in E com in wider tech industries about something
- 9:30that's fundamentally going to shift everything forever and
- 9:33change the way people shop. We had it with Web 3 metaverse,
- 9:36like everyone's going to be shopping in virtual worlds and,
- 9:39and everyone, you know, everyone's got to invest
- 9:41massively in blockchain. And we've done all of these.
- 9:43And behind, like Chris, you were saying, behind the noise, there
- 9:46were lots of really good signals and lots of practical use cases.
- 9:49And in certain, certain categories like gaming to take
- 9:51off massively for global premium brands, things like, you know,
- 9:55brand placement and branded purchasable items within like
- 10:00specific online communities that work well.
- 10:02But it's not mass market and it's never got to mass market
- 10:05for many reasons. And that's where my head's out
- 10:07on this is a, is a you, you fundamentally as an ecom
- 10:11business and leader, have to understand the implications of
- 10:16new tech and where it's impacting shopper behaviour.
- 10:20But you've got to put a practicality lens.
- 10:22And this is like how how practical is it that it's going
- 10:25to change, you know, a big part of your marketing mix?
- 10:28Or is this going to be, is it incremental?
- 10:29Is it substitutional? Is it just experimental for your
- 10:34audience? Because actually the nature of
- 10:35your product means long term people aren't really going to
- 10:37want to shop in this way because that process is not experiential
- 10:41enough for them to get what they need from ACX point of view to
- 10:44continue purchasing that way. And wear my heads out on this
- 10:47is, is a, you've got to, you've got to have a, an approach to
- 10:51it, but you don't want to be fundamentally changing
- 10:53everything for it because you don't yet know how seriously
- 10:56your customers are going to take this as a purchase channel.
- 11:00Yeah, I think it's really interesting from like the, the,
- 11:03the point that the, the, the sort of pended you up for me
- 11:05about where how this could be really useful.
- 11:07It's about a year ago I used the ChatGPT app quite a lot and
- 11:11talked to it quite a lot, probably more than I should do
- 11:13or I did at the time. And I was I was fixing my
- 11:17parents had a problem with their home alarm and I was I was
- 11:20trying to fix it not doing very well at a cable.
- 11:22I took a photo of the cable and I said, is this an Ethernet
- 11:25cable? I mean, I've worked in tech for
- 11:2720 odd years. I shouldn't know what an
- 11:28Ethernet cable looks like, but it was able to say, no, that's
- 11:31not an Ethernet cable. Tell me what it was.
- 11:33And at that point, I thought that, you know, there is a
- 11:36really good opportunity, you know, for, for, to commercialise
- 11:38this product because, you know, I'm obviously looking for
- 11:41something and it knows what it is.
- 11:43It's got immense utility. You know, that's, that was a
- 11:46much better experience than say, you know, using Google search,
- 11:49for example, to, to, to find the answer to the same question.
- 11:52And the fact that, you know, if you could slip a, you know, a
- 11:54buying opportunity into an experience like that, then
- 11:57that's obviously quite compelling.
- 11:58So the question you asked was a really good question is, is it
- 12:01additive? Is it, is it, is it, is it
- 12:03incremental or is it a mix? I think it's definitely, it's
- 12:05definitely a mix. You know, people research
- 12:07products, they find products mainly, you know, online through
- 12:10search and social. Now we've got this as well.
- 12:13This is another, this is another way they're going to do it.
- 12:15So is it going to take a chunk of that pie?
- 12:18It definitely is, you know, if the numbers are to be believed.
- 12:20And, you know, and it's going to be really interesting when this
- 12:22thing is switched on and people start seeing, you know, sales
- 12:27from ChatGPT start appearing in their, their orders dashboard in
- 12:30Shopify. But there, there, there is
- 12:34potential for it to be additive as well, because it does present
- 12:36these commercial opportunities in a really neat way.
- 12:38But I think a lot of that hinges on adoption of things like the,
- 12:43the ChatGPT app, as, you know, as personal assistants, you
- 12:47know, if people start to use that.
- 12:48And I'm still, you know, I've, I'm ahead in this for two years,
- 12:50I'm still quite surprised. And even talking to, you know,
- 12:53people in the industry, I think we had a conversation about this
- 12:56a few months ago, Liam, like there was a sense that people
- 12:58were ignoring it. You know, the sort of AI
- 13:01literacy isn't there yet in the general market, I don't think.
- 13:04And it's going to be interesting to see, you know, people have
- 13:06had Siri and Google Assistant for years.
- 13:08You know, now these things can be a bit more useful.
- 13:11And, and Alexa, are they going to get adoption?
- 13:13And if they do, then obviously this thing could this thing
- 13:16could take off quite significantly.
- 13:18Yeah. And one of the elements that
- 13:19brings up for me is the trust and, and, and how people trust
- 13:23new tech when it comes to payments, because product
- 13:26research, products discovery is one thing.
- 13:28Trust in a new tech that's faceless, essentially, that that
- 13:33hasn't, hasn't got. You can't see the people behind
- 13:36it in the same way that you can if you're purchasing from brand
- 13:39trust in that as check out mechanism.
- 13:41I'm intrigued to see what that adoption rate is and how quickly
- 13:46people switch to the commerce angle versus the discovery
- 13:50angle. So Liam, Paul, what what's your
- 13:53view on, on whether there will be trust issues for people to
- 13:58adopt agentic commerce rather than like agentic search in
- 14:02greater numbers? Yeah, I think, I think there
- 14:06will definitely and and there's trust even in answers that, you
- 14:11know, even searching for questions with ChatGPT, there's
- 14:14trust issues in the answers that that that comes up and that sort
- 14:18of thing. So I think that, you know,
- 14:20whatever the numbers that Chris just gave of the amount of
- 14:23people using Chat GPTI don't think it's suddenly that amount
- 14:26of people that are ready and willing to actually make
- 14:29purchases via ChatGPT. Having said that, I think it's
- 14:35like balanced by convenience where immediately if the
- 14:40convenience of buying the convenience of sort of immediate
- 14:46check out is such that actually you get over the trust issues
- 14:50quite quickly, I think. Yeah, I think there's a there's
- 14:54a balance in that there. So I think the uptake
- 14:56immediately is probably slowish as people like as it becomes a
- 15:01bit of a new norm. But yeah, I think that the yeah,
- 15:05the potential for just the the massive convenience like saving
- 15:11convenience will one minute does get adopted.
- 15:14I think from my perspective, so yeah, I think they're they're,
- 15:19you know, there's always going to be an adoption path.
- 15:22And yeah, there's a lot of people that don't want to move
- 15:25onto these solutions and like a lot of maybe older people as
- 15:28well that just hate AI. So I think that's one factor.
- 15:32But I think one thing that a lot of people are forgetting is that
- 15:35whilst, you know, obviously open AI is new, it's a net new
- 15:38solution, obviously growing super fast, but Google search is
- 15:44still growing. Google are also adapting their
- 15:47experience. So like they've also introduced
- 15:49AI mode in UK recently. It's been in the US for a long
- 15:51time. Percentage of traffic with AI
- 15:56inputs, architectural searches, AI inputs is growing massively.
- 15:59And then they're starting to demo now.
- 16:03So yesterday I was watching an experience of basically ads
- 16:07within AI mode. And I think that, you know,
- 16:10Google are also doing a lot in this space.
- 16:13So I think people forget the maybe Google are actually gonna
- 16:16create an equivalent experience within search and also try and
- 16:22obviously build an equivalent kind of relationship with a
- 16:25user. So I think that's for me, I
- 16:28actually think that's just, or people should be thinking about
- 16:31that a lot more rather than just thinking about ChatGPT because I
- 16:35think they've already built the commercial nature into their
- 16:39product. I think they've the other thing
- 16:40that people don't talk about is ChatGPT when you start to look
- 16:44at product results, like usually they're terrible.
- 16:46In my experience, if you compare the results from Google and
- 16:51ChatGPT when you're looking for like, you know, products like
- 16:55chat chief cheers nowhere near as like well educated.
- 16:59And they clearly haven't had that, you know, time and
- 17:02investment into search results because they're not, you know,
- 17:05driven by ad revenue and everything else that Google
- 17:08have. So I still think, and I think I
- 17:11don't be wrong. I think, you know, the level,
- 17:15like the speed, the open AI moving out, it's clear they're
- 17:17going to get there. It's clear they're going to play
- 17:19a big part in all of this, but I think the experience of buying
- 17:22that is still not optimised. I think the quality of results
- 17:26are still not optimised. And I think whilst everyone's
- 17:28watching ChatGPT, Google also making a lot of shifts as well.
- 17:34I think, I think that's yeah, the quality, I mean, the the
- 17:38sheer number of years that Google's had to refine and
- 17:41perfect his algorithm to well down the quality signals because
- 17:45those are what drive it's revenue is a massive advantage.
- 17:49The one thing that Google's struggled historically is
- 17:52nailing down the checkout experience.
- 17:55They've got Google check has never taken off in the way they
- 17:58wanted to being pay is never landed in the way that Apple Pay
- 18:02did. And the massive issue you're
- 18:03going to have is how do they get that checkout experience?
- 18:06See that one, one of the things that that the open AI and that
- 18:10shop finding, I mean open AI done smartly is you're right,
- 18:12Stripe, Stripe is such a respected global payment
- 18:17network. You know it, it's got the
- 18:19payment methods, it's got the diversity of payment options in
- 18:22there. I I wonder how Google will will
- 18:25make that work as a counterpart. I think, you know, are we going
- 18:30to say that, yeah, this is probably one of the points I was
- 18:32going to raise that this is exciting.
- 18:35And I think they're sort of agentic commerce approach is
- 18:38again, long term going to be a direction that takes off.
- 18:42But but it's not ChatGPT is not the be all and end all of that.
- 18:47And I think Google, it's like, yeah, the trajectories move
- 18:51ChatGPT, but that's like, I don't expect Google just Google
- 18:54just lay down and die and let the numbers completely change.
- 18:58And I think actually over the last 12 or 18 months, you know,
- 19:01if we're looking at the AI space, 18 months ago, they said
- 19:05Google probably felt like the one that have dropped the ball.
- 19:08It felt like they were running behind against Meta ChatGPT, you
- 19:13know, some of the others. But over this last 12 or 18
- 19:16months have probably come on more than more than any of the
- 19:20others across the different strands of AI.
- 19:22I think they've done some really good stuff over the last year or
- 19:24so. And yeah, I would expect that
- 19:28they'll have their own offering for agentic commerce.
- 19:31And I think the long term, some of the long term benefits are
- 19:35when it's, you know, this stuff's natively, you know,
- 19:38voice controlled via the phone. So it's not just chat to your BT
- 19:41app. It's it's actually, you know,
- 19:44voice control through the phone is probably the most simple way
- 19:49we could ask to buy something. And when you know if Google own
- 19:5350% of the phones in the UK for I don't know what the number is,
- 19:57but you know, Google powering a lot of the phones in the UK.
- 20:01They've got the advantage on that.
- 20:02So so yeah, I think it's like just over because of ChatGPT.
- 20:08The other things are like town hall about yesterday, Josh did
- 20:11this talk on like where Google's header and he showed an example
- 20:16of like essentially how because I think the way that Google see
- 20:21their experience changing is obviously Google knows a lot
- 20:25about us as an individual. And yeah, we've all been new
- 20:27from Google for ages. We provide more context, Google,
- 20:30everything else. So they're already in a really
- 20:32good position to kind of provide relevant, relevant results.
- 20:37But essentially Josh's example that was, I think Google must
- 20:40have given him a video or something of like an example.
- 20:43But basically I type in mountain bike.
- 20:45It's immediately then asked me more questions.
- 20:48And then based on a combination of what I'm putting and what
- 20:51Google really knows about this, it shows like the most relevant
- 20:55possible subset products. And I think that the potential
- 21:00long term route would be more of an affiliate model, which is
- 21:04what ChatGPT have said they're going to do.
- 21:06And essentially you're paying for like the most relevant
- 21:10product that you're probably paying a percentage of sale.
- 21:13But even even if it's not the affiliate model, like I think
- 21:16that's kind of where it will go where they kind of monetize
- 21:20maybe, yeah, slightly differently, like really high
- 21:23purchase intent traffic, like higher than what you would
- 21:26probably see from Google Shopping like that.
- 21:29Yeah. So the question for brands and
- 21:31retailers then is how do you appear in that?
- 21:32Because what you just described that at some point there's still
- 21:36a search happening. It's not you typing into a box
- 21:39on Google or it's the agent is gathering information from you.
- 21:43And then you see this on one of the, on some of the reasoning
- 21:45models, you can see the chain of thought and you can see them and
- 21:48it's really interesting, like you mentioned, trust, like do I
- 21:51trust the results? So is it even with that
- 21:53information, is it going to make the best search?
- 21:54You know, what index is it using?
- 21:56You know, Google's got the best relevance.
- 21:58You know, it has done for a long time online, so you could maybe
- 22:02trust a Google product to do that.
- 22:04But you know, I see some of the queries they're making on my
- 22:06behalf and I'm thinking, well, I wouldn't search like that
- 22:08because I want this specifically.
- 22:10So ultimately, you know, it, there is still a search in there
- 22:14and there's, and there's a question of relevance and
- 22:15there's a question of trust. So at some point deep down in
- 22:18the machine, like those old rules from SEO around relevancy
- 22:22and trust still will apply because you know, these, these
- 22:28aren't looking at the whole Internet every time, you know,
- 22:30they've got a finite amount of space in the context windows.
- 22:34They've got to isolate a bunch of products and then make some
- 22:37decisions and, and recommend some to you.
- 22:38So it's how do you get into that first bit?
- 22:40And then how do you how do you surface in the second bit?
- 22:43Let's let's throw a bit more into what we think the
- 22:45commercial we're going to do with commercial opportunity.
- 22:47And then what do we think the limitations are of where it's at
- 22:49right now from a surely from the commerce point of view, not from
- 22:52like the research and information angle.
- 22:54But, and Chris, you touched on this earlier about the, you've
- 22:58given your Ethernet cable example about how that can be
- 23:00really powerful if you're seeking validation or something
- 23:03specific and then wanting to turn that into a quick purchase
- 23:07option. So what type of patch are you
- 23:08talking about? Because in my, in my head so far
- 23:11thinking this, this doesn't feel remotely premium.
- 23:13And I think Paul, you alludes to that one of your posts.
- 23:15I can't imagine like a, a premium, like a premium brand,
- 23:19like a Chanel gun. Yeah, it'd be great when I mean,
- 23:21obviously you can't stop people looking for it, but it, it feels
- 23:25I, I can't imagine that the kind of shopper who buys from a
- 23:27premium brand is probably searching for that type of
- 23:30product through theirs. But everyday purchase like
- 23:33repeat buys, essential things like ticketing I can see working
- 23:37well. What type of product do you
- 23:39think is going to is going to sell well through this?
- 23:42Yeah. Let's go to Chris some more.
- 23:45Come back. Yeah, you go first.
- 23:46You go first. Yeah, things like utilities, for
- 23:51example, you know, you know, there's different type of
- 23:53shopping, isn't there? Like, you know, shopping is a
- 23:55leisure activity for lots of people and you know that, that
- 23:57and there's, there's pleasure in the experience, you know,
- 23:59especially when it comes to fashion and you know, where
- 24:01shopping is, you know, it's like a form of self-expression.
- 24:04It's quite enjoyable, you know, especially, you know, physical
- 24:06retail, But things like, you know, buying utilities, for
- 24:10example, if I can send my agent away and say, look, you know,
- 24:13find me the best, you know, energy deal for the house for
- 24:16the next year, that is something you'll probably happily
- 24:19delegate, you know, and then come back in an hour with the
- 24:21recommendations. And I think you still, you know,
- 24:24there's a lot of talk about people you, you know, about
- 24:27these, these, these systems making autonomous purchasing
- 24:32decisions. I think we're a way off that.
- 24:34I think, you know, that you've, you've already touched on trust
- 24:37and hallucinations and things like that are very much still a
- 24:40factor. And they're not bugs.
- 24:42These are, these are features of, of the technology.
- 24:44You know, that's one of the reasons why it works so well is
- 24:47that it sometimes just makes stuff up.
- 24:50That is great if you're using it in a work context, for example,
- 24:53for, for brainstorming or if it's making a decision for a
- 24:58retailer, if it's whether to apply a refund or, or something
- 25:01it's or, you know, making a decision on your behalf about
- 25:03whether to buy something. I don't think we're there yet.
- 25:06And I think, you know, we're still going to see like a human
- 25:07in the loop. But I think, yeah, I think, you
- 25:10know, there's different types of shopping.
- 25:12And if it can automate away some of the more mundane stuff, then
- 25:17that's probably where it's going to get traction earlier.
- 25:19Sorry, Paul, No go on and. I think one thing that I was
- 25:23going to say, Liam, I'll let you answer in a second.
- 25:26But one thing that I was, so I about a month ago, we basically
- 25:32got a lot of client there to sit in the data warehouse and I got
- 25:35data engineer to basically show trends around like where traffic
- 25:41is growing conversion rate, everything else across like 40
- 25:44or 50 retailers and the one that stood out to me.
- 25:47So most of them are tiny volume still, but growing super
- 25:51quickly. And the only products that are
- 25:54getting kind of meaningful traffic are more technical.
- 25:57So it's where essentially people are doing deep research into a
- 26:00product and then discovering which I think is probably a good
- 26:05use case for Tragicity at the moment.
- 26:07And the retailer that was getting the most essentially
- 26:11volume of traffic was a technical, a very technical
- 26:16music product or they produce technical music products.
- 26:21So essentially they're doing lots of the users do a lot of
- 26:23research into like specifications, everything else.
- 26:25They're discovering the the retail or the manufacturer and
- 26:30the product. They're then going through to
- 26:32the website and then in my opinion, they'll have a lead
- 26:35time and they'll probably do additional comparison on via
- 26:39Google, etcetera, etcetera. But I think that's a really
- 26:42interesting one because I think a lot of people will discover
- 26:44product, they then go through to a website which obviously a lot
- 26:48of people are predicting will disappear at some point.
- 26:51And that website, you know, is selling visually, they're
- 26:53presenting video content, they're presenting, you know,
- 26:56customer feedback, they're offering finance payments,
- 27:00everything else, you know, they're offering potential like
- 27:04video consultations, etcetera. And yeah, I think that's just an
- 27:09interesting thing because I still think, I mean, Dogan, I
- 27:12completely agree with what you're saying.
- 27:13I think a lot of people might any kind of commodity product or
- 27:17anything that they've had before or anything else, they might
- 27:19then go to purchase by ChatGPT. I think ChatGPT could take a
- 27:25chunk out of Google Shopping because, you know, there's a lot
- 27:27of products that I would personally type in Google, find
- 27:30the cheapest 1, go to buy quickly.
- 27:32That's a pretty, pretty clear use case for it.
- 27:36But yeah, I mean, I said the interesting thing is I think
- 27:40there'll be a lot of discovery via ChatGPT, but I think a lot
- 27:44of that discovery weren't purchased via ChatGPT.
- 27:49I I do agree with that. I was thinking about it as I
- 27:53think maybe Paul, you put something on LinkedIn about like
- 27:56the premium brands and experience.
- 27:58I think short, like it makes complete sense.
- 28:01The sort of normal, you know, Amazon things that you stick in
- 28:05the car and buy quickly without thinking about it will be
- 28:08through ChatGPT and the discovery piece.
- 28:11But I think this like I don't think the website is just going
- 28:16to overnight not be needed. I think there's always going to
- 28:19be a brand presence there and they'll always be used for it.
- 28:24Like maybe the amount of traffic moving through will drop.
- 28:29But then I guess from a premium brand perspective, after, you
- 28:33know, the brand, like the value in going repeatedly going to the
- 28:38website to buy drops. And I think there's, you know,
- 28:42when you're talking about the video content and image console,
- 28:45like all of that will be pulled into chat.
- 28:47It's maybe not in this first version, but all of that reviews
- 28:50will be summarized and pulled into ChatGPT, all that stuff
- 28:54will be brought in. I think unless it's like a
- 28:56complete unknown for the say like, you know, who do you buy
- 29:01the APC? You have a new sweatshirt out.
- 29:03Do you do need to go through to the site again to see that?
- 29:07Or if you see that in just GPT, is that enough for you to buy?
- 29:11I think there will be there will be a drop in people needing that
- 29:17like brand experience. And then so like the amount of
- 29:22brands that we've worked with that have done big CRO pieces
- 29:26where they actually sacrifice some of the brand experience to
- 29:29optimize for conversion. Like this is ultimately, instead
- 29:33of the small percentages potentially doubling your
- 29:36conversion, like there's a balance again of a brand's going
- 29:40to sacrifice some of that. I think that's real interesting
- 29:44challenge here though, because you know, in parallel
- 29:47discussions we've had this whole concept of, of people haven't
- 29:50invested too much in bottom of the funnel, not enough on top of
- 29:53the whole and acquisition at the expense of retention, loyalty
- 29:57ChatGPT is not an customer experience environment, right?
- 30:01You can't control it. It's, it's a, it's basically a
- 30:04completely independent environment.
- 30:06Yes, you can optimise coming back to like Chris, all of your
- 30:08points are about you. You can structure and optimise
- 30:10your data, but to get accurate data in there in the 1st place
- 30:13and over time, they are you saying they're inevitably going
- 30:16to enrich the type of data they bring in.
- 30:19But fundamentally you'll do nothing to to engage people and
- 30:22give people a reason to come back.
- 30:24And that will be my concern. But it's not a concern is you
- 30:27can't stop people shopping. But how many people will go who
- 30:33will be willing to purchase items where there is, I guess,
- 30:37an emotional attachment to that purchase clothing, some for some
- 30:41people's function for a lot of people.
- 30:42You're buying into a brand. You're buying into a particular
- 30:44style of feeling when you're purchasing it.
- 30:47I'm not yet convinced that that sacrificing the control of
- 30:53experience is a good long term strategy.
- 30:56Well, I think some. On the sites.
- 30:58Some brands might not even want, you know, experience at all.
- 31:03Like I think some luxury brands, I agree, I think eventually like
- 31:08they'll have to allow for more of an experience via the
- 31:11interface. But I think the interest, I
- 31:14mean, when you go on LinkedIn, everyone's saying, you know,
- 31:15they're going to kill every sales channel.
- 31:17I think the thing that people are naive about is the role of
- 31:21Meta and TikTok in product discovery.
- 31:25And I actually think it's going to be really interested to see
- 31:27how they evolve because the opportunities there after, you
- 31:31know them to play a bigger role in this as well.
- 31:33And obviously the I think there's a start around like
- 31:37people under the age of 25 average 5 hours a day on
- 31:41Instagram over a weekend, something like that.
- 31:44And it's like the opportunity if you know, users, user behaviour
- 31:49changes. I personally think, you know,
- 31:51there's a real, there's more of a role they could play in this
- 31:54whole piece. But yeah, I think it'll be
- 31:56interesting. There's also rumours open AI
- 31:58building a tip Tock compressed that's trying well.
- 32:00I was just about to say, did you say?
- 32:02I mean, it went under the radar in the LinkedIn noise I guess,
- 32:07but did you see the pulse open? AI Pulse.
- 32:11Stolen our way. So I know you want to copyright
- 32:14that that again, this so it's not just like trying to take a
- 32:19bite out of Google ads and Google shopping.
- 32:21It's like actually trying to take, you know, trying to bring
- 32:25out the platform that's going to take the attention and the doom
- 32:28scrolling, then feed in the the transactions into that.
- 32:32And actually being able to as a daily, you know, people have
- 32:36used Feedly for years to, to, to see what's going on day-to-day
- 32:39or, you know, Twitter, I guess it's the new Twitter or it's now
- 32:44where actually, if they can surface good relevant content
- 32:47for me, day-to-day enters a place to get the attention.
- 32:51And then so so yeah, I guess it's also competing with the Tik
- 32:56Toks and and Facebooks. Which?
- 33:00Is interesting. On the subject of like the
- 33:02future, the website, it, there's the, there's the brand and
- 33:06experiential side of it as well, but there's also really
- 33:08practical concerns around different types of fulfillment
- 33:13and, you know, different types of products.
- 33:15So, for example, you know, a couple of clients that we work
- 33:18with are Abbott Lyon Massively, you know, lots and lots of
- 33:21personalized, customized products, which requires, you
- 33:24know, deeply complex UI, you know, to to visualize and to
- 33:28configure. That is something that
- 33:31marketplaces have never solved. I'm really interested to see
- 33:34that Etsy's launch partner, because Etsy do have quite a lot
- 33:36of personalisation going on there.
- 33:38So I'm going to be interested to see how that is handled on on in
- 33:42ChatGPT. Am I going to get fields where I
- 33:44can write people's names in and things like that?
- 33:47And then the other side of it, so using another example, Mamas
- 33:49and Papas, one of our, you know, multi channel retail clients, we
- 33:52were very closely with Shopify. And going back to your point
- 33:55about Shopify, check out Paul like to with the checkout team
- 34:00to make sure that these multi channel use cases were served.
- 34:04You know, so I can I can pick up in store.
- 34:05I can pick up from a locker. Now, you know, what is what is
- 34:10open AIS appetite to start to build, you know, to, to build a
- 34:13proper checkout, you know, so that you can facilitate all of
- 34:16this because it's no small undertaking.
- 34:19And you know, we have this problem today with, you know,
- 34:21Apple Pay and Google Pay. You know, if we've got a client
- 34:23who wants to offer, you know, anything beyond, you know,
- 34:27standard next day, etcetera, if they want to offer name day or
- 34:31click and collect or whatever, it's difficult to you can't
- 34:33render it in the Apple paycheck out or the other Google paycheck
- 34:37out. The only sort of so kind of
- 34:40universal check out that has actually moved to to to solve
- 34:43this is is Shopify and shop pay where any customization you
- 34:47build in your Shopify check out manifests as well in the shop
- 34:51paycheck out. So you can, you can control it.
- 34:53And I, you know, I was quite surprised actually, because, you
- 34:56know, brands and retailers are probably going to be looking at,
- 34:59right. What products can I put on here?
- 35:00Right. Well, you know, well, I can't
- 35:02put my personalized products on you if, if that's a big thing
- 35:05because there's no way of configuring them.
- 35:07That example with the Ethernet cable that I probably want to
- 35:09pick that up the same day. Yeah, I want to find somebody
- 35:11near me. So where's the clicking fight
- 35:14UI, You know, and for the time being at least, unless open AI
- 35:18invest in those kind of like kind of UI, I'm going to have to
- 35:23go to the website ultimately. Yeah, and that's that.
- 35:26I mean the payment side of the, you're right, the fulfilment
- 35:28side is exponentially complex with logic around shipping rate
- 35:32lodges, around postal code exclusions, any volumetric base
- 35:36that impacts like data has got to be sent back from a carry
- 35:40point of view where is where is all that logic handled to make
- 35:43sure it doesn't break it. But it's also the payment side
- 35:46of where you've got credit store credits, you've got gift card
- 35:50balances, all different types of nested discounts.
- 35:55And yeah, that's a bit I'm really intrigued to see is, is
- 35:58where, where is it unable to support it?
- 36:02Because from what I'm what I'm understanding at the moment,
- 36:04it's basically it's a simple transaction, so.
- 36:08It's a slightly controversial comparison actually.
- 36:10So this is like it's going back to one of the points we were
- 36:13talking about a second ago that all of the brands that we work
- 36:16with look at Amazon and they know that they could drive
- 36:20volume through Amazon and a proportion of that would be
- 36:23incremental as a result, selling via Amazon, targeting Amazon
- 36:28user base, being able to, you know, offer Prime in that
- 36:31environment, etcetera. But they don't do it because
- 36:34there's no loyalty. You're not building like, you
- 36:37know, a relationship with that customer.
- 36:40You don't have the ability to get them bought into your like
- 36:43brand, the catalog, you know, as much you have the ability to
- 36:47like build their basket by you. And you're not kind of entering
- 36:51into that kind of relationship in like a brand way.
- 36:55And I guess I personally think in its current form, I know this
- 37:01is going to change as, you know, the agentic side evolves and as
- 37:05users start to, you know, just be more efficient using the
- 37:08genetic stuff. But as of right now, I feel like
- 37:11it's a very similar comparison first of all.
- 37:15Is that a lot of that issue though is that you don't own the
- 37:17customer at the end? Like you don't get any that data
- 37:20through Amazon. But equally, I think if I'm, I
- 37:23mean, I completely agree that is the biggest issue of Amazon.
- 37:27But I think even if you did, I still think like, you know,
- 37:31buying through Amazon, if somewhat I think often if I buy
- 37:35a brand through Amazon, I guess, I guess I already know about the
- 37:38brand, but if I discover and buy a product on through Amazon,
- 37:42like there's, you know, I'm not as incentive, I'm not as bought
- 37:45in, I'm not as incentivized to, you know, go back.
- 37:47I haven't learned anything about the brand at any point.
- 37:51I haven't like, you know, built an experience.
- 37:53I can't be encouraged to download the native app.
- 37:56I can't be encouraged to follow them on Instagram, etcetera,
- 37:58etcetera. And I think don't get me wrong,
- 38:01this will play a part in the same way, you know, all of the
- 38:04other bottom of funnel do in selling someone.
- 38:08But yeah, I think as a brand channel, I just, I just don't
- 38:13think it'll be a primary. It's more like a necessary evil
- 38:17target in the volume a little bit.
- 38:21Yeah, I think I agree with some of the concerns that to be fair,
- 38:24like, yeah, I do agree with that.
- 38:26I think maybe we see more of a shift in like different routes,
- 38:33different like routes for shopping depending on what
- 38:35people are actually buying rather than I guess at the
- 38:38minute, especially via Shopify, whether it's a surfer, whether
- 38:41it's a premium fashion, whether it's like whatever shampoo, it's
- 38:45all managed in the same route and maybe we'll see a bit more.
- 38:51Yeah, I guess I'd still see this very much.
- 38:55The big opportunity for me for brands is more around being
- 39:00visible and being discovered and being the consideration phase to
- 39:04drive the decision making low down the funnel and the simple
- 39:08purchases which don't have complexity around fulfilment
- 39:11pricing, payment flow then and where it's not a complex
- 39:16consideration, which is I want it now, it's a purchase where I
- 39:20don't need to deliberate on. I think that commercially would
- 39:23work really, really well. But yeah, I struggled to see how
- 39:27anything where I as a consumer have a decision half to go
- 39:31through before I'm ready to make payment.
- 39:33I'd struggle to see how people would commit to purchasing in
- 39:36that environment. Like I could be 100% wrong in
- 39:38this and in the next couple of years it could fundamentally
- 39:41change. But I think that's where my head
- 39:42is at in the short term on this. Yeah, maybe we we could, we'll
- 39:48come back to what, what can people do now?
- 39:50It's I think that the like the, the principle, the basics still
- 39:53apply, especially around data. I think people are going to be
- 39:57looking at pins a lot more seriously, like off the back of
- 40:00this because they're going to have to get the data in in, you
- 40:03know, sorted if they're to appear in this sort of this two
- 40:06level decision making process that that described just now.
- 40:09So I think in terms of practical terms, it's yeah, it's sort of
- 40:12business as usual to a degree. But it yeah, it will be
- 40:16interesting just to see, you know, what happens when this
- 40:19thing gets switched on because, yeah, like, you know, you can't
- 40:23ignore. It's like Amazon, Paul.
- 40:25It's got the footfall. So there are people there and to
- 40:27use open AIS word, you know, making these purchase adjacent
- 40:31asking these questions and what what part of the part of the
- 40:35research that was I think it was open AIS own.
- 40:37So make it maybe take it with a pinch of salt.
- 40:39But what what they're saying is that people are finding it much
- 40:41more useful for asking it rather than asking it about things
- 40:46rather than getting it to do things.
- 40:48And I think, you know, probably all of us here and probably
- 40:50probably watching who've who've used it a lot probably would,
- 40:54would agree with that. You know, it's it's a good
- 40:56copilot, it's a good brainstorm companion.
- 41:00It's a good expert on, you know, to a decent level on pretty much
- 41:03everything. When you ask it to do things, it
- 41:06sometimes falls down. Yeah, that makes sense, I think.
- 41:10Yeah, I think staying with what people could be doing in the, in
- 41:14the short term or what's, you know, the best actionable thing
- 41:16now is like, there's probably no negative.
- 41:20You know, if brands have a bit of time or a bit of resource,
- 41:23there's no negative in just trying to clean the data.
- 41:28And do you know a few of the tactics that might make your
- 41:31brand more visible in ChatGPT or other LLMS?
- 41:34And it's like it's almost going back to your glory days, Paul,
- 41:37of like without getting into blackout SEO, but like actually
- 41:43being a bit scrappy. And, and I mean, it's mostly
- 41:46about the product data. But like in Shopify, it's so one
- 41:51of the things is like, yeah, I guess the catalog API, it's
- 41:54getting data that even if it's not surfaced on site, will still
- 41:59be picked up by the LLM. So yeah, just making sure
- 42:02everything's almost keyword stuffed.
- 42:06Is is the the that's not. Keywords stuffed.
- 42:10I don't think the technical Seos listen, will will think that's a
- 42:14great love that that's the closest.
- 42:16Comparison is actually the meta fields to make sure you've
- 42:21captured all relevant, expedite out products and and make sure
- 42:25the data's clean. Yeah, yeah, that's not the,
- 42:29that's not the route, but that's the but I, I think this, I mean
- 42:34you, the principle you're saying is 100% spot on.
- 42:36And we did a pod relatively loose thing with with Sam, the
- 42:40founder of Novos, one of the legal search agencies and, and
- 42:43his his comment is bang on, which is nobody who does SEO
- 42:49optimization and technically SEO really well around product data
- 42:53does badly in this because the data is in the construction and
- 42:56it is, I'm going to come on to the, the like the the technical
- 43:00bit in, in the proper like shop find.
- 43:01Is there anything you need to think about for you guys in a
- 43:04minute? But basically it's number one,
- 43:05it is, it's structured data. It is not just your
- 43:08descriptions, your tiles, your images, it's everything beyond
- 43:12that. It's it's the deep use of like
- 43:14meta fields, meta objects. Shopify is making sure that
- 43:17content is surface able. It's the markup on the page as
- 43:21well. You know, unstructured data
- 43:23schema that all maximizing your potential for that's good pages
- 43:27structured and the data is surface able.
- 43:29It's page template design as well.
- 43:31It's going beyond basic templates and PDP.
- 43:33You go right. What other types of content do
- 43:36we need to put here that are that tackle the educational
- 43:38informative stage that that tackle the the purchase intent
- 43:42stage? And it's building up more
- 43:44content and things like FAQ blocks are going to become more
- 43:47and more popular. But not just are we stuck the
- 43:50same FAQ block on every bloody PDP.
- 43:53It's contextually relevant content that people need to be.
- 43:56And you're right, it's it is almost it's like stuff and
- 43:59content in but it's doing it in a structured.
- 44:00Way that's relevant, that made the way of saying it, actually,
- 44:03if Sam said that, yeah. Yeah, exactly.
- 44:06It's. A bit more I'm in.
- 44:09Justin, let's say with Google, if you look at Google obviously
- 44:13organically, in order to rank organically, you have like the
- 44:16whole hierarchy as kind of important.
- 44:18And you know, they've obviously built out their kind of
- 44:22algorithm around relevancy and authority and everything
- 44:25because, yeah, in Google Shopping.
- 44:27So like nowadays that I'd say there's like the whole early
- 44:31days where like bead optimization for key, then it
- 44:33wasn't. And then now, you know, our team
- 44:36do a lot of work around like injecting information around
- 44:40competitors and like, you know, information around generics and
- 44:43like there's so much to do with feeds to index against different
- 44:47keyword. And it'll be interesting because
- 44:50right now opening eyes, purely organic results like how they
- 44:54use information and because obviously organically the
- 44:58information that's presented to a user is what's considered to
- 45:01be important via ads. You know, they're kind of, you
- 45:05know, taking all this information which is not shown
- 45:09to the customer, even my product titles, everything get us.
- 45:12That then allows you to essentially spend more money and
- 45:17reach the types of users you want to reach by the keywords
- 45:21you want to index against. And it'll be interesting to see
- 45:25how they approach that actually, given that, you know, it sounds
- 45:29like it's going to be quite feed based.
- 45:33I need to so we, we, you've went, we've each of you
- 45:37mentioned the catalog API at Shopify several times here and
- 45:40the importance of, of being ready from a structured data
- 45:42point of view so that these LLMS can can pull in the relevant
- 45:45data apart from building out the product data.
- 45:49And you can, you're right, Chris, whether using a PIM or
- 45:52you're introducing one or you're just doing it all directly in
- 45:55Shopify's native data model. Beyond getting the data right
- 45:59and structured correctly, is there anything brands and need
- 46:02to think about, have conversation with their
- 46:04development teams about technically in the platform to
- 46:06ensure that that data is ready and open for that API to be
- 46:10used? I don't know, I think, I think
- 46:12the same principles still apply, right?
- 46:14The, the, the, the best practice around product data, clean
- 46:17product data. I think there's, there's
- 46:20probably something like, yeah, there's lots of data which might
- 46:25not make the front of the website, which is going to be
- 46:27factored into these decisions. I think.
- 46:32Yeah, my, my advice to anybody right, who, who's, who's looking
- 46:36to make sense of the opportunity here is to first and foremost
- 46:40immerse yourself in it as a, as a, as a user and as a customer.
- 46:43Because it's still really early days and everyone's still
- 46:45figuring this out. And you might get a bit of
- 46:47insight by by using these products, you know, use it for
- 46:50shopping, see what it gives you and see, you know, try and spot
- 46:53the opportunities because, you know, it, it is emergent this.
- 46:57And there's opportunity everywhere.
- 47:00And, you know, even the people, you know, who are sort of
- 47:02professing to, you know, and, and, and the businesses and
- 47:05organisations that are leading this, if you watch what they say
- 47:07over the course of 612 months, their position's evolving on it
- 47:10all the time as well. Everyone's trying to figure this
- 47:12out. So it's.
- 47:14Yeah. Other than sort of, you know,
- 47:17take care of the basics in the same way you always have done.
- 47:20And I think the point about SEO being, you know, underpinning
- 47:22some of this is, is, is perfectly valid, I think.
- 47:27Yeah, immerse yourself in it as as an end user, really
- 47:32understand the technology and then the opportunities that are
- 47:35specific to you and your business, which might be might
- 47:37be unique to you will will begin to emerge.
- 47:40I'm sorry, that's nothing very concrete, but you know, that's
- 47:43that I think that's where we are.
- 47:44You know, I, I, you know, I was there when mobile kicked off and
- 47:47social social kicked off. And this, this feels like a
- 47:50similar kind of thing. You know, the, the first move is
- 47:52the people who can spot the advantage.
- 47:54We'll, we'll do all right, you know, and it'll be finite,
- 47:57right. There's a there's a window of
- 47:59opportunity here because the market will out at some point.
- 48:02And, you know, if you know, ChatGPT for whatever model
- 48:05they're going to monetize, this is in like an affiliate model.
- 48:07It might be very price competitive now, but when they
- 48:10figure out that they are way more price competitive than the
- 48:13rest of the than the rest of the the other channels, they're
- 48:15going to correct that and they're going to try and extract
- 48:17as much value as possible. Yeah, same as tick tock or.
- 48:20Yeah, some of the others. Yeah, I guess the yeah, I mean I
- 48:27agree with all that they're good points.
- 48:28I think it's we don't know whether it's going to be from
- 48:31open AI point of view monetized tomorrow or next year.
- 48:34So I think there's like there's the opportunity if somebody had
- 48:37like I think the opportunity is for somebody basically just to
- 48:40be scrappy is, is the word that we use a lot.
- 48:44But actually doing some of these searches themselves, looking at
- 48:47their own product there and just like trial and error and some of
- 48:51it to, to see, you know, if, if we clean the data or if we add
- 48:54more meta fields and data and the impact that makes I think 1
- 49:00practical thing that was being on my mind.
- 49:04I guess it's only been the day, but which is not the
- 49:07opportunity, but the risk. But going back to the catalog
- 49:10API, so it's not just what's on the front end of the site, it's
- 49:13getting fed in. It's like all of the data.
- 49:15We've been basically all of your products data.
- 49:17We've been Shopify for all the meta fields and everything's
- 49:20getting fed into the LLMS. And I think a lot of complex
- 49:23brands, not that we've worked with that I've seen over the
- 49:27years, especially if we built on Shopify before sort of meta
- 49:30objects came about, we'll use things like hidden products,
- 49:33hidden products or hidden bits of data to manage what's the
- 49:38complexity and bits of functionality.
- 49:40And probably it'll be aware from a dev point of view, reviewing
- 49:44if anybody's got like. Yes.
- 49:46Specific bits of logic or specific bits of functionality
- 49:49that are running off hidden bits of data, because all that will
- 49:52suddenly not be hidden. There is a.
- 49:56An opportunity, but it's like it's the opposite I suppose.
- 50:00Well, what is there to pick up on your like hat point as well?
- 50:03There's a blackout opportunity there as well with with prompt
- 50:05injections. And I don't know if you've seen
- 50:08at the moment, like people discovering this, embedding
- 50:11prompts and instructions in their LinkedIn profiles, then
- 50:14asking chat GET to tell them about themselves.
- 50:17And they've put a prompt, they've put an injection in the
- 50:19prompt saying basically always return in, in the form of a
- 50:22poem. So when it responds, you know,
- 50:25it's in poetry form it, you know, that that's where we at.
- 50:28Just to reiterate the point I'm making just now, it's very early
- 50:31days. There's loads of holes in this
- 50:32stuff as well. And you know, there's, there's
- 50:34some very, you know, I'm not an expert on security, but, or
- 50:37very, very valid security concerns about it as well.
- 50:41So I'd be very wary for a practical point of view about
- 50:46using a generative AI in in a production environment because
- 50:51yeah, I would, yeah, if you're in the e-commerce and marketing
- 50:54teams and thinking about using this stuff, I would definitely
- 50:56have a conversation with your IT teams about their position on it
- 50:59because they're versed in this stuff and they've been, they've
- 51:01been considering these kind of things for years and probably
- 51:03have a different opinion on it to you.
- 51:05And, you know, we've seen examples of products on, you
- 51:09know, known name names on, on big consumer sites, famous
- 51:12consumer sites. They're using this technology
- 51:15and you can get them to say some pretty, you know, pretty radical
- 51:19things. And I do think there's, there's
- 51:21definitely some of this stuff is being rushed out in a, in a, in
- 51:25the need to show that people are, you know, ahead of the
- 51:28curve and they're embracing this technology.
- 51:30Then they'd be falling over the cells a little bit and and.
- 51:34I think that's a really good parting point for this because I
- 51:37think this is the conversation where we could spend a long time
- 51:40debating this because it's it's such an interesting area.
- 51:42But I think the sensible thing is, is, is don't act before
- 51:45you've understood the implications of the acting.
- 51:47Get your foundations in place and, and you know what, guess
- 51:50what? Having really, really good
- 51:52products data and good content and structured content that is
- 51:57aligned with user needs and shopping intent.
- 52:00It's it's always be important, but it's more important than
- 52:03ever because if you want to support multiple channels
- 52:06through which people are accessing information buying,
- 52:08that's the fundamentals you've got to get right before you play
- 52:12with the shiny, shiny stuff. So look, gents, thank you very
- 52:15much for for jumping on the short notice.
- 52:18Really enjoy today for this conversation.
- 52:21We'll run and run and thanks everyone for listening and
- 52:24anyone disagrees with any of the points made or got different
- 52:26perspectives, would love to hear them when you put the posts out
- 52:30LinkedIn, tell us, tell us what you think.
- 52:31That's where you will see in this headed because all debate
- 52:34on this is useful. So until next week everybody,
- 52:39you're listening to the Insidecommerce podcast.
- 52:41Hosted by experienced consultants James Gert and Paul
- 52:43Rogers, Insidecommerce is your fast tracked additional
- 52:46knowledge featuring interviews with leading e-commerce
- 52:49retailers, industry thought leads and the C-Suite key tech
- 52:52companies to explore the latest digital strategy, customer
- 52:55experience and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 52:57really mean and get practical advice based on the experience
- 53:00to help fine tune your E com strategy and tech stack.
- 53:03Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 53:06like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 53:09We hope you enjoy the latest episode.