Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Becoming a Teacher: What the Modern Teaching Profession Really Demands
Transcript
- 0:00Have you ever crammed for a massive exam, walked
- 0:03into the room, absolutely aced the test, and
- 0:06then completely forgotten every single thing
- 0:09you studied by the following Tuesday? Oh, absolutely.
- 0:12I mean, we've all been there. Right. But did
- 0:14you actually learn anything in that scenario,
- 0:16or did you just temporarily rent some space in
- 0:19your brain to pass a piece of paper? Just a short
- 0:21-term lease on those facts. Exactly. Well, welcome
- 0:24to the psychology undergrad. Today we are opening
- 0:27up our educational psychology source material
- 0:29to figure out what is actually happening in the
- 0:32modern classroom. Yeah, we're doing a real deep
- 0:34dive into the teaching profession and the gritty
- 0:38psychological mechanics of the learning process
- 0:41itself. We really want to understand what it
- 0:43means to genuinely learn something. and how four
- 0:48massive unstoppable forces in modern education
- 0:51are completely transforming the way teachers
- 0:53have to operate. And bringing you the listener
- 0:55into the study session with us kind of changes
- 0:57the stakes, right? Because whether you are a
- 0:59student right now or maybe a parent trying to
- 1:01navigate the school system. Or just someone trying
- 1:04to survive a world that constantly bombards you
- 1:07with new information. Yes. Understanding these
- 1:10mechanics is basically a survival skill. Like
- 1:13grasping the psychological pressures on modern
- 1:15educators and understanding the actual clinical
- 1:18definition of learning, it'll fundamentally shift
- 1:21how you view every educational experience you've
- 1:23ever had. For sure, and every piece of new information
- 1:26you encounter moving forward too. So before we
- 1:29look at the massive shifts in the education system,
- 1:32we have to isolate the core concept here. The
- 1:35big question, what actually is learning? Right,
- 1:38what is learning? Our source material provides
- 1:41a very specific clinical definition. Learning
- 1:43is a relatively permanent change in behavior,
- 1:46skills, knowledge, or attitudes that results
- 1:49from an identifiable experience. I think the
- 1:51operative phrase driving that entire concept
- 1:54is relatively permanent. The change has to stick.
- 1:57It has to stick. To help lock this in for our
- 1:59midterm, I like to think about the difference
- 2:01between getting a tattoo and applying henna.
- 2:04Oh, that's a great way to put it. Right. Because
- 2:06if you put henna on your arm, It looks incredibly
- 2:09intricate and cool for a few days, but eventually
- 2:11it washes right off. And that is not learning.
- 2:14Exactly. Or like, if you look up a one -time
- 2:16passcode on your phone, type it in, and forget
- 2:19it 30 seconds later, you didn't learn those numbers.
- 2:22No, you just held them in your working memory,
- 2:23like the brain's short -term holding cell, until
- 2:26they just weren't useful anymore. Right. For
- 2:29an experience to qualify as actual psychological
- 2:33learning, the neural pathways have to physically
- 2:36alter. The change has to be permanent. It has
- 2:39to leave a tattoo. And we often default to thinking
- 2:42of learning as this strictly cognitive exercise,
- 2:45you know, like memorizing the periodic table
- 2:47or the capitals of the 50 states. Yeah, strictly
- 2:50academic stuff. But the psychological definition
- 2:52is so much broader than that. This permanent
- 2:55change applies across the entire human experience.
- 2:58It can be physical, like finally internalizing
- 3:01the subconscious balance required to ride a bicycle.
- 3:03Oh, absolutely. Muscle memory. Yeah, but it can
- 3:06also be profoundly emotional or social. Like,
- 3:08you can learn to resent a specific type of authority
- 3:11figure based on one highly impactful, identifiable
- 3:15experience. Wow, yeah. You don't sit down at
- 3:17a desk and, like, study how to harbor prejudice.
- 3:20Exactly. But if an experience fundamentally and
- 3:23permanently shifts your attitude, psychologically
- 3:25speaking, you have learned. It carries this heavy
- 3:28moral weight when you realize we are constantly,
- 3:31um... learning our emotional reactions to the
- 3:34world. That's intense. But the tricky part is
- 3:37that applying these permanent tattoos isn't just
- 3:39a matter of repetition. There is a story in the
- 3:42research by Kelvin Seifert about his son Michael.
- 3:45Oh, I love this story. It perfectly illustrates
- 3:48the psychological barriers to learning. So Seifert
- 3:50is an educational psychology professor, and he
- 3:53decided to use his own preschool -aged son as
- 3:55a live demonstration for his undergrads. To show
- 3:58how children process the world, right? Which
- 4:00is like the ultimate occupational hazard of being
- 4:02the child of a psychology professor. Seriously.
- 4:05So he brings little Michael into the lecture
- 4:07hall and sets up a classic cognitive development
- 4:10test, a conservation task. Right, where the goal
- 4:13is to see if a child understands that the quantity
- 4:15of a substance stays the same. even if its shape
- 4:18changes. Yes. So Cypher takes this tall, skinny
- 4:21drinking glass full of water and pours it directly
- 4:24into a wide flat pie plate. And he asks Michael,
- 4:28is there more, less, or the same amount of water?
- 4:31And Michael, operating with a totally normal
- 4:34preschooler's brain, looks at the shallow puddle
- 4:37and confidently says, there's less water now.
- 4:40Yeah, there's less. His dad tries to correct
- 4:42him, walking him through the logic that, hey,
- 4:45no water was added or removed. And Michael kind
- 4:47of humors his dad, right? Yeah, he nods along.
- 4:50But by the end of the class, he reverts right
- 4:51back to his original stance. The pie plate has
- 4:54less water. The hanna washed off. Zero permanent
- 4:57learning occurred. The mechanics of why he didn't
- 5:00learn are so crucial here. He hadn't reached
- 5:02the necessary developmental stage where that
- 5:04abstract concept could actually, you know, permanently
- 5:07take root. His brain was quite literally incapable
- 5:09of integrating that logic into his current model
- 5:12of reality. Exactly. You cannot force a psychological
- 5:16tattoo onto a brain that isn't chemically or
- 5:19structurally ready to hold the ink. Which makes
- 5:21the punchline of the story fantastic because
- 5:23every single year, Seifert brings Michael back
- 5:27to the lecture hall. And every year, Michael
- 5:29fails the water glass task. Right up until he's
- 5:32six. Yes. The year Michael turns six, his dad
- 5:35says, it's time to visit the class again. And
- 5:37Michael turns to him and says, are you going
- 5:39to ask me about the water in the pie plate again?
- 5:42Because I know the amount stays the same when
- 5:43you pour it. But do you want me to fake it this
- 5:46time? For your student's sake. That is so funny.
- 5:50But it also highlights a really profound reality
- 5:52about the teaching profession itself. How so?
- 5:55Well, teaching isn't this transactional process
- 5:58where you just deliver a stimulus and immediately
- 6:00extract a permanent response. It requires orchestrating
- 6:04these incredibly complex layered activities over
- 6:07long periods of time. Just waiting for the student's
- 6:10psychology to catch up to the material? Exactly.
- 6:13The source material refers to this as the artistry
- 6:16of teaching. And there is this fascinating, almost
- 6:19spiritual thread woven into this idea in the
- 6:22text. Oh, about the immensity of it. Yeah. The
- 6:25research notes that teaching the immensity of
- 6:27a subject can be a profound source of wonder,
- 6:30excitement, and optimism. I love that word, immensity.
- 6:34It changes the whole framework. It implies that
- 6:36a teacher's highest calling isn't just, you know,
- 6:38transferring isolated facts from a syllabus into
- 6:41a student's working memory. Right. It elevates
- 6:43teaching to a moral dimension. The goal is to
- 6:46point students beyond the confines of a single
- 6:49classroom. sparking a lifelong reverence for
- 6:52knowledge. You're basically teaching them that
- 6:54the universe is infinitely complex and that true
- 6:57learning is a perpetual state of awe. So if we
- 6:59accept that learning is this permanent tattoo
- 7:02-like change driven by a reverence for the immense,
- 7:05we have to look at the physical environment where
- 7:07this is supposed to happen. Because the modern
- 7:09classroom is completely different from the environment
- 7:11of, say, 50 years ago. Totally unrecognizable
- 7:13in some ways. So to track how the educational
- 7:15landscape is shifting, I use the mnemonic DAPT.
- 7:19DAPT. Education is always adapting to four major
- 7:23forces. Diversity, accountability, professionalism,
- 7:27and technology. DAPT. That's good. And if we
- 7:31unpack these, we can see exactly why the psychology
- 7:33of teaching has become so incredibly demanding
- 7:36today. Let's start with the D. The first force
- 7:38is diversity. We're not just talking about a
- 7:41variety of cultural backgrounds here. It is a
- 7:44massive, functional, and cognitive diversity
- 7:46exploding within single classrooms. Right. The
- 7:49demographic data in our sources outlines three
- 7:51specific types of diversity we need to look at.
- 7:53The first one is language. Which is a huge shift.
- 7:56Massive. Roughly 14 % of the US population is
- 7:59Hispanic. And within that group, a significant
- 8:01percentage speak limited English. Right. So we
- 8:04are now in a reality where a general education
- 8:06teacher, who mind you, is not a specialized ESL
- 8:09instructor, must constantly adjust their instruction.
- 8:11They have to accommodate students processing
- 8:13the material in a second language while still
- 8:15keeping the native speakers engaged and moving
- 8:17through the curriculum goals. Psychologically,
- 8:20the cognitive load on the teacher to translate,
- 8:23adapt, and monitor all those multiple levels
- 8:26of comprehension at once is just staggering.
- 8:29It really is. And the second type of diversity
- 8:31completely stretches our definition of who a
- 8:34student actually is. We have the phenomenon of
- 8:38lifelong learning. Oh, yeah. The age gap. Exactly.
- 8:41We're no longer just talking about kids sitting
- 8:43in rows of desks. The spectrum now ranges from
- 8:46like three year olds in early childhood education
- 8:48programs all the way to 40 year old adults taking
- 8:51trade courses at community colleges. And your
- 8:53psychological approach has to completely fracture
- 8:56to accommodate that age gap. I mean you cannot
- 8:58design learning experience for an adult with
- 9:00a mortgage the same way you design one for a
- 9:02high school sophomore. Obviously not. The adult
- 9:04brings a wealth of lived experience that acts
- 9:07as this powerful intrinsic motivator, but they
- 9:10also have zero patience for busy work. None.
- 9:13The instructor has to tap into an entirely different
- 9:15set of psychological triggers to make that learning
- 9:17permanent for them. Which brings us to the third
- 9:20type of diversity, and this one is perhaps the
- 9:23most philosophically profound. Special needs
- 9:26and the push for inclusion. This is a massive
- 9:29part of the source material. Yeah, heavily driven
- 9:31by policy. Specifically, the Individuals with
- 9:34Disabilities Education Act of 1975, which was
- 9:38updated in 2004, alongside similar legislation
- 9:41internationally. And those laws guarantee a free,
- 9:44appropriate education for children with cognitive,
- 9:47emotional, behavioral, or physical disabilities.
- 9:50Exactly. And the prevailing model now is inclusion,
- 9:53meaning students with severe developmental delays
- 9:55are brought into general education classrooms
- 9:58right alongside their neurotypical peers. And
- 10:00inclusion for is a real reckoning with the core
- 10:03morality of the education system. Well, think
- 10:06about it. When you have a single teacher managing
- 10:08a room where one student is ready for advanced
- 10:11physics, another is managing severe ADHD, and
- 10:14another has profound cognitive impairments, society
- 10:17can no longer rely on a one -size -fits -all
- 10:20assembly line of knowledge. The text actually
- 10:22points out that this environment forces us to
- 10:24ask a really hard question. What in the curriculum
- 10:27is truly important to learn? Wow, yeah. It strips
- 10:31education down to the absolute studs. If everyone
- 10:34in the room has a wildly different cognitive
- 10:36capacity, the teacher has to look at the material
- 10:39and decide what possesses fundamental, intrinsic
- 10:42human value. It challenges the entire apparatus
- 10:45to justify what information is actually worth
- 10:48tattooing onto a student's brain. So you have
- 10:51a single human being trying to orchestrate meaningful
- 10:53permanent change. in a room with five different
- 10:56languages, varying developmental stages, and
- 11:00profound cognitive differences. It's almost an
- 11:02impossible task. How does a teacher actually
- 11:04manage that cognitive load? Well, that pressure
- 11:07cooker of diversity forces us to look at the
- 11:09next major trend adapting the classroom, technology,
- 11:13the T. in our DAPT mnemonic. Yes, and the role
- 11:16of technology has undergone such a massive evolution.
- 11:19We've moved way past the era where computers
- 11:20were just fancy typewriters, you know. Or, like,
- 11:23digital encyclopedias locked away in a specific
- 11:25computer lab down the hall. Exactly. The ubiquity
- 11:29of the internet allows the teacher to fundamentally
- 11:31change their psychological posture in the room.
- 11:34They transition from full frontal teaching...
- 11:37Standing at the chalkboard acting as the solitary
- 11:39bottleneck for all information. Right. They move
- 11:42from that to acting as a guide on the side. They
- 11:45facilitate the students as they construct their
- 11:47own knowledge through digital tools. It definitely
- 11:50democratizes the information, but it also changes
- 11:53the teacher's primary function from information
- 11:56provider to sense maker. Sense maker, yeah, I
- 12:00like that. But I have to play devil's advocate
- 12:02here for a second. Okay, lay it on me. If the
- 12:04internet literally contains the sum total of
- 12:07human knowledge, and the teacher is merely a
- 12:10guide, why do we need the physical classroom
- 12:13at all? Why hasn't the entire educational system
- 12:16just dissolved into a purely digital matrix where
- 12:19students just interact with software? That's
- 12:21a fair question. The source material addresses
- 12:24the hurdles keeping that digital matrix at bay,
- 12:26and they are largely psychological and economic.
- 12:29Economics make sense. Yeah. First is the harsh
- 12:32reality of funding and equity. Equipping every
- 12:35single student with high speed, unrestricted,
- 12:38high quality digital access is incredibly expensive.
- 12:41Right. And if we rely solely on technology, the
- 12:45digital divide immediately becomes a permanent
- 12:47educational and economic divide. It would be
- 12:49a massive ethical failure. Exactly. But beyond
- 12:52the economics, the text emphasizes the psychological
- 12:55danger of internet fluff. Just because an unlimited
- 12:59ocean of information exists doesn't mean a developing
- 13:01brain has the maturity to navigate it. That is
- 13:04so true. Sorting empirical truth from beautifully
- 13:07designed misinformation requires advanced critical
- 13:09thinking skills. And a search engine cannot teach
- 13:12a child how to evaluate the bias of a source.
- 13:15That requires the artistry of a human guide.
- 13:17Plus, some human endeavors inherently require
- 13:20human presence. You can't computerize the physical
- 13:22synchronous harmony of a choral practice. Or
- 13:25teach the spatial awareness and moral responsibility
- 13:28of driver's education solely through a virtual
- 13:30simulation, right? Good point. OK, so that brings
- 13:33us to a critical intersection. We have these
- 13:35highly diverse classrooms, heavily supplemented
- 13:37by technology, where teachers are trying to impart
- 13:39permanent learning. With tattoos? Right, the
- 13:41tattoos. But how does society actually know if
- 13:44it's working? Who ensures the tattoos are setting?
- 13:47That leads us to the final two letters of our
- 13:50DAPT acronym, Accountability and Professionalism.
- 13:54Let's tackle accountability. It's the third massive
- 13:57force. Over the past few decades, there has been
- 14:00an overwhelming public demand for empirical evidence
- 14:03that public money is actually resulting in prominent
- 14:06learning. Society wants proof. They want proof.
- 14:09And the primary mechanism for generating that
- 14:11proof is high -stakes testing. High -stakes testing.
- 14:14The absolute boogeyman of modern education. And
- 14:18the definition here is really crucial. These
- 14:20are standardized tests taken by all students
- 14:22in a region that carries severe We are talking
- 14:24about tests that dictate whether a student passes
- 14:26a course, whether they are allowed to graduate,
- 14:29or if they qualify for higher education. But
- 14:31the pressure isn't just on the students, right?
- 14:34These test scores are heavily utilized to evaluate
- 14:37the performance of the teachers themselves. And
- 14:40to determine funding for entire school districts.
- 14:43Which creates an incredibly thorny philosophical
- 14:46dilemma. Because of the diversity we just talked
- 14:48about. Exactly. Think about the massive diversity
- 14:50we just unpacked. Language barriers. Cognitive
- 14:54delays. Trauma. Vastly different home lives.
- 14:57Does a standardized high -stakes test align with
- 15:00the fundamental public education ideal of giving
- 15:03every child an equal start in life? Or does it
- 15:06just function as a rigid sorting mechanism that
- 15:09inevitably disqualifies marginalized students
- 15:11from future opportunities? It is a brutal psychological
- 15:14reality. If a student deeply understands the
- 15:16immensity of a subject, but experiences severe
- 15:19test anxiety and fails a high -stakes multiple
- 15:22-choice test, what did the test actually measure?
- 15:26Did it measure their permanent learning? or did
- 15:28it merely measure their ability to perform under
- 15:30artificial pressure? Right. And because teachers'
- 15:33livelihoods are tied to these scores, they are
- 15:35psychologically pressured to abandon the artistry
- 15:37of teaching. They're forced to spend months teaching
- 15:40test -taking strategies instead of fostering
- 15:43a reverence for knowledge. Which can make the
- 15:45top -down pressure of accountability feel incredibly
- 15:48bleak. But the source material provides a powerful,
- 15:51organic counterbalance to this pressure. Which
- 15:54brings us to our final trend. professionalism.
- 15:58Specifically, the rise of action research. Yes,
- 16:01action research. It's so exciting about this
- 16:04concept because it essentially turns teachers
- 16:06into frontline psychologists. They don't just
- 16:09passively receive mandates from the state. They
- 16:11actively engage in the scientific method within
- 16:14their own classrooms. Action research, also known
- 16:16as teacher research, occurs when educators systematically
- 16:20investigate their own students or their own instructional
- 16:23methods to generate concrete empirical improvements.
- 16:26They aren't waiting for a university academic
- 16:28to publish a study 10 years from now. They are
- 16:30generating real -time data to solve immediate
- 16:32problems. And the practical examples in our text
- 16:35show exactly how this works. Imagine a teacher
- 16:37as a student who is severely struggling to read.
- 16:41Instead of just guessing at interventions, the
- 16:43teacher initiates an action research study. They
- 16:46systematically observe that specific child, meticulously
- 16:50tracking their phonetic hurdles, their attention
- 16:53span, their responses to different reading prompts
- 16:56over an extended period. So they compile this
- 16:58data to create a custom psychological roadmap
- 17:01for that specific student. Exactly. And the beauty
- 17:05is they can then share that empirical roadmap
- 17:07with their colleagues to help other children
- 17:10facing similar hurdles. It builds a localized
- 17:13grassroots database of educational psychology.
- 17:16That's amazing. There's another example in the
- 17:18sources that focuses on the mechanics of engagement.
- 17:21A high school social studies teacher might wonder
- 17:23if the structure of their questions actually
- 17:25impacts the room's energy. Like, does it matter
- 17:27if they use open -ended exploratory questions
- 17:29versus closed fixed answer questions? Right.
- 17:32So to find out, the teacher sets up a camera
- 17:34in the back of the room and videotapes their
- 17:36own lesson. Later, they sit down and systematically
- 17:39code the footage. Oh wow, they actually code
- 17:42it. Yeah, they analyze the body language, the
- 17:44frequency of student participation, the depth
- 17:47of the answers in response to both types of questions.
- 17:51They are analyzing the psychological engagement
- 17:54of the room and utilizing their own empirical
- 17:57evidence to permanently alter their teaching
- 18:00style. The text even applies this to highly subjective
- 18:03fields, like art. Really? How do you measure
- 18:05that? An art teacher wants to know if they can
- 18:08explicitly entice students to take greater creative
- 18:10risks. But how do you empirically measure creativity?
- 18:14Yeah, that seems impossible. Well, the teacher
- 18:16carefully examines a batch of drawings, identifying
- 18:19specific markers of visual novelty, unusual color
- 18:22choices, breaking perspective rules, things like
- 18:24that. OK. In the next lesson, they explicitly
- 18:27encourage these novel risks. They then analyze
- 18:30the new batch of drawings against their established
- 18:32markers to see if the rate of innovation statistically
- 18:34increased. Applying empiricism to subjectivity.
- 18:37That elevates the entire concept of what a teacher
- 18:40is. You are not a glorified babysitter, and you're
- 18:43not just a cog in an accountability machine delivering
- 18:46standardized test prep. No, you are an active,
- 18:48professional researcher designing, measuring,
- 18:51and refining complex psychological experiences.
- 18:54Action research takes the immensity of the subject,
- 18:57respects the diversity of the room, utilizes
- 18:59technology to track the data, and provides a
- 19:02much healthier form of accountability. The teacher
- 19:05proves they are effective by showing their ongoing
- 19:07research. It's brilliant. So as you process all
- 19:10of this, whether you are stepping into a classroom
- 19:12tomorrow or just trying to navigate your own
- 19:15personal learning journey, keep these underlying
- 19:18mechanics in mind. Use the DAPT mnemonic. Diversity,
- 19:22accountability, professionalism, and technology.
- 19:24Use it to understand the complex pressures shaping
- 19:28educational environments. And remember the tattoo
- 19:30analogy, true learning requires a permanent change.
- 19:34Recognizing the sheer difficulty of creating
- 19:36that permanence helps you appreciate the orchestrational
- 19:39artistry happening every single time an educator
- 19:42steps to the front of a room. It also serves
- 19:44as an invitation to approach your own pursuit
- 19:46of knowledge with a sense of wonder. You aren't
- 19:48just accumulating trivia, you are allowing the
- 19:51immensity of the world to leave a permanent mark
- 19:53on your mind. I love that. Well, I want to leave
- 19:55you with one final slightly unnerving thought
- 19:58to chew on before we close the books on this
- 20:00deep dive. Uh -oh. Lay it on us. We have spent
- 20:04this entire session establishing that educational
- 20:07psychology defines learning as a relatively permanent
- 20:10change in your knowledge. The tattoo has to set.
- 20:13Right. But think about the history of science
- 20:15or medicine. What happens with the foundational
- 20:18facts we painstakingly learned in school? are
- 20:21later proven to be completely wrong by new discoveries.
- 20:24Oh, wow. If the knowledge itself turns out to
- 20:26be impermanent, does our learning suddenly cease
- 20:29to exist? Or did we just permanently learn the
- 20:33psychological process of how to believe something
- 20:34is true? That is heavy. Good luck sleeping with
- 20:37that riddle bouncing around your head tonight.
- 20:39Thanks for joining us for this deep dive into
- 20:41our educational psychology sources, and we will
- 20:43catch you next time on The Psychology Undergrad.