Latest / The Afterwife Hours / The Captive Car Conversation: Why It Always Starts When the Door Closes
Transcript
- 0:02The Afterwife Hours podcast. I'm Kerrie your host,
- 0:05and I am a therapist whose turned coach,
- 0:08helping women navigate high conflict marriages.
- 0:13And today what we're going to be talking about is this:
- 0:17The Captive Car Conversation.
- 0:20Why does it always seem to start when the door closes?
- 0:23Here's what it looks like.
- 0:26You get in, and before you even hear the car door close,
- 0:30you hear his voice. Why can't you try harder?
- 0:34Are you okay? You seem off. Don't you see how much I'm trying?
- 0:38Don't you see how much I'm changing?
- 0:41And here's the thing, this doesn't happen at home.
- 0:43Because at home you could walk into another room.
- 0:45No, it happens in the car where you can't leave,
- 0:48you can't look away. And if you go quiet,
- 0:51suddenly you're the one who's shutting down.
- 0:53So this is what I call the captive car conversation.
- 0:57And if you're in a high conflict marriage,
- 0:59I didn't even need to finish the sentence.
- 1:00Your stomach immediately dropped,
- 1:02and you might have even thought about the last time this happened.
- 1:04Why the car
- 1:09This is not bad timing. This is chosen timing.
- 1:14So I'm going to talk about why it happens in the car.
- 1:18He may not have this whiteboard somewhere with this saying that says,
- 1:23I'm going to ambush her on the highway and I'm going to do it when
- 1:27we are getting into the car on a Tuesday.
- 1:30Most of the time this runs on their innate instinct.
- 1:34when they feel as though they have the most opportune moment to do this.
- 1:38So the instinct picks the car for these reasons.
- 1:43And I want you to see all four of them.
- 1:45So the first one's obvious.
- 1:47Which is this. You obviously can't leave,
- 1:49but at home you can. You have exits,
- 1:51you have the bathroom, you have the laundry,
- 1:52you have, my gosh, this kid is screaming in the other room and they need something,
- 1:56right? But at seventy miles per hour,
- 1:58your options are extremely limited.
- 2:01You have a couple, you engage,
- 2:03or you get accused of stonewalling.
- 2:05That's not a conversation. That is a containment strategy.
- 2:08Second. And this one's sneakier because
- 2:13It's something that you probably hadn't thought about,
- 2:15but once I say it, you're gonna be like,
- 2:16yeah, that makes total sense. No one has to make eye contact in the car.
- 2:20Side-by-side seating lowers the cost of saying things that they would never
- 2:26say to your face. And there's a reason people who work with teenagers,
- 2:29and sometimes I even say this with parents that I work with,
- 2:33I'll say, Hey, why don't you go for a ride with them in the car?
- 2:35This is like the best way to talk to them about.
- 2:38Different situations that might be ~ a little bit more tense,
- 2:42right? So there's a reason why when you are driving with teenagers,
- 2:46it is advantageous and for some reason it just comes out in the car where they
- 2:50are talking about the hard things.
- 2:53Why is this? Because hard things come out sideways easier than they come
- 2:57out head on. There is no eye contact involved.
- 3:00Third.
- 3:01There's a clock when he is in the car and he is holding it.
- 3:05The conversation ends when you arrive and it starts when you get in.
- 3:09So that means the entire drive,
- 3:11when you pull up to the party,
- 3:13when you pull up to the school event,
- 3:15your mother's house, whatever,
- 3:17and you're completely emptied out,
- 3:18you're expected to walk in again smiling and pretending.
- 3:23And what do you know? He walks in fine.
- 3:25And you walk in wrecked.
- 3:28And if you're not sparkling there,
- 3:30guess what happens? See, she's always in a mood.
- 3:33I don't know what her deal is.
- 3:35He gets the last word and the character witness.
- 3:38Fourth, my personal least favorite,
- 3:42which is called plausible deniability.
- 3:45So when you try and describe it to someone else,
- 3:48and you're like, yeah, he interrogated me the entire drive to the wedding.
- 3:53When you say it out loud, they're like,
- 3:54really, the entire the entire drive,
- 3:56like, does that really happen?
- 3:57Yeah, it does. And it did. But you don't have anyone else to share that with because
- 4:02nobody else was in the car. So it's hard to confirm this,
- 4:05right? Every high conflict pattern that I've ever seen survives
- 4:11on exactly this.
- 4:12when you end up doubting your own account of it happening and you don't have anyone
- 4:17else who can be in your corner,
- 4:19literally. So what I mean is this,
- 4:21you bring it up again to him, you bring it up to someone else,
- 4:25and there is no one on your side because it's just you.
- 4:29And here's what happens: you begin to doubt yourself again,
- 4:32because to be honest, you're probably pretty used to this if you are in this type
- 4:36of marriage.
- 4:38So no, you're not crazy for dreading the passenger seat of your own
- 4:41car and you're not crazy at all.
- 4:43You're cornered. These are very different things.
- 4:46The next thing I want to talk about is this.
- 4:49What is this actually costing you?
- 4:51Because you've been paying it in a currency that no one counts.
- 4:57Every one of these drives trains your body to brace.
- 4:59And I hear the women that I work with constantly ask me this.
- 5:03my gosh, we have this really long car drive coming up.
- 5:06Like I would expect that they're gonna talk to me about X,
- 5:09Y, and Z. What should I do, Kerrie?
- 5:11You know the pre-drive math And you know that either on a Tuesday when you're having
- 5:17to drive your son to school and you have a four-hour drive because it's
- 5:21his first day of college, the pre-math is already in there.
- 5:25It's gonna take four hours and he's gonna have four hours of my ear,
- 5:28right? But here's the thing.
- 5:32You can decide what topics are safe.
- 5:34You can decide how long this drive is going to be.
- 5:38Sometimes I do want to say this though.
- 5:40People will ask me, and I've seen it happen,
- 5:43they will bring kids in the car as a buffer.
- 5:47Should this happen? No. Never.
- 5:50Should this happen? No, never.
- 5:52You should never bring a child in the middle of anything that is high conflict,
- 5:57that is toxic, and that has to do with two adults who are trying to navigate this.
- 6:02Children should not be brought into adult conflict and they should not be used
- 6:06as a buffer. When this happens,
- 6:08that is not marriage. That is a threat assessment.
- 6:11And you have gotten so good at it,
- 6:13sometimes you honestly forget that this isn't normal.
- 6:16And here's the part I actually want you to hear.
- 6:18Whenever you are in a decision,
- 6:19if you spend the whole drive managing his feelings and arrive with nothing left
- 6:25for the people you were driving to see,
- 6:26that is data. That's a pattern.
- 6:29Why is it that every time I get in the car,
- 6:32I find that I get out after he has belabored me on 10 different topics,
- 6:39I am drained and I do not want to participate in this activity.
- 6:44That is your answer about this marriage.
- 6:46Sitting in the passenger seat.
- 6:48You've said it out loud, maybe not to yourself,
- 6:50but you have it, it's there, and you don't have to say it today.
- 6:54But I would like it if you could stop volunteering for the front row seat
- 6:59of this because you are just costing your own energy and your own time.
- 7:02And to be honest, you're demonstrating something for your kids that's not healthy.
- 7:08The next thing I want to talk about is probably the most important.
- 7:11How do you protect yourself from this?
- 7:13There's five moves. And I want you to notice something about all five.
- 7:18None of them require his cooperation.
- 7:20And again, I'm gonna say it. None of them require his cooperation,
- 7:24his agreement, or his growth. That's on purpose,
- 7:27and that is the entire point.
- 7:29And this is what I tell the clients that I work with in my private practice
- 7:33and my coaching program. I say this:
- 7:35set the agenda before the engine starts.
- 7:38Any drive where there is a history of him doing this,
- 7:42where he unloads, or you might anticipate that he will,
- 7:46you frame it out ahead of time out loud,
- 7:49and you say
- 7:51Sure, if you want to drive to go drop off our daughter Emma to
- 7:55her high school graduation party at her friend's house,
- 7:58which is a half hour away, fine,
- 8:00I'll go with you. But here's the conditions.
- 8:02I am not going to be discussing X,
- 8:05Y, or Z. And if you plan to do so,
- 8:07I will be driving separately. Now there's an agenda.
- 8:10And when he pivots to, well,
- 8:14why can't you dry harder while you're on the way to Emma's party?
- 8:18You have a legitimate on off ramp.
- 8:20Either you say, Hey, I told you that I'm not participating in this conversation,
- 8:26and that conversation is bigger than this car ride,
- 8:30and I'm not engaging in it. Let's talk through the schedule first,
- 8:35right? Let's talk through the agenda that we agreed upon first.
- 8:39Notice what you did there. You didn't refuse to talk,
- 8:42you refuse to talk.
- 8:45to them when they have brought up the very things that you said are off limits.
- 8:51Boundaries without a condition are not boundaries.
- 8:55And when you do this, when you say I'm not talking about it,
- 8:59you take the power back in the car.
- 9:02Sometimes people have asked me,
- 9:03well, what do I do when it happens?
- 9:05Right? Well, you obviously can't like change it while it's happening in real time,
- 9:09meaning like, hey, he violated the boundary condition.
- 9:12Now what? You can reframe it and you can say we're not talking about
- 9:15it as I discussed. But what you do is this when you get back to a place where
- 9:20you have an exit like your home,
- 9:22you say to him, most likely in an email or a text exchange,
- 9:27one because it's documentation,
- 9:28it's neutral.
- 9:31And you have a a potentially a non-confrontational space,
- 9:36I want you to say this. Hey, we discussed and agreed upon that we were
- 9:41not going to talk about X, Y, or Z on the way to Emma's party.
- 9:44And what happened is you brought up the things that were off limits.
- 9:49You said to me, Why are you acting the saying?
- 9:51Why aren't you seeing I'm trying?
- 9:53Why can't you work harder on our marriage?
- 9:54And because you've violated the boundary conditions,
- 9:57I'm not going to be driving in the car with you.
- 10:00~ for said period of time, right?
- 10:03The second thing. How can you protect yourself when this happens and when
- 10:09the stakes are high? Anything that's court adjacent.
- 10:13So if you are litigating, probably not the best idea to be driving together because
- 10:18you're already in a very contentious space.
- 10:22Any day you need to arrive basically as a functioning person.
- 10:27So if you're going to a funeral,
- 10:29if you're going to an ~ interview and they have to drive you for
- 10:36one reason or another, you can try to plan.
- 10:40I mean it sounds simple, but try to plan that day with arranging another mode
- 10:45of transportation. Here's the other thing you can do:
- 10:48you can say this.
- 10:49Well, just so you know, I'm gonna be running errands after,
- 10:52and so we really don't need to ride together.
- 10:54~ I would I'm going to, you don't ask for their permission,
- 10:57you don't say, Is it okay? You say,
- 10:58I am going to run errands after.
- 11:00So I'm going to be taking two cars.
- 11:02And the thing is this,
- 11:06when you do that.
- 11:09You are already setting the stage for the boundary.
- 11:12And when you do this, I want you to know this:
- 11:15it's an oxygen mask. When you put yours on first,
- 11:18it's not selfish. This is considered what I call safety briefing.
- 11:21Move three. Stop performing the response.
- 11:27And this is so easy to do because you just it's natural,
- 11:30you know, to be in this exchange process with him.
- 11:34When he says, Are you okay in that voice again?
- 11:36Are you okay? I've noticed ever since you started to see that friend again
- 11:42or started that medication or what have you,
- 11:45you've been different. When he does this,
- 11:48he is collecting data. He's opening the show,
- 11:51and your answer is the co-star walking on stage.
- 11:54So don't audition. Don't engage as you did before.
- 11:58Yeah, I'm good, fine. Why? Why do you keep saying that?
- 12:00Because what happens is this. He rebuttals,
- 12:03he refutes it. Well, I don't know.
- 12:04You've been doing this and then you defend your argument,
- 12:06right? That's just cyclical and ongoing and never ending.
- 12:09What you say instead is this. You say,
- 12:12I'm fine. We can talk about that at home,
- 12:15but I'm not talking about that here.
- 12:17Remember, we're not talking about that.
- 12:20I know this feels wrong because you were raised to give answers to direct questions.
- 12:24You're generally an honest person and you're used to having these sorts
- 12:29of exchanges with healthy relationships.
- 12:31Again, with healthy relationships.
- 12:33This is not a healthy relationship.
- 12:35Okay. If any of this resonates with you,
- 12:38this is not a healthy relationship.
- 12:41But what I want you to remember is this,
- 12:43when you are talking to these individuals,
- 12:45if you get trapped in the car,
- 12:46when you use boring and vague neutral comments,
- 12:52they absolutely freaking hate it.
- 12:55Why? Because it's armor. This particular show,
- 13:00when you use this vague neutrality,
- 13:02it cannot run without a co-star.
- 13:05So you decline the role. I'm fine.
- 13:09We can talk about it at home, but not in the car.
- 13:12That's not you being mean. That is you reclaiming your voice,
- 13:16your autonomy, and setting the stage for more appropriate boundaries.
- 13:21Move four. Protect the landing.
- 13:25If the drive can't be avoided,
- 13:27guess what? The arrival can still be saved.
- 13:30What you do is this.
- 13:33Let's say you get in the car and it went horrible,
- 13:36right? You set the agenda and you're like,
- 13:38yeah, if we go to Emma's party,
- 13:40you know, I don't want to talk about this.
- 13:41Can you agree to that? He's like,
- 13:42Yeah, sure, fine. You get in the car,
- 13:44he's like, What's going on with you?
- 13:45You started those meds and it's just been awful.
- 13:47Or why is it that whenever you ~ talk to me in this way,
- 13:53it makes me feel like you think I'm an awful person and I'm really trying,
- 13:58right? We're getting back into that land of
- 14:00I'm trying, why can't you see this?
- 14:02Okay. If this happens and you are just dysregulated because it went backwards,
- 14:08the arrival can still be saved.
- 14:11So when you get to Emma's party,
- 14:12you say, Hey, I'm gonna go use the bathroom first.
- 14:15And you collect yourself in the bathroom.
- 14:17Or you say, I'm gonna go grab that gift from the trunk,
- 14:19and you take a long ass frickin' time getting that gift from the trunk.
- 14:23Maybe the gift drops on the ground and shit,
- 14:25you gotta pick it up. And it takes forever to pick it up,
- 14:28right?
- 14:30And the other thing I say is text ahead,
- 14:33okay? If you are going to Emma's party and maybe you're good friends with Emma's
- 14:37mom, you text Emma's mom and you're like,
- 14:39my gosh. Steven did it again.
- 14:42He captured me in the car. I'm really trying to compose myself,
- 14:46but I might be a little off when I get there,
- 14:49just so you know. Ninety seconds alone,
- 14:52whether that is you telling your friend what might be happening when you get there.
- 14:57Whether that's you going into the bathroom or whether that's you going into
- 15:00the back car to get the gift for Emma,
- 15:0290 seconds alone where you're collecting yourself is your ability
- 15:08to regulate yourself again. You're allowed that.
- 15:11And you were allowed that the entire time.
- 15:13And to be honest, you should have been allowed that while you were in
- 15:16the car as well. Move five. And if you've listened to the show before,
- 15:20you knew this was coming. Here it is.
- 15:23Ready?
- 15:24Write it down. Write it down. Why?
- 15:27Because if you don't write it down,
- 15:28it didn't happen. And if you go to court,
- 15:29and especially one that's high toxic conflict-ridden,
- 15:32right? You are going to need this.
- 15:35Write it down. Not to win the argument later,
- 15:40to see the pattern. Also.
- 15:43Because if you do need to bring it up in court,
- 15:45if you do need to bring up examples of when they did not respect your boundaries,
- 15:50namely if this happened when children were around and you asked them not
- 15:54to do it when the children were around,
- 15:56this can be really useful in court.
- 15:57But it's also useful for you because you can start to see a pattern.
- 16:02What he said, how you arrived,
- 16:04because these conversations are engineered to evaporate into well,
- 16:10we just talked in the car, and you don't even remember the specifics of it.
- 16:13But if you wrote it down, especially after it happened,
- 16:16most likely you will always remember the specifics of it.
- 16:22And if this marriage ends up across the desk from an attorney,
- 16:27here's the other thing. Patterns matter enormously.
- 16:31I had a client that I worked with years ago,
- 16:34and I remember when I first started working with her,
- 16:36I said, here's what I want you to do today.
- 16:38I want you to start writing out all the times that this happened.
- 16:42And I'm not gonna get into the specifics of it,
- 16:44but for purposes of what I'm bringing up,
- 16:47she wrote down all the times that.
- 16:51The co-parent was not demonstrating a safe,
- 16:55reliable healthy
- 16:58~ relationship with their son.
- 17:01And so she had this whole log,
- 17:04right? It wasn't it wasn't filled with this cathartic like specifics.
- 17:08It was just no, on this date, this happened.
- 17:11My child showed up at my house and he was complete completely dysregulated.
- 17:15He didn't eat dinner. I sent him a text message on this date and I asked
- 17:19him see the text message dated on this date.
- 17:22And he said no he only had eggs today,
- 17:24right? And he spent 12 hours with your co parent and he got
- 17:28home and you ask that co-parent like hey he had a soccer game today could
- 17:33so could you make sure that you give him a shower when he gets home he's like yeah
- 17:37sure whatever fine and he gets to your house and he hasn't showered right this
- 17:42is all documentation that you may need and this person that I'm talking about
- 17:47had this sort of documentation and it was her saving grace in court
- 17:51And I just want to say this as a disclaimer.
- 17:53I know sometimes people can hear me and they think that I am on this team
- 17:58of just you know, making sure that the other co-parent doesn't
- 18:02get their parenting time, right?
- 18:05That's not the purpose of this because there are wonderful parents out there.
- 18:10There are wonderful marriages out there,
- 18:12but the type of space that I work in is for the type of marriages where that doesn't
- 18:16happen, and I help support women.
- 18:21Because they will at one point in time probably need to speak
- 18:24on that documentation and the history if they need to supply it in court
- 18:29and if they need to be asking for more custody.
- 18:32So the last thing I want to leave you with is this.
- 18:36The passenger seat isn't where the conversation happens by accident.
- 18:40It happens there because you can't leave.
- 18:44And once you've seen this, you can't unsee it,
- 18:46which honestly is the whole point of this whole episode,
- 18:48right? You are not obligated to be a captive audience in your own life.
- 18:53So here's the thing: set the agenda ahead of time.
- 18:57Take your own car. Be boring. Be vague.
- 19:01I don't know, I have to get back to you.
- 19:02I'm fine. We'll talk about that later.
- 19:04Protect the landing. Write it down.
- 19:08And when I say protect the landing,
- 19:10what I mean is
- 19:12When they say to you, Hey,
- 19:15I am very upset with you and how this how you acted today,
- 19:21and maybe the entire car, right?
- 19:23Was went awful. When you land,
- 19:25when you when you end up getting to your destination,
- 19:28you can decide how you enter into that social event.
- 19:31Remember, I talked about collecting yourself in the car,
- 19:33texting your Fred ahead of time,
- 19:35and letting him know what happened.
- 19:36And if you nodded through this entire episode.
- 19:40If you already know exactly which drive I described,
- 19:43and you're like, yep, shit, that happened last Tuesday.
- 19:45Every time I get in the car, my gosh,
- 19:48how does she know this? Then you're past wondering whether it's happening because
- 19:53you know it is. And if I'm talking about this,
- 19:55you know that it's so common that it happens a lot in these types of marriages.
- 19:59So, you're like, great,
- 20:03now what do I do? That is where I come in.
- 20:07If you message me the word clarity,
- 20:09that will automate you ~ being able to connect with me inside of
- 20:14my coaching program and we can set up a free booking call because what
- 20:18I do inside of my one-on-one coaching program is not only just some
- 20:22of the things that we talked about today,
- 20:23but I give you scripts to use ahead of time.
- 20:27I'm Kerrie, and I'm super glad that you joined me today.
- 20:30I will see you next week, and I hope you enjoyed today's episode.