Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Mentalizing Part 2
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I love you.
- 0:02Keep going podcast with George Hoss.
- 0:05For more information, please visit our website at
- 0:07www.medicare.gov org, that's www.a.
- 0:12Me TT a gr, oup dot-org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:19This is I love you keep going. It's December 8 2022, it 7:30 6
- 0:23p.m. Pacific time and I don't think
- 0:27we really finished talking about mentalizing enough.
- 0:32We started last week on it and I thought maybe we could continue
- 0:35a little bit more about it, but mainly talking about the
- 0:40patterns of mentalizing and the assets and deficits that brings
- 0:47focusing on the early. Early period.
- 0:52We learn to mentalize from our caregivers in the way that they
- 0:56interact with us when we were children.
- 0:58When were infants, righted starting right?
- 1:01At the very beginning. Like human babies.
- 1:05You know are born quite prematurely in comparison to
- 1:08other species and are incapable of survival.
- 1:13Really incapable of much a newborn infant can't roll over
- 1:17occurrences or sit up over. You have that sense of babies
- 1:22that have never been around them and much time.
- 1:27And then you know, they if you've ever been around them,
- 1:30you see that they do thousands of these little tiny baby
- 1:33crunches, you know, trying to sit up straight and strengthen
- 1:38their muscles and they learn to roll over and they learn to
- 1:42creep, just so they sort of slide themselves along the
- 1:46floor, because they can't really lift themselves up on all four
- 1:49and then make it up. I know poor and they can crawl
- 1:52that to an exploration. Begins, they go from crawling
- 1:56to. Pulling themselves up on
- 1:59anything that's around them, and then they go through a period of
- 2:04learning to balance by holding onto things, and moving around
- 2:08in the space, where they can hold onto things and balance
- 2:13themselves. And then about 10 months or a
- 2:17year old, they have some Mobility, one to two feet, I did
- 2:28not early Crucible of the interaction with the caregiver.
- 2:33We're actually the whole experience of the world is in
- 2:37the face of the caregiver. It's the reflection in the face
- 2:41of the caregiver, that's who see which is the information about
- 2:46the nature of yourself and where you begin to construct the
- 2:51working model of self. Who you are, what your assets
- 2:56are, what your deficits are will happen in that early experience
- 3:01of self. We talked about the self of
- 3:03course, in Buddhism, is this not substantial solid ongoing
- 3:09continuous experience. But that something that arises
- 3:13based on conditioning in each moment, the sense of self arises
- 3:19based on the conditions of the present moment.
- 3:22So huge. Moment is sense of self that
- 3:25arises is slightly different pattern of sensing experiences
- 3:31taken in Touching, seeing hearing tasting, smelling mind
- 3:35of course, is the activity of cherry-picking.
- 3:39The things out of the environment that we're going to
- 3:42use to create this experience of the world in the moment of the
- 3:48there. And in that cherry picking,
- 3:52we're also cherry picking the fencing with experiences that
- 3:57react to our conditioning. That create the sense of self
- 4:01that arises in the moment to experience.
- 4:04What we've created that sense of duality of, this is the self
- 4:10experiencing what's out. There is all one experience Owen
- 4:17boost in duality of The appearance of the self being
- 4:21other than the sensitive period, but actually it's just a little
- 4:25one experience. The database gets built up in
- 4:32these early Reflections in the pace of the caregiver.
- 4:37Or the people that are around us, we present ourselves or
- 4:41tentacley in an effort to get our needs met without knowing
- 4:46what it is that we're doing or communicating in that sense.
- 4:50And then our hopefully sensitive enough caregiver empathetically
- 4:57Tunes to us and begins to decode Are very particular expressions
- 5:03and understand their meaning and then if they're able to do so
- 5:07provide a good enough response to it.
- 5:12So that we have a sense of being seen and being known and being
- 5:17valued. By the person Delight is one of
- 5:22the currencies of secure functioning that we have a sense
- 5:26that we are delightful. So in in a good enough
- 5:34relationship with a caregiver that sense of delight is, is
- 5:38abundant enough that we generally regard ourselves as
- 5:42divided, who even when we were distressed and demanding, we
- 5:47have it sense because it's given to us that we are delightful.
- 5:54And that were valuable. That we're not too much that are
- 5:59caregivers have resources to be able to respond to us in any of
- 6:04our manifestations. And then if that isn't what
- 6:09happens, we develop a working model that's different, and that
- 6:14secure model Peter Van again, Anthony Bateman at the Tavistock
- 6:22Clinic, which is part of the Anna, Freud Centre London
- 6:25developed this map of the early mentalizing experience that
- 6:31arises from the interactions of the caregivers.
- 6:35And they talked about it in four dimensions in one dimension.
- 6:40It's, I like to call it spontaneity and monitoring they
- 6:44would call it automatic or Controlled.
- 6:51The reason I like spontaneity better is because we're
- 6:57meditation group and we're talking about mindfulness, we're
- 7:00being mindful of the experience of the present moment in
- 7:04automatic tends to suggest. That you're not necessarily
- 7:08mindfulness mindful of what's happening and then monitoring is
- 7:12continuously monitoring. So in that Dimension, not
- 7:16interfering with the experience of sensing.
- 7:19But at the same time continue, The monitoring it.
- 7:23But you'll notice in over monitoring situation, for
- 7:28instance, is that the sensing experience becomes quite
- 7:31inhibited. If we use auditory thinking as
- 7:33an example for that, you might notice that the, all the always
- 7:37chatty mind that you have completely shuts down.
- 7:40When you bring your attention to auditory thinking space and it's
- 7:43just completely quiet that's an over monitoring situation.
- 7:48So you have to loosen up the mind.
- 7:51Allow the spontaneous flow but then don't want to get swept up
- 7:55into the content of what the the talk is in.
- 7:59Lose the the monitoring position.
- 8:02The second one is self and other that you have a sense of your
- 8:07own experience and you have a clear distinction between
- 8:13between the experience of others Buddhism.
- 8:16Often we talk about self and world but what we really mean is
- 8:21Ourselves and other people because of the people are.
- 8:24So the other thing that we know the information about ourselves,
- 8:30even in adults relationships after childhood, the main way
- 8:34that we have a sense of how we are being in the moment that for
- 8:39being, it's reflected off the experiences of other other
- 8:43people of what's Happening. I like to talk about this in
- 8:50terms of emotional Clarity, partly that you have the
- 8:55emotional reaction to the present moment.
- 8:57You have self-generated motion, which is Bentley regulating you
- 9:01have. So, so Matta sized emotional
- 9:03experience which is the old stuff that stored in the body
- 9:06and you have the capacity for the empathetic experience of
- 9:11other people when you're in connection to them.
- 9:14So that when you have a clear, Prince of self.
- 9:19Those first three are there. Clear understanding of what the
- 9:23emotional response to the present moment, is your able to
- 9:27monitor your thoughts and understand that each thought has
- 9:30an emotional component to. It are able to track that able
- 9:34to track the background old stuff that's held in the body
- 9:39and can be reactive to the present moment and you're
- 9:42actually able to track the empathetic experience of the
- 9:46other person. Which gives you an indication of
- 9:50them and you can hold your own emotional experiences separate
- 9:54from the empathetic experience and notice the interaction
- 9:58between them. You have a reaction to the
- 10:01empathetic experience, you have in the person that you're in
- 10:04relationship to has a reaction to the their empathetic
- 10:09experience of you which you can, you can track in the empathetic
- 10:13experience of them. So there's an exchange and you
- 10:17really connect. It and can peel into each other,
- 10:20have good clarity about the separation of the two
- 10:24experiences. and then there's a sensitivity to the Differences
- 10:34in conditioning, that that caused you to create an
- 10:38experience of the present moment which is different than the
- 10:42experience of the present moment.
- 10:44They're creating even though in some sense, you're sharing the
- 10:49experience of the present moment Your perspective of the present
- 10:54moment is based on your conditioning.
- 10:56There's is based on their condition and because there's
- 10:59their different, you create different versions of the same
- 11:04shared experience. And this is something that's
- 11:08important to understand and actually really value because
- 11:11you get you get information from that, that you wouldn't be able
- 11:15to get on your own, because you can compare the experience that
- 11:21you've You've created of what's happening in the present moment.
- 11:23There's and did some way to expand into where use their
- 11:29database to create a different perspective on what's actually
- 11:34happening. The third dimension is internal
- 11:39versus external. You have.
- 11:48A capacity to allow information about what's actually happening
- 11:53and we also have the capacity to limit or filter what we allow
- 11:59ourselves to know about what's happening.
- 12:02So for instance, dismissing people have a tendency to
- 12:06restrict information about emotional experience that they
- 12:11might be having and it can get quite severe in the amount of
- 12:15information that they restrict that they don't have any sense
- 12:19of emotions in the body. Sometimes they can cut off the
- 12:24body, but still have a cognitive understanding, whatever emotions
- 12:27are but they also have the capacity to eliminate awareness
- 12:31of that and not Know what their emotional responses to anything.
- 12:36That's a quite a severe restriction.
- 12:43But in internal external, there's that the the capacity of
- 12:46allowing yourself to know everything about yourself.
- 12:49And when you look at the, the neurobiology of this and the
- 12:57Limited capacity that we have. Anyway.
- 12:59It's quite startling and I find little more amusing, things
- 13:04about the conscious Human Condition.
- 13:09You know, the research is ongoing, of course, one of the
- 13:15things about using any aspect of Science in a discussion is that
- 13:20the science is ongoing and so it's constantly changing and so
- 13:23that there's a in understand The nature of that is it's a
- 13:29constantly updating thing. With the way it goes, like right
- 13:34now, 11 million bits per second is the capacity of the sensing
- 13:38body that you live in, if you're fully sense, But the, the width
- 13:45of Consciousness, the width, the width of information that the
- 13:49self experience gets in each moment is only 16 out of 11
- 13:54million. So that to say that the self is
- 13:59the author and the doer, and the organizer, and the creator of
- 14:03the actions that you take is humorous.
- 14:08When you look at that equation, Actually what you are is the
- 14:12witness to what you do in the self experience, rather than
- 14:16being the organizer and doers not making sense.
- 14:22So you're watching what you do from the self-destructive, in
- 14:26case you can you decide on some really boneheaded move and you
- 14:31can intervene that's the controlled side just in time to
- 14:36avert some disaster of your own making.
- 14:43Have you ever started it sentence looked at the
- 14:47expression of the face of the person that you're talking to
- 14:49and cut it off. That would be a case of what I'm
- 14:54talking about. Oops, I didn't read that at all.
- 15:05And and Buddhism, of course, we're talking about
- 15:07Enlightenment and Enlightenment is really to understand the
- 15:11nature of the human condition and be present for the
- 15:14experience. And that's what we really need.
- 15:17And so, all of these things are Pointers to that.
- 15:21How we begin to understand this activity that we're engaged.
- 15:27And so the, my, my George nests or your Jonas, your Cristiano
- 15:33Saul. Coming from that database.
- 15:40And the way that we assemble it in the moment, and if we're
- 15:44clear about it and can really see the pieces that is to say,
- 15:47we can mentalize fast enough to understand our reaction to the
- 15:51present moment, how we're formulating it, and then may be
- 15:54adjusted. So that it's really skillful.
- 15:56Before we allow it to be expressed, which would be the
- 15:59external aspect of it. And then also, how do we
- 16:03understand other people? We see the external presentation
- 16:07of the people and we interpret a meaning of it and sometimes if
- 16:11we have a good empathetic connection to, then we can feel
- 16:14into their emotional being and compare them and get a sense of
- 16:23whether that there's come congruence there.
- 16:28You also need to track that they do what they say they're going
- 16:31to do, don't do what they say. They're not going to so that we
- 16:35really have integrity and they're a lot of its in
- 16:40childhood learned. It split off that what they do
- 16:44and what they say peace because we can't add up the family
- 16:50system that we live in. If we have to connect them, and
- 16:56then the fourth aspect is the Cognitive versus affective or
- 17:02emotional experience in the west, it's this.
- 17:08These poles one side is thinking one-sided, feeling in Buddhism.
- 17:14We don't really have that or all thought has an emotional
- 17:19component to it. I always think back.
- 17:25To wide days in film School. When they would show a film.
- 17:35Which would have the visual and have the auditory, and it would
- 17:38have the music, the feeling and the back, could create a very
- 17:43Vivid experience of Cinema, but if you pulled any one of them
- 17:47away from that, it greatly diminished the impact of it.
- 17:51Because all of them come together to create a the sense
- 17:55of reality that we have, the simply, the auditory simply the
- 17:59visual without the feeling sense, doesn't have the same
- 18:02depth of reality, that one there.
- 18:05Are all together. But understanding auditory and
- 18:10visual thinking and understanding emotion and how
- 18:12they come together to create that rich experience of
- 18:17aliveness. Christian.
- 18:25George the avoidant children is they don't they don't develop
- 18:31like the effective mentalization skills but they can develop the
- 18:36cognitive right skill. Does that mean that their
- 18:41caretaker wasn't closely kind of face-to-face mirroring and
- 18:46marking their affective States? For them to not get that
- 18:51portion. The avoidance strategy developed
- 18:59early from profound neglect. So part of that neglect is a
- 19:09lack of enough time with the face, mirroring back the
- 19:17experience of the child, so that they can identify it.
- 19:21The other thing that happens from neglect, of course is that
- 19:24it's frightening and painful. to be have that sense of being
- 19:31abandoned that sense of being rejected and because there's no
- 19:36help from the caregiver to teach the child, how to regulate those
- 19:41experiences, the child begins to learn to suppress them as a way
- 19:49of survival, really so, So there is no feedback and then the
- 20:00child is left to its own devices to figure out a way to regulate
- 20:04those experiences and the solution that children come up
- 20:07with is to prevent the experience of them arising
- 20:14consciousness. Does it mean that they don't
- 20:17have the people in States? They do have the feeling States.
- 20:21It just means they don't have conscious awareness of the
- 20:24feeling state. So, in studying children and the
- 20:28strange situation, they did put EG zon kids to see what was
- 20:36going on by, okay. You know, in the body with and
- 20:42they found that the anxious avoidant kids were the ones that
- 20:44were in the most distressed. But they are also the ones that
- 20:47had no external presentation of being in distress.
- 20:52And one of the thoughts they had was that because they don't have
- 20:56conscious awareness of in this of being in distress.
- 20:59They never seek help for the distress from anyone.
- 21:03It's simply stays unconscious and so they have distressing
- 21:08experiences which they don't make any attempt to regulate in
- 21:12any way, so they can get to be more intense.
- 21:16So that means they have like poor interoception.
- 21:20Yes. Pash.
- 21:29Yeah, I might have maybe a maybe this is a question about this
- 21:32tournament and since you seem to be able to hold the entire model
- 21:35in your head, at once I can ask you.
- 21:39So when you hear you talking about mentalizing, it sounds
- 21:43like an experience that I can recognize as maybe view or maybe
- 21:48conditioning and internal imagery asserting itself into a
- 21:51view. What are the components of it in
- 21:55mindfulness that I can kind of maybe look at to see the Hole.
- 22:00So what do you want to be able to do is track auditory thinking
- 22:03visual thinking and the emotional experience in the
- 22:08body? And as you formulate conceptual
- 22:11reality, using the past and that you would, you would want to be
- 22:15able to trace the memories threads that are activated when
- 22:21you create the experience of the present moment that you have
- 22:24some sense of what conditioning response it is that you're
- 22:30having and then what you want to be able to do is compare what's
- 22:34happening in the present moment to the condition thread, to see
- 22:38if they line up enough. And then also to see that you're
- 22:42responding to the present moment and not responding to what
- 22:46happened in the conditioned threat that make sense.
- 22:51It does my follow-up, that is about that thread.
- 22:56How do you how do you hold that threat in Equanimity because it
- 22:59seems like the driven response would be to suppress.
- 23:02It may be I think that. Well, in the process of actively
- 23:19mentalizing. And, of course you you hold it
- 23:23in the past. What often happens to people
- 23:29that have unresolved the, the conditioned experiences is that
- 23:37they experience of them being the past is lost in that can
- 23:42become experiences as if they're in the present.
- 23:48And overwhelming in that way. But it's a little by little kind
- 23:54of thing, you want to get up to the speed of mentalizing.
- 23:58Are you can begin to track that, you can really hold things that
- 24:02have happened in the past and hold the present moment
- 24:06separately from the intensity of the experience of them is
- 24:10diminished and when you do it enough times, each time they
- 24:16diminish to the point where they're no longer overwhelming.
- 24:21That's violent. You know, in in this formulation
- 24:29of taking the raw sensing data and forming it into conceptual
- 24:35reality first, the Mind goes around and gathers, little bits
- 24:39of sensing data. Then that this is all
- 24:44unconscious preconscious, it's the evaluation of how urgent it
- 24:49is. How much attention it needs is
- 24:51made it. If it's urgent to go to the head
- 24:54of the line, It's been compared to the perceptual database for
- 24:59an experience. That's close enough to it that
- 25:03the meaning of the condition, meaning attaches, the experience
- 25:07of the present moment and then that folds open into conceptual
- 25:13reality and then the intention for the response to the
- 25:18interpretation of conceptual reality forms.
- 25:21And then you you're free to take an action in response.
- 25:25And what formulation you created.
- 25:30And adequate mentalizing would be that you could follow that
- 25:35whole process. And in the intention part of it
- 25:40evaluate, whether your response is make sense, given the actual
- 25:45conditions of the present moment.
- 25:48And when you tend to take actions that are not, so in line
- 25:52with the present moment, it's usually because he's lost track
- 25:56of the present moment are just in the flow of The conditioning
- 26:03and you're responding it to, for virtually responded to things
- 26:07like that. I like the quantum physics model
- 26:142 in each moment, every single possibility that you could
- 26:20choose that's available in. That moment is available.
- 26:26But we do get into these ruts of Sam sorrow.
- 26:29Just pick over and over again. From this very limited selection
- 26:33of possibilities. Each time we do, of course, all
- 26:36of the other possibilities disappear and it's just the one
- 26:40that we pick that formed the next moment.
- 26:44And then all of the possibilities that are tied to
- 26:48that previous choice is what opens up so that you can get
- 26:52into these Vicious Cycles of over and over again repeating
- 26:56conditioned Behavior, which is can be terribly defeating and
- 27:00painful. Which does it mean that it needs
- 27:02moment, all of the other choices?
- 27:04Weren't there. They were there who just keeping
- 27:06the did. You just didn't pick them?
- 27:11Uh-huh. I wanted to ask the follow-up
- 27:19question, from what I'm hearing from you, congruence is come up
- 27:23and what you described a few times.
- 27:26It's congruence than a byproduct of this process or is that
- 27:28another intentional effort, how you meaning it?
- 27:33I'm like emotional congruence like you were talking about when
- 27:36when the other sees you you know they're able to tell if your new
- 27:40congruent expression mode. That would take somebody, who
- 27:45knows, you really well and would also probably take some inquiry.
- 27:53I don't know about you but I totally flunked High School
- 27:57telepathy. It did.
- 28:01Take it in college. This is what I think is going
- 28:12on. It's a good statement, this is
- 28:15what's going on exotic. It's safer.
- 28:18This is what I think is going on.
- 28:20What do you think is going on? Is a wonderful basis for
- 28:24communication. This is what you said to be in.
- 28:31This is the effect that it had on me.
- 28:34Was that the intention of your expression is a good way to
- 28:38inquire about something that's hurtful.
- 28:42And if it was actually an accurate in understanding of
- 28:45what it is, and it was hurtful, then you have a ground for
- 28:49dialogue about it. You did this without such a
- 28:56fertile ground because the anger shuts everybody down creates a
- 29:02defensive to it. And often what you're noticing
- 29:08is that the big, the big self experience is what's Happening
- 29:13and then we get lost in identification with big self
- 29:17experience. That we need to defend the big
- 29:19wounded cell for the big Angry solve for the big frightening
- 29:22self and actually that's insubstantial.
- 29:27Let that come and go and continue to seek closeness and
- 29:35understanding The more secure you are of course in your
- 29:40connection to other people. It's that kind of dialogue is
- 29:46this frightening because you don't worry about being rejected
- 29:50or or abandoned due to worry about being seen and understood
- 29:55and you worry about seeing that a person and understanding them
- 30:01more than you do about being abandoned.
- 30:05And lost to. The difficult world, we live in.
- 30:12That makes me sneeze. If you look at the development
- 30:18of mentalizing, And the attachment systems that arise
- 30:28in. Secure attachment right out of
- 30:31the gate. Most people can mentalize wildin
- 30:33out and have this dynamic range of in the early mentalizing
- 30:38experience. That means one they show up at
- 30:42the play grounded 4 or 5 years old.
- 30:46They have a basis for communicating and for
- 30:49interacting with the world and interacting with other people
- 30:52and doing the assignments of socializing and learning and all
- 30:58the rest of it pretty well. And then you notice that other
- 31:03people are less able to do that. So that early platform is what
- 31:11offers us a springboard. If you will into the thing, the
- 31:17later development and the lack of those foundations actually
- 31:22inhibit or restrict our capacities.
- 31:27And so as as Life Goes On, The the lack of enterprising skills
- 31:35can be quite inhibiting in terms of moving ahead with what needs
- 31:40to happen. in the Development of a collaborative relational
- 31:52systems which is the foundation of secure functioning when you
- 31:57don't have a responsive it of caregiver.
- 32:00And this is somebody who responds thirty percent of the
- 32:02time or better which is a which is an astonishingly low bar.
- 32:09I think when you look at the success of the human species on
- 32:12the globe, you would need the something that was an
- 32:15astonishingly low bar to. Make sense of how we go.
- 32:23But this missing people, because nobody comes to them, they don't
- 32:29move out of this original Auto regulating stands.
- 32:33We all come into the world as Auto regulators and then if
- 32:38people come well enough and respond to us, well, well enough
- 32:43we re oriented toward external regulation a because nobody
- 32:48really Ali comes well enough for a avoidant child.
- 32:56They stay in that order. Regulating States, one of the
- 32:59reasons why they learn to suppress their emotions as a way
- 33:03of dealing with the difficulties of having to only Auto regulate
- 33:11is because it's too painful otherwise and because they don't
- 33:14have actual help from anybody else.
- 33:16They don't have options. You do differently.
- 33:21Christian, but avoiding children like they learn to become good
- 33:29explorers, I guess generally. So there are they actually being
- 33:32encouraged in their exploration, by their caregivers in some way.
- 33:37Or is it just kind of like like You know, like whatever our
- 33:42attachment styles were learning how to get our care and we're
- 33:47going to respond in a way that's going to get us cared for.
- 33:50And so are they just learning to become good explorers?
- 33:52Because that's just what they have to do with themselves or
- 33:56they're actually doing that as a response to the caregiver
- 34:00encouraging just that but not encouraging the effective part.
- 34:06well, you might Call it pseudo exploration rather than the
- 34:13vital exploration of secure person.
- 34:16So secure child, Begins exploration, when they're able
- 34:23to actually locomote away from the caregiver explore things.
- 34:28So you're talking creeping they don't get very far but crawling,
- 34:32they do a child will crawl say to the the middle of the room
- 34:39and looked back for encouragement and if they get
- 34:41encouragement they'll be bold and to go further and then I'll
- 34:44get to a door when they'll look back.
- 34:46No coal out of the door and crawl right back in and looking
- 34:50to see that The caregiver is there supporting them and the
- 34:55more reliable the caregivers, the greater, the distance is
- 34:58that they get to explore. That would be a secure one and
- 35:01then the child discovered something and they rush back to
- 35:04the caregiver and they can't wait to share their Discovery
- 35:08with the caregiver in the caregiver that has an
- 35:11opportunity to still light in the child discoveries and go
- 35:16through that with the child. And then the child learns that
- 35:19their interests are important. Oughtn't and what their
- 35:22perspective is important, and something valuable that they can
- 35:27share with somebody who's interested in and their
- 35:31perspective. But this isn't what really a
- 35:34dismissing person is doing. But you'll notice in dismissing
- 35:41or anxious avoidant children is, they explore because nobody
- 35:47inhibits them from going. They don't come back because
- 35:53there's nothing to come back to well often if they're restricted
- 35:58in some way, or they have to perform in some way to satisfy
- 36:03the caregivers and their, their actual interests aren't
- 36:07rewarded. They learn to keep those secrets
- 36:10and perform in the way that they need to in order to get their
- 36:14needs met. So they don't give up on getting
- 36:16their needs that they don't learn to collaborate with other
- 36:20people. To meet those needs in the way
- 36:22that secure people do. So there we would say that they
- 36:27get really focused on secondary exploration, which is the
- 36:32acquiring of resources to transact.
- 36:36The kind of care that they want. They tend to go for social
- 36:39positions or money or some kind of resource, they can then use
- 36:43to trade for kind of care that they want as adults.
- 36:49Which is very different than a secure person collaborating with
- 36:53somebody else mutually caring for each other.
- 37:06If somebody comes good enough that you reorient toward
- 37:09external regulation but they're not reliable enough that you can
- 37:13predict how to elicit a response from them.
- 37:17So secure kids they make a gesture, the caregiver
- 37:22sensitively, a Tunes them understands of the gestures and
- 37:26then provides the care that the child wants the child
- 37:29understands in doing that. That if I make this gesture, I
- 37:32can get that care. And so they begin to move.
- 37:35Move out of the externally focused into the collaborative,
- 37:40experience of care. I need this.
- 37:42I make this expression and in my caregiver meets my needs, and as
- 37:47I get older, I understand that. My caregivers separate for me
- 37:51that they have an agenda and I have an agenda that I can
- 37:54collaborate with them so that each of our agenda, that can be
- 37:57met in a way that provides the care that I need.
- 38:02That collaborative balance that doesn't happen with the
- 38:06discussing person and with the preoccupied person because care
- 38:10is too inconsistent for them to be able to understand what to do
- 38:17to get the care that they want. They don't develop that sense of
- 38:24security, that sense of collaboration with a caregiver,
- 38:29And then they don't have that capacity when they hit the
- 38:32playground and move into the mid childhood development period,
- 38:39that making sense. so that what we talked about, in terms of
- 38:44using meditation, to train mentalizing, is to begin to
- 38:47understand the maps of assets and deficits that we have based
- 38:52on our early conditioning and train the deficits What are what
- 38:59are the things that I find the most Charming about this?
- 39:04Is that most people would prefer to train the skills.
- 39:08They already have then to have to go through the learning of
- 39:12the skills that they don't have, because one is pleasurable in
- 39:14one is challenging. So it's that that kind of that
- 39:20moving away from paying toward pleasure concept of the Buddha
- 39:24talks about. And here we have two really
- 39:27insist that we train the deficits Christian.
- 39:35So do you find in the kind of modular way that you, you teach
- 39:39for Boston, alike, mentalization skills, that, that Maps pretty
- 39:43consistently with your students attachment Styles, or like
- 39:47whatever the a, I said that they'll struggle with a certain
- 39:52group, Asana skill, or meditation type and Excel at
- 39:57others, and it's pretty consistent.
- 40:00It is with organized insecure people.
- 40:05So secure people and organized insecure people.
- 40:08That's pretty consistent with dismiss.
- 40:10With disorganized people, it's still all over the place,
- 40:14Karthik to tell. But you know that, for instance,
- 40:18said, this missing person typically doesn't have any
- 40:20memory before puberty. One of the ways that they learn
- 40:25to emotionally Regulators to focus intentionally away from
- 40:29anything that has an emotional content to it.
- 40:32They're very material oriented object-oriented.
- 40:39They learn to be object-oriented because objects don't typically
- 40:43produce much in the way of emotion and they're looking for
- 40:47an emotional list existence because emotions are painful.
- 40:54But human memory requires a strong emotion in order to make
- 40:58it from short-term memory into long-term memory, because
- 41:00they're focusing so much on things that have no emotion.
- 41:04I don't remember anything because they don't succeed in
- 41:08passing the short-term to long-term transition because the
- 41:13emotional content is too little or the experiences are really
- 41:16bad and they suppress those So, with a dismissing person you
- 41:22wouldn't necessarily say oh let's try and dig up all the
- 41:24memories of your child and because the only ones I can
- 41:26remember are bad and who wants that, particularly what you
- 41:32don't need them to repair the mentalizing capacity, where the
- 41:37attachment conditioning. So we're economical.
- 41:41Now, my preoccupied people don't monitor anything, they just
- 41:45respond. It's when you We predict what
- 41:50you have to do to get the response, you want to just have
- 41:53to keep going through through presentations until you hit one,
- 41:58that works. And because there's no
- 41:59consistency, moment-to-moment you just keep scrolling through
- 42:03them and does it matter whether you track them or not because if
- 42:07it succeeds, even if it exceeds succeeds In This Moment, there's
- 42:10no likelihood that it will exceed in succeed in the next
- 42:14moment. So I can send.
- 42:17So what's the point in tracking that doesn't get?
- 42:20What does it get you? What you need and it takes too
- 42:23much energy. You can see why these things
- 42:27happen and then preoccupied people tend to not remember so
- 42:31much about themselves, but they remember a lot about other
- 42:34people. There are good resources for
- 42:37other people memories of other their experience of other
- 42:40people, but since they don't track their own experience, they
- 42:45don't remember their own experience.
- 42:49So these are the kinds of patterns that you can see when
- 42:52when you do these, these investigations It's organized
- 43:01people know truthfully preoccupied fearfully avoidant
- 43:06tend to go one way or the other like organized people do the
- 43:11complexly. Disorganized people that are
- 43:14present anything. But they can do that.
- 43:19It's one way that you have a sense of reduces level of
- 43:21disorganization, Joan. So how do you categorize a child
- 43:28who may look on dismissive? So it looks very controlled on
- 43:33the outside and it's not expressive but on the inside has
- 43:36access to motion and it could be can feel extreme.
- 43:43Then you're probably looking at a passively preoccupied.
- 43:48So we tracked different things, role role reversal or
- 43:53involvement in the mindset of the caregivers.
- 43:56The thing that causes preoccupation. but if you add to
- 44:01that rejection, Then that's what creates that particular.
- 44:05Formulation the child learns that they can't make any
- 44:08authentic expression above them about themselves.
- 44:13That's the cutoff part that looks like this missing person
- 44:17but they have a chaotic internal life of a preoccupied person.
- 44:23So, with receive. So that's what that mean.
- 44:30You said disorganized or passively?
- 44:33No, passively preoccupied is insecure.
- 44:36Organized strategy. oftentimes the, the assumption is that
- 44:45there is missing because they're cut off But they're, they're not
- 44:55dismissing. People are cut off from
- 44:57themselves and passively preoccupied for not cut off from
- 45:01themselves. They cut off, they cut
- 45:04themselves off from other people.
- 45:07That's why when you're looking at them, it has a similar
- 45:10appearance. And they keep that expression
- 45:18secret which is also something that this hissing people do to
- 45:22see people really keep their there are the central core of
- 45:26their five secret because of the rejection that they experienced
- 45:32in childhood. So the common factor is
- 45:38rejection. Yeah, sensibly.
- 45:42Normally you have dismissing from neglect but sometimes
- 45:46neglected has a rejecting components.
- 45:51The childhood of profound neglect has in addition to that
- 45:56rejection. but that creates a much more cut off person, but
- 46:02you can also have the rejection in relationship to bracket
- 46:07patience. Use you see it?
- 46:11An eating disorder? Experiences.
- 46:13Common to have the involving role, reversing and the
- 46:17rejection. That's the Hallmarks of that.
- 46:24So what do you think? Shall we do some meditation?
- 46:31We can either go the Met away, or we can go to the positive
- 46:34way. What do you think?
- 46:36Mehta the pasta. Why not both?
- 46:47It's a tie. I did matter today.
- 46:52Once all be the tiebreaker will go beep Asana.
- 46:55All right. Go ahead and take your
- 46:59meditation posture. Lot of subliminal talk.
- 47:12Oh good. Yeah.
- 47:16You mean it didn't ever burst into Clear Talk.
- 47:20Yeah like muttering repetitive you know there was some emotion
- 47:28generator but not nothing like a super potent, good good inside.
- 47:36Adele. Dealing with the hindrance of
- 47:41sloth and torpor. Yes, it's late.
- 47:46It is yeah. Wind through that very Oliver
- 47:56poem, it's already late. Stand up.
- 48:08Open the Eyes block, those are the remedies to slot the torpor
- 48:15indeed, I just got back from a retreat.
- 48:19So there was there was some standing indeed.
- 48:23Yeah. Or just to come to the
- 48:26deliciousness of falling asleep. Oh yeah.
- 48:31It was funny because who was it? I don't know when I was talking
- 48:36to somebody and they did a retreat in Burma and it was like
- 48:40month-long with a bunch of monks and then he opened his eyes
- 48:43during the retreat one time. And saw this monk at the front
- 48:45of the stage is like he's like well at least it's not me, just
- 48:48me. Yeah, we were there said, it
- 48:55said, you're getting off easy. You don't have to be in the Zen,
- 49:01do until 4:30. There were a lot of that.
- 49:12Yes, very hardcore. Everything else, do you think
- 49:21your back scrubber for for the chanting on the discrete
- 49:24structures? There there are.
- 49:32Those who treats the chanting was that in the evening.
- 49:37At 10:00 p.m. so you can start the day as for and then you
- 49:44chanting in 10cm long day. So we have the holidays coming
- 49:59up, so really for the rest of the year, we're not doing that
- 50:02much but then in January we are going to start a new level 1 and
- 50:07Pacific time. And then a level 2 and then
- 50:13we're going to do another level 1 in EU time.
- 50:19In April, I think it is and then I'm doing a in-person retreat in
- 50:29Utrecht in June, which is in the Netherlands of, it's been a half
- 50:32hour south of Amsterdam. And I think that takes us all
- 50:42the way into July of next year. we'll be doing another couple of
- 50:48level ones, and a Second round of level 2 over the summer here.
- 50:58And then in the fall, we'll do one in EU time our 1st level 2nd
- 51:05times of, you know, people over there.
- 51:08Because it is the holidays and some gift-giving might be in
- 51:12line. We have new merge in case you
- 51:15want to take a look at it here. Three, do t-shirts a new, I love
- 51:23you. Keep going a new met Against the
- 51:26Machine and the first version of always cool.
- 51:32Always kind, which I think it's a lovely idea for shirt.
- 51:37We have a new chat book on secure attachment case.
- 51:41You want to a primer on that and then I have a new book called
- 51:46punchouts. So three or four days to get the
- 51:49shirts and so on. And then it takes about eight
- 51:52days. It's sort of got a book if you
- 51:54want that. I'm a marketing guy told me to
- 51:57make this pitch, so that's due to fully complying.
- 52:02A lot of it is a beautiful book like so how did you How did you
- 52:07come up with those bracelets? All these are t-shirts.
- 52:11Well what we've been doing met Against the Machine for a while.
- 52:14It was doing you a bracelet still bracelet bracelets.
- 52:18What's up? Do you have the what would Jesus
- 52:21do bracelets now no I have one that says what's the secure
- 52:25Choice? Do that?
- 52:27Okay. Okay I probably need one.
- 52:30I have one that says Compassionate resistant.
- 52:39Kind action. I love you.
- 52:42Keep going of course may you be peaceful.
- 52:47We have one of those. What happened to love people and
- 52:54feed them. You know, since all of the
- 52:59meditation centers closed and there's no in person, it's hard
- 53:04to hand out dollar bills to people and say, give them away.
- 53:12He's referring to when I first started teaching meditation and
- 53:17I would ask people, or I would say that that generosity The
- 53:23entrance into the path since we don't really teach generosity
- 53:28in. The west is very hard for people
- 53:31to grasp that. So then I would say give a
- 53:34dollar to a homeless person if they ask without, considering
- 53:38whether they deserve it or not and nobody would do it because
- 53:42there was a scarcity mentality counties.
- 53:45So then I started stamping dollar bills.
- 53:47That love people and feed them and giving them to the people
- 53:50who came to the meditation. Classes with the instruction to
- 53:55give them away to a homeless person.
- 53:58If somebody asked about evaluating whether they deserved
- 54:02it or not there's a lot of friends in Civ If a homeless
- 54:08person came up and they were drunk.
- 54:10A lot of people have this idea that they shouldn't help them,
- 54:13because they're causing their own suffering, but we don't have
- 54:20a good way of judging how somebody ended up in front of us
- 54:24in the way that they are. so, and that people began to give
- 54:30away the dollars because they wasn't their dollar and they
- 54:35were instructed to it a plus. I would give him another dollar.
- 54:38If they gave away the dollar that I gave them and then they
- 54:42begin to have the experience of generosity which was great
- 54:46actually quite amazing. So, I don't know whether you
- 54:51know this or not but they made a documentary film about it.
- 54:58I ended of course on The Cutting Room floor because it took the
- 55:06opinion that mentally ill, homeless people should be forced
- 55:10into treatment. I would try to support
- 55:17anecdotally. You also had to set your Stamper
- 55:20up because people at the end of the class want to stamp their
- 55:22own money does ever settle involved with the practice.
- 55:36See this? I love you.
- 55:40Keep going. I love to love people feed them.
- 55:45Which is somebody the two dollar bill.
- 55:48I only gave away dollar, don't you may have heard that?
- 55:56Sorry, I'm back on my soapbox in New York there.
- 55:59Now rhymed in people up and declaring that they're mentally
- 56:04ill institutionalizing and whether they want to go or not.
- 56:14Which is a, which is heartbreaking.
- 56:19You might really appreciate your practice.
- 56:21Thank you for coming. We'll see you soon.
- 56:23I hope somewhere along the path. I am going to take the week off
- 56:27between Christmas and New Year's so we won't have a meeting then
- 56:32but we will with all of the other times.
- 56:35See you soon. Bye.