Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Zooming Into Trouble: Remote Legal Practice and Its Ethical Traps
Transcript
- 0:03Good afternoon, everybody. My name is Mike Douglas,
- 0:06and I am the chair of the BHBA ethics and legal
- 0:11malpractice law section. I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:14you to our speakers, Paige Adamczyk and Jennifer
- 0:19Saunders. Jennifer is a partner at Hinshaw and
- 0:22Culbertson with more than 40 years of experience
- 0:26defending professionals across the legal, financial,
- 0:30real estate, insurance, and engineering sectors.
- 0:34A certified specialist in legal malpractice by
- 0:37the California Board of Legal Specialization,
- 0:40Jennifer advises clients on errors and omissions
- 0:43claims, professional responsibility matters,
- 0:47and complex disputes involving technology, privacy,
- 0:51and media issues. Jennifer is widely recognized
- 0:54for her practical counsel. thought leadership
- 0:58and long -standing commitment to the legal profession.
- 1:02I'd like to also introduce Paige Adamczyk, who
- 1:05is the founder of Adamczyk Legal PC, where she
- 1:09focuses on legal ethics and professional responsibility,
- 1:14drawing on her substantial earlier experience
- 1:17in the entertainment industry and general civil
- 1:21litigation. She represents attorneys and creative
- 1:24professionals in ethics matters, including state
- 1:27bar investigations and bar admission issues.
- 1:32And Paige is particularly passionate about assisting
- 1:34independent artists and smaller production companies.
- 1:39Thank you, Jennifer and Paige for joining us.
- 1:42And now let's go ahead and get started. Thank
- 1:47you so much. So happy to be here with you guys
- 1:51and thank you Jennifer for being here with me
- 1:54so we can do this together. We're going to talk
- 1:57a little bit about remote work and the unauthorized
- 2:00practice of law and something that everybody
- 2:03should know a bit about. It's super relevant.
- 2:07Nowadays, post -COVID, a lot of us are still
- 2:10working remotely, haven't returned to the office,
- 2:12and there's some huge advantages but also some
- 2:15huge risks. So we're going to walk through that
- 2:17a little bit over the next hour. I'm gonna take
- 2:21you through a roadmap of what we're gonna be
- 2:22talking about. We're gonna be going through roughly,
- 2:26I would say five topics if we're able to get
- 2:29through them. So we're looking at talking about
- 2:32what is the unauthorized practice of law itself.
- 2:35And to do that, Jennifer laid a little foundation
- 2:38for us as well as far as what we think about
- 2:40when we think about law practice. Also, we're
- 2:43gonna talk about lawyers that are coming to California.
- 2:47So an inbound lawyer who arrives in California,
- 2:52whether virtually or physically, but is licensed
- 2:55elsewhere, we are going to talk about California
- 2:57lawyers who go out of California and are practicing
- 3:02elsewhere, whether again. physically or whether
- 3:05they're doing it virtually, we're going to talk
- 3:07about holding yourself out. This is a really
- 3:10important part of UPL and something that you
- 3:14can do inadvertently without even realizing it.
- 3:16One of the things we'll do is we'll walk through
- 3:18not only some case law and some authorities,
- 3:20but also some hypothetical scenarios that will
- 3:22let you see that in place. You can kind of evaluate
- 3:25whether or not that's something you need to concern
- 3:28yourself with in terms of what you're doing right
- 3:30now. Kind of take an inventory of exactly how
- 3:32you're making sure that you don't have any holding
- 3:34out issues. We're also going to talk about issues
- 3:38that can be associated with assisting someone
- 3:40else with the unauthorized practice of law and
- 3:42how that plays for you as the lawyer or you as
- 3:45the firm owner depending on on your situation.
- 3:52Hey Paige, let me just start out by saying that
- 3:57the remote practice of law is a lot more than
- 4:01just setting up your laptop at your dining room
- 4:07table or your kitchen table. It involves a whole
- 4:12lot more than that. And so hopefully some of
- 4:18the things that we'll talk about will get you
- 4:21thinking about exactly what is involved in the
- 4:29issue of remote workplace. What is considered
- 4:35the practice of law? In California, it's not
- 4:41actually defined by a statute. The most the statute
- 4:46says is that it's unlawful not to be a licensed
- 4:53lawyer in the state of California. So what is
- 4:57the practice of law? The practice of law is performing
- 5:01services in a court of law in California or perhaps
- 5:08in other jurisdictions. It is providing legal
- 5:12advice and it is the preparation of instruments
- 5:18that can only be performed by a lawyer. It is
- 5:27not just in the situation of, and you can go
- 5:33to the next slide. It is not just in the situation
- 5:37of litigation. It has to do with every practice
- 5:46of law. So it can be real estate. It can be any
- 5:50number of things. It can be estate and trust.
- 5:54It is not limited to the litigation. So next
- 6:02slide. What are the rules of conduct? As I indicated
- 6:12before, The business impressions code sets out
- 6:18the practice of law in California, 6125. It also
- 6:27sets out the penalty for the unauthorized practice
- 6:33of law, which is in 6126. So you can find that
- 6:40set forth. in those code sections. But what is
- 6:48also important is that we're not suggesting that
- 6:54in a particular area of the law, such as immigration,
- 7:01that you can't practice immigration law in California.
- 7:07So it is very important that when you are looking
- 7:12at what areas of law you are practicing, whether
- 7:19you're in California or another jurisdiction,
- 7:22that you carefully analyze that situation. And
- 7:26we'll talk about the rules that relate to that
- 7:31as we proceed. Next slide, please. So we thought
- 7:41this was important to identify for you at the
- 7:46outset. What issues are there in California that
- 7:51bind you? And those are clearly set forth in
- 7:56the State Bar Act, Business and Professions Code
- 8:006060. 8 and 61, 25 to 27. The rules of professional
- 8:08conduct, those are all binding. And the California
- 8:13rules of court, 9 .40 and 9 .48 or through 9
- 8:20.48, these are binding authorities. There is
- 8:29and are various advisory opinions that may provide
- 8:36you with some assistance depending on the situation,
- 8:42but those advisory opinions are not necessarily
- 8:46binding on either the state bar of California
- 8:52or the courts. And those can be advisory opinions
- 8:59that are through the LA County Bar Association,
- 9:04through the ABA, through COPRAC. Any number of
- 9:09bar associations may issue advisory opinions.
- 9:13Just keep in mind that those may not be binding
- 9:18authority. Next slide, please. So in analyzing
- 9:30remote practice, it's important to keep in mind,
- 9:37are you a California lawyer that is going to
- 9:43a different state? Or are you an inbound lawyer
- 9:48coming into California and licensed only in other
- 9:54another jurisdiction. So we're going to hopefully
- 9:59cover this. So let's say you are a California
- 10:06lawyer and you go to Arizona, Texas or a beach
- 10:11house for the summer. So you're gone from California
- 10:15for a period of time. It's important to determine
- 10:24what the jurisdiction of that, what the authority
- 10:30says in the jurisdiction that you're going to
- 10:33in order to determine whether or not you can
- 10:37continue to practice. On California cases, Paige,
- 10:44do you want to add anything to this? Yeah, I
- 10:48think, you know, it's and we'll get further into
- 10:51the details on this as we go. But, you know,
- 10:55one of the things you'll be looking at, obviously,
- 10:56as we kind of go through this discussion is how
- 10:59long you are in those other states and what exactly
- 11:03the situation is with that. But if you're a California
- 11:07licensed attorney and you go on vacation for
- 11:09a week, obviously, it's not the same thing as
- 11:11you go sublet a place for the summer and you're
- 11:14going to be there for three months. So there's
- 11:16different factors that are going to go into this
- 11:18evaluation. But I think the key point is what
- 11:21you were just talking about. You know, you have
- 11:23to know that state's rules and always be mindful
- 11:26of that. Don't assume that it's okay. Just because
- 11:29reflexively it feels like it makes sense doesn't
- 11:32necessarily mean it's okay. And some states it
- 11:34would be completely permissible, but other states
- 11:37you'd find yourself with a problem and that problem
- 11:41will chase you. all the way back to California.
- 11:43So if you violate that state's rules in that
- 11:47state, you are violating the terms of your California
- 11:51membership in the state bar. So you can have
- 11:53disciplinary factors that arise from that. That's
- 11:57the 5 .5A1, as you see there, makes their answer
- 12:01your California problem. So next slide, please.
- 12:09So we referred earlier, Paige referred earlier
- 12:13to 5 .5. 5 .5 controls a lawyer no matter where
- 12:20they are, California lawyer no matter where they
- 12:23are. And that rule says that you are not entitled
- 12:30to practice law in a jurisdiction or doing so
- 12:34violates that jurisdiction's regulation. So that's
- 12:39why it's important. If you know that you're going
- 12:42to be going someplace for an extended period
- 12:46of time, let's say Texas, wherever you're going
- 12:50on the East Coast, and you're going to be gone
- 12:54for three months, you need to check that jurisdiction's
- 13:01regulation to see if you can practice. and you
- 13:07are not allowed to knowingly assist a person
- 13:11in the unauthorized practice of law. So that
- 13:16is sort of a side to you can't do it yourself,
- 13:23but you also cannot assist one doing it. If you
- 13:28are not admitted in California, but you come
- 13:34to California, you are not authorized to engage
- 13:42in the systematic or continuous presence in California
- 13:48for the practice of law. So you can't hold an
- 13:51office here. You can't advertise on your website.
- 13:59You can't represent to anyone in the state that
- 14:06you can't hold yourself out, in other words,
- 14:11that you are a lawyer admitted to practice or
- 14:14could be construed to practice law in the state
- 14:18of California if you are not licensed. And one
- 14:23thing I want to add to that, Jennifer, actually,
- 14:26is the holding out piece is super nuanced here.
- 14:30Because it's not just affirmatively holding yourself
- 14:33out and that's something really important to
- 14:34keep in mind. It's also holding out by omission.
- 14:37So you can create a misimpression. And again,
- 14:41you're gonna see us exhaustively as we go through
- 14:44these slides. And I really hope we're able to
- 14:46get through all of them because we have a lot
- 14:47of good stuff for you. But by failing to... actively
- 14:54disclose that you're exclusively licensed elsewhere
- 14:57or not licensed in California, that's a holding
- 15:03out. It's a passive holding out of a sense, but
- 15:06it's a holding out nonetheless. It's like a lipo
- 15:08mission. We can advance to two slides, please.
- 15:20So as we indicated earlier, you cannot practice
- 15:25in California unless you're licensed in California.
- 15:29And that holds true in any situation. So let's
- 15:40move to the next slide. the practice in California.
- 15:51What are the considerations that we need to bear
- 15:54in mind? You need to look at quantitatively what
- 16:00the activity is that you're engaged in. You need
- 16:03to look at qualitatively what the lawyer is actually
- 16:11doing in California. So we're not suggesting
- 16:16by any stretch that if you're here for a deposition
- 16:20and you're authorized, you have permission to
- 16:23do that. Perhaps you have become a Prohac Vichay
- 16:28in a federal court action. We're not suggesting
- 16:33that that is improper. What we're suggesting,
- 16:37and as it says here, the mirror attenuated contacts.
- 16:43does not sustain a finding of unauthorized practice
- 16:48of law. But you need to consider the circumstances.
- 16:53So the primary focus here is what is the lawyer
- 17:00doing here? Is the lawyer engaged in sufficient
- 17:06contacts for activities as a lawyer in the state
- 17:10of California? that creates a, or creates a continuous
- 17:19relationship with the California client that
- 17:24it carries the duties and obligations of a lawyer
- 17:28practicing law in the state of California. Those
- 17:32are the inquiries that we need to make when we're
- 17:38determining the question. In case you have anything
- 17:47to add to that? No, I think that you summed it
- 17:53up perfectly. What we're looking at is we're
- 17:57not looking for those. random small interactions.
- 18:02We're looking at something that's more substantial
- 18:04that makes it apparent that you are doing something
- 18:07that would be considered the practice of law.
- 18:10And I think the inquiry sets it forth there for
- 18:12you. And by the way, just to kind of mention
- 18:16for the audience sake, at the end of this. Presentation,
- 18:21we have a table of authorities for you where
- 18:22you can find authorities, not just the rules,
- 18:24but some case law that also references and gives
- 18:27context for all of this as well. So we're going
- 18:30to talk about the case that actually established
- 18:32that test in a little bit. We can actually talk
- 18:37about it now because and you can move to the
- 18:41next slide. The cases. Thank you. Brewer Brower,
- 18:52and the citation is here. What Brewer Brower
- 18:58involved was a situation where a law firm that
- 19:03was a New York law firm with no attorneys licensed
- 19:09in the state of California was retained to provide
- 19:14legal services to a California entity with its
- 19:24principal office in California. And they did
- 19:30render services to the California entity. And
- 19:37they ended up settling the case with another
- 19:43California entity. The question that was addressed
- 19:48in Bear Brower was whether the unlicensed attorney
- 19:55who was engaged in or whether the unlicensed
- 20:00attorney was engaged in sufficient activity that
- 20:07created a relationship with a California client.
- 20:16when they're not licensed in California. And
- 20:22Berber are held that not only mere fortuitous
- 20:30or attenuated contacts do not sustain a finding
- 20:36that an attorney was, that unlicensed attorney
- 20:46was practicing law in California but also held
- 20:50that the question that we all need to address
- 20:54is whether or not the unlicensed attorney was
- 20:58engaged in a sufficient activities in the state
- 21:03of California or be created a continuing relationship
- 21:09with a California client that included the legal
- 21:15duties and obligations of an attorney to that
- 21:19client. And Berber also talked about the fees
- 21:26that were owed, claimed owed to the attorneys.
- 21:33And the court ended up holding that while the
- 21:41attorneys may be entitled to activities and fees
- 21:48for the work that they did in New York. They
- 21:53were not entitled to fees that were incurred
- 21:59through activities in California. So there was
- 22:05a distinction there that was raised that was
- 22:11significant, I think, and did set forth the question
- 22:17that needed to be addressed with regard to the
- 22:23unauthorized practice of law. Paige, do you have
- 22:26anything to add to that? Yeah, I think I thank
- 22:30you. I think that You know, the point here is
- 22:34that Berber still still holds up in terms of
- 22:37the test itself. And then the other thing to
- 22:39think about, you know, none of us want to be
- 22:41putting in hours and hours and hours on a case
- 22:44and then being forced to waive our fees. And,
- 22:47you know, this is this is the civil consequence,
- 22:50one of the civil consequences. And of course,
- 22:52there's the disciplinary consequence as well.
- 22:55And that's a whole separate matter. But from
- 22:57a from a fee perspective, from a business perspective,
- 23:00just bottom line. You know, in addition to the
- 23:04discipline, in addition to risking your licensure,
- 23:07in addition to all of those problems, there's
- 23:09the fact that, you know, if you've got a New
- 23:12York fee that's traveling back and forth to California,
- 23:15and they're spending money on that travel, on
- 23:17the airfare, on the hotels, on all the legal
- 23:19services that were provided related to the California
- 23:22work, then they're going to be potentially losing
- 23:25a lot of money. And I think it's important to
- 23:27note true on Burr Brower. They initially none
- 23:32of the fees were going to be permitted. So the
- 23:34initial response was that. the New York and California
- 23:39fees were all going to be forfeited by virtue
- 23:42of the UPL associated with California, but ultimately
- 23:45they went through and, you know, through an appeals
- 23:47process were able to get to their right to seek
- 23:51fees for the work that was done in New York.
- 23:52So I think Berber are really, it's kind of an
- 23:56old case now in 1998, but it stood the test of
- 24:00time. You know, it's definitely still standing
- 24:03for the propositions that we need to look at.
- 24:05when we're looking at whether or not you're at
- 24:07risk? Well, and I think also it was interesting
- 24:12to revered Burr Beerbrower because they made
- 24:19a note that the law firm or the California entity
- 24:31knew that they were retaining a firm, which was
- 24:38a New York firm, and which had no licensed attorneys
- 24:42in California. And they knew that at the time.
- 24:48So they benefited, I think, clearly by the situation.
- 24:57Yeah. Could have been strategic. It was a tech
- 25:00company, too, I believe, out of Silicon Valley.
- 25:03That's interesting. Yeah. All right. So the next
- 25:08case is interesting as well. And that is the
- 25:15estate of Condon case, which is cited. And in
- 25:19estate of Condon, it was a Colorado attorney
- 25:24who was rendering services to a trustee or an
- 25:30executor, co -executor. who resided as well in
- 25:37Colorado. And it dealt with a situation where
- 25:42there was a, I believe it was a buy sell agreement
- 25:46that was involved that the Colorado attorney
- 25:53had drafted and that needed to be addressed.
- 25:59in Colorado, because it involved property in
- 26:04Colorado as well. And in that case, and it was
- 26:10a probate case, the court held that the attorney,
- 26:17the Colorado attorney was entitled to reimbursement
- 26:21of his legal fees incurred, even though he was
- 26:26not practicing law. in California per se. And
- 26:36there was a special probate code section that
- 26:40was dealt with in that situation. But he did
- 26:45not come to California to provide any legal services.
- 26:54in connection with the probate case, and I think
- 26:58that that's a significant difference between
- 27:05that case, the Condon case, and the Berberhauer
- 27:11case. Would you agree with that? No, I do. Absolutely.
- 27:17I mean, this was all done, you know, and you
- 27:19can see it there. We have it there on the facts
- 27:21for you, but telephone facts and mail. So this
- 27:23was all done remotely as opposed to our New York
- 27:26firm member Brower, who was traveling back and
- 27:29forth. And I think even if I recall correctly,
- 27:31I think even at one point he came and stayed
- 27:33for a couple of weeks, even in Silicon Valley
- 27:36when they came over from New York. So, you know,
- 27:39definitely more than sufficient contacts there.
- 27:42And here, you know, this is much more attenuated,
- 27:46for lack of a better word. This is definitely
- 27:48much more remote. I think the other thing is,
- 27:54and you guys can see we have it there for you,
- 27:57but the client's location was highly relevant.
- 27:59So the client in this case was a Colorado client,
- 28:03sought out a local attorney, was dealing with
- 28:05things that were in California but also were
- 28:08in Colorado. So the client's location really
- 28:11impacted things. because the client, if the client
- 28:16was a California client and he had a California
- 28:19estate, then we would have 90%. I mean, you never
- 28:23know for sure. We would have to go through all
- 28:24the details, but we would likely have an issue
- 28:27with UPL and a 5 .5 violation, but because they
- 28:31were Colorado -based, both of them, and because
- 28:34he wasn't physically present, I think that that's
- 28:37significant. I agree. And also these are both
- 28:43Berber and Condon are 1998 decisions, and there
- 28:50is nothing since that time. So I think we can
- 28:54definitely look back at those for insight, if
- 29:01nothing else. I mean, the other thing about Condon
- 29:05is that when Condom was decided, they waited
- 29:10on the holding on Burr Brower. So both cases
- 29:14were kind of happening simultaneously. And if
- 29:18I recall correctly, I believe they stated that
- 29:21they were waiting on the holding on Burr Brower
- 29:23before making a final determination. I think
- 29:25they wanted to see what the authority was that
- 29:28came out of Burr Brower before they came down
- 29:30on Condom. So that was kind of interesting too.
- 29:35Next slide. OK, so you guys can see these are
- 29:45all the different rules of court. This is a very
- 29:48top line resource for you, but we wanted to kind
- 29:51of. let you know some of the authorized doorways
- 29:54for visiting California. So you can see Prohoc
- 29:58Vichy and that's 9 .40 to 9 .44 are different
- 30:03forms. So that's why we're not going 9 .414243.
- 30:08I should have put a dash there. Sorry, we didn't
- 30:09do that. But nonetheless, different approaches
- 30:13for Prohoc Vichy. So ways to come in by appearing
- 30:17in one case and associating with existing council
- 30:21hearings. California and if it's litigation driven
- 30:24I'm sure you guys realize then you need to get
- 30:27court permission so otherwise you need to set
- 30:30up and take a look at the rules and set up the
- 30:34appropriate documentation to confirm that you
- 30:36are truly pro -hoc VJ. We're going to talk about
- 30:38another case in a little bit. Wells where the
- 30:42woman thought that she had set up pro -hoc VJ
- 30:44properly and she hadn't so that'll be kind of
- 30:47an interesting corollary to this. And then there's
- 30:50other carve -outs here and you can see the rules
- 30:53are listed there for you but Legal aid attorneys,
- 30:56in -house counsel. So if you work for a company
- 31:00and they have offices here and you're traveling
- 31:02in and out, same thing with legal aid organizations.
- 31:06If you're temporarily here and we have a rule
- 31:08for litigation and for non -litigation for transactional
- 31:11type law. and 47 and 48 right there. But the
- 31:16key to remember about every single one of these
- 31:18is none of them exist for a person that's taking
- 31:21up residency here. So these are four visits for
- 31:25kind of a transitional sort of moment and not
- 31:28somebody that's actually setting up. a permanent
- 31:32residency or office or anything like that here
- 31:35in California these will not apply to you anymore.
- 31:38So take a look at the rules if any of them apply
- 31:41to you or if you're going to be traveling just
- 31:44keep yourself safe. So okay Jennifer anything
- 31:47you want to add on that? It's interesting because
- 31:51a lot of these rules, even the ones we didn't
- 31:55highlight, they have to deal with or they deal
- 31:58with the regulations in California for attorneys
- 32:05that are, let's say, military attorneys. you
- 32:10know, and different types of situations that
- 32:14exist. So in your spare time, you might want
- 32:19to take a look at these doorways, if you will,
- 32:24for the attorneys who are practicing in California,
- 32:28if there's any questions about the legitimacy
- 32:31of practice. Next slide. So if you're inbound
- 32:44coming to California, the question is that there
- 32:51are four questions that you need to look at.
- 32:53One is where is the client that you're providing
- 32:57the services to? Number two is whose law is it
- 33:03that applies? And this includes the jurisdiction
- 33:09where the attorney is, quote unquote, practicing
- 33:14law. And number three is how continuous is it?
- 33:21Is it just an attenuated situation or is this
- 33:26a more permanent situation? And do any of the
- 33:31doorways that we just went over apply? So those
- 33:39are the four questions, whether you're leaving
- 33:44California or you're coming into California that
- 33:49you need to take a look at. There's also an ABA
- 33:54opinion that we cited here, 495. It is not adopted
- 34:00in California. However, It does provide some
- 34:06interesting anecdotes such as you cannot, the
- 34:13guardrails, so to speak, are you cannot represent
- 34:20local coins. You can't hold yourself out as a
- 34:24lawyer in California. You cannot have any local
- 34:28office in California and you cannot engage in
- 34:32the practice of or the advertising that you are
- 34:37an attorney in California. So those are the four
- 34:45questions that you need to apply. As set forth
- 34:50in. So we have a hypothetical page. Did you want
- 34:58to add something? Yeah, could we go back just
- 35:011 sec? Suzanne, please. So 1 thing I want to
- 35:05say, thank you about the about the formal opinion.
- 35:08And you can see it right next to the section
- 35:12from the 5 .5 rule, which is our California rule
- 35:14right there. The presumption under the ABA rule
- 35:19is that if you're in a state that is following
- 35:21the ABA rules, if you stay within those four
- 35:25guardrails, you will avoid UPL issues. But in
- 35:28California, You can see if you look to the left,
- 35:32the lower left box, no resident office. We have
- 35:36no local office under the ABA. But the no systematic
- 35:39or continuous presence doesn't exist on the four
- 35:42guardrails site. So the ABA opinion isn't automatically.
- 35:47guarding against you having essentially your
- 35:50butt in the chair in that state. It's saying
- 35:53if you don't violate these four things that you
- 35:57could potentially avoid UPL issues and it doesn't
- 36:01address whether or not sitting in a chair in
- 36:04that state would create an issue all by itself.
- 36:07California says, if you sit in a chair in our
- 36:10state, any systematic or continuous presence,
- 36:12so for more than a week, then you could be having
- 36:17problems. So it's a different standard. So yeah,
- 36:21that's all I wanted to add. Thank you. So we
- 36:25have a hypothetical that we hope to be able to
- 36:28get through called the Scottsdale Summer. Okay,
- 36:37great. So in this hypothetical, Anna is a California
- 36:42attorney. She has a practice in Los Angeles.
- 36:48She goes with her spouse to Phoenix, Arizona
- 36:54for a one -year assignment that he has for work.
- 37:00For 12 months, she works there out of a rented
- 37:04house. Every client that she works with is a
- 37:09California client. Every matter that is governed
- 37:14by California law and every court appearance
- 37:18she makes is a California remote appearance in
- 37:23the Superior Court. She maintains her website
- 37:29as a Los Angeles office and on her letterhead.
- 37:35She has no Arizona client, no Arizona advertising,
- 37:39and no Arizona sign on the door, so to speak,
- 37:45of practicing, I'm practicing law here. So. The
- 37:51first question is, is Anna engaged in the unauthorized
- 37:55practice of law in Arizona? And as the individual
- 38:02who is there suggests, we don't know the answer
- 38:07to that question. But it is incumbent upon Anna
- 38:14to investigate and determine what is the law
- 38:20in terms of Arizona practice for the unauthorized
- 38:26practice of law. And until she knows the answer
- 38:30to that question, it could be that she is engaged
- 38:37in the unauthorized practice of law in Arizona
- 38:41at the time. It may not be. We just don't know.
- 38:46But it is something that should be checked before
- 38:51you go on any kind of extended type of stay outside
- 38:58the state of California. Yeah, and not to keep
- 39:04reiterating the same point, but I'm going to
- 39:05keep reiterating the same point. So if she gets
- 39:08in trouble in Arizona, she will also potentially
- 39:12get in trouble in California. So, you know, it's
- 39:15not like if she gets in trouble in Arizona, she
- 39:17can go, oh, I did EPL in Arizona. It doesn't
- 39:20matter that much because I'm licensed in California.
- 39:22I'm going home anyway. It doesn't matter. California
- 39:26that 5 .5 and you should read it carefully and
- 39:29know it well that 5 .5. it will become an issue.
- 39:33If Arizona says she can't be doing what she's
- 39:35doing, then California is gonna say, we honor
- 39:38what Arizona is saying here. You can't be doing
- 39:40what you're doing and you're gonna get in trouble
- 39:42in both states. And that's on the disciplinary
- 39:44level and then potentially on the criminal level
- 39:46as well, depending on the criminality of it.
- 39:49And we'll talk more about that in a little bit.
- 39:51So. I have had several cases. I would say within
- 39:57the last 10 years where on exactly this kind
- 40:01of situation occurred and the attorney was practicing
- 40:06in a different jurisdiction, different state,
- 40:11and California took, they, he was subject to
- 40:17disciplinary proceedings, investigations in both
- 40:22states, not just one. So there is a level of
- 40:27communication between the state bars on that
- 40:32issue. Let me ask you a question about that actually
- 40:35just I think this may interest everyone here
- 40:37as well but just you know for you know speaking
- 40:40to the remote practice piece does it change your
- 40:44analysis of that at all when you consider the
- 40:47attorney is maybe staying in Arizona, like let's
- 40:51say Anna's staying in Arizona, but she's only
- 40:53doing litigation work and she flies back for
- 40:56every single court appearance and she appears
- 40:58personally or drives back. Maybe she drives back,
- 41:01but nonetheless, she makes it physically back
- 41:04to California for every court appearance. Like,
- 41:06does that change your analysis of whether or
- 41:09not she's engaged in the unauthorized practice
- 41:11of law in California? You know, I don't think
- 41:15so because the question is, And we don't know
- 41:19the answer to this, is what does Arizona provide
- 41:24in terms of the unauthorized practice of law?
- 41:27And it's that jurisdiction that she may be making
- 41:32recommendations to her California clients, may
- 41:36hold meetings through Zoom, et cetera, to her
- 41:41California clients. It may be having communications
- 41:45with opposing counsel. you know, from Arizona.
- 41:49So it just depends on what Arizona provides in
- 41:55this instance. Yeah. And you can see, I mean,
- 41:59it can get, it can get really drilled down. Like,
- 42:01let's say she's strictly a trial counsel. You
- 42:03know what I mean? She's an outside litigator.
- 42:06So we can get very, very fact specific on it,
- 42:09you know, and certainly make arguments on both
- 42:11sides. Interesting. Okay. So next slide. Same
- 42:18fact pattern, but does California care? And I
- 42:23think we answered that already, is yes, California
- 42:27does care. And depending upon the situation here,
- 42:38Anna could be subject to a disciplinary investigation
- 42:41in California. for her activities in Arizona,
- 42:47assuming it was unauthorized in Arizona. Yeah,
- 42:53and I want to I want to call out to the practice
- 42:56point at the bottom you guys check the destination
- 42:59state before the lease not after So if you are
- 43:03going to be making a move like this, just you
- 43:05know Do your legwork beforehand don't get yourself
- 43:07into a situation where you're committed or obligated
- 43:10to something and then you find yourself having
- 43:12to either back out or Kind of take your chances,
- 43:16which is by the way, never a best practices sort
- 43:19of tip. So yeah So the next slide is, does anything
- 43:25change if Hannah takes one Arizona client? And
- 43:32again, she's not licensed in Arizona. So I don't
- 43:39think she can take an Arizona client and she
- 43:44can't hold herself out by telling people that
- 43:49she is an attorney. if that representation could
- 43:54be construed as one which is licensed practice
- 44:01in the state, you just can't do both. So it's
- 44:09a question of, again, what does the Arizona provide
- 44:17in terms of the unauthorized practice of law
- 44:21on both accounts. And I moved to the next slide
- 44:25because it is possible. That question, it is
- 44:33possible that she is holding herself out as an
- 44:39attorney in that state, especially if it's a
- 44:43country club in Arizona. This is the live bio
- 44:50mission I was talking about, right? So when she
- 44:54says she's a lawyer, there's going to be a natural
- 44:56presumption. You know, people think of the world
- 44:59around them. Like they're more immediate space.
- 45:01If she's talking to her friends at a country
- 45:03club, they're going to assume that she's an Arizona
- 45:06lawyer. Why wouldn't they? Unless she expressly
- 45:09tells them otherwise. Exactly. Exactly. Next
- 45:14slide. Do you want to handle this one page? Sure.
- 45:18Hold on just a minute. This is just basically
- 45:24the fact that the license your license your bar
- 45:27license doesn't travel with you And I think we've
- 45:30kind of touched this quite a bit But appearing
- 45:33in another state, you know, whether it's physical
- 45:35or remote it doesn't change anything. So Here
- 45:39today we're talking about remote practice in
- 45:42UPL So you're looking at if you were to travel
- 45:45remotely via court call or via zoom and make
- 45:48an appearance in that court You still would need
- 45:51to be admitted Prohac Vichay there, presuming
- 45:55that the state requires that. So again, this
- 45:57is a case of making sure that you know that local
- 46:00states rules and that you abide by them. So make
- 46:03sure that you do that and avoid discipline there
- 46:05as well as here in California, which would be.
- 46:08basically derivative discipline coming from what's
- 46:11going on there. The same thing applies when you're
- 46:14looking at things like depositions. You need
- 46:17to be thinking about where everybody's sitting,
- 46:19even if everybody's attending via Zoom, and make
- 46:22sure that what you're doing is appropriate. So
- 46:25it's not so much where you're sitting, it's where
- 46:27are they, and what are the rules where they are,
- 46:31right? So this all, the theme that you're going
- 46:34to, excuse me. the thing that you're going to
- 46:36hear very often over and over and over is going
- 46:39to be check their rules check their rules because
- 46:42that's really the most important thing that you
- 46:44can do if you're talking about practicing in
- 46:47somewhere other than California and then arbitration
- 46:51you can see there as well and then to the right
- 46:54here we're talking about Formal Opinion 495,
- 46:58the ABA opinion that we referenced earlier with
- 47:01the four guardrails that we were talking about.
- 47:03So here's what you don't get from it. OK, so
- 47:07if you look at the scope of the opinion, you
- 47:09can practice your own jurisdictions law while
- 47:12you're physically elsewhere under the ABA opinion.
- 47:15Okay. It depends on that state whether or not
- 47:18they've adopted this ABA opinion. And remember,
- 47:22these opinions are persuasive and informative,
- 47:24but not binding. So make sure to check the rules.
- 47:27I told you I was going to keep saying that. Advising
- 47:30on another state's law, same exact issue. Okay.
- 47:35That becomes that state's UPL question. and the
- 47:38federal exceptions we've talked about a little
- 47:41bit. So those are things like the military lawyers
- 47:44and things like that. However, you are still
- 47:47going to have to do your diligence in terms of
- 47:50understanding your pro -hoc VHA obligations and
- 47:53making sure that you do whatever you need to
- 47:54do to not violate where you are. Even if you're
- 47:57in federal court, you still need to make sure
- 47:59that you're not violating. And I mentioned a
- 48:03matter of wells a little bit, a little bit ago,
- 48:05and I'll mention it again here, because she is
- 48:09doing some, I believe it was Title VII work,
- 48:12and so it was federal work, but she also accidentally
- 48:16stepped into doing some state advising because
- 48:20she was referencing state statutes as well. And
- 48:22the minute that she did that, now she's technically
- 48:25practicing in the state. So, and we'll talk about
- 48:27that more again in a little bit, but You know,
- 48:30this is where even the federal exception, even
- 48:33if you were able to fully clear that hurdle,
- 48:36the fact of the matter is there are still little
- 48:37nuances that are going to attach to it just kind
- 48:40of naturally by virtue of advocacy. So before
- 48:43you calendar anything, before you make a plan
- 48:46to make an appearance, make sure you confirm
- 48:48what you need to do and make sure you're complying
- 48:53with that state's rules. So that's kind of a
- 48:56best practices slide there for you. OK. Let me
- 48:59just add, I think that when you're dealing with
- 49:04an arbitration, you need to also check that organizations
- 49:10wherever the arbitration is being held, whether
- 49:14it's through Jams or ADR or the AAA, you need
- 49:20to check those authorities to determine whether
- 49:24or not a certificate is needed. and what the
- 49:30level of your ability to represent the party
- 49:34in that arbitration is. So. Perfect. OK, next
- 49:47slide, please. OK, so this is the case I keep
- 49:52talking about. So we arrived at it in the matter
- 49:56of well. So you can see the facts there on the
- 49:58left. And it's kind of an interesting case if
- 50:00you go and read it, which I encourage you to
- 50:03do if you're interested in this. This affects
- 50:05all of us. Whether you're an existing lawyer
- 50:08or aspiring lawyer, understanding UPL and how
- 50:11to avoid it is significant. And I do I will say
- 50:15I do a lot of more character applications in
- 50:18my ethics practice. That's kind of my favorite
- 50:20pocket. And what I see quite often is issues
- 50:24with the appeal arising with people that are
- 50:26just about to be lawyers. So they don't quite
- 50:30know the rules yet. So this is this is important.
- 50:32So if you're an aspiring lawyer, if you're a
- 50:34law student or recent grad and you're looking
- 50:36or if you're a lateral attorney, you know, those
- 50:39are those are important things to know. Okay,
- 50:42so in this case, it's a California licensee and
- 50:45she had been licensed for a long time and she
- 50:47moved to South Carolina and she represented at
- 50:50least nine local clients there over several years.
- 50:54She was married, she traveled over there and
- 50:56she did what she did. And on her letterhead,
- 50:59she never disclosed she wasn't licensed in South
- 51:01Carolina. So there's that omission thing that
- 51:03I keep harkening back to. She needed to say that
- 51:07she was licensed only in California and she should
- 51:10have that as an asterisk somewhere on her letterhead
- 51:13it should be on her website on her business card
- 51:15wherever else she needs to be very expressed
- 51:17it should be in her signature block we communicate
- 51:20all of us so much by email and those are things
- 51:23that you would never want there to be a question
- 51:26that you are not holding yourself out and the
- 51:28way you avoid that is by being very clear with
- 51:31what you're doing anyway UPL is in South Carolina
- 51:35is a felony So that's significant. So clearly
- 51:41I think it's almost what we would consider per
- 51:43se UPL, right? She's in South Carolina. She knows
- 51:47she's not licensed in South Carolina. She represents
- 51:50clients nonetheless while she's there. And what's
- 51:55really wild if you look at this case is that
- 51:58she moved back to California. She got divorced,
- 52:01moved back to California. I want to see, 2001?
- 52:05I'm not sure she moved back to California and
- 52:08a year after she moved back is when the state
- 52:11bar complaint came down. So it's kind of wild
- 52:14because all this time in South Carolina she was
- 52:16getting away with it and she was doing it and
- 52:19you know and then she came back and California
- 52:22brought the hammer down. So Okay, where she went
- 52:25wrong. You guys can see that right you know she
- 52:29served local residents, she let them believe
- 52:31she could so she was holding out. She was providing
- 52:34illegal services when she wasn't entitled to
- 52:36do so either one of those things by itself. could
- 52:39get her unauthorized practice of law violations.
- 52:42However, together, they're kind of textbook.
- 52:45So there's the rule for you to look at 7 .1,
- 52:48disclosing the limits of your license. So that's
- 52:51kind of to what I was just talking about, about
- 52:52putting it on your letterhead, on your signature
- 52:55block, wherever you have your public facing profile.
- 52:59And in California, and this is not an advertising
- 53:02CLE, but just worth mentioning, you need to have
- 53:06your address. And one of the reasons you need
- 53:08to have your address is because it makes it clear
- 53:11that we have a local office. So if she had had
- 53:14an appropriate address, like a California address,
- 53:17and not a South Carolina address, maybe she would
- 53:19have had at least a little argument to make that
- 53:22she didn't understand she had to be explicit
- 53:24about it, but that she was genuine about the
- 53:26information she was providing. She didn't do
- 53:28any of that. So the California. Oh, I'm sorry.
- 53:32Go ahead. And I think what's important here is
- 53:34that Rule 7 .1 talks about, it says specifically,
- 53:41a lawyer shall not make a false or misleading
- 53:45communication about the lawyer or the lawyer
- 53:49services. And so that's important because it's
- 53:55pretty broad. in terms of the statement, but
- 53:59it also says a communication is false or misleading
- 54:03if it contains a material representation of fact
- 54:08or law or admits a fact necessary to make a communication
- 54:14considered as a whole not materially misleading.
- 54:19So I think that's very important. and if you
- 54:23haven't checked out the rules of professional
- 54:26conduct in California, I always recommend that
- 54:30you do, again, in your leisure, but read them
- 54:37because a lot of times they provide information
- 54:43that is enlightening. Yeah, yeah, so I think
- 54:52it's a little light reading for bedtime. The
- 54:56California hook, you guys, is down there. California
- 54:59disciplined Ms. Wells, and they gave her a two
- 55:05-year state suspension with the first six months
- 55:07to be an actual suspension. And then she had
- 55:09the two -year probation that went on top of that.
- 55:12So, you know, basically the way that that plays
- 55:14is she gets six months actual, and then she's
- 55:17on probation for the other year and a half. And
- 55:20should she have any issues if she violates her
- 55:22probation in any way? And by the way, probation
- 55:26violation can be something as little as filing
- 55:28a report late, telling them what you've been
- 55:30up to, because you have to file reports on a
- 55:34specific schedule. But if she has any probation
- 55:37violation, it could potentially trigger that
- 55:39state suspension to become an actual suspension.
- 55:42And then she could have ended up with a two -year
- 55:43actual. So with that being said, she ended up
- 55:48with six months which doesn't feel terrible to
- 55:50me, all things considered. I feel like they were
- 55:53reasonably light. And you can see this was under
- 55:56form over 1300B, which is our 5 .5A1 today. Because
- 56:02this case is significantly older, I wonder if
- 56:05she wouldn't get harsher discipline today. Because
- 56:09that just doesn't feel like very much to me,
- 56:12all things considered. Anyway. South Carolina
- 56:16didn't proceed against her for the UPL because
- 56:18California took her for the UPL and she's not
- 56:20a South Carolina license anyway, and I'm sure
- 56:22she would never get one. So she's good that way.
- 56:25And then the thing, the thing that I wanted to
- 56:27mention too, is that I put right there for UPL
- 56:31in South Carolina is a felony. So I did some
- 56:36research I was not able to find and it's possible
- 56:39that I that I missed it because I'm not extremely
- 56:42familiar South Carolina But I was not able to
- 56:44find any record that she was prosecuted for it,
- 56:46which I thought was pretty interesting Because
- 56:49I didn't find any criminal records for it, but
- 56:51the case is there for you guys I made it nice
- 56:55and well We sorry made it nice and big and blue
- 56:58and easy read so you could go check it out because
- 57:00I think it's definitely a case worth reading
- 57:02It's pretty interesting. She also Side note,
- 57:05she also had a bunch of other violations. She
- 57:08had a prior discipline matter for a trust account
- 57:10violation. And then there were other allegations
- 57:13of failure to cooperate and lack of candor and
- 57:15trust account violations here. So there were
- 57:18a lot of things that were charged against her
- 57:20in the notice of disciplinary charges with the
- 57:22state bar. It wasn't just what you're seeing
- 57:24here on the slide. This is just what's really
- 57:26relevant for our perspective. But it is worth
- 57:29noting that there were a lot of other things.
- 57:31But then the other thing that made her fact pattern
- 57:34particularly interesting is, as I said, she did
- 57:37federal law, and her position was that it was
- 57:42permissible for her to be doing what she was
- 57:43doing because she was practicing in federal law,
- 57:46she was doing Title VII stuff. And then on one
- 57:48case where she did not where she wasn't just
- 57:52doing federal law, she joined Prohoc Vichy and
- 57:56she has a document to that effect with another
- 57:59council that was there in South Carolina. And
- 58:02so she thought she was clearing her hurdles.
- 58:03She genuinely thought. that she was doing what
- 58:06she needed to be doing, which makes her a great
- 58:08cautionary tale because she wasn't completely
- 58:11ignoring it. On its face with these facts as
- 58:14we wrote them, I could have put a laughing emoji
- 58:16in the middle of the screen and you guys would
- 58:17have thought it was appropriate. But in reality,
- 58:20if you look at her facts, she didn't completely
- 58:23ignore it. She thought she was paying attention.
- 58:26But as I mentioned earlier, in her federal in
- 58:30her federal stuff that she was doing, she made
- 58:33reference to state statutes. She was leaning
- 58:35into state law, and she was making advocacy arguments
- 58:38that related to the state of South Carolina.
- 58:42And so that's where her issue came from. But
- 58:45it's a pretty interesting read. So I definitely
- 58:47would say, in addition to the rules that Jennifer
- 58:50recommended for your bedtime reading, I'm going
- 58:51to add this. You should check it out. Well, and
- 58:55also, I think Paige raised an important point,
- 58:58which is this case was a number of years ago,
- 59:0411 years ago or more. So that is before the time
- 59:14that California adopted a different mission in
- 59:20terms of its state bar. prosecutions, investigations,
- 59:25et cetera. So I think had this case come up currently,
- 59:32we could have been seeing a different result.
- 59:37Like a more severe type, longer suspension or
- 59:40disbarment even. Especially if you guys read
- 59:44the NDC, like the amount of charges are crazy.
- 59:48Thank you. We're going to wrap this up with the
- 59:52next slide, because we're already up against
- 59:56a time frame. And this is meant to scare anyone.
- 1:00:03But if you do engage in the unauthorized practice
- 1:00:10of law, you are subject to a misdemeanor, which
- 1:00:16is a criminal. prosecution. That doesn't mean
- 1:00:20that the DA or, you know, city prosecutor is
- 1:00:24going to race out and file that against you,
- 1:00:27but it's something just to keep back in the recesses
- 1:00:32of your mind. You can also be held in contempt.
- 1:00:38You can engage in services for no fees. under
- 1:00:46Bear Brower. And you can also be disciplined
- 1:00:49by the state bar, not just California, but any
- 1:00:54other jurisdiction where you're going. So it
- 1:00:59looks like we are past the time. I don't know
- 1:01:03that we have time to... Let's comment on these
- 1:01:08really quick. The thing is, and we knew that
- 1:01:12this is a pretty dense topic, so there's actually
- 1:01:15a lot more to say. And if you guys can believe
- 1:01:17we cut the slide deck down. by about 15 slides
- 1:01:20last night. And I spent hours like, OK, this
- 1:01:24is way too long and too much. So just to let
- 1:01:27you know, guys, there are more resources here.
- 1:01:31There's a little bit more to look at. Key takeaways
- 1:01:34that we recommend that you check out, as well
- 1:01:36as the authority. So since we don't have time
- 1:01:38to run through all of them with you, just want
- 1:01:41to let you know that they're there for you. And
- 1:01:44Jennifer and I are here for you. So if you have
- 1:01:46any questions, of course, please reach out. Yes,
- 1:01:49definitely. And unfortunately, we're against
- 1:01:53our time. So I'm not sure where we stand with
- 1:01:59questions and answers. Let's go to Suzanne. Could
- 1:02:06we go to the last slide, please, like the end
- 1:02:09of the deck, just so they can have contact information?
- 1:02:14Next slide. There's us since we are out of time
- 1:02:19in case you want to get all of either of us and
- 1:02:21ask any questions. Thank you so much for the
- 1:02:23hour. It looks like Jennifer and I would have
- 1:02:25done well with 2. So. Yeah, thank you. Thank
- 1:02:29you. Thank you so much. This concludes today's
- 1:02:33presentation. Thank you so much Jennifer and
- 1:02:35page for an excellent presentation today and
- 1:02:37thank you so much to our audience for joining
- 1:02:39us. Have a great day. Everybody.