Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #No 53🎙️ Public Inquiry Shell Companies - Week 4 Day 2
Transcript
- 0:03The day started with a conflict of interest flagged by Patrick
- 0:07Haughey in relation to Mr. Alvin and landmark chamber. Mr. Alvin
- 0:12being counsel for dfi. I hadn't a clue what landmark chambers
- 0:17were when I asked Google what landmark chambers were in
- 0:21Northern Ireland. This is what it described. Landmark chambers
- 0:25is a top tier UK barristers set specialising in planning,
- 0:30property, Public Law, environmental law, with members
- 0:35working on significant projects in Northern Ireland, such as the
- 0:41north south Ireland interconnector, known for
- 0:45expertise in high profile judicial reviews, infrastructure
- 0:51development and land disputes. They operate across the UK and
- 0:56internationally. As an aside, it's amazing the extra knowledge
- 1:01I'm gaining as a result of this process. Every day I learn
- 1:06something new. How useful it will be for me going forward?
- 1:11Well, that's a question not to divert. Apparently, Elvin had
- 1:18access to documents which may have been prejudicial to
- 1:22proceedings. However, this was strongly refuted by Mr. Byas
- 1:28counsel for nie Deira, as he explained that all barristers
- 1:34were self employed and independent members of chambers,
- 1:38that there was no conflict of interest unless barristers were
- 1:43involved on both sides. So that put that one to rest for now.
- 1:50This was then followed by a long discussion about the
- 1:53relationship of Wheaton with Delray and gold, which was a
- 1:57follow on from conversation yesterday, and this is what I
- 2:01believe I heard some years ago when dalradian were in financial
- 2:05difficulty, Wheaton gave a loan of 75 million to delraydion.
- 2:12Under close scrutiny, it was revealed that Wheaton now owns
- 2:16everything belonging to dalradian Except the name, all
- 2:20rights, assets, land, plant and machinery authorization,
- 2:25production, insurance, licences, investment on capital and so on
- 2:31and so on, really like a holding company for Delaware in making
- 2:36it effectively a shell company and for this 75 million loan
- 2:43delrayden gave Wheaton for the life of the mine, which is which
- 2:47means, for the length of time that the mine is operating, a
- 2:52slice of future gold value, where it was agreed that Wheaton
- 2:57can purchase from delrayden An amount of refined gold equal to
- 3:02payable gold, so that means they're able to buy gold at a
- 3:06reduced rate when it goes to market. It should be noted that
- 3:13the land alone that delraydian stroke Wheaton has would be
- 3:17worth about one 20 million or maybe more. So certainly the
- 3:23plant and machinery would be far more, maybe two or 300,000,001
- 3:28has to wonder how Wheaton got such a sweet deal. There are
- 3:33easier methods to raise 75 million to fund an operation
- 3:38without giving away the crown jewels. I There were a number of
- 3:43other probing questions, such as the whereabouts of the 620,000
- 3:49received from the bulk sample, also supplementary to the known
- 3:574% royalty payable to the crown a separate royalty agree
- 4:04agreement surfaced dated 13 December 2004 and states that a
- 4:112% smelter return royalty is payable by dollar alien gold to
- 4:18Minco, another subsidiary in one would imagine at this point that
- 4:25have you, if you had paid a royalty to a smelter, and there
- 4:28are only about five or six in the world, you would know where
- 4:32you were going to process the gold, as it will be going to the
- 4:36smelter Where the royalty has been paid. Apparently, not. We
- 4:42still don't know where the gold has been processed. I wonder why
- 4:49it has been withheld. The question is, how and where have
- 4:56all these considerable costs been factored into the
- 4:59Dalrymple. In economic modelling that nobody has seen and what
- 5:05checks were in place to protect all the public funding delrayden
- 5:09has received, to date, direct grants from Invest NI and DOE
- 5:16linked projects, 336,000 police escorts written off 437 610,000
- 5:27and other public environmental schemes, 25,000, and if dal
- 5:35radian is now only a shell company without assets, what
- 5:39happens to workers if they suddenly close down, who
- 5:43compensates the employees, who maintains the mining waste,
- 5:48tailing stump, who's responsible for the clean up, who pays for
- 5:54it? As they say, follow the money, and there's the story.
- 6:01Finally, the DFI economic department was asked directly,
- 6:07was there a forensic accountant hired when the proposal was
- 6:11presented to them? The answer was a flat No, despite us
- 6:16hearing just yesterday that they did not possess the expertise to
- 6:22thoroughly scrutinise an economic proposal such as this,
- 6:27basically it was above their pay grade. There's a nice thing in
- 6:32the tale to this story. Wheaton's loan has to be paid
- 6:36back before any taxes are paid from profits, and no other loans
- 6:42can be taken out without wheaton's consent. I feel it'll
- 6:47be a long time before any taxes materialise here in Northern
- 6:51Ireland, there's a lot more detail to this story around the
- 6:57price of gold will be sold, which is 18% of the spot price
- 7:01on the day and how this impacts taxes received. Read the detail
- 7:07on the don't minus website, but this gives you some flavour of
- 7:12the direction of travel today. One of the questions the
- 7:19Commission asked was how the aspirations to employ unemployed
- 7:24people will be realised. And Conor Fagan, counsel for fodc,
- 7:30commented that the draft plan as presented by the applicant, was
- 7:35vague and high level. He also didn't think it was enforceable.
- 7:42He asked where the real financial commitments were, in
- 7:47contrast to lofty promises that were short on detail, He also
- 7:53noted that there were contractual arrangements to be
- 7:56in place before any employment was offered. I think Mr.
- 8:03Burgess, the expert for the economic detail for fodc,
- 8:08commented that he had not seen the employment plan, genuinely
- 8:15not realising that the draft plan was the plan which speaks
- 8:20for itself. He wrapped up with the remark that it was creative
- 8:27accounting. He was not impressed. There was a lot
- 8:32today, and I'm going to wrap it up now, as it's almost 1145 and
- 8:38we were back again tomorrow. But before I go, there were some
- 8:43heated moments stemming from pure frustration, and from this
- 8:49came deeply moving human responses. And here are just two
- 8:54saying of the day has to go to Cormac mclear When he spoke to
- 8:58the Commission about what the barristers and they're in
- 9:02entourage don't realise that this whole process is about the
- 9:07people. It really affects the people here. Day after day, lay
- 9:14people with a conscience. This was later followed up by Mary
- 9:19Brawley, who said, the people in this room are the people
- 9:24affected by this application, lay people with a conscience, as
- 9:29Cormac had already described, who have had direct experience
- 9:33of the applicant. They're not professional experts such as
- 9:40those to the right of the room, and they have turned up every
- 9:44day despite the lack of respect shown by DFI and dal raid in
- 9:49this application before the PAC and therefore they deserve
- 9:54respect. Likewise, you the commissioner. Have rolled your
- 10:00eyes on occasions in frustration, and this is our
- 10:04objectors way of expressing frustration, and we would be
- 10:09obliged for your patience. I think the clangour of the day
- 10:15was when lindo Sullivan asked the question about whether there
- 10:19had been account taken in the Phantom economic model of the
- 10:24probable unification of Ireland within the next 25 years, and
- 10:29what the tax implications will be for the Republic of Ireland.
- 10:34I believe Mr. Beatty's outright denial of the possibility of
- 10:39Irish unification was his rebuttal to this query, which
- 10:44wouldn't make good headlines, but he would say that, wouldn't
- 10:48he being from county England, see you all tomorrow. You.