Latest / The Vegan Report / The End of Factory Farming!? With Bruce Friedrich | Ep. 109
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report, my name is Ryan
- 0:03and do you think ending factory farming is possible?
- 0:08If yes, what form of activism do you believe
- 0:12will stop factory farming for good? Institutional
- 0:16change? Street protests? Legal reforms? Well,
- 0:22our guest today, Bruce Friedrich, founder of
- 0:24the Good Food Institute, thinks ending factory
- 0:28farming is possible. But activism is not the
- 0:32answer. For him, the solution to this issue is
- 0:36cultivated meat, the perfect replacement for
- 0:39regular meat because it would taste the same,
- 0:43cost the same, but with no health risks, no environmental
- 0:47damage, and certainly no animal suffering. He
- 0:52recently published a book titled Meat. How the
- 0:55next agricultural revolution will transform humanity's
- 0:59favorite food and our future, which details his
- 1:03proposition and gives us a behind the scenes
- 1:06look into a much talked about industry. I highly
- 1:11recommend the book. You can order it now by following
- 1:14the link in the episode notes. And in this episode,
- 1:19we discussed the new MEK veggie. that has launched
- 1:22in Canada, the consolidation of power in the
- 1:26hands of a few big food corporations, the Campbell's
- 1:31Soup 3D printed lab -grown chicken debacle, and
- 1:35the opposition to cultivated meat by some animal
- 1:39advocates. Many of them have appeared on the
- 1:43show. I will add links in the description to
- 1:46all those episodes, including an amazing debate
- 1:50hosted by United Poultry Concerns featuring Bruce
- 1:54himself. For more thought provoking episodes,
- 1:58follow the show, share the podcast with the vegans
- 2:01you know, leave a good review. I greatly appreciate
- 2:05your support. Thank you. So let me start with
- 2:10this plant based meat alternatives are not doing
- 2:15very well. And right now I'm thinking about a
- 2:19product I really like a brand I really like,
- 2:22which is Beyond Meat. You know, their stocks
- 2:25are in the garbage. When I go grocery shopping
- 2:30for Beyond Meat products, I find them in the
- 2:34plant based aisle, which I think was not the
- 2:37goal at first, you know, we wanted them. with
- 2:41the other meat products. Here in Canada, where
- 2:45I am, there are so many, you know, B2B partnerships
- 2:49that just went nowhere. They had their breakfast
- 2:54sausages with Tim Harden's that lasted for a
- 2:58few years, no, few months. What lasted for a
- 3:02few years was their partnership with ANW. Now,
- 3:05ANW has a their own in -house, you know, patty
- 3:11option. And, you know, when I look at that, when
- 3:15I look at, you know, how unsuccessful they were,
- 3:20I worry about, you know, the prospects of cultivated
- 3:25meat. So I guess my first question for you is,
- 3:30how do you explain the recent failure of plant
- 3:35-based meat products? Yeah, I mean, I dive into
- 3:39this in the book, especially in chapter seven,
- 3:43which is specifically about plant -based meat.
- 3:46And the theory of change is not that people are
- 3:51going to pay more for products that they don't
- 3:53like as much, which is what's required for the
- 3:58current products, almost all of them, to succeed.
- 4:03When Nectar, which is a project of food system
- 4:05innovations, when Nectar, N -E -C -T -A -R, last
- 4:11year tested 124 plant -based products. They found
- 4:17six that most meat -eaters liked as much as meat.
- 4:22And even those six products still, when you actually
- 4:27did the calculations, were not at, if 1 .0 is
- 4:31taste parity with meat, they did not reach 1
- 4:34.0, but they came close. and the Beyond Burger
- 4:38was one of those products. I think four of them
- 4:40were impossible products. And all of those products
- 4:44cost significantly more. So the plant -based
- 4:47beef costs about twice as much at retail, and
- 4:52the plant -based chicken and pork cost even more
- 4:56than twice as much at retail. So if you look
- 5:00at the history of really every innovation, it
- 5:04takes time for the products to get better, and
- 5:08it takes time for the products to come down in
- 5:11cost. And it is when the products get better
- 5:14and come down in cost that they have the capacity
- 5:17to really succeed. So as a couple of examples,
- 5:21and I have a whole bunch of examples in chapter
- 5:23eight of the book, but at the turn of the last
- 5:27century, so circa 1900, between 1900 and 1910,
- 5:32more than 500 car companies failed, including
- 5:36Henry Ford's first car company. And that was
- 5:40because the cars were hard to start. They broke
- 5:44down a lot and they were too expensive. And the
- 5:48Model T was launched in 1908. It was the first
- 5:51car that was not hard to start. It was the first
- 5:54car that was relatively easy to operate and wasn't
- 5:58constantly breaking down. and it came down in
- 6:02price by, it was a third the price that it launched
- 6:06at after about five or six years. And so 500
- 6:11car company failures didn't mean that cars were
- 6:14not long for this world. It meant that they needed
- 6:17to come down in price and they needed to get
- 6:19better. Flash forward 100 years from that to
- 6:23the turn of the last century. And we have the
- 6:26dot com bubble where the NASDAQ dropped by 80%,
- 6:31literally trillions of dollars. Amazon fell from
- 6:35$213 to less than six. So 97 % drop in value.
- 6:41Most dot coms, most internet commerce companies
- 6:44went out of business, including famously pets
- 6:47.com. And the commentary was brutal. Whoever
- 6:54thought somebody would want to buy pet supplies
- 6:56online? when is this Jeff Bezos character ever
- 7:01gonna turn a profit? And here we are, just 26
- 7:07years later, and Chewy, the replacement for pets
- 7:11.com, has a valuation north of $13 billion, which
- 7:16is more than 30 times the maximum value that
- 7:21pets .com ever got to, $400 million. And I'm
- 7:25pretty sure I haven't looked recently, but I
- 7:27think Amazon is doing OK. So it is just the nature
- 7:31of innovation that a lot of companies fail and
- 7:36that the products need to get better and the
- 7:39products need to come down in price. And so the
- 7:42book is really focused on making the case that
- 7:46although we don't have products that are price
- 7:49and taste competitive now, we also have not tried
- 7:53very hard. And it's an optimistic case that I
- 7:57believe we can get there if we bring the will
- 8:00and I talk about how I think we can make that
- 8:02happen. Yeah, let's get into that. You know,
- 8:06how do you define the price and taste parity?
- 8:11You know, because if I think about the price
- 8:13aspect of it, you know, meat prices fluctuate.
- 8:18And so what is that, you know, fixed definition
- 8:22of a Parity, what is the goal that we want to
- 8:26reach? And how do we measure that exactly? When
- 8:28somebody goes to the grocery store or is ordering
- 8:31off a menu, the products need to be indistinguishable
- 8:35or better. Right now, nothing is indistinguishable
- 8:39or better on a plant -based side, and they need
- 8:42to cost less. So because the products require
- 8:47so many fewer resources, the things that give
- 8:51these products significant benefits from an environmental
- 8:54standpoint and from a global hunger and malnutrition
- 8:58standpoint, the fact that they are so much more
- 9:00efficient also mean that as they scale up, prices
- 9:04will come down and they will end up significantly
- 9:09less expensive than what they're replacing. In
- 9:12the same way that renewable energy has been coming
- 9:16down and EV battery costs have been coming down,
- 9:20And they're not going to stop at parity with
- 9:23conventional. They will continue to fall. At
- 9:26some point, it will level out. But there's not
- 9:31any indication on the solar side that we're close
- 9:34to that leveling out. There's something called
- 9:36Wright's law, which says for every doubling of
- 9:40capacity, costs fall by a consistent amount.
- 9:44For solar, and I think also for EV batteries,
- 9:47that's every doubling of capacity costs fall
- 9:49by about 20%. We don't know what that is yet
- 9:53for plant -based and cultivated meat, but we
- 9:56do know that Musa Meat, the company that created
- 10:00the 250 ,000 euro burger back in 2013, their
- 10:06costs are down by a factor of 100 ,000. So their
- 10:09costs are down in less than 13 years by 99 .999%.
- 10:17And costs are going to continue to fall and they
- 10:21should go well below the costs of conventional
- 10:24meat because the products require so many fewer
- 10:27resources. The plant -based products require
- 10:30something like a ninth the resources and the
- 10:33cultivated products require something like a
- 10:35third the resources and they also have fewer
- 10:38stages of production. So as production scales
- 10:43and as the ingredient manufacturing ramps up
- 10:48and catches up with demand, the prices will fall.
- 10:52Well, let's say, you know, we achieve that parity
- 10:58of taste and price. Then, you know, what does
- 11:04it mean for let's start with meat consumption?
- 11:09You know, let's say a year later, you're probably
- 11:12going to go out shopping for a car. and you will
- 11:17buy one car. You will either buy an electric
- 11:20vehicle or you'll buy a gas powered vehicle.
- 11:24In the same way, people will go out and buy burgers
- 11:29or they'll buy whatever it is that they're buying.
- 11:33And the plant -based products or the cultivated
- 11:36products will be healthier, less likely to have
- 11:40bacterial contamination, less likely to have
- 11:43drug residues, and they will be identical in
- 11:47taste or better eventually, and they will cost
- 11:51the same or less. And so many consumers will
- 11:56select the plant -based products or the cultivated
- 11:59products instead. And over time, as the concept
- 12:03of plant -based meat and cultivated meat are
- 12:05socialized, there will be a steady more and more
- 12:10replacement. Do you have a timeline in mind of,
- 12:14you know, how long would it take for those meat
- 12:17products to be mostly or maybe entirely replaced?
- 12:24Well, I mean, it's going to require getting to
- 12:26price and taste parity. And so we'll get to price
- 12:29and taste parity for burgers, at which point
- 12:33ground beef, plant based or cultivated beef,
- 12:36whichever gets there first. will shoot up the
- 12:38S curve of adoption to whatever point is the
- 12:43substitution rate. For cultivated meat, I think
- 12:45it will get very, very high, 95 % or more. For
- 12:52plant -based, it's a lot harder to know how many
- 12:57people are going to prefer animal -based beef
- 12:59to plant -based beef, even though the plant -based
- 13:02beef will have less fat, less saturated fat,
- 13:05some fiber. more protein. It's a healthier product,
- 13:09but there will certainly be some people who just
- 13:12really want animal meat. And my guess is probably
- 13:1740 to 65, 70 % will go for the plant -based if
- 13:22that's the product that gets there first. If
- 13:25we have price parity and taste parity for both
- 13:27plant -based and cultivated beef. So you've got
- 13:29plant -based beef, cultivated beef, and conventional
- 13:32beef. It'll be really interesting to see what
- 13:35the split is between plant -based and cultivated.
- 13:38And there are hypotheses that there will be people
- 13:41like Michael Pollan and Alice Waters who want
- 13:44animal -based beef, but it will be regenerative,
- 13:48grass -fed, high -welfare alternatives. And then
- 13:53also people like Joe Rogan and RFK Jr. probably
- 13:58in that same boat. But once we have plant -based
- 14:02and cultivated products at price and taste parity,
- 14:06I don't think there will be an incentive for
- 14:09the meat industry itself to continue to raise
- 14:14animals in factory farming conditions. I want
- 14:18to go back to the Joe Rogan and RFK people of
- 14:22this world. It deeply fascinates me, you know,
- 14:26their reaction to cultivated meat. But, you know,
- 14:30first, the impact of cultivated meat success
- 14:34on plant -based meat. I feel like if cultivated
- 14:39meat arrives at parity first and has that level
- 14:46of success, then people will just stop purchasing
- 14:52plant -based options. I think I would do that
- 14:57as a consumer. I think I would prefer uh, the
- 15:02best option, um, the one that has parody and
- 15:05I don't care, you know, if it's plant -based
- 15:07or, um, you know, the, the real thing, um, at
- 15:11that point, um, because what I'm looking for
- 15:14is, you know, that level of protein and also
- 15:18that taste. So have you thought of, you know,
- 15:23maybe how cultivated meat might have, you know,
- 15:26a negative impact on the cells of plant -based
- 15:29meat? That's interesting. I mean, when you ask
- 15:35people why they're eating plant -based meat,
- 15:36despite the fact that it costs more and doesn't
- 15:39taste as good, people say they're eating it for
- 15:41the health benefits. My hunch is that plant -based
- 15:47meat already is healthier than animal -based
- 15:51meat. The macronutrient analysis is just much
- 15:54better. And the studies indicate that plant -based
- 15:59meat is better for your health, better for your
- 16:03heart, better for your weight, better across
- 16:07all of the things that are tied to weight gain,
- 16:12et cetera. So I would be surprised if we had
- 16:17plant -based meat and cultivated meat that tasted
- 16:21the same. I'm not gonna be surprised if a lot
- 16:25of people go for cultivated meat because animal
- 16:28-based meat just has this sort of aura around
- 16:33it and lots of people believe that it is incredibly
- 16:37healthy. But a lot of people know that hamburgers
- 16:42are not healthy. A lot of people know that chicken
- 16:44nuggets are not healthy. So if you've got a plant
- 16:48-based product that has some fiber, less fat,
- 16:52less saturated fat, no cholesterol, more protein,
- 16:56I think there's probably a pretty significant
- 16:58market for the plant -based meat products, even
- 17:01in a world of cultivated meat, because it will
- 17:03be, the cultivated meat is exactly as healthy
- 17:06as animal -based meat, but without the bacterial
- 17:11contamination or the contamination of the drugs
- 17:14that are fed to the animals, et cetera. So that's
- 17:17the health benefit, but it's not a macronutrient
- 17:20health benefit. The plant -based meat will still
- 17:22have the macronutrient health benefit. Interesting.
- 17:26Something fascinating happened recently here
- 17:29in Canada, McDonald launched its very first vegan
- 17:34option, which is the Mac veggie, I think. And,
- 17:40you know, I've had I haven't tried it yet. But
- 17:43surprisingly, the Mac veggie does not imitate
- 17:48the taste of meat. It is the good old, you know,
- 17:53veggie patty option. How do you explain that
- 17:57choice from McDonald's to release that product?
- 18:02Yeah, it's interesting. I just pulled it up.
- 18:04It's carrots, green beans, zucchini, peas, soybeans,
- 18:07broccoli, and corn. That's a fascinating ingredient
- 18:11list. Yeah, I'd be interested in that. I know
- 18:16Burger King, when they first launched the BK
- 18:18Veggie, they did something similar. And that
- 18:22was in the U .S. They replaced the BK Veggie,
- 18:25pretty sure it's replaced, they might have both,
- 18:27with the Impossible Whopper. And the reviews
- 18:33for the Impossible Whopper are way better than
- 18:36the reviews were for the BK Veggie. The reviews
- 18:38were kind of ruthless on the latter. So maybe
- 18:42they're appealing to vegetarians and trying to
- 18:45get people who would not otherwise be coming
- 18:46to McDonald's to come to McDonald's. But Beyond
- 18:51that, I'm not sure. Right now, there aren't that
- 18:55many studies on the effects of providing price
- 19:01and taste competitive plant -based meats on consumers'
- 19:06meat consumption. And have you thought, have
- 19:11you considered funding maybe to your organization
- 19:15more research on that topic? I mean, the first
- 19:20principles on it are extraordinarily strong,
- 19:23as I argue in the book. It is notoriously difficult
- 19:27to test consumers and what consumers will want
- 19:32to do with a product that doesn't exist yet.
- 19:37So you have somebody like Henry Ford saying,
- 19:41if I had asked consumers what they wanted, they
- 19:44would have set a faster horse. And that concept
- 19:48has been cited favorably by some of the greatest
- 19:52innovators in history, including Steve Jobs and
- 19:56Elon Musk, both of whom didn't say, hey, I wonder
- 20:00if people are going to want EVs or satellites
- 20:03or SpaceX or the Apple home computer, the Mac
- 20:09that was launched to an awful lot of befuddlement
- 20:12in the early 1980s when the Mac came out. So
- 20:16to the iPhone, there was, and I talk about in
- 20:19the book, all of the people who mocked the iPhone
- 20:22when it came out, said consumers don't want all
- 20:25of this stuff on one device. And there was a
- 20:29lot of support for that as a concept. So it's
- 20:33very clear that maybe one of the most consistent
- 20:39findings in social sciences research that the
- 20:45most important things for food for consumers
- 20:48are deliciousness and affordability. And it's
- 20:55also true that there have been a lot of studies
- 20:58of why people eat plant -based meat, why they
- 21:03stopped eating plant -based meat, why they haven't
- 21:05tried plant -based meat, and literally 100 %
- 21:09of the studies of why people stopped or why people
- 21:12haven't tried it. the top two answers are either
- 21:16I tried it, I didn't like it, and it was too
- 21:18expensive, or I haven't tried it because I know
- 21:21I'm not gonna like it and it's too expensive.
- 21:24So it seems pretty clear that addressing those
- 21:28problems is the best path forward. And with a
- 21:33limited budget, funding things that feel discretionary
- 21:38doesn't feel like a great use of limited funds.
- 21:41I, there is a, an episode I released last week
- 21:45and one of the guests is, uh, Miyoko Shiner.
- 21:49And she's the one who got me interested in the
- 21:51topic of cultivated meat because I had the default
- 21:55position of thinking of cultivated meat as the
- 22:00Messiah and how, you know, what we were doing
- 22:04as animal advocates was just holding the fort.
- 22:08for this technology before this technology would
- 22:12come and then resolve the problem of factory
- 22:15farming. Now, through Miyoko and many other animal
- 22:21advocates, I discovered that this opinion is
- 22:24not shared widely in the animal advocacy community.
- 22:30And you know that very well because you even
- 22:33debated some of those outspoken uh, people, uh,
- 22:39like Johnson, but Mansu or facility, uh, Stennis
- 22:44Stennis. Yeah, I think, uh, his, his last name
- 22:47is, um, in any case, you know, what do you make
- 22:52of that, um, distanciation from animal advocates,
- 22:58from this technology? How do you explain how
- 23:02they are truly skeptical? in the prospects of
- 23:08cultivated meat? I mean, I think there's a pretty
- 23:12complete overlap between the people who are opposed
- 23:17to improvements in farm animal welfare and the
- 23:22people who are opposed to cultivated meat. And
- 23:26the argument is pretty similar. The argument
- 23:30against welfare reforms is that we are granting
- 23:35the property status of animals and that in doing
- 23:41so, we're setting back veganism. The argument
- 23:45against cultivated meat is that we're granting
- 23:48the idea of animals as consumable and again,
- 23:52setting back animal rights. I think both of those
- 23:56are just transparently bad arguments and I think
- 24:02they both really suggest a kind of remarkable
- 24:09lack of empathy for the animals who are in those
- 24:14conditions. And I really just can't even understand
- 24:20it. I will say that even an awful lot of people
- 24:24who are not fans of the welfare reforms are huge
- 24:30advocates of cultivated meat. for example, the
- 24:34founder and president of People for the Ethical
- 24:36Treatment of Animals, Ingrid Newkirk, may be
- 24:39the biggest cultivated meat booster on the planet
- 24:44and is not a fan of the welfare reforms for the
- 24:49reasons that I just identified. So I think it's
- 24:53a pretty small group who continue to look at,
- 24:58I mean, just think about we are now eating about
- 25:0365 % more meat than we did 25 years ago. That
- 25:09is literally tens of billions of animals. We
- 25:13are going to eat something like 50 to 65 % more
- 25:17meat by 2050 on our current trajectory. So that's
- 25:21literally 40 to 50 billion more animals by 2050.
- 25:28The idea that anybody would look at a solution
- 25:31to that and say no. Really, I think doesn't really
- 25:37hard for me to allow them, you know, who am I
- 25:40to say, but it's really hard for me to take seriously
- 25:43the idea of somebody who has that position, as
- 25:47somebody who cares at all about animals, and
- 25:51can possibly empathize with what they're going
- 25:54through. What do you make then of my initial
- 25:58position on cultivated meat, you know, thinking
- 26:01of it as the great solution to all of our issues
- 26:05in this struggle for animal liberation. Do you
- 26:11think this is an overly optimistic attitude?
- 26:16I think it's fair. I don't think anybody should
- 26:21rest on their laurels. There's a very legitimate
- 26:24concern that some people have that if we present
- 26:29cultivated meat as sort of the be -all and end
- 26:33-all and the solution, some people might think,
- 26:37oh, good, cultivated meat. I'm going to continue
- 26:40to eat meat right now because cultivated meat
- 26:43is coming. And I think that's a very real and
- 26:48reasonable concern. But I also think that it
- 26:52shouldn't stop us from doing everything that
- 26:55we can to try to get cultivated meat to price
- 27:01and taste parity as soon as possible. Because
- 27:04that will be the beginning at the end of industrial
- 27:07animal farming. And that probably is the only
- 27:11way we get to the beginning of the end of animal
- 27:15farming, you know, absent something catastrophic.
- 27:19There is this faction in the animal advocacy
- 27:23movement that really does not believe in cultivated
- 27:26meat. there's that same faction in the conservative
- 27:30movement of people who are all about, you know,
- 27:34eating meat. And I would include Joe Rogan in
- 27:38that list, although I've heard Joe Rogan talk
- 27:41about how, you know, factory farming was horrible.
- 27:45And that's why he was a hunter. And there was
- 27:49this recent incident with Campbell. Have you
- 27:53followed that story? Yeah. Well, there was an
- 27:58executive at Campbell who was videotaped talking
- 28:02about how the chicken in the Campbell soup was,
- 28:07was love grown chicken. Those were the words
- 28:13he used. And that created like a wave of dismay
- 28:19in the conservative community. And, you know,
- 28:23there are so many news articles and I've seen
- 28:26I've heard so many independent media talking
- 28:29about how, you know, this was horrible. How could
- 28:33they, um, you know, do that to their consumers
- 28:37and, um, lab grown meat. This is a terrible product.
- 28:42And I thought, Oh my gosh, the cultivated meat
- 28:45people have some work to do. Uh, you know, selling
- 28:49that the cultivated meat concept and products
- 28:52too. uh, to conservative audiences. Um, so what
- 28:57do you make of, of that, you know, faction of
- 29:02the society that truly looks at it as, um, with
- 29:07suspicion, um, and you know, I, I say they are
- 29:12conservative, but I think there are plenty of
- 29:14moderate people who, you know, also share those,
- 29:18uh, preconceived ideas about cultivated meat.
- 29:23I mean, I guess the first thing to say just as
- 29:25sort of a precursor observation is that he was
- 29:29right. Way more than cultivated meat is lab -grown
- 29:35meat. The current chicken is lab -produced chicken.
- 29:43Every agricultural studies department on the
- 29:48planet has meat labs and they are studying all
- 29:54kinds of different things, having to do with
- 29:57how to get the contamination off the meat, how
- 30:02to cut out the abscesses, how to deal with cancer
- 30:06chicken. There's a range of things happening
- 30:10in meat labs, but when somebody refers to lab
- 30:14-grown meat, 99 .9999 % of what goes on in meat
- 30:21labs has to do with the meat that is in grocery
- 30:25stores and in Campbell's soup right now. In the
- 30:31book, I point out that in the US, and I don't
- 30:36know what the regulations say in Canada, but
- 30:39there are a hundred drugs that it's legal to
- 30:42have them in animal meat. including things like
- 30:46ivermectin and ractopamine and penicillin and
- 30:50amoxicillin. These are all things that it's legal
- 30:52to feed to farm animals and that it's legal to
- 30:55have in the meat that we consume as long as it's
- 30:58in low enough levels. We're also feeding farm
- 31:02animals massive doses of antibiotic drugs. And
- 31:08even when you buy meat that says raised without
- 31:11antibiotics, when that meat is tested, a fifth
- 31:16of it has residues of antibiotics that are still
- 31:21measurable in the meat. So when you look at the
- 31:25polling that's done with regard to cultivated
- 31:28meat, even when you call it lab -grown, even
- 31:31when you include some disgusting photo, you still
- 31:34end up with north of 20 consumers, north of 20
- 31:37% of consumers who are enthusiastic to consume
- 31:40it. Because I think most consumers have a sort
- 31:44of visceral understanding that the way that meat
- 31:49is made today is not great. So we really only
- 31:54need 1 % in North America to have a $2 billion
- 31:59per year industry, which is a pretty massive
- 32:03industry right there. So 20 % is a $40 billion
- 32:07per year industry. And once you have two products
- 32:12on shelves and one of them does not have any
- 32:15chance of being contaminated with ivermectin
- 32:18and ractopamine and antibiotics and has a fraction
- 32:22of the likelihood of being contaminated with
- 32:24listeria or E. coli or salmonella or Campylobacter,
- 32:29I think people will go for the cleaner, healthier,
- 32:33more pure product would be my hypothesis. However
- 32:36much people before the products even exist, have
- 32:41concerns about it. And really, I mean, it doesn't
- 32:44matter that a lot of people now have a visceral,
- 32:50I don't know about that response, because the
- 32:53products don't exist yet. And when they do and
- 32:57people are buying them, they're still going to
- 32:59be sold for a premium for a while. And there
- 33:02are lots and lots of people who are excited about
- 33:05buying them, even for a premium. Well, you know,
- 33:09it's It's something I even heard from my parents.
- 33:13Um, I forgot about that, but I was mentioning
- 33:17how social media was a dangerous place to get
- 33:21information about, you know, veganism and all
- 33:24of that. And they started talking about lab grown
- 33:28meat and how this was bad and how, you know,
- 33:32there were tumors and it induced cancer in people.
- 33:36And I thought, what, what? I mean, it. took me
- 33:40by surprise because they were consuming all of
- 33:43that social media content and it seems like there
- 33:47is some kind of narrative on social media about
- 33:52how cultivated meat is really bad for you. Now,
- 33:57who is behind that? Is it appearing from Is it
- 34:05like a cultural reaction to this new technology?
- 34:09Is it like an organic reaction or is there some
- 34:14party funding, some kind of PR campaign here?
- 34:20I mean, the only people who I know are promulgating
- 34:24those sorts of things on social media are like
- 34:30the Organic Consumers Association, which has
- 34:34a very nice name, but they're also anti -vaccine.
- 34:39They're really anti -science. And then sort of
- 34:43similar other anti -science. Yeah, I mean, it's
- 34:48the same people who are anti -vaccine for the
- 34:50most part. There are also the organic agro -ecology
- 34:59back to the land, back to nature. And again,
- 35:03that's the Joe Rogan types on the one side, the
- 35:06Joe Rogan RFK types on one side, the Michael
- 35:09Pollan, Alice Waters types on the other side.
- 35:12Although I will say Michael Pollan is actually
- 35:14in favor of plant -based and cultivated meat,
- 35:17which is nice. But I think he personally is more
- 35:21enthusiastic. He's in favor of it as sort of
- 35:23a backup plan for people who are going to eat
- 35:26industrial meat. He thinks it's better than that.
- 35:29but he would prefer that people go with regenerative
- 35:33heritage breeds, et cetera. So it's really, it's
- 35:39those folks. And that kind of thing can spread
- 35:42pretty quickly on social media, but just like
- 35:46the vast majority of people are taking the vaccines
- 35:49that they need to take, fortunately, it's not
- 35:52the sort of thing where measles can come back
- 35:56because 30 % of people are not getting the measles
- 36:00vaccine. As long as we have 20 % adoption, that's
- 36:06gonna be overwhelmingly enough to socialize.
- 36:10This is a much healthier, better alternative,
- 36:13and we'll get vast majority uptake. I will also
- 36:19just note, I don't know how many of your listeners
- 36:21are in the United States, but. When I was researching
- 36:26the book, one of the things that I found was
- 36:27that during the Biden administration, the poultry
- 36:30industry petitioned to have a regulation that
- 36:36kept inspectors on chicken slaughter lines, looking
- 36:40for avian leucosis, so chicken cancer, and were
- 36:46successful in both A, having the inspectors taken
- 36:49off the line, and B, changing the regulation
- 36:52so that chicken carcasses that are contaminated
- 36:55that have cancer do not have to be condemned.
- 36:58They just have to cut the cancer out of the carcass.
- 37:01And I talked about this in chapter seven of the
- 37:04book, but part two of that is it's the honor
- 37:08system. So they have to cut the cancer out, but
- 37:12there's not anybody there making sure that they
- 37:15do that. So, and that was already the regulation
- 37:18for pork and beef, because the pork industry
- 37:22and the beef industry had successfully argued
- 37:24the economics of 500 pound, or I guess it's probably
- 37:30a 300 pound pig or a 650 pounds edible meat on
- 37:36a cow. If they had argued that do you really
- 37:40want us to, you know, the cow has cancer eye,
- 37:42you really want us to condemn the entire carcass
- 37:47and the USDA had said, no. Now you're looking
- 37:51at a four pound chicken and the answer is still
- 37:54no. You can process the rest of the chicken,
- 37:57even if you've got an awful cancerous lesion
- 38:00tumor, whatever on the bird. So it's a little
- 38:04ironic considering what your parents said that
- 38:06the current chicken beef and pork supply, at
- 38:08least in the US, who knows how many of those
- 38:12animals have cancer, but it's a big enough deal
- 38:14that the industry asked not to have to condemn
- 38:18the carcasses and in the US USDA agreed. It was,
- 38:23I could not believe what I was reading. It was,
- 38:26it's one of my favorite part of the book. Um,
- 38:30and, and so, you know, who is in charge of creating
- 38:34this marketing strategy, you know, to introduce
- 38:38cultivated meat into culture and, uh, people's,
- 38:43you know, um, habits and food habits, you know,
- 38:48because, you know, I was looking into the response
- 38:55of Campbell from that whole outcry and what they
- 39:00did was just, you know, go and publish a statement
- 39:07that strongly condemns, you know, the use of
- 39:12lab grown chicken in their products. and they
- 39:16made it clear that no LibroKrone products was
- 39:20in their soups. They did not take the road of
- 39:23saying, hey, actually the products we're using
- 39:28and that are... you know, we call them cultivated
- 39:31meat and they're better for your health than,
- 39:34you know, the, the chicken, the usual chicken
- 39:37that you find. And that makes us a better brand,
- 39:41you know, than our competition or something like
- 39:44that. So the response was really to just deny,
- 39:49deny, deny. And so yeah, who, who is in charge
- 39:53of, of marketing for cultivated meat? Well, I
- 39:57mean, Campbell's isn't using cultivated meat.
- 40:00So it would have been, they couldn't say that
- 40:03they're using cultivated meat because they're
- 40:04not. So it would be sort of weird for them to
- 40:08talk about how great cultivated meat is since
- 40:11they're not using it. So they would have to say.
- 40:13Sorry, I misunderstood because you said that.
- 40:19that person that was recorded on video was right.
- 40:23I assumed you meant they were using actually
- 40:26cultivated meat products in their lab grown meat.
- 40:31So if 90, you know, if 99 .999 % of meat labs
- 40:35are using conventional chicken, and that's the
- 40:38stuff that has the, you know, tumors and the
- 40:40abscesses and drug residues and everything else.
- 40:44That is what we should refer to as lab grown
- 40:48meat. not cultivated meat, which consumers will
- 40:51never be eating cultivated meat that came out
- 40:53of a lab. They'll be eating cultivated meat that
- 40:56came out of a factory that looks an awful lot
- 40:59like a brewery. And I love what Uma Vledi, the
- 41:03CEO of Upside Foods, they literally put glass
- 41:05walls in. They said, we will live stream cultivated
- 41:09meat production. And we challenge the conventional
- 41:13industry to live stream their farms and slaughterhouses.
- 41:17They're not going to want to do it. But if the
- 41:21idea of calling something lab -grown meat is
- 41:23that it started in a lab, then 100%, well, not
- 41:28100%, but more than 99 % of the current chicken
- 41:32supply is there on the basis of techniques that
- 41:37were developed in a lab. And 99 .999999 % of
- 41:45labs that are working with chicken are working
- 41:48with chicken, the kind of chicken that is showing
- 41:51up in grocery stores and in cans of Campbell's
- 41:54soup. So that was that was the point that I was
- 41:57making. Yeah, I think it's it's part of it, you
- 42:01know, that this marketing problem, because people
- 42:04use lab grown meat and cultivated meat, me included
- 42:08interchangeably. And, you know, it's kind of,
- 42:12you know, there is no guide for, you know, What
- 42:16is this and that and what compels someone to
- 42:20use one term instead of the other? Well, we encourage
- 42:24people not to say lab -grown meat if what they
- 42:27mean is cultivated meat. Great. Yeah. I've been
- 42:29trying to correct myself. Okay. Is there, you
- 42:36know, you mentioned earlier that there was no
- 42:39product yet. But first, your comment about those
- 42:44glass walls, I found it very interesting because
- 42:47now you have factory farms doing the same thing,
- 42:51putting glass walls and showcasing even doing
- 42:57tours of their facilities in an effort to normalize
- 43:02that type of exploitation of animals, which I
- 43:08find interesting. It's smart. It's smart, you
- 43:12know, from a marketing perspective, it's really
- 43:15smart. Maybe the cultivated meat people should
- 43:19recruit their marketers. So you mentioned how
- 43:25there was no product available yet, but I've
- 43:29heard of many people who have tried, you know,
- 43:32cultivated meat. But none of them are in my network
- 43:36of animal advocates. And I think it ties back
- 43:40to that faction in the animal advocacy movement
- 43:43who goes against this concept and this technology.
- 43:48Nobody has tasted it. I felt a bit crazy, you
- 43:53know, I started going through my contacts and
- 43:55asking them, have you ever had cultivated meat?
- 43:58Because, you know, I've had discussions with
- 44:00those people about cultivated meat, but none
- 44:03of them ever tasted the product. Um, and that
- 44:07includes, you know, frontline leading researchers
- 44:11in animal advocacy, um, you know, entrepreneurs,
- 44:15uh, even, you know, the head of a vegan, um,
- 44:19label, you know, um, labeling products. So how
- 44:24come, you know, no one has tasted the product
- 44:27in the animal advocacy space? I mean, I think
- 44:31everybody in the animal advocacy space in Israel
- 44:34and San Francisco, I would guess, maybe not everybody,
- 44:36but if you're in Israel, if you're in the Netherlands,
- 44:41if you're in San Francisco, it's not hard to
- 44:49find yourself in a situation where you're eating
- 44:52cultivated meat. I've probably eaten cultivated
- 44:55meat more than 50 times, I would guess. Yeah,
- 45:01I'm not, I mean, it's not that surprising. It's
- 45:05not easy to come by. Most of the people who have
- 45:07tried it are actually working in the space, I
- 45:12think. I will say that when I had cultivated
- 45:16meat for the first time, I had to share half
- 45:20a chicken nugget with Susie Welch, NYU professor.
- 45:25This was at Jack and Susie Welch's in their kitchen
- 45:28in Manhattan. And Uma Velletti, the CEO of Upside
- 45:32Foods, which was then Memphis Meats, came to
- 45:35New York City and we ate half a chicken nugget,
- 45:39which I'm sure cost thousands of dollars. Now
- 45:41it'd be $5. The price has come down by a factor
- 45:46of 100 ,000. It's not that hard to come by if
- 45:50you're someplace where there's a company working
- 45:52on it. You can't actually buy it in probably,
- 45:55I don't know, a bunch of restaurants in Singapore,
- 46:01a few in Australia and New Zealand, a few in
- 46:03the US, there's one in San Francisco, a few in
- 46:06Oregon. So it's not completely impossible to
- 46:09come by, but it's certainly not easy. There was
- 46:13a, an influencer on Instagram, handsome guy who
- 46:18was, you know, defending cultivated meat. I think
- 46:20his whole influencer thing was about that. And
- 46:24he had the contest where you could like, uh,
- 46:28one of his posts and comment, and then you get
- 46:31the chance of, uh, having, uh, you know, a sample
- 46:35of cultivated meat products. and I thought it
- 46:39shouldn't be random strangers online. You should
- 46:41send them to animal advocacy people, researchers,
- 46:45and so on, including those who are outspoken
- 46:48critics, because I feel like there would be a
- 46:51before -after moment from having the product
- 46:54in your hand and tasting it, maybe intellectually
- 46:59that could play into it in the perception of
- 47:04the product. So that's just an idea I'm sharing
- 47:09with you. Yeah, I mean, if somebody wants to
- 47:14try it, I don't think it's that hard for them
- 47:16to make that happen. I'm just thinking about
- 47:20how high should it be on the priority list of
- 47:24the cultivated meat industry. I think not that
- 47:28high. As you know in the book, I'm really focused
- 47:32on the food security and the economic benefits
- 47:35of plant -based and cultivated meat. Because
- 47:38the goal of the book is to help with the effort
- 47:42to generate government support for these technologies
- 47:47in the same way that governments have supported
- 47:49most, if not all, successful technologies over
- 47:54the last, certainly, 50 to 75 years, if not longer.
- 48:00And so what does it look like for that to happen?
- 48:03governments, they're not going to put significant
- 48:07amounts of money into alleviating cruelty to
- 48:09animals. Most governments are not going to put
- 48:12significant amounts of money into alleviating
- 48:16hunger and malnutrition unless it's in their
- 48:18country or the range of environmental harms.
- 48:23They'll pass laws and regulations to stop egregious
- 48:27environmental pollution, but it's not going to
- 48:29be a top priority. of most governments to actually
- 48:34like address global problems in that way. But
- 48:37what governments do care about is food security,
- 48:40food self -sufficiency, economic competitiveness.
- 48:43So that's all of chapter nine and chapter 10
- 48:46is making the pitch to governments. And as you
- 48:49know, the Good Food Institute, we have about
- 48:52240 full -time staff around the world. The plurality
- 48:55of our team members are scientists. And our number
- 48:59one goal is to build a maximally robust scientific
- 49:02ecosystem. The way we think you do that is you
- 49:04get governments to fund science. So you need
- 49:06the best scientists in a country saying, this
- 49:10is something I want to study so that governments
- 49:12will see it as legitimate. But then those scientists
- 49:15want government money to be there. So it's sort
- 49:17of the stance where you need to be petitioning
- 49:19the governments to make money available, petitioning
- 49:21the scientists to apply for it. And the best
- 49:25way to do that is really leading in. on the economic
- 49:28benefits of the technologies, the fact that it's
- 49:31a market -based intervention, and then also the
- 49:35food self -sufficiency, food security, those
- 49:37sorts of benefits. And we've been successful.
- 49:40Seven years ago, there was no government money
- 49:42for plant -based or cultivated meat other than
- 49:45in Israel and Singapore. And it was in Israel
- 49:49and Singapore because they're so tiny. And they
- 49:51saw the benefit, both the economic benefit Israel
- 49:56is the startup nation, incredibly innovative.
- 50:00Israel and Singapore import the vast majority
- 50:03of their food. And if they can move towards something
- 50:06that is so much more efficient way of producing
- 50:08meat, they saw the benefit of that. Now we have
- 50:12India, Brazil, the US, Canada, Australia, New
- 50:18Zealand, Japan, Korea, China, the European Union
- 50:23and a whole bunch of countries in Europe. funding
- 50:27both R &D and incentivizing manufacturing and
- 50:30infrastructure, which is a lot of progress in
- 50:34less than seven years in terms of governments
- 50:36and scientists leaning in on these technologies.
- 50:43The governments are funding it for the economic
- 50:45benefits and the food security benefits. A lot
- 50:47of the scientists are doing it for environmental
- 50:51reasons or global hunger reasons or global health
- 50:55reasons. Some are doing it for animal protection
- 50:58reasons as well. But I do think when we're thinking
- 51:02about what are the best use, you know, what is
- 51:05the best use of time and resources? The thing
- 51:08I was thinking about was, is the best use of
- 51:11time and resources getting animal activists excited
- 51:16about the technology? When in my experience,
- 51:18most animal activists are already excited about
- 51:21the technology and the ones that aren't. I don't
- 51:25know. I mean, I don't think I had heard John's
- 51:27name in years. I don't know if he's spending
- 51:34any time on it, but it doesn't seem like he's
- 51:38that incensed or somehow it's not breaking through
- 51:41to me. And I think I would have heard about it.
- 51:45So it doesn't seem like it's a big, a significant
- 51:49obstacle or even an insignificant obstacle. Most
- 51:56of the time when politicians publish a book,
- 51:59it's because they're going to run for an office
- 52:02or there's something they want to create momentum
- 52:06for some political project. Is there such agenda
- 52:11behind the release of your book? Is there something
- 52:14big coming up that you're creating momentum around?
- 52:20I mean, the book was really a response to we've
- 52:24seen these articles that are basically obituaries
- 52:28for plant -based and cultivated meat. And you
- 52:30read the article, and in zero of the cases did
- 52:36the journalist talk to a single scientist working
- 52:39on plant -based or cultivated meat. I mean, remarkable.
- 52:42There was a cover story in Businessweek. It was
- 52:45more than 4 ,000 words. And it spent 4 ,000 words
- 52:50saying the products aren't good enough. and they
- 52:53cost too much without literally without talking
- 52:57to anybody working in the space. Not a single
- 53:03scientist. It was really quite remarkable. And
- 53:07yeah, really quite remarkable. And there've been
- 53:09a couple of those, but that was the most prominent
- 53:11one. Similarly, there have been obituaries of
- 53:15cultivated meat that say the sector has spent
- 53:19$3 billion. Where's my cultivated burger? essentially.
- 53:23And again, not talking to a single, there are
- 53:25literally hundreds of scientists working on cultivated
- 53:27meat. Incredibly impressive biomedical scientists
- 53:32and others. Not a single scientist working in
- 53:36the field quoted in this story that I'm thinking
- 53:39of. It was more, again, more than 4 ,000 words,
- 53:41like the business week story. It's just a remarkable
- 53:45lack of understanding of what innovation progress
- 53:49looks like. And $3 billion, that's the cost in
- 53:53the US of bringing two drugs to market if you
- 53:56already have a massive pharmaceutical firm. So
- 54:00none of the costs of setting up a factory, none
- 54:04of the costs of related to hiring your CFO and
- 54:09line staff and everything else. And this is across
- 54:12more than 100 companies a decade. You know, so
- 54:17all of time, 100 companies, $3 billion. That's
- 54:19less than the cost of one EV battery factory.
- 54:22And people are writing the obituaries of these
- 54:25industries. So the book was basically a response
- 54:28to that. And the idea of the book is to be optimistic
- 54:34about the science while being realistic about
- 54:38the fact that a scientific endeavor can be perfectly
- 54:42sound and still fail. if you don't bring the
- 54:46will to the effort, if you don't try hard enough.
- 54:50So the book is basically saying all of the evidence
- 54:53indicates that the science is sound. The question
- 54:56is, will we do what we need to do to make sure
- 55:00that the technologies succeed as soon as possible?
- 55:05So that's basically why I wrote the book. To
- 55:10close this chapter on you know, people against
- 55:16cultivated meat. Is there any like actual evidence
- 55:21that would make you reconsider, you know, developing,
- 55:26supporting, promoting this alternative, you know,
- 55:30proteins, products? Sure. I mean, if, if there
- 55:39were I mean, if the preponderance of the scientific
- 55:44analysis were that we can't get to price and
- 55:48taste parity with either of the products, that
- 55:51would cause me to think we shouldn't work on
- 55:54that product, probably. I mean, it's interesting.
- 55:58You read the book Abundance by Esser Klein and
- 56:00Derek Thompson, and they make a pretty strong
- 56:02case that something like mRNA many years in this
- 56:11sort of scientific wasteland, and it ended up
- 56:15being the COVID vaccine. And there's that sort
- 56:23of the concept that science progresses funeral
- 56:25by funeral, because there's just sort of a common
- 56:28wisdom in science, something's not possible.
- 56:30And then the young scientists come along and
- 56:33they do it anyway. So if I were convinced that
- 56:37the science wouldn't work, or for some other
- 56:41reason that price and taste parity for the products
- 56:44wouldn't work, or for some reason price and taste
- 56:46parity for the products wouldn't shoot us up
- 56:49the S curve. There are a variety of things that
- 56:54would convince me not to proceed, but all of
- 56:58the evidence is in diametrically the opposite
- 57:01direction. And I mean, when we started GFI, we
- 57:04didn't expect to be working on Cultivated Nate.
- 57:06When we started GFI, we thought we were going
- 57:09to try to create an ecosystem of competitors
- 57:12with Impossible and Beyond to try to turn plant
- 57:16-based meat into a commodity product, essentially.
- 57:21And then Uma Valetti started Upside Foods at
- 57:25about the same time we were starting the Good
- 57:28Food Institute. We literally share a birthday
- 57:31on February 1st, 2016. And Uma convinced us that
- 57:36cultivated meat was a lot farther along scientifically
- 57:38than we believed it to be. And two of GFI's first
- 57:43six staff members were scientists. One of them
- 57:47was charged with figuring out the scientific
- 57:50viability of plant -based meat. The other one
- 57:52was charged with figuring out the scientific
- 57:54viability of cultivated meat. And I will say,
- 57:58as I mentioned, the preponderance, I mean, the
- 58:01plurality of GFI's team members around the world
- 58:03are scientists. And the more they dive in, the
- 58:06more optimistic they become about the viability
- 58:09of the science. Yeah, you go into that story
- 58:14in the book and it's truly fascinating. I do
- 58:18really recommend the book to people because for
- 58:22me, Cultivated Meat had a bit of lack of transparency
- 58:27problem, I think, and I could not see where this
- 58:31was coming from, the mechanisms behind it. what
- 58:35is driving this industry, who are the people
- 58:38driving this product? And this is what this book
- 58:42offered me, you know, a look at behind the scenes.
- 58:46And this is what was most precious to me, you
- 58:50know, from the book. One last point before we
- 58:54stop the recording. In the beginning of your
- 58:59book, you talk about different, you know, approaches
- 59:03that were tried to stop people or at least convince
- 59:07them to diminish their intake of animal products.
- 59:11And, you know, the traditional ways we, we do
- 59:14activism and, and how, you know, this had the
- 59:18ceiling and that cultivated meat could help us
- 59:21go beyond that ceiling. And, you know, I, I felt
- 59:26like, you know, the, the number of initiatives
- 59:30you named despite their success. are truly limited
- 59:34in their scope. I feel like cultivated meat is
- 59:40really a product of creativity, innovation, thinking
- 59:45outside the box, you know, but there are other
- 59:50ways of doing activism that are, that have been,
- 59:54you know, and exploited that are also innovative
- 59:58and that, you know, activists just do not engage
- 1:00:01in an example of that is outreach to conservative
- 1:00:04people, you know, never been done. What about
- 1:00:09religious, you know, based activism and outreach?
- 1:00:14I know you're religious yourself, but you know,
- 1:00:18like, there aren't that many organizations and
- 1:00:20they're not well funded that, you know, do outreach
- 1:00:23to conservative to religious institutions and
- 1:00:27religious communities and make the religious
- 1:00:30argument for caring for animals. And so, do you
- 1:00:36really believe this is the ultimate solution
- 1:00:39or is there something else that excites you in
- 1:00:43the realm of activism? Well, I mean, I'll say
- 1:00:47two things. The first is that I don't think you
- 1:00:53could possibly be more successful than Matthew
- 1:00:57Scully was with his book, Dominion. So, Dominion
- 1:01:03came out. George Will wrote about it for Newsweek
- 1:01:07magazine and the Washington Post, and that was
- 1:01:09syndicated. Charles Cronhammer, who at the time
- 1:01:13was probably the most famous and well -respected
- 1:01:17conservative thinker. It got a cover story in
- 1:01:23American Conservative, got a cover story in New
- 1:01:25Republic, which is the sort of house organ of
- 1:01:29the conservative establishment. I mean, Matthew
- 1:01:32Scully, he was speechwriter for George W. Bush
- 1:01:35for all of Bush's governorship and then for the
- 1:01:40first four years of Bush's presidency. So one
- 1:01:44of the three speechwriters on Bush's speech writing
- 1:01:48team leaves to write a book about religious and
- 1:01:52conservative reasons to care about farm animals
- 1:01:55and not eat them. was just way more successful
- 1:02:01than anything that has ever happened from the
- 1:02:04other side. Yeah, I mean, just massive impact
- 1:02:10among conservatives and religious people. So
- 1:02:16I'm not sure what else to say other than that.
- 1:02:20That doesn't mean we shouldn't keep doing that.
- 1:02:22I wouldn't be here if not for education and activism.
- 1:02:27And I think that's true for most of the people
- 1:02:29who started the companies, the plant -based meat
- 1:02:33and the cultivated meat companies. It's true
- 1:02:34for a lot of the scientists and a lot of other
- 1:02:37people who have gotten on board. So I'm not saying
- 1:02:40it's not successful at influencing individuals.
- 1:02:45And I'm certainly not saying that we shouldn't
- 1:02:47do more of it. What I am saying is that it is
- 1:02:50unlikely to change the massive upward trajectory
- 1:02:54of meat consumption globally. meat consumption
- 1:02:58globally has gone up every single year for more
- 1:03:01than 60 years, and probably every single year
- 1:03:05since forever, absent something like a massive
- 1:03:09pandemic or the bubonic plague or a war or something
- 1:03:12like that. As long as population is going up
- 1:03:16and people are getting wealthier, GDP is going
- 1:03:18up, meat consumption is going up. And that has
- 1:03:22happened every year since 1961, which is the
- 1:03:24year the UN Food and Agriculture Organization
- 1:03:26started measuring. So we need at least more tools
- 1:03:30in our toolkit. I'm not suggesting that anybody
- 1:03:32stop doing anything. I am suggesting that we
- 1:03:36add this tool to our toolkit. The one thing that
- 1:03:40feels to me like it is underrepresented in activism
- 1:03:44is concerted university focused activism. So
- 1:03:51I really like what for us, our senior is doing
- 1:03:55with allied scholars for animal protection ASAP.
- 1:04:01I think the one of the things that's really worked.
- 1:04:06It seems to me with things like the young Republicans
- 1:04:10or the Federalist Society is a long view that
- 1:04:16focuses on things where you can go for four years.
- 1:04:21of ensuring that people understand your perspective
- 1:04:25and then they go out into the world with that
- 1:04:28perspective. What seems like it works less well
- 1:04:32is hoping that somebody will read something,
- 1:04:35go back into their daily lives, which are going
- 1:04:39to be just completely populated with people who
- 1:04:42are not vegan or vegetarian or animal sympathetic
- 1:04:46to the degree that they're gonna change their
- 1:04:48diets. and expect them to stay changed. So I
- 1:04:53do think that that's the one thing that feels
- 1:04:55to me like it is underutilized as a mechanism
- 1:05:01of change, but I don't think even that is going
- 1:05:04to change the massive upward trajectory. One
- 1:05:07of the things that's really great about market
- 1:05:09-based mechanisms and alternative proteins, alternative
- 1:05:13beads as a market -based mechanism is that once
- 1:05:16you've got price and taste parity, it can scale
- 1:05:18globally. Whereas with anything that requires
- 1:05:22behavior change, even if you make a massive difference
- 1:05:25on one campus or even in one city or even in
- 1:05:29one country, there's not some obvious way that
- 1:05:33that is going to scale beyond that endeavor.
- 1:05:39So one of the really great things about renewable
- 1:05:41energy, like I am in favor on the fossil fuel
- 1:05:47front of encouraging people to ride bikes and
- 1:05:50walk. I think we need bullet trains and great
- 1:05:52public transit and energy efficient everything
- 1:05:56from light bulbs to buildings to everything else.
- 1:05:58But we also need renewable energy. The same thing
- 1:06:01is true here. Sure, absolutely. Let's lean in
- 1:06:05on education of conservatives and religious people
- 1:06:08and everybody else. But my guess is that we're
- 1:06:12also going to need alternative proteins. Yes,
- 1:06:17we love Farah as he was a guest on the show too
- 1:06:20and I think he works for you for the good food
- 1:06:24Institute too Yeah, I think you know the book
- 1:06:30was really popular and I know Matthew but We
- 1:06:36need to look at how politicians do it. They create
- 1:06:39a community. They are always there. They are
- 1:06:43always in contact. It's more than just releasing
- 1:06:46a book. It takes more to instill those values
- 1:06:52into the culture. And yeah, I do think it takes
- 1:06:58more of an organized effort and more of a systematic
- 1:07:02effort. Okay, my last question for you, Bruce,
- 1:07:08before I let you go, this, I mentioned how Miyoko
- 1:07:14was the one who got me interested in the whole
- 1:07:18debate around cultivated meat. And I asked her,
- 1:07:22you know, does she have a question for you maybe?
- 1:07:26And her question for you was this one, who is
- 1:07:31in control of the food system once, you know,
- 1:07:35cultivated meat becomes a success. And I think
- 1:07:39she's referencing to this tendency in the market
- 1:07:43of, you know, food products becoming more and
- 1:07:47more owned by the same, I think, big five for
- 1:07:52corporations, which is a problem. So what do
- 1:07:57you make of that question? Yeah, I mean, as you
- 1:08:01know from reading the book, I lean in on that
- 1:08:03question in chapter 10. And what I, GFI was formed
- 1:08:08to try to turn plant -based meat into a commodity
- 1:08:11product that isn't controlled by just a couple
- 1:08:14of companies. So for people who are concerned
- 1:08:19about that question, the thing that surprises
- 1:08:22me is that like people who are concerned about
- 1:08:24that question, their response to the concern
- 1:08:29is to not get involved. I would think the response
- 1:08:32to the concern would be to get involved. So our
- 1:08:37number one goal, as I mentioned, is scientific
- 1:08:41ecosystem building. And the goal of the scientific
- 1:08:44ecosystem building is to have as much open access
- 1:08:48science as possible. The alternative to that
- 1:08:52is consolidation in a few startups or the current
- 1:08:58industry and IP that is controlled by a very
- 1:09:03limited number of actors. So as you know from
- 1:09:07reading the book, what I hope is that we'll move
- 1:09:09toward commodity products and that this will
- 1:09:14allow us, because it will free up so much land,
- 1:09:18because it will free up so many resources, it
- 1:09:21will allow us to move in the direction of a significantly
- 1:09:31more egalitarian agricultural reality that is
- 1:09:35in particular good for the environment, good
- 1:09:39for farmers, and a shift away from get big or
- 1:09:43get out. So get big or get out has been the mantra
- 1:09:47and agriculture has been consolidating since
- 1:09:51the early 1970s when Earl Butz brought that to
- 1:09:55the United States. And every single year, more
- 1:09:57and more farmers and ranchers go out of business,
- 1:09:59even as more and more meat is produced. And that's
- 1:10:05because of agricultural consolidation. And as
- 1:10:08long as we're going to need to produce 50 % more
- 1:10:11meat in 25 years, it's really hard to think about
- 1:10:17how that process can possibly reverse. But if
- 1:10:21we can start producing meat in a way that requires
- 1:10:24a tiny fraction of the resources, and that frees
- 1:10:27up vast quantities of land, that gives us the
- 1:10:30opportunity to recenter agriculture in a way
- 1:10:34that's better for the environment, better for
- 1:10:35farm families. And you can imagine a world in
- 1:10:38which the current consolidation, if we're basically
- 1:10:42starting over with the way that meat is made,
- 1:10:44I mean, good luck reversing where we are now.
- 1:10:48But if we start over in how meat is made, then
- 1:10:52we can start over in a way that is a lot more
- 1:10:55focused on smaller scale production. And I guess
- 1:11:00my challenge is to people who are concerned about
- 1:11:03this issue, think about how you affect it. Opposing
- 1:11:09plant -based and cultivated bee is not gonna
- 1:11:12be helpful, but advocating for open access science
- 1:11:19will be successful. and challenging an IP dominated
- 1:11:25food system. So I mean, you know, that's, that's
- 1:11:29what I would suggest. Thank you so much, Bruce,
- 1:11:34did you want to add something for we stopped
- 1:11:36the recording? I mean, I hope people will check
- 1:11:39out the book. The website for the book is just
- 1:11:42meet book dot org, any at book dot org. And if
- 1:11:48you do read it, I would love to hear what you
- 1:11:50think. I do think it's a classic of animal rights.
- 1:11:55I don't know if you want me to say that, but
- 1:11:57I do look at it as that. Bruce, this has been
- 1:12:03a pleasure. Thank you so much for having taken
- 1:12:06the time to answer my questions, some of them
- 1:12:09challenging. Hopefully you found them interesting.
- 1:12:13I really appreciate your willingness to confront
- 1:12:17even the most challenging ideas. and to have
- 1:12:21written this book to address them or at least
- 1:12:24a big chunk of them. And thank you for all of
- 1:12:27your work. It's hard to be the builder at the
- 1:12:32front line and doing the innovation work because
- 1:12:35then you get all of the criticism and all of
- 1:12:39the. Yeah, so I see that, you know, and and I
- 1:12:44think you're brave in your fight. So thank you
- 1:12:48so much, Bruce. Thank you everyone for listening.
- 1:13:08I kindly invite you to share this podcast with
- 1:13:11the vegans you know. Let's encourage more people
- 1:13:14to take action. Again, thank you so much for
- 1:13:18caring, and I will see you next Tuesday for a
- 1:13:21new episode.