Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Claws, Paws, and Laws: Protecting the Animal Performer's Brand Under the Lanham Act
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07Claws, Paws, and Laws, Protecting the Animal
- 0:10Performer's Brand Under the Langnam Act. I'm
- 0:14Alla Pulley Castro, Director of Education and
- 0:16Professional Development at Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:18Association. And today, I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:20our speakers, Lauren Hanson and Max Kirkham.
- 0:24Lauren is an attorney in the Entertainment Technology
- 0:27and Advertising Practice Group at Shepard Mullen.
- 0:30Lauren's practice covers all areas of entertainment
- 0:33law with a primary focus on transactional matters
- 0:36related to film, television, and digital media.
- 0:39She counsels studios, production companies, networks,
- 0:43independent producers, media companies, and talent
- 0:45on the creation and exploitation of motion pictures,
- 0:48documentaries, television series, podcasts, virtual
- 0:51reality, and other digital media. Recently, Variety
- 0:55named her as one of Hollywood's new leaders.
- 0:57Max is a coordinator in business affairs at the
- 1:00Walt Disney Company, where he supports the legal
- 1:03and business operations of 20th Television. He
- 1:06brings a strong foundation in entertainment law,
- 1:08having honed his expertise through roles at prominent
- 1:11entertainment, technology, and media law firms
- 1:13and studios. Prior to his legal career, Max spent
- 1:17several years working across the various aspects
- 1:19of television production and has been an active
- 1:22civic leader in Los Angeles, serving an elected
- 1:25and appointed roles in neighborhood councils.
- 1:28We're so excited to hear what they have to share
- 1:30with us today. So I'm now going to turn it over
- 1:32to them. Awesome. Thank you so much. Yeah, thank
- 1:38you so much. So as Aliyah said, my name is Max
- 1:42Kirkham. I'm very excited to be here presenting
- 1:44this with Lauren. Before I get started, I just
- 1:47want to give a quick thank you to Shepard for
- 1:50helping to make this happen. And Lauren, thank
- 1:52you for getting this article published and doing
- 1:55this with me. This has been really fun. So, clause,
- 1:58pause, and laws. What are we doing here that
- 2:03we can't necessarily get through our normal contracting
- 2:07with performers, right? Let's go to our first
- 2:11slide, please. Wonderful. First, we're going
- 2:18to just kind of set the scene. We're going to
- 2:20get all on the same page as to what exactly we're
- 2:22doing here with trademark law that we can't get
- 2:25through normal contracting principles. And then
- 2:27I'm going to go over Kind of the basics of trademark
- 2:30law. Of course, this is a half hour presentation.
- 2:32So these are going to be broad strokes. These
- 2:35are kind of broad strokes that we're going to
- 2:38be going over here. And the scope and the strength
- 2:42of both the right of publicity and the right
- 2:43of privacy vary widely from state to state. So
- 2:47that's another reason we're not going to go too
- 2:48deeply into this. We're just getting on the same
- 2:51page. These are two the right of privacy and
- 2:55the right of publicity are two similar but different
- 2:59Rights, they are common law and statutory little
- 3:03correction to the bottom of the screen there
- 3:05These are similar but different common law and
- 3:08statutory rights which provide a broad range
- 3:11of protections governing how certain aspects
- 3:14of a person's identity that is their name voice
- 3:16image and likeness are used and commodified these
- 3:21are The one on the right, the right of publicity,
- 3:24is the one that we're really focusing on today.
- 3:27This is a property -based right which is generally
- 3:31aimed at protecting against unfair commercial
- 3:35exploitation of a commercially recognizable human's
- 3:39identity. This is essentially, I have built my
- 3:44brand. I've put all this effort and work into
- 3:46building this. And by you using my identity,
- 3:49you are taking from me something I would otherwise
- 3:51make money off of. A right of privacy, just to
- 3:55really briefly touch on it, this is the kind
- 3:59of analogous right for, it's easier to win for
- 4:02private figures or non -famous persons as opposed
- 4:04to the right of publicity, which is harder to
- 4:07win for non -famous people. Next slide, please.
- 4:13So which one are we focused on today? When we're
- 4:16talking about protecting someone's name, voice,
- 4:20image, and likeness in a commercial context,
- 4:23we're talking generally about rights that fall
- 4:25under the broader umbrella of the right of publicity.
- 4:27But for animal performers, these protections
- 4:30fall away, leaving their identities unprotected
- 4:33in the same way. And why is that? Well, that's
- 4:36largely because these rights are born out of
- 4:38the common law. later codified, modified, or
- 4:42expanded by many state legislatures. And to our
- 4:44knowledge, no court has ever recognized a common
- 4:48law right of privacy or publicity belonging to
- 4:51a non -human being, nor has any state legislature
- 4:54extended such rights by statutes. So that brings
- 4:57us to the big question. If the right of privacy
- 5:01and the right of publicity are both defined in
- 5:03part by how a person's identity is used, then
- 5:07how do we protect the name, voice, image, and
- 5:09likeness rights of animal performers? Let's put
- 5:12it another way. If a person manages to make their
- 5:15pet famous, builds a recognizable name, a distinctive
- 5:18look, sound, or other identifiable quality, what
- 5:22legal mechanism do they have to control the use
- 5:24of their furry companion's identity and, frankly,
- 5:28to protect the investment they've made in that
- 5:31brand? Next slide, please. Trademark law. Quick
- 5:37disclaimer. We're talking here, of course, about
- 5:38federal trademark law. In particular, federal
- 5:41trademark law as enacted under the Lanham Act
- 5:43in 1946. There are, of course, state -based trademark
- 5:47laws. But we, again, don't have time to go into
- 5:49those today. So just be sure to check the local
- 5:52rules of your jurisdictions for all those fun
- 5:54nuances in gray areas. Next slide, please. So
- 6:00trademarks are all about communication. They
- 6:02tell customers, consumers where a product or
- 6:06service comes from. So we've gotten into out
- 6:08of the, what are we doing here with trademark
- 6:10law and into kind of the basics now of trademark
- 6:12law, what you should be aware of if you're going
- 6:14to go down this path. To be clear, before we
- 6:20go down this, I wanna be very clear about the
- 6:23term source, which we're gonna, I'm gonna use
- 6:24a lot and Lauren will use as well. We're talking
- 6:27about a trademark showing someone the source
- 6:30of a good or service. Source in this context
- 6:33does not necessarily mean the company that manufactured
- 6:37the product. In fact, the end user or consumer
- 6:41may not actually know who owns the company where
- 6:44the product was made. All that matters is that
- 6:47they know the trademark is pointing them to a
- 6:49consistent commercial source. So let's give a
- 6:53real world example of this for Sephora. The items
- 6:58sold under their brand name are not necessarily
- 7:00made by them. Same thing with Target. If you
- 7:03look on the back of a Target brand thing, it
- 7:04says distributed by Target, not manufactured
- 7:06by Target. So under the Lanham Act, a trademark
- 7:10can be any word, name, symbol, slogan, product,
- 7:13packaging, trade dress. A lot of these are fairly
- 7:16obvious. I'm not going to go into too many of
- 7:18them except to point out that something like
- 7:21a trade dress or product packaging, if you see
- 7:23the Coke bottle there, the actual shape of the
- 7:26Coca -Cola bottle, the glass bottle, is trademarked.
- 7:29and protected. Same thing with Hershey's Kisses.
- 7:33You'll see down there at the bottom, the shape
- 7:35of the Hershey's Kiss is trademarked. And we'll
- 7:38get into a little bit later how these shapes
- 7:40and sometimes you need secondary meaning. And
- 7:44that goes for things like if you see the tractor
- 7:46there, the green and yellow combination on certain
- 7:50farm equipment is a trademark of John Deere.
- 7:53That's a John Deere tractor right there. trademark
- 8:00prevents trademark law in order to allow this
- 8:04to work trademark law limits the ability of others
- 8:07to use the same or confusingly similar marks
- 8:09on their same or confusingly similar goods and
- 8:12services and more importantly it does this whether
- 8:15the trademark is registered or not that's actually
- 8:18that's how foundational this concept is and how
- 8:20powerful trademark law is federal trademark protection
- 8:24may be available for qualifying unregistered
- 8:27marks Although the scope of the protections and
- 8:31other benefits available to unregistered mark
- 8:34does differ, and it can substantially, from those
- 8:38available to registered marks. And we'll get
- 8:39briefly into that in a second. Just a quick note,
- 8:47let's just talk about how really important trademark
- 8:52law is. And it's one of the mechanisms that kind
- 8:55of undergirds the modern economy. If you think
- 8:59about it, a creator doesn't actually have to
- 9:01personally hand you their product every time
- 9:03you buy it. You go to the grocery store looking
- 9:06for your favorite cereal. You know exactly what
- 9:08it's called. You know what the box looks like.
- 9:10You know which Ralph's carries it and which don't.
- 9:13And that's the store that gets your business.
- 9:16When a consumer is able to identify a product
- 9:20or service that they want more of, the fact that
- 9:22they can walk into any store and trust it and
- 9:26only it to appear under that same name and in
- 9:29the same recognizable packaging the next time
- 9:31they wanted, that's the whole ballgame, right?
- 9:34That's everything. Next slide, please. So why
- 9:43register? I remember I touched on this very briefly.
- 9:46Unregistered marks under the Lanham Act, the
- 9:50term trademark is defined as a mark I'm paraphrasing
- 9:55here, is a mark used in commerce or that is,
- 9:59there's a bona fide interest to use it in commerce
- 10:01and it's registered. So that fact that a trademark
- 10:04can be just used in commerce allows unregistered,
- 10:07along with some other parts of the law, allows
- 10:09unregistered marks to be protected. as long as
- 10:13they're used in commerce, it may be geographically
- 10:15limited. That is, if you're defending in court
- 10:17the area where you're using the trademark, the
- 10:20court might say you can use this trademark in
- 10:22this part of the country, and it's not the same
- 10:24in the other parts of the country. So there's
- 10:26no presumptions. You have to establish that the
- 10:29mark is valid and protectable. You have to establish
- 10:32your ownership. And you have to establish the
- 10:34scope, which might include that geographic limitation.
- 10:38And then that's also where you might see TM.
- 10:40TM is only used or should only be used on unregistered
- 10:45marks. Federal registration gives you nationwide
- 10:48public service. It allows you to use the R, the
- 10:51registration mark, and it gives you, if you are
- 10:54having to, if you find yourself in court, it
- 10:57gives you presumptions of validity, ownership,
- 11:00as well as the exclusive right to use the mark
- 11:02for the list of goods and services. Next slide,
- 11:06please. In theory, trademarks can last forever.
- 11:10Um. This is obviously different from copyright,
- 11:13which is limited to the life of the author plus
- 11:1670 years or patents, which are limited to 20
- 11:19years, at which point it is given to the public.
- 11:21Trademarks are indefinite as long as generally
- 11:26you hit these main points, right? It remains
- 11:28in commercial use and is not abandoned. It doesn't
- 11:32accidentally or it doesn't become generic somehow.
- 11:36One of my favorite terms, genericization, fun
- 11:38to look up. It must continue to identify a particular
- 11:42source of goods. The owner must take reasonable
- 11:45steps to protect against infringement when necessary.
- 11:50The license uses must be subject to appropriate
- 11:53control. So if you are, let's say you're doing
- 11:55a partnership, if your trademark is appearing
- 11:58on another brand's product as a partnership,
- 12:03you should have controls over how that is used
- 12:06so that the public doesn't start seeing your
- 12:10brand associated with other things leading to
- 12:12weakening of the mark. And then you also have
- 12:14to worry about satisfying any applicable maintenance
- 12:17and or renewal requirements as well. One interesting
- 12:21example of a mark being protected against is
- 12:26what you see on the right hand side, Patagonia,
- 12:29suing the drag queen Patagonia for trademark
- 12:32infringement. This is really just in the last
- 12:34few months. You'll see May 27th on the article
- 12:37date there. You may have heard about this case
- 12:39between Patagonia and Patty. Full disclaimer,
- 12:43I followed Patty for years. I'm a big fan of
- 12:45both the aesthetic and the activism. Although
- 12:48frankly, I think Patagonia has a fairly strong
- 12:51argument here. So Patti has nearly 3 million
- 12:55followers across all of her social media platforms,
- 12:59of which I am too, on both Instagram and TikTok,
- 13:02where she encourages her followers to get out
- 13:04into nature and has also raised millions of dollars
- 13:07for environmental causes. Patagonia, which exists
- 13:11in the exact same space, if you know anything
- 13:12about it, alleges that Patagonia's use of the
- 13:16similar name in connection with the sale of clothing
- 13:18and other outdoor apparel, as well as very visible
- 13:22environmental activism, is likely to cause confusion
- 13:25among the public by causing them to believe that
- 13:28Patagonia sponsors approves of or is affiliated
- 13:30with Patagonia's products and activities. So
- 13:35this is ongoing. Apparently, there were attempts
- 13:38to try to settle. They thought that there was.
- 13:40It didn't go. Eventually, Patagonia concluded
- 13:43that it needed to file suit to protect its trademark
- 13:46rights. And actually, it's interesting, I would
- 13:49argue, that whether or not Patagonia ultimately
- 13:52wins in the end, filing the lawsuit helps publicly
- 13:56reinforce that lack of a tie, that non -authorization.
- 14:04Next slide, please. So secondary meaning or acquired
- 14:10distinctiveness, Lauren and I discussed this.
- 14:13We feel like we would be remiss if we didn't
- 14:15touch on secondary meaning. It's a really important
- 14:17concept in trademark law. That said, it is very
- 14:23context specific, very factually specific, and
- 14:26often jurisdictionally specific. And honestly,
- 14:30it can just be fairly confusing. So we're going
- 14:33to high level broad strokes. saying, remember,
- 14:38trademark rights do not arise just because a
- 14:42business uses a word, color, sound, scent, or
- 14:46image of a famous animal in connection with its
- 14:48goods and services. Fame alone is not enough.
- 14:52You can recognize a famous or well -known mark
- 14:55without understanding the mark to identify the
- 14:58source of the product on which it appears. Think
- 15:01if you're at Target and Target is selling a shirt
- 15:04with a logo of your favorite band on it, that's
- 15:07not necessarily showing the source of that product,
- 15:10right? You need to have that second association
- 15:14in order for trademark protection to apply. And
- 15:18that is if it's not inherently distinctive, That's
- 15:23when you'd need to establish that secondary meaning.
- 15:24So let's do some real -world examples of this
- 15:27to suggest this. If you go to the next slide,
- 15:32please. So some different examples of acquired
- 15:35distinctiveness, which is another word for secondary
- 15:39meaning. Color. Color is never inherently distinctive.
- 15:44It must acquire a secondary meaning or acquire
- 15:47distinctiveness. The color red on the bottom
- 15:51of Louboutin shoes did not automatically mean
- 15:54that consumers understood it as Louboutin's trademark.
- 15:58The company had to use it over time in such a
- 16:01way that consumers came to understand the red
- 16:04sole as identifying Louboutin as the source of
- 16:07the shoes. Even then, it's context specific,
- 16:11right? Because when Louboutin tried to sue Yves
- 16:15Saint Laurent to protect its trademark, they
- 16:17were making a line of shoes that had an all -red
- 16:20shoe, not just the sole. The Second Circuit holds
- 16:23that Louboutin's red sole had acquired secondary
- 16:26meaning, only in contrast with the rest of the
- 16:29shoe. So Yves Saint Laurent's shoe fell outside
- 16:33of the scope of the mark. Tiffany ooh, I brought
- 16:39in a prop Tiffany the fact that you don't even
- 16:42have to see Tiffany and company on this box The
- 16:44colors a little different in the screen that
- 16:47showed that's how Tiffany was able to trademark
- 16:49this color the color blue It's called 1837 if
- 16:52you go by painting Pantone's colors And even
- 16:55then it's contextual right Tiffany doesn't have
- 16:58this color blue and every on everything. It's
- 17:01only for the the goods and services that they
- 17:07have that registration for. Sometimes sounds,
- 17:15so moving to sounds, sounds sometimes require
- 17:18secondary meaning, sometimes they don't. Darth
- 17:21Vader's voice, Lucasfilm has a mark on the sound
- 17:24of Darth Vader's voice, is more likely to be
- 17:26inherently distinctive because it's described
- 17:30as the sound of rhythmic, mechanical, human breathing,
- 17:35through a scuba tank regulator. In context with
- 17:38a toy, that's more arbitrary and so it doesn't
- 17:41need that secondary meaning, as opposed to the
- 17:44bell from the New York Stock Exchange, which
- 17:46is more likely to need that secondary meaning
- 17:50because they use bells at a bunch of different
- 17:52stock exchanges. So they have to use it over
- 17:55time and be very specific with what that bell
- 17:56sounds like. And then finally, before I pass
- 18:01it off to Lauren, I do just want to be clear
- 18:04about what trademark law does not do. Oh, sorry,
- 18:08Plato at the bottom. They have a trademark on
- 18:13the scent. So whether you see the packaging or
- 18:16not, the fact that you smell Plato and you can
- 18:18recognize that as being Plato, that is trademarked.
- 18:23So just to be clear on what trademark law doesn't
- 18:26do, It is a specific protection, not a general
- 18:30protection. By asserting a right of publicity,
- 18:33a person can control commercial use of their
- 18:37identity based on the fact that it's their identity,
- 18:40right? Their identity. Trademark law, on the
- 18:43other hand, only protects an animal's identity
- 18:46to the extent that the animal's name, image,
- 18:48or likeness functions as an indicator of the
- 18:51source of particular goods or services. In other
- 18:54words, we're actually protecting that most American
- 18:57of things, the animal's ability to monetize their
- 19:00brand, right? Also, there's trademark limitations
- 19:04and defenses as well. Descriptive use, nominative
- 19:06fair use, First Amendment free speech, creative
- 19:09use, things like that. Now I'll pass it off to
- 19:16Linda. Yeah. So let's go to the next slide, please.
- 19:30So as Max explained, trademark law is the primary
- 19:35vehicle to monetize an animal's name image likeness
- 19:38because the right of privacy and publicity don't
- 19:41apply to animals. But just to be clear, the pet
- 19:46owners own these trademarks, not the animals
- 19:49themselves. So let's dig into some popular and
- 19:53successful animal trademarks. Next slide, please.
- 20:01We're going to start with an oldie but a goodie.
- 20:05The next slide. Lassie. So Lassie first appeared
- 20:11on screen in 1943 in the MGM classic Lassie Come
- 20:15Home. with a dog named Pal playing Lassie. Her
- 20:19trainer was Rud Weatherwatt, who would later
- 20:24also work with the dog who played Old Yeller
- 20:26and the Beagle, who served as the New York Mets
- 20:28team. Pal appeared as Lassie in six other MGM
- 20:32films through 1951. And then, in interesting
- 20:38development, Pal's trainer acquired the Lassie
- 20:41name and trademark from MGM. MGM apparently felt
- 20:44that after seven films over almost a decade,
- 20:49the dog Pal was getting older this time, that
- 20:51Lassie had run a course. So Weatherwax apparently
- 20:54acquired the rights in exchange for giving $40
- 20:57,000 in back pay that was apparently owed to
- 21:00him by MGM. Weatherwax went on to appear with
- 21:06Pal. went on to appear with Powell as Lassie
- 21:08at rodeos, fairs, and similar events across America
- 21:11in the early 1950s. And he also transitioned
- 21:14Lassie's career to television. In 1954, the television
- 21:17series Lassie debuted on CBS, and over the next
- 21:2019 years, a succession of Powell's ascendants
- 21:23appeared on the series. Next slide, please. But
- 21:29Lassie's legacy did not stop at film and television
- 21:33and live appearances. Lassie has been a registered
- 21:38trademark continuously for decades in a variety
- 21:41of categories. As you can see here, there was
- 21:45a line of Lassie dog food, a Lassie lunch box,
- 21:49and several types of Lassie plush toys. The Weatherwax
- 21:54family, as owners of the trademark, were able
- 21:57to benefit from Lassie long after Pal died and
- 22:00the Lassie show ended. And those rights have
- 22:03since changed hands to new owners over the years.
- 22:06In 2000, the Lassie trademark was sold by the
- 22:09remaining members of the Weatherwax family to
- 22:12Classic Media. And then in 2012, Classic Media
- 22:15was acquired by the Frameworks Foundation, and
- 22:17then it was renamed to Classics. And now that
- 22:20company is a subsidiary of NBC Universal as of
- 22:232016. As you can see, Lassie is not one specific
- 22:29dog. Lassie is a character and a trademark. The
- 22:32registered trademarks create continuity of the
- 22:34brand across multiple animals in over eight decades
- 22:37and allowed each generation of registered folders
- 22:39to maintain exclusive control over the name,
- 22:42likeness, and commercial identity, regardless
- 22:44of which animal performed the role on screen.
- 22:49Let's go to the next slide, please. Can we get
- 23:04the next slide, please? We're going to turn to
- 23:10a more modern example and one of the most well
- 23:12-known recent animal trademarks, grumpy cat.
- 23:16Where Lassie got her start on the big screen,
- 23:18grumpy cat modeled a new path to pet stardom,
- 23:21going viral. In 2012, a cat named Tartar Sauce
- 23:24with feline dwarfism and an underbite went viral
- 23:28for its hilariously grumpy expression. Reddit
- 23:31users created memes like, these on the right
- 23:35here. And Grumpy Cat's owners created social
- 23:39media profiles with the cat. Grumpy Cat's Facebook
- 23:42profile has around 8 million followers, and the
- 23:45Instagram account has around 3 million followers.
- 23:50Next slide, please. But Grumpy Cat's owners didn't
- 23:53let things stop at memes and social media. Grumpy
- 23:58Cat became the official spokes cat for Frisbee's
- 24:01cat products. Here's an Well, can we have the
- 24:04next slide, please? I can't give you the example
- 24:08yet. OK, here's an example of one of Grumpy Cat's
- 24:14sponsored posts as a spokescat. He's promoting
- 24:18a toy from Friskies. Grumpy Cat also partnered
- 24:23with brands such as Disney, Lifetime, Cheerios,
- 24:25and McDonald's. Next slide, please. The cat's
- 24:31owners formed an LLC and registered Grumpy Cat
- 24:34as a wordmark and as a sign mark. The marks cover
- 24:37multiple classes, including entertainment services,
- 24:39merchandise, and food and beverage. Examples
- 24:43include Grumpacino coffee, which is pictured
- 24:45here on the bottom left, and a wide variety of
- 24:48merch, including clothing, plush toys, balloons,
- 24:52as pictured here, along with other items such
- 24:55as phone cases, posters, and all kinds of things.
- 24:59And there are also several Grumpy Cat books and
- 25:02comic books. Grumpy Cat also appeared in the
- 25:06Lifetime film, Grumpy Cat's Worst Christmas Ever.
- 25:10Grumpy Cat's owners haven't disclosed how much
- 25:13money their trademarks have made them, but online
- 25:15speculation estimates it's in the millions. The
- 25:18Grumpy Cat trademarks played a significant role
- 25:21in this success. And although Grumpy Cat... or
- 25:24tartar sauce the real cat has sadly passed away,
- 25:26his owners can continue to generate revenue from
- 25:29their marks for years to come. Go to the next
- 25:34slide please. Our next example is a pug with
- 25:41around 18 million social media followers across
- 25:44various social media profiles. Doug the pug.
- 25:49He became famous for parody style videos, wearing
- 25:52human clothes, eating pizza, and participating
- 25:55in internet trends. And his owners have styled
- 25:58him as the king of pop culture. Next slide, please.
- 26:04Stud the Pug has been particularly prolific with
- 26:10brand partnerships, including a line of merchandise
- 26:13at Claire's, a range of stuffed animals, backpacks,
- 26:16and apparel with Gund, green cards with American
- 26:19greetings, a pair of shoes with Skechers, and
- 26:22a brand of pet CBD products. He's also partnered
- 26:25with Geico, like this picture on the top left,
- 26:29Hard Rock Cafe, and even the University of New
- 26:31Haven. It was a surprise to me. Doug's owner
- 26:37has used trademark law as an important tool in
- 26:39the monetization of Doug's brand, but it doesn't
- 26:42stop. there. Doug has also performed on screen.
- 26:45He appeared in Katy Perry's music video for Swish
- 26:47Swish, in Fall Out Boy's music video for Irresistible,
- 26:50and in the DNC lyric video for Kissing Strangers.
- 26:55Doug voiced the role of Monchi in the Sony Pictures
- 26:59Netflix animated feature of The Mitchells versus
- 27:02the Machines, and there is a Doug the Pug animated
- 27:05series in development as well. And he also has
- 27:07a foundation. Doug the Pug Foundation, a charity
- 27:11that helps children fighting cancer. So Lassie,
- 27:15Grumpy Cat, and Doug the Pug illustrate how valuable
- 27:19trademark protection is for these pet owners.
- 27:21Their positioning holds commercial value and
- 27:24attracts legitimate partnership deals because
- 27:27they have registered IP to back it up. Without
- 27:30the trademark, any competitor could launch a
- 27:32rival, sorry, if we go back, could launch a rival
- 27:35brand using the same name and imagery. These
- 27:37pets also illustrate that the trademarks are
- 27:40often part of a multifaceted strategy of monetization,
- 27:43combined with live performance, on -screen performance,
- 27:47and other types of valuable IP, including, you
- 27:50know, books. Okay, we could go to the next slide.
- 27:53Thank you. Grumpy Cat and Doug the Pug are petfluencers,
- 28:01which is... The pet fluencer economy started
- 28:06out as sort of a novelty and it was a narrow
- 28:09market, but over time it's grown to be commercially
- 28:12significant. Early partnership deals with pet
- 28:15fluenters focused on pet specific brands. For
- 28:18example, as I mentioned, Grumpy Cat was the official
- 28:20Friskies spokes cat and Friskies is an animal
- 28:23product company. But then these deals started
- 28:26diversifying beyond pet brands to mainstream
- 28:28consumer brands. For example, Doug the Pug with
- 28:31Skechers and Klairs. Jeff Pond, the Pomeranian,
- 28:34partnered with GAP. Now leading pet influencers
- 28:38will compete for and win partnerships across
- 28:41every major consumer category, from travel and
- 28:44hospitality to automotive brands, tech and smart
- 28:47home brands, and financial services. Additionally,
- 28:52high -end fashion and beauty brands have entered
- 28:54the chat. Pictured here on the right. is a dog
- 28:58with the handle Tika the Iggy, who has amassed
- 29:01more than 2 million followers on TikTok. She
- 29:04attends fashion weeks in New York and Milan and
- 29:06often wears designer products from Maschino,
- 29:09Valentino, Fendi, Boss, Thora, and Crocs. And
- 29:11she's also worked with beauty brands like Lady
- 29:13Gaga's House Labs, Dr. Barbara Sturm, and Drunk
- 29:17Elephant. And also pictured here on the left
- 29:20is a dog named Booby Billy with around 270 ,000
- 29:24followers. She specifically avoids pet brand
- 29:29partnerships in favor of luxury brands like Gucci
- 29:32and has partnered with Julie Brand Maturi. We
- 29:36can go to the next slide. So we're a bit tight
- 29:43on time now, but just to wrap things up, here
- 29:45are some common provisions that you might see
- 29:47in a pet fluencer deal. In -person services may
- 29:51be an element of the deal, such as photo and
- 29:54video shoots with the pet. handler services from
- 29:57the owner, trainer, and promotional appearances.
- 30:01There may be social media and other promotional
- 30:03deliverables. For example, having the pet's Instagram
- 30:06account promote the brand. And these deals could
- 30:11include a trademark license. In this section,
- 30:14the pet owner will want to ensure there's a narrow
- 30:16and exhaustive list of permitted uses of the
- 30:18marks. want approvals over any modifications
- 30:22to the mark, along with standard protective language,
- 30:25a goodwill remains with the owner. Also, there
- 30:29may be like a post -term use provision. For example,
- 30:31if there's merch for the brand to sell off, like
- 30:36a sell -off period for merch after the term.
- 30:40And there may be other IP being licensed, such
- 30:43as copyrighted artwork or custom creative materials
- 30:46that were created just for this deal. Custom
- 30:49creative the agreement should note who owns those
- 30:52materials are they owned by the brand the pet
- 30:55owner or frozen So neither party could use it
- 30:59those materials without the permission Depending
- 31:04on the structure of the deal there may be approvals
- 31:07and controls going both ways So the brand may
- 31:10want approvals over the post that the pet wants
- 31:12are posts on social media for example and vice
- 31:15versa if the brand is posting for reposting or
- 31:20boosting the pet posts. And if there's branded
- 31:24merch, the pet influencer may want approval over
- 31:26the designs for the merch. And you'll have typical
- 31:30parameters for approvals here, like deal with
- 31:34an approval right, so whether a submission is
- 31:36deemed approved after a certain period of time,
- 31:39how long the other party has to respond to a
- 31:41submission, and whether their approval can be
- 31:44unreasonable or delayed. How many passes of review
- 31:48do they get? Things like that. The brand partner
- 31:51may seek some form of exclusivity during the
- 31:53term. So, for example, maybe the pet influencer
- 31:56can't partner with specific competitors of that
- 31:59brand or others in certain categories, such as
- 32:02no other pet food companies. And with this, maybe
- 32:07there are carve -outs for pre -existing deals
- 32:09if the pet already partnered with another brand
- 32:12in that category. It's also possible to have
- 32:16exclusivity with the brand. So like the brand,
- 32:19maybe we would say the brand can't partner with
- 32:21another dog. This dog is the only dog partner
- 32:25for the brand. That would be maybe a higher level.
- 32:29In terms of compensation, the fee could be a
- 32:32flat fee per deliverable. It could be like a
- 32:34flat campaign fee and you may have royalties
- 32:36as well. So for example, royalties from the licensed
- 32:39merchandise with the animals marks on it. And
- 32:44then you might also have expense reimbursement.
- 32:48So maybe there's travel and accommodation for
- 32:50a shoot or a personal appearance, maybe even
- 32:56glam, which in this case would be grooming for
- 32:58the shoots. And then you would have some standard
- 33:02boilerplate provisions in here too, which I'll
- 33:04just briefly touch on. In terms of representations
- 33:09and warranties, the owner might represent and
- 33:11warrant that. they have the full legal authority
- 33:14to enter into the agreement and grant the rights
- 33:16that they're granting, that the animal is in
- 33:18good health, maybe they have to notify the brand
- 33:21if the animal isn't in good health, they'll rev
- 33:24and warrant that they own or control the license
- 33:26marks, the marks are valid and subsisting, that
- 33:31there's been no prior grant of rights that would
- 33:33conflict with these rights granted. All content
- 33:37created will comply with applicable laws such
- 33:39as FTC disclosure requirements, and that the
- 33:43owner will not make any false or misleading statements
- 33:45about the brand's products or services. And then
- 33:48in turn, the brand may rep and warrant that the
- 33:51brand has the authority to enter into the agreement
- 33:53that their products comply with applicable law,
- 33:56that they will only use the license marks as
- 33:58expressly authorized, and that the brand will
- 34:00comply with all applicable laws, including FTC
- 34:02disclosure law. And there may be some animal
- 34:07specific provisions like the owner's right to
- 34:09withdraw the animal from an activity on welfare
- 34:12grounds if there's unsafe conditions on set,
- 34:14for example. And there could be a requirement
- 34:17to obtain an animal liability insurance policy
- 34:20as well. Indemnification, if negotiated, this
- 34:25would typically be mutual. So each party would
- 34:28indemnify the other for claims arising from their
- 34:30breach. And then if the pet's providing services,
- 34:33maybe the owner will indemnify the brand for
- 34:36claims arising from negligence or behavioral
- 34:39issues with the dog. And then IP indemnification
- 34:43would probably go both ways. The owner and the
- 34:47brand indemnifying the other for claims arising
- 34:49from their brand or their marks. And then your
- 34:55classic other boilerplate provisions might be
- 34:59term and termination. breach, death, and capacity
- 35:02and mentality. As a final note, as you can see,
- 35:09trademark law is being used in human creative
- 35:12ways all the time, whether it's smells, sounds.
- 35:17And I'll point out one interesting parallel here
- 35:20that illustrates what a powerful and versatile
- 35:22tool trademark law is. We've been discussing
- 35:25how trademark fills a gap for animal performers
- 35:28where the right of publicity and privacy doesn't
- 35:30Apply pet owners can monetize the name image
- 35:33likeness of trademark law Recently humans have
- 35:39also been looking to trademark law to fill a
- 35:41gap created by recent developments in AI Taylor
- 35:45Swift has filed trademarks to protect her voice
- 35:48in appearance and money has done something similar
- 35:52performers increasingly are feeling that the
- 35:55right of publicity and privacy isn't enough to
- 35:57protect them in the face of this new technology,
- 35:59and so they have turned to trademark law. I mean,
- 36:03it's not the only place they're looking. Obviously,
- 36:04there's the Deepfakes Act, and there's other
- 36:07things people are turning to, but this is just
- 36:10an example of how trademark law is quite powerful,
- 36:17and especially when maybe other laws don't. get
- 36:21you where you want in terms of monetization.
- 36:26So we're a little over time. So with that, we'd
- 36:29just like to thank you guys all for tuning in
- 36:31and we'll wrap it up here. Thanks so much, everybody.
- 36:35Thank you so much.