Stranger Leaves His Car Running: The Disappearance of Earl Casey

Disappearance Stories · Jul 23, 2026 · 18m

Stranger Leaves His Car Running: The Disappearance of Earl Casey

A tidy Honda Civic was found at 7:14 a.m. on February 9, 2014 with the driver’s door open eight inches and an empty prescription bottle labeled Earl Casey placed upright on the dashboard - yet there were no footprints in the thin, uniform snow around the car. Who left the car running and why was Earl’s phone missing while his apartment showed no signs of disturbance?

In this episode, we lay out the facts of Earl Casey’s disappearance, from the scene at Calvary Ridge Church to the details investigators found in his apartment and…