Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Rear-Wheel Drive Electric City Car Benefits
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the Deep Dive. We're here to break down complex
- 0:12research into insights you can actually use.
- 0:15Today we're diving into something really fundamental in
- 0:17automotive engineering, especially now with electric
- 0:19vehicles taking over. It's all about how the power
- 0:22gets to the road, The shift from combustion engines to electric,
- 0:27well, it's shaking up how cars are designed from the ground up.
- 0:30We're asking that core question for EVs.
- 0:33Should they be front wheel drive FWD, rear wheel drive RWD, or
- 0:38all-wheel drive AWD? Exactly.
- 0:40And for this deep dive, we're leaning heavily on a a pretty
- 0:44detailed comparison thesis from researchers at the Polytechnico
- 0:47di Torino. They use some really
- 0:49sophisticated simulation tools to properly measure everything,
- 0:51consumption, cost, performance across these different layouts.
- 0:55So our goal here is to kind of cut through the jargon and
- 0:57understand the real technical trade off they uncovered.
- 0:59OK, good. Because you hear a lot about AWD
- 1:01and electric cars. You do, and the market
- 1:03definitely seems to prefer AWD or 4 wheel drive for EVs.
- 1:08People like the better handling, the safety, the traction, and
- 1:11what's interesting is with EVs, adding that second motor for AWD
- 1:15doesn't necessarily hit your energy use as hard as it would
- 1:19in a traditional car. It's a different calculation.
- 1:21Right. Unlike adding Dr. shafts and
- 1:24differentials in a gasoline car, OK.
- 1:25Let's unpack this. But before we even get to which
- 1:28layout is best, there's a story in how they even managed to do
- 1:31the research efficiently. Yes, the simulation speed.
- 1:35That was critical. So the researchers were using
- 1:38this standard test, the WLTP cycle.
- 1:40That's the worldwide Harmonized lightweight vehicle test
- 1:43procedure, right? Super important for figuring out
- 1:45EV range and efficiency. That's.
- 1:47The one the industry standard. But they ran into a problem.
- 1:49A big one. It was taking too long.
- 1:51Way too long. We're talking over 10 minutes.
- 1:53Yeah, 720 seconds to be precise, just to run 1 simulation cycle
- 1:58using their initial model. Wow, and if you want to test
- 2:00lots of different setups like different power splits for AWD,
- 2:0310 minutes a pop is just not workable.
- 2:06Exactly. It totally limits your ability
- 2:08to explore the possibilities. The bottleneck was essentially
- 2:12the complexity of their model. What kind of model were they
- 2:15using? It was.
- 2:16It was called a four wheel double track model.
- 2:19You can think of it as a a very detailed digital twin of the
- 2:23car. It simulates everything.
- 2:25All four wheels independently, steering angles, how the body
- 2:29rolls in corners, side slip, the works.
- 2:32You need that detail if you're simulating, say, aggressive
- 2:36cornering. OK, so very complex physics
- 2:38involved. Very complex, especially the
- 2:40tire models. They were using these things
- 2:42called Basajka magic formulas which are standard but
- 2:45computationally heavy, plus loads of look up tables for
- 2:48data. But then they had an insight,
- 2:50right? They did, they realized.
- 2:52Wait a second. The WLTP test cycle, when you
- 2:55run it in the lab on rollers, the cars just going straight,
- 2:58there's no steering involved. So if there's no steering, you.
- 3:01Don't need to calculate all the complex physics related to
- 3:03cornering. Things like side slip or body
- 3:05roll become pretty much negligible, so they could.
- 3:07Simplify. Radically simplify, they ditch
- 3:10the four wheel double track model and move to what's called
- 3:13a single track or sometimes a bicycle model.
- 3:16Bicycle model. OK, explain that.
- 3:18Imagine collapsing the car down its center line.
- 3:21You treat the front wheels as one combined wheel and the rear
- 3:23wheels as another, like a bike but with the cars mass and
- 3:27inertia. I see, So you still capture the
- 3:29forward motion, the acceleration, the braking?
- 3:32Precisely. You get the longitudinal
- 3:34dynamics you need for a straight line consumption test, but you
- 3:37throw out all the lateral dynamics calculations that
- 3:39aren't relevant here. That sounds incredibly clever,
- 3:42just focusing on what actually matters for this specific test.
- 3:45It's smart engineering. They also streamline some other
- 3:48things like removing unnecessary data logging.
- 3:52In the result, what was the speed up?
- 3:54It was significant. They cut the simulation time by
- 3:5625%, down to about 542 seconds. Still not instant, but much,
- 4:02much more manageable that. 25% gain must have made a huge
- 4:05difference for their ability to actually compare all the
- 4:08different configurations properly.
- 4:10Absolutely essential. It opened the door to really dig
- 4:12into the efficiency details, especially for AWD, which you
- 4:17know, brings us to their main findings on consumption and
- 4:19cost. OK, so with the faster
- 4:21simulations they could really explore how efficient these
- 4:23different layouts are. Now AWD in an EV has this
- 4:28theoretical perk right? Intelligent torque allocation.
- 4:30Yes, that's the big promise. The car's brain can decide
- 4:33millisecond by millisecond whether to send power to the
- 4:37front axle, the rear axle, or both, specifically targeting the
- 4:40most efficient operation at that exact moment.
- 4:43So what did the WLTP cycle simulations show?
- 4:47Did AWD live up to that promise? It did, but with A twist.
- 4:51Something quite counterintuitive actually came out of the
- 4:54consumption analysis. What's that?
- 4:57The most efficient way to run an AWD system is not a perfectly
- 5:00balanced 50.40 power split between the front and rear
- 5:03axles. Really I would just assumed, you
- 5:05know, share the load equally. That's got to be best.
- 5:07You'd think so, but it boils down to how electric motors
- 5:10work. Every motor has an efficiency
- 5:13map, combinations of speed and torque where it operates best,
- 5:16it's sweet spot. If you have two identical motors
- 5:20and you ask both to deliver a small amount of torque, they
- 5:23might both be operating quite inefficiently.
- 5:26The AWD system can be smarter. It can say, OK, for this amount
- 5:30of torque needed right now, it's actually more efficient to send
- 5:33most or even all of the power to just one of the motors, letting
- 5:38it run closer to its peak efficiency point.
- 5:40I see, so it's better to load up 1 motor effectively than to
- 5:44underutilize 2? In many situations, yes.
- 5:47That's why the simulation show the points of minimum
- 5:49consumption. The best efficiency often
- 5:52occurred with really uneven asymmetric splits.
- 5:55Like how uneven? We're talking things like 15% of
- 5:58the torque going to the front and 85% to the rear, or the
- 6:01other way around 85.15. 1585 that's basically acting like a
- 6:06rear wheel drive car most of the time, but with a little help
- 6:08from the front. Kind of, yeah.
- 6:10But the beauty is that the optimal split actually changes
- 6:13depending on how much power you're demanding.
- 6:15Well, the study found that as the total power needed drops,
- 6:18like when you're cruising steadily at lower speeds, the
- 6:21most efficient split tends to move closer to an even
- 6:24distribution. Maybe not 50.50 but more like
- 6:2730.70 or even 40.6 here. OK, so the AWD system gives you
- 6:32that flexibility to always find the best operating point,
- 6:35whereas a simple FWD or RWD car is just stuck with its single
- 6:40driven axle. Exactly.
- 6:41It offers optimized efficiency across a wider range of driving
- 6:44conditions, plus you still get the traction benefits when you
- 6:47need them. Makes sense, but efficiency
- 6:49isn't everything. What about the cost?
- 6:51Adding a whole extra motor and power electronics must add up.
- 6:55Absolutely. From a pure component cost
- 6:57perspective to WD whether it's front or rear is undeniably
- 7:00cheaper. Fewer parts, simpler set up.
- 7:02No surprise there. But the study did something
- 7:04interesting. They looked at the total vehicle
- 7:06cost, including a reference battery.
- 7:08They used a 90 kilowatt pack, which is pretty substantial.
- 7:11And when you factor in the expensive battery?
- 7:13The cost difference between a 2WD and an AWD powertrain
- 7:18suddenly looked much smaller in percentage terms.
- 7:21Often the premium for AWD was only around 5% of the total
- 7:24vehicle cost. Only 5%?
- 7:26That's less than I might have guessed.
- 7:29Still, 5% on a, you know, expensive EV is not pocket
- 7:33change. True, it's still a cost
- 7:35increase, but it puts the trade off into perspective.
- 7:38You're paying maybe 5% more for potentially better efficiency in
- 7:42some scenarios, plus significantly better performance
- 7:45and traction, which we'll get to.
- 7:47Is that 5% premium worth it just for the potential energy savings
- 7:51or is it more about the performance?
- 7:52That's the $1,000,000 question for designers, isn't it?
- 7:55The study suggests the efficiency gains alone might not
- 7:57always recoup the extra cost, but when you add performance,
- 8:01that changes things. And don't forget weight.
- 8:04Right, the AWD system adds. Weight.
- 8:05Yep, about 50 to 70 kilograms heavier than the 2WD versions in
- 8:09their simulations. Mostly the extra motor, inverter
- 8:12and associated bits. And weight is always the enemy
- 8:14of range. So it's this constant juggling
- 8:16act, Cost, weight, efficiency, performance.
- 8:18Oh, it's OK, let's talk performance then.
- 8:20The fun stuff. They looked at acceleration,
- 8:23right? Zero to 100 kilometers per hour.
- 8:25They did the classic 0100 kilometer Sprint and also the
- 8:3081120 kilometer 8 elasticity test which is a good measure for
- 8:35Hwy. overtaking power. And I bet AWD shines.
- 8:38Here. Oh, absolutely, especially when
- 8:40you start dealing with higher power levels.
- 8:42They tested up to 270 kilowatts, which is quite a bit of power.
- 8:45What happens with FWD and RWD at those levels?
- 8:48They just run out of grip, simple as that.
- 8:50They hit the tire traction limit really quickly, you stomp the
- 8:53accelerator and the tires just spin because they can't
- 8:56physically transmit all that torque to the road through only
- 8:59two contact patches. So you get wheel spin instead of
- 9:02acceleration. Exactly, which is obviously
- 9:04slows you down. AWD though, it just solves that
- 9:06problem. By splitting the torque demand
- 9:08across 4 tires instead of two, it dramatically increases the
- 9:12total amount of force the car can put down onto the pavement.
- 9:15Makes perfect sense. More grip equals faster
- 9:17acceleration. The results were clear,
- 9:19Significantly quicker acceleration times for the AWD
- 9:22configurations, especially at higher power.
- 9:24OK so AWD wins for outright acceleration if you have enough
- 9:28power, but what about the 2WD options?
- 9:32We see a lot of sporty EVs going for rear wheel drive.
- 9:35Why RWD over FWD for performance?
- 9:39There's a solid physics reason for that.
- 9:41It's not just tradition. RWD consistently performed
- 9:44better than FWD in the acceleration tests, even when
- 9:47traction was the limiting factor.
- 9:48Why is that? It's due to dynamic weight
- 9:50shift. When you accelerate hard, what
- 9:53does the car do? The nose lifts and the rear
- 9:55squats down. Right, right.
- 9:56The weight shifts backward. Exactly, and that shift puts
- 9:59more vertical load onto the rear tires.
- 10:01More load means potentially more grip, so the rear tires on an
- 10:05RWD car can actually handle more torque during acceleration
- 10:10precisely because of this weight transfer.
- 10:12So the active accelerating actually helps the RWD car put
- 10:15its power down better. Precisely.
- 10:17FWD has the opposite problem. The weight shifts off the driven
- 10:20wheels, reducing their grip potential just when you need it
- 10:23most. And there's another benefit to
- 10:24RWD for sporty driving. Isn't there something about
- 10:27steering feel? Yes, that's crucial too.
- 10:30With RWD, the front wheels are only doing the steering, not
- 10:33also handling the power delivery.
- 10:35This means the forces coming through the steering wheel are
- 10:37cleaner, giving the driver better a feedback.
- 10:39Whereas FWD can suffer from torque steer.
- 10:42Right torque steer is where the high torque going through the
- 10:45front wheels tries to pull the steering wheel left or right,
- 10:47especially if the grip isn't perfectly even.
- 10:50It's not ideal for performance driving feel.
- 10:52OK, so the performance picture is AWD is king if you have high
- 10:56power and want maximum acceleration.
- 10:59But if you're sticking with 2WD, RWD has inherent advantages due
- 11:03to weight shift and cleaner steering dynamics.
- 11:06That sums it up nicely. Yes, hashtag tag outro.
- 11:08So bringing this all together, what's the big take away from
- 11:12this research? It sounds like choosing the best
- 11:14EV powertrain isn't simple. Not at all.
- 11:17It really confirms that it's a classic engineering compromise
- 11:20wise. It depends entirely on what the
- 11:22primary goal for that specific vehicle is.
- 11:24If cost is absolutely the number one priority.
- 11:26Then you probably stick with a simpler, lighter 2WD layout,
- 11:30either FWD or RWD. Lower component costs, less
- 11:34weight. But if you're chasing maximum
- 11:36performance or you want that optimized energy efficiency you
- 11:39get from the really clever torque allocation.
- 11:41Then AWD becomes the clear winner, especially once the
- 11:44power levels get high enough that 2WD systems start running
- 11:47into those traction limits we talked about.
- 11:49And the research specifically showed that just a generic 50.50
- 11:53AWD split isn't the magic bullet for efficiency, right?
- 11:57Correct. The simulations suggest that a
- 12:00simple 50.50 split is often less efficient and potentially more
- 12:04costly in terms of components than a really well optimized
- 12:08asymmetric AWD system that constantly adjusts the split.
- 12:11Sometimes even a basic RWD setup might be more efficient than a
- 12:15naive 50.50 EWD. Yeah, you look at some major EV
- 12:19makers like Tesla for instance. They often use the same motor
- 12:22unit on the front and the rear axle in their dual motor cars.
- 12:25That kind of implies a default 50.50 or hardware capability.
- 12:28That's a very important point, and it leads us out of the pure
- 12:31simulation world and into to manufacturing reality.
- 12:33Because this research, detailed as it was, didn't really factor
- 12:36in economy of scale, did it? Exactly.
- 12:39Think about it from a car company's perspective.
- 12:41What if you could design just one standard excellent motor and
- 12:45power electronics unit? OK.
- 12:46And then you just install that same unit on the front axle for
- 12:49an FWD car, the Weir axle for an RWD car, or on both axles for an
- 12:54AWD car. A fixed 50.50 dough hardware set
- 12:57up by default. You'd save a fortune in design,
- 13:00manufacturing, inventory, logistics, building just one
- 13:03core component instead of multiple variations for
- 13:05asymmetric systems. Massive potential savings.
- 13:09And so here's the final provocative thought for you to
- 13:11chew on. Could those huge savings from
- 13:13mass producing a single standardized powertrain unit
- 13:16actually outweigh the small, measurable loss in energy
- 13:20efficiency that the simulations show, compared to a
- 13:23theoretically perfect but much more complex custom asymmetric
- 13:27AWD system? That's the real World Trade off,
- 13:30isn't it? Balancing peak technical
- 13:31optimization against the practicalities and costs of mass
- 13:34production. It's not always about squeezing
- 13:36out that last .1 kilowaters per 100 kilometer.
- 13:39It rarely is in the real world. There are always other factors
- 13:41at play. Well, this has been fascinating,
- 13:43a real journey from simulation optimization to the nitty gritty
- 13:47of powertrain choices. Thank you for walking us through
- 13:49it. My pleasure.
- 13:51And thank you all for joining us for this deep dive.
- 13:53We hope you feel better equipped to think critically about how
- 13:57electric cars are put together and the choices engineers are
- 13:59making for the future.