Latest / Falcon Forward / Private Equity, Lawsuits, and Your Insurance Bill
Transcript
- Peter Brecht: Welcome to Falcon Forward. It is July 2nd. We're already in July. ⁓ we've got the 4th of July coming up. My son's birthday is tomorrow. There's just so much activity in my household. ⁓ 250 years of ⁓ American history right here. So about to cross that line. anyways, Mike, how are you doing? I know ⁓ you're you're you're traveling or you're doing, you're kind of doing stuff. We're always doing stuff, but ⁓ how's things out your way? Mike Tanghe: Yes. Fantastic. birthday time of year with Braden's birthday in America. then today is my oldest 21st birthday. ⁓ yes, sorts of monumental stuff going on in our families, in nations lives. So happy birthday to all three of those important people. ⁓ Peter Brecht: All right. Yeah. Exactly. Man, I remember ⁓ so Braden's my first and he'll be seven, so he's in his mind he's a young man now and I think I agree with him. ⁓ but I remember I was in the hospital with my wife and it was July third like afternoon and I was like, Rach, you gotta hold like the fourth of July, we gotta hold on for another twenty four and she's like she looked at me and she's like, You can shut up now. ⁓ So you know, that's that's that's that's neither here nor there, but it's a very memorable moment in my early fatherhood. Mike Tanghe: less. Yes. Yes. Peter Brecht: ⁓ it was it was good. So anyways, ⁓ we're here to talk about a couple insurance things, update y'all on what's going on, some interesting news, some ⁓ I guess just highlights that we want to bring up. So I was listening to another podcast this morning actually, as I was get I was getting ready, ⁓ just about insurance, which is basically all I do. If it's you know not insurance related, it's oil and gas, or I'm hanging out with my family. But their ⁓ their overall synopsis of the Mike Tanghe: Okay. You Peter Brecht: the the the market right now, property markets are softening, litigation is getting more difficult. it's getting harder right now. ⁓ but interestingly, the last this last week, so third party litigation funding actually got cut in North Carolina. So there's been a lot of conversation around that. wanted to talk about what that is, ⁓ why this and maybe, you know, what are the chances that this gets kind of, I guess, introduced to other states. So Mike, I'll kick it over to you and we'll we'll kind of work through a couple of these quick topics. Mike Tanghe: Yeah, so excellent. this was welcome news for everyone in different, a few different ways we can measure that. So most people are fairly aware that politics in our country is this, you know, no one gets along or gets agrees on anything. So in North Carolina, they passed in their on a 45 to one. So 45 in favor, one opposed. So you know if it's legislation like that, like that's usually, you know, for the feel-good stuff, proclamations of so-and-so's day in the city or like very few votes are unanimous or in this case 99 % unanimous. And what they did was they passed a law prohibiting called litigation funding, third-party litigation funding. ⁓ you know, what does that, what does that mean? ⁓ what that means is you cannot ⁓ like a private equity company that says, ⁓ have no relationship to you, ⁓ we'll fund your lawsuit against whatever company that you want to sue. And know, kind of unpack like when would this happen or why would this happen? ⁓ So you think about it, in our in the U.S. society, and this is why everyone who complains about the cost of their insurance, this is a large reason why your insurance costs what it does is... When an accident happens, it's viewed as almost a lottery ticket in US society, meaning that, my gosh, something bad happened to me. Who can I sue to make pay for this? ⁓ for certain things, ⁓ when there is a clear, you know, someone did something bad and deliberately tried to hurt someone, ⁓ yes, should be lawsuits in those types of instances ⁓ if other party doesn't step up and first fix what they did, like acknowledge what they did was wrong. and cover those costs. We don't always have to have lawsuits for every certain thing because again, people will realize, ⁓ my gosh, this is a terrible incident. get it. Like ⁓ at fault. Like how can I fix this for you on So but if think it, we've now gotten to a point where again, anyone who's injured thinks someone else needs to pay for this when it purely could just be an accident or even worse, that could not even be an accident. It could be someone who does something dumb on their own. ⁓ And is injured and again, why should they get compensated by someone else for this? So if you think about how things were let's say 10 years ago 15 years ago 20 years ago if something bad happened to me and went home and I'm injured and I'm talking to someone and someone's like, you should sue And let's say it's an iffy case like, you know I wasn't paying attention or I was doing something wrong or I was doing something dumb because I mean ⁓ we've all stories about you know, the person who Spills coffee on themselves and sues the person who gave them the coffee for millions of dollars or people who are Trespassing on someone else's property and they fall and get hurt and then sue for that or you know ⁓ San Diego There is one where someone was fleeing the police Wouldn't when the police wanted to pull them over they're fleeing the police and ⁓ you know crashed their motorcycle and got a multi-million dollar pay payment because they were ⁓ being chased the police ⁓ on stuff Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: So just all these types of things that can happen. If you had a frivolous case, you're going to go to a lawyer and you're going to say, hey, here's my case. And lawyers in a lot of these situations will take things on what's known as a contingency basis, meaning they don't get paid unless they win. So a lawyer is going to look at this and they're going to be like, hey, if this thing has a good probability of winning, I'll take it, right? And I think you have a good case. And why do think that ⁓ or why they care about that? They want to get paid. And if something has no probability of winning, a lawyer is going look at that and be like, sorry, I'm not going to waste my time in the unlikelihood that we're going to get a payout because I know the law, I've seen how these things work, and you have no shot at all on this. And what that effectively does is that law firm is kind of creating a bar that you must surpass of enough things must have gone wrong in that situation. There must be enough, at least hints of negligence in these situations. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: for an attorney to be like, yeah, this is worth my time of working for three, six, nine, 12, 24 months, however long these things stay, expending my own resources on that, because I know that there's a high likelihood that I'll get paid on it. So if you imagine that's our bar, again, what do our insurance companies do? They look at the law of large numbers, if they insure X number of homes, if they insure this number of vehicles, if they have this number of liability umbrellas out there, that... just through their law of large numbers and their use of data and statistics, they'll know that, for this many customers, this is how many claims that we'll expect to happen just because we've been doing this a hundred years and we have this historical data. Now all of a sudden you have these third party companies coming in and going to those law firms and saying, hey, we know that you turned down 50 % of the cases that come across your desk. And we know why you do that, because you know that they have no problem with these cases winning. The very smart people when it comes to numbers, maybe a little challenged on the ethics front ⁓ the P.E. side will say, hey, we want you now to take every single one of those cases. ⁓ you know, the lawyers responses, why would I do this? I'm not going to get paid. ⁓ private equity people are saying, don't worry about that. We will pay you for single case that you take. And then in exchange for doing that, we want now a portion of it, of what comes in on it. And what these private equity companies know is that if they flood the legal system, which they have done over the past several years, that insurance companies are now going to be more likely to settle frivolous claims. And, you know, if you spend two grand on attorney fees from what this private equity company would be advancing or paying in this case, and they're getting enough 10K settlements, and then some of them may be 15K, some of them 20, 25, 30, they know that, again, just through their use of data and statistics. Peter Brecht: Mm. Mike Tanghe: that this is financially a very profitable ⁓ way for these guys to try and earn another dollar. Something that private equity folks are very good at. But it goes along, just because you can make money at doing something, again, it's blowing up a system that wasn't designed for that. So this clogs up our courts so that the necessary cases, the real ones that should be litigated or tried in front of judges or juries, ⁓ clogs everything up. and our courts just cannot function. We don't have enough judges. We don't have enough people signing up for or volunteering for jury duty to do all this. So ⁓ just jams up the whole system. And that's what's happened with litigation funding in that insurance companies are now paying out more than they intended to pay out ⁓ on historical data. court systems are getting clogged up where that real people or real cases aren't getting their ability to be heard in timely fashions and that's why these things can take years to play out. And again, it's just not how our system was designed to do. ⁓ so you're now seeing the legislatures in these states saying, wait, hold on a minute. These private equity guys, you know, they're always one step, it seems like ahead of everyone else in how they can make a buck and we're going to allow it in our state. And North Carolina was the first state. to do this and the fact that they voted 45 to 1 ⁓ a very powerful lobbying tribal bar is pretty astounding to me. So anyways, pause. There's a lot of talking right there as usual for me, but does that make sense or questions on how that works Peter? No, I Peter Brecht: No, I I mean I think it it makes perfect sense. I can't I'm just sub I'm honestly I got I saw that headline, I was surprised that it occurred. Like it to me is surprising that that we had common sense, I guess. But what are the like how quickly do you think and this is a this is such a hypothetical, but how quickly do you think that this changes anything with insurance in that state? Because to me, if I'm an insurance carrier, I'm thinking, okay, I only have to worry about real claims now. I don't have to think about certain things. I I like I guess do you think it really has an impact on any of those th from from a material perspective in within the next, let's say, two years? Mike Tanghe: Two years I think would be pretty aggressive. think this is more like if you're a consumer and you think, my rates have been going up, my auto insurance rates, my home insurance rates, at least the liability portion of that have been going up or my umbrella. So I think realistically, like this is something that, like this gets passed in North Carolina, there'll be appeals, there'll be further appeals. Pretty resounding though that 45 to one shows that, you Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: Again, hopefully that they drafted this legislature with something that can withstand appeals. I think more realistic realistically is three to five years where you start to see a difference. ⁓ But, where this is good is insurance companies, you know, when they charge ⁓ what they think they need to charge, they use forecasts of, if litigation were to continue like we've seen it, then ⁓ here's what our three year, four year, five year, 10 year rates look like. this modeling will come in and will certainly soften that. And then if enough time goes by and ⁓ goes through and private equity has a thought of a new way to try and bend the rules, then very positive for all. And it also positive the direction, you know, this article that we had come across noted that, California, Colorado and Illinois are all considering the same type of legislation. Again, California, super powerful trial bar state, not employer friendly at all. So the fact that, and then also, you know, heavily 90 some percent, think is our... ⁓ Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: the Democrat to Republican tilt in the state. So the fact that their legislature is even considering this, it's like, wow, like probably isn't something that's good overall for our country ⁓ or consumers ⁓ ⁓ Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. I have a ⁓ there's a guy that I used to go to high school with and ⁓ he became a a litigation attorney and he's kind of I follow him on on on one social media platform purely for entertainment. ⁓ and and like I actually learn like what the other side looks at and it's pretty fascinating just to see what they're looking at from a like when they get the when they actually get a grow a group of people to to be backed by private equity how that goes down. It's very interesting to kind of watch. And he's very public about it. I'm surprised. I won't share his Instagram. You can ask me personally, but ⁓ it's it's pretty interesting to see. ⁓ not the not the role of life I thought. Like he was not an attorney type person in high school by any means. And here he is. He's very successful in San Diego. So anyways, our next topic, so if we can move on unless he had any other comments, but so Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Peter Brecht: Auto insurance, uninsured motorist, underinsured motorist, all that. most recent statistics statistic came out. It's one in three drivers went uninsured last year. One in three. last survey that I read on this, I think was from 2022, and it was one in seven. ⁓ and I think the the that was that was a a national survey they took. I think California was one in four, but one in three, that is ⁓ that is ⁓ a that's astounding. Mike Tanghe: Yeah, it's a function of cost, If you've got to put food on the table and you have an insurance premium that's due next week and it's either going go to one or the other, I'm not faulting the logic that goes into that. But things that we talked about in our prior topic, the litigation funding, that drives up everyone's costs on things. these attorneys that were exploiting the litigation funding and the PE firms backing them, again, they're saying there's no free lunch. Someone has to pay for these things and ⁓ invariably in higher costs for everyone else. So we're not gonna solve on this podcast the society challenges that cause people to choose one or the other. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: your family or paying for your insurance costs. But again, without like I'm too much on a soapbox is if you're going to operate a vehicle, you should operate in a responsible way, which means carry insurance that if an accident does happen and you cause injury or injures someone else's car, ⁓ that you insurance that will pay for the damage that you've caused. So ⁓ again, Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: arguing or going into detail on why people could be in that instance. But the reality is, okay, you we're not going to solve it on this podcast conversation. And for our clients, they're also not going to solve it themselves. But it does leave them in a very exposed position of that, you know, if I'm driving my car and I'm obeying all the rules of the road and someone hits me and they either have too low insurance or they don't have any insurance, okay, what does that mean for me? What am I going to do in that situation? ⁓ so there's coverage that we, you all clients will carry, which is called uninsured motorist coverage or underinsured motorist coverage if they have too little. And it's designed to one, pay for your car so that if ⁓ your car is damaged someone else, that it's not something that you would have to pay for. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: most people don't realize though is that your deductible will apply in those situations. So you'd have to pay for your deductible even though you weren't at fault in that instance. And then if the insurance company is able to collect either via lawsuit or ⁓ judgment other party can pay. Sometimes you come across people that just they can pay ⁓ for they have assets. But they whatever reason either carry too low insurance or they don't carry any at all. And in those you can collect a judgment against those people. ⁓ Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: have the money, can force them to pay. In which case your doctor will get refunded in those instances. know, are cars, right? Some are very expensive, but I don't of anyone that we know of that. a car would physically them. just not realistic. ⁓ However, just imagine you're injured and you work or you have some, ⁓ one of our producers, his spouse was ⁓ by an uninsured driver ⁓ many years ago and ⁓ six or seven back later. It's been a significant lifetime of challenges in and costs that she's had. that is something that could potentially, if not bankrupt, significantly alter your lifestyle from paying for medical costs, from making up for lost salary if you're unable to work, or hiring someone if you're going to, in a worst case scenario, like if you're paralyzed or something like that, I mean, you're talking hundreds of thousands of dollars, if not more, a year that you weren't expecting to pay. Peter Brecht: Mm-hmm. Mike Tanghe: Again, who's going to pay for that? If you have good uninsured motorist coverage and you have uninsured motorist coverage on your excess or umbrella policy, that's how you mitigate against that risk. Yeah. Peter Brecht: Yeah. very it's it's such a tough topic, but but because yeah, it i it is a there is a a sensitivity to all these things, right? And there's ⁓ like you a lot of things to solve. ⁓ if we travel across the Atlantic and we go to Belgium, right? It's a little different over there, right? And and you you brought this up. I just want to bring it up because it was interesting as we were kind of talking before we hit record, but ⁓ Belgium handles things a little different and Mike Tanghe: Right. Yes. Yeah. Peter Brecht: I don't know if I'm I think I like it. So maybe we could share what they do over there. A little different. Mike Tanghe: Yeah. the World Cup fans out there, ⁓ versus the US is the next ⁓ of games for the US. I have, my father's originally from Belgium. He was the only one in his family who immigrated, which is a long time ago, 1960s. But ⁓ what's super cool about is ⁓ my cousins that I in Belgium, I see as often as ⁓ cousins that I have in the US. and that's been throughout our whole life. So special to have a relationship of people in a foreign country, ⁓ at school. And we running low on things to talk about, but my cousin was making a comment on how many ⁓ tickets he's had, ⁓ speeding tickets traffic tickets and all these other types of tickets, like ⁓ monthly tickets. of course, having in the insurance and that insurance mine. So I'm thinking to myself like, man, how do you get insurance? the question, Kurt, how do you get insurance? he kind of looked at me like incredulously, like what do mean? I'm like well doesn't all these tickets that you have, I would think your insurance would be sky high or even if you could even get insurance on it because he gets a lot of tickets it sounds like. Not all he tells his family about so hopefully they're not listening. Peter Brecht: Sure. Mike Tanghe: you know, he again looked at me kind of incredulously and said, no, he's like, the insurance companies don't find out about your tickets. He's like, that's invasion of my privacy. So I just found that very interesting that, ⁓ so I a little research on how does Belgium work for their insurance. And so in Belgium, ⁓ everyone pays the same level of insurance for stuff. again, it's not quite socialism ⁓ over there, but, you they definitely are ⁓ much more of a socially focused country than it is in the US. And so everyone will pay the same level of insurance. And then if you go accident free, which of course your insurance company is going to know about, because they're the ones who are paying out for that accident. So if you haven't called them that year, no accidents, then your insurance ratchets down or your cost will ratchet down year over year over year. And if you get tickets, it has no bearing on your insurance at all. But if you do get an accident, then you lose that kind of claims free and you get bumped up and you'll pay higher insurance for a number of years until it starts ratcheting down again after you start going claims free. So people get a lot of accidents in Belgium, very expensive insurance or difficult to buy insurance. ⁓ get a lot of tickets but no accidents, ⁓ you can pay some of the lowest rates. And then again, It's framed upon this would be an invasion of your privacy if you share what your driving habits actually are. Versus in the US, we'll at things like what's your credit? Where do you live? What kind of car do you have? If you sign up for Telematics, how ⁓ fast do accelerate? So all these of characteristics that will come up with a very unique profile. And again, if you ⁓ check low risk for those categories, going to pay a lot less in insurance versus again that more socialized outlook in Belgium where everyone will pay higher. So in the US the very safest drivers would pay a lot lower than they did in Belgium. And the, but conversely in Belgium, your high risk drivers are going to pay less in Belgium they would if they were in the US. So ⁓ again, there's no free ⁓ At ⁓ the end the all the costs ⁓ have to get figured ⁓ amongst that group. So I thought that was He did share with me though, one thing that ⁓ actually I would be in favor of, but in the US. ⁓ Peter Brecht: Hm. This is this is what I liked about what you said. This was the thing I was like, I I like this one. Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Yeah. know, inattentive driving or people not paying attention. So again, without boring people completely on stuff. In the 1970s, driving was very, very dangerous on the US freeways and highways. was in so much so that towards the end of the decade, 1980 ish, insurance companies and the government and car manufacturers got together and they're like, like this can't go on. Like this is truly an epidemic of how many people are dying on our roads. And so they did a couple of things. And for those who are my age or older, you'll remember like seat belts were, ⁓ know, if your car had them, they were lap belts, which did not really do a whole lot of good. And you know, ⁓ they they were almost an optional ⁓ and majority of people weren't using seat belts at all. The other thing that people were doing that isn't necessarily good for driving was there was no social taboo on drunk driving. Like it was almost funny. Like, man, you know, ⁓ was plastered last night and can't believe he made it home. You know, ha ha. know, people would laugh at cocktails over lunch the next day talking about ⁓ So the worked with car manufacturers and said, hey, we got to make seat belts safer. And if you remember cars in the 1980s, they actually had automatic seat belts that when you sat down, ⁓ like a physically the seatbelt like went over you, you had no control over it. It's hilarious. Yes. And then when people kind of found their way around that and like would unbuckle it afterwards, it would create these super annoying alarms on stuff. ⁓ But it got to a point where everyone started wearing seat belts because your kid, you know, they would do public service announcements that would tell kids to tell your parents to buckle up. So when you got in the car, Peter Brecht: They were so cool. I still think they're really cool when they do that. It's like, yeah, it's high tech. Mike Tanghe: and you weren't bucking up, know, you're kidding the back seats like, you know, mom, dad, you know, we saw something at school that says you're going to die. So it eventually changed societies that now seat belts, think the majority of people, vast majority of people were just put on a seatbelt. It's an automatic and now there's shoulder belts, lap belts, you know, much, much safer that went into it. Peter Brecht: Yep. Well, Volvo, so I don't know I don't know how many people know this, but I'm a like a logo geek. I love this stuff. But Volvo's logo is the is the driver's seatbelt across the chest, right? And so they actually supposedly patent that and shared it with the world and saved a lot of lives. But that's if you ever see a Volvo, you'll see that that cross. That's meant to be the the seatbelt. So big deal. and they and they love telling people about it. It's like their thing. So Mike Tanghe: the that drives the seat belt across That's funny. I thought the Volvo symbol was always like the male symbol. Like marking like a male bathroom or something. Peter Brecht: Yeah, no, it's ⁓ th yeah, if you look at any front of a Volvo, yeah, they're gonna have that crossbar across the the front, like they will not they don't wanna let that thing go. So which is cool. I like it. I think it's it's testament to their safety, you know, they're one of the safer cars on the road and all that and ⁓ they Yeah, it yeah, very much so. ⁓ new moms love Volvos, right? It's kinda one of their slogans. Anyways. Mike Tanghe: Nice. Yeah, 100%. Yeah, seatbelt wearing is now something that everyone does. Drunk driving is no longer this ha ha. It's again, one of those social taboos with pretty heavy penalties for people who do that. So what all that did was, starting in early 1980s, every year, the death per mile statistic, which is how they measured it, how many miles are driven, how many people are dying, that dropped every single year from like 1982 or 84 from when it peaked, had been, you every year been going up, up, up, up, peaked. And then it started going down and literally went down until, I'm probably should have researched this a little bit, but probably 2022 is when it reversed. And why is it reversed? And why is that now going back up? Cars are infinitely more safer now than they were in the eighties with. Peter Brecht: Mm. Mike Tanghe: warning lights and airbags and all these types of things, but it's distracted driving. So it's everyone on their phone has now caused the fatality rate per miles driven to start increasing back up. So it's a concern all over the world and Belgium, in my opinion, has a pretty drastic way of dealing with it. If you're holding your phone, like it has to be in your center console, can't be on your passenger seat, can't be in your hand. Kurt, my cousin, relayed to me that ⁓ he, in his mind, 100 % was not holding his phone, it was locked away, but his wallet looks like his phone, was holding his wallet, got pulled over, he was a few hours from home, ⁓ anywhere from eight to 15 days immediate suspension of your license, doesn't matter where you are, but gotta pull your car over on the side of the road and you're not driving, you're in the penalty box for, ⁓ in case, it was 14 days. And not a huge fine, he said it was like a 175 euro fine, couple hundred bucks. But he had to call his wife, call his son to come drive out and pick up him, pick up the car. that's, but again, not reporting your insurance company. So you have a two week, can't drive applied immediately if you have that, which again, is a lot more drastic than here in the U S on things. But again, way of that kind of social system of ⁓ the Belgium government, skirting laws on some side of the table of can't share. ⁓ ⁓ tickets with your insurance company those are separate but ⁓ they can take away your license for up to two weeks for being on the phone so ⁓ ⁓ Peter Brecht: Yeah. There would be a lot less drivers, teenage drivers especially, in my neighborhood, if they got rid of that. It's ⁓ it's a thing. So anyways. Mike Tanghe: I mean, you could just have a massive impound lot at any intersection and just direct people into it. especially at night when you look, the glow of everyone on their phone ⁓ is quite interesting. So anyways, that's your Belgium versus US. Peter Brecht: ⁓ yeah. Mm-hmm. Well, it's it's it's it's my navigation. Like I I I use it my car to navigate. Like anywhere I go, even if I'm driving to the office and I know where I'm going, I still have my phone up with navigation running. And that you know, there I go. I guess I'd take my car too, but ⁓ bummer. Well, ⁓ yeah. Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Yeah. So we'll see. Yeah. Big World Cup game between those two countries. So we'll see who maybe the Belgian bus driver will be on his phone on the way to the game. Peter Brecht: Yeah. let's hope not. we'll see. I mean I like it's it's good to watch the games either way. It's been fun. MLR season's over too. I mean, we've got ⁓ lots things to watch and keep up with. So we we definitely overshot our fifteen minute goal here, Mike, by double. but I guess it's just good to catch up and keep things going. So ⁓ thank you guys for listening. Have a happy fourth Falcon West. We're ⁓ closing a little early today so we can all get started with our Mike Tanghe: Yeah. Ha ha ha. Yeah. Peter Brecht: our weekend plans and ⁓ we'll see you back again next week. Mike Tanghe: Sounds great. Thanks, Peter. Happy birthday to Braden, too. Peter Brecht: All right. Thank you, Mike.