Latest / The Women's Soccer Podcast / The NWSL's Youth World Cup Dilemma: Why Informal Negotiation Makes Everyone Lose
Transcript
- 0:09The U -20 World Cup is a biannual tournament
- 0:12that often comes and goes without making many
- 0:14headlines. U .S. women have historically not
- 0:17had the same dominance in that competition that
- 0:20they've had at the senior level, but it's often
- 0:22seen as a vital stepping stone for players to
- 0:24get the needed international experience before
- 0:27ultimately putting on the U .S. kit and representing
- 0:30the badge at the senior level. The last time
- 0:32a U -20 Women's World Cup happened was just a
- 0:35few months after Emma Hayes started her tenure
- 0:37officially as the head coach of the US Women's
- 0:40National Team. The senior team had just won an
- 0:43Olympic gold medal despite Hayes' minimal time
- 0:46with the team before the competition. I felt
- 0:48like a new vision was budding for a program that
- 0:50had long -term benefits, not just with the senior
- 0:53team, but with the overall structure of the program.
- 0:56And that came down to youth teams. So at the
- 0:59time, a third place finish in the U -20 World
- 1:01Cup wouldn't have seemed that disappointing.
- 1:03Hayes had just started and her ability to really
- 1:05have a lot of say in the program at that time
- 1:07was minimal. Two years down the line, the U -20
- 1:10program really still serves as a very vital and
- 1:13important phase in a player's development. And
- 1:15Hayes' emphasis on developing not just the U
- 1:19-20 and younger programs, but also the U -23
- 1:21program, I think that a big part of the general
- 1:24ethos of the U .S. national team now is the interconnectedness
- 1:28between the U of T teams and the senior team.
- 1:31And so looking ahead to this U -20 World Cup,
- 1:35it's really interesting that... Four players
- 1:38in Claire Hutton, Willie Ohannes, Jordan Buck,
- 1:42and Kimmy Ascanio, among many others, were all
- 1:45left off of the C20 World Cup roster. Not for
- 1:49form, of course, but because they weren't released
- 1:51by their clubs or because there was some sort
- 1:53of misalignment. We don't know the exact reasoning
- 1:56for each player not partaking in this competition.
- 2:00Given Vicky Jepsen's remarks at her press conference
- 2:03recently, we've heard about how these competitions
- 2:06are. really important for players' development,
- 2:09something that Emma Hayes has repeatedly mentioned
- 2:11to the media. These experiences are really important
- 2:14for these players to develop. And when I posed
- 2:17this question, thinking about the morals, the
- 2:19benefits, the stakeholders in the situation and
- 2:23who benefits, and given the fact that we saw
- 2:26the compromise that England made with... very
- 2:29own NWSL players, Erica Meg Parkinson and Lauren
- 2:31Thompson, who skipped the Portugal pre -camp
- 2:34but got to go to the actual World Cup. It got
- 2:36me thinking, with other federations and NWSL
- 2:40teams that the majority of these U -20 U .S.
- 2:43players are being held back from participating
- 2:45in the World Cup from, could negotiate and could
- 2:47find common ground to benefit all parties involved,
- 2:52why can't this be done with U .S. soccer and
- 2:55the club teams? The big topic of this episode
- 2:58today goes far beyond just this World Cup and
- 3:01really how seeing how these tensions of the growth
- 3:05of the game, everyone wanting the slice of the
- 3:08pie that the game is growing and how when incentives
- 3:11clash, both club and country can suffer. And
- 3:15I think we saw a situation here where everyone
- 3:18in Norway suffered. The player doesn't get the
- 3:19experience to go to the World Cup. They might
- 3:22be mad at the club because they were held back.
- 3:24The country, of course, suffers because they
- 3:26can't have the best players in that age group
- 3:28available to get the necessary experience. And
- 3:31so that's where I want to start today. The same
- 3:33NWSL infrastructure produced two completely different
- 3:36outcomes for national teams within weeks of each
- 3:39other. And while the Lionesses were able to find
- 3:42a solution and collaborate with NWSL to avoid
- 3:45the very same problem US soccer is facing, at
- 3:48the end of the day, US soccer was unable to call
- 3:51up the roster that they would have wanted to
- 3:53do because of NWSL teams holding players back.
- 3:56So let's think about the role. Why can NWSL clubs
- 3:59hold these players back? Because I think that's
- 4:01a misconception that a lot of people have because
- 4:03it's not like senior international competition
- 4:05where it's in designated international FIFA windows
- 4:09where clubs are legally mandated to release players.
- 4:12This is not a big thing that... is publicized
- 4:17and it's not even something really in the cba
- 4:19the cba only defines national team duty as players
- 4:22going away from their clubs to represent their
- 4:24country i think if you look at the mandatory
- 4:26release date for the world cup in 2023 it was
- 4:3010 days before the opening match july 10th and
- 4:33so the youth running world cup like other youth
- 4:36tournaments because it's not part of the official
- 4:38fifa windows during which clubs are required
- 4:41to release players it actually isn't a tournament
- 4:44where the clubs are mandated to release people.
- 4:46This isn't a women's soccer gap or a US Women's
- 4:50National Team specific problem. It's something
- 4:52that every FIFA youth tournament, every federation,
- 4:54every gender faces. It's a calendar architecture
- 4:57argument that speaks to how with the finite time
- 5:01we have in the soccer year that feels like it's
- 5:04just getting more jam -packed every year of fixtures.
- 5:08There's definitely a big point here of the overall
- 5:13systemic tensions between federation and clubs.
- 5:17So I think there's something that is really important
- 5:20to see here is that it's not just NVSL clubs
- 5:24that are facing these problems because the U
- 5:26-20 World Cup also clashes the beginning of the
- 5:28European season and their preseason. And so European
- 5:31clubs have called the national associations to
- 5:33stick to the rules around the release of players
- 5:36for this year's Women's World Cup. And that was
- 5:38something that happened more in 2023 where...
- 5:41The European Club Association said it was concerned
- 5:43about the volume of alerts from the members clubs
- 5:46on national sides calling up players for international
- 5:49duty outside of the mandatory release windows.
- 5:52And now the funny part about this is Emma Hayes
- 5:55is on national team side, was on club side. She
- 5:58was the coach of Chelsea in that fight in 2023
- 6:01before she became a national team voice arguing
- 6:04the opposite. Even the advocate's position, who
- 6:07is fighting for these players to be released,
- 6:09has evolved. She was for keeping players at club,
- 6:12and I think it speaks to the incentive analysis
- 6:14of this situation, and that everyone is coming
- 6:17to the table with the right mindset. But the
- 6:20mechanism is the real issue here, because the
- 6:23release obligation for FIFA competitions is compulsory
- 6:27for all international windows listed in international
- 6:30match calendars. World Cups aren't on that calendar.
- 6:35It's not just the fact that FIFA doesn't require
- 6:37it, that's the problem. It's the fact that it's
- 6:40not even acknowledged in the calendar. And that's
- 6:42been something that Emma Hayes has spoken a lot
- 6:44about today. So let's think about this on the
- 6:47point from the senior level, where this obligation
- 6:50to release players has had a lot more legal precedence.
- 6:54Clubs that stall on the release have lost at
- 6:56the court of arbitration for sport in 2008. Shakhtar
- 7:00Donetsk, which is a Ukrainian club, was in a
- 7:02law case versus FIFA. And the outcome by the
- 7:07panel confirmed that the obligation to release
- 7:09players to the regulatory duty under the RSTP
- 7:12and not subject to bargaining. Basically, that
- 7:15was added legal way and precedence to the FIFA
- 7:18calendar mandate that would actually bring to
- 7:21youth tournaments enforceable mandatory duty
- 7:24within cast precedent behind it. Basically meaning
- 7:28that. This wouldn't just be like a novel idea.
- 7:31This has been fought in arbitration before. And
- 7:34while NWSL and U .S. Soccer will both claim that
- 7:37there's amicable relations, I think it's important
- 7:39to recognize that they both have contrasting
- 7:42incentives. They both want the best for their
- 7:45teams, for their programs, for not just on the
- 7:48pitch, but commercially. And so it's a bad look
- 7:50for U .S. Soccer when the U .S. Women's National
- 7:52Team struggles with these competitions. It's
- 7:54a really bad look. And I think... It's something
- 7:59that we have to flag now because there's no equivalent
- 8:02date for U -20 or U -17 World Cups like the one
- 8:06that was created for the Women's World Cup and
- 8:09other big senior people competitions with the
- 8:1110 -day before opening game mandatory release
- 8:13date. And that's a problem because that ambiguity
- 8:16means that even without these regulations, teams
- 8:22are essentially… choosing for themselves and
- 8:26there's a lack of communication between clubs
- 8:29and federations on what's mandated and it kind
- 8:31of just ends up being an individual by individual
- 8:34case by case situation and that's a problem but
- 8:37i also don't want to pretend that like adding
- 8:39this solution of a mandatory release date would
- 8:42completely solve problems because even mandatory
- 8:45windows have been contested at the same world
- 8:47cup the european club association was actually
- 8:49um like fighting on that same thing this is not
- 8:53something that can just be solved with a simple
- 8:55mandate on release date because there's still
- 8:58pushback from clubs it's not just the ambiguity
- 9:00it's the fact that the teams are unwilling to
- 9:03release players especially when it interferes
- 9:04with their club play and that makes sense to
- 9:06be honest clubs will have their own competitive
- 9:08incentives they want to win matches and for a
- 9:11league in the end to be settled that gives more
- 9:13u21 players minutes than any other top five league
- 9:17in the world these players aren't just roster
- 9:20on the sides, right? They actually are making
- 9:22really big impacts. And so their losses will
- 9:24be felt. Hence why teams like the Seattle Reign
- 9:26only called up or allowed for players to be called
- 9:29up to the U -20 World Cup that weren't necessarily
- 9:32as big contributors minute -wise at club. For
- 9:362026, only eight of the 21 players at the U .S.
- 9:39roster for the World Cup are current NWSL professionals
- 9:42with 13 playing in the NCAA. I think it very
- 9:46much undercuts the assumption that like, This
- 9:50ratio is based on skill because I think that
- 9:54with all due respect to the NCAA players, a lot
- 9:56of them are probably better than some of the
- 9:58pro players in this age group. There's so many
- 10:01pro players who technically could play at the
- 10:04C20 World Cup that are not being called up. And
- 10:06so let's think about the reasons that players
- 10:08were left off. I think some of the big names
- 10:11being that I mentioned at the top of the episode,
- 10:13Claire Hyden, Lily Ohannis, Kimmy Escanio, among
- 10:16others, left off the team with three besides.
- 10:19Johannes playing in NWSL, which is in the thick
- 10:23of the regular season. And Johannes plays for
- 10:26LDS in France with her club season about to begin.
- 10:29And she's never appeared at a youth world cup
- 10:31despite 20 senior caps. And I think it shows
- 10:34that players can skip the youth pipeline and
- 10:37still become a senior international. So I feel
- 10:40like that is a really important piece to add
- 10:43to the puzzle here because just because players
- 10:45are missing this camp in particular, especially
- 10:48if they weren't called up due to clashes between
- 10:50their clubs. Vicky Jepsen emphasized that won't
- 10:53be held against those players. And that is not
- 10:55just a new precedent being set. It's been one
- 10:57that's been implemented in the past. Mila Familtry
- 11:00and Alyssa Thompson, who are now regulars to
- 11:03the senior national team, were eligible by their
- 11:06age to compete in the U -20 World Cup in 2024,
- 11:09but stayed with their professional teams, missing
- 11:11the competition, and later are now key parts
- 11:14of the U .S. team, who arguably would both be
- 11:16on the World Cup roster next summer. But Moultrie
- 11:19will probably miss it due to her ACL tear unless
- 11:21she recovers in time. U .S. soccer's own framing
- 11:24is really important here because I think they
- 11:27are very much trying to take the direction of
- 11:30we have good relationships with the clubs. There
- 11:33isn't necessarily a fight trying to be picked
- 11:36by U .S. soccer here. They don't want it to be
- 11:39like. The clubs are the villains. They're not
- 11:41trying to perpetuate that narrative. I don't
- 11:42feel like at all. But I think they're very much
- 11:44trying to put pressure on clubs going forward
- 11:46because I think Emma Hayes' statement about how
- 11:50important these competitions are is very true.
- 11:52And Vicky Jepsen spoke about this. We can't force
- 11:55a club to release a player. We have to respect
- 11:57that. I worked with a player for 10 months and
- 11:59prepared them for World Cup and they're not released.
- 12:01That's upsetting to me because of the athlete
- 12:03that misses out. And that's the ultimate important.
- 12:06Part of this to discuss here is that it's not
- 12:08just the club and country that are the two major
- 12:11stakeholders. Arguably the number one stakeholder
- 12:13is the player who's divided behind arguments
- 12:15that go far beyond them as a footballer. And
- 12:18I think the real cost here is that players who
- 12:21are missing out on this competition miss out
- 12:23on what can be an incredible career opportunity
- 12:25to grow and develop and something that they'll
- 12:27really cherish and value. But I think it's important
- 12:30to also understand the NWSL and their separation
- 12:33from U .S. soccer. In that time, it has since
- 12:36become much more of a global league. In the past,
- 12:38U .S. soccer established the NWCL with the primary
- 12:40objective of developing U .S. women's national
- 12:42team -ready talent, but NWCL is not just a domestic
- 12:45producer league anymore. The scale of internationalization
- 12:49is insanely vast. At the end of May, 108 NWCL
- 12:54players represented their national teams across
- 12:5630 nations and from 14 different NWCL clubs,
- 13:00with most of those hailing from outside of the
- 13:03U .S. So every time the NWSL is expanding the
- 13:07international roster spots to compete for global
- 13:09talent, it's also expanding the number of foreign
- 13:14federations that now have a release policy relationship
- 13:17with an American league that they don't govern.
- 13:20Because the international roster growth leads
- 13:23to release policy exposure growth. And I think
- 13:25these tensions, as the NWSL continues to grow
- 13:28with a league that, again, runs on a calendar
- 13:31year -based schedule, definitely thrives. The
- 13:35Wave have players on the roster who are age -eligible
- 13:38for this competition, like 20 -year -old bowler
- 13:40Dudina, who of course isn't competing due to
- 13:42unfortunately suffering her knee rupture earlier
- 13:45this year. We've seen a national team duty on
- 13:46Brazil, meaning that federations like Brazil
- 13:49have skin in this game. A lot of federations
- 13:51beyond U .S. soccer have skin in the game. Everyone
- 13:55wants their preference, their side on this debate,
- 13:59and I think it speaks to the growing pains of
- 14:00the sport when incentives are clashing and Everyone
- 14:03kind of loses in a way. The growth of the game
- 14:05is so vast that it feels like there's been a
- 14:08180 switch in a way, like a total reversal of
- 14:13what we knew the status quo to be because with
- 14:16everyone competing for these athletes for their
- 14:19time, for their skill, their product in the field,
- 14:22it ultimately... can wear athletes out. And we've
- 14:25heard players speak about the damage it does
- 14:27to their bodies. And Lee Williams in particular
- 14:29is speaking about how the calendar is out of
- 14:31control right now. And so I think that's one
- 14:33thing that's really important to mention is that
- 14:34this is not just an issue at the youth level.
- 14:37This is one that's very much a problem at the
- 14:39senior level and something that we'll continue
- 14:41to see be talked about going forward. And I feel
- 14:44like this incident is almost like the inciting
- 14:47incident of what could be a much longer legal
- 14:50battle. And speaking about another battle, the
- 14:53battle for talent between the NWSL and WSL, The
- 14:57Courage had signed Erica Meg Parkinson, who's
- 15:00a senior England international for the 2029 season,
- 15:03and 18 -year -old Wake Forest native, an American
- 15:06-born player who's England eligible, Lauren Thompson.
- 15:09As I spoke about earlier, Parkinson and Thompson
- 15:12withdrew from the final preparation camp in Portugal
- 15:15for the England U20s. They were still released
- 15:18for... the actual tournament itself. So it makes
- 15:23sense that they're allowing these players to
- 15:25still pursue the competition, still get that
- 15:28vital experience, but also fulfill their club
- 15:31duties to the degree that they can without missing
- 15:33too much time at club. So this kind of made a
- 15:36few more questions arose for me because we've
- 15:40seen now that it's possible to do both, to allow
- 15:43players to stay with their clubs. have them not
- 15:46be penalized for the actual competition because
- 15:48they're still going to make the roster. They
- 15:50did. And so question number one that came to
- 15:53my head was, why would a club say no to a training
- 15:56camp, but yes to the tournament? The tournament
- 15:58is longer, but I think it shows the value of
- 16:01the ask. The prep camp provides much lower value
- 16:04for the team during the NFL playoff push. Well,
- 16:07the World Cup itself is in higher value ask.
- 16:10I think it's important to see that. These players
- 16:13are not the only ones who benefit. The clubs
- 16:15benefit too. The players are getting the experience
- 16:17that they need at the international level, and
- 16:19they're bringing that experience back to clubs.
- 16:21They'll grow as players, and the clubs will benefit
- 16:24by allowing these players to have a chance to
- 16:26thrive. Vicky Jepsen at her press conference
- 16:28mentioned Linda Ulmark as a primary example,
- 16:31and NWCell as a player who is playing lots of
- 16:34minutes for Houston. She's starting practically
- 16:36every game, but Houston did release her because
- 16:39they acknowledged the value of... this competition
- 16:43this experience for the player and ultimately
- 16:45they'll feel the rewards from it and my second
- 16:49question is is this model that the lionesses
- 16:52and courage negotiated a better model than the
- 16:54all or nothing usa outcome i negotiated a partial
- 16:57result preserves the relationship club still
- 17:00keeps the control but the player still gets access
- 17:03rather than a binary release deny system that
- 17:06leaves federations upset and players stuck in
- 17:09the middle per jefferson's very own language
- 17:11and i think it's understandable why she's frustrated
- 17:15understandable every no one's in the wrong here
- 17:18but i think it really speaks to how this can
- 17:20be a lot simpler than it is they're making it
- 17:22so complicated but then it makes the next question
- 17:26rise which is is this an actual like something
- 17:32that we can really like definitively say would
- 17:34work for the US as a whole, but, or is this just
- 17:39like a one -off situation with two players from
- 17:41one club and one federation? We don't have necessarily
- 17:43precedence on this for US soccer because of the
- 17:47very binary system that has existed in the sport.
- 17:50And so I guess what I'm trying to kind of get
- 17:52at is like, how applicable is the situation to
- 17:56the US and how can, teams kind of work around
- 18:00this idea of clearly not all of them while they
- 18:04acknowledge the value of the competition are
- 18:06willing to relinquish the players from their
- 18:08club duties due to their value that they provide
- 18:11at club i think this is a big sticking point
- 18:14is that as i mentioned earlier these players
- 18:16aren't just getting rostered the players who
- 18:18weren't getting a lot of minutes with their nbcl
- 18:20teams were released the players who were not
- 18:22released are players that are most likely starters,
- 18:25key contributors to their club teams. A lot of
- 18:28the players that aren't going are still going
- 18:29to be getting high -level experience. Players
- 18:32like Claire Hudden and Lily Johannes are going
- 18:34to play at the World Cup next summer. These players
- 18:37will get international experience. Their time
- 18:39will come. Mel Barsanis is another player we
- 18:41haven't even spoken about today. She's incredible.
- 18:43And she's obviously someone who I think would
- 18:46be on this roster if her club allowed her to
- 18:48be released for the competition. And also it's
- 18:51like, These players are contracted to the league.
- 18:53There's a salary cap. There's so many other things
- 18:55that are outside of US soccer's control that
- 18:57the NWSL enforces on teams with the way of having
- 19:00so many injuries. I get not wanting to release
- 19:02one of their top players when they can barely
- 19:04fill up a bench full of 18 people because of
- 19:06how many injuries they've had. Many NWSL teams
- 19:09are struggling for that same problem. And so
- 19:10I think it really speaks to the overarching issue
- 19:13of calendar congestion. But speaking of a player
- 19:16who I think also someone we talked about on the
- 19:20show, Adem Elou, and someone who will be competing
- 19:23in a competition. She signed with Gotham, but
- 19:25has been on loan in WSL2. She made the roster
- 19:29while playing for Ipswich Town. And so her release
- 19:33wasn't Gotham's decision to make it all. It was
- 19:36a loan agreement that presumably had a very different
- 19:39relationship with the Lionesses and to the opportunity
- 19:43of U for World Cup than NWSL team mid. playoff
- 19:47push would have. And she's also not a player
- 19:49who I would assume would be starting with Gotham,
- 19:51given that she was loaned out. She's a younger
- 19:52player who's still developing with an incredibly
- 19:55high ceiling. But I think about Gotham, given
- 19:57that they spotted her at the Euros last summer,
- 20:00she shared in our interview, and I switched down,
- 20:03recognized the benefit. But I think it's the
- 20:06trade -off in it. I think everyone universally
- 20:08recognizes the benefit of these competitions.
- 20:10But the problem right now isn't that these competitions
- 20:13aren't valuable enough. It's that For clubs,
- 20:16having their players during these valuable games
- 20:18just simply outweighs. It's a more important
- 20:20benefit for these teams, and it's something that
- 20:23will always be a sticking point until FIFA adds
- 20:28these competitions to the calendar, which is
- 20:30the solution I want to talk about later today.
- 20:32But before getting there, I think it's important
- 20:34that we provide our final diagnosis of the issue.
- 20:38It isn't a problem that just NWSL has. This is
- 20:42an issue that... every single league around the
- 20:44world faces, given the fact that, funnily enough,
- 20:47given the calendar debate, the misaligned calendars,
- 20:50the one thing that's very, very aligned is the
- 20:52fact that the U20 World Cup pretty much sucks
- 20:55for every single club team in the schedule. So
- 20:59it's really about whichever club currently holds
- 21:01the player's registration and how the loan structures
- 21:04move that registration around constantly for
- 21:07the specific instance of Princess. And I think
- 21:11any mandate that targets The NWSL specifically
- 21:13will always have issues with loans like this
- 21:17one because let's just say the NWSL and US Soccer
- 21:19come to an agreement. What happens with players
- 21:23being loaned out to USL or to another league
- 21:25around the world? There needs to be something
- 21:27universally, which is why I don't think we can
- 21:29just make it as simple as US Soccer and NWSL.
- 21:32NWSL has much wider connections. US Soccer has
- 21:35much wider connections. This is an issue that's
- 21:37going to be needed to discuss. And same of college.
- 21:41College teams need these players, right, too.
- 21:43It's not ideal for any of them. So I think the
- 21:46in -season conflict with literally every single
- 21:50calendar with NWSL Youth World Cups or rather
- 21:54Youth World Cups landing mid -regular season
- 21:56in the playoff push for NWSL, whereas the Senior
- 22:00World Cup is off -cycle summer timing where the
- 22:02NWSL plans around those Youth World Cups. There's
- 22:05no insurance or load management. for the youth
- 22:08level, unlike FIFA's club protection program
- 22:10that exists with the senior windows. And a rostered
- 22:14NWSL teenager who, let's just say, doesn't make
- 22:18nearly as much money or have as much influence
- 22:20or power in this situation than like a Aydan
- 22:25Obamati -tier superstar. The power in this dynamic
- 22:29is really interesting because the club and the
- 22:31country ultimately hold a lot more power. influence
- 22:35over the own player's decision and the player
- 22:37themselves. And that's the real issue I want
- 22:39to get at today because I think giving an answer
- 22:41for this very blanket question is hard because
- 22:44every player has different values and needs and
- 22:46they should have a say on the final decision.
- 22:50The league that's in the U .S. is one that Tana
- 22:53Mamati has said is doing a good job of marketing
- 22:57the league and communicating everything. The
- 22:59pitch to internationals is partly built upon
- 23:01a well -run player league which cuts against
- 23:05forcing release without similar incentives for
- 23:09the club to do so. So I think we're kind of seeing
- 23:12this not just global clashing of incentives with
- 23:16the NWSL. We've asked a lot of questions about
- 23:19its identity, but the big one is what does this
- 23:22league want to be and when is it going to finally
- 23:23take stances? NWSL's own competitive pitch cuts
- 23:27against unilateral mandates. NWSL is explicitly
- 23:30selling itself as... of being well run and player
- 23:33first the league in the u .s they're doing this
- 23:36it's a way to pave the way for players and give
- 23:41them more autonomy that's something that the
- 23:42league has really prided itself upon but and
- 23:45you're also saying that clubs have power to hold
- 23:47players back without their consent i know that's
- 23:49what the wording is but i think these conflicts
- 23:52are not just going to be solved by more legislation
- 23:55that is ambiguous there needs to be clear cut
- 24:00mechanisms that are not player by player case.
- 24:03And I think a good starting point would be adding
- 24:06this competition to the calendar, but then it's
- 24:08like the clubs need to have time to finish the
- 24:11game. So it's all just such a disaster. It's
- 24:13just very complicated issue that I think I'm
- 24:18not going to solve today. I think the CBA and
- 24:20the league competitive rules saying that the
- 24:22club rests entirely with the power of Releasing
- 24:28players for youth national team duty like this
- 24:30U -20 World Cup because it doesn't fall in the
- 24:33senior international windows means that clubs
- 24:36are not legally mandated to release these players,
- 24:38nor are they legally mandated to comply with
- 24:40the players' request to leave. What I think is
- 24:43the big point of this discussion today is how
- 24:46far is player autonomy? really actually executed
- 24:49right now in the status quo? And how far can
- 24:52it be executed? Will these contrasts in interest
- 24:54just always exist? And will players always be
- 24:57the one to suffer? Emma Hayes herself uses the
- 25:00example of Spain, who have dominated European
- 25:03and global youth competitions for a while now.
- 25:06And that was very imperative in order to them
- 25:09actually being able to win their first Senior
- 25:11World Cup in 2023. This is correlation though,
- 25:15in my opinion, not proven causation. Spain's
- 25:18edge is much more plausibly the academy system
- 25:20broadly with La Masia -style development, not
- 25:23just a tournament minutes for a few weeks. I
- 25:25don't think Spain winning these youth competitions
- 25:27speaks to how the youth competitions themselves
- 25:30led for players leading internationally, but
- 25:32I think it speaks more largely to the overall
- 25:34development of young players in this country
- 25:36and raises more questions for me, in my opinion,
- 25:41about how we develop players in our development
- 25:43system and the status quo versus whether we release
- 25:46players for this single tournament. with 13 of
- 25:4921 of these players being NCAA college athletes.
- 25:52These college players are in these programs that
- 25:55in a lot of ways have been really important to
- 25:58the U .S. Women's National Team's past success
- 26:00with Title IX, but at some point the game just
- 26:03is growing so quickly, and WSL and U .S. soccer
- 26:07and U .S. women's soccer as a whole has to overarchingly
- 26:11develop alongside it. So what have we learned
- 26:14today? Let's come up with a few different solutions
- 26:15that I've spoken about with The policy options
- 26:18being proposed, I thought that I kind of came
- 26:21up with. Option one, FIFA adds the U17, U20 Women's
- 26:26World Cups to the mandatory FIFA calendar, which
- 26:29is what I've spoken a lot about today and also
- 26:31what Emma Hayes has asked for in the aftermath
- 26:34of this World Cup selection fallout with the
- 26:38roster. I think in theory, this is probably my
- 26:42favorite choice because I think it is important
- 26:45for it to be. added to the calendar and to have
- 26:49that sense of enforceability because right now
- 26:53it's just not acknowledged. And I think that
- 26:54having it in one standardized place for clubs
- 26:57to like refer to and for it to be in writing
- 26:59is really important. My one concern though, is
- 27:02that then to be still already takes a month break
- 27:04in the season. I think this year was a special
- 27:06reasoning around the break and the deflection
- 27:08process for the timing because of the fact that
- 27:11of course the men's world cup was happening in
- 27:13the U S but I think going forward. My at least
- 27:16solution would be to try and find a way to take
- 27:19the break around the U -20 World Cup when you
- 27:22take the month break. But then again, it's like
- 27:24in a few years, there's always going to be stuff
- 27:27that like it has to be worked around for. And
- 27:29in 2028, when the next U -20 World Cup is, there's
- 27:33going to be the Olympics. And so the Olympics
- 27:34is what they're going to take the break for.
- 27:35So I think logistically, it might be really complicated.
- 27:39Although to go back to the theory of it first.
- 27:41It definitely brings back this idea of cast -backed
- 27:44enforceability we spoke about to begin this episode,
- 27:47but it also shows how even that iteration of
- 27:52FIFA policy, compliance wasn't automatic, even
- 27:55when existing within mandatory windows. So that
- 27:58option, while on paper one that I think would
- 28:02be preferable for national teams and one that
- 28:04Emma Hayes lauds as the best choice forward,
- 28:07I think has a lot of... errors to it as well
- 28:10and flaws. Option two would be a mandate plus
- 28:14insurance load management backstop specifically
- 28:17for youth tournaments, which answers this kind
- 28:20of idea about the FIFA infrastructure investment
- 28:23that is much more heavily present with the senior
- 28:26teams now than the youth teams. And then this
- 28:28would give the clubs the protection to release
- 28:31players and know that they're protected in the
- 28:34same right. I actually hadn't known too much
- 28:36about this clause, but researching it for this
- 28:38episode is really interesting because, of course,
- 28:41even in the NDP cell, when players are put on
- 28:43SEI and their salaries don't hit the cap, the
- 28:46club is still responsible for compensating the
- 28:48athlete as they should. So I think having that
- 28:51protection, having a net positive in this move
- 28:53would be good. Option three. would be an NWSL
- 28:57-only CBI release rule that would be faster,
- 28:59unilateral, but that's not really a universal
- 29:02solution. I know this episode was mainly supposed
- 29:04to be about NWSL, but it leaves European -based
- 29:07Americans like Johannes and lone club scenarios
- 29:10untouched, which is a fairness gap within the
- 29:13tournament itself. And so that's obviously not
- 29:15the most equitable solution for worldwide purposes.
- 29:18But I think for this episode, we're going to
- 29:20focus more specifically on the NWSL. That's a
- 29:23really good idea to just like have something
- 29:26in there. But then again, then there's the reasoning
- 29:28with clubs won't be happy about it. The league
- 29:30probably doesn't want to lose a lot of these
- 29:31young players who are really important to the
- 29:32team. So again, it's kind of a problem. And then
- 29:35I think option D would be to formalize the partial
- 29:39release model that we spoke about with the Lionesses
- 29:41and the Courage, which would make it mandatory
- 29:43release for the tournament itself, but negotiable
- 29:46for pre -tournament camps. And that's already
- 29:50kind of happened before. I think that this is
- 29:53one of the more like original policy contributions
- 29:55that I'm proposing that I feel like is more modeled
- 30:01off of something that has worked, but also is
- 30:05like very new to U .S. soccer. No one in the
- 30:08current debate is proposing this middle path.
- 30:10It feels like it's very, I've used it a lot today,
- 30:13binary in the discussions of they're going or
- 30:15they're not. And I think that the fact that Linus
- 30:17is at North Carolina Courage. found a way to
- 30:20both compromise, to both get what they needed
- 30:22is really important. My initial question for
- 30:25the title of the episode was, should it be mandatory
- 30:27for NWSL teams to release players for FIFA World,
- 30:30UEFA World Cups? I think no. I think there's
- 30:33a lot of reasons behind why that's not the best
- 30:35scenario. And sometimes the player won't even
- 30:38want that. So I think there's a lot more nuance
- 30:40than just mandatory release or not. And I think
- 30:42that finding a less binary solution to this you
- 30:49know, give everyone what they want at the end
- 30:51of the day is what's most important. I think
- 30:53that formalizing option D will phasing in option
- 30:56B is as the FIFA infrastructure, like as a whole
- 31:00can catch up to actually enforce this properly
- 31:03with like the insurance and load management existing,
- 31:06not just as like a piece of paper or document,
- 31:10but something that's genuine that will help teams
- 31:12with this model that's already been tested. I
- 31:15think it is something that. has proven real outcomes,
- 31:18we can point to. It's a very microscopic lens
- 31:22and level that it's worked on so far, but it's
- 31:25worked much more than what this controversy we've
- 31:27seen between U .S. soccer and NDP cell. Granted,
- 31:29it's not a crazy controversy. I don't want to
- 31:31like over intensify these discussions. I don't
- 31:34think that everyone just wants the best for their
- 31:36teams. And for that to happen sustainably long
- 31:41-term, there needs to be more negotiations. I
- 31:44want to wrap this episode up with. Repeating
- 31:46something I've mentioned a lot today. The same
- 31:48lead that couldn't get Hutton, Barsena, Spug,
- 31:51or Escanio released fully still found a middle
- 31:54path for two England internationals just a few
- 31:56days later. I think that's a good data point
- 32:00about what is actually negotiable and that these
- 32:03NWSL teams can be more lenient when required
- 32:06because they think, well, Vicky Jepsen and co.
- 32:09would prefer to have the USWNT NWSL players.
- 32:13in the camp for the full time, it's better to
- 32:16have them for at least the tournament than to
- 32:18have them for nothing. Again, this is the same
- 32:21league, it was the same month, and it was three
- 32:23different resolutions, the same structural gap
- 32:25that we've spoken so much about today. Informal
- 32:28negotiation produces this exact kind of inconsistency,
- 32:31which is why there needs to be more formalized
- 32:33policy that can ensure that players, clubs, and
- 32:36national teams can all... while not always benefiting,
- 32:40work together harmoniously to produce an outcome
- 32:43that is not just based on rushed policy and decision
- 32:48-making, but what's best for all parties and
- 32:51constituents involved. That's all for me today.
- 32:53That was a handful and a lot. I hope I did a
- 32:56good job of explaining that. Peace out from your
- 32:57host, LDG. Bye. See you next time. Thank you
- 33:12for listening to the Women's Soccer Podcast.
- 33:14If you enjoyed this episode and would like to
- 33:16help support the show, please subscribe and leave
- 33:18a rating and review. To stay up to date with
- 33:20the Women's Soccer Podcast, you can follow our
- 33:22show on Instagram at the Women's Soccer Podcast
- 33:24with underscores in between each word and on
- 33:27Blue Sky at the Women's Soccer Pod. Make sure
- 33:29you hit the follow button wherever you get your
- 33:31podcasts so you can be the first person to hear
- 33:34our Thursday interviews with a special guest
- 33:35and our Monday deep dive solo episodes covering
- 33:38the newest headlines in the women's soccer world.