Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Football Woos Auto Advertisers, Rivian’s Lobby Journey, The Merge Worked
Transcript
- 0:00Yo, good morning, good morning. Happy Monday.
- 0:03Today we're gonna talk about football, really throwing in on the football adv- uh, automotive throwing in on football ads, Rivian's lobbying journey, and Kyle has a hat on that isn't flat. Where I go.
- 0:14The people really wanna know who I am. Kyle showed up on the livestream this morning. I was like, "Who's this?" Instead of wanting to be me. "Who got access to the stream?" [laughs] Instead of wanting to be me.
- 0:22Sent the wrong link to the wrong guy. Kyle, tell the people- It's crazy... where you're at.
- 0:25If you're, if you're- I, I'm in- Well, if you're listening only, Kyle might sound the same, but he looks different, and he's like- Right... he's got a background and all.
- 0:32I am in beautiful, gorgeous Cumming, Georgia this morning, on a golf course behind me, uh, the Polo Golf Course and, Polo Club and Golf Course. It is absolutely beautiful.
- 0:44Out here with, uh, our good friend, investor, uh, just general incredible human, Patrick Abad, and his team with Beaver Toyota. They are raising funds for some really incredible local charities that support kids.
- 0:58Uh, and this place, I'm telling you what, if, if you've not been to, to Beaver Toyota, the actual store with a, with a cafe and a nail salon and everything like that, you, you, you have to know that Beaver Toyota d- only does things one way, and that's full throttle.
- 1:13[laughs] And they've done it again, uh, in- They've translated that to the golf charity tournament... to the golf course. Yeah. So, so I've got my, my golf hat on.
- 1:21Uh, I, I've got a quarter zip 'cause it's a little brisk out here, at least for us Southerners.
- 1:25[laughs] It's only 63, and uh, yeah, just really excited to kinda have a day and, and, uh, experience this and, and, uh, ride alongside these guys 'cause they are, they're transforming communities, uh, uh, just like many auto dealers.
- 1:39So I can't wait to, to story it up. It's gonna be great. That's amazing. Actually, it's warmer in Syracuse than it is in Cumming, Georgia today. That's nuts. [laughs] I just checked. 69 degrees to date.
- 1:49[laughs] To d- [laughs] Or at least right now. Don't worry. We'll get- Right now... we'll get 91 today. Yeah. [laughs] We'll get 91. We'll get it. Yeah, we definitely won't. We'll get 75, right?
- 1:56[laughs] That's, that's it. We're at 75 for a high today. That's great. Um, but obviously the world is spinning. A lot of things going on. Um, football is back. Like, if you don't real- Yeah.
- 2:06I mean, I know it started last weekend, but we were out of Sotucon, so like, although, you know, we were walking around and we saw the screens where football was being played, like, I missed week one all in all.
- 2:16Had no clue. Yes, exactly. I mean- I know the Eagles had a win. [laughs] I got to see, like, three plays while I was picking up food. Yeah, yeah.
- 2:22So, uh, yesterday was, was really fun because I get, uh, I get the reminder text. I do a little fantasy football, and I get the reminder text, and it's like, there's, like, a billion injuries from week one.
- 2:32[laughs] Oh, right. So, yeah, it was- I know Dak Prescott, right? He's the only one I knew that got hurt real bad. Yeah, which is my quarterback. Oh, is he really? [laughs] I'm so sorry. That didn't... Yeah.
- 2:41I was like, swap that out, done. [laughs] So sorry. All well. I say that.
- 2:46[laughs] But it is back in full swing, and I'm telling you what, just watching, uh, you know, you think about, like, when you, when you constantly, when you start to have your brand hat on a lot- Mm-hmm...
- 2:57you start looking at everything across the way content's created, commercials. Mm-hmm. You think about...
- 3:03Like, I even think, you know, we were running last week with the Sotucon and watching our team take the morning footage and, and pop it out the night before, and just the efficiency that sportscasting has- Yeah...
- 3:16to go, like, that play just happened- And here is a-... and then we ran it back, slow mo, you know, from 18 different angles... multi-angles.
- 3:23And then when you come back from commercial break, it's part of a stinger reel, right? Right. With, like, some- Full, full stinger... some crazy music playing, right? And you're seeing all the hits. Eh.
- 3:31[laughs] Yeah, I guess we could learn a thing or two. I guess it was kind, did kinda feel a little bit- It's unbelievable... bit like, uh, the NFL.
- 3:36Well, today we're talking about football in the beginning, because football automotive ads are back in full force. Spending jumped 260% week over week, um, according to iSpot.tv data.
- 3:50Uh, that's from $6.6 million to $23.8 million spent by automotive OEMs, and 75% of that was allocated- Big money... to the NFL. The other 25 was, uh, allocated to college. And get... And check this out.
- 4:05I think I saw a stat that was, like, 75% of all live TV watching over the weekend was football. [laughs] That's n- that is nuts. I believe it, though. What else are you gonna watch? 75%? What else you... Yeah.
- 4:16I mean, you- Uh, well, and not just that, but a lot of it is still, like, uh, most people don't stream NFL these days 'cause it's, like, a ticket package or something like that.
- 4:23'Cause it's terrible So- Because DirecTV's terrible. Exactly. [laughs] So they're, they're still... That's linear.
- 4:28So if you think about it, like, the, the, the TV watching, but I'm j- I'm guessing even the general TV watching, there's just not much- Well, it's live... to watch on the weekends. No. You know? It's live.
- 4:37It's, there's not much to watch. First week of September- I get it... second week of September. I, I agree.
- 4:41And so, um, but either way, all eyes are on football, and therefore a lot of auto advertisers trying to take, uh, a couple different directions on, um, on how they're gonna, like, portray or trying to promote impressions and brand impression throughout this time.
- 4:56So we are gonna roll three commercials. We've never done this before. We're gonna roll three commercials. Oh. Um, we're gonna roll, uh, one from Honda, one from Nissan, and one from Hyundai.
- 5:05And so Honda and Nissan grabbed the number one, two s- one and two spots by spending the most money. Honda dropped 8.1 million. That's a lot of money. Oh my goodness. That's getting close to Super Bowl money.
- 5:16[laughs] You know what I mean? That's unbelievable. I mean, granted- But-... granted, these com- commercials have been everywhere... if 75% of the attention is there, then why not go where the attention is, right?
- 5:25I mean, it's, it's kinda good timing for Honda, right? Like, we saw on the news that they kinda got dinged by dealers as one of the lowest, as one of the lowest kind of- Right... brand...
- 5:34I don't remember what the survey was, but they, they were kind of at the bottom, so it's kinda nice that they have a big spend coming up.
- 5:39If you're a Honda dealer, you know you're feeling good seeing your brand out there, um, on there. So, uh, Isaac, why don't you pull up the Honda commercial?
- 5:45This is a 30-second commercial, and, uh- Motorized bicycle company... here it is... they said, "You'll never be more than that." [motorcycle revs]What will they say next?
- 5:59All right, so what you saw- Honda, the power of dreams... Honda, the power of dreams. If you're just listening, what you saw was, uh, the fact that H- Honda started as a motorized bicycle company.
- 6:09Then obviously they're showing motorcycles, and then they're showing cars, and they're showing off-road, and they're showing boats.
- 6:14And they say, "What will, you know, what will, what will, you know, people dream of next?" And then it's actually, like, a quadcopter mobile transport flying through a city. Okay.
- 6:23So I- s- we see what you're doing, Honda- Nice... talking a little legacy. I see you. Right? Yep. 'Cause obviously the next step, you know, they go all, like, quadcopter, but obviously EV is in the big transition.
- 6:32So a big brand play, right? Nothing, nothing about a specific product or anything. Go brand. Right. Uh, let's see what Nissan did. So this one is called 60... uh, Honda's is called Forever Determined.
- 6:43Nissan's is called 60 Years in 30 Seconds. Roll the tape, Isaac. [rock music] It took a while to get up here. We started out around 1959. That's Captain Marvel, by the way. Then we took a hard left in East Africa.
- 6:58A right at Baja. A 180 in the Empty Quarter. And that 65-degree incline at Hell's Revenge. But we didn't do all that just to get here. We did it to give you a truck that'll take you anywhere. This is the new Nissan.
- 7:16All right. So, uh, I can't remember- All right, we're seeing a theme. What? Yeah. I think we're seeing a theme. This, this was a big theme. Right?
- 7:21Well, the third one's gonna punch you in the face after this, but- All right... but, uh, I can't remember her name, but I just remember her as Captain Marvel.
- 7:27So obviously they got some star power behind the wheel, and she was driving all the different vehicles as they're going through, again- Through the years. Yep...
- 7:34the old stuff, into the new stuff, into the off-road, into, you know... And it ends with, I think it was a Pathfinder. Was that a Pathfinder up on top of the mountain? Yep, I think so. "What will we think of next?"
- 7:43Right. Brie Larson. Thank you so much, Nathan. I appreciate that. Okay, so that is Honda's. Now, I mean, that is Nissan's. Hyundai's now is called Chewy,
- 7:53and this one's probably gonna need a little more description after the commercial because there's less, you know, it, it describes less of what's going on.
- 8:00But just, just, if you're just listening to the podcast, just be absorbed in the moment and know that it involves a puppy that gets older. All right, go ahead. Roll it. Aww. Maybe we can go to Grandma's house after this?
- 8:12No, it's a puppy. [gasps] Can we keep him? Look at its face. Please. No. So the dad's out. He's like, "I'm not keeping the puppy." But the dog's in the car now. Yeah. Mile 4,095 it says. Oh, you got a sniff, okay. Stay.
- 8:27Oh, no. [screams] Go, go, go. Puppy runs into tent, shakes off. [laughs] This is true football- I am really-... commentating the, the video. [laughs] Dad's getting home now. Dog is waiting for him when he gets home.
- 8:43We're at, like, mile 12,000. Oh, love in his eyes. Hey, what you got there? All right, go get it. Dog has now grown up at mile 62,000- Come on. Yeah, good boy... playing with dad on the beach. Who's your buddy?
- 8:53I'm your buddy. Ready? Go. Dad, I got it first. No, you- We're at mile 75,000 now. The kids go to get in the car and the dog is in the front seat. With the sweater matching the dad.
- 9:04[laughs] When it comes to lasting relationships, we're thinking of every mile. The new Hyundai Tucson: it's your journey. The, the sweater, though, is what gets me the most. I missed that all together s- Did you miss it?
- 9:15[laughs] I missed the sweater part. So basically what you have is a 60-second journey of, "Can we get the dog?" The dad's like, "Heck, no." Dog's in the car.
- 9:24As the miles on the vehicle are going, right, the dad's getting more and more connected to the dog. He's ingratiating himself till at the end where, like, the kids are older and the dog is now in the prime spot, right?
- 9:34I d- I didn't realize the first time through it's a Tucson commercial. So it actually is a product commercial, not a brand commercial. Oh, yeah. Without a doubt. Yeah. Yep.
- 9:42And so- I mean- That, that one got- But, but here- That one was, like, the fan favorite. Big surprise, right? [laughs] Yeah. I mean, all the feels. But all, all three of them are doing this, like, legacy emotion, right?
- 9:53That's the, that's the... It seems like all three of these car commercials have said, "Here's the legacy. Here's the walkthrough. Here, there's a timeline. There's a journey that then ends somewhere."
- 10:03And so I think you're seeing that as the storyboard for a lot of OEMs right now. I've seen that across a bunch of OEMs, that it is going less product-focused, and, and all of the focus...
- 10:14Actually, it's interesting because, um, I, I mean, I'm a Mazda guy, but you go back, like, four or five years, and actually Mazda was an early, early, um, like, legacy through-the-years, uh, car commercial.
- 10:26So you see that storyboard coming, coming through. You know, BMW's done a lot of that in the past. Um, interesting to see that as the, the theme for all three of these. It is.
- 10:36And we, we thought it was a lot of fun, a, uh, a good way to, uh, get us into Monday, because the next one's not gonna be so fun-loving. This one has a lot of scratches in it. Speaking of brand adoption. Stop. Segway.
- 10:47Time. [upbeat music] Hit it. So a good friend of ours, uh, shot this article over to me, uh, yesterday and said, "Yeah, read the article, but, but please read the comments." So, um, here we go.
- 11:02We're gonna get into this a little bit. So the chief... This is a Wall Street Journal article, so I want you to contextualize the audience, right? This isn't a random Reddi- Reddit thread with anonymous commenters.
- 11:11Right. Right? This is the Wall Street Journal audience, so you think, um, business folks, entrepreneurs, um, kind of the, you know, the mid to upper income, right? You pay for a subscription. It's owned by Dow Jones.
- 11:23So I just want to give you that as context. This is a long-form article. We linked it up in the show notes. It's worth reading. Really is worth reading the entire article. Absolutely is. It's very lo- Yep...
- 11:31it's a, it's a long one. But, and read the comments. So here it is. The chief lobbyist at Rivian, his name is Jim Chen. He's a former Tex- Te- uh, Tesla executive.
- 11:40He wears cowboy boots, and he's making it his mission to end the traditional model of selling cars.
- 11:46It is a fascinating story what, um, he would describe as himself as a wonky lawyer who produces evidence for his views and talks a lot about free market principles.
- 11:55He worked for the EPA-And he actually helped Tesla fix some, like, tax incentive, like, mess-ups that were happening there. Ended up getting hired by Tesla. Got burned out after a few years at Tesla. He was working...
- 12:08He was on the road 50 weeks a year. Actually, Kyle- That's a lot... he actually said when he knew he had to go is because his dog died.
- 12:14You know, [laughs] trailing on the dogs from the la- His dog died because he didn't have time to take it to the vet. Oh, my goodness. Ow. Yeah, you gotta be done at that point. Yeah, he- Unbelievable. Yeah, I know.
- 12:24[laughs] That's, that's putting in some work. [laughs] It is. That- that's some work.
- 12:27Um, his father served in the Taiwanese Navy, and he also cites not letting China get the advantage on this new emerging EV technology, um, as one of his primary motivators. So he's got...
- 12:39It seems like a man with a- He's got a little chip on his shoulder... some deep passion. There we go. I like the fact that he wears the cowboy boots, 'cause, you know, it might as well be a flatbrim hat.
- 12:47[laughs] Yeah, the picture. Do we have the picture of him? If we don't have the picture, I love it. [laughs] We get... Yeah. It- it- it's- We- we gotta get the picture of him up. Yeah. It's good.
- 12:54So- so basically, um, this is a story of him and kind of the...
- 12:59It's a good story about, like, the history of the franchise model, um, kind of the history of trying to get th- you know, the- the direct-to-to consumer model adopted through the States. It tells a little Tesla story.
- 13:09And what it does highlight is that he's saying the- the local dealer network at the state level is kind of the- the last holdout for the reason there can't be mass influx of direct consumer, right?
- 13:24Talks about, you know, the reasons Ford and the other traditional OEMs would want it to happen, and how Ford tried in the past, it didn't work.
- 13:31Actually cited a couple people that we were, uh, spent some time with earlier in the year. Both Don Hall and Mike Stanton are cited in the article right next to each other.
- 13:38I'll read this quote, Kyle, and then, uh, we- we'll move on and we'll- we'll start talking about, uh, the comments and stuff.
- 13:43So, um, here's Don Hall: "When you have one person who controls all the marbles, you get marbles when they want to give it to you." So obviously- Man...
- 13:52his position why the direct-to-consumer model and ha- giving the OEMs all the distribution power and sales power would not be good for the consumer. Uh, Mike Stanton, who we all know, president of NADA, said there are...
- 14:04Added, "There are rules in place for a reason." Okay. There's a lot to unpack here. There's a- Oh, there's the picture. There- there's the picture, in the back of a truck. I love it. It's great.
- 14:15But there's a lot to unpack, and I, you know, I wa- I try and look at this from both sides, 'cause obviously, being on the dealer side, a- a pro-dealer person, and also understanding the consumer, you know, you look at both sides and there- there are so many benefits on both sides.
- 14:31And- and the problem is is that typically, the way that we communicate is i- in a very adversarial way, right?
- 14:39And so I love Don and I love Mike here, but saying, like, "There are rules in place for a reason," or, "These people control all the marbles," is an adversarial approach to why the, why the dealer network is so good.
- 14:53And I think if we positioned it much more of a consumer-centric, like, that it actually cares for the customer, that the comments in... that we're about to read may not come so harshly. Um, I don't know.
- 15:06It- No, I mean, I think- It- it seems like our mode of communication is just adversarial instead of, like, "Hey, we realize we've messed up. Sorry." Yeah. You know?
- 15:15There, I mean, it's not all the communication there was, but I would agree with you that the position usually taken is- is, like, wartime language, right? Right. Yep.
- 15:23It's wartime language, and wartime language, um, doesn't tend to communicate any empathy, right? It- it- Yeah, yeah. I agree... communicates ultimatums and facts, right?
- 15:33Facts are good, but when you're communicating with a consumer, you need facts, but you need to lead and bathe that sucker in empathy and in understanding so that you open the ears and eyes and hearts of people to be able to willing to even listen.
- 15:47Because when you- you draw a line in the sand, and I know, like, we're- we're fighting for our lives here, so there's an important element. Yeah.
- 15:53And we just wanna encourage, like, we need, we need to win the hearts of the consumers back, right? And there are a lot of people. Yes. Like, you're sitting right now- Yeah...
- 16:00in the midst of a big, uh, Beaver Toyota charity golf event, major part of the community. Like, you have hearts, minds, right? You h- They're all there, right? Yep.
- 16:10And that story needs to be told there, because those are the folks, the consumers are the ones we need to step up for us, right?
- 16:17'Cause laws are made by legislators, legislators are voted in by people, and then people vote with their emotions and their hearts, and their, not always their heads. You know what I mean? So, um- Exactly...
- 16:27we're gonna read some comments from this Wall Street Journal article, and then we'll just, uh, throw out a little commentary, and then Kyle's got a tee time. I don't know what your tee time is. Do you have a tee time?
- 16:35Real soon. [laughs] Okay, okay, okay, okay. It's, okay. It's 10 o'clock and I gotta get registered, and they say it takes 15 minutes, so let's roll. Okay, okay.
- 16:41[laughs] "Dealers and state lawmakers," here's comment w- number one, "who oppose Mr.
- 16:45Chen's efforts say that independent dealerships play a critical role in the car buying processes, helping to complete competition between franchises that ultimately keeps prices available.
- 16:54They argue dealers also provide important services such as repair and warranty work, and arrange financing for buyers at competitive rates."
- 17:01We've heard all of those arguments put forward by dealers, and he says, "How can these arguments be proffered with a straight face?
- 17:07Do they really think we're gullible to believe that online sales would enhance competition by letting customers shop around?" Or would not enhance competition.
- 17:15He said, "Ask anyone who has a brain if they'd rather be able to avoid trips to a showroom, and also if they think they'd be get better financing deals online. Ridiculously anti-consumer." There's one.
- 17:26Here's another one: "Auto dealers have been a-" That's harsh... "fixture of American life since the early part of y- the 20th century." This is, he's repeating what's in the article.
- 17:33"Independent dealers did the hard work and expensive work of finding customers, advertising in specific markets, and servicing." We fully agree with that. That was a lot of hard work.
- 17:41"They're the reason there is wide automotive adoption in the US." And he said, "That's an awes- that's the same argument the Weavers Guild made centuries ago when the loom was invented. Give me a break."
- 17:53I was like- Brother, brother dropped the mic and walked out.
- 17:56That's cold-bloodedGolly But seriously, like, we can't, we can't just say because it's always been there, it has to be there That doesn't work There has to be a better story.
- 18:07Because it's- yeah We have to tell a better story Exactly. Um, let's go, let's go with one, uh, one, with one more. A couple people stepped up.
- 18:14One person said, "Buying a car without trying it first or driving it first is ridiculous," obviously advocating for an in-person experience.
- 18:22And, uh, one other person says, "I, I think most of us could agree that buying a car is one of the most painful aspects of daily life.
- 18:27The games dealers play by putting a salesperson in front of you as a puppet or mouthpiece for the sales manager is silly at best.
- 18:34If you wanna pay cash and don't have a trade-in, you lose because the sales team has no leverage."
- 18:38Um, and another comment said, "Car manufacturers want to eliminate the dealers because that eliminates the middleman and increases their margins." So a full range of real talk in these comment sections.
- 18:49It, it's a bunch of real... It, uh, you know, we, we always know that the negative comments in, in, in threads, that's... I don't care if it's Reddit or The Wall Street Journal, always rise to the top.
- 18:57But we have to be cognizant of the fact that this is the c- prevailing narrative in our culture.
- 19:02And crafting a better story that isn't filled with legacy mindsets or we've always done it this way and the rules are in place, so the rules can happen.
- 19:10We have to tell a better story that's consumer-centric, that understands the needs of the consumer, drives them to online purchasing like they're asking for, and creates a narrative that they desire.
- 19:20And, and that's, that's the wa- wave of communication that every dealer, every state organization, the NADA, doesn't matter what organization, has to, has to enter into.
- 19:29We have to just tell a better story, not state the facts. Yeah, so we're not reading these things to you this morning to bum you out, right? We're saying, like, this is out there.
- 19:37We are compelling you, the ASOTO community, the ASOTO verse. We just spent time together understanding and believing in what this can be, and we need to work.
- 19:47And now, like, the hard work was a distribution network and real estate and all that stuff. The new hard work is communication and compelling hearts and minds. [upbeat music] Kyle's got a tee time to get to.
- 19:59You have a lot of hearts and minds to compel. We're gonna start doing it with you today. Go out there, compel a heart, compel a mind. Tell us what happened. We'll post it here on the show. [upbeat music]