Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 236. Cortisol and Your Thyroid, T3 Timing and More with Paul Robinson
Transcript
- 0:00Now, Paul Robinson and I, you guys know Paul Robinson. He has been in the thyroid space for decades, has written multiple books. He is a very accomplished author and really a thyroid patient advocate for the
- 0:24Without Paul and his information, his books, his blogs, I think we would still be 10 years behind.
- 0:34in our thyroid treatment. Now, Paul and I have been trying to get together now for over a year. We joke about that in the actual interview. But today we're talking about, and it's something I always wanted to have Paul's brain on, is timing your T3 with your cortisol. If you happen to have that low cortisol pattern that I can't get up in the morning kind of feeling. So we deep dive into that, but of course we expand into...
- 1:02how you should dose your T3 and where your free T3 levels should be. Paul is not only a thyroid patient, he's going to tell his story of how he became ill with hypo in his late 20s, but through his own research and his process of understanding T3, he recovered himself. And through that process, now in his 60s, now he's written three books for you. So Recovering with T3,
- 1:28the CT3M handbook, which is very, very useful if you want to adopt any of the protocols that we talk about in the interview today and the thyroid patients manual. So Paul and I are so much alike in so many different things. We're both speaking hope to you. We are both telling you, the thyroid patient, that there are things that you can do to be your own advocate that you don't have to accept.
- 1:56the medical gaslighting by your doctor. You don't have to accept the fact that your conventional doctor is still stuck 20 some odd years ago and hasn't progressed in their way of thinking of thyroid treatment and how to get you optimized. So that thyroid patient's manual is, I think, a handbook for...
- 2:16All patients, all thyroid patients need that book. So you can find his books. We're going to put all the links in the show notes. No worries. You can find all his books on Amazon and you can go to his website at paulrobinsothyroid.com. Now just go enjoy the interview.
- 2:32So blessed to have literally the man, the myth, the legend in the thyroid space, Paul Robinson. Paul and I have been trying for one year to make this happen, to have this conversation for you guys. So I'm just super pumped that he's on. Hi, Paul. Welcome. Thank you. Thank you very much for talking to me, Amy. Yeah. We've had a few things get in the way and I'm looking forward to it as well. Absolutely.
- 3:02No, no, you really are. You totally are. Your books have changed people's lives, thyroid patients' lives, but also they've changed the minds of some practitioners. Because I know many people who have handed your book to a practitioner to open their eyes to the power of T3. So you really, I mean, you really are a powerful force in this whole thyroid community.
- 3:26Yeah, I wish it was more so in the UK, but not so many practitioners over here have actually taken it on board yet, but we'll see.
- 3:36And it's a shame. I mean, I see this daily in my practice, but yet I'm still amazed. I don't know why I'm still amazed, but I'm still amazed at the amount of just the lack of knowledge, the lack of true knowledge. When you just look at biology and you look at how the body works, and we go back to the medical textbook of what does the pituitary do? And what's the
- 3:58What does the thyroid do? And it amazes me that practitioners are still stuck in this old, old, old paradigm of thinking and they can't break out. Yeah. TSH, very reliable. Yeah.
- 4:12Yeah. Should we say more now? Just leave it there. Yeah. That's probably the single biggest thing I hear from patients all the time. I'm not sure when this is a bit too detailed straight away, but this whole idea that TSH is just complete reliable and you can put your trust in it. It doesn't matter what happens. It's always right. People wear glasses. People have hearing aids. People have heart problems, lung problems,
- 4:39liver problems they need insulin they have joint problems muscle problems but my goodness me the pituitary is always perfect spot on never wrong tsh is completely reliable so we're up against that still i'm afraid
- 4:55We are still up against that. And I still see doctors freak out over low TSH too. And that amazes me. And so even, and I tried to tell that, and I know we're just kind of conversing right now. We'll get into some checks here soon, but it still amazes me that,
- 5:12A doctor will base it on TSH alone, and yet they're the same doctor that's giving copious amounts of T4 to this person, which can also push down and suppress TSH. So I still see it on a daily basis. But if we can change one practitioner at a time,
- 5:29then I think it's worth it. So Paul, I know you've gone through your own health struggles. I think many people have heard your story, but can you give us the brief version of when you were misdiagnosed? I haven't done this story for a long time, so I will try and keep it brief. But yeah, I was a young man, 29, 30, very happy, great job, successful, ever felt great, never really had many health issues.
- 5:57And then over a couple of years, I went downhill and found myself not remembering people's names and put weight on and all the usual stuff that we know now is associated with hypothyroidism. So I went to my family doctor and she did some tests and lo and behold, I had incredibly low hypothyroidism.
- 6:16thyroid levels and very, very high autoantibody levels because she tested them. She even tested FTC3, for goodness sake, which a lot of them don't. Right. She said, you've got something called Hashimoto's, but you'll be fine. Just take this little bottle of pill, one pill a day to start with, and you'll be completely well.
- 6:35And that little pill was levothyroxine or Synthroid. And I actually had two weeks where it took me from feeling absolutely terrible to quite a bit better. But those are the best two weeks I ever had on it during the seven years that I took it. And after that, it was just all downhill from then on.
- 6:54And I could never get well. They said that I saw, I must have seen about six or seven endocrinologists. Half of them were ones I had to pay for because I got sick of the other ones. And every time I paid for one, I was thinking, oh, this is, I'm paying for this. This guy's really going to listen to me. It's going to be great. But the same old, same old thing. We've done the test. Your TSH is kind of okay. Your FT3 is in range. It's okay. It's fine. You should be fine. There's nothing wrong with you. It's not thyroid anymore.
- 7:23I'm thinking, I had this conversation with so many of them, Amy. I said, I have the same symptoms now that I had when I was diagnosed and I didn't have any of them before Hashimoto's. Now you're telling me I've got the same symptoms, but it's something else.
- 7:41even though my lab numbers are in range. And they said, yeah, it's something else. And I said, OK, find it. And they would say, well, no, I've done my job. It's not thyroid. There's nothing else we can do for you. So yeah, that went on for a long time. And eventually, I found someone to give me T3.
- 7:58who had no clue how to use it. And I had to do my own research, and I spent two or three years eventually figuring out that I had to dose it in a certain way to make it work for me. And then I was fixed. But that's kind of the potted summary. It was 10 years of pain in which I lost my career. I damaged family relationships, and it was a disaster in terms of what it did to me personally. Yeah.
- 8:26And as it does to many, many people that don't get treated quickly with the right treatment. Great. I'm just going to say that I'm glad that you mentioned the job and the family aspect, because I don't think we focus on that enough. You know, obviously, we're focused on the patient and the symptoms. Or if it's yourself, you're focused on you, but you're not realizing or you are realizing that.
- 8:46And it's not talked about enough, the destruction that goes on around you. So you might be too tired to even go to your job or do adequate work to be able to keep your job. You might be too tired to do anything and your spouse doesn't understand and your friends don't understand. So it has hypothyroidism absolutely affects the person on a deep, deep level, but it has these fingers that go out and it starts affecting other people in your life. Right.
- 9:12Absolutely. I was basically at the worst of it. I was virtually an invalid. I could basically have to sleep on the sofa during the day. I had to go upstairs to sleep during the day, but I had to go up on my hands and legs. I couldn't walk up. I was too tired, too physically debilitated to do it. I would pass out regularly. It was just terrible. And, you know, people can be really ill.
- 9:36But if they get treated and they're completely well within two years, that damage isn't done to the same extent. Quick diagnosis and quick treatment and trying different therapies properly that can stop that damage. It's when it goes on for years, and it goes on for years in so many cases. And that's where the real problems come in terms of the larger effect to the person.
- 10:03Absolutely. And that's why we want to catch it early. And just like you, Paul, I was misdiagnosed six times. I was put on Synthroid T4. I gave it about five months. And then I was like, time out. This isn't doing anything. This is horrible. So I started doing my own research and I found this thing called T3. So I'm going to let you, I mean, I speak on it all the time because it saved my life, but I want you to dive into a little bit more about that power of T3 because you have a book out.
- 10:33all about T3, using T3 to literally reverse hypothyroidism, reverse your symptoms of hypothyroidism, and its relationship to cortisol. So that's where we're going to go. So I'll let you start. Okay. Big topic area. I think what most patients when they first get diagnosed don't realize, and I would still say quite a lot of doctors don't realize, is that
- 10:58The T4 that the doctors give the patients and the patients take is levothyroxine, Sincere, there are other brand names, but basically T4 is really pretty inert. It doesn't do a lot. It doesn't work inside the cells at the cell nuclei where everything happens. It doesn't do anything. It's not really a thyroid hormone at all. It only works if the body, if the cells in the body are able to convert it to the active hormone T3.
- 11:28you know, that change has to occur within the cells. And if it doesn't occur sufficiently, you don't get enough T3, then basically you don't have enough thyroid hormone, so you still have all the symptoms you had to start with, or virtually all of them. So doctors, often doctors don't fully understand that. Often they don't test free T3, which is the biologically effective,
- 11:54available thyroid hormone and they don't realize that simply having a number for t3 ft3 that's in that lab reference range they don't realize that just being in there is enough yeah it has to be at the right place in that range for that individual person that's very different by person
- 12:14And the analogy I often use is if you've got a large barn door and you've got a white circle drawn on it and you've got a baseball and you throw it, having an FT3 in range is like having that baseball hit the barn door. That isn't success.
- 12:31It's only successful when it hits within that circle that's right for that individual. It has to be spot on. And it's really FT3 that has to be spot on. Absolutely. Rather than FT4, certainly rather than TSH. You know, that's the first thing. And sadly, you mentioned education to start with. A lot of doctors don't even get that basic principle. Mm-hmm.
- 12:55I know I don't get it either because it is so inactive. And I just did a podcast the other day, just kind of as a training, like a mini training for practitioners, really going back to the basics and reviewing the fact that T4 is inactive. Why are we even still relying on that?
- 13:12Is there even a point to T4 in your opinion? Absolutely. Yeah, absolutely. It's a great treatment for many people, particularly those people that have very, very good ability to convert T4 to T3. And if they've got a largely working thyroid gland that maybe isn't working as well as it can,
- 13:32then they can do really well on T4 if they convert it well. So I've had people who have come to me who are on T3 and they say, I can't really get well. And I say, OK, tell me about your history.
- 13:44And they can go through the history and they've been on T4, but their doctor stopped increasing it because TSH was low. So I said, well, why didn't you work? You were improving with your FT3 level on that. Why didn't he go up higher on the T4 and ignore the TSH? Because you were getting better. Right. And I've gotten to go back on T4 on T3.
- 14:07Okay. And just increase it beyond there so they get enough free T3 from it. And they've been great. And being able to take T4 once a day and get enough free T3 from it is a great solution. It's so much simpler for them. But it just doesn't work in a lot of cases. Correct. So I'm not anti-T4. I never have been. But because I'm well associated with T3, people think I am. I'm actually not. I think all the treatments have a real place.
- 14:35Paul, again, this is another area we're similar because I talk about T3 so much. And I share the fact that I am on a higher dose of T3 only. And I have been for 17 years. So this is what keeps me optimized. But people tend to think the same thing about me. I am not anti-T4. I wanted to get your opinion on the use of T4 in certain cases, like you said. And if we can keep a little bit of T4, if we can keep that in and give you that storage vat,
- 15:03that's sitting there waiting to be used and your body can use it, then great. But if you give me T4, it just all goes to hell in a handbasket because I go hypo in a week. Yeah, yeah, me too. I can take 10 micrograms of T4 and be hypo in a week.
- 15:20Exactly. Same, same, same. So when we're talking about cortisol, you really know this area. And that's why I wanted your brain on this podcast really diving into this. When you're talking, you had to do a lot of your own research on the effects of cortisol and how cortisol works with thyroid hormone. So start there with what got you into looking at the path of cortisol and the adrenals and its relationship to thyroid and then how important it is.
- 15:47Well, I got into it because I had to, because I was on T3 and I was still sick. I mean, it improved some things. I was still sick and my symptoms fit low cortisol. I mean, I was very weak. I had low blood pressure. I was regularly passing out still. Yeah.
- 16:07I'd lost a lot of weight and I looked into it. By this stage, I had a bookcase full of actual endocrinology books I'd bought from a university book supplier.
- 16:24Um, and I went through it and yeah, I thought the low cortisol fits this. So I asked my GP to test it in a blood test and then a 24 hour urine cortisol collection, which had free cortisol and total cortisol and everything came back super low. My, my cortisol results on the, on the 24 hour test looked like they were the X axis. They were just like, they were just, I think we were on the ground.
- 16:50And I went to an endocrinologist. I should have learned a lesson by this state. I know. I went to an endocrinologist and I said, look, these results are really awful. He said, oh, I know what we'll do. We'll do a synaptic test, which is an ACTA stimulation test. We'll test you for Addison's. That'll be fine. So we went to hospital for half a day or something. They did the test, came back, and I saw him again. And he said, oh, no, you're...
- 17:17Your response to the ACTH stimulation was fine. You've not got Addison's, you're fine. I said, my normal cortisol levels are incredibly low. And he said, well, it's not Addison's. Your adrenals are working. Nothing that can do for you. I'm thinking, OK, so you're going to be around every day and give me ACTH injections to get my adrenals working? My adrenals are not putting cortisol out.
- 17:42So it looked like I had secondary hypercortisolism, right? But they weren't interested in doing anything because I passed the Addison's test. My adrenals were perfectly well. There was nothing wrong with them. They were in great shape. They just weren't putting anything out because there was no request coming in from the pituitary gland.
- 18:00So at that point, I knew I had a problem with cortisol. I just hadn't put two and two together until I read a couple of different endocrinology books and realized that the rhythm of cortisol production in the body is actually synchronized with the rhythm of FT3 in the body.
- 18:22And it turns out that the pituitary starts stimulating cortisol production with a signal called ACTH, which is adrenal corticotropic hormone. Starts stimulating it really hard in the middle of the night, very, very hard. The signal from the pituitary gets higher and more frequent, and it basically gets the cortisol starting to ramp up. So by the time you wake up in the morning, 8 o'clock,
- 18:50you know, or whatever time you wake up, you're loaded up with cortisol, you're ready for the day, and that really works well. But for those people that don't have that normal rhythm,
- 19:02they wake up in the morning, they think, oh my God, I have to get out of bed. I can't do it. I'm dead. I can't, I can't do this. I'm so tired. And they're not good all day long, usually. And that was me. However, as soon as I looked at all this, I thought, okay, I'm taking T3, but I'm taking T3 in the daytime. And I stopped taking it about six o'clock in the evening. I'm thinking,
- 19:27my T3 levels are now going to drop because it's not like thyroid's working properly. My T3 levels are going to look a bit lower. And they're going to get really low by the time this horrendous action happens from the pituitary to make cortisol go up. I thought, that's not a good combo. So that's when I started to experiment with taking T3 in the night. And that's when, as soon as I did it, the first day I did it, I had a completely...
- 19:56different response, I felt amazing.
- 19:59And I kept doing it. And then I thought, let's do some science here. So I went back to my GP. And the only test we had then was this 24-hour urine cortisol collection. And I said to her, I would like to do six or eight of these in a row, please. I'm going to do it with different timings of this T3. And lo and behold, we did that. She was brilliant. She was absolutely really supportive. And thank God she was, because we did it. And every time I took it, if I started by taking a T3 dose when I got up,
- 20:29And then I took it half an hour earlier than an hour earlier, until I got to four or five hours earlier than when I got up. And when we got the results, cortisol went up every time I took it earlier.
- 20:43to the point that was optimal for me. It was like a linear relationship. It was just clear cut. So I kind of knew there's a relationship for some people, not everyone, but for some people that have low T3 in the night that might have a really poor pituitary response and not be able to make the cortisol. And that's kind of what I did for several years until my GP, the same one, suggested I actually wrote about it.
- 21:09And I just thought I was like this one person in the whole world that probably had this weird problem. Why would I want to write about it? I mean, I thought I was weird, weird. You know, I just thought I was unique. Right. But eventually I did write about it and I coined the term the circadian T3 method or CT3M, which is only just for people that have low cortisol. If they respond to it, then that's great.
- 21:35But it's not, you know, it's not the whole of my protocol. Some people think I'm all about that. But again, it's just a minor, it's a minor part of what I've written about. But for me, it made the difference. It got me from being on T3 and having part of a solution, but to have the whole solution. And then I felt well.
- 21:53That's fascinating. And I mean, that even being one of the components of your research is key because that little shift can help so many people. So I want to unpack that, just kind of break it down. Number one, it's sounding like we use the term adrenal fatigue so often.
- 22:09And it really isn't adrenal fatigue because like you said, your adrenals were just fine. It's more like a pituitary fatigue or a T3 fatigue. I mean, there's something else going on where we always blame the adrenals themselves, but it might not be an adrenal problem at all.
- 22:27True. I mean, some people do genuinely have an adrenal problem, but I think the majority of the people that I've worked with, maybe it's 60%, 70% of the people that I've worked with that have low cortisol don't have a genuine adrenal problem. They have a low cortisol problem. And often, often it's because...
- 22:49they haven't got enough T3 hormone during the 24 hours that they need it to make the pituitary work properly. And it's not always that. You know, I admit it's not always that. But there's a large number of people that do have that particular problem. So it's good to have a tool or something available to help with it when it's that.
- 23:11And sometimes it could be CT3N. Sometimes low-dose naltrexone does the same thing. Yep. Yeah, LDN is great too. So if you were back to your story when you started dosing yourself earlier and earlier, let's say someone does have issues getting up in the morning. They are that like, oh my gosh, I can't get going. I'm drinking coffee. Nothing's happened. I'm not waking up. Do you suggest that they take, maybe wake up two hours before or four hours before since it T3 peaks at the four hour mark
- 23:41how much earlier than their normal waking time when we want that cortisol high, should they take their T3 in the middle of the night? Well, I wouldn't, I would start and do one step first. I'd make sure they made sure they tested it properly. I want to see low cortisol. I'd like to test it a number of ways. I'd like to do a morning, early morning blood test, just a one-off blood test. I'd like to do a cortisol saliva test. And ideally,
- 24:09an ACTH stimulation test just to rule out Addison's. Okay. I mean, it's good because cortisol, you know, the symptoms of low cortisol overlap so many, with so many other conditions like hypothyroidism, like low B12, like a number of other things. It's really important to know you're dealing with low cortisol before you start trying to fix it. But if there is low cortisol and the person's got those problems, then normally I, it depends how bad it is.
- 24:38If it's like a minor thing, then I usually suggest taking a T3 dose an hour before they get up and then moving it back by half an hour steps.
- 24:50up to about four hours, sometimes a little bit further. But if someone's got absolutely awful low cortisol, I definitely don't have Addison's, then I'd go straight to four hours before. I wouldn't mess about. I'd just do it like that and try and get something going on, try and get some confirmation, diagnostic confirmation that this is the problem we're dealing with. Mm-hmm.
- 25:13life's too short to mess about. And that's the problem, you know, we talked about earlier. And I think sometimes you just need to get on with it and try and fix things. Just do it. Just dive in and don't waste more time. Absolutely. So how often do you dose your T3 during the day then? I only do twice a day just simply because that works for me. I would be open to splitting it up if I needed to. But what is your take on how often someone should be taking their T3 dose?
- 25:42I think, again, it depends on how much they're taking. What I don't tend to like too much is taking really huge doses of T3. At once. I take 60 micrograms a day, which is not a massive dose of T3. I wouldn't want to be taking two doses of 30. It's a lot. And I can do really well with a dose of 20 micrograms. I know I can.
- 26:07So I've chosen to split it three times in 24 hours with a 20 microgram dose. Some people don't get a response from 20 micrograms. They might need 30 or 40 or even more. But I think whatever dose you get a good response to, you shouldn't go way beyond that just to make sure you get two doses a day.
- 26:27it's better to have a good response and know you're not pushing the peaks of T3 too much. Right. Okay. Then you can have a more of a physiological delivery of T3, a more of an easy, smooth delivery of T3 to the body. Whereas, you know, if you take it all at once or twice a day, it can be too much for some people. I know there are people that dose T3 once a day. I mean, Dr. John Lowe was an advocate of that. Yeah. I know people still do that.
- 26:56I've tried that in my experiments in the past. I've taken 180 micrograms to three once a day.
- 27:05I didn't feel very good on it. I can tell you. There was no dose of T3 that left me feeling okay for 24 hours. I always got hypo anyway. But with a high dose, I felt awful. Oh, yeah. You just spiked and then crashed on the other side. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. So I like T3 to be at a dose that works well and not beyond. And then...
- 27:29take another dose when it looks like that T3 is starting to run out or at least just before then. So the person never feels hypo and never feels hyper either.
- 27:41Yep, that makes sense. Well, now you said that you've taken your T3 all the way up to 6 p.m. Does that interfere with your sleep at all? Do you find people that do it three times a day and push it a little bit later in the day? It starts messing with your sleep? Yeah. When I first started, when I had low cortisol, yeah, it was terrible. I mean, I could not cope with a later dose because it was arriving at the time when my cortisol was low. The T3 was coming in.
- 28:11but the cortisol was really low and those two did not work together t3 and cortisol need to be partners they need to be both both together at the same place whereas you come in with a big dose of t3 and you've got super low cortisol what the body is going to do is say we need more steroids so what we're going to do we can't make cortisol we'll make adrenaline and so you get this massive adrenaline kick and
- 28:34You can't sleep and your heart's pounding and it's just horrible. So when I first started, I definitely could not take a later dose. I used to take it at three o'clock in the afternoon or four o'clock in the afternoon. That was it. Now, after being on T3 for so long...
- 28:50My cortisol is high end of normal. It's good. I can take it anytime. I often forget to take a dose of T3 and I might go 12 hours or longer. I'm just completely forgotten about it. And I don't notice it now because the rest of my system is so much more well balanced.
- 29:08Again, another similarity. I'm the same way. If I miss it or if I'm skipping it for a blood draw, I don't really notice it. Whereas, of course, when you're starting out and you're just getting optimized, you're going to notice that missing dose big time. But yeah. So, Paul, I want to rewind back to lab testing and kind of optimal labs because your analogy of the...
- 29:30The bullseye on the barn is exactly what I use when I'm talking about all standard lab value ranges. The standard lab value range is out here. It's the barn. And then the optimal functional range where we want you on every single test is like a bullseye. So for free T3, I always say the upper quadrant of the range is.
- 29:48or above. Now I still see, again, it's something else I see conventional practitioners or even functional practitioners that are too stuck in conventional when it comes to the thyroid, they'll see a free T3. Even if that person took 24 hours of no meds, they'll see a free T3 of a six and the cutoff was 4.5 and they freak out for that person hyper.
- 30:13So can we talk about the ranges of 3T3 when being tested? Yeah. Well, this is another one of my bugbears. I went on about TSH to start with by the whole idea that TSH is always right. You have to trust it. The other thing that the endocrinologists and the GPs just are blind to is the fact that these lab ranges are built from testing people that are either...
- 30:42have no thyroid issue or are on levothyroxine. Right. We know for a fact now that when people are on levothyroxine, they tend to have a lower top-of-the-range FT3 and slightly higher FT4 than normal healthy people. Right. So we know the lab ranges are based around combination healthy people and those people that are on levo. So that tends to lower the top-of-the-range anyway anyway
- 31:12of ft3 that's where it is it's lower than it would be if it was just healthy people but not only that it's based around people with reasonably normal levels of t4 in their systems it is not based on a cohort of people who are on t3
- 31:32There ought to be a lab range, a set of lab ranges for people who are only on T3, but that doesn't exist. And my problem with that is that when you are on T4 and they draw the blood and they test FT4 and they test FT3, they're testing what's in the blood. They don't know what's in the cells in actuality. But within the cells, we know that some of that T4 is also getting converted and used.
- 32:00converted to FT3 and used. So those people on levothyroxine have more hidden FT3 within the cells than are showing up on the lab ranges. So limiting their FT3 in a lab range to X amount
- 32:15might be okay, but if you're on T3, you haven't got that extra conversion. You need more leeway at the top of the range. So the current lab range, everyone across the world who is for FT3 is not an acceptable level for those people on T3 only.
- 32:32Now, having said that, to go back to your original question, what do I see as an optimal? Yeah, I'd say upper quadrant, maybe a bit above those people on FT3. It depends on when you test it, when you test the T3, because you know very well, if you take a T3 dose and you test FT3 two or three or four hours later, you're going to see a huge spike. Huge, yeah. Yeah.
- 32:56Yeah, and if you leave it over 18 or 24 hours, that's going to come right down. So where do you test it even? Can you even test it and use it usefully? We don't know. It's hard to say. So I tend not to focus too much on that. It's nice to see the FT3 go up so you know the person's absorbing the meds, but I don't have really a specific target because I don't really trust the use of the labs for people on T3 only or T3 mostly. I don't really trust them.
- 33:26Right. It's also possible that for someone, you know, some people might do really well with a mid-range FT3. And if they do and they feel great and they've got normal symptoms, that's great. Yep. Fantastic. Yep. It's all based on how you feel, 100% based on how you feel. But, no, I agree with you. I know LRAS and I and you all know each other, and we'll tend to experiment. So I always tell my patients, if you're going to experiment,
- 33:52seeing where your level goes after you take your T3, do it with like a self-purchase lab so it doesn't run through your insurance and your doctor never has to see it. Because if you take your T3 and you come in at like an 11 for your FT3, they're going to freak out. So just do that kind of on the side. But I've been wanting to do that just to take my usual morning dose and go two, three, four hours after, just seeing where I go.
- 34:20Yeah, I mean, if someone doesn't peak after that, they know they've got another problem going on. They know they've got an absorption problem. It's really nice to be able to see that that happens, but it's really not nice to sit in front of a doctor who's telling you you're going to have a heart attack or you're going to lose all your bone density within a week or something. Yeah, same thing, same thing here. And they're still saying it to this day. It's been disproven, but they're still saying it. Yeah. Ah, yeah.
- 34:48So Paul, one last thing. I don't know how long you have. I could talk forever. One of your blogs, which I go to your blog all the time to find different information. If I need a source, if I need a reference, I will go to your blog and see what references you used in order to get that information. I mean, it's just a wealth of information. It's amazing. Yeah.
- 35:10One of the articles that you wrote on, and I know we didn't even talk about this pre-show here, but the relationship of estrogen to thyroid and cortisol, because as you know, a lot of hypothyroidism, Hashimoto patients are women, most of us are. So a lot of women listeners with, and I see this all the time in my practice.
- 35:32sex hormone dysregulation because they're not optimized up here with the thyroid. So now all their sex hormones are going all over the place. So can you pull in the estrogen topic? Because I found that article really fascinating.
- 35:46I mean, it's an area that I've had no choice but to look into because it comes up quite a lot. It's not an area that I would say, you know, I wouldn't advocate that people come to me because they've got a sex hormone imbalance issue. I'm not, I don't specialise in that.
- 36:04I'm a thyroid cortisol kind of person, but I've had to look into it. And I think the biggest the biggest single issue is either high estrogen or estrogen dominance that I've seen. Either one or the other. Let's one step back. If a woman is postmenopausal and they have super low estrogen and progesterone,
- 36:27That is not a good thing, period. End of. It's not good because estrogen is really required for the cardiovascular system to maintain bone density and for the person to feel good and even be able to have a brain still and think and have energy. So having...
- 36:46At least proper postmenopausal estrogen and progesterone levels are balanced properly is important. And I've seen so many people that just have had their thyroid issues sort of treated, but they still feel awful. And it's because the estrogen and progesterone are either just out of balance or just way too low.
- 37:05So that aside, having said that, the biggest issue I see is just high estrogen or estrogen dominance, because that tends to, it tends to, one, lower cortisol a little bit, not a huge amount, but that can be enough of a knock-on effect to cause a problem. The other thing it does, which a lot, again, a lot of doctors don't understand, is high estrogen dominance.
- 37:32or estrogen dominance tends to increase their thyroid binding globulin. So you get, as a result of higher thyroid binding globulin, you need less free T3 and free T4. So it can make the person more hypo as well. So if someone's got high estrogen or estrogen dominance, it's important to try and deal with that because it can help both cortisol and thyroid levels. So that's probably the single biggest issue I've seen.
- 38:00Less so with low levels, other than low levels that are just too low for the person. You probably know much more about this area than I do. Well, no, I mean, everything that you said was spot on. So if you are postmenopausal and you have bottomed out estrogen, progesterone, testosterone, you need those replaced. We can't be walking around with zero hormones.
- 38:22And then on the flip side, I love what you said in your blog, because you're one of the very few people that I actually hear speak about this relationship. And it was just one sentence, but I picked up on it. The relationship of estrogen to progesterone. You do not need estrogen in the 600s to call yourself estrogen dominant. You could have an estrogen of 300, which on that standard lab value range looks totally normal, but your progesterone is less than 0.3.
- 38:50That is estrogen dominance. And I speak about that, but I was super happy to see that in your blog. Yes, it's almost as bad to have that imbalance. You really need to have the estrogen balanced by progesterone. It's really important for the body to work as it's designed to work. Right. So, yeah. Yeah.
- 39:08Right. And you even mentioned the turning on of Hashimoto's, which I always tie to low testosterone. I've seen a lot of articles on low testosterone and that's flipping of the switch to the on position for Hashi. Of course, there's stress and underlying infections and all those other things that can turn that switch on too, but even imbalanced hormones can. Yeah.
- 39:30Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah. So, yeah, I've had to learn about it. I have no choice. I tend to advise when I see I do ask people, women to test these things and I see the problem. I can give some suggestions, but I often suggest that they they go and see someone that really does specialise in treating with bioidentical hormones to get it sorted out properly.
- 39:54It's not something I really want to get into with them because I just don't have the experience of doing it. Right. Right. The thing that I respect with any practitioner is when they they focus on their specialty. And if they don't know something, you refer out. I mean, that's what I do. I don't claim to be a kidney specialist. So I'm going to refer you out if you come to me with kidney issues.
- 40:19Paul, you had mentioned that cortisol, T3, that topic that we dove into is a kind of a portion of your book. But is there anything else that you really wanted to touch on today that you talk about in either of your books, the recovering with T3, the thyroid patient, what's the second one, thyroid patient's manual, it should have it written down right in front of me, but
- 40:38Yeah, I think the Thyroid Patients Man is a really good starter book for anyone who's got a thyroid problem. I think it's quite sad because when people think they've got a thyroid problem or they're originally diagnosed, there's still majority of them have still got their health and they just handed it over to the person across the table for them in the surgery. And they've handed that health over.
- 41:04And sometimes that can work and the doctor can put them on a treatment that works. But in many cases, it's just a disaster. And it takes that person so long to realise that, hmm,
- 41:16I need to do something about this. I need to learn what's going on here because this isn't working right. So I think the Thyroid Patients Manual is a great book because it really goes into a lot of details still, but quite a broad set of information to help someone learn quickly. And again, I'm a big advocate for learning fast and getting things sorted out fast, because that's the way you stop collateral damage happening.
- 41:40Absolutely. Now, do you focus on putting Hashimoto's into remission with antibodies or do you more focus on the free T3, which we didn't even get in the reverse T3, but from the free T3 reverse T3 numbers? Yeah.
- 41:55Yeah, I think it can work really well putting Hashimoto's into reverse. If you do it really, really early, if you catch it early before the significant amount of thyroid damage, the thyroid is still pretty much functioning, then putting it into reverse by whatever means, be it supplements, be it.
- 42:17LDN, whatever you want to use can work. If it's been going on for quite a while and the thyroid is fibrotic and it's just basically dead, you've already lost the single most important organ of T4 to T3 conversion in the body. It's gone.
- 42:34And at that point, it doesn't really have the same degree of value. And to be honest, the people that come to talk to me are the people that have been knocked from pillar to post and been around the houses so many times. They come to me after, you know, 5, 10, 20, 30, 40 years in some cases when they're still not well. And at that stage, you know, usually that benefit of even attempting it is way past that.
- 43:01Yes. Yeah, no, I completely agree. And I think too many people get hung up on the antibody numbers. I see, you know, I hear patients say, oh, my antibodies went up by 50 or they went up by 100. And it's like, you know what, it really doesn't matter if you're feeling better, if you're if we're going up in your medication to find that right sweet spot, if your numbers are trending better. And again, how you feel, because I could I could show you a person with antibodies of
- 43:3110. And yeah, maybe they've pushed those down. But like you said, Paul, their thyroid's so far destroyed. They're not going off their medication ever. If they did, they would have zero thyroid hormone. I'm one of those. I went longer with my free T3 test once just to see how much I was actually producing. It's too far gone.
- 43:54I get to see people and talk to people way too late for that to be of any real use. I think if you're seeing a doctor on a regular basis and you're having some reasonable health checks that include a look at thyroid and suddenly you can pick this up. Yeah, sure. You can get on top of it really fast and maybe make a difference and get those antibodies down and see a real benefit. But a lot of people don't get there fast enough. No fault of their own, just the way it is.
- 44:23Right, right, exactly. Any last closing words, anything else you want to tell people about? I think a lot of people think our own problems are really incredibly difficult to resolve. I actually don't think they are incredibly difficult to resolve.
- 44:43You just need the right information, be aware of what can be done, and have some support from a doctor, the right doctor, who is willing to try things out and get on with it. I mean, it's not that hard. It really isn't that hard. So I don't think people should be as down about it and think they have to be locked in this thyroid prison for the rest of their life. They don't have to be. Right, right.
- 45:11Oh, I'm so happy that you said that because I say the same thing. I think everybody thinks that they're a very tough case because of the amount of time they've been dealing with their symptoms. But really, I mean, whether you've been dealing with them for five years or 20 years, there's still hope. And it's not that difficult, like you said. Yeah.
- 45:28So, Paul, we're going to put the links to your books because those are classics. I mean, I know you're kind of retired, semi-retired right now. Yeah, what are you doing? Are you still seeing patients or are you kind of just laying low? I've had a few issues this year, so I've not been seeing too many, but I hope to do a few again. I am semi-retired. I'm not working anywhere near like I used to. I'll probably keep doing a little bit.
- 45:50But, you know, I'm 64 in December and I've been doing this for a long time now. And I'm ready to do some other things as well. So I won't be completely going away anytime soon, but I'm doing a little bit less.
- 46:04Well, good. At least we still have you in this space for a little bit. But we'll link to your books, we'll link to your blog, your website. Like I said, it's an amazing source of information for all thyroid patients. And again, I'll just thank you. I'm so happy that we made this work. It's been such a pleasure. I love the information you give. My people desperately need to hear it. So this has been amazing. Thanks, Amy. Thanks for talking to me. It's been really good. Absolutely.