Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Crisis Intervention Teams: How Police Respond to Mental Health Crises
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine someone in your house, right, is having
- 0:02a severe medical emergency, like a massive heart
- 0:06attack. Oh, God. Terrifying. Yeah, totally terrifying.
- 0:09So you dial 911, and instead of paramedics showing
- 0:12up with a defibrillator, an armed SWAT team kicks
- 0:15down your door. Right. And they just start shouting
- 0:17commands at the person clutching their chest.
- 0:19It sounds completely absurd. Sounds like a dystopian
- 0:22movie or something. Exactly. But if you look
- 0:24at the source material we are diving into today,
- 0:27this is... This is exactly the paradigm we use
- 0:31when dealing with severe mental health emergencies
- 0:34in our society. So welcome to the Psychology
- 0:36Undergrad. Glad you're here studying with us.
- 0:38Yeah, we are two psychology undergrads. And today
- 0:41we are doing an intensive study session. We're
- 0:44looking at a pretty dense stack of research,
- 0:46basically anchored by chapter five of the text
- 0:48on crisis response and law enforcement. It is
- 0:51a heavy chapter, but incredibly important. For
- 0:55sure. Our mission today is to define and examine
- 0:58the psychological, the systemic, and honestly
- 1:01the moral implications of how our society handles
- 1:03severe mental health crises. And specifically,
- 1:07we need to understand why law enforcement is
- 1:09currently the default response. OK, let's unpack
- 1:11this. Yeah, the stakes here are, they're incredibly
- 1:15high. The authors really frame this not just
- 1:18as a logistical problem, but as a reflection
- 1:20of our societal values. I mean, a society's morality
- 1:24can often be measured by how it treats its most
- 1:26vulnerable, you know? Absolutely. And what the
- 1:28data reveals is that we've essentially built
- 1:30a system where armed encounters in county jails
- 1:33have completely replaced human dignity in clinical
- 1:35health care. We're really looking at a massive
- 1:38systemic failure today. Right. out how to fix
- 1:41a crisis or a broken system, we first have to
- 1:44understand the mechanics of what is currently
- 1:45broken. You have to look at the reality on the
- 1:47ground. Exactly. And the current default response
- 1:49is just this massive psychological mismatch.
- 1:53Like, police officers receive rigorous training,
- 1:55but that training is overwhelmingly focused on
- 1:57criminal threat assessment. Right, they are taught
- 1:59to establish what they call command presence.
- 2:01Yes, command presence, which basically means
- 2:04taking immediate physical and vocal control of
- 2:06a scene to neutralize a threat. But when you
- 2:10apply command presence to a clinical psychological
- 2:12crisis, the results are well. They're often catastrophic.
- 2:16Yeah, the statistics and the research paint a
- 2:18really grim picture of that mismatch. People
- 2:21with untreated mental disorders are up to 16
- 2:24times more likely to be killed during a police
- 2:26encounter than people without those disorders.
- 2:29Wait, 16 times? 16 times. That's the baseline
- 2:31multiplier. And when you look at the intersectionality
- 2:34of the data, the risk elevates even further.
- 2:37For people of color experiencing a mental health
- 2:39crisis, that statistical likelihood of a fatal
- 2:42encounter actually doubles. Wow. If you are listening
- 2:45and you want a visualization trick to remember
- 2:47this core stat for a test, just imagine a scale
- 2:50of justice, right? But one side is completely
- 2:53weighed down with 16 heavyweights. That is the
- 2:5616x multiplier of danger for someone with a mental
- 2:59disorder. That's a great way to remember it.
- 3:00And this isn't like a rare occurrence. Up to
- 3:0320 % of all police responses nationally involve
- 3:06a mental health related call. 20%. That is a
- 3:10massive portion of a patrol officer shift. It
- 3:13really bigs the question. Why are police fielding
- 3:17so many of these calls in the first place? Well,
- 3:19the volume is high because the underlying healthcare
- 3:21infrastructure is just, it's failing. Over half,
- 3:24I think it's 51 .5 % of people diagnosed with
- 3:27a serious mental illness report their needs are
- 3:30completely unmet. Unmet, meaning no therapy,
- 3:33no medication. Right, and it's worse for addiction.
- 3:3694 % of people struggling with severe substance
- 3:38abuse receive no clinical treatment at all. So
- 3:41when those untreated illnesses inevitably reach
- 3:44a crisis point, 911 is literally the only number
- 3:47people know to call. Which brings us back to
- 3:49that mismatch. It's like using a sledgehammer
- 3:52to fix a fragile watch. Police are trained for
- 3:55criminal threat assessment, not clinical psychological
- 3:58de -escalation. That sledgehammer analogy is
- 4:00spot on. The text highlights a few case studies
- 4:02that really illustrate this tragic default. Take
- 4:05Melissa Perez. Oh, that case was so tough to
- 4:08read. It really was. She was a mother in Texas
- 4:11was schizophrenia. She was in a deep state of
- 4:14psychosis, fully believing the FBI was listening
- 4:17to her through her apartment's fire alarm wires.
- 4:20So she started cutting them. And the fire department
- 4:22called the police. Right. When officers arrived,
- 4:25she explicitly told them she had schizophrenia,
- 4:28retreated inside her home, and locked her door.
- 4:30And what's so frustrating is that the local police
- 4:32department actually had a mental health unit.
- 4:35Right. Yes. A 20 -member specialized unit trained
- 4:39for this exact clinical scenario, but they were
- 4:42never dispatched. Instead, patrol officers just
- 4:45decided to force entry into the apartment without
- 4:48a warrant. Which, psychologically speaking, is
- 4:50the worst thing you can do. If someone is experiencing
- 4:53clinical paranoia and thinks the government is
- 4:55hunting them, officers smashing through a window
- 4:57isn't going to calm them down. It validates their
- 5:00worst delusion. Exactly. In her terrified state
- 5:03she picked up a hammer and the officers shot
- 5:06and killed her through the glass. Just absolutely
- 5:09tragic. And we see this pattern repeated over
- 5:11and over. The text details James Chass in Portland.
- 5:15A man with schizophrenia stopped taking his meds.
- 5:18He didn't commit a crime, but was brutally arrested.
- 5:21His ribs were broken 26 times during the struggle.
- 5:24He died because they took him to a jail instead
- 5:27of an ER. And then there's Arcadio Castillo III.
- 5:31His mother called police asking for medical help
- 5:34for her mentally ill son. An officer burst in
- 5:37and shot him within five minutes. It's just...
- 5:40it's a moral failing. I mean, the authors challenge
- 5:43us to ask if it is morally acceptable for a society
- 5:46to allow jails and armed encounters to replace
- 5:48health care. We are essentially abandoning the
- 5:51sick to the criminal justice system. It's profoundly
- 5:53unethical. So if a police response is fundamentally
- 5:56the wrong tool, the sledgehammer, what does the
- 5:59right tool look like? The research points to
- 6:01a structural alternative called behavioral health
- 6:03crisis response systems. Okay, let's break that
- 6:05down. It's built on three core elements. First...
- 6:08Someone to call. Right. Which means getting away
- 6:10from 911. Exactly. The national model is shifting
- 6:14toward the 988 suicide and crisis lifeline. It
- 6:17entirely bypasses police dispatch. You talk to
- 6:20a trained clinical counselor, not a dispatcher
- 6:22trained to send a squad car. Which is huge for
- 6:25de -escalation right off the bat. Right. And
- 6:27the second element is someone to respond. If
- 6:31the phone counselor can't handle it, they deploy
- 6:33mobile crisis teams. Okay, we have to talk about
- 6:36cahoots here. Yes. Cahoots in Eugene, Oregon.
- 6:40They are the gold standard. They've been doing
- 6:41this for over 30 years. Instead of a police cruiser,
- 6:45they send a two -person team. Usually a medic
- 6:48and a mental health crisis worker, often a peer
- 6:50specialist with lived experience. And they roll
- 6:53up in a plain white van, right? Not a cop car
- 6:56with sirens. Exactly. No weapons, no sirens.
- 6:59Psychologically, that is so important. Think
- 7:01about the amygdala, your brain's threat center.
- 7:03If you are having a manic episode and flashing
- 7:06red and blue lights pull up and officers step
- 7:08out in tactical gear, your brain floods with
- 7:11adrenaline. You're in fight or flight instantly.
- 7:13You're escalated before anyone even speaks. Right.
- 7:16But if two people in jeans and t -shirts walk
- 7:19up holding a bottle of water, the ambient tension
- 7:22just evaporates. What's fascinating here is how
- 7:26programs like Kahoot's actually work in deep
- 7:28partnership with the police. They take the burden
- 7:31off law enforcement so officers can focus on
- 7:33actual crime. Which police departments usually
- 7:35love, honestly. Oh, totally. And it runs on a
- 7:38tiny budget. Kahootz operates on about $2 million
- 7:41a year, but they saved the city an estimated
- 7:44$8 .5 million in public safety costs, plus millions
- 7:48more in ER costs. OK, a great memory tool for
- 7:51you guys listening to remember these pillars
- 7:53is the acronym CRG. Call, Respond, Go. And I
- 7:58like to link it to the biblical parable of the
- 8:00Good Samaritan. Oh, I like that. Yeah. So you
- 8:02need the cry for help, which is the call. You
- 8:04need the compassionate person stopping on the
- 8:05road, which is the respond. And you need the
- 8:08inn where the injured person is taken to heal,
- 8:10which is the go. That perfectly transitions to
- 8:13the third element, somewhere to go, crisis stabilization
- 8:15centers. And the key concept here is the no wrong
- 8:19door approach. Define that for us. It means the
- 8:22facility never turns anyone away. Historically,
- 8:25if police pick someone up, they'd sit in a chaotic
- 8:27ER waiting room for eight hours waiting for a
- 8:29psych bed. It takes the officer off the street.
- 8:32And it's terrible for the patient. Exactly. The
- 8:35no wrong door approach means police can drop
- 8:37someone off, hand them over to clinical staff
- 8:39instantly, and be back on patrol in five minutes.
- 8:43Police are never burdened with assessing clinical
- 8:45needs. And we should note, the text points out
- 8:47that these CRG systems have to be culturally
- 8:49relevant. You can't just copy paste the Eugene
- 8:52model everywhere. Right. You need specialized
- 8:54responses for BIPOC communities, LGBTQIA plus
- 8:58targeted services, and geography matters too,
- 9:01like Native American populations in Alaska. You
- 9:04can't just drive a van into the tundra. But airlifting
- 9:07someone hundreds of miles away from their cultural
- 9:10elders causes profound secondary trauma. Right.
- 9:13The system has to reflect the community. So call,
- 9:16respond, go is an amazing safety net. It is.
- 9:19But a safety net assumes someone is already falling.
- 9:21Yeah. What if we could stop people from falling
- 9:23off the tightrope in the first place? Moving
- 9:25from reactive to proactive. Exactly. The research
- 9:28talks about proactive community treatment. Let's
- 9:31look at ACT and FAST -CT. OK, so ACT stands for
- 9:35Assertive Community Treatment. It's for individuals
- 9:38with severe mental illnesses. The traditional
- 9:40model expects a severely unorganized patient
- 9:43to, like, take three buses to make a 10 a .m.
- 9:46clinic appointment. Which just doesn't happen.
- 9:48Right. They miss it, stop taking meds, and end
- 9:51up in crisis. ACT flips that. The clinic goes
- 9:54to the patient. It's a multidisciplinary team,
- 9:57a prescriber, therapist, peer support, substance
- 10:00abuse And they actually go to the person's house,
- 10:02right? Yes. Multiple times a week, they manage
- 10:05meds, help buy groceries, make sure rent is paid,
- 10:08they handle daily life. That's incredible. And
- 10:11SET is basically the same thing, but Forensic
- 10:13Assertive Community Treatment. Exactly. It specifically
- 10:16bridges the criminal justice system with behavioral
- 10:18health. It targets high -risk individuals caught
- 10:21in that revolving door of repeated arrests. Okay,
- 10:24here's where it gets really interesting. but
- 10:26also where I have a question for you. Sending
- 10:29a team of five highly trained professionals to
- 10:31a single person's house four times a week, that
- 10:34sounds incredibly expensive. How does a city
- 10:36justify that cost? It sounds expensive, sure.
- 10:39But if we connect this to the bigger picture,
- 10:41the macroeconomics actually make it a no -brainer.
- 10:44The cost of an ACT team is a tiny fraction of
- 10:47the alternative. Which is what? ER visits, years
- 10:51of incarceration, and multi -million dollar wrongful
- 10:54death lawsuits. The text mentions the tragic
- 10:57death of Daniel Prude in Rochester. That resulted
- 11:00in a massive municipal payout. Paying for proactive
- 11:04care is so much cheaper than paying for reactive
- 11:06trauma. That makes total sense. It's basically
- 11:08preventative maintenance for society. But OK,
- 11:11let's be realistic. Even with the best mobile
- 11:13crisis teams, even with robust ACT and FACSI
- 11:16teams, the system will never be perfectly airtight.
- 11:18Right. People will slip through. And police will
- 11:20inevitably still encounter people with mental
- 11:22disorders. Yeah. So how do we reform those unavoidable
- 11:25encounters? How do we make them safer? The cornerstone
- 11:28of that reform is CIT training, the crisis intervention
- 11:31team. It's often called the Memphis model. Because
- 11:34it started in Memphis? Yeah, after a tragedy
- 11:36in 1987. A young man named Joseph DeWayne Robinson
- 11:39was in a suicidal crisis, holding a knife. Police
- 11:43followed standard protocol, yelled commands,
- 11:46he didn't comply, and they shot him. Which sparked
- 11:48massive community outrage. Right. It forced police
- 11:51and mental health advocates to create CIT. It's
- 11:54a 40 -hour program focusing on active listening,
- 11:57recognizing diagnoses, and DS - It's like fighting
- 12:00a grease fire. This is a great analogy. If a
- 12:03person is in a manic state, coming at them with
- 12:05physical force shouting, it's like throwing a
- 12:08bucket of water on a grease fire. It just explodes.
- 12:11Exactly. It creates a violent reaction. De -escalation
- 12:14is like calmly putting a lid on the pan to slowly
- 12:18starve the fire of oxygen. You lower your voice,
- 12:22you drop your hands, you give them physical space.
- 12:24This raises an important question, though. Can
- 12:27a 40 -hour training course truly change a deeply
- 12:30ingrained police culture? A culture that, for
- 12:33over a century, has defaulted to commanding presence
- 12:37and using force. Fair question. 40 hours isn't
- 12:39a lot to undo a century of institutional habit.
- 12:42Right. Which is why some places use co -responder
- 12:44teams. Instead of just training the officer,
- 12:46you literally pair them up with a mental health
- 12:48clinician in the field. They ride in the same
- 12:50car. Bellingham, Washington, and Portland do
- 12:53this. So the clinical expertise is physically
- 12:55right there on the front line. Exactly. And there
- 12:58is a really fascinating statistical reality the
- 13:00text brings up regarding the gender dynamic in
- 13:03policing. Oh, I loved this part of the chapter.
- 13:05It's so interesting. Female officers make up
- 13:07less than 15 % of police forces, yet they are
- 13:11significantly less likely to use excessive force.
- 13:14And psychologically, it makes perfect sense.
- 13:17Because female officers generally can't rely
- 13:19on brute physical strength to muscle through
- 13:22a confrontation, they rely much more heavily
- 13:25on verbal de -escalation. Exactly. Empathy, negotiation,
- 13:29reason. They inherently use the lid on the grease
- 13:31fire instead of the water. It just shows that
- 13:34diversifying who we hire can organically shift
- 13:37the culture toward non -lethal outcomes. Absolutely.
- 13:40All right, let's run through a quick study guide
- 13:41summary for everyone listening. We've covered
- 13:43a ton of ground. First, remember the deadly 16x
- 13:46multiplier for mental health police encounters.
- 13:48And that risk doubles for people of color. Right.
- 13:51Then we have the CRG framework call, respond,
- 13:53go. We talk about proactive ACT and FACT -CT
- 13:56teams doing house calls. And finally, the essential
- 13:59need for CIT de -escalation. Calm, isolate, talk.
- 14:05That's a solid summary. But before we sign off,
- 14:07I want to leave you the listener with a final
- 14:09philosophical question that the source material
- 14:11really provoked for me. Yeah, hit us with it.
- 14:13We've discussed all the mechanics of crisis response,
- 14:16but think about the deeply ingrained social scripts
- 14:18we all follow. If you were building a brand new
- 14:21society from scratch today, would you invent
- 14:24the concept of the police to deal with a medical
- 14:27and psychological illness? Wow. Right. What does
- 14:31our reliance on dialing 911 for a healthcare
- 14:34crisis say about our collective moral imagination?
- 14:37That is a deeply profound question to chew on,
- 14:40and it perfectly captures why we have to examine
- 14:43these systems. Thank you so much for joining
- 14:45us for this intensive study session on the psychology
- 14:48undergrad. Yeah, thanks for studying with us.
- 14:49Keep asking questions, keep examining the systems
- 14:52around you, and we will catch you on the next
- 14:54deep dive into the material.