Latest / On the Path / Leaky Boats and Flip-Flops
Transcript
- Steven: Good day, and welcome back to On the Path, where we explore the challenges, experiences, and realities of serving on the front lines of Global Missions. I'm your host, Stephen, and I'm so glad to have you with me. Today, I will be recounting a story from one of our very own Concilium teammates in a narrative form. It's a story of isolation, resourcefulness, and lessons learned the hard way. And as you'll discover, Sometimes the greatest threats to a ministry aren't the ones we typically think about. Sometimes they're the ordinary things we overlook. So join me as we travel to a remote island off the coast of Madagascar, where a simple leak in a wooden boat would teach a team some unforgettable lessons about preparation, risk, and the importance of planning for the unexpected. Well, the boat wasn't supposed to be on the beach. It was supposed to be floating offshore, secured to a heavy concrete mooring beneath the surface of the water. But sometime during the night something had gone wrong. Now the team's wooden motorboat lay battered along the shoreline of a remote island off the coast of Madagascar. An island off the coast of another island. Several of the boat's structural ribs were now broken. Much of its wooden planking had been shattered, damaged, or torn away. And this wasn't some little fishing canoe that a couple people could simply drag out of the surf. This was a thirty foot boat constructed from heavy local hardwood. Moving it farther up the beach beyond the reach of the tide would require dozens of people working together. For the missionaries living on that island, the implications were serious. There were no roads connecting them to the mainland. No airport, no dependable ferry service, and the nearest place to purchase many of the supplies their families depended on was hours away across open water. Their boat wasn't just transportation, it was their connection to the outside world. It carried their food, their supplies, and the things they needed to sustain their lives and their ministry. It was their mode of escape in an emergency, and now well now it was broken. Imagine discovering that one of, your Vehicles of your family was now unusable. Now imagine that there were no roads, no rental cars, no tow trucks, and no repair shop around the corner. Imagine that getting replacement parts could require an ocean crossing. And imagine that you're not alone. Other families, including children, are depending on that same transportation. The team was not facing an immediate life-threatening emergency. They did still have food and some shelter in the community around them. But a critical part of their ability to operate had disappeared overnight. Now how did they get there? How does a boat secured offshore end up broken apart on a beach? The answer begins with something that at the time hardly seemed significant a small leak. To understand why this boat mattered so much, we need to go back about a year. A group of missionaries had traveled to Madagascar, an island nation off the southeastern coast of Africa. Their purpose was to live among the local community, learn its language and culture, and participate in a ministry training program designed to prepare them for long term missionary service. The program emphasized learning through experience. So rather than studying everything in a classroom before going overseas, participants would learn much of what they needed while living among the people they hoped to serve. It was an ambitious approach, and their destination was certainly ambitious. The missionaries weren't moving into an established city with reliable infrastructure and easy access to transportation. They were going to a small island off the coast. Getting there was a journey in itself. Travel from the United States to Madagascar could take several days. After arriving in the capital, the team faced another long journey north by local transportation. And from there, a truck carried travelers toward the coast, and then came the final leg, the boat ride that could last six to eight hours, depending on the tides, weather, and sea conditions. By the time they reached their destination, they had left behind nearly every convenience that most Americans take for granted. There was no electrical grid, there was no running water, no paved roads, no cars or motorcycles. The villages consisted of homes. Built primarily from local materials. Walls were constructed from the woody centers of palm or bamboo fronds. Roofs were covered with palm leaves. Some homes had dirt floors, while others had some simple wooden floors. Cooking was done over charcoal. At night, light came from kerosene lamps, and occasionally there was a small solar panel providing some limited electricity. Water had to be carried from a well that was typically some distance away from a home, often in large containers. Most local families depended on fishing, coconuts, and other resources available on the island to survive. For the missionaries, daily life required constant adjustment. Things that had once been effortless now required planning. Water had to go be collected, food had to be managed, equipment had to be maintained, and every trip to the mainland required careful coordination. The team lived among several small villages, with families and single missionaries spread across the area. Altogether, more than twenty people, including children were part of the group, and all of them depended to varying degrees on this single wooden boat. It was roughly thirty feet long and powered by an outboard engine with a smaller backup motor. About once a month, members of the team would travel to the mainland to purchase supplies for the families. Things like rice, food staples, household necessities, and other items that couldn't be obtained locally would be brought back across the water. The boat also gave them a degree of independence. Without it, they would have to rely on local boat owners and whatever transportation happened to be available. And while there were local fishing boats, there was no established ferry system they could count on. This boat represented mobility. It represented access. And perhaps most importantly, it represented the ability to continue living and ministering in a place where almost everything required more effort than it did back then. But there was a problem. The missionaries were not experienced mariners. One of the team members later described his previous boating experience as nothing more than operating a small boat on the lakes and ponds of the American Midwest. Now that same experience was being applied to a heavy wooden vessel operating in open ocean conditions. The team was learning, but the ocean can be an unforgiving classroom. The boat was normally stored offshore. Rather than pulling it onto the beach, After every use, the team had constructed a heavy concrete mooring that could hold the vessel in place. The boat would float offshore, tied to the mooring until it was needed, and periodically someone would swim out to inspect it. And on one particular day a missionary responsible for checking the boat noticed something unusual. Water was entering up through the hole. Not a lot, just a trickle. The boat was still floating normally, there was no obvious sign of immediate danger. So he bailed out the water and reported the leak to the team leader. The decision was made not to address it immediately, and it's worth remembering the context. This was a team living in a remote environment, managing an enormous number of unfamiliar challenges. There were ministry responsibilities, language learning, family needs, supply logistics, and the countless small tasks required to make daily life work. A small leak in a boat might not have seemed like the most pressing concern at the time. But risk has an unfortunate habit of accumulating quietly. One problem creates vulnerability to another, and sometimes the danger isn't in any single condition. It's in what happens when several conditions occur together. The leak was the first condition, the mooring arrangement was another, and then came the weather. Within the next night or two, strong winds began sweeping across the water. Waves rose and pushed against the hole. As the boat rocked and more water entered through the leak, and as more water entered, the vessel became heavier. Now you can picture what was happening. The boat was filling with water, but enough of its structure remained above the surface for the wind to catch it. And the wind and waves pushed against the boat, and the boat pulled against the concrete mooring. The additional weight of the waterlogged vessel. Combined with those forces of the weather, became more than the mooring could hold in place. Slowly the boat was driven towards shore, dragging its concrete weight along the seabed. Eventually it reached the beach, and once it was there, the waves continued their work. The heavy wooden hole was repeatedly pushed and battered against the shoreline. By morning, the damage was now extensive. Several ribs were broken, much of the planking was damaged or gone. The boat had Connected the missionaries to the mainland was now no longer seaworthy. A small leak had become a major operational problem, and now the team had to figure out what to do. The first priority was preventing further damage. The boat needed to be moved beyond the reach of the tide, but the vessel was enormous and heavy. It took roughly thirty or forty men working together to drag it farther up the beach. That alone gives some perspective on the scale of the problem. This wasn't a minor repair. that could be handled with a few tools and an afternoon of work, the whole would require substantial reconstruction, they faced two immediate questions who could repair it? And where would they find the materials? Based on the team's understanding of the island, the answers were discouraging. They believed that the specialized boat building skills needed for such extensive repairs weren't available locally. They also believed they would need to purchase materials on the mainland. That meant Someone would have to travel to town, find a craftsman, purchase supplies, and arrange to bring everything back. Ordinarily, the team would have used its own boat, but that was precisely what they no longer had. The situation wasn't a medical emergency, and no one needed to be rescued from a sinking vessel. There was no immediate need to evacuate the island. But the team's normal supply system and ability to respond should something terrible happen had stopped functioning. And the longer that situation continued, the more complicated life would become. For a ministry living in such an isolated location, a logistical disruption could eventually become something far more serious. The team had to act. Two missionaries were selected to travel to the mainland and find a solution. Obvious problem, they needed a boat to go find someone who could repair their boat. Someone had heard of a mailboat that occasionally visited the southern end of the island. If the missionaries could reach its landing point before morning, they might be able to catch a ride to the mainland. It wasn't a guaranteed solution, but it was a possibility. The landing point was roughly seven miles away, and the boat was expected early. So, the missionaries arranged for a local man to guide them through the island during the night. By the time the group actually began making its way south, it was around midnight. You can picture this. It's the middle the night, you're in a remote tropical island. There are no paved roads, no streetlights, and no familiar landmarks to guide you. Your destination is miles away. And the transportation you're trying to catch may leave before sunrise. The terrain wasn't a maintained hiking trail either. The group crossed open fields, moved through trees and brush, and occasionally followed stretches of beach. In places they simply picked their way across the landscape. Their headlamps eliminated the what lay immediately ahead of them while the patterning of their flip-flops echoed in the night. Not exactly the footwear most people would choose for a seven mile nighttime trek through unfamiliar terrain, but this was everyday life on the island, and they were working with what they had. One of the missionaries had never traveled the full length of the island before. He later acknowledged that without their local guide he probably would not have been able to find their way in the dark. And that detail matters, because once again, The missionaries were depending on local knowledge to accomplish something their own experience had not prepared them to do. So they continued south. The goal was simple: reach the landing before the boat departed. After hours of walking, they finally approached the village where they expected to find their transportation, and then they heard something. An engine! Out in the distance. But it wasn't getting louder. It was fading away. The mailboat was leaving. They had missed it. Think about the time, and they had set out late in the evening, walked through the night, navigated unfamiliar terrain, reached the landing point, and arrived just in time to hear the engine of the boat they needed disappearing into the distance. All of that effort, and they were still on the land. Now they needed another plan. With the mailboat gone, the two missionaries found a space that they could get a few hours of sleep. Then they learned of another possibility. A local outrigger canoe regularly traveled between the island and the mainland. It wasn't a motorboat, it was a traditional dugout sailing canoe. The vessel was approximately thirty feet long, with a narrow wooden hole, an outrigger for stability, and a sail made from material resembling a plastic tarp. Its schedule depended on the wind. When the wind blew in one direction, the canoe could travel to the island. When it shifted, the boat could make the return journey. There were no engines to power through changing conditions, no comfortable passenger seats and no separate luggage compartment. Passengers and their belongings occupied the same platform with little room to move around. The missionaries arranged passage, and when the wind shifted, they set out. Now consider the contrast. Back home, a trip to purchase supplies might involve getting in your car and driving to a store. Here the missionaries had already spent the night trucking across the island, missed their intended transportation, and were now crossing open water in a traditional sailing canoe. The journey was certainly outside their usual experience. They reached the mainland. They found lodging, and over the next several days they began to work on locating a boat builder and purchasing the materials needed to repair their damaged vessel. Eventually, they arranged a motorboat to transport them, the craftsmen, and their supplies back to the island. So the plan was working. They had found the expertise they believed they lacked, they had secured their materials, and they finally were bringing a solution home. Or more so they thought, because once the boat builder began his work, the missionaries would discover something unexpected, something that would cause them to reconsider Nearly everything about the journey they'd just made. The boat builder began building the damaged vessel. The work was extensive, the ribs were now getting replaced, new planking was getting installed, the seams needed to be sealed to make the whole watertight, and the repairs were taking several weeks. And during that process, something became apparent. The boat builder was actually sourcing some of the wood he needed directly from the island. He was cutting local timber and shaping replacement ribs by hand. Materials the missionaries had believed would need to come from the mainland were, at least in part, available right where they lived. And that wasn't the only discovery. As the team learned, they realized that several local men likely possessed the knowledge and skills necessary to much of the work on it themselves. Not just one person, several. People living in the surrounding communities, people whose expertise the missionaries had not known how to identify or access. Consider the irony. Two missionaries had walked through the night, missed their intended boat, crossed open water in a sailing canoe, spent days arranging repairs, and transported a boat builder back to the island. Yet some of the expertise and materials they needed, if not all, may have been available within walking distance of their homes. Now that doesn't mean the journey was pointless. They solved the problem. The boat was repaired, and they gained experience they would never forget. But it revealed a weakness in their understanding of the environment. They had assumed that resources weren't available, and they had planned their response around that assumption. Part of the problem was language. Missionaries were still learning the local dialect. Their training program emphasized immersion, which meant language proficiency developed gradually through daily interaction. And when you're trying to communicate something as specific as rebuilding a wooden boat, limited language skills can become a significant barrier. Part of the problem was familiarity. They simply didn't know who possessed what skills. And part of it was the difficulty of recognizing what you don't know. The teen had been living among the community. They had developed relationships, but they hadn't yet discovered the full extent of the resources around them. In hindsight, better local knowledge might have prevented much of the difficulty. And that realization raises an important question. How often do organizations develop contingency plans based on what they assume is available or unavailable rather than what they've actually verified. When one of the missionaries later reflected on the experience, he didn't blame the weather, at least not entirely. The storms and waves had certainly contributed to the damage, but the incident had begun before the weather changed. It began when the leak was discovered. The boat was still floating. The problem seemed manageable and the decision was made to wait. Looking back, the missionary recognized that the team simply hadn't understood the significance of what they were seeing. Their experience with wooden boats was limited, their knowledge of maritime maintenance was limited, and their procedures for responding to equipment problems weren't as rigorous as they needed to be. In other words, they were operating in an environment that demanded expertise that they had not yet developed. And that's a situation many missionaries can relate to and recognize. A sending organization may have years of experience working in one region, only to discover that a new location introduces an entirely different set of risks. A team accustomed to road travel may suddenly depend on boats. A ministry accustomed to reliable electricity may find itself operating entirely on generators or solar power. A family accustomed to nearby medical care may move somewhere that requires hours of travel just to reach a hospital. The mission may be familiar, but the operational environment is not. And when that happens, experiences in one setting doesn't automatically translate into competence in another. The boat incident illustrates a principle that is fundamental to risk management. Small problems are often easiest to address before they become emergencies. A leak discovered during a routine inspection is a maintenance issue. A boat filling with water during a storm is a much more serious problem. A shattered boat on a remote beach is an operational crisis. Same underlying vulnerability, very different consequences. And that's why security planning often includes what are called tripwires. A tripwire is a predetermined condition that requires a specific action. It's not simply noticing that something is wrong. It's deciding ahead of time what you'll do when that condition occurs. For example, if a critical piece of equipment develops a leak. It must be inspected and repaired before continued use. If weather conditions exceed a certain threshold, travel is postponed. If essential supplies fall below a predetermined level, resupply or relocation plans get activated. The value of a tripwire is that the decision has already been made. You don't have to invent your response while the situation is deteriorating. And for Perhaps just as importantly, you don't have to argue with yourself about whether the warning really matters. Because that can be one of the most dangerous tendencies in risk management. We identify a concern, we acknowledge that it could be a problem, and then because nothing terrible has happened yet, we convince ourselves that it it can wait. Until it can't. But the lessons from this experience went beyond boat maintenance. They reached back to decisions made before the missionaries ever set foot on the island. The location had been selected because of its cultural importance to the people group that the team hoped to reach. There was a meaningful ministry rationale for being there for sure, but it was also an unusually difficult place to support. Transportation depended on open water, supplies required complicated logistics, medical emergencies could require specialized evacuations. And the organization had limited previous experience placing itself and its teams in this kind of maritime environment. Before the team arrived, a risk assessment had been conducted, but it had been done remotely. The assessment team had not physically visited the island, and in hindsight, some of the operational realities may not have been fully understood. That's not necessarily a reflection of carelessness. Remote assessments can be useful. They can identify political instability, crime, health concerns, transportation limits, and Other risks. But there are things that are difficult to appreciate until someone actually visits a location. The distance between a home and its water source, the difficulty of transporting supplies, the skills available within the local community, the realities of operating a wooden boat in open water, and the consequences of losing that boat. And there was another question worth considering. The island was culturally significant, but Larger communities of the same people group also lived on the mainland. Could the ministry have achieved similar objectives from a more accessible location? Could the team have maintained relationships with the island while operating from somewhere with better infrastructure? Perhaps. We can't know with certainty, and it's easy to ask those questions years later, knowing how events unfolded. But they are precisely the kind of questions that should be explored before a team deploys. As risk management isn't simply about preparing for danger. After you've arrived, it's also about making wise decisions about where, when, and how ministry should take place. The goal isn't to avoid every difficult situation and location. Some of the world's most underserved communities are difficult to reach precisely because where they are isolated and located. And reaching them may require accepting significant hardship. But there is a difference between accepting a risk that has been carefully considered and unknowingly accepting one that hasn't. Sometimes the most faithful decision is to go, sometimes it's to go differently, and sometimes it's to you know, take more time to prepare. One of the most revealing parts of the story is that nobody was facing an immediate emergency when the boat was destroyed. The missionaries weren't trapped on a sinking vessel and they weren't under attack. They weren't running out of drinking water that morning, and they weren't completely cut off from all possible transportation. Other boats did exist. Alternative arrangements could be made. During their time on the island, the team even experienced medical emergencies requiring evacuation, including one that involved bringing a helicopter to the island. So the situation was not hopeless, but it was serious. Because the team had lost a capability essential to sustaining its operations, and that is an important distinction, a crisis doesn't always begin with a dramatic event. Sometimes it begins when an organization loses the ability to do something it depends on. Transportation, communication, access to money, medical support, a reliable supply chain, the ability to evacuate people. The ability to maintain basic living conditions. A ministry can often continue for a while after losing one of those capabilities. But the clock begins to run. Supplies are consumed, equipment deteriorates, other needs arise, and the longer the capability remains unavailable, the more pressure the organization faces. Eventually, a manageable disruption can become a threat to the ministry itself. That is why contingency planning matters. It forces us to ask not only what could go wrong, but what would happen next? If our primary transportation becomes unavailable, what is our alternative? If our local contact can't help, who else can we call? If we lose access to supplies, how long can we sustain ourselves? If a medical emergency occurs, how do we move someone to appropriate care? And perhaps most importantly, have we actually tested these assumptions? Because a plan that depends on resources we haven't verified may not turn out to be much of a plan at all. And there's one final lesson from this experience, and it may be the most important one for the broader missions community. The missionary who shared this story did so knowing that it wasn't a perfect reflection of every decision that had to be made. There were mistakes, there were assumptions, there were things that the team could have done differently, and there were organizational decisions that, in hindsight, perhaps deserved more scrutiny. It's vital to discuss and share stories like these because other people could learn from them. Not to embarrass anyone, not to assign blame, and not to diminish the good work that the missionaries had gone there to accomplish. A group that is often exceptional at talking about and analyzing events is the missionary aviation community. When something goes wrong in aviation, there is often a deliberate effort to understand why. Not simply, you know, who made the mistake, but what combination of conditions, decisions, systems, and assumptions contributed to the outcome, and what can be changed to prevent it from happening again. That's a mindset that could benefit the entire missions community. We're often eager to share stories of success, the doors that open, the people reach, the answers to our prayers, the remarkable ways God provided, and those stories deserve and should be told. But there is also value in telling the stories where things didn't go according to plan, where the warning signs were missed, where the team wasn't adequately prepared, where an assumption turned out to be wrong, where someone learned a lesson the hard way. Because if we can learn from one another's experiences, Perhaps the next team won't have to learn those same lessons through its own crisis. And this really is a form of stewardship. Stewardship of your people, of the resources, of the trust placed in us by churches, families, and supporters, and ultimately of the opportunities we've been given to serve. So think back to the boat, a heavy wooden vessel floating offshore, a small leak, decision to wait, then wind and waves, and a shattered hole lying on a remote beach. The team eventually repaired the boat, they restored their transportation, they continued their work, and they came away with lessons about preparation, maintenance, local relationships, contingency planning, and the importance of understanding the environment in which they served. But the most important lesson may be the simplest. A warning doesn't have to look like an emergency to deserve our attention. Sometimes the difference between a manageable problem and a major crisis is whether someone recognizes that warning early on enough to react. For missionaries serving in remote or difficult environments, preparation isn't a distraction from the mission. It's part of what makes the mission sustainable. It helps protect families, it helps preserve resources, it helps organizations make decisions, and it helps ensure When challenges do come, and they inevitably will, the people serving on the front lines have the support and capabilities they need to continue. At Concilium, we believe that the gospel is the highest value. And because of that, the people carrying it, the ministry supporting them, and the resources entrusted to their care deserve thoughtful preparation. Faith and planning aren't competing ideas. We can trust God while also taking seriously the responsibility to prepare. And sometimes That preparation begins with something as ordinary as inspecting a boat, recognizing a leak, and deciding to fix it before the next storm arrives. So if anyone listening happens to have a leaky boat out there, real or metaphorical, this is your friendly reminder to go fix it. And until next time, may your ministries be faithful, resilient, and effective.