Latest / Indie Film Hustle® - A Filmmaking Podcast / IFH 748: Screenwriter's Guide to Plotting Stories & Theme with K.M. Weiland
Transcript
- 0:03You are listening to the IFH podcast Network. For more amazing filmmaking and screenwriting
- 0:08podcasts, just go to ifahpodcastnetwork dot com. Welcome to the Indie Film Hustle
- 0:14Podcast, Episode number seven forty eight. The beautiful part about writing is that
- 0:18you don't have to get it right on the first time, unlike say,
- 0:22brain surgery. Robert Kromeer broadcasting from the back alley in Hollywood. It's the
- 0:29Indie Film Hustle Podcast, where we show you how to survive and thrive as
- 0:33an indie filmmaker in the jungles of the film biz. And here's your host,
- 0:37Alex Ferrari. Welcome, Welcome to another episode of the Indie Film Hustle
- 0:42Podcast. I am your humble host, Alex Ferrari. Today's show is sponsored
- 0:46by Rise of the Film Entrepreneur. How to turn your independent film into a
- 0:50profitable business. It's harder today than ever before for independent filmmakers to make money
- 0:55with their films from predatory film distributors ripping them off to huckster film aggregate who
- 1:00prey upon them. The odds are stacked against the indie filmmaker. The old
- 1:03distribution model of making money with your film is broken and there needs to be
- 1:07a change. The future of independent filmmaking is the entrepreneurial filmmaker or the film
- 1:14entrepreneur. In Rise of the Film Entrepreneur, I break down how to actually
- 1:18make money with your film projects and show you how to turn your indie film
- 1:22into a profitable business with case studies examining successes and failures. This book shows
- 1:27you the step by step method to turn your passion into a profitable career.
- 1:33If you're making a feature film, series, or any other kind of video
- 1:36content, the Film Entrepreneur method will set you up for success. The book
- 1:41is available in paperback, ebook, and of course audiobook. If you want
- 1:46to order it, just head over to www. Dot filmbiz book dot com.
- 1:49That's film bizbook dot com. Now, guys, today on the show,
- 1:56we have returning champion author and writer Katie WiLAN And she has written some
- 2:01of the best books on writing and characters in the marketplace today. The last
- 2:09episode I had with her was talking about character arcs, talking about her book
- 2:14Creating Character Arcs, The Masterful Arthur's Guide to Uniting Story Structure, and it
- 2:19was easily one of the most downloaded episodes I have ever had. Of the
- 2:23Bulletproof Spirit on a podcast, so when her new book came out, I
- 2:27had to have her on now. Her new book is writing your Story's Theme,
- 2:30The Writer's Guide to plotting stories that matter. And theme is that mysterious
- 2:37cousin of plot and character, and it's too often viewed as abstract rather than
- 2:42actionable, and theme is frequently misunderstood and left up the chance. Many screenwriters
- 2:47insist on not even thinking about theme when they're writing their stories, and this
- 2:53is extremely unfortunate because in many ways, theme is story. Theme is the
- 2:59heart and the point of your story. Nothing that important should ever be overlooked.
- 3:06And Katie and I go deep down the rabbit hole and discuss theme,
- 3:12how to create themes from plot and character, why every supporting character and subplot
- 3:16should be enhanced by the theme, how to prevent theme from seeming preachy or
- 3:21on the nose, and so much more so, without any further ado,
- 3:27please enjoy my conversation with Katie Wiland, I'd like to welcome back to the
- 3:31show returning champion, Katie Wiland. How are you doing, Katie? Thanks
- 3:37for having me, of course, thank you for coming back on the show.
- 3:39Your first your first appearance on the show about character arcs was extremely popular.
- 3:46A lot of people really really liked it. A lot of people in
- 3:51the tribe really really liked it. So when I saw that you had a
- 3:53new book out covering theme, of course I had to invite you back to
- 3:58chat about the darks and theme are two of my favorite subjects. So,
- 4:02and you're excited to talk to those and your new and your new book is
- 4:05called Writing Your Stories Theme, Yes, And it just came out a few
- 4:10weeks ago as of this recording. So and it's already number one on like
- 4:14multiple lists on Amazon already and everything. So, yeah, that's very exciting.
- 4:18It's always excited being on Yeah, I remember when I get when you
- 4:21get that little, that little orange thing next like number one bestseller on you,
- 4:26it's like the You're like, oh, that's so nice. It's so
- 4:30nice when you do that. So all right, So, can you define
- 4:34what a theme is the theme of a story is for for the audience?
- 4:40Yeah, So I think that's kind of like why I wrote the book,
- 4:43because I think that there's a lot of ways that we can think about theme,
- 4:46and there are a lot of ways that people approach it. You'll have
- 4:49one person talking about it in this aspect and somebody talking to the other,
- 4:53and there there's a lot of confusion I think because of that, particularly about
- 4:58applying theme, because some of those descriptions are not practical. Some of them
- 5:01are just very abstract. So you can have theme as just like a unifying
- 5:06idea of the story something like that. You can have thematic metaphors in which
- 5:11the story represents something, it's an example of something that is, it's demonstrating
- 5:16from within. But for me, the way that I approach theme, in
- 5:19the way that I have found it most interesting and most practicable, is to
- 5:26think of it to realize that really what it is is the meeting of plot
- 5:30and character, and that, particularly when I was working on the character Arcs
- 5:34book, it became really clear to me that when you're developing character arc,
- 5:38what you're doing is proving your theme. And this is true ultimately, whether
- 5:44people are trying to impose a theme onto the story apart from the character arc
- 5:47or not. What your character undergoes and how he changes with over the course
- 5:53of the story, that ultimately is what your story is about. And whatever.
- 5:59We'll call it a lesson, though I don't really like that because it's
- 6:00very moral of the story ish, but whatever lesson that character is learning,
- 6:04whether it's existential or moral or I mean, it can be very deep or
- 6:09very shallow, but that ultimately is what your story is putting out into the
- 6:13world and what it's positing about our reality. And that ultimately is the theme
- 6:17of the story. So if you can identify that that through line where your
- 6:23black and your character come together, and also like harmonizes this debate we have
- 6:28between plot versus character and which is better because together they come together and they
- 6:32create the theme of the story and this beautiful through line. And then of
- 6:36course there's so much complexity that arises out of that, and how we're then
- 6:42able to, you know, bring in symbolism and bring in all kinds of
- 6:45layers of metaphor to really garnish kind of the theme as we go along,
- 6:53to support the theme if you will. Yeah, well, does every story
- 6:57have a theme? I believe yes, even the bad stories. Well,
- 7:03that's a good question. I think that I've always taken issue with this idea
- 7:09that people will talk about just a story. I think that's totabal on me,
- 7:14because ultimately, one way or another, a story is always saying something
- 7:18about our world. Sometimes it's saying it really well. Sometimes it's not saying
- 7:23it very well at all. I think a big problem with a lot of
- 7:26stories that don't work is they don't really know what they're saying, and so
- 7:30they're just kind of throwing out multiple messages. They're still saying something, but
- 7:32it's not a unified, cohesive and resonant kind of a whole. But yeah,
- 7:39I think every time you put a visual on the screen, every time
- 7:42your character says something, every sentence on the page that's saying something, and
- 7:47within the patterns that arise in a larger work, you're always going to have
- 7:50a theme, whether it's well executed or not. So can we can I
- 7:56can I do like a couple of rapid fire movie title and see if you
- 8:00can decipher a theme for me, just like off the top, if you
- 8:03see, I'm gonna try to choose some very popular wars. So any of
- 8:07the Indiana Jones is like, what is the theme of Indiana Jones because he's
- 8:11one of the more famous characters in cinema history. Yeah, So Indiana Jones
- 8:16is interesting because he is a character that is typically seen not to have a
- 8:20character arc you know, he's very very bond exactly exactly. It's very episodic.
- 8:26I mean that's the way it was designed to be, as like the
- 8:28old serial shows. A long time since I've seen those movies, I would
- 8:37say the first one, we definitely can see themes of responsibility in the end,
- 8:43in the climax, we see how the bad guys, the Nazis,
- 8:46are disregarding the the arc of the Covenant and are not respecting the history and
- 8:52the archaeology, and Indy does and Indy survives and they die. So right
- 8:56there, I think even just in that, we have a statement, you
- 9:00know, from the storytellers about what they think, you know, is a
- 9:03truth, and inherent in that is a theme. So the theme is basically,
- 9:09like I think you just said that clear word, it's a statement.
- 9:11So the storyteller is creating a statement for the world to understand through the story
- 9:18that they're writing, essentially, and that's what as a writer you should start
- 9:22thinking about the theme or the statement that you're trying to make through character,
- 9:28which then in terms goes through character plot and then essentially theme. And I
- 9:33think isn't theme essentially character and plot kind of exactly together. Yeah, I
- 9:37think a lot of there's this like misconception I considered a misconception that a lot
- 9:41of it was definitely something that I was taught a lot or read a lot
- 9:45when I was starting out. It was basically like, don't think about your
- 9:50theme, don't write a theme. We'll be right back after a word from
- 9:54our sponsor, and now back to the show, because if you do,
- 10:03one of two things will happen. Either you'll end up with this horrible moral
- 10:05of a story or you'll end up, you know, just trying to hammer
- 10:09this theme into a story and it doesn't fit and it's inorganic. And I
- 10:13think there's a lot of truth to that, But I think once you understand
- 10:18that theme just emerges organically when your plot and your character are working together.
- 10:24So I think it, Yeah, it's really important and amazing when an author
- 10:28has a passionate statement that they want to make. But at the same time
- 10:33I would be liptle cautious of that because you don't want it to end up,
- 10:35you know, being so moralistic that that's all the story is about.
- 10:39And it's the art of story is making the plot and the character arc an
- 10:46external metaphor for the theme. So you could. There are many many stories
- 10:52that never actually say what they're about, they never state what the theme is.
- 10:56But if they're really well done, then just simply through the scenes,
- 11:01the visual scenes, through the characters and their interactions, and ultimately through how
- 11:05the characters have changed and what is decided in the climactic moment of the conflict,
- 11:11the readers and the viewers get it. You know, we see very
- 11:13clearly what is demon I mean, Indiana Jones is a great example because we
- 11:18see it's very visual. We see exactly what is being said in this story
- 11:24or not right exactly, so just so everybody understands listening. So if if
- 11:28you, as if the author, if we lived, then on alternate universe
- 11:33where I think there is a show called the The Man on Top Castle or
- 11:39something like that, where the Nazis won, where the Nazis won, and
- 11:43Indiana Jones then would have been never called Indiana Jones. It would have called
- 11:46the Nazis or just trying to find some archaeological experiments. If that whole concept
- 11:52was switched, where then the bad guys win, the good guys lose,
- 11:56and that's just the way it's supposed to be. That's a statement by the
- 12:01storyteller stating that that's the way the world should be. That's that's what they're
- 12:05trying to put out there into the world. That's the theme of the story.
- 12:09So and then it's up to you to believe it or not. So
- 12:11it almost becomes a propaganda. But propaganda now we're getting into another conversation where
- 12:15propaganda is all about point of view, and the point of view of the
- 12:18Nazis. It's not propaganda. It's a story, but from our point of
- 12:20view is like, that's just essentially propaganda. Yeah, and I think that's
- 12:24a really good example actually about point of view in that you could we could
- 12:28and we have many stories that do not end well that seeming to be positing
- 12:33something that most of us would completely disagree with. But because of the way
- 12:37it's done, you know, it's done with irony, we understand like this
- 12:41this is not like this isn't literally what the filmmaker or the writer is saying,
- 12:46but they're using irony to kind of say the exact opposite, whereas in
- 12:50other stories it's completely on the nose and like, yeah, Nazis are great,
- 12:54that's that's the message, and that is you know, where we get
- 12:58into the whole thing of propaganda. Right, Well, I mean so,
- 13:01I mean, just using a movie like Thumb and Louise, I mean,
- 13:03it does not end happily. I mean they do not. They do not
- 13:07ride off into the sunset. They kind of do, but not in the
- 13:11way that we normally. And I think that was also a beautifully twist that
- 13:15they did. They literally did ride off into the sunset, but unfortunately spoiler
- 13:18alert off a cliff. So, but the themes in that movie are so
- 13:24powerful and and and that story are so powerful and so it's and it's I
- 13:31mean, it is pretty on the nose. I don't know, how would
- 13:35you like, I mean, im assuming you've seen Thumb on Louise. Oh,
- 13:37yeah, it's it's on the nose, but it's it's not though,
- 13:41I don't know, what do you think? Well, I was going to
- 13:43say that I think that it's much easier to do themes that are not on
- 13:48the nose when they don't end happy happy. It's not to say happy endings
- 13:54don't work or aren't resonant, but when everything works out, you know,
- 13:58when the hero is the shining night of truth and he's completely rewarded for this,
- 14:01it doesn't resonate it doesn't ring true. And so I think in a
- 14:05movie like Thelma and Louise, which ends tragically, there's this resonance because there's
- 14:13also there's also a triumph. There's also a heroism in the way it ends,
- 14:16because they they end in alignment with the story's truth, even though it
- 14:20also is you know, the end of their lives and therefore tragic end the
- 14:24story. So but I think that's that's a really important point. Actually,
- 14:28it's not that you can't end happy endings. We all love happy endings,
- 14:33but it's important that the happy ending when you if that's what you're doing,
- 14:39is earned, that the character, whether they you know, have represented the
- 14:45thematic truth throughout the story or they've come to it in the end, that
- 14:48it hasn't been easy, because I think we all resonate with that because in
- 14:52our own lives it's not easy, and we kind of resent it when the
- 14:56hero is just like everything's just super easy for him, and then he can
- 15:00shake his finger at us in the end and say, see that was the
- 15:03truth. Everybody should do this, and we resent the authors is what we
- 15:07resent when that happens. And that and that, and I'll use one of
- 15:09the movies I bring I bring this movie up a lot because it's such a
- 15:13powerful story, a very popular story, not powerful, but very popular story
- 15:18in the zeitgeist of the world. Right now are the Avengers in the whole
- 15:22Marvel universe where I'm assuming did you see the Last Avengers, the big the
- 15:26Endgame one? Okay, so you know, And again, if no one's
- 15:31seeing it, please stop the recording because I'm going to give you a couple
- 15:33of spoiler alerts here. But the end of that movie, it could so
- 15:37easily just been a normal the good guys beat up the bad guys. There's
- 15:43no there's no risk, there's no no loss, no nothing. But yet
- 15:48in that they they created not only a little loss, massive loss where Tony
- 15:54Stark essentially sacrifices himself because the obstacle was so large that someone had to die,
- 16:00and that made that resonate so much more than everyone sitting around eating scharma
- 16:06at the end of the movie, which we're work fined for the first Avengers,
- 16:10but not so much for the last one because they had built it up
- 16:12over ten someone had to die in order for this to work. So would
- 16:17you agree, Yeah, totally. I was really psyched that basically, they
- 16:22brought the story to an end, you know, even though it's hopefully supposedly
- 16:26it's going to continue in other movies. They brought that story to an end.
- 16:30And that's something that I find is very problematic in serial fiction, whether
- 16:33it's you know, TV series that just go on and on and on,
- 16:37or things you know potentially like the Marvel universe, there's no end, and
- 16:41if there's no end, there's no there's no meaning ultimately, because they're not
- 16:45saying this is what the story is about. And also it's really hard,
- 16:49like you say, to ramp those stakes and say this matters if there isn't
- 16:53an end and there aren't consequences. So yeah, that was something I mean
- 16:59that series as a whole big Marvel fan, but I mean it was,
- 17:02like you say, it had its problems. It wasn't a seamless presentation by
- 17:06any means. But I was very happy and very impressed with what they did
- 17:10by bringing it full circle in that final story in a lot of ways,
- 17:14first and foremost for bringing it to an end, but also I just thought
- 17:18it was just fantastic how they brought it for full circle, how the beginning,
- 17:22the very first movie, we go all the way back to Iron Man.
- 17:25It ends with him saying I am Iron Man, and then we get
- 17:26it come all the way to the end and it means something completely different.
- 17:30In the beginning, it's totally egoic. In the end, it's totally self
- 17:33sacrificial. So I thought that was very powerful, a very powerful example of
- 17:40why we need to bring stories to an end. And also, I mean,
- 17:42and we want to talk about thematic. I mean, well, comic
- 17:45books is specifically the Marvel comic book characters. They are I mean, the
- 17:49themes are so I mean, Stan you know, God at Rest in Peace
- 17:55has created some of the most memorable characters in human history essentially, and but
- 18:00their themes are extremely powerful, and I think that's one of the things that
- 18:06resonates so powerfully with with people around the world, every one of those And
- 18:10it's not stories that have themes, but I feel that the characters have theme
- 18:15more because there's a theme attached to Spider Man and to Hulk and to Fantastic
- 18:19Four and to X Men. X Men is racism and being a loner and
- 18:23standing out. Spider Man is being a young kid just trying to figure things.
- 18:27Hulk is obviously Anger Fantastic four is family issues, but they're themes associated
- 18:34the character. Can you attach themes to characters? I mean obviously you can,
- 18:37but you what's your take on that? Yeah, And I think that's
- 18:41actually that's a great way to bring it back to plot and character because and
- 18:45honestly, the whole Marvel if we look at the whole Marvel cinematic universe,
- 18:49you know, through that story arc, there's a bazillion different plots going on.
- 18:52Everybody's got their own plots. You know, every movie's got its own
- 18:56plot. And really, at the end of the day, it's not the
- 18:57plots we remember, you know. We we don't think about, oh,
- 19:00that was such a great plot in in you know, that particular movie,
- 19:04because most of them weren't. A lot of the plots were very problematic in
- 19:07a lot of the movies, Like I could remember, Like when you said
- 19:10that, I'm like, which are the plots I remember? Like Winter Soldier
- 19:12was really good. Winter Soldiers probably one of the best. And there's like
- 19:15a handful of like plots that I remember, But I don't remember the plots
- 19:19as much. Yeah, you remember the characters. And I think that it's
- 19:23exactly because theme is so rooted in character and the story, the series works
- 19:29as a whole, overarching because that does have a plot that has a unifying
- 19:33plot in which everything kind of works together with Thanos as the antagonist, which
- 19:38is another good point about how antagonists pull together the plot, which is why
- 19:42a lot of the individual movies had their problems with plot. But yeah,
- 19:48it's the characters. Theme is inherent in the character arc. It's inherent in
- 19:52the the internal conflict between thematic lies and truths that happen on a character level.
- 19:59We'll be right back after a word from our sponsor and now back to
- 20:06the show. And you can stick, you know, themes onto the surface
- 20:11of a plot and say, this plot is about why war is evil or
- 20:15whatever. But if it's not happening inside of the character, if you're not
- 20:18just feeling that struggle, then you're really going to struggle to execute a meaningful
- 20:26theme that is going to resonate with with viewers or readers. Now, what
- 20:33is the the thematic principle? Okay, thematic principle is basically a term for
- 20:40any iteration of theme that you find in your story. So it's the unifying
- 20:45idea though when you are trying to figure out what is my theme, and
- 20:49you're you know, looking at like, well, it's kind of about this,
- 20:52and it's kind of about that. The thematic principle is going to be
- 20:56your through line. So that is something that once you identify it, which
- 21:00once you identify what is at the heart of specifically the protagonist's character development,
- 21:06that is going to become the thematic principle for the story and is something that
- 21:10you can then kind of use as a plumb line to measure all the other
- 21:14little elements and decide is this working, is this supporting the theme, is
- 21:17it proving the theme, or is it just kind of extraneous and really telling
- 21:21a different story altogether. Now, how do you prevent theme from becoming a
- 21:26little bit on the nose or preachy, because that, I mean, we've
- 21:30all seen movies or read books that are a little bit on the nose,
- 21:33a little bit like, stop preaching to me so much and just tell me
- 21:38a story. I think it's a good question because I mean, so many
- 21:44of us, you know, if we're interested in theme at all, it's
- 21:47probably because we really are passionate about certain topics and we want to be able
- 21:52to comment on them. Or share our views in some degree. And honestly,
- 21:57that's a tricky thing to do in the medium of fiction because when you
- 22:02are on the nose, when you say this is the way it is,
- 22:03this is what I think and you should think it too, it never goes
- 22:07well. But I think one of my favorite ways to look at this,
- 22:11and it isn't explicit, but one of my favorite kind of rules of thumb
- 22:18is to think of it as if stories are not there to answer to provide
- 22:23answers, they're there to ask questions. And I think this is most powerful
- 22:29when the author himself is asking the question, because I mean, we all
- 22:33have our ideas about how we think things should be or how things will turn
- 22:37out if this and this happens. But I think when the author him or
- 22:41herself really inhabits that question, whether they think they know the answer or not,
- 22:47and explores it from within the drama of the story, you know,
- 22:51throws the characters into the plot and lets events start happening. You to really
- 22:57explore that you have to get down on the grind own and get down and
- 23:00dirty and really question your own beliefs about things. Otherwise the characters do not
- 23:04ring true and I've always said that if you don't, like, you're not
- 23:08almost convinced by your antagonist's point of view, then you're not writing him write
- 23:15and your theme is probably going to come across very one sided. I think
- 23:21the most powerful themes are the ones where the protagonist and to some degree the
- 23:26author and to some degree the readers have a serious question about what about the
- 23:30worldview that's being presented? Is this working? You know, is this really
- 23:34how it's going to be because of the sacrifices that are involved and the moral
- 23:40gray areas and all of that. I think Sam Raimi's speaking of Marvel.
- 23:44I think Sam Raimi's versions of his original two Spider Man movies first to get
- 23:48a really really great job of this really explored the consequences of heroism and responsibility.
- 23:56And I mean we really see that even in the second one, where
- 24:00Peter's like completely questioning, do I do I even want to be Spider Man?
- 24:03The stinks I don't want to do this, And that really flies in
- 24:07the face of kind of the surface obvious way to go about, you know,
- 24:11being a hero's great, this is awesome if everybody wants to, you
- 24:15know, have these powers, right, And I need. That was a
- 24:18very powerful exploration of that subject. Yeah. I mean, because you're right,
- 24:22because everybody's like everybody wants to have powers, but everyone. That's what
- 24:25made stand so amazing is that he gave superheroes problems, Like Superman never had
- 24:30any you know, like issues with his relationships. You know, at the
- 24:36beginning, you know, Batman was pretty wonderment like he's like you know,
- 24:40and wonder Woman did dead and Aquaman did that. But when you got into
- 24:42the Marvel, I mean you got Spider Man who had pimples and was dealing
- 24:45with you know, being a nerd at school, like oh, like everybody
- 24:48else that's dealt with at one point in their life or another, and gave
- 24:52it and giving those problems. That's I think what made those characters so they
- 24:56resonate so much even to this day. And that's why I guess the popularity
- 25:02of the MCU so much is because even the crazy even like ant I mean
- 25:06ant Man, like you know, Guardians of the gal Like when ant Man
- 25:08and Guardians of the Galaxy came out, I was like, wow, man,
- 25:11they are just scraping like the like nobody wants to see an ant Man
- 25:17movie, and yet ant man was like an amazing heist film. It was
- 25:22just like a fun heist film almost. It was just it's it's it's remarkable.
- 25:26But you also said something earlier in regards to antagonists bringing together the theme.
- 25:33Can you kind of delve into that a little bit more like using let's
- 25:36say Thanos as an example, because Santos was such a an overarching he was
- 25:41only this the true villain in two two movies, right it was the last
- 25:45two Avengers. He was that he was the actual villain where he always was
- 25:48kind of like, you know, he was a puppet master for the first
- 25:52eight years or something like that, and then he just showed him. He's
- 25:56like, well, apparently no one else is gonna get it done, so
- 25:57I'll show up and take care of it. But how how does a character
- 26:00like thatanals kind of bring together the theme of that whole overarching first ten years
- 26:06of the MCU. Well, I think to me, the best entry point
- 26:11to that question is really to look at how and the antagonist kind of defines
- 26:15the plot. And obviously, as we've been talking about the plot, theme,
- 26:19character, they're all they're all three sides of the same thing basically,
- 26:23So you can hardly talk about one without talking about the other. But the
- 26:27antagonist is as the obstacle that is opposing the protagonist in the story. He's
- 26:34what creates the conflict. So no antagonist, no conflict, no story.
- 26:38The protagonist just you know, goes straight to finish and gets two hundred dollars
- 26:42or whatever. But the antagonist is as we all get that, So,
- 26:48yeah, there's a horrible bad guy out there in the distance that we know
- 26:52is going to show up and be the big boss in the climax. But
- 26:56if that antagonist isn't consistently what is opposing the protagonists throughout the structure of the
- 27:03story, then ultimately the story it just I mean, at its best,
- 27:07it still kind of works, but it loses that deep cohesion and resonance because
- 27:12the protagonist is off doing other stuff. He's you know, dealing with other
- 27:17antagonists. And I think we see that again and again in the Marvel movies.
- 27:19It's like the antagonist is is kind of the subplot. He's off doing
- 27:23whatever shows up for the big battle, and most of the time it's more
- 27:27interesting personal problems that are actually the plot of the story. As we like
- 27:32Iron Man two immediately comes to mind you were like, I mean, like
- 27:36Black Panther had a great antagonyest he has a fan. There's there's a handful
- 27:38of really good villains. Very few though, I want to say probably like
- 27:42five out of all the movies that were like, Holy cal these are really
- 27:47good. I mean, I think Warmonger is actually going to get his own
- 27:49spin off movie. Really, I heard. I heard, I heard through
- 27:52the geek the geek vine, that that he's actually gonna get his own spin
- 27:59off because he was he was just the opposite side of the coin of Black
- 28:03Panther, and he arguably was was right and the in regards to what his
- 28:11point his world point of view was. Even Black Panther agreed with him.
- 28:15He just didn't agree with how he was doing it, but he agreed with
- 28:18it. That's what made it so amazing, because the hero is not supposed
- 28:22to agree with the point of view of the villain. But yet you're like,
- 28:23look, I you're right, you know things were bad, but you
- 28:26just can't go around killing people. Yeah. I think that Black Panther is
- 28:30actually a good example of kind of both sides of the coin, and that
- 28:36structurally it struggled with the antagonist a little bit. It had some issues with
- 28:40the antagonist being there throughout the story and being you know, he kind of
- 28:42doesn't show up until I want to say, like halfway through almost really like
- 28:45he's because they had the build they had to set up. Yeah, they
- 28:48had to kind of set everything up right anyway. But he's also a great
- 28:51example of what I was saying about how we need to be almost convinced by
- 28:56the antagonist's point of view, and when that happens, you get that really
- 29:00is like the generator of all of this potential for amazing change within the protagonist,
- 29:04And when the protagonist starts changing or any character, but particularly the protagonist,
- 29:08that's where then is generated because it can't help but just spontaneously emerge from
- 29:15what's happening from the events in the story. Well, yeah, like I
- 29:18mean, Thanos's point of view is like, look, everything's overpopulated. We
- 29:22need to we need to thin the herd. I mean again, rough conversation
- 29:26to have do we agree with the concept of like, yeah, all the
- 29:32resources are being taken away and there are too many you know, creatures in
- 29:34the world, in the universe and things like that, But you can't just
- 29:37kill everybody with the snap of a finger. So the point of view is
- 29:41it's like, it's not That's what I think. Always find a good villain
- 29:45to be in a good theme for a villain is is the the twisting of
- 29:48the mustache character. Oh, they're just horrible, They're just like, oh,
- 29:52he's just being bad because there's no point. I've just been We've been
- 29:56watching a lot since we've been locked up. Will be right back after a
- 30:00word from our sponsor, and now back to the show. A lot of
- 30:08old movies again, a lot of old shows again, and and when you
- 30:12see a villain, you're like, oh, that villain has no point of
- 30:15view, and it's the whole movie dies, the whole the whole story falls
- 30:21apart when the when the there's no real strong point of view. But when
- 30:25the villain does have the strong and you're right, theme just kind of just
- 30:27just flourishes right out of that because it has to there is no other way.
- 30:32It has to be there. Yeah, it's like the protagonist, you
- 30:34know, comes in and says, you know, this is the right way
- 30:37to do it, and then as soon as the antagonist comes up with a
- 30:40convincing argument, why that's not so, it's just the protagonist is kind of
- 30:42like, oh, well, plan B, I guess if there is no
- 30:47Plan B, And so then all of a sudden there's like genuine you know,
- 30:52character development, story development, unexpected, you know, original events that
- 30:56come out of that, because it is so genuine in in that the author
- 31:02or the storytellers are really you know, having that discussion with themselves like,
- 31:07oh well, maybe maybe my hero is not as right as I thought he
- 31:11was. What does that mean? And all kinds of interesting things come out
- 31:12of that, absolutely absolutely Now Thematically a film series and a character like James
- 31:18Bond, James original James Bond pre Daniel Craig, what is the theme of
- 31:25those movies? You know, woman eyes, drink a lot of alcohol and
- 31:30then just kill people in distract in describability, like like, yeah, I
- 31:34haven't seen any of the ones before Daniel Craig, but of course I'm familiar
- 31:37with the gist of them. I don't know. Yeah, see that,
- 31:42That to me is an example of every story has a theme, but just
- 31:48because it's saying something doesn't necessarily mean that it's having a positive influence on the
- 31:55world, right Because James, because James Bond, honestly before Daniel Craig Daniel
- 31:59once because you of course, I always consider Concino Royal probably the best James
- 32:01Bond movie in my personal opinion. Yeah, I really like that. I
- 32:05mean it's just it's a masterpiece in that genre. But he was a character,
- 32:10he had a character arc. James Bond never had a character arc before,
- 32:15like you know, Sean Connery's car, you know, and Pierce Bras
- 32:17and they were the same dude from the beginning to the end. They never
- 32:21really changed. They just kind of went along. Not even the people around
- 32:24them changed. I mean maybe some of the female toys that he used along
- 32:30the way, like the Bond Girls, which is so out of date,
- 32:32but that for the time that it came out, it was it was it.
- 32:36But you go back and thinking, like, this is not a message
- 32:39that kind of resonated. Now, if you just forget all about the message,
- 32:44just enjoy the ride, then I get it. It's a ride and
- 32:47you're going along. The good guy's going to stop the bad guy. But
- 32:51it's not really deep. Yeah, and I think that's fine to a point.
- 32:58But that's why I say there's no such things, just a story,
- 33:00because anything that you're bringing into your environment that is becoming a part of your
- 33:05own view of the world and your own reality that's changing you in some way
- 33:09or another. You know, whether you're it could be conscious, it could
- 33:13be not. So I think that's a great example. I haven't seen those
- 33:16movies, so I'm not I can't directly comment on them. I've only seen
- 33:20the Daniel Craig Winz. But I think it's a great example of how mindless
- 33:24entertainment is never actually harmless entertainment. There's always something that is affecting your view
- 33:31of the world. You know, you're absolutely right, because like mindless video
- 33:37games and things like that, people are like, it could get video games
- 33:40or stories and we're telling a story. With the video games, you're just
- 33:44performing the story yourself. But a lot of times those stories and those kind
- 33:47of mindless movies or mindless shows, there's something coming through it. Sometimes it's
- 33:54not good, and it does have an effect on people, whether that be
- 33:58ultra violence, whether that be misogyny, eaether it be you know, the
- 34:01Nazis, win I mean, you know, any of those kind of things.
- 34:08It's as storytellers we have a very big responsibility with especially if you're given
- 34:15the platform of and millions and millions of dollars to make a movie or show.
- 34:21We have a big responsibility and the creators have a big responsibility to what.
- 34:25I love what you alas you've been saying this a couple of times.
- 34:28The deposit what are you depositing into? You know, the statement you're making
- 34:32you're depositing this into the world's narrative. Now, that's a very powerful statement,
- 34:38and I love that you said. I might actually steal that because it's
- 34:43it's true every time you tell a story, you're depositing it into the library
- 34:46of the human experience that might live for a long time or might just fall
- 34:52off to the to the wasteland. But it is extremely important that you know
- 34:57that you have that you have this respon ponsibility. Would you agree, Yeah,
- 35:01totally. That's something I'm I'm very happy you said that, actually,
- 35:06because that's something I'm really passionate about, just in that I think there's so
- 35:13much entertainment is so available to us now, and it's so easy for people
- 35:17to create it. You know, we're all every and I think that's great.
- 35:21I mean, I think storytelling is a deeply important thing for anybody to
- 35:27do that it's it's very powerful just on a personal level. Never mind if
- 35:31you're actually able to, you know, share that with other people. But
- 35:35I think we are able to share what we're creating more and more easily with
- 35:38people around us. There's just so many platforms, and it's so easy,
- 35:43you know, and easy to you know, get out there and have an
- 35:45audience. And most of us do it because it's fun, it's entertaining,
- 35:51it's fun, you know, and we just want to We think we just
- 35:52want to entertain other people. And that's fine to a point, but I
- 35:57do think we have to truly recognize the responsibility of what we're doing. Stories
- 36:02are It's one thing to say this is my view of the world. I
- 36:07want you to believe it. It's another thing to write a story about it,
- 36:08particularly a relatively well crafted story, which ultimately is a subliminal message.
- 36:15You know, most people are not conscious of what they are, of the
- 36:17truths that they're receiving through stories. If the themes are really well done,
- 36:22nobody's saying them, but they're they're just the same. They're being proven,
- 36:24you know, through the reality of the story, through the visuals and the
- 36:29events. And I believe very strongly that it's deeply important for artists of all
- 36:36stripes, but particularly storytellers in this context to recognize that, you know,
- 36:40the power is yours to do what you well with, but be conscious of
- 36:45it, because there is no such thing as just a story. Even if
- 36:49you are the only person who reads it, it's still affecting you. It's
- 36:52changing you, and insofar as it changes you, it's going to have a
- 36:55ripple effect that changes the world around you. It is arguably one of the
- 37:00most powerful things that the human the humans have created. His story, because
- 37:07it is a story, can change a person's perspective, point of view.
- 37:14It could go bad or it can go good. And that's also relatively speaking.
- 37:19Like I always tell people, you know, Hitler didn't wake up every
- 37:22morning thinking he was the bad guy. He woke up every morning like I'm
- 37:27doing God's work, Like you know, that was that was as a villain.
- 37:30You have to think like Darth Vader is not sitting around going I'm so
- 37:35bad. No, he had. It's always about a point of view,
- 37:39and but it is we as filmmakers have to think that. And I know
- 37:45you've probably seen this as well when you read stories by first time writers or
- 37:50young writers, that that's not there. They're not thinking that far ahead in
- 37:55regards to the story of how this story could actually affect people. They're just
- 38:00trying to get a story written. That's hard enough, let alone, Like,
- 38:01oh god, you're can throw this responsibility on me now that I have
- 38:05to I have to like, oh my god, what I like? I
- 38:07have a loaded shotgun and I have them walking around with them like no,
- 38:09look, look, yes, but don't worry. You're not going to kill
- 38:14anybody with a story, hopefully, hopefully, hopefully, But it is a
- 38:21responsibility. But you don't see that. And only when you start seeing like
- 38:24the master's work, then you start seeing they just weave theme in so effortlessly.
- 38:30Character is almost so effortlessly that you just go, Okay. So when
- 38:34you start reading Shakespeare, you know that dude, or you start reading you
- 38:40know, even current day masters like Stephen King or JK. Rowling and the
- 38:45Harry Potter series, like you start looking at the stuff that they did and
- 38:49how they wrote it. It's just but the themes just pop so heavily in
- 38:53all of those things. Yeah, And I think you use the word master,
- 38:58and I think that's the key there is that they've mastered the plot they've
- 39:00mastered the character. And because of that, like I say, the theme
- 39:04emerges and it's there, and it's so powerful because the stories they're writing are
- 39:08so cohesive, they're so resonant. All the pieces are there for a reason,
- 39:15and they had I think both Stephen Kingham probably rolling they have. They
- 39:17have things they want to say and they say them, you know, well
- 39:22they say them, you know, through the honesty of their own stories,
- 39:23and that has clearly resonated with billions of people. But yeah, I think
- 39:30I think it is perhaps good for writers who are starting out to realize that,
- 39:36yeah, you're it's not the weight of the world on your shoulders.
- 39:38It's more about just a consciousness just I mean, don't approach it. Approach
- 39:44it with fear and trembling, but don't approach it with this you know sobriety.
- 39:47Approach it with that same childlike wonder that you had when you were a
- 39:51kid and you were making up, you know, probably the stories of greater
- 39:53truth than you will ever write as an adult. We'll be right back after
- 39:59a word from our sponsor, and now back to the show. And it
- 40:07was just fun, you know, you were just tapped into it and it
- 40:09was fun and exciting, and then I think we kind of we start overthinking
- 40:14it as adults. We were like so serious with the responsibility of our adultness
- 40:17and how we've got to make sure that everybody else is just as responsible,
- 40:21and you know, then we start writing stuff that's on the nose, we
- 40:25lose the muse, we lose that childlike innocence. Really, it's not just
- 40:30the wonder but the innocence that allows us to ask questions, you know,
- 40:35to just step into that story world and look around and see, you know,
- 40:38what, what do I think? I don't know. Let's let's find
- 40:42out. Let's you know, throw some characters out there and see what happens.
- 40:45And maybe by the end, you know, I will have been impacted
- 40:47by this more than anybody who reads it. But it's exciting, It doesn't
- 40:52it needs to be something that we take seriously. But I definitely think that
- 40:58ultimately it's still about having It's still about entering that kind of that dream zone
- 41:02and just playing. Absolutely. Now, we talked a lot about character affecting
- 41:08theme. How can you use plot specifically, how can we use plot to
- 41:15help create our theme? Yeah, So, like I say, plot,
- 41:19character theme, they're what I call the Big three. And really, if
- 41:22all, if your story is working well, then they are seamlessly, organically,
- 41:27even effortlessly, going to be working together. So if your plot is
- 41:30working really well, then it's almost certain that your characters and your theme are
- 41:35also there. And if something's wrong with your plot, it's probably because something's
- 41:37off with one of the other two. But specifically, if you look at
- 41:43character arc and how that works over the entirety of the story, you can
- 41:47see how deeply tied in it is with plot structure, and you know,
- 41:53more or less all plot structure systems are pointing to the same thing, just
- 41:58with you know, different perspectives. I specifically use the three act structure,
- 42:01and you can just pretty much just overlay you know, a basic character or
- 42:06structure onto the plot structure and they interact. You can't have one without the
- 42:09other. It's not like the characters off doing his little subplot development. Well
- 42:15you know the James Bond action is happening over here, Yeah, because then
- 42:17they wouldn't be. But that's also then you wouldn't be the main character,
- 42:22you'd be a sub character. Yeah, So it's it's happening together. The
- 42:27internal conflict is what is prompting the character to act in the external conflict,
- 42:31and then the external conflict is you know, coming back and asking him to
- 42:36question within himself what he's doing and why he's doing it. And so it's
- 42:39it's from within that the character has certain mindsets and ideas that he wants to
- 42:45accomplish, and the plot is then through the conflict, you know, and
- 42:49the consequences and the stakes is going to prove one way or the other whether
- 42:53the characters you know, initial ideas are true. And from that is where
- 42:58fem emerges. So well, can you tell can you talk a little bit
- 43:04about the difference between theme and a message, because that is that there's a
- 43:08there's a subtleness to that. Yeah. So I think it was Michael Hauga
- 43:13who wrote writing screenplays that sell I believe, Michael Hay, Michael Haig,
- 43:17Yeah, Michael Hegg Okay, Yeah, So I believe he was the one
- 43:22that that differentiated that, or was the first person I'd seen who differentiated theme
- 43:27from message, and I thought that was such a keen observation. And the
- 43:31way he defines them basically is that theme is a universal principle. It's we'll
- 43:37just say, love conquers all something that everybody resonates to, regardless who they
- 43:42are, where they live, their their circumstances. Message, however, is
- 43:46very specific to the situation within the story. So the message is something that
- 43:52is only going to apply to people who are like the protagonist, people who
- 43:59are in this situation. You know, like I'm trying to think of something
- 44:05that has to do with love conquers All. But you know, in your
- 44:07specific love story, right, it's like it only applies to you and your
- 44:12partner. It's not something that's necessarily you know, the lessons that you learned,
- 44:16and the theme of that isn't something that's necessarily going to apply to all
- 44:21people everywhere, even though we all relate to the idea of love, right.
- 44:24So I think that's really important because it allows you to play out the
- 44:28specifics of a scenario and yet still have something to say to a much broader
- 44:31audience. Beauty in the Beast, love Conquers All. I was racking my
- 44:37love conkers all un comfort Beauting the Beast perfect, okay there? Yeah,
- 44:40And how many of us, you know, have to go through that where
- 44:43you're you know, it's the beast and you have to redeem him and you
- 44:45know, well, that's pretty specific. That's uh well, I mean arguably
- 44:50that is, it's according to my wife. Uh not that not that specific.
- 44:54Uh, I mean that's true. That's the beauty of it because it
- 44:59is like a premely archetypal story. And yet again the specifics of it,
- 45:04you know, particularly in the fairy tale medium, very specific. The message,
- 45:08you know is, you know, don't make the fairy mad when she
- 45:12comes to your castle, you know, or she's gonna cursey and you're gonna
- 45:15have to go through all this. So let's let's let's since we've talked now,
- 45:17since we've touched upon the fairy tale. The fairy tale is is these
- 45:22stories have been around for hundreds, if not some of them, even thousands
- 45:27of hear some of these stories, and they're so archetype. They're so on
- 45:31the nose. They're so on the nose. Like beauting the Beast is fairly
- 45:36on the nose. There is nothing subtle about beauting the Beast or Little Mermaid
- 45:39or Lion King or I'm going through Disney movies now, but but they're they're
- 45:45they're very on the nose. They're those themes are such, but those that
- 45:49kind of those kind of stories are extremely important to the human condition the whole.
- 45:52The love conquers All is a very powerful and important theme that as humans
- 45:59we should understand stand or at least have some sort of inkling of what that
- 46:04is. These stories, like I always love that George Lucas said this,
- 46:08He's like, myth is essentially the meat and potatoes of our society, and
- 46:14that's how we pass along the core elements like love conquers all, good versus
- 46:20bad, you know, be honest, you know, the boy who Cried
- 46:24Wolf. These kind of like very struck these kind of themes. I'd love
- 46:30to hear your take on that. On fairy tales and what the power of
- 46:34what they do. I am archetypal stories or something else I'm very passionate about,
- 46:40and I think I would argue that they are not on the nose.
- 46:44I think that they are because they are so metaphor. I mean, they're
- 46:49not literal. You know, nobody actually turns into a beast. You know,
- 46:52they're not cursed by fairies and turn into a beast. That's a metaphor.
- 46:55And therefore, even though the stories are very straightforward and simplistic, in
- 47:00some ways, they're not on the nose, simply because they're not literal.
- 47:05If you had a good boy criedwoof, you know, if you if that
- 47:09was a story where the boy the mother told the boy stop lying, and
- 47:12the boy came in, and you know, it's no longer about what's actually
- 47:16you know, being dramatized. It's specifically like an in my book, in
- 47:22the theme book, I talk about how when I was in middle school,
- 47:25I had to read these stories about kids who you know, did kid stuff.
- 47:30They had to mow the lawn to earn some money they had, they
- 47:32found they found a lost wallet and they had to return it. You know.
- 47:36It was like these these little lessons about how to be a good kid,
- 47:38you know, and that's all they were. There was nothing about them
- 47:43that wasn't literally, this is what you're supposed to do as a kid.
- 47:45And I hated them even as a kid. They're so preachy and on the
- 47:51nose. But stories, I think, like you know, anything where you
- 47:54find that really archetypal element, whether it's fairy tales or our Wars or comic
- 48:00books, I think it's because they transcend the literal. Spider Man is just
- 48:07a teenage kid who reminds all of us of ourselves at some point in our
- 48:12lives. But he has spider powers. You know, that's nothing that any
- 48:16of us actually relate to. It's just a metaphor and a hyperbole of our
- 48:22own lives. Now we've talked about theme in regard to like I think you
- 48:30were talking about, well, that's the concept of love conquers all and certain
- 48:34themes within stories. But genre has such a powerful point in regards to theme.
- 48:42Whereas there's certain things that you just can't do with theme because of the
- 48:46genre they're in, and then sometimes when you can transcend that because then you've
- 48:52really hit like get Out is an amazing example of taking the horror genre and
- 48:59completely flipping it on his head. Thematically. Yeah, yeah, I think
- 49:05genre actually, to me, genre stories are very archetypal. I think the
- 49:08essence of genre is archetype. We have most obviously perhaps in the romance romance
- 49:14genre, but also in many, many different I mean the very fact that
- 49:17there are tropes and there are templates that readers expect you to follow that creates
- 49:22an archetype. But most of them are even more deeply rooted in archetype than
- 49:28even just modern conventions about the actual genre. So yeah, there are certain
- 49:32themes that are inherent in certain genres, love conquers all being an obvious one
- 49:37for romance, or the you know, good conquers evil being an obvious one
- 49:42for action adventure stories, things like that, And so yeah, I think
- 49:46we can see that these are they're archetypal because there's stories that are perennially asking
- 49:52the same questions. We'll be right back after a word from our sponsor and
- 50:01now back to the show. Because we say love conquers all or good triumphs
- 50:08over evil, But then there's that part of us that has a question,
- 50:13you know, like there is a deep part of us that believes in those
- 50:15things. But for most of us, there's also a question too, does
- 50:19love conquer all? Does good always triumph over evil? And so I think,
- 50:23no, yeah, no, no, The answer is because we live
- 50:27in the real world exactly, And I think that the really good genre stories
- 50:32are the ones that keep asking those same questions over and over in ways that
- 50:37give us fresh insights into really are not perennial statements, but are perennial questions
- 50:43within the human existence. One thing that I found one of the storytellers that
- 50:47I've always studied and loved. I'm a big fan of as a director or
- 50:52writer. Director is James Cameron because he is obviously he knows how to tap
- 50:55into something. Because his track record is nobody else has ever had a track
- 51:02right, nobody, not even Spielberg, not even It's just a very specific
- 51:07track record that he's created for himself. But what I've noticed in all of
- 51:10his stories he does something that is really interesting. He he actually not only
- 51:20smashes genres together, but also I'm not sure if he's he smashes themes together,
- 51:27but he definitely mashes genres together. So if you look a Terminator,
- 51:30his first real work, it's an action adventure, but it's a love conquers
- 51:35all story. You know, you look at the Abyss action adventure, Love
- 51:39Conquers All, Titanic action adventure, Love Conquers All, and then some other
- 51:44themes in there as well, about classism and and that kind of stuff.
- 51:46Same thing with Avatar action adventure, Love conquers All, and then then there's
- 51:52also you know, environmental themes and other things like that he threw in there,
- 51:55but he slams all of this stuff together. So Avatars are really good
- 52:00example of that. There is a lot of stuff going on in Avatar thematically.
- 52:04Yeah, I think that that it's first of all, I think it's
- 52:06He's what you've presented there is a good example of how you can have a
- 52:09main through line of the where the theme and the plot and the character all
- 52:13come together and provide that cohesion in resonance, and then you can still explore,
- 52:16you know, other things that come up naturally through the story's premise.
- 52:22But I would specifically like to reference Terminator and Titanic because I think that the
- 52:28thing to me about James Cameron, because he is, like you say,
- 52:31does all these crazy things with genre, and yet underlying it, particularly for
- 52:37those two movies, I feel, is this rock solid archetypal story and I
- 52:42think we don't always notice it because it's not the hero's journey. And this
- 52:46is something that I'm really excited about right now and I'm going to start writing
- 52:50about on my site hopefully next year. But just the realization that we are
- 52:55so fixated on the hero's journey, like that's the only archetypal underpinning for all
- 53:00stories everywhere, and of course it's not. And I think that actually something
- 53:06that I realized in reading Kim Hudson's her book was called The Virgin's Promise,
- 53:12I think, but she pausits specifically like a counter type character journey that's more
- 53:19feminine based. And in that too, she talks about how really that's just
- 53:22the first act the hero, the virgin and the hero are just the first
- 53:27act of human existence. Most stories do not even tap, you know,
- 53:30the more mature archetypes of the second act, much less our elder archetypes in
- 53:36the third act. So this is something I've really been researching this year and
- 53:39I'm really excited about. But to me, why James Cameron was so fantastically
- 53:46on point in Terminator and Titanic specifically, was he nailed the virgin journey.
- 53:53He nailed that version, that feminine journey, and not just within the character
- 53:59but specific Terminator. The whole thing is a metaphor for that feminine journey.
- 54:04You've got the protector and the predator and then how in the end they both
- 54:07die and she's the one who has to deal with it, and it's just
- 54:10fantastic. I love Terminator, the first Terminator and the second one of just
- 54:15the best of the series. Yeah, anyway, but really I think what
- 54:19it is for me anyway, why those stories work is not just because they're
- 54:22well told, well plotted, not just because they're entertaining or have something to
- 54:25say, but because they are just rock solid on that archetypal level. Yeah
- 54:30and and yeah they take the virgin story, but then they also take I
- 54:35mean, if you look at Terminator is such a brilliant just a genius piece
- 54:38of literature, not literature but of cinema, but just writing the storytelling.
- 54:44And that is so complex on its but it's on its surface there's a big
- 54:50dude with a gun trying to kill two other people. That's that's on the
- 54:54surface. But that's what That's the brilliance of Cameron, I think, is
- 54:58that on the surface, it's a the Titanic, it's about we all know
- 55:01where we all That's what the thing when I heard about Titanic, like James
- 55:05man like we all know where the ending, we all know where this is
- 55:07going, Like how can you be excited about a movie that you know the
- 55:10ending to? But yet he was able to pull that off in such a
- 55:15way. And I'm always fascinated. I always love talking to story people who
- 55:19really analyze and study story about Avatar because Avatar story and themed. I mean
- 55:25he theme thematically Avatar is pretty it borders preachy. Sometimes it borders preachy.
- 55:34Yet how was it because it wasn't just the cool visuals, because we've seen
- 55:37cool visuals before. There was something else that resonated in the human condition that
- 55:44made it the biggest movie in the world of all time and arguably still is
- 55:50one of the biggest movies of all time. What did he do in that
- 55:53story from your point of view that connected thematically? Because I think the themes
- 55:59are extremely Love conquers all you have to protect that obviously, the environmental themes
- 56:06good versus very big, good versus evil themes, Like, what did you
- 56:10think about that? It's been a long time since I've seen that movie,
- 56:14and I only saw it once, so I'm trying to remember. I think
- 56:19all of everything you've said, you know is really true is what gives it
- 56:23a big feel. I would say though that really I'm as far as I
- 56:29remember, because again it's been at least ten years since I've seen it.
- 56:34It's it's that character, the main character, and how he's we get a
- 56:37good character arc from him. And also there's that this relatability because of the
- 56:43situation that he's in. He's crippled, he you know, gets to go
- 56:45off into video game land and you know, have a whole new body.
- 56:49And I think there's something there's always something powerful about, first of all,
- 56:55completely understanding why a character is the way they are and why they're doing what
- 57:00doing. Because he's kind of a jerk in the beginning, if I remember,
- 57:02right, he was, Yeah, but we still you know, you
- 57:06can still get why why he's doing what he's doing. Why because of you
- 57:10know, this deep motivation that I you know, I want my body back.
- 57:13Basically, I want to be able to walk again, and then to
- 57:16be able to take that and arc it. It's a really tricky thing when
- 57:22you're doing a positive change arc, and so the character has to start basically
- 57:24a deficit, you know, he's he starts in a negative place and then
- 57:29arcs to the positive. So how do you make the character in the beginning
- 57:31somebody who's likable and not the character the readers you know, aren't just immediately
- 57:36fed up with because he's not. He doesn't get it, you know,
- 57:37he's not on the right side of it. And in a in a complex
- 57:43story that particularly rises out of you know, complex lies that the character might
- 57:47believe and why he's you know, confused in the beginning, because we all
- 57:52are, you know, so there's there's a deep relatability there that even in
- 57:55characters who aren't as inherently likable, I think when we understand stand where they're
- 58:00coming from, that's really a really powerful way to begin the character. In
- 58:05therefore the theme, because we'll follow them. If you're not going to follow
- 58:08the character, you're never going to get to the you know, the juicy
- 58:10parts of the theme. Well, I mean, I think you touched on
- 58:14something that characters are driven by the story that they've told themselves about the world,
- 58:20about about how the world works, and that's James Bond has a very
- 58:24specific story he tells himself to get up in the morning. Indiana Jones has
- 58:29one. Luke Skywalker at the beginning of Star Wars has one as opposed to
- 58:32at the end of the trilogy, he has another story he tells himself.
- 58:37In a lot of times, humans, specifically now in the story, but
- 58:42also in real life, we will fight tooth and nail to defend our point,
- 58:47our story point of view, our life point of view. And it's
- 58:51extremely difficult to change that perspective, because that could be societal, that could
- 58:55be experimental experience, the experiences you've had in life, like if you're if
- 59:00you're a girl, and and we're beaten by your father all your life,
- 59:07early on, in your in your in your childhood. The association that all
- 59:09men are bad is a very tough conversation to have because it's a story that
- 59:15you've told yourself and it's honestly the story that's holding you together. Yes,
- 59:22it's an idea, it's exactly, it's the identity that you've put yourself together.
- 59:25And to break the identity, people will will die to defend it.
- 59:30Is that so as a story as I know, we're going deep now,
- 59:34uh, we're going a little deeper than theme, but but actually could actually
- 59:37could touch back to the theme. I'd love to hear what you think about
- 59:39that. Yeah, I think in essence that story and I think that's definitely
- 59:45the foundational principles of character arc. The way I approach it, it's character
- 59:51arc is basically this conflict, this inner conflict between a lie the character believes
- 59:55and the thematic truth. Will be right back after a word from our sponsor
- 1:00:05and now back to the show, and depending on the type of arc,
- 1:00:09the character might start out believing in the lie or the truth, and he
- 1:00:13might represent the truth steadfastly throughout the story. But in a positive change arc,
- 1:00:17where you have a story a character who starts out the story with a
- 1:00:22limiting belief of some kind, that's the essence of the story. The entire
- 1:00:27story is going to be built to put that character into situations that are going
- 1:00:31to challenge that belief, show him the limitations, and yeah, you know,
- 1:00:36if he arcs positively, is going to bring him out of that into
- 1:00:38a greater truth. But again, in you know, the conversation of not
- 1:00:44having it beyond the nose, the way we keep that from happening is it's
- 1:00:46not easy. You know, there's a reason we hang on to these limiting
- 1:00:51identities and these limiting beliefs, and we all do it every single of the
- 1:00:54day. Every human being on the planet does it. Yeah, absolutely,
- 1:01:00and it's you know, we're we're quite happy to stay that way, and
- 1:01:01so is the character. And tell something happens that you know, that first
- 1:01:06plot point happens and completely rocks the character's normal world and suddenly they have to
- 1:01:10start questioning not just you know, how do I defeat the bad guy.
- 1:01:15But you know what am I going to have to change within myself? You
- 1:01:19know, what views, what stories? What identities? Am I going to
- 1:01:22have to painfully shed in order to be able to grow and move forward?
- 1:01:27Or you know, refuse you do that and stay where you're at basically,
- 1:01:30and that is basically the analogy of life. I mean, it's that's what
- 1:01:36That's why we resonate so much with story and theme in general, because it's
- 1:01:42just an example of what we're going through. It helps us deal with this
- 1:01:46existence. Right. Yeah, I think that you know, people, people
- 1:01:53you know, start learning about story theory and story structure and you know,
- 1:01:58all these ideas about theme and care, and a lot of times there's this
- 1:02:01feeling of like, no, you know, I don't want to impose all
- 1:02:05of these rules onto my creativity, onto my story. And you know,
- 1:02:09it can feel that way when you're you know, you're first making all of
- 1:02:13this conscious. But the truth is exactly the opposite. The only reason we
- 1:02:15have these ideas, these theories about structure and character, arc and theme is
- 1:02:20because we've seen them arising from you know, thousands of years of stories and
- 1:02:27thousands of years of our lives. The psychological journey of a potent character arc
- 1:02:31is only potent in a story because we recognize and resonate with it from our
- 1:02:36own lives. Right The hero's journey, which is it's something that resonates pretty
- 1:02:42much in every culture around the world. It's because we've all done that,
- 1:02:46we all we all understand that. That's why it's such a powerful That's what
- 1:02:51Joseph Campbell was talking about with The Hero with a Thousand Faces, is that
- 1:02:54that is a very through line. I just literally had Chris Fogler on the
- 1:02:59show, who wrote the Writer's Journey, and I was I actually tell him,
- 1:03:02I'm like, Christ's let's talk for a second, Chris. A lot
- 1:03:07of people say, you know, this hero's journey things out of me,
- 1:03:09like it's completely out of whack. You know, it's done. Everybody knows
- 1:03:13that. We've all seen Star Wars. It's kind of blase, you know,
- 1:03:16is it even worth dealing with the hero's journey? And today's very advanced
- 1:03:21storytelling audience, You know, the audience is so well versed. It's so
- 1:03:24much harder to be a storyteller today than it was four hundred years ago.
- 1:03:30One hundred years ago, you could get away with so much. That's totally
- 1:03:34true, and now you really got to know what to do. And he
- 1:03:37said something very very and I wanted to see what he said, and he's
- 1:03:40just like, Alex, I agree with you one hundred percent. It is
- 1:03:44one of many ways to do it. But elements of the hero's journey,
- 1:03:49all of those archetypes are in every story. Yeah, It's just that's regardless
- 1:03:54if you want to believe it or not. There is always going to be
- 1:03:58a trickster somewhere, you know, depending on the story you're telling, a
- 1:04:01trickster, a mentor the old man, the young the young buck who's trying
- 1:04:06to, you know, become a man and all this, all of this
- 1:04:10kind of that's always going to be there. But he goes. But of
- 1:04:13course, there's a thousand different kinds of story structures. There's a thousand different
- 1:04:15ways to tell that story. But the hero's journey is a model that we
- 1:04:20It is the meat and potatoes. It is the foundation that we all kind
- 1:04:24of need to understand as a storyteller. Would is that a fair statement?
- 1:04:28Yeah? I would agree with that, And I think that you know what
- 1:04:30I'm researching and exploring right now, is the idea that the hero's journey is
- 1:04:34not the only one specifically within just the basic, you know, really simplistic
- 1:04:40level of archetypal mythic storytelling. And I think that's a lot of the reason
- 1:04:44the way people you know, wonder like, come on, here's journey one
- 1:04:47story, you know, one ring to roll them all. And by the
- 1:04:53way, you can, you can throw the hero's journey on almost any story
- 1:04:57like after the fact, after the fact, and the truth of it is
- 1:05:00a because it's that archipat type story, but also because it is you know,
- 1:05:05it adheres to that three act structure and so those beats. That's something
- 1:05:10that I am realizing is that, yes, it looks like the hero's journey
- 1:05:14applies to all stories, and it does often. But a lot of it
- 1:05:17is that we think we were not aware of these other these you know,
- 1:05:25these other archetypal journeys, and so we just kind of say, you know,
- 1:05:30there's similarities, right, they all follow a similar arc. It's just
- 1:05:33more of a life progression as instead of it just being you know, the
- 1:05:36young buck the hero. So I think that's part of why people don't always
- 1:05:42It's why I didn't resonate with the Hero's Journey. For a long time,
- 1:05:45I felt like it was just too confining, but then I started realizing,
- 1:05:48like, this is totally it's the three act structure. It is, it's
- 1:05:51right there. But the nuance, I do think that it changes and evolves,
- 1:05:57and that's something that I like, I said, I want to start
- 1:05:59exploring or am I in a series on my site soon? Very cool,
- 1:06:01but yeah, I'm really excited about it. But yeah, I think that
- 1:06:06the Hero's Journey is an incredibly important archetypal story and that it's important because it's
- 1:06:16so simple, and I think that there's there's a difference between We think sometimes
- 1:06:21that complicated stories are the way to go, you know, the way to
- 1:06:26talk to our very sophisticated audience, and I don't think that's the truth at
- 1:06:29all. What we want is complex stories, and complexity is born out of
- 1:06:32simplicity. It's that simple archetypal layer that's provided by archetypal stories like the Hero's
- 1:06:40Journey, and then we get to build the complexity on top of that by
- 1:06:43really exploring those themes and asking those questions and looking at the million different you
- 1:06:48know, angles on a story that's you know, it's it's complexity, but
- 1:06:54it's all coming out of the same base instead of you know, being who
- 1:06:57knows where all over the place. And that brings us back to James Cameron,
- 1:07:01which is a perfect example. The Terminator is is is a question of
- 1:07:06like, will the machines eventually take over? There's that's that's one question,
- 1:07:12but we'll love conquer all. And it's a very simple story. You know,
- 1:07:16it's basically three characters running, that's the story. Yeah, exactly,
- 1:07:23But there is so much complexity in that story and the themes that he the
- 1:07:28themes that he asks questions about. He asks a lot of questions in his
- 1:07:32in his movies, and and that's a really I think that's what really drives
- 1:07:38his kind of storytelling and all of the films that he's made. It is
- 1:07:43very That's why I'm really curious about the new avatars, all four of them.
- 1:07:45I think he's going to be doing for the next eight years or something
- 1:07:51like. But anytime, anytime he comes out with something, people like,
- 1:07:55what do you think of Like, dude, in Cameron, I trust like,
- 1:07:58yeah, I can't. Like I stopped not betting on camera and after
- 1:08:01Titanic I was like, you know what, just if you can make this
- 1:08:05work, brother, you can make almost anything work. And just do you?
- 1:08:10You do you? James? Yeah, Now I'm gonna ask you a
- 1:08:14few questions. I ask all my guests. I usually ask like, what
- 1:08:16are three screenplays that every screenwriter or storyteller should read? If you if that,
- 1:08:21if you don't know anything specific, three screenplays, three films that which
- 1:08:26I mean obviously we would talk about Terminator, but yeah, other films.
- 1:08:30Yeah, I'm not much of a screenplay reader, so I will. I
- 1:08:35mean, I think that it's like super obvious. But I have to always
- 1:08:39go back to the original Star Wars because I feel like that number one.
- 1:08:44I feel like it's gotten lost kind of in the the new movies. But
- 1:08:49for me, there's no comparison, and I feel like that, I mean
- 1:08:51that to me is that's the essence of our modern myth. And so I
- 1:08:55say, you know, go back to that one. I go back all
- 1:08:58the time constantly. But that's the he But that's the hero's journey, Like
- 1:09:01that is the exactly perfect personification of the hero's journey, and yet you go
- 1:09:09back to it constantly, even as as simplistic as the hero's journey is and
- 1:09:13everything, but it's it's executed. It's like eating a really good apple pie.
- 1:09:16Like it's a simple thing. It's not a complex dessert that's going to
- 1:09:20explode. But if you do it, well, you've got a business.
- 1:09:25Yeah. Well, and I think we see that with Rowling, right with
- 1:09:28the Harry Potter series again, I mean, so similar to Star Wars,
- 1:09:31and people just ate it up again, you know, and honestly to me,
- 1:09:35well, I mean, we'll leave that to the books. I guess
- 1:09:38I was going to say the movies, but I know I recommended this the
- 1:09:42last time that I was on the show, but it's still my all time
- 1:09:45favorite movie, so I have to say it again. And that is the
- 1:09:47classic World War two movie, The Great Escape. This is directly by John
- 1:09:51Stars. Yeah, but that went to me. There's so much, such
- 1:09:56a simple story again, you know, guys want to escape. We'll be
- 1:10:00right back after a word from our sponsor. And now back to the show.
- 1:10:11So much complexity, so much character development, and the themes are so
- 1:10:15subtle, they're never stated, they're just you know there. But there's all
- 1:10:18of this, just this this richness in this subtext that's happening there. And
- 1:10:25then number three oh, why not say Terminator because I feel like like there's
- 1:10:34there's just a lot of goodness in that story, and I think it's it's
- 1:10:38a really good counterpart to Star Wars, and that Star Wars is very much
- 1:10:42the male hero's journey, and Terminator is this, in my opinion, pitch
- 1:10:46perfect female, the feminine journey, the feminine psychological journey. So I think
- 1:10:51that they're really good book ends, and it's so it's just a it's so
- 1:10:56amazing that a man has written so much being like some of the most impressive
- 1:11:03female leads in cinema history. He's written between Aliens and Terminator, and all
- 1:11:11of his films that he's worked on, a lot of them have really strong
- 1:11:15Pertamine Rose. I mean, she's pretty strong. She's essentially she ends up
- 1:11:20being the character that runs Titanic. Well, I think, and I do
- 1:11:26think that the you know, why not? You know, I think that
- 1:11:28archetype. But we all have this deep archetypal understanding. And when he's telling
- 1:11:32archetypal stories so well, to me, it's like, yeah, why not?
- 1:11:35And I think we see it with a rowling. You know, there's
- 1:11:38a woman writing a story about hero's journey and a boy. Yeah, So
- 1:11:42it's like that's the fun of writing, you know, that we get to
- 1:11:45explore all of these things that are different from us and do it from a
- 1:11:48place of deep psychological understanding that sometimes we don't even know we have. I
- 1:11:56wanted to ask you a side question because it just came up. You know,
- 1:12:00as a storyteller. You know myself and with the work that I've done
- 1:12:02over my life. As you get older, that story, that perspective,
- 1:12:10that story you tell yourself morphs and changes a lot, and a script that
- 1:12:16I might have written ten years ago I go back to and go ouch,
- 1:12:23that is definitely a perspective of a thirty year old That is not the perspective
- 1:12:27of a forty five year old man who's gone through some other stuff in the
- 1:12:30last fifteen years. There is such a focus on youth and telling that youth
- 1:12:35story of the young buck turning into a man, or the virgin story of
- 1:12:42the on the woman's side. But yet you kind of touched on this earlier.
- 1:12:45There isn't a lot of story about the third chapter in our Lives,
- 1:12:48or even the second chapter. Is they're starting to get mean, you know,
- 1:12:51lifetime pretty much runs the midlife crisis story now either for men or we've
- 1:13:00been going through like oh god, I'm just joking, but there is more
- 1:13:03stories now about people our age, uh and this kind of this kind of
- 1:13:10second chapter, you know, midway through chapter of Our Lives, but there
- 1:13:14is very few good stories about that the third chapter of Our Lives? Can
- 1:13:21you make a make a And it's also because it's harder to sell. Is
- 1:13:27that the main reason you think? Well, I think it's it's an interesting
- 1:13:30thing because, yeah, as I've been preparing to do this this series,
- 1:13:34it's been very challenging to find really good examples of these later life arcs of
- 1:13:40the third act, you know, the third act of the human life.
- 1:13:44It's because there aren't a lot of them. And I think, yes,
- 1:13:46to some degree, it's a hard sell because you, like you say,
- 1:13:48we're a very youth centered culture who's terrified of death, so we really don't
- 1:13:53want to go there. And because I think a lot of times when we
- 1:13:58do see stories about the you know, the end of life, that they're
- 1:14:00not empowered stories. Their stories about you know, coming to terms with death
- 1:14:05in a pretty limited way. And what I'm discovering is that you know,
- 1:14:11there there are empowering arc, the arcs in the second act Midlife, and
- 1:14:15the arcs and the third act for the Elder Years. They are just as
- 1:14:19powerful and magnificent in some ways, more so than what we've grown used to
- 1:14:24with the Hero's Journey. And I think it's just that we as a culture
- 1:14:28have so lost touch with our elders. You know, it's not a we
- 1:14:32don't have. Very few of us really have people in our lives from that
- 1:14:38time in their lives where they can you know, we can see that and
- 1:14:41they can mentor us. And I think that's part of too even you know,
- 1:14:44we don't have the mentor character who shows up for us in our own
- 1:14:48Hero's Journey when we are young, and so there's a there is a missing
- 1:14:54piece kind of I think that's that has happened within the archetypal story of our
- 1:14:58culture. So yeah, I think it's a hard sell, but I think
- 1:15:01there are some amazing stories to be told from those later arcs. And I'm
- 1:15:09not thinking of any examples off top I can give you that. I can
- 1:15:13give you one that is probably as pitch perfect as humanly possible, which is
- 1:15:15Up. Yeah, okay, Up is as perfect well up as a masterpiece,
- 1:15:23as I mean in the first basically, that first three minutes is the
- 1:15:27best, the best summary of a human life. I've ever seen it in
- 1:15:30my entire life. It's so well thought. But it's a it's an older
- 1:15:35character going on a hero's journey. He goes and his mentor happens to be
- 1:15:41a boy scout in any ways, what it is is it's the little boy
- 1:15:45who's going on a hero's journey and he's the mentor, but it's told from
- 1:15:49his point of view. The characters all come full circle, right, it's
- 1:15:53the mentors in the hero's journey who are the heroes of the third act character
- 1:15:58arcs, right, but we don't ever see that, right. That's why
- 1:16:00I was so like everybody. And it's an animated kids film, which is
- 1:16:03so brilliant. I can't like, only Pixar could do something like that.
- 1:16:09But yeah, there aren't many good stories like that. But that's funny though,
- 1:16:12if you look up resonated with kids around the world as well as every
- 1:16:20every stage of life, from a kid all the way to someone in their
- 1:16:25elder years watches up and goes, okay, I get it, I get
- 1:16:29it, And that's the kind of if you can. If you can pull
- 1:16:31that off, you're doing something as a storyteller. That's the power of archetypal
- 1:16:36stories. Now, where can people find your new book and more about you
- 1:16:43and all the cool stuff you're doing. Yeah, so obviously the books on
- 1:16:45Amazon and all of those places, but if they want to specifically look at
- 1:16:49what I'm doing, they can visit my website at helping Writers Become Authors dot
- 1:16:54com. Very cool, Katie, Thank you so much for being on the
- 1:16:58show. I know I want to keep talking to you, just want to
- 1:17:00keep I just want to keep talking. I love talking story. I love
- 1:17:03going deep into this kind of nerdy story stuff and it really helps me just
- 1:17:09think about In all honesty, it just helps you think about life more.
- 1:17:13Totally. Totally, It just makes you think about life. And we are
- 1:17:16in a weird time. There's a lot to think about. There's a lot
- 1:17:20of stuff going on right now in the world, and I feel like that's
- 1:17:24one of the reasons why we're gravitating to story and our Netflix. I have
- 1:17:29Netflix, Hulu, HBO, like I got all of them, but like
- 1:17:30I just need I need something to escape to. I need something to attach
- 1:17:34myself to to escape this crazy world we're living, but it does just help
- 1:17:39us get through the day of this insane existence that we call life. So
- 1:17:45I want to really really appreciate you coming on the show. Thank you so
- 1:17:47much, and keep doing the good work that you're doing. Yeah, you
- 1:17:50too, Thank you so much for having me. I want to thank Katie
- 1:17:54for coming on the show and dropping her knowledge bombs on the bulletpoof screenwritingbe Thank
- 1:18:00you so so much, Katie. If you want to get links to anything
- 1:18:02we spoke about in this episode, including how to buy her new book Writing
- 1:18:08Your Stories theme, head over to any film huscle dot com forward slash seven
- 1:18:12forty eight, and if you have it already, please head over to Filmmaking
- 1:18:15podcast dot com, subscribe and leave a good review for the show. It
- 1:18:20really helps us out a lot, guys. Thank you again so much for
- 1:18:24listening. Guys, as always, keep that huscle going, keep that dream
- 1:18:27alive, Stay safe out there, and I'll talk to you soon. Thanks
- 1:18:30for listening to the Indie Film Hustle podcast at indiefilm hustle dot com. That's
- 1:18:34I N D I E F I L M h U S T l E
- 1:18:38dot com.