Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / The Vatican’s Case Against Digital Feudalism
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to today's deep dive everyone.
- 0:01I'm your host and today we are looking at something honestly
- 0:05pretty mind blowing. Yeah, thanks for being here with
- 0:07me. Mind blowing is definitely the
- 0:09right word for this. One right?
- 0:10So I want you to picture the most advanced piece of
- 0:13technology on earth for a second.
- 0:15You know, you are probably imagining a massive hyper cooled
- 0:19server farm humming with trillions of calculations a
- 0:23millisecond predicting human behavior with terrifying
- 0:27accuracy. Oh, absolutely.
- 0:29The classic Silicon Valley image.
- 0:30Exactly. Now contrast that image with a
- 0:33guy in a white robe living in a Renaissance palace in Rome,
- 0:36writing a letter by hand on May 25th.
- 0:39Those two vastly different worlds collided in a way that,
- 0:42frankly, nobody really saw coming.
- 0:44The contrast is so jarring. But I mean, maybe that's exactly
- 0:47why it carries so much weight. You have an institution steeped
- 0:50in 2000 years of ancient rituals.
- 0:53Suddenly, you know, inserting itself into the bleeding edge of
- 0:56algorithms, deepfakes, and machine learning.
- 0:58OK, let's unpack this because it wasn't just a passing comment or
- 1:01a quick press release. The Vatican released a 40,000
- 1:05Word document about the future of artificial intelligence.
- 1:08Yeah, a massive undertaking. It's a papal encyclical by Pope
- 1:11Leo the 14th. Actually, his very first one
- 1:14since taking office ties to Magnifica Humanitus, which
- 1:18translates to great humanity. Right.
- 1:21And for anyone listening who might not be super familiar with
- 1:23Catholic terminology and encyclical, is essentially the
- 1:27highest, most authoritative teaching document, a publican
- 1:31issue. It's a big deal.
- 1:32A huge deal. It's a circular letter meant to
- 1:34be read not just by Catholics, but by heads of state,
- 1:36scientists, and essentially the whole world.
- 1:39And what's fascinating here is that this one is entirely
- 1:41focused on how we survive the AI era without losing our humanity
- 1:46in the process. The historical gravity of this
- 1:48is just massive. I mean, scholars are already
- 1:50comparing this to stuff from over a century.
- 1:52Ago they are. They are holding Magnifica
- 1:53Humanitis up next to another incredibly famous encyclical
- 1:56from 1891 called Rourim Novarum by Pope Leo the 13th.
- 2:01OK, wait. 1891 puts us right in the brutal thick of the
- 2:04Industrial Revolution. Right.
- 2:05Yes, exactly. A time when society was being
- 2:08actively ripped apart by industrialization.
- 2:10I mean, you had kids in coal mines, massive labor
- 2:13exploitation and traditional social safety Nets were
- 2:16completely collapsing. Just a totally chaotic time to
- 2:19be a worker. Completely.
- 2:21Yeah. And Rio Novarum stepped directly
- 2:23into that chaos to redefine labor rights, argue for living
- 2:26wages, and advocate for human dignity against the machinery of
- 2:30the era. The Church intervened when human
- 2:32bodies were being mined for profit.
- 2:34Oh wow, so they are doing it again.
- 2:36Right now, this new document is attempting to do the exact same
- 2:40thing for the digital revolution.
- 2:42It's intervening at a moment when human attention and
- 2:45cognition are being mined for profit.
- 2:47That is such a clear parallel. The core mission of this deep
- 2:50dive is to map out how we navigate an AI driven world
- 2:55without letting technology override what fundamentally
- 2:57makes us human. And just to be super clear for
- 3:01everyone listening, our goal today isn't to say this document
- 3:04is the absolute truth or, you know, to endorse its specific
- 3:08critiques of tech companies and capitalism.
- 3:10No, not at all. Our job is just to impartially
- 3:12report on the arguments the Vatican is making so you can
- 3:15understand this massive cultural moment.
- 3:18We are just untacking the source material here.
- 3:21Exactly. And to set the table for that,
- 3:23it's really important to note the encyclical is remarkably pro
- 3:28technology in many ways. Yeah, it's not a Luddite
- 3:31manifesto. Not at all.
- 3:32It explicitly praises AI for its potential to revolutionize
- 3:36medicine, democratize education, and alleviate poverty.
- 3:39It definitely sees the value. Right, but it raises a giant red
- 3:43flag about what happens when a civilization becomes driven
- 3:45purely by algorithmic efficiency.
- 3:47Because when efficiency becomes the ultimate metric of a
- 3:50society, the human being is inevitably reduced to a data
- 3:54point, right? Something that just needs to be
- 3:55managed, predicted and optimized.
- 3:57So to really understand the Vatican's warning here, we first
- 4:00have to look at the primary metaphor the document uses to
- 4:04describe our current trajectory. They pull from the book of
- 4:07Genesis, specifically the Tower of Babel.
- 4:10Yeah, the Babel analogy. Now, if you're listening, stick
- 4:13with us. This isn't a Sunday School
- 4:14lesson. The document uses Babel as a
- 4:17really deep psychological and societal warning.
- 4:21It's a great metaphor for today. It really is, the ancient story
- 4:24goes, that humanity tried to build a massive tower to the
- 4:27heavens to show off their own power right?
- 4:30To engineer their way to godhood, and the result wasn't a
- 4:34beautiful utopia. No, it was a total breakdown of
- 4:36language. They literally couldn't
- 4:38understand each other anymore and the community shattered.
- 4:41Generative AI makes that metaphor chillingly literal
- 4:44today, doesn't it? It does.
- 4:45Think about how large language models actually work.
- 4:48They are mass producing text, audio and video at a totally
- 4:51incomprehensible scale. It's.
- 4:52Just a flood of content. Exactly.
- 4:55And if 90% of the content on the Internet is soon generated by
- 4:58bots talking to other bots, we literally lose the ability to
- 5:02know who we are communicating with.
- 5:03Which is terrifying. We are building this towering,
- 5:06perfectly optimized digital infrastructure, and the direct
- 5:09result is that our actual, authentic human connections are
- 5:13disintegrating. We are quite literally losing a
- 5:17shared language of reality. Wait, hold on though, I have to
- 5:20push back a bit because I struggle with this.
- 5:22If you talk to anyone in the tech industry, you will hear a
- 5:25very standard defense against this kind of doom saying which
- 5:28is technology is neutral. Oh, the classic defense.
- 5:31Right. I mean, isn't a line of code
- 5:33just a tool like a hammer? A hammer isn't inherently good
- 5:37or bad, it just depends on whether you use it to build a
- 5:41house or hit someone. It's up to the user.
- 5:43The encyclical actually takes that specific tech is neutral
- 5:47defense and completely dismantles it.
- 5:49Oh, really? How so?
- 5:51It argues that framing AI as a neutral tool is a myth used by
- 5:54corporations to dodge ethical responsibility.
- 5:57I mean, a hammer doesn't have a profit motive built into its
- 6:00physical structure. AI does.
- 6:02That makes sense. Every algorithm, every data set
- 6:05chosen, every recommendation engine.
- 6:08They do not exist in a vacuum. They are shaped by the capital,
- 6:12state, power and the giant tech monopolies that fund them.
- 6:15Because yeah, you don't just accidentally build a multi
- 6:18billion dollar supercomputer. Exactly.
- 6:21It is built specifically to generate a massive return on
- 6:24investment, right? Let's look at the mechanics of
- 6:26the apps you use every single day.
- 6:29The algorithm curating your social media feed isn't a
- 6:31neutral librarian trying to show you what is most true or what is
- 6:35most enriching for your life. It definitely doesn't feel like
- 6:38a librarian. No, it is mathematically
- 6:40designed using reinforcement learning and real time AB
- 6:43testing on millions of users to figure out exactly which
- 6:46combination of pixels, outrage and notifications will keep you
- 6:49scrolling the longest. It preys on human dopamine loops
- 6:53because your prolonged attention is what generates ad revenue.
- 6:57The bias toward extraction is baked into the math itself.
- 7:00So in these digital ecosystems, we kind of think we are the
- 7:03customers, but we are actually just the raw material.
- 7:05We are the product. Yeah, the document makes this
- 7:08compelling point that we are the producers of the data, but we
- 7:11are completely locked out of being the masters of our own
- 7:13digital lives. Exactly.
- 7:15The architecture is owned by a few giant entities and we just
- 7:19perform within it. Which really begs the question,
- 7:22if AI is actively shaping our environment based on this flawed
- 7:26profit driven and logic, how is it fundamentally changing our
- 7:30definition of what it means to be smart, or even what it means
- 7:33to be a human being? That is the big question, and
- 7:37the document dives into some fascinating philosophical waters
- 7:40here by highlighting the absolute chasm between an AI
- 7:44processing information and a human being experiencing the
- 7:47world. Because AI operates strictly on
- 7:50statistics. Right.
- 7:51Yes, it maps probabilities. It simulates reality.
- 7:54Right, like an AI can generate a staggeringly beautiful poem
- 7:58about grief. It can use all the right words,
- 8:00the perfect cadence, the ideal structure.
- 8:02It can sound incredibly convincing, but it.
- 8:04Has never actually felt the physical, visceral pain of
- 8:07losing a loved one. It doesn't have a body.
- 8:09It doesn't know what a sudden silence in a room feels like.
- 8:12Or, you know, the exhaustion of crying.
- 8:14That's spot on. The machine possesses fast data,
- 8:17but because it lacks that physical lived experience, it
- 8:20possesses 0 wisdom and 0 moral weight.
- 8:23Which is a huge distinction. And the encyclical fiercely
- 8:27attacks a modern ideology that tries to blur that exact line.
- 8:30It really goes after transhumanism and posthumanism.
- 8:34Oh man, transhumanism. This is the Silicon Valley
- 8:38philosophy that basically views human biology as outdated legacy
- 8:42hardware, right? Exactly.
- 8:43It's the belief that aging is simply a software bug we haven't
- 8:47patched yet. A bug?
- 8:48Yeah, that physical pain is just inefficient data, and that death
- 8:52is ultimately a technical failure we need to engineer our
- 8:55way out of. So treating human limits like a
- 8:57glitch is basically trying to enjoy a roller coaster without
- 9:00gravity. The thrill, the meaning, the
- 9:02entire experience comes from the.
- 9:04Limits. That is a great analogy.
- 9:05The Pope makes this profound claim that our greatness as
- 9:08human beings doesn't come from being infinitely powerful or
- 9:11perfectly optimized. It comes specifically from our
- 9:14finitude. Yes, our vulnerability, our
- 9:17aging, our mortality. Think about it.
- 9:19Why do we feel empathy? Because our bodies are fragile
- 9:22and we know what it means to get hurt, right?
- 9:24Why do we sacrifice for others? Because our time on earth and
- 9:27our energy are strictly limited, so choosing to give those things
- 9:31away actually means something. If we were immortal,
- 9:34indestructible, perfectly optimized data points, the very
- 9:38concepts of love, moral courage, and self sacrifice would
- 9:42evaporate. It simply wouldn't compute.
- 9:44It would just be math. Exactly.
- 9:45And the encyclical warns that pursuing this transhumanist
- 9:48dream of optimizing humanity isn't going to result in a sleek
- 9:52sci-fi utopia for everyone. It never.
- 9:54Does it's going to create a terrifying new class divide
- 9:57based entirely on biology? You will have a technologically
- 10:01enhanced elite, those who have the billions required to
- 10:04literally upgrade their bodies, install neural laces, or alter
- 10:08their genetics. And then everyone else, right?
- 10:10The unoptimized masses, people who lack the capital and will
- 10:13simply be viewed by society as inefficient, slow, and
- 10:17ultimately obsolete. Here's where it gets really
- 10:20interesting, because if this philosophy views the unoptimized
- 10:24human body as a glitch, it completely changes how
- 10:28corporations view those bodies in the workplace.
- 10:31Absolutely. This threat of an unoptimized
- 10:34underclass isn't some distant problem for the year 2100.
- 10:38It brings us directly to the physical reality of how we spend
- 10:42most of our waking hours right now, which is our labor.
- 10:45And the document leans heavily into the idea that work isn't
- 10:48just an economic transaction to pay the electric bill.
- 10:52Work is fundamentally about human dignity.
- 10:54It's how we shape our identity, build a community unity and find
- 10:57a role in the social fabric. But the AI era is actively
- 11:01threatening that dignity through a systemic process called
- 11:04deskilling. We are seeing this happen in
- 11:06real time across multiple industries.
- 11:08Delivery drivers, factory workers, customer service reps,
- 11:11They're increasingly being stripped of their autonomy.
- 11:14How does that actually work on the ground though?
- 11:16Like practically. Well, take a modern warehouse
- 11:18worker. They aren't making decisions
- 11:20about how to stack goods or honing a physical craft.
- 11:22They wear scanners that track their hand movements down to the
- 11:25millisecond. That sounds it.
- 11:27Is an algorithm. Dictates their exact pacing,
- 11:30maps their routes through the aisles and times their bathroom
- 11:33breaks. The worker doesn't use
- 11:35judgement, they just follow the prompt on the screen.
- 11:38So they are basically just biological extensions of the
- 11:40software. Yes, they are just the physical
- 11:42hands doing the final step the robot hasn't learned to do yet.
- 11:46I want to turn that lens directly on you, the listener,
- 11:48for a second. Think about your own job right
- 11:51now. Are you making choices and using
- 11:53your unique skills, your intuition, your judgement?
- 11:56Or are you increasingly just executing a series of prompts
- 12:00handed down by a digital system? It's a scary question to ask
- 12:04yourself, right? The encyclical gives this
- 12:06phenomenon a name, Digital feudalism.
- 12:09Digital Feudalism. Yeah, in medieval feudalism,
- 12:12serfs worked land they didn't own for a Lord they couldn't
- 12:15question, give them up the fruits of their labor just to
- 12:17survive. Today, we work on platforms we
- 12:20don't own, governed by algorithmic bosses we can't even
- 12:23see, let alone appeal to. The Pope argues that if
- 12:27businesses continue to relentlessly prioritize
- 12:30algorithmic efficiency over the dignity and agency of the human
- 12:34worker, we are driving straight toward massive societal and
- 12:39psychological collapse. So what's the fix?
- 12:41Does the document offer one? It does.
- 12:43It actually demands a completely new social safety net and robust
- 12:47retraining systems to prevent this human fallout.
- 12:50Because I mean, if our physical bodies and our labor are being
- 12:54micromanaged by invisible algorithms, it forces us to ask
- 12:57what is happening to our minds. Precisely, if algorithms are
- 13:01optimizing the warehouse, they are also optimizing the flow of
- 13:03information. Which leads right into what you
- 13:05called the epistemic crisis earlier, right?
- 13:07Epistemic just relates to how we validate what is real and what
- 13:10we know. The encyclical raises a massive
- 13:13alarm about the flood of deep fakes, synthetic media and AI
- 13:16generated content. It's getting so hard to tell
- 13:18what's real online. It is, and for a democracy, or
- 13:22really any functional public life to exist, you and I need a
- 13:26shared baseline of reality. We have to be able to agree on
- 13:30basic, verifiable facts. But the business model of the
- 13:33Internet actively prevents that. It shatters it.
- 13:36We're all retreating into these personalized algorithmic echo
- 13:40chambers. And the truth is no longer a
- 13:41shared landscape. It's whatever the algorithm
- 13:44determines will keep your specific demographic the most
- 13:48angry, the most validated, and the most engaged.
- 13:51So society splinters into tribalism.
- 13:53Exactly when reality becomes bespoke, society breaks apart.
- 13:58The encyclical insists that truth must be treated as a
- 14:00public good. It is as vital to human survival
- 14:03as clean water, and it cannot be treated as a market commodity
- 14:06manipulated for clicks and AD revenue.
- 14:08That makes total sense, and the Pope also points out how this
- 14:11epistemic collapse is warping our schools too, right?
- 14:13Yes, the education aspect is huge.
- 14:15He introduces this concept of schools devolving into algorithm
- 14:20adapters. Instead of forming whole human
- 14:22beings who are capable of deep reading, critical thinking, and
- 14:26complex moral reflection, educational institutions are
- 14:29feeling enormous pressure to just churn out compliant tech
- 14:33workers. People whose primary skill is
- 14:35just adapting to whatever the latest software update tells
- 14:38them to do. OK, I have to play devil's
- 14:40advocate here. I hear all of this, but nobody
- 14:43is strapping me to a chair and forcing me to stare at my phone
- 14:47or scroll for three hours. Nobody is prying my eyes open to
- 14:50make me believe fake news on a social feed.
- 14:52I have free will, right? So how can the Pope frame this
- 14:56as a systemic crisis when we are the ones voluntarily tapping the
- 15:00screens? Don't we have a choice?
- 15:01That is the most crucial pushback you could make, and the
- 15:04encyclical directly answers it by introducing the concept of
- 15:07the new slavery. The new slavery.
- 15:09Wow, that is a really heavy term.
- 15:12It is heavy and it requires breaking down the mechanics of
- 15:15coercion. If we connect this to the bigger
- 15:17picture, traditional slavery relied on violence, chains,
- 15:21physical confinement and overt fear, right?
- 15:24Right. The new slavery doesn't need any
- 15:26of that clumsy physical apparatus.
- 15:28It uses convenience, entertainment, and variable
- 15:32reward schedules. Like a slot machine.
- 15:34Precisely like a slot machine, these digital platforms are
- 15:37engineered by thousands of the smartest behavioral
- 15:40psychologists and computer scientists on the planet to
- 15:43harvest our attention. And they are very good at it.
- 15:46They use infinite scroll and intermittent dopamine hits so
- 15:49subtly and so effectively that we literally mistake our own
- 15:53neurological addiction for free choice.
- 15:56Oh wow, we think we are freely choosing to engage, but the
- 16:00architecture was built from the ground up to ensure we couldn't
- 16:03look away. Our attention is harvested and
- 16:06we actively participate in our own subjugation because it feels
- 16:10frictionless and comforting in the moment.
- 16:12That is chilling. So what is the Vatican's
- 16:15antidote to this addiction? A radical call for digital
- 16:18temperance. And this isn't just about, you
- 16:20know, putting your phone on silent during dinner.
- 16:21Right, it's bigger than that. It means actively reclaiming
- 16:24silence in your life, reclaiming solitude and deep offline face
- 16:30to face connection. We have to intentionally build
- 16:33physical spaces and routines where the algorithm simply
- 16:36cannot reach us, so our brains can remember how to think
- 16:39independently. And we desperately need to
- 16:41preserve that independent thought because the stakes go
- 16:44way, way beyond our personal screen time.
- 16:46They absolutely do. Because when truth decays and
- 16:49individuals lose their autonomy to tech giants, those tech
- 16:52giants begin to wield a level of power that historically only
- 16:56belong to entire nations. Which leads to the most
- 16:59terrifying geopolitical consequences in the text.
- 17:02Yeah, the darkest section of this encyclical deals with the
- 17:05militarization of AI. We are talking about autonomous
- 17:08weapons, right? Right.
- 17:09Drone swarms. AI targeting systems that
- 17:12identify a threat and pull the trigger without a human ever
- 17:15being in the loop. Yes, and the Pope draws an
- 17:17incredibly firm, uncrossable ethical line against lethal
- 17:21autonomous weapons. Why is that the line?
- 17:23The rationale against this goes right back to our discussion
- 17:25about transhumanism and finitude.
- 17:27A machine has no physical body, so it cannot fear death, right?
- 17:31Because it cannot fear its own destruction, it is completely
- 17:35incapable of feeling guilt, empathy or remorse.
- 17:39It's just processing data. Exactly.
- 17:41So if you hand the power of life and death over to a mathematical
- 17:44system that cannot possibly comprehend the moral weight of
- 17:48taking a human life, you completely normalize violence.
- 17:52You change the entire calculus of conflict.
- 17:54I mean if a nation can send a swarm of autonomous drones into
- 17:58a city and no human soldiers come home and body bags, the
- 18:02political cost of going to war drops to nearly 0.
- 18:05Exactly. It lowers the threshold for WAR
- 18:07entirely. It makes mass violence cheaper,
- 18:10faster and totally abstract for the people pushing the buttons,
- 18:14while the civilians on the ground suffer just as much.
- 18:16The human hesitation is engineered out of the system.
- 18:19And you know, this mass consolidation of power isn't
- 18:21just military. The Pope warns about the reality
- 18:25of global governance today. What does he mean by that?
- 18:27These tech giants now hold quasi sovereign power.
- 18:31Three or four companies control the cloud infrastructure of the
- 18:34entire planet. They map our streets.
- 18:37They control the public square communication.
- 18:39They store The Globe's financial data.
- 18:41And they do this entirely without democratic oversight.
- 18:44They act like unelected super governments.
- 18:46They absolutely do, and the document warns that without
- 18:49strict, enforceable global AI governance, the economic and
- 18:53structural gap between these tech rich monopolies and the
- 18:56global S will become unbridgeable.
- 18:59It creates a massive power gap. The nations that lack the
- 19:01capital to develop their own AI infrastructure won't just fall
- 19:04behind economically, they will be permanently marginalized.
- 19:08It's resulting in a digitized global power imbalance that
- 19:11makes the old colonial eras look tame.
- 19:13Wow. So what does this all mean When
- 19:16you zoom out and look at the entirety of this 40,000 word
- 19:19warning, what is the ultimate conclusion?
- 19:22The encyclical is fundamentally telling us we're in the middle
- 19:24of an existential plash. On one side, you have the
- 19:27culture of power. This is the worldview that
- 19:30worships efficiency, domination, perpetual optimization, and
- 19:34treating humans as metrics and. On the other.
- 19:36Side on the other side is what the Pope calls a civilization of
- 19:39love. This is a worldview that defends
- 19:42human dignity, recognizes the beauty of our vulnerability, and
- 19:46centers empathy and compassion above productivity.
- 19:49That's a beautiful way to put it.
- 19:51The core take away here most urgent question of the 21st
- 19:54century is not some sci-fi anxiety about whether machines
- 19:58will become sentient and launch nuclear weapons.
- 20:00Right, it's not Terminator. No, the real question is whether
- 20:03we will forget what it means to be human while we build them.
- 20:07AI is not going to inevitably oppress us on its own.
- 20:10But it will if we let it. Exactly.
- 20:11It absolutely will oppress us if we stand by passively and let
- 20:15the culture of power dictate how it is designed, funded and
- 20:18deployed in our schools, our workplaces and our militaries.
- 20:21We have to force the technology to serve the human standard,
- 20:25rather than forcing humans to adapt to the algorithmic
- 20:27standard. We have to choose to protect our
- 20:29finitude. Which brings me to a final
- 20:32provocative thought for you, the listener to Mull over today,
- 20:36something we haven't touched on yet, but directly builds on
- 20:39everything we've discussed. Oh, I'm curious.
- 20:40We've talked a lot about algorithms optimizing our work
- 20:43and our news feeds, but what about our relationships?
- 20:47Tech companies are aggressively rolling out AI companions and
- 20:50digital romantic partners. Yeah, chatbot's designed to
- 20:53perfectly agree with you. Exactly.
- 20:55They never argue, and they offer frictionless affection on
- 20:58demand. But if human relationships are
- 21:00inherently messy, difficult, and wildly inefficient, and we
- 21:05increasingly choose to replace them with perfectly optimized AI
- 21:08friends who never challenge us, are we voluntarily locking
- 21:11ourselves inside our own personal tower of Babel?
- 21:14Wow, are we trading the friction of real love for the illusion of
- 21:19a perfect simulation? Exactly, it's definitely
- 21:22something to think about the next time you reach for your
- 21:23phone. That is all for our deep dive
- 21:26today. Thanks for joining us and we
- 21:29will see you next time.