Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E024: Market Forces & Fed Reactions with Nik Bhatia
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that the last
- 0:03trade is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10Now for a word from on RAMP on RAMP is a Bitcoin asset
- 0:14management platform built on multi institution custody.
- 0:17We serve high net worth individuals, institutional
- 0:20investors and financial intermediaries with the best in
- 0:23class suite of products which include multi institution
- 0:26custody, a spot Bitcoin fund, Onram Wealth for Rias and
- 0:32private wealth services for high net worth individuals.
- 0:35Leveraging our partnership with Bit Go and other industry
- 0:38leaders, Onram's Multi Institution Custody is a first
- 0:41of its kind institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:46institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:50unique permissions have been met.
- 0:52Our multi institution vaults utilize cold storage, key
- 0:55signing and authentication at the direction of the client to
- 0:59maximize security for client assets.
- 1:02This pioneering approach to custody is the foundation of On
- 1:05Ramp's financial products which reduce counterparty risk
- 1:09associated with trusting a single institution.
- 1:12To learn more about how On Ramp can help you secure a new or
- 1:16existing Bitcoin position, please visit our website at on
- 1:19rampbitcoin.com, where you can schedule a consultation and
- 1:23connect directly with our team. What you're telling me is that
- 1:28music is about to stop, and we're going to be left holding
- 1:31the biggest bag of odorous excrement ever assembled in the
- 1:36history. Of doctors. 1974. 1987. 90.
- 1:42297-2000 and whatever we want to call this, it's all just the
- 1:46same. Thing over and over.
- 1:47We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell, hey, I say
- 1:53when we sell. We can jump off from there and
- 2:01we're live. Nick Bhatia, founder of the
- 2:05Bitcoin Layer offer, author of Layered Money you've been
- 2:09charting since 4:00 AM your time.
- 2:15I have been. I woke up at.
- 2:18I woke up at about 4:30 today and.
- 2:25It was right into it because this morning 5:30 we had jobless
- 2:31claims, 7:00 was we had factory orders as well and just the as a
- 2:41West Coast rates person your day, you have to be on the desk
- 2:47by 5:30 so. You have to if if you want
- 2:50coffee, if you want anytime in the morning to do anything, you
- 2:54have to be up way before 5:30. Because once 530 starts, the
- 3:01analysis has to be the the analysis has to start.
- 3:04And it honestly has to start before, because Europe has had
- 3:08time to digest what happened yesterday here, which was a
- 3:13massive miss on ISM, so. It's not every day that I force
- 3:18myself to be on the desk, 'cause that's what I have to do.
- 3:22It's that when the markets are moving, because there's material
- 3:25information that either has or even might happen, I I just have
- 3:34to be on it. And so yesterday's ISM was
- 3:37material One of the biggest. I think one of the biggest
- 3:43releases that we've had in several months to give us an
- 3:46indication on what's going on. So, yeah, I've been in the last
- 3:5124 hours, especially yesterday with Fed day, last 48 hours have
- 3:56been absolutely plugged into the markets, but it's not always
- 4:00like that for me. Before before we jump into all
- 4:03that it was before the restart hit recording.
- 4:08We were talking about the time zone difference and appreciating
- 4:11Nick for jumping on. And it was almost like a flex.
- 4:13It wasn't. But like Nick was like I've
- 4:15been. I've been charting since Marta,
- 4:17you you were sleeping on your having dreams about this pod and
- 4:20when you when you started the pod where you're like you've
- 4:22been charting since I was in diapers, it was that's where I
- 4:24was going to go with the whole Nick.
- 4:26Nick flexing on on working at 4:00 AM.
- 4:28But I I felt this. We were in Vegas last week.
- 4:31I don't spend a lot of time on the West Coast, but I mean,
- 4:33obviously Jesse has and. Being, you know.
- 4:38Pacific Standard Time. It's a it's a whirl.
- 4:40When you wake up and the whole world's already like, moving
- 4:42around, you're like, holy shit, I just lost three hours, so
- 4:46yeah. I went to bed.
- 4:47I went to bed before 9:00 PM yesterday.
- 4:51So that's it's it is an adjusted schedule.
- 4:54But you know, that's just the life of that's kind of our
- 4:59lifestyle, that's how we operate, the three of us in this
- 5:02family, me and my wife and our daughter.
- 5:07Yeah, it's a grind and there's a lot going on.
- 5:10Like you said, a lot of news. You know the ISM, Logan, if you
- 5:13pull that up, pretty abysmal. Today's IMISM showed that a
- 5:19grand total of 11% of industries, 2 out of 18 posted
- 5:22any growth in October, the same depressed share as in the spring
- 5:26of 2020, in the fall of 2008. But there's no recession, right.
- 5:29So in your mind, how are you reading this IMISM print?
- 5:34What were the expectations and? What does this print essentially
- 5:39say? Yeah.
- 5:40So ISM is a is APMI, it's that means purchasing managers index.
- 5:48It is a diffusion index in which the 50 line is on average a
- 5:57response of no change to our activity, no change from last
- 6:02month above 50 means. Stronger orders, stronger hiring
- 6:08below 50, weaker hiring, etcetera.
- 6:12So the reason that we love ISM is that it's the longest data
- 6:18series that genuinely correlates with GDPI.
- 6:22Look at ISM as a live GDP, and it's realized in that it's last
- 6:29month's data. On the 1st of the month and it
- 6:33is a series, a series that's been out for the 40s from the
- 6:36manufacturing side. So it's just it's just a great
- 6:39series, it's the best series that we have and so when ISM
- 6:45misses, but where it is, is is probably the most important.
- 6:51So we've been below 50 on ISM. For quite some time and it's
- 6:58been trending down since 6 from 60 range two years ago.
- 7:04So the economy has been in decline for a couple years and
- 7:08it it has been from a manufacturing perspective in
- 7:12contraction for a few months. But there's there was a recent
- 7:16bounce up to 49 and this this draw down back to I believe 46.9
- 7:24is the number that we were at. And I'll pull it up just to make
- 7:28sure, but the the fact that the bounce in the economy was short
- 7:37lived or is not there based on this ISM means that red flags
- 7:42are going off from every research analyst that takes this
- 7:46stuff seriously. Every alarm bell is going off
- 7:50that the recession that we thought is coming is coming.
- 7:57And that's that's the basic, as much as I can summarize it, but
- 8:02this mess, basically it it puts the oh, we're going to avoid
- 8:09recession. It puts that narrative firmly,
- 8:14firmly on watch. And of course, no one data print
- 8:19tells us everything. And so we're gonna be looking
- 8:22for other things to confirm this.
- 8:24But the way that yields responded yesterday in all parts
- 8:30of the curve tells me that many, many read it the way that I did
- 8:35yesterday, which was that it's it was a bad sign for the
- 8:38economy, for the US economy. So, so Nick, does that mean that
- 8:43you are thinking that this is a soft landing, medium landing,
- 8:50hard landing situation that that we're looking at and and also
- 8:55for some clarity for for everyone when you're talking
- 8:59about yields reacting, I saw yesterday that the I forget
- 9:03which two yields uninverted after you know the last year of
- 9:09being inverted. Is that what you're talking
- 9:11about? Is that it?
- 9:12Yeah, twos, 30s, nine inverted. But I.
- 9:16The shape of the yield curve wasn't necessarily what I didn't
- 9:22actually. I don't think that the yield
- 9:25curve move was material important yesterday.
- 9:30The signal was the bull move and the fact that twos declined as
- 9:34well as 10s and 30s declined the whole curve.
- 9:38The whole curve was bit yesterday and that is what I.
- 9:43Am talking about here, it's not actually the.
- 9:46Sometimes the shape of the curve is the more important thing,
- 9:52sometimes it's the direction, sometimes it's the magnitude.
- 9:55Yesterday it was just the magnitude lower in yields
- 10:01breaking to new lows of recent range.
- 10:04Of course that's relative, because yields have been
- 10:08screaming higher. In especially the long end of
- 10:11the curve, in the short end of the curve they've actually been
- 10:14very flat and we're and we're well bid yesterday that's almost
- 10:20the most important thing was kind of the action in twos and
- 10:24the action in twos did UN invert twos 30s as twos were bid right
- 10:29and and 30s were not bid as well and it UN inverted that shape of
- 10:34the curve. So twos 30s is material in that.
- 10:37Yeah, the two year part of the curve.
- 10:39Was the thing that I watched most closely yesterday and you
- 10:44know I have, you know I have half an eye on it today here as
- 10:47well. Yeah, I saw a few days ago, I
- 10:50guess Stan Druckenmiller said that he is, it has a big bullish
- 10:56position on treasury bonds because he does not believe that
- 11:02hire for longer is possible and and then the move yesterday kind
- 11:07of suggests that the market is starting to see that as well.
- 11:12Yeah, I I probably read it the same way as him on this one.
- 11:16I know he had a dollar bear call recently that I didn't I didn't
- 11:23agree with. And so, but yes, I don't, I
- 11:28don't really believe in hire for longer either in that the
- 11:32average is around 7 to 8 months and I think you know.
- 11:38I think we might get 12 months of it tops you you mean
- 11:43specifically between the the last rate hike and the the first
- 11:48rate cut historically has been an average of of seven or eight
- 11:52months and and I guess now we're at like 3 months or something
- 11:56like that. Yeah.
- 11:57So the last rate hike was in July, yeah.
- 12:01And so you know by mid next year?
- 12:06It is my base case that the Fed goes into cuts.
- 12:10It might still be in QT, which is the.
- 12:13I think that's one of the most important things to watch and
- 12:19might be more important than interest rates.
- 12:21And in fact, I do believe that the balance sheet is potentially
- 12:30more of a serious impact than. Rate direction yeah this was
- 12:37something I was I was going to make sure to to check in on you
- 12:41with. I came on your show about a year
- 12:44ago and you you felt that the the Fed was going to continue
- 12:51rolling assets off their balance sheet and and they would have no
- 12:55problem doing that and and I didn't see how that was
- 13:00possible. They still have managed to keep
- 13:02that going, but at the time I I was indexing back to the last
- 13:08time they they tightened and they tried to roll assets off
- 13:12their balance sheet. They managed to get 14% of their
- 13:14balance sheet off before they had to reverse and right now
- 13:18they've managed to roll 11% of their balance sheet off.
- 13:22Do you think that that continues?
- 13:24Do you think that they run into some sort of brick wall, you
- 13:27know and and are forced to, you know, in the next six months if
- 13:34that lines up with rate cutting that they are forced to start,
- 13:37you know, reversing that? Yeah.
- 13:39So I definitely don't know when I don't really have a projection
- 13:43there. But the the key is that the wall
- 13:48is there because the whole framework is an ample reserves
- 13:53framework. So that's what the Fed calls
- 13:56what they do. It's a defense or an explanation
- 14:00of QE. X post.
- 14:03So what they did is they did QE and then several years later
- 14:07they said, OK, we're calling this an ample reserves
- 14:10framework. It's actually hilarious.
- 14:14It's actually hilarious. But this is the framework that
- 14:17they give us. So they have an ample reserves
- 14:20framework. It means that we our goal is to
- 14:23keep an ample amount of reserves in the system.
- 14:28So as to not affect the money market curve having a
- 14:32disruption, and as long as there's a as long as they're
- 14:38ample reserves, then onshore U.S. banks have the ability to
- 14:44move money around to protect against or basically to
- 14:48arbitrage away any differences in money markets based off what
- 14:55the Fed is offering. In repo and reverse repo which
- 15:00are essentially it's policy tools now the reverse repo
- 15:03facility the the interest on reserve balances that it pays
- 15:09banks, those are you know what they use as floor rates and then
- 15:15the ceiling rate is the standing repo facility which they're
- 15:18willing to to lend out into the market.
- 15:20So they if the Fed has these repo rates, and by the way, both
- 15:24of them are relatively new. They've had to start them after
- 15:28the ample reserves framework to manage the reserves.
- 15:31So the the Fed is operating under an entirely new monetary
- 15:35regime today than they were ten years ago, and then that itself
- 15:40is magnitudes different than it was pre 2008, yeah.
- 15:46So we're in an ample reserves, this ample reserve to answer
- 15:49your question when they draw down the reserves.
- 15:53The reserves hit a level at which they are no longer ample
- 15:59and that is all you need to understand.
- 16:02I really want to explain the basics here.
- 16:04It's ample until it's not and that level is there.
- 16:09They hit it in 20/18/19 they had to reverse.
- 16:16The reverse was way before the pandemic and they are going to
- 16:21hit it. I don't know when.
- 16:23But this is what this is, what we're watching here.
- 16:26As Parker Lewis would say, it's a very simple equation.
- 16:28There's too much debt, not enough dollars.
- 16:30Interest rates are high, reserves are being drained and
- 16:34pulled off the market and at some point it will hit that
- 16:38wall. And I think it's very
- 16:40interesting. We had the ISM print yesterday.
- 16:42Obviously we had Jerome Powell getting up and giving comments
- 16:47on on the continued pause and he I think this was like the most.
- 16:53Unorganized, he's ever been in. It was complete word salad
- 16:57trying to frame like, oh, we don't know what we're going to
- 16:59do. We're going to look at the
- 17:00indicators. We don't want to tighten too
- 17:02much and we don't want to loosen too much.
- 17:05On top of that, you had the Atlanta Fed come out and cut GDP
- 17:08forecast down from I believe 2.4 to 1.3% for Q4 this year.
- 17:14So all that in aggregate is basically saying, all right, we
- 17:18might be in a recession and bonds.
- 17:22Bonds. Reverse stock market is up.
- 17:26And I think it's indicative of the fact that right now we live
- 17:30in a market where the tail wags the dog Like it became glaringly
- 17:35obvious that we're either entering A recession or in the
- 17:38middle of a recession yesterday. And markets pumped because they
- 17:43see that and they're like, oh, the Fed's gonna have to drop
- 17:46rates and pour more money in. So party's back on, which is
- 17:49completely insane. My book.
- 17:52And. I was just gonna say, pal, pal
- 17:56can't say anything other than what he said because he's he's
- 17:59totally trapped. Like he he can't.
- 18:01He can't say that. Oh, it's looking bad, 'cause
- 18:04then everything screams higher because they they sense the the
- 18:09stimulus. And he can't say, he can't say
- 18:11it's that great because it's not.
- 18:13Sorry, Mike. No.
- 18:15No, no, it's fine. I was, I was curious.
- 18:17I come at this from like just the way my brain works from a
- 18:20qualitative like. Not first principled but like in
- 18:23the market perspective of of and it's always challenging.
- 18:27We have folks on where we have conversations that we basically
- 18:30talk in Fed speak even whether we know it or not.
- 18:32We talk about interest rates and recessions and soft landing in
- 18:35like from anybody in the market. It's completely a hard landing.
- 18:38We're in a recession deeply, and it's ISM.
- 18:41Never heard of it, right? Coming in.
- 18:43I believe it. Just speech.
- 18:45But like the angle, what I look at it is.
- 18:50The, the and it's just funny and it's just just just.
- 18:54Juxtaposed. Juxtaposing what happened with
- 18:57Wework yesterday with Wework file for bankruptcy and anybody
- 19:01looking at that. I didn't catch that.
- 19:03Yeah. And anybody looking at that is
- 19:06like that was clear before let's call it three years ago, but
- 19:09everybody knew you're sitting on these firms venture you know
- 19:12back that. Are have, don't have cash.
- 19:14Flows. It was a big kind of almost
- 19:15Ponzi in the middle, and I don't know if you know.
- 19:18Nick, I was at we work in the middle of the Ponzi but and it's
- 19:21no longer there, which is why they bank went bankrupt.
- 19:26Exactly. But the but the point being is
- 19:28that like we've seen in these charts and there was a recent
- 19:31Carta chart that shows the the number of startups that have
- 19:33just completely like gone under either you know are completely
- 19:36insolvent and gone away the amount of capital coming into
- 19:38the system. So it makes complete sense that
- 19:40we work's model, but that's we work, it's just like a microcosm
- 19:43because that means real estate, that means everybody that's
- 19:45using that. When we talk about interest
- 19:46rates, amount of consumer spending, so it's like obvious
- 19:49whatever the ISM stands for, stands for, had to have gone
- 19:53down. But it's just like a big shock
- 19:54and now we're like, oh, we're in a recession.
- 19:56It's like we knew this 12 months ago.
- 19:58And I I'm more curious like how do you manage that from like
- 20:01your own intellectual kind of like two sides of the brain and
- 20:03how you talk to folks that are looking at it, 'cause you can't
- 20:05really say that to people because the Fed's saying
- 20:07something else and we have to play that game.
- 20:09But it's always just been curious how we we we're
- 20:12basically saying two different things anyway.
- 20:15Yeah, it's a great the the way I address it is the way I teach it
- 20:22to my students, which is cycle theory of investing.
- 20:28And in a cycle theory, you have a business cycle when the cycle
- 20:35is just getting started, meaning a recession has just happened.
- 20:42The worst out of the after the worst part of the recession is
- 20:48when things seem the most pessimistic for everyone out
- 20:53there. The most number of people have
- 20:55lost their jobs, the most contraction has happened.
- 21:00Spending has fallen off of a Cliff, 'cause everyone is
- 21:03terrified of everything. At that point.
- 21:07If you invest in risky assets, you will outperform.
- 21:13And if you get rotate out of risky assets into conservative
- 21:17assets right before the recession hits, you can
- 21:24outperform this idea of a 6040 portfolio.
- 21:28That is what I teach my students and how to approach this whole
- 21:34game of macro market analysis. Because what's the whole point
- 21:39of macro market analysis? It's to be able to to have
- 21:44performance on your assets. Now if the performance on your
- 21:47assets has a benchmark, then you can compare yourself.
- 21:50If it doesn't, then you can do whatever you want with
- 21:53investment. But for 99% of the investing
- 21:57world. And so just the way that you
- 22:01teach it or you've come from the perspective is that if you can
- 22:06just buy the S&P and go to sleep every night, then that's what
- 22:12you should do. But if you think you can
- 22:14outperform the S&P, which most people cannot by the way, most
- 22:18professionals underperform, Marty knows this, we've talked
- 22:22about this, most professional managers underperform.
- 22:26That is the law of numbers. So if you think you can
- 22:30outperform the S&P or whatever basic benchmarks are out there,
- 22:35you have to have an approach other than by the buy and hold
- 22:38the S&P. And so that's that's just how I
- 22:42approach it. Your question was how, how do
- 22:45you like boil it down 12 months in advance.
- 22:47You just say, hey we're tracking the business cycle and the
- 22:50business cycle is ending. That's what we've been talking
- 22:53about for 12 months at the Bitcoin layer.
- 22:55Look at the cycle, it's over and you should rotate into
- 23:01conservative assets from risky assets as just a one.
- 23:05We don't give investment advice, but it's it's the, it's the
- 23:09binary approach to investing, risky or conservative, not
- 23:14stocks or bought versus bonds or Bitcoin versus stocks or Bitcoin
- 23:20versus treasuries. It's just A or B.
- 23:24And that's how I teach it. So you look at the cycle, you
- 23:28show them, you show them one or two metrics that show where we
- 23:34are in the cycle like World Trade or ISM.
- 23:38And you just tell them, look, there's a correlation with
- 23:41returns and the cycle. You can perform better than the
- 23:46average if you rotate between A&B and you time it right over a
- 23:545 to 10 year time horizon. And that's the way that we
- 23:59approach it, not in a trading mode or looking at every little
- 24:04thing. I do that because I have to do
- 24:06that as well as the longer term. That's my job, that's my
- 24:10profession. It's the analysis of this sector
- 24:13itself. So I analyze every rate from
- 24:17overnight to 30 years and but when we're boiling it down, you
- 24:22just say, hey look at the cycle and the yield curve is another
- 24:25indicator. So when that went into inversion
- 24:28a year ago, that was your red flag two, almost two years ago
- 24:31now. And and just to pull on that a
- 24:35little bit more, the thing that reminds me of is it's a cousin
- 24:37of in 21 talking with individuals, the Fed speak was
- 24:42transitory when it was clear it wasn't like we we knew the
- 24:44amount of money supply. What what what would that play
- 24:48have been or how would that have been realized in the market to
- 24:50protect an individual or you know, middle of 21, I remember
- 24:54talking with Goldman Sachs private investors saying it's
- 24:57just transitory. They believed it in their soul
- 24:58and they were telling everybody the exact same thing and.
- 25:01That was what was being related to them.
- 25:03But what was the play there 'cause I'm just trying to
- 25:05understand in my own mind, how do you?
- 25:07Take the market for telling you and realize that it's it's not
- 25:10what's actually happening. And then how do you protect
- 25:12yourself, or at least have a like a fundamental frame of
- 25:14reference to manage what's being, like, drained in people's
- 25:17heads? That's just obviously not true.
- 25:19The play in going into the hiking cycle with if you see the
- 25:25inflation, the play is to go into bills, It's to go into
- 25:28actual cash so that you get the new rate every three, you know
- 25:33one to three months when it goes up and you just stay in bills
- 25:39and the rotation from bills to like longer term treasuries is I
- 25:44think happening now. Then rates will come down across
- 25:49the curve and then the time to get into risk will be right at
- 25:53that point where the Fed comes in with the with the with the
- 25:57rescue package etcetera, etcetera.
- 25:59So it is a playbook that you have to follow, you have to
- 26:04time, but even for people that aren't trying to time the
- 26:07market, I think just understanding generally what's
- 26:11going on is is advantageous and at the point in which the Fed
- 26:16it's it's guaranteed the Fed is going to start hiking rates.
- 26:19You have to get out of both the treasuries and the stocks
- 26:24because yields will go up it'll damage your returns and and
- 26:31stocks will come down because yields are going up and making
- 26:34the present value calculation of equity go down.
- 26:37So the only way to avoid that is bills because you never lose
- 26:41you, you you buy it for three months, it matures, you get it
- 26:44the higher yield, it matures you get the higher yield and you
- 26:46outperform everyone. And that's what people say go to
- 26:49cash they mean go to bills and of course Mike of course Mike it
- 26:55looking Expos hindsight is 2020. Of course we know everything is
- 27:01that's going to happen in advance.
- 27:02No, that's not the way it goes. That's why I I'm not in the, you
- 27:07know, my career track could have been toward portfolio manager
- 27:10one day, but I didn't want that because it's not that's not what
- 27:14I want. I know Marty also is at an asset
- 27:18manager. Jesse, you've worked in asset
- 27:21management if I remember correctly, or you have a
- 27:24background there as well? But.
- 27:26Yeah kind of like I I ran a little crypto hedge fund so yeah
- 27:30yeah so you know what it's like to be fiduciary you guys are are
- 27:34fiduciaries with with your your VC as well it money on the line
- 27:39is a serious serious endeavor and from a from a multi billions
- 27:46of dollars perspective and playing these markets for me it
- 27:51was more just go toward the research instead of trying to
- 27:55time the market because it's it is a unique skill set that
- 28:02whether or not I had it I didn't choose to pursue that I I chose
- 28:06to pursue the education side of things because it's a really
- 28:11really tough job to try to time this stuff.
- 28:14And this brings up an interesting topic I think we
- 28:18should dive into Because Michael Yu.
- 28:20Mentioned we work going bankrupt.
- 28:22We talked about them a few months ago when the news of the
- 28:25corporate bond yield trading at like 90% or something like that
- 28:30popped on to our radar. And I was like, oh, this is very
- 28:33high risk. And obviously with the rate hike
- 28:35regime of the last two, 1 1/2 years, we can safely assume that
- 28:43there are probably a lot more Weworks out there and despite
- 28:47the fact that we're getting. These bearish economic
- 28:51indicators and cutting GDP growth forecast, Fed still has
- 28:59rates where they are. And I guess that's the big
- 29:01question like to put yourself in Jerome Powell's mind.
- 29:05And even though the indicators are saying all right, maybe it's
- 29:09time to reverse course with our interest rate policy as.
- 29:14We mentioned earlier the amount of time between the last hike
- 29:17and the first cut is typically 7 to 9 months or something like
- 29:21that. So that would put us at what,
- 29:23beginning, end of Q1 next year? If we're, if we're using that as
- 29:27barometer, we're at middle Q1. So a few months from now.
- 29:32And I guess that's the big question.
- 29:34Can all of these corporations out there with bond yields that
- 29:40are screaming debt service? Levels that are still high
- 29:44because interest rates are high, like can they survive the next
- 29:48few months before the the rate cuts come if they do
- 29:53materialize, if Jerome Pal decides to do that, who knows,
- 29:56maybe he can be stubborn and be like, no, we're keeping them
- 29:58higher for longer. But I guess that's question one
- 30:03and then question 2. I forgot question two.
- 30:09So let's focus on question one and I'll remember question 2.
- 30:12All right. So the, the way to the way that
- 30:16I approach this again, it kind of goes back to Mike's question
- 30:23as well. There are going to be defaults
- 30:27and bankruptcies on the fringes and then move toward.
- 30:31It keeps moving toward the center, but the way it moves
- 30:35toward the center is that the customers of the center are at
- 30:38the fringes. So when the bankruptcies happen,
- 30:41happen out, then it affects the next level and then the next
- 30:44level. And then ultimately the core
- 30:47earnings of the mega caps do decline as as unemployment has
- 30:55spiked enough to actually damage the consumption component of
- 31:01GDP, which you guys know is about 3/4 of the economy is what
- 31:05people spend. And when people spending goes
- 31:09down, it only happens after the spike in unemployment.
- 31:11That can only happen after enough companies contract or go
- 31:17bankrupt and and all that. So in the cycle, these things do
- 31:20take time to play out, but you only need one indicator and it's
- 31:26not ISMI promise. It's the S&P 500 because the Fed
- 31:33they pretend that their mandate is unemployment and inflation,
- 31:38but it's not. It's the S&P 500.
- 31:41It's the wealth effect and to a lesser extent home prices, but
- 31:47it's the S&P 500 and and to a lesser extent home prices.
- 31:51That's it. You could remove the Fed's
- 31:54entire framework and them just move rates based off of what
- 31:59stocks are doing. So when how long can the Fed
- 32:07stay on higher for longer? They can stay at higher for
- 32:11longer as long as you don't get go into violent decline on the
- 32:14S&P 500 and even if you go into slow decline they can even hang
- 32:19on for longer. But I will give you a threshold
- 32:24which is that at a 50% decline from the all time highs, you are
- 32:30guaranteed to see a complete reversal in policy in that QT
- 32:35stops QE, either QT stops QE resumes rates are cut
- 32:40dramatically or a combination of the sort to get really things
- 32:45started. So the answer is that there can
- 32:51be a lot of pain on the fringes. And the bigger the bubble grew
- 32:55and let's not even call it a bubble, the more the economy
- 32:59expanded based off of just natural tendencies to leverage
- 33:05up and start new businesses and invest in projects like we work
- 33:10or you know other pockets of the economy.
- 33:14That only happened during these times when all of the the larger
- 33:19that expansion is, which you we can argue has been 15 years in
- 33:22the making now or 12 years in the making somewhere in that
- 33:27range that all of those will contract before you see a 30%
- 33:34decline in the S&P 500. And so can they hang on for a
- 33:3930% decline in the S&P 500 without fully like a full pivot?
- 33:48Yes, is, especially if it's slow.
- 33:51If it grinds out and that is all that's, I would say that's
- 33:58almost my base case and so. And that would be like a soft
- 34:02landing, sure. And because again and I know
- 34:08that your question was about the the type of the landing Jesse.
- 34:11But when I think about that question and how to answer it,
- 34:14it's a landing it it doesn't have to be, you don't have to
- 34:18characterize the landing because the remember if we're focused on
- 34:22investment returns it's when you go out of cash to treasuries to
- 34:27treasuries to stocks in the binary sense of the and so when
- 34:33the landing happens it's when stocks are going down South.
- 34:39Measure the stock decline is, is how you should characterize it
- 34:43and what is the stock decline? I don't, I don't really know.
- 34:47I don't know how to characterize that.
- 34:49I do know the Fed. It's it's it's the Fed's mandate
- 34:52to not allow that to crash. So you have a you do have a put.
- 34:57But I do know that they you better take them seriously in
- 35:01that the put is nowhere, it's nowhere close.
- 35:04It's nowhere to be found. It's not a 10%, it's not at 20%,
- 35:08it's not at 25%. So it is somewhere between 25
- 35:13and 50%. That's again, that's the
- 35:17framework. Thanks for tuning in to the last
- 35:20trade. If you're enjoying the show and
- 35:23want to dive deeper, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com where
- 35:27you'll find a full suite of institutional grade research and
- 35:31analytics, including our recently published white paper,
- 35:34bitcoin's full potential valuation, and our new tool, the
- 35:39On Ramp Terminal. Now back to the show.
- 35:44Isn't there like a an escape velocity point where that
- 35:46decrease happens and then it starts to compound because you
- 35:49just like reduce margins if interest rates are higher.
- 35:51So margins are reduced from profit centers in people's
- 35:55personal balance sheets are decreasing whether it's because
- 35:57inflation is still running. So there we know like credit
- 36:00card and all the things associated with that coupled
- 36:02with their purchasing power is reducing and they're spending
- 36:05less. And now you just start and so
- 36:06they're that cycle starts to go backwards and you hit that 20%.
- 36:10Next, you know, you're at 40%. You know, like it is, Yeah, I'm
- 36:15smiling because you're describing it.
- 36:18You're describing it in a way that is both accurate and wrong
- 36:25at the same time. I'll explain why.
- 36:27OK you it's completely right that once it hits 20, it's easy
- 36:31to get to 40, but it's not because of the stuff that you're
- 36:35describing, It's because of market structure.
- 36:38And this is the scary thing. And This is why I smile 'cause
- 36:41now I'm remembering my mentors and their words in in in my
- 36:45brain literally right now. My mentors taught me that you
- 36:50guys know what the terms OK, A2 Sigma event, A5 Sigma event.
- 36:55What that means is that you have a 2 standard standard deviation
- 36:59move or A5 standard deviation move means that this is like a
- 37:04one in you know it's a one in 100 occurrence or this this
- 37:10should only happen one every 63 years.
- 37:14I'm just making up a number, right.
- 37:17The events that are supposed to occur one every 63 years are
- 37:22occurring one every five to 10 years in these financial markets
- 37:26the way that the structure is. So Mike, it the answer is yes,
- 37:30but it's because of this not necessarily just that leverage
- 37:34got out of hand so that the contraction kind of feeds on
- 37:38itself. That does happen, but that's
- 37:42what drives GDP from 5% growth to 1% contraction.
- 37:52But it's not what drives the S&P 500 down 550%.
- 37:56The what drives the S&P 500 down 50% is the fact that five Sigma
- 38:00events are happening every few years now.
- 38:05And the reason that those events are happening is because of
- 38:09hidden leverage and hidden counterparty risk that we can't
- 38:14see on the surface of the market but we almost have to assume is
- 38:20there, which I smile because it it it is a danger zone that
- 38:25you're talking about and not something I cover too much
- 38:28because I don't. I don't, I don't want to try to
- 38:31scare people about the speed at which financial crises can
- 38:36happen, because talking about a financial crisis is coming is
- 38:40not, that's not, it's just not my business.
- 38:43I'm trying to, you know, analyze the cycle while in the
- 38:47background you do have to understand this, this component
- 38:50of market structure. And I try to explain that
- 38:52through the existence of the euro dollar system, the offshore
- 38:56dollar system, the existence of interbank risk, shadow money,
- 39:02forex swaps repo, which is all kind of this shadow money world
- 39:09that there's so much leverage and risk in there that you never
- 39:12know what's there. We, we do know that the Fed is
- 39:15willing to step in the swap lines with the ECB and the Swiss
- 39:19National Bank are there. They've been exercised.
- 39:23They will be exercised again. So all of that stuff is there at
- 39:27the surface. Yeah.
- 39:29I guess the the point in bringing that up and where the
- 39:32risk is, is because it's like micro or macro where it's like
- 39:35the individual that has it's overextended and.
- 39:38You know, stock market starts to fall.
- 39:40They have to sell the boat or they, you know, get foreclosed
- 39:42and that person owes, you know, the manufacturing facility all
- 39:45the way to the hedge fund. They're both, you know, two
- 39:48sides of the same coin of that. Like the it's more the Fed
- 39:51having to be prepared for that. And at what point, I know you're
- 39:54referencing it could be the 20 to 30% but it feels like that,
- 39:58you know, risk. They know it exists and so is it
- 40:02really 30% or is it 12% or 15% where it's like, oh shit starts
- 40:06to break. And you have to step in before I
- 40:08guess is maybe where Jesse was a little going to.
- 40:10It was like how much can they really take before somebody
- 40:13comes in? How much?
- 40:15Yeah, yeah. I mean in the end the
- 40:20unemployment rate, if it does get high enough they they do
- 40:26have to pivot before stocks but. My point is that stocks will
- 40:32exhibit that long before unemployment and the
- 40:35unemployment will maybe even lag and could lag.
- 40:40And those are structural, you know, those are structural
- 40:43problems with the US economy that have to solve each time we
- 40:46go through a cycle. Because in a recession, old
- 40:48business models do die off. And so that comes with that,
- 40:53comes with recessions, and recessions bring unemployment.
- 40:59And unemployment brings, you know, can bring a lot of
- 41:03devastation. Yeah, I I think one of the
- 41:07assumptions I have when thinking about how this plays out is that
- 41:12the Fed is inherently reactive and and managing based on you
- 41:17know the last 12 months of data they're driving in the the rear
- 41:23view mirror. So fundamentally they're always
- 41:26late to to make shifts in policy that they should make and if you
- 41:31play that forward into you know you're you're you're landing the
- 41:34plane is it it's a crash landing is it going to be a soft landing
- 41:38or or hard landing. But you're managing your descent
- 41:42based on data from 12 months ago.
- 41:46You're not going to have a graceful landing there and and
- 41:50that you know in in how these. And how a recession sort of
- 41:56becomes a gradually then suddenly kind of event the the
- 42:02the track record of the Fed is to always be ham fisted until
- 42:07the crisis becomes acute and then they swing hard in the
- 42:12other direction and the pendulum goes to stimulus in a big way
- 42:15very quickly. So they're always kind of, you
- 42:17know, bouncing from one guide rail to the next because they're
- 42:20inherently managing based on old data.
- 42:24And and that's just how it works out.
- 42:25So you know based on that history and that just kind of
- 42:29reality that they are so conservative in managing based
- 42:33on data and the data sets that they're they feel comfortable
- 42:36with are 1218 months long that they're they always miss it.
- 42:41And so they're going to miss the time when they should be
- 42:44pivoting into a graceful, you know, like going neutral in
- 42:49order to hit that 30% decline. And rather than avoiding and
- 42:53avoid a 50% decline, you know assuming if that's what the the
- 42:57Fed would would view as a optimal outcome which I think is
- 43:01reasonable. And I think it's probably their
- 43:03dream, you know to to deflate the housing market a little bit
- 43:06but not kill people and do the same with the S&P.
- 43:11But they're they just don't know when to actually go neutral.
- 43:16They're gonna. You know, drive this thing into
- 43:19the ground and and go to that 50% decline and then you know,
- 43:24swing too hard in the other direction and we're going to see
- 43:26$10 trillion of stimulus over the next few years.
- 43:30That that just feels like the scenario that that we're on
- 43:32track for in my book. Well, and I think we have to
- 43:35bring in inflation too. I think that I think yesterday,
- 43:38if there was one thing to be gleaned from Powell's comments
- 43:42is that he's still wolf like petrified of inflation remaining
- 43:47high. Because if.
- 43:48You know, we do go into a recession and we get into like a
- 43:51stagflationary event and he's forced to lower rates and pump
- 43:54more money into the system. It could be a complete collapse
- 43:58in confidence. And so I guess, I I mean, I
- 44:04think we believe so. I think they're trying to
- 44:06pretend like they can avoid it and it's a big game of chicken.
- 44:10And I think enough, I think probably the majority of policy
- 44:13makers genuinely believe that that.
- 44:15Stimulus is not directly causing inflation and and I I think that
- 44:20that is the world in which our our policy, the majority of
- 44:23policy makers believe that still and they will will learn that
- 44:29lesson the hard way over the next decade or so.
- 44:34And you know, so I think that like the number one thing that
- 44:37they need to be cognizant of avoiding if they want to keep
- 44:41inflation down. They are not going to be aware
- 44:45of like, you know, they're they're going to think of it as
- 44:46a saviour, like stimulus as a saviour to get out of an
- 44:49economic crisis. That's what, that's what you
- 44:52know, everybody is trained in in this sort of Keynesian economic
- 44:57cycle of interventionist approach to to monetary policy.
- 45:02Like that's that's the bread and butter is you stimulate your way
- 45:05out of a crisis and that makes it less bad.
- 45:08And and you're literally not taught that like, oh the the
- 45:10stimulus, the growing the monetary base causes the price
- 45:16of everything to inflate. Well, and there's another factor
- 45:19here that Nick, I'd like to get your thoughts on, which is with
- 45:23raids staying higher for longer, who knows how long, but as we've
- 45:27seen. Over the last six months the
- 45:30Treasury is on a bit of a a debt binge, issuing new treasuries at
- 45:34higher rates. Like, how much does that factor
- 45:37into the Fed's decision too? I know Powell made some comments
- 45:41about the fiscal side of things earlier this week, but he
- 45:45definitely he can't admit it. But there's definitely that
- 45:47thought in the back of his mind. He's looking at Janet Yellen
- 45:51issue $1.7 trillion worth of debt in the course of of the 1st
- 45:553/4 of this year. Or maybe it was just an.
- 45:58Q3 this year. And we're up to .1 trillion
- 46:03dollars since the the actually more than that now since the
- 46:07debt ceiling lifted in June. Yeah.
- 46:09So four months. Yeah, yeah.
- 46:11So Q3 almost 2 trillion. So Powell's gotta be seeing
- 46:14that, seeing where he has rates at and be like, holy shit like
- 46:17you're gonna completely bankrupt the country and have the
- 46:21interest rate explode through the roof.
- 46:23Which Logan bring up that chart? Of the ratio of GDP to interest
- 46:29expense, comparing how quickly it grew in the last three years,
- 46:35comparing it to the gross of the ratio in the 70s.
- 46:39What took 20 years in the 60s and 70s took three years in in
- 46:47the twenty 20s. Wow.
- 46:51I wow. I didn't.
- 46:52I've never seen that chart. That's incredible.
- 46:55And so real yields, so we can real yields have risen
- 46:59substantially to account for this real yields right now at
- 47:05about 2 1/2 percent above and beyond the 10 year inflation
- 47:11expectations which are at about 2 1/2 percent they these are
- 47:18multi decade highs. So the fact that people are
- 47:23demanding more of a real return for their treasury investment
- 47:28above and beyond longer term inflation expectations is a
- 47:32result of how much debt is being issued that's I mean that's been
- 47:40the the driver here. The answer Marty to your
- 47:43question is just remember March joint statement from Yellen and
- 47:49Powell. Saving the system BTFP Silicon
- 47:53Valley joint statement with Lagarde about Credit Suisse,
- 48:02that's what that's where we are. It's the five Sigma events
- 48:06happening every couple years. The next one will bring a joint
- 48:14statement from Yellen and Powell, or whoever is in power
- 48:18at that time. And it'll be another because
- 48:23they can't not right the structural size of the debt, the
- 48:28structural problems in the system.
- 48:31They're too big for the stimulus to not be the answer in some
- 48:34way. My my point in terms of how long
- 48:39they can, you know they can extend and pretend doesn't have.
- 48:45It doesn't, It won't necessarily be driven by all of a sudden
- 48:49interest rates as a percentage of GDP back to 5% which is multi
- 48:55decade highs. It is more going to be the
- 49:02result of something more within the financial plumbing side of
- 49:08things, not just a raw or nominal.
- 49:12Interest expense regime. Because remember, if this goes
- 49:16back to what Jesse was saying about the Fed being lagging, the
- 49:19Fed is lagging. One of our slogans at the
- 49:22Bitcoin layer is rates lead the Fed.
- 49:25It's a core principle of what we do. the Fed is almost
- 49:29irrelevant. When inflation was going, you
- 49:33asked, Mike asked what do you do when inflation is going.
- 49:35Look at the two year yield it got, It went from essentially 0.
- 49:41To 3% faster than the Fed could even get like its first trip and
- 49:48shoot, you know, shoelaces tied out of the door with the rate
- 49:50hikes, the market is so ahead of the Fed it's not even funny.
- 49:56You don't even have to really look at what the Fed is doing.
- 49:59You could just look at the twos part of the curve fives 10s and
- 50:03understand what's going on with investors and what they demand
- 50:08for current inflation. Which if you looked and 2021,
- 50:12you would sell the shit out of every single fixed income
- 50:16investment that you owned because of duration.
- 50:20And so look, he he pulled back. No, no, I'm sorry.
- 50:25Like us back 'cause this is. I'm glad you brought this up,
- 50:27Nick. This was a key thing and I don't
- 50:29know if it's a general, general consensus on this and I don't
- 50:32think it's in the standard market.
- 50:33But I heard you a few weeks ago bring this up with Peter on this
- 50:37exact aspect that basically private markets are driving
- 50:41interest rates and then the Feds, the lagging lagging
- 50:44indicator, lagging behind. But what started to like and I'm
- 50:48just curious the thoughts and like if this makes any sense is
- 50:51that we talk about feds because it said in the beginning, we say
- 50:54it all the time and there's like this inflation and that you even
- 50:56said it. You said real rates.
- 50:58And I make the case that the real rates aren't even real at
- 51:01the long, you know the 10 year that they're still you know very
- 51:05out of water in or underwater. And so it feels like it's in.
- 51:09And then Jesse said or maybe it was Marty that referenced the
- 51:15that they believe or it was Jesse that said they don't
- 51:16believe that printing money drives inflation.
- 51:19And it's like it's the common thought of people like what
- 51:22BlackRock knows what the fuck Bitcoin is.
- 51:23Like, they're not in this. You know, they, they have
- 51:25research, they have all the money.
- 51:26It's like these people in my mind working through this is
- 51:29like they understand exactly what it is, but it's a
- 51:31confidence game. And if your assumption or what
- 51:33you said is correct and I think it is where the market is
- 51:36driving, then they have to signal that inflation is not
- 51:38what it is, that it's coming down, that we're soft landing.
- 51:41Because the second you start to signal that this thing is
- 51:43actually 12 to 15 to 20% to what you're describing completely
- 51:47blows out, you know, the treasuries and what the actual
- 51:51yields reform and so like. How do you does that make sense?
- 51:55It does. So I'll answer it with the real
- 51:58yield question. The real yield is a market rate
- 52:04and that's why I quote it because the TIPS yield, Treasury
- 52:10inflation protected securities are market instruments.
- 52:14They have a market yield and when you buy them.
- 52:18You get that yield plus ACPI look back and then that that sum
- 52:25is paid to you as your coupon. So it's not a it's not a fixed
- 52:32coupon security in that it's a floating coupon.
- 52:36It pays a different coupon based off of whatever the look back of
- 52:40inflation is for that period. But it has a fixed portion and
- 52:43that fixed portion is the market yield.
- 52:46So when you buy that bond at 2 1/2 percent, you are getting 2
- 52:511/2% plus the look back of CPI. And I know that CPI has its
- 52:56faults and it it is a government statistic and it probably has
- 53:01tremendously understated inflation over.
- 53:05And which compounds each year that you do it.
- 53:08So I'm not dismissing any of that and I do try to, I do I'm.
- 53:13I'm definitely guilty of the feds speak.
- 53:16But I do try to make sure that I'm choosing my words carefully
- 53:20too. The real yield going up is
- 53:25genuinely people saying we don't want zero plus last year CPI.
- 53:31It's probably we call bullshit on last year's CPI.
- 53:34So we want more and more and more and so that real yield
- 53:39going up has driven yields where they are and they and yes the
- 53:46market does lead the Fed in that the people when they demand an
- 53:51amount of interest they are doing so not based off of.
- 53:57What the Fed is going to do but what inflation is in the market
- 54:01and what the alternative opportunities for investment is.
- 54:05And it's not that the Fed doesn't matter the the rates
- 54:08lead the Fed because the rates people have to arbitrage what
- 54:12the Fed is going to do. Because they do raise the policy
- 54:15rate they do decrease the policy rate.
- 54:18There is a. Mechanical, like I said, the
- 54:22repo windows there is a math component to the way that they
- 54:26raise the rates. But when you invest in the two
- 54:29year, five year, 10 year part of the curve, what you're doing is
- 54:32you are arbitraging whatever the Fed is going to do based on your
- 54:36expectation. So bring it back to the
- 54:39beginning of our conversation. What did I wake up thinking
- 54:41about today, the two year yield because it is the best
- 54:45expression of what the market genuinely thinks the Fed is
- 54:48going to do. And as it creeps lower, the
- 54:51higher for longer narrative fades away and it just means
- 54:54that the cuts are actually going to come because it's even if
- 54:59just to get into the bond math of it, even if the Fed funds is
- 55:03at 5 and a third right now twos are at 499, so 5%, they're
- 55:10trading at 33 basis point discount.
- 55:12It doesn't mean that the market necessarily thinks that you're
- 55:16going to get. A 25 basis point hike one year
- 55:19from now and then maybe one more a a year from now, a a year from
- 55:25then, and then you get like 30 to 50 basis points of hikes over
- 55:29that period. It actually means we think
- 55:32there's a 50% chance of them cutting by 60 or there's a 20%
- 55:39chance of them cutting by 100 roughly.
- 55:44I'm just saying, I'm just giving you the example there.
- 55:46When the when this two year yield trades lower, it's saying
- 55:50hey there's more and more of a chance that they have to just
- 55:54cut rates in three months. So that's the way that the fixed
- 55:59income investors approach it. They have to do this probability
- 56:02math. And they have to assign a
- 56:04probability that hey, the Fed is either going to cut by 100 basis
- 56:07points in the next six months as shit hits the fan or it can go
- 56:11on hold for another 12 months and probably ends up cutting the
- 56:14year after, which would be your actual soft landing Jesse
- 56:18scenario, right. So they they it's like 50%
- 56:22actual soft landing, 50% shit hit the fan and we this is our
- 56:27discounting mechanism now. So that's why I watch these
- 56:30markets. It's like.
- 56:31Who cares what the Fed is doing or saying what they even think
- 56:35about inflation? What cares what the market
- 56:38thinks about inflation with twos at 5 and the policy rate at 5
- 56:42and a third? The market isn't worried about 5
- 56:45to 10% inflation. It's it's wondering are we going
- 56:49to be between 0 and 5% inflation?
- 56:52Where are we going to be there? Because if we're at like 3
- 56:56status quo, maybe soft landing. If we're If we're at 2 or below,
- 57:02shit has probably already hit the fan because CPI is lagging
- 57:05to what's happening in the economy.
- 57:06Remember, prices go down if the consumer stops showing up.
- 57:11The consumer stops showing up if the consumers been fired.
- 57:14The consumers only fired if the businesses have gone under, and
- 57:18the business don't only go under when they can't make their debt
- 57:20payments, which has just started to happen.
- 57:25So that's the runway. Yeah.
- 57:32So at the front end of that order of operations, we.
- 57:35Could be, could be, but then you also have this five Sigma risk
- 57:39always, which is ironic because it's supposed to be 5 Sigma.
- 57:42It's supposed to. These are not supposed to happen
- 57:46every few years. Or if you, you shouldn't even
- 57:48have to worry about them happening every, you know, twice
- 57:51a year. But they're they're there
- 57:54somewhere. And so it's tough to, it's tough
- 57:58to forecast something like that. So, so let's I guess to kind of
- 58:03expand on, on that point there like these five Sigma events
- 58:07happen more frequently in a system that's becoming
- 58:11increasingly fragile, you know because of the level of debt.
- 58:20You know all the macroeconomic factors that are that are
- 58:22playing into that this system is is overly leveraged versus
- 58:28historical norms and we swing, you know our swings are more
- 58:33radical. So that's how you get the like
- 58:35increasing frequency of five Sigma events because the the
- 58:38data set is based on historical norms and we're living in a more
- 58:43radical time and then you know. I guess when when when I'm
- 58:50thinking about how the bond market is reacting to everything
- 58:53I've it, it seems like the the core assumption that the bond
- 58:57market continues to have is that everything is going to be OK
- 59:01like that. We are still within the normal
- 59:04range of like a healthy balance sheet basically for, for the
- 59:09country, for the G7, you know in private markets and public.
- 59:15And I think the bitcoiner perspective, you know that the
- 59:20the the hardcore bitcoiner perspective is that we've
- 59:23already passed the the effective event horizon on on Fiat and the
- 59:32and our debt system and that we are going to have to inflate
- 59:37away the debt and we're necessarily going to see a high
- 59:41inflation as a as part of that. And that you know the purchasing
- 59:47power of the dollar is going to erode at an increasingly rapid
- 59:50rate and and the bond market seems to behave in a way that
- 59:56doesn't doesn't believe that that is on the table or or if it
- 59:59is on the table it's like a 1 to 5% chance and and it's otherwise
- 1:00:03business as usual. Do you think that that is a fair
- 1:00:06characterization first of all? And do you think that that is
- 1:00:09starting to shift, I mean? Inherently like if you're seeing
- 1:00:13a a greater frequency of five Sigma events, you have to
- 1:00:16reassess why that is happening and and start to think, OK,
- 1:00:20maybe we're living in a changed environment and we can't rely on
- 1:00:2350 years of data because you know things are breaking.
- 1:00:28Yes, it's a great question, Jesse, and this is the one that
- 1:00:33we could just go go on forever about because there's so much
- 1:00:37there. First of all, it is a fair
- 1:00:40characterization that the bond market isn't too worried about
- 1:00:44the fundamentals of the US fiscal picture.
- 1:00:47In a long term basis. However, real yields have risen
- 1:00:52from from zero negative to 2 1/2.
- 1:00:56So there is there's definitely more of a premium.
- 1:01:01They call this term premium or? Risk premium even for owning
- 1:01:05treasuries themselves, which is why it's not usually referred to
- 1:01:09as a risk premium from the treasury perspective.
- 1:01:13But there is some, there is some statement from the market that
- 1:01:17we want more compensation, OK, but generally they're not at
- 1:01:23record levels, they're at multi decade highs, but they're not at
- 1:01:26record levels or anything to be too alarming.
- 1:01:30So I think it is a fair characterization.
- 1:01:33That the bond market isn't generally too worried.
- 1:01:35One caveat though, I won't say G7 because I just don't.
- 1:01:42I just don't. I can't say that for those, OK,
- 1:01:45I'm AI, am a predominantly US analyst and I also have a bias
- 1:01:51toward the dollar versus all the other Fiat including the euro,
- 1:02:01the pound. The yen, the Chinese one,
- 1:02:07etcetera, I do have a strong bias in that.
- 1:02:10I think that the US can outlast, outlast every single one of
- 1:02:14those countries, both on the sovereign debt market and on the
- 1:02:18FX market, which are two sides of the same coin, especially
- 1:02:22when you go into offshore banking.
- 1:02:24So that's the first thing. Second thing is that while the
- 1:02:28debt to GDP is above 100%. I would characterize it as an
- 1:02:35unprecedented situation that the US is in from a global financial
- 1:02:43systems perspective and the privilege, this privilege of
- 1:02:47being the reserve currency, is much larger than I could even
- 1:02:53try to quantify. That's the second thing.
- 1:02:56Third thing is you have to compare the size of the US
- 1:03:00Treasury market, which shameless plug for my YouTube video last
- 1:03:05night. You guys should go subscribe to
- 1:03:09the Bitcoin Layers YouTube channel.
- 1:03:11I got a really fancy new charting tool that has changed
- 1:03:15the game for us on the longer term, so we're really excited
- 1:03:18about that. Anyway, comparing the treasury
- 1:03:21market I showed comparing the treasury market to the stock
- 1:03:24market. To the size of real estate
- 1:03:26wealth, to the size of the euro dollar banking deposit market
- 1:03:32and to the size of the FX swap market.
- 1:03:35OK, the NYSE Plus, OK, the US Treasury market right now 33
- 1:03:40trillion from bottom to top Offshore dollar.
- 1:03:44Banking market 17 trillion FX swap market 30 trillion, 30 to
- 1:03:5235 trillion. New York Stock exchange plus
- 1:03:55NASDAQ 47 trillion and US real estate wealth that's non
- 1:04:01corporate. So household and non corporate
- 1:04:04business wealth real estate wealth 60 something trillion I
- 1:04:08believe 67 trillion or so. So you have all this wealth
- 1:04:15around the world and if you think about the treasury market
- 1:04:19relative to that market. And assigning a risk factor to
- 1:04:24those things relative to the fact that the US will pay you
- 1:04:27back in the nominal dollars regardless of what you think
- 1:04:31inflation is, regardless of what the TIPS yield is, which would
- 1:04:34be the real yield, and regardless of what CPI is, you
- 1:04:38will get the yield that they promise you nominally in USD and
- 1:04:44in onshore custodied. USD not a banking.
- 1:04:51A claim that turns immediately into a banking liability that
- 1:04:55could be at any bank around the world.
- 1:04:58Which dollars exist in that form?
- 1:05:01Probably probably to a much greater size than they exist in
- 1:05:06the United States because of this FX swap market factor.
- 1:05:11So I in in summary. The treasury situation and the
- 1:05:19fiscal situation not being all that bad based on where bond
- 1:05:25yields are and where real real yields are, I would somewhat
- 1:05:29agree with the bond market's characterization of that risk,
- 1:05:34which is that it is not that present and I do feel like this
- 1:05:41opinion specifically. Separates me from a lot of
- 1:05:45bitcoiners, but I don't think you need, I don't think you need
- 1:05:50a a, a, a cascading US fiscal and monetary crisis to spur
- 1:05:58Bitcoin adoption long term. I think, I just don't think you
- 1:06:02need it at all and I don't necessarily think that that is
- 1:06:05our near term, medium term future.
- 1:06:10Wait, you're providing me with a good segue?
- 1:06:12Sure, you could have. Could hear it earlier, but I
- 1:06:14screenshotted some charts and I think it's a good opportunity to
- 1:06:20look and bring up the chart. The second one I sent and just
- 1:06:23let's just reflect on the year that's been we've got Bitcoin
- 1:06:26verse, TLT, KB W, which is a regional banking index in the
- 1:06:33S&P 500. It's been a year about
- 1:06:35performance for Bitcoin some. Would say like the the year of
- 1:06:41the decoupling, I said that last week, so I'll just I that's what
- 1:06:44I believe this year is proving. And then obviously we're staying
- 1:06:48elevated around the $35,000 level.
- 1:06:52It'll be interesting to see with these new economic indicators
- 1:06:56and the markets be getting the signal that the Fed is has to
- 1:07:00reverse at some point if Bitcoin's success continues.
- 1:07:04I think that would be a validation of what you just
- 1:07:06said. Nick, which is that Bitcoin
- 1:07:09could succeed in any of these markets 'cause there was a a big
- 1:07:15meme in the space that Bitcoin can only go up when the monetary
- 1:07:19base is expanding. But it proved that that wrong
- 1:07:24this year. And I think what we're getting
- 1:07:26at here is that Bitcoin is its own unique animal that is sort
- 1:07:30of external to all these factors.
- 1:07:33And so when you said that, Nick, are you really?
- 1:07:36Saying something like Bitcoin's unique properties are such that
- 1:07:39it is a step function improvement on anything else
- 1:07:42we've ever seen, so people are gonna adopt it regardless of
- 1:07:45external factors in the bond market or stock market.
- 1:07:50Yes, Bitcoin is certainly a step function improvement type of
- 1:08:01technology that will continue. To demonstrate usefulness and
- 1:08:09adoption for many, many years to come, regardless of what is
- 1:08:15happening with QE rates, blah blah blah.
- 1:08:20I say blah blah blah because really, Bitcoin has nothing to
- 1:08:25do with what Yields are doing and what the Fed is doing.
- 1:08:31On the margin, it has everything to do with a technological
- 1:08:36solution to decentralized currency.
- 1:08:39To never been done, doesn't need to be done again.
- 1:08:42I I, I that's how I teach Bitcoin versus crypto.
- 1:08:46You don't need to reinvent the solution to the Byzantine
- 1:08:49Generals problem. Just doesn't need to be done.
- 1:08:51You don't. And so that is a binary.
- 1:08:56It's a zero to 1 moment for for Bitcoin.
- 1:08:59And it demonstrates immediate usefulness in its scarce supply,
- 1:09:04in that it's a juxtaposition of the current monetary system,
- 1:09:08which has an infinite supply from a theoretical perspective,
- 1:09:15and that is also binary, infinite versus finite, though
- 1:09:23the difference between those two is so stark that.
- 1:09:28While Bitcoin was aspiring to be like gold from Satoshi's own
- 1:09:32words and rhetoric and even word selection, the.
- 1:09:42The. The.
- 1:09:44Difference between Bitcoin and the current monetary system and
- 1:09:47Bitcoin plus Bitcoin as a technical solution means that
- 1:09:52over any any time horizon. That's not I think 12 months or
- 1:10:00or even you could even go out to five years over any time horizon
- 1:10:04that's shorter than that. There's no impact, I would say
- 1:10:07no impact from what the markets are doing.
- 1:10:12And but that again assumes, assumes that you have already
- 1:10:17tagged Infinity, right. You have to assume that that's
- 1:10:22what your tag is here. In the difference between
- 1:10:26Bitcoin and the current system, then if you assume it's
- 1:10:28infinite, there's nothing that they can do to shock you.
- 1:10:31And I think that Bitcoin's market value over the last 14
- 1:10:38years has demonstrated that thesis and that is not clear to
- 1:10:46everybody in the world yet, but I think it's very clear to many
- 1:10:51people. Which ends up driving the market
- 1:10:54value and contributing to the thesis that the rate stuff
- 1:10:59doesn't actually matter. We know what they're gonna do.
- 1:11:03They've already done it. Yeah, I think it's a yeah, go
- 1:11:07ahead, Michael. I I was gonna say I think it's a
- 1:11:09there's a component of asymmetric information and the
- 1:11:11value problem Bitcoin. But then also the current market
- 1:11:13cause, the anchoring back to the, we were thinking there was
- 1:11:15$22 billion that evaporated that somebody's in, you know,
- 1:11:18counterparty risk becomes real. In the world that we're heading
- 1:11:22to where somebody thought they had a bag of something and now
- 1:11:24it's either 110th of it or zero, we've seen that this increase
- 1:11:28in. And so to your point Nick, like
- 1:11:30if that continues to occur, people recognize that you can
- 1:11:34take possession, delivery, there's finite supply.
- 1:11:36There's all these things associated with the even if like
- 1:11:38the the amount of dollars in the system stayed at a static state
- 1:11:42at this exact point. It's being more, it's being
- 1:11:44priced against other assets, which is just something we've
- 1:11:48talked about before that most people don't bring up of like.
- 1:11:51The counterparty risk because it hasn't really existed in the
- 1:11:53traditional world of other things.
- 1:11:55And SVB was an example, but there could be others in other
- 1:11:58markets where it's like you thought you had something and
- 1:12:01you didn't anyway. So it's just like kind of
- 1:12:03further reinforces that there is a, there's a component.
- 1:12:06To that. Yeah.
- 1:12:07And as Americans, that's an that's a particular challenge to
- 1:12:12education and adoption is there's no tangible, there's
- 1:12:16never been a tangible worry of. Monetary safety or even
- 1:12:23financial security from a banking relationship perspective
- 1:12:28because of things like FDIC but but many other insurance type
- 1:12:35mechanisms and psychological honestly, a psychological
- 1:12:41operation from the entire banking complex.
- 1:12:47That liability money is normal and OK and preferable.
- 1:12:53That that itself is not well understood by Americans.
- 1:12:58It's much better understood by people in more unstable currency
- 1:13:05regimes. And so a huge portion of the
- 1:13:09world is more is more familiar with that.
- 1:13:12And then again, a large portion of the world is intimately
- 1:13:15aware. And familiar with this concept.
- 1:13:18So Bitcoin as a technical solution.
- 1:13:21You talk about storage, Mike that that component can only be
- 1:13:27discovered by the people that are looking for a solution to
- 1:13:33something like that. Each SVB will drive a few
- 1:13:36Americans towards that. But maybe still, from a storage
- 1:13:43perspective, Bitcoin doesn't exist.
- 1:13:46As that for Western people as much as it does for people in
- 1:13:52other countries, and those people that do have an intimate
- 1:13:57fear of liability, money and banking money and credit money,
- 1:14:04etcetera. Those people drive the education
- 1:14:11on a global scale because they're like, hey, look what it
- 1:14:14does for us. And I just, I do my best to try
- 1:14:19to empathize with those people and step into their shoes and
- 1:14:22hear their stories. But even even I as an American
- 1:14:27have a relationship with the dollar and liability money and
- 1:14:31credit money that would be maybe for some people unfit for
- 1:14:36bitcoiner. Because you have to.
- 1:14:38There is a there is a security that we do have and insurance
- 1:14:43mechanisms. In this country, you guys are
- 1:14:46setting up financial vehicles that have all these traditional
- 1:14:50banking relationships. That is how things function and
- 1:14:55we can March toward a Bitcoin world.
- 1:14:57But we all know that from a Bitcoin denominated perspective,
- 1:15:02you're still only building, You're still only building.
- 1:15:05You're not there. You're not actually even getting
- 1:15:08to a full denomination system anytime soon.
- 1:15:11You're not even necessarily. Striving for that in the short
- 1:15:14to medium term, but you're focused on the tools and the
- 1:15:18ability to do it in Bitcoin. Yeah, interesting.
- 1:15:24So. So I, you know, I share the view
- 1:15:28that I, I characterize it as like digital gold that you know
- 1:15:32that that's the easiest value proposition of Bitcoin to to
- 1:15:39wrap your head around that, like that this thing is scarcity
- 1:15:43embodied and and you know, the increasing scarcity function of
- 1:15:47the halvings creates very attractive investment properties
- 1:15:52And that's enough, you know, like in my book that is enough
- 1:15:56to get anybody excited that, you know, this thing can go to
- 1:15:59500,000 per per Bitcoin just based on matching gold.
- 1:16:03And then but that doesn't even touch these other forms of
- 1:16:06utility, I guess different types of utility.
- 1:16:09You know, there's that disintermediation utility of
- 1:16:12like Bitcoin can disintermediate Western Union, Visa, even
- 1:16:18banking, all sorts of financial intermediaries and in theory can
- 1:16:22eat the market cap of companies in in that that get
- 1:16:27disintermediated by Bitcoin And you sum up the value of that and
- 1:16:31that adds to the total market value of Bitcoin in time.
- 1:16:36But I think that's small relative to store value digital
- 1:16:41gold. And then there's this other
- 1:16:43piece that you know, we we I I think we do a bad job of parsing
- 1:16:47out that there's digital gold and there's as Foss, Greg Foss
- 1:16:52characterizes the credit default swaps CDs on shit going to hell
- 1:17:00and and Fiat money collapsing and and that Bitcoin has has
- 1:17:05value as an insurance policy. It's the lifeboat idea here of
- 1:17:09what's the value of insurance on the Fiat system.
- 1:17:14And you know Foss's calculations come up with that portion of the
- 1:17:18value of Bitcoin is $2,000,000. So you know in it in his mind
- 1:17:23Bitcoin should be $2,000,000 per Bitcoin based on properly baking
- 1:17:29in the insurance value of the risk of everything going to hell
- 1:17:33in in the Fiat monetary system and that's a a separate from
- 1:17:37digital gold. And So what what what I'm
- 1:17:40hearing is that you maybe you don't characterize it as digital
- 1:17:44gold, but you think that that you know there's value As for
- 1:17:48for Bitcoin as a digital store value, even if you think that
- 1:17:52the CDs value is less than most Bitcoiners believe.
- 1:17:59Yeah, I. I I I don't.
- 1:18:04Because insurance is insurance. The cost of insurance is the
- 1:18:08cost of insurance. So today the cost of Bitcoin is
- 1:18:10what it is to say an insurance cost and then model it based off
- 1:18:15of what you really think it is. I'm not so sure about that
- 1:18:19because you're extrapolating something that's not necessarily
- 1:18:23there. The price of Bitcoin is what it
- 1:18:24is today, so whatever. The insurance premium of shit
- 1:18:28going to hell. Is in the price today?
- 1:18:31I would argue that, but how do you value Bitcoin?
- 1:18:37Is it digital gold the best way? I mean, that's what I went with
- 1:18:39and layered money I I explained to people that hey, this is a
- 1:18:44digital store of value and if it went to the gold size, it could
- 1:18:48be 500,000 per coin. But how do you really value
- 1:18:56Bitcoin? It's by the utility of the
- 1:18:59people using it. So if the utility goes up and
- 1:19:03the number of people go up, then the price should go up.
- 1:19:08So I think about, I just think about from the adoption
- 1:19:14perspective, how useful is Bitcoin and how and the the
- 1:19:21utility of Bitcoin goes way beyond gold and I think.
- 1:19:26Jesse that's what you were trying to hint at as well.
- 1:19:29It does definitely go way beyond gold.
- 1:19:32And gold doesn't even begin to characterize what it feels like
- 1:19:36to move Bitcoin around the world.
- 1:19:38Because I know all of you have experience doing that.
- 1:19:40It is an the power is unreal. You have unleashed from banks
- 1:19:46and governments at the same time.
- 1:19:48Such a game changer. It's not even funny.
- 1:19:51So that gives Bitcoin a ceiling. Which is hard to define.
- 1:20:01It's going up forever, Laura. Well.
- 1:20:04I'll say that that is actually a report that we just put out at
- 1:20:10on ramp and and if anyone listening to this is interested
- 1:20:13you can go to our website and right there at the top of the
- 1:20:15page there's a button to download the full potential
- 1:20:17evaluation analysis for Bitcoin. And you know, this is a thought
- 1:20:24problem I've been. Working on for three years and
- 1:20:29and this latest version is the most expanded iteration of it
- 1:20:34and you know I I try to analyse like what defines the ceiling
- 1:20:41for Bitcoin and it's it's you know it starts by having to take
- 1:20:47stock of what defines the ceiling for other store value
- 1:20:50assets and and. Based on my understanding of of
- 1:20:55these things, the ceiling tends to be dictated by what is the
- 1:21:00new supply issuance for any given commodity that has to be
- 1:21:05absorbed every year by the market by by demand in the
- 1:21:09market. And that equilibrium kind of
- 1:21:12sets the the ceiling for what's possible for a given commodity,
- 1:21:16whether that commodity is is gold or or real estate.
- 1:21:23And that Bitcoin, because it it has this terminal absolute
- 1:21:27scarcity where there is no new issuance, is not constrained by
- 1:21:32that typical ceiling. So then the ceiling becomes not
- 1:21:35how much supply the market can absorb every year, but instead
- 1:21:43how how much of A portfolio do people end up wanting to have in
- 1:21:48a perfect store of value relative to other assets that
- 1:21:51that you want. You know, whether that's real
- 1:21:54estate or stocks or bonds or fine art.
- 1:21:59And so that that ends up becoming the framework by which
- 1:22:03I analyze what is the full potential valuation for Bitcoin.
- 1:22:07And the result is shockingly high.
- 1:22:11You know, like 2025% of, based on my conservative assumptions,
- 1:22:152025% of all the wealth out there.
- 1:22:19Whereas today it's 12000 put a number on it.
- 1:22:25Well, it comes up with $10 million per Bitcoin in today's
- 1:22:28dollars. That's what Hal Finney said.
- 1:22:30Yeah, it aligns with Hal's. With some different assumptions,
- 1:22:36but I ended up at yeah, at the same place and and, and it's
- 1:22:40worth noting that a lot of other people have sort of gotten to
- 1:22:43that number with various approaches.
- 1:22:48To pat myself on the back, I I think I as far as I'm aware, I I
- 1:22:52it's the most like rigorous triangulation that I've seen out
- 1:22:55there. Yeah, my original, my original
- 1:23:00price target based on my understanding of the size of
- 1:23:07financial assets and what I thought Bitcoin could or might
- 1:23:11become was in the 2 to $4 million range.
- 1:23:16You know that. Put it at you know in the 40
- 1:23:21trillion you know zone and just you know thinking thinking it
- 1:23:30out loud you you can get to much higher numbers and then the only
- 1:23:35thing stopping you from getting there is network adoption And
- 1:23:40the only thing that can happen, you know that can prevent that
- 1:23:43is time. So it it does just.
- 1:23:48Whatever your ceilings are, and even Foss with the 2 million, he
- 1:23:53just thinks that it's for him. It's insurance that's worth 2
- 1:23:57million, and so he buys it today at 35 S The price is always the
- 1:24:01expression of what people are willing to pay for.
- 1:24:04And you know, you, you you buy if you think it's undervalued.
- 1:24:08Right. And the people who do their
- 1:24:10homework on it end up coming up with a valuation that's above
- 1:24:13the current market price. I know we have to keep
- 1:24:16happening. Right.
- 1:24:18But I I hesitate saying this, but I'm going to say it because
- 1:24:20it's it rounds out what I wanted to say earlier is that I don't I
- 1:24:23100% believe that there is no top and the reason why there is
- 1:24:26no top is I think of like human action from a micro example.
- 1:24:29That's the best way I can explain any of this stuff that
- 1:24:32comes from just like real world application of we're talking
- 1:24:35about the stock market and we could have been a little bearish
- 1:24:38on like or we traditionally go in that version on this pod of
- 1:24:41like shits getting messed up. But the reality is cost of
- 1:24:45capital increases, people go out of business.
- 1:24:47People have to step in from unit economics of Ubers and all these
- 1:24:51things in the world. It's a real big opportunity if
- 1:24:53you can actually think through a business model from an
- 1:24:54entrepreneurial perspective to deliver value to the market.
- 1:24:58So if that exists, and then to Jesse's point, information
- 1:25:03asymmetry, we learn what the value of Bitcoin is, then you're
- 1:25:05always starting to actually. Think of the most productive
- 1:25:08way. Do you hold the Bitcoin or do
- 1:25:09you start the business? Can you think of a better, more
- 1:25:11productive way to deliver the value and services that were
- 1:25:14given to the market but weren't really having the right unit
- 1:25:18economics and margins to be sustainable because of the cost
- 1:25:21of capital being zero? You end up at this point where
- 1:25:24you end up stepping in. Somebody steps in and finds a
- 1:25:26floor because you can deliver those services.
- 1:25:28That justifies making more Bitcoin back than the actual
- 1:25:31units that you're holding. Which is effectively, partially
- 1:25:34what we're doing here. When you think about building a
- 1:25:36business and what we're we have a choice that we can, you know,
- 1:25:39hold Bitcoin. We can, you know build a
- 1:25:41business and potentially make more Bitcoin in the future
- 1:25:43state. And if you do that right and you
- 1:25:45do that with a sustainability, you can deliver more value to
- 1:25:48the market which increases you know, GDP and all the things
- 1:25:51associated. And so that's where I think this
- 1:25:54whole thing doesn't necessarily have a top because if you end up
- 1:25:55with a base unit that has those properties and all the things
- 1:25:58get repriced. But then at the same time it's
- 1:26:00those things getting repriced, people are providing more and
- 1:26:03more value, which increases the purchasing power of that
- 1:26:05capital. And so I really think like, you
- 1:26:07know, it's a meme, but you know, says there's no top.
- 1:26:09There really is no top because it's this whole thing works.
- 1:26:11It changes the dynamic of how people produce goods and
- 1:26:14services. Yeah, I I agree there's no top
- 1:26:20in nominal dollars and but I. Take the stance of like, I
- 1:26:24actually think that I think that I'm going to say something
- 1:26:28controversial here, that I I think that the everything
- 1:26:34divided by 21 million, the Infinity divided by 21 million
- 1:26:38concept is wrong. But it's very helpful.
- 1:26:43Like I'll I'll I'll admit that it's very helpful to help Orient
- 1:26:47people's thinking about the potential scale of this.
- 1:26:52You know it it it approaches Infinity.
- 1:26:54I'll, I'll say that. But but I think that ultimately
- 1:26:57like there is a value to other assets and you're people are
- 1:27:01going to want to hold other assets in addition to just
- 1:27:03holding Bitcoin. And so if there's anything else
- 1:27:07out there you're you're not you know Bitcoin doesn't eat
- 1:27:10everything. Bitcoin doesn't become Infinity.
- 1:27:12It becomes a percentage of what's out there And you know
- 1:27:16like for that matter, like I I think that.
- 1:27:21And it's a weird thing to say, but the ultimately there's
- 1:27:24there's not 21 million Bitcoin worth of value in the world.
- 1:27:27There's 100 million Bitcoin worth of value in the world.
- 1:27:31Or maybe it's 60, maybe it's 200 because people choose to to to
- 1:27:37value other things, even if they're priced in Bitcoin.
- 1:27:41So there's a hundred $120 trillion of Fiat money in the
- 1:27:46world today, but there's $900 trillion of store value assets.
- 1:27:51So, you know, even though there's there's $120 trillion,
- 1:27:54we we understand that there's $900 trillion worth of value out
- 1:27:59there. I think that, you know, Bitcoin
- 1:28:01ends up long term, you know, becoming the unit of account and
- 1:28:07slots in into that $120 trillion role.
- 1:28:11But it's a better money. So it ends up being a a larger
- 1:28:14percentage of the world's assets and ends up it ends up sucking a
- 1:28:20lot of value out of that $900 trillion bucket.
- 1:28:22And like we're focusing on real estate specifically like real
- 1:28:25estate should be somewhat of a consumption good with some
- 1:28:28premium put on it for aesthetic, aesthetic, location, land,
- 1:28:36whatever it may be. So you have the, like, the
- 1:28:38consumable, like how big is the house?
- 1:28:40How many bedrooms does it have, how many bathrooms, what is that
- 1:28:42worth to consume those luxuries? And then a premium on the
- 1:28:46aesthetics and location, school, district, whatever.
- 1:28:51But it will not be like what we're seeing now where people
- 1:28:53are just shoveling money into real estate because it's the
- 1:28:57only thing that's holding value relative to the dollar.
- 1:29:00The counter that there was a productive asset like the
- 1:29:02counter to what Jesse's saying is you basically have two forms
- 1:29:04of assets. One that competes with money and
- 1:29:06then the other one's a a claim on a productive asset which
- 1:29:09would be like a a equity or a piece of real estate because
- 1:29:12it's a productive asset that you can provide utility.
- 1:29:15So that would be the the, the counter that's like you
- 1:29:17basically competes with money. So Bitcoin owns it.
- 1:29:19And then if it's a productive asset, like a piece of real
- 1:29:21estate or Amazon stock, because you're taking Bitcoin as a
- 1:29:24dividend from it and everything else, and it wouldn't be in
- 1:29:27between, that's why it's Infinity.
- 1:29:30But there's. But then there's you still have
- 1:29:32to allow for, like, fine art. Like people are going to want to
- 1:29:35own Monet's whether or not, you know they're producing any
- 1:29:38Bitcoin or not. Michael says no.
- 1:29:42He'd rather Michael would rather hang a big coin on the wall than
- 1:29:45a Monet, because Michael's got terrible aesthetics.
- 1:29:49You can. You can tell by the I'm kidding.
- 1:29:55We're we're rambling here now, though.
- 1:29:58Well. OK, but I I'm going to tie it
- 1:30:00back to I I cringe every time I see Infinity divided by 21
- 1:30:05million and I feel like. It's very helpful for plebs.
- 1:30:09It's very helpful for people who don't have a traditional finance
- 1:30:12background to understand the scale of what they're buying.
- 1:30:16But I think that it doesn't do us any favors when we're talking
- 1:30:21to traditional finance to. Be talking in Infinity terms?
- 1:30:26No, I think a better meme is there's 8 billion people and
- 1:30:28only 21 million Bitcoin. I love that.
- 1:30:32Yeah. And I think the productivity
- 1:30:33claim is that the important factor there is that we've seen
- 1:30:36a lot of unproductive capital. And again going back to the we
- 1:30:40work is when you have this like no cost of capital.
- 1:30:42It changes that dynamic. On what goods and services are
- 1:30:45delivered and that's where that purchasing power continues to
- 1:30:47increase. You can get more efficient as a
- 1:30:49society. That's the idea behind, I think
- 1:30:51that the essence of an Infinity is that, like, you continue to
- 1:30:53grow the purchasing power of the money, which is what money was
- 1:30:56supposed to do. Yeah.
- 1:30:57And you're echoing something that Stan Drunkenmiller said
- 1:31:00earlier this week, which is the Fed has introduced a hurdle rate
- 1:31:03back to the market, which should make capital allocation the due
- 1:31:09diligence behind it more more intense and actual.
- 1:31:13Do actual diligence. Not gonna be Sequoia, just
- 1:31:17watching SPF play League of Legends and talk about turning
- 1:31:20bananas into digital currencies and being like, I love this
- 1:31:23founder. Here's $200 million.
- 1:31:25Those days may be gone. One of my favorite takes from
- 1:31:29that is from from safe. That said that like they should
- 1:31:32have let. SPF and that whole thing, it
- 1:31:34reminded me of what Nick was talking about with like just
- 1:31:36Counterparty risk in the States versus international, like the
- 1:31:40BTFP program. If they would have let SPB fail,
- 1:31:43like so many people would have found Bitcoin right off the bat.
- 1:31:46Same layers like FTX people would have learned like, oh, it
- 1:31:48wasn't Sam's fault, it was in exchange and all the things
- 1:31:51associated with it. Now you think about like the
- 1:31:53Counterparty Risk associated with the asset.
- 1:31:59Yeah, Nick, is there anything on top of your mind that we didn't
- 1:32:03cover that we should touch on before we leave?
- 1:32:08Writing my second book. It'll be out next year and I'm
- 1:32:13extremely excited about it. It is a Bitcoin focused book,
- 1:32:18which is a little bit different than Layered Money, which was a
- 1:32:20more monetary focused book. So I hope people will stay tuned
- 1:32:26for that and you can catch everything we're doing at the
- 1:32:29Bitcoin layer. So subscribe.
- 1:32:32Definitely check out our research, publication and our
- 1:32:36YouTube channel podcast. Awesome.
- 1:32:39Thank you for your insights. I think your perspective on
- 1:32:43rates, bonds, fed actions is really unique and this was a
- 1:32:49great conversation on that. I'm very happy this was a very
- 1:32:53rates focused episode 'cause there's a lot of questions out
- 1:32:58there. Yeah.
- 1:33:00Hear more from Nick on that. The last Peter McCormick pod I
- 1:33:03listened to, it was really great to get more insights into that.
- 1:33:06So yeah, if you want to hear more.
- 1:33:09Yeah. And and Nick, I'd I'd like to
- 1:33:11thank you for, you know in in the Bitcoin sphere we we
- 1:33:17discount the bond market as like not being perfectly right but.
- 1:33:24It's the biggest market in the world for a reason.
- 1:33:26You know, like you know the the the smartest people in the world
- 1:33:29are dealing with the biggest market in the world because it's
- 1:33:32the most money there. And so you know, I think it's
- 1:33:36really helpful for bitcoiners including me to have that like
- 1:33:41dose of reality, that reality check of like you know the bond
- 1:33:45market is rational even if they may in my opinion be not
- 1:33:51appropriately. Baking in the the potential of
- 1:33:55of hyperinflation or or inflating away the debt.
- 1:33:59At least they're more rational than bitcoiners tend to assume.
- 1:34:05And it's very helpful to have your expertise and your voice
- 1:34:09and your knowledge about the bond market out there.
- 1:34:11So hopefully this is valuable to to bitcoiners listening.
- 1:34:15Appreciate that. I'm I'm very glad, Nick, that
- 1:34:18you gave Marty an outlet because I think he really genuinely
- 1:34:21enjoys talking about this. Obviously he's here every week
- 1:34:24but his Co host on his other podcast really does not like
- 1:34:26talking about bonds and so he at least you know Marty gets to
- 1:34:32scratch both sides of the the brain.
- 1:34:34Yeah I'll try to dive down a a macro or rabbit hole metal.
- 1:34:38Just be like yeah just stay on the stacks.
- 1:34:39That's there's nothing that shit out on.
- 1:34:41ONS are a shit coin and then it's just.
- 1:34:45Shout out to Matt, Marty, Mike, Jesse.
- 1:34:47Appreciate you guys a lot, man. Alright, Nick, thank you.
- 1:34:52Enjoy the rest of your day on the West Coast.
- 1:34:55Michael, Jesse, we're all in Texas now.
- 1:34:57We should meet up. We should get together in
- 1:34:58person. I'll look through the screens.
- 1:35:00We'll see you guys next week.