Latest / The So What? / AMSA: The Sound and Fury of a Partial Closing
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans. You can find a written
- 0:16version of this content on JP's website jplantman.co.za. I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:27This podcast, dated the 27th of January 2025, is titled AMSA, the sound and fury of a partial
- 0:36closure. We came back from a delightful holiday in Namibia and walked into a storm. What was
- 0:43it about? Was it just about steel factories closing?
- 0:47Ostensibly, yes. It was about the announcement by Arcelor Mittal, South Africa, which we will
- 0:53refer to as AMSA, closing their long steel business. But in reality, Ruda, it's about
- 0:58much more. It's about import tariffs, it's about protection of local industry, it's about
- 1:05localisation, it's about industrial policy. All these things came together in this AMSA
- 1:10issue and it's what we do in this note in January. We unpack all these issues a bit.
- 1:16Tell me about the origin and the history of AMSA, Arcelor Mittal, South Africa.
- 1:21AMSA started its life as YSKOR, the South African Iron and Steel Corporation, which
- 1:26was founded by Hendrik van der Bijl, the man who single-handedly industrialised South Africa
- 1:31way back in the 1920s. It became a big steel business in South Africa and it played a huge
- 1:37role in producing the steel and many steel products that you need in the modern economy.
- 1:44What I think is important to remember is that the old ISKOR consisted of two businesses,
- 1:49steelmaking, but they also had a mining side. On the mining side, they had iron ore and
- 1:53coal mines. The benefit of having iron ore mines is that you can buy or acquire the iron
- 2:01ore that you need for steelmaking cheaply. You have your own mines, you can make arrangements.
- 2:07That's the way in which the old YSKOR operated.
- 2:11Then, how did it become Arcelor Mittal?
- 2:14Yes, in 1989, ISKOR was privatised and listed on the JoBurg Stock Exchange. In 2001, 12
- 2:22years later, it was split into two separate companies. The one is YSKOR Steelmaking and
- 2:28the other one, Kumba Resources. They took the iron ore and coal mines. In 2004, Lakshmi
- 2:36Metal that we will talk about bought the company and they changed the name from ISKOR to Mittal,
- 2:41called Steel. In 2006, I think the problem started because then Kumba Resources itself
- 2:50was split into two companies, Kumba Iron Ore, which still exists today and is a very profitable
- 2:57miner of iron ore, and Exxaro. Exxaro Resources, as you know, is a mining and coal company
- 3:05also listed on the JSE. That's the history. This split up of Kumba between coal and iron
- 3:13ore had the effect that in 2010, Kumba Iron Ore cancelled the arrangement that they had
- 3:20with the old YSKOR or Mittal Steel to provide iron ore for the steelmaking on preferential
- 3:26terms. They wanted a much more market related agreement. There were court cases, negotiations
- 3:32and political interventions and so on. But in 2013, Kumba Iron Ore and Mittal Steel made
- 3:41an agreement where they still bought the iron ore from Kumba, but at much less preferential
- 3:47terms. That must have hit AMSA's or YSKOR's balance sheet considerably.
- 3:53Another thing that comes up in this whole conversation is the difference between long
- 3:57steel and flat steel. Explain that? Yes, as the names indicate, long steel is
- 4:04anything that is long. Bars that you use in reinforced concrete, for example, railway
- 4:11tracks, it's long steel. Anything like that goes through as long steel. Flat steel is
- 4:17basically sheets which are made, whether you use the sheet to fold it and use it for car
- 4:23manufacturing or whether you use the sheet to fold it into corrugated iron that you can
- 4:28put on a roof. It's basically long versus flat. Now, what AMSA is doing, they're closing
- 4:34their long steel business, but it's important to note that they're not closing their flat
- 4:38steel business. That will continue. What part of the business is the long steel?
- 4:43They don't disclose the numbers, but the general understanding in the market is that long steel
- 4:49is more than 50% of AMSA's business. It is a big part of the company.
- 4:54What is the global context? What's happening in other places across the world?
- 4:59What happened in the first half of the 20th century is that many, many countries in the
- 5:03world had the belief that just as you had to have a national airline to be a serious
- 5:09country, you had to have steelworks and you had to have your own steel company. Therefore,
- 5:14a lot of governments in the world created steel companies like the government here created
- 5:19e-score in the 1920s. Exactly the same story. Now, the problem is if everybody is building
- 5:25a steel factory, then there's huge overcapacity in the world. Many of these steel companies,
- 5:30particularly the government owned ones ran into financial difficulties. And there's
- 5:35an Indian entrepreneur, Mr. Mittal, who saw the opportunity. He started buying up the
- 5:40steel companies worldwide. And of course, he rationalized them, reduced the staff numbers,
- 5:46sweated the assets and he himself became fabulously wealthy. And in the process, he
- 5:51drove the consolidation of steel capacity worldwide. And this process has been ongoing.
- 5:59Mr. Mittal's rationalization drive was not the only one. For example, British Steel,
- 6:06which for a long, long time was the biggest steel company in the world, had massive rationalizations
- 6:12and buying up other companies and merging and so on. And in the end, they themselves
- 6:18merged with the Dutch steel company Koeninklijke Hoogovens and became Corus Steel. Corus
- 6:25Steel in turn was taken over by another Indian company, Tata. And what Tata did was to close
- 6:31down a huge amount of capacity. And today the UK, which once had British Steel and was
- 6:37a very, very big steel producer, today the UK produces about 25% of what they produced
- 6:43in the previous century. So a lot of capacity has been closed down worldwide. And this Lakshay
- 6:49Mittal initiative and the Corus Tata initiative is not the last. We've seen very recently
- 6:56Japan Steel, Nippon, once wanted to buy US Steel and it's a transaction that was vetoed
- 7:01by President Biden when he was still in office. And it all plays into this thing of overcapacity
- 7:07in the world, trying to protect jobs, trying to protect all industries. And it's an ongoing
- 7:12process. Was the closure of the, at least the long steel part of ArcelorMittal unexpected?
- 7:21But for people who were in the industry, we have a friend who used to be in steel construction
- 7:29his entire life, a civil engineer. After he retired from steel construction projects,
- 7:34he became a professor at the engineering faculty at Stellenbosch University. And about eight
- 7:40years ago, a long time ago, he guided one of his master's students to do a thesis on
- 7:46can you develop long steel products, particularly steel bars from welded steel? In other words,
- 7:54can you use flat steel products to produce a product which is normally made in long steel?
- 8:00And this was eight years ago. And I asked him, so what prompted you to guide the student?
- 8:04And he said, look, it was already clear 10 years ago that long steel is in trouble because
- 8:10there's this huge overcapacity worldwide. If you can import long steel from Indonesia,
- 8:15I'm just mentioning a name, or you can import it from India, why on earth would you make
- 8:19it in Vereneeneging? And he saw this coming. So for people in the industry, it wasn't quite
- 8:24a surprise.
- 8:25Then there's a whole raft of other players in the field called mini mills. What are they
- 8:32and what do they do?
- 8:34Steel is made from iron ore in a furnace and you get your products out in the other side,
- 8:40long steel or flat steel. But what you can also do is you can use scrap metal and you
- 8:45can use electricity at very high temperatures to melt it. So you put the scrap metal in
- 8:52on one side and the other side you've got steel products coming out.
- 8:55Recycling.
- 8:56Recycling basically. Now we haven't had mini mills in South Africa. It's a phenomenon
- 9:00of the last 10, 17 years to be precise. And how it works is like this. If you're a scrap
- 9:07metal merchant and you buy scrap metal from wherever in the public office it to you, you're
- 9:13not allowed to sell that or to export it. You first have to offer it to a mini mill
- 9:18in South Africa. And the price that you have to offer it is the international price of
- 9:23scrap in Rotterdam minus 30%. So in that way, the scrap dealers of course take a cut. They
- 9:30suffer a little bit. They can't now export at market prices. But the mini mills get it
- 9:37at Rotterdam minus 30%. So their input cost is much lower. And therefore a whole flourishing
- 9:43mini mill industry started to develop in South Africa. As I said, 17 years ago there was
- 9:49nothing. And today this policy of benefiting or helping mini mills has resulted in 50%
- 9:57more or less of long steel products in this country being made by mini mills. In the past
- 10:0120 years ago, 25 years ago, AMSA made the whole lot. Now their market share is down
- 10:07to probably less than 50% because there's also still imports. So the rise of the mini
- 10:13mills on the back of aggressive government policy has also changed the landscape quite
- 10:17considerably. Now these two elements of the mini mill policy, i.e. scrap metal must be
- 10:24offered at 30% discount and you cannot export it. The export ban and the price regulation
- 10:31go together. The question is, if you take those two things away, will the mini mill
- 10:36industry survive? And we just don't know. The current arrangement is scheduled to end
- 10:42in 2027. I think it's June 2027. But of course it can be renewed. Now Arsalan Mattal and
- 10:49many other players in the country are pushing very strongly that it shouldn't be renewed,
- 10:55that in 2027 this subsidy effectively for the mini mills should fall away. We will see
- 11:00what happens in two years time and we will have to see how many of the mini mills can
- 11:05survive. But I must just make one point quite clear. A lot of people think that the mini
- 11:10mills are just a sort of inferior operation. And that's not the case at all. Score metals,
- 11:18which in fact is more or less the same age as Arcelor Mittal or YSKOR, fall more or less
- 11:24at the same time. They are also now a big mini mill producer and they export high quality
- 11:32steel products all over the world, including to China. Now there can't be too many companies
- 11:37that export steel products to China. So it shows you it is possible to be a mini mill
- 11:41and run a highly sophisticated operation. That is quite possible.
- 11:47Does Arcelor Mittal itself play in this field? No, not at all. They never invested in the
- 11:51technology. Mini mills operates on entirely different machinery, entirely different technology.
- 11:57And no, they never invested money. And in fact, if you go through all the reports and
- 12:02so on, there's a lot of criticism of AMSA that they made the wrong capital allocation
- 12:07decisions over the years. People say they could have spent their money better and they
- 12:13would be a much more productive and a better steel producer today. Now I'm not wading
- 12:17into that argument. I'm just noting that those accusations are there, that they haven't
- 12:23spent their money in the most optimal way. What does the steel market in South Africa
- 12:27look like? How much do we use? What do we produce here? Do we import?
- 12:31Yeah, that's very interesting. We've got capacity between Arsalan Mattal and all the
- 12:36mini mills to produce 8.8 million tonnes of steel a year. Last year we only produced 4.1
- 12:43million tonnes, less than half. And of those 4.1 million tonnes, we imported 32% or about
- 12:511.3 million tonnes. So that gives you the story. Now the steel people, AMSA in particular,
- 12:58argues that if the economy is growing at a higher rate, then there will be more demand
- 13:02for steel and things will be better. Well, that's of course true because steel demand
- 13:06is very sensitive to economic growth. 3% is much, much better than 1%. And as you know,
- 13:12we've been growing at 1%. That will change once you've got 3%. But does that mean that
- 13:18our full capacity will be utilised? Not necessarily, because as I've said, even under these depressed
- 13:24conditions, we import 32% of our steel. So if there's a bigger demand for more steel,
- 13:31you may find that your imports also go up. Why do we import if we have the local capacity?
- 13:35It's all about price and quality. So, you know, steel is not just steel. And steel products
- 13:41are not, all of them are not made the same. I'll give you two examples. In the old, in
- 13:47previous times, in the old South Africa, when we still built railway lines, we imported
- 13:5230 to 40,000 tonnes of railway tracks a year, because the old Iskor then couldn't produce
- 13:58them locally. Today we've got a very flourishing motorcar industry. We import about 300,000
- 14:05tonnes a year for steel that go into the assembly of motorcars. So either the prices locally
- 14:13cannot compete with foreigners or the quality is not there. So that's why you, that's why
- 14:19you have imports. And that will probably carry on even if there's a higher demand for steel.
- 14:25Could tariffs make a difference with President Trump at the moment, saying, seeming to think
- 14:31that tariffs are the answer, whatever the question? Look, at the moment there is an
- 14:37import tariff on imported steel of about 9%. AMSA says it's not enough. They want 25%.
- 14:44And that takes you to the heart of the matter. Do you force consumers to pay more for a product
- 14:50in order to protect the local industry or do you subject the local industry to competition?
- 14:55And there's no clear answer on it. There's no right or wrong. It's a public policy choice
- 14:59that you make. AMSA likes to point out that there are countries like Mexico, for example,
- 15:04where there's 82% import tariff on steel. We've seen that President Joe Biden refused to take
- 15:11over by nipping off US steel. So it plays into jobs, into politics, into protection, localization,
- 15:19that sort of story. In the end, I don't think tariffs will make much of a difference. That's
- 15:23the experience worldwide. In the end, you have to have the best product at the best price. And to
- 15:29get to the best product at the best price, you need investment. You need the latest technology.
- 15:33You need the latest machinery. You need best practice. If you don't apply that,
- 15:38then you're not going to make it irrespective of what the...
- 15:41And I suppose you need scale. And you need scale. Absolutely,
- 15:46there's a very important point. You need scale. And if your local economy is not big enough,
- 15:50well, then you must be good enough to export. And that brings you back to best practice,
- 15:54best product, and so on. Yeah, so scale is absolutely important. If we look at the world today,
- 16:02in many industries, for example, electric cars, the Chinese are just way, way ahead. What do they
- 16:08have? They have the latest technology, better than anybody else, including Tesla. And they have scale.
- 16:14And that enables them to produce cars to the extent that build your dreams. The EV manufacturer
- 16:21in China is outselling, has begun to outsell Tesla. That's what happens when you've got the
- 16:27technology and you've got the skills and you've got the scale. We also see it here in the poultry
- 16:33industry. Absolutely. Steel and chicken bring to the fore the same issues. We pay import levy on
- 16:42imported chicken. Chicken is the country's biggest source of protein. So now your consumers pay more
- 16:47for their protein than what they would have if they were no tariffs. On the other hand, you're
- 16:52protecting the local industry. And there's your choice. What do you want? Consumers pay more
- 16:57or subsidize the local industry? And again, there's no right or wrong. Make your choice.
- 17:02It's a public policy choice that you have to make. Shifting our focus back to steel,
- 17:07what's going to happen? What are the possible scenarios? Well, the interesting thing is for
- 17:13the short term, it's important to note that at the end of November last year,
- 17:16the revenue service imposed import tariffs on what is called structural steel products
- 17:24from China and Thailand. In the case of China, the levies are 52%. In the case of Thailand, 9%. So
- 17:31those are clearly two countries which export products to us very competitively. That's why
- 17:36they put it in. But that's a temporary measure for six months only while ITAC,
- 17:42ITAC is the International Trade Commission, investigate allegations of dumping and they
- 17:47will make recommendations. And then we will see which way it goes. So that's the one thing.
- 17:53The other thing to bear in mind, that's happening, the Chinese have built the ultra-modern steel
- 17:58plant in Zimbabwe. And they came into operation last year and those products have already started
- 18:04arriving in South Africa. So we can see steel imports from ZIM taking place here. A third
- 18:12development that's taking place, different Chinese companies are looking at building
- 18:16a steel factory in Limpopo. But there's huge, huge environmental resistance to it. So something that
- 18:23I was just wondering about is what are the possibilities that those steel companies are
- 18:27convinced instead of building in Limpopo, rather take over the plants that I'm so closing?
- 18:33Refurbish them, make them modern, put in new equipment and run with that existing infrastructure
- 18:39in terms of roads, railways, water and so on, rather than stuffing up the Limpopo province.
- 18:45But I don't know what will happen. We'll have to see how these things play out.
- 18:48Is that just a twinkle in your eye or do you know that something is happening?
- 18:52No, it's just a twinkle in my eye. I know that the Chinese are trying to build a steel factory
- 18:57in Limpopo and I know there's huge opposition. We'll have to see how that plays out.
- 19:00But it sounds as you've said that this is fundamentally about industrial policy and
- 19:06not just South Africa. It's a point of principle everywhere.
- 19:11Yes, it is. Now there's a very interesting Japanese economist, Richard Koo, who wrote
- 19:18some very interesting books on what he called persecuted economies. And what is a persecuted
- 19:23economy? It's an economy that had a golden era of manufacturing and industrialization.
- 19:30And then the golden era passed because new economies came up that were more efficient,
- 19:36more better technology, later equipment and so on and so forth. And they started persecuting
- 19:41the old economy. So the old economies, in a way he tells it, is the US, the UK, Europe,
- 19:48even to some extent Japan. Who are the new economies? Taiwan, South Korea, China and as
- 19:54we've seen Thailand. So they become to eat away. The hunters of yesterday have become
- 20:01the hunted of today and they're new hunters persecuting the old hunters. This is a fundamental
- 20:08development that's taking place worldwide. And it's happening in a large number of industries.
- 20:14For example, the German car industry, I think is in huge trouble as a result of competition from
- 20:21Chinese car companies who've built an enormous car sector. So the question is how do you position
- 20:26yourself in the light of that? And my own feeling is that it's no good trying to maintain that
- 20:33which comes from yesterday. Yesterday's industries cannot be sustained. There could be a transition
- 20:40period. There could be a time that you allow for adjustment, but in the end you cannot protect the
- 20:45old industries. You've got to develop new industries through innovation, new discoveries and so on.
- 20:51And that's where I think we have to focus. The persecuted economies had their golden era. It's
- 20:57over. They must now look at chips or satellites or you know what other industries there are in
- 21:04which they can excel. They can't excel any longer in the old industries. So coming to So What? How
- 21:13serious is this in the picture? The closing down of the Arcelor Mittal long steel business?
- 21:20Not as serious as the media for all rate suggested. First of all, Kobus Verster, the
- 21:27chief executive of AMSA, he himself has said that once they've closed down the long steel business,
- 21:33they can actually have a very flourishing flat steel business. So that's there. We know that on
- 21:38the long steel side, 50% of the product currently in the country is being supplied by minimal. So
- 21:45it's there. Thirdly, we know that there are strong imports and that we can import more from whatever
- 21:51we need from overseas countries. So I don't buy the narrative at all that the entire steel industry
- 21:58will now collapse. And with that, the further argument that manufacturing will collapse.
- 22:02I mean, for example, the automobile components industry, they lamenting and shouting and screaming
- 22:10and so on. But they also said the closure of Newcastle, if it can be postponed for 12 months,
- 22:15then minimals can be certified by the auto manufacturers for having the quality
- 22:22and the standard needed for the motor car industry. So that's a period of transition.
- 22:26You upgrade yourself if you're a minimal, put in whatever the auto
- 22:30makers want and lifeguard is on. Now, I think it's part and parcel of life where old industries die
- 22:36out and you adjust to new ones. Think of gold mining. There was a time when South Africa was the
- 22:41biggest gold producer in the world. Today, we don't really feature. Why? Well, because all the gold's
- 22:46been taken out. Industries arise, industries die. The question is, how do you adapt?
- 22:52And for you, you don't normally really put forward your opinion. You don't really
- 22:58put forward your opinion, but you do this time. What is for you the so what when it comes to public
- 23:04policy? No, I think we should focus on those. We should have an industrial policy. That's number
- 23:10one, not one based on subsidies and protection, but one based on developing new industries where
- 23:16we've got a competitive advantage. Now, I mentioned, for example, green energy. We are abundantly
- 23:25blessed with solar and wind resources. We can use that to build a green energy industry. We can
- 23:32build hydrogen, for example, tourism. We are abundantly blessed with tourism assets. With that
- 23:38comes conservation. So those are areas where we've got a competitive advantage. Then there are areas
- 23:44where the capabilities of the nation enable us to compete. For example, hospitality and personal
- 23:51services. Think of hospitals. People will tell you that the treatment they get in hospitals here are
- 23:57better than what they get in many European countries. So focus on that. Enable that kind
- 24:01of industry to grow and to expand and employ more people. Then there's arts and culture. I don't
- 24:08have to tell you about the success of something like Jerusalem and other South African artists.
- 24:13So instead of thinking just in terms of smokestack factories, think of these new industries that we
- 24:20have, which we can expand. Lastly, take agriculture. We've got a highly, highly successful
- 24:26agricultural industry. So if you're successful in agriculture, think of what is just next to it.
- 24:32Agro-processing. What can we agro-process where we have the competitive advantage that we can
- 24:38compete in the world? So that, I think, is the approach one must take. Is not to defend the old,
- 24:44but to develop the new and from there get economic development. Thank you for listening to the So What
- 24:52podcast. If you enjoy this content, please don't forget to leave a review and a rating,
- 24:57and please consider subscribing so you don't miss any future episodes. Also, tell your friends.
- 25:03Remember, you can find a written version of all JP's content at jplandman.co.za.