Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Law of Reciprocity Backfires in Office Politics
Transcript
- Lucas: You know the old rule — give before you ask. Build a bank of goodwill, then make a withdrawal when you need it. Luna: Right, the reciprocity principle. Classic influence tactic. Lucas: Except sometimes that bank turns into a debt ledger — and people start avoiding you because they feel they owe you. I've seen it happen. There's a real case from a Fortune 500 retailer, a marketing manager named Sarah who was the most helpful person in her division. She'd stay late to review decks, share her vendor contacts, even cover for colleagues on weekends. Luna: And that made her popular, right? Or did it backfire? Lucas: Initially it made her indispensable. But after about six months, she noticed people stopped asking for her help. They'd go to other teams, even less qualified people. She felt frozen out. Luna: That's the opposite of what you'd expect. What happened? Lucas: She'd over-given. Psychologists call it 'indebtedness aversion' — the discomfort of owing someone. When the debt gets too large, the easiest way to discharge it is to avoid the creditor. Luna: So people weren't ungrateful — they were uncomfortable. Lucas: Exactly. A 2023 study in Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes found that about 40 percent of employees reported feeling manipulated by unsolicited favors. The recipients felt the giver had an agenda, even when the giver was sincere. Luna: That's a huge number. So generosity can actually damage trust. Lucas: It can, yes, if it's not handled carefully. The classic reciprocity principle says that when someone gives you something, you feel obligated to return it. But that works best when the favor is requested, or at least clearly needed. Unsolicited favors create a one-sided ledger. Luna: I'm thinking of the times I've given help without being asked — maybe I was trying to build goodwill, but I might have been making people uncomfortable. Lucas: If today was actually useful to you, the way these stay ad-free is listener support. You can buy me a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That small gesture helps keep the episodes coming, no obligations. Luna: Yeah, it's a nice way to say 'this was worth my time' without the debt feeling we just talked about. No strings. Lucas: So back to Sarah. She fixed the problem by changing how she gave. She started asking 'Would it be helpful if I reviewed your deck?' instead of just doing it. That small shift — getting consent — removed the indebtedness because the recipient had a choice. Luna: So the favor becomes a transaction they agreed to, not a debt imposed on them. Lucas: Right. Research by organizational psychologist Adam Grant shows that 'givers' who succeed long-term are what he calls 'otherish' — they give strategically, not indiscriminately. They protect their own time and they make sure the giving is aligned with a real need. Luna: What about scale? Is there a rule of thumb for how much to give? Lucas: The best advice I've heard is to keep favors small, reversible, and non-recurring. A small favor — like a quick introduction or a five-minute edit — creates a light obligation that's easy to repay. A big favor — like covering a whole project — creates a heavy burden. And if you keep giving the same favor repeatedly, it becomes expected, not appreciated. Luna: And once it's expected, you lose the power of reciprocity altogether. Lucas: Exactly. Sarah learned to limit each favor to something that cost her less than thirty minutes. That way, the debt was small and her colleagues could reciprocate with something equally small — a coffee, a kind word, a shared credit. Luna: That also prevents the giver from burning out. Lucas: Big time. Another mistake people make is keeping score. If you mentally track who owes you, it shows. Recipients can sense the implicit ledger, and it makes the relationship transactional. The best givers genuinely forget what they gave — or at least act like they do. Luna: But isn't the whole point of reciprocity that the favor gets returned? Lucas: It is, but if you force the return, you destroy the goodwill. The most effective reciprocity is spontaneous. You give without expectation, and the other person returns when they feel ready. If they never do, that's a signal about the relationship — maybe they're not someone you should keep investing in. Luna: So it's as much a diagnostic tool as an influence strategy. Lucas: Exactly. Use small, consensual favors to test the relationship. If you give and they reciprocate, you've built mutual trust. If they don't, you know where you stand without having lost much. Luna: And if they start avoiding you, like Sarah's colleagues, you've probably over-given. Lucas: Right. Indebtedness aversion kicks in strongest when the favor is large, unsolicited, and personal. Sarah was doing favors that involved her personal time and expertise. That felt more like a gift than a transaction, and gifts create the most uncomfortable debts. Luna: What about giving in a team setting? Does it play out differently? Lucas: It can. In a team, reciprocity can be more diffuse — you give to the group, and the group returns the favor indirectly. But the same rules apply. If you're the only one giving, you become the team's 'helper' and people may start taking you for granted. Luna: So the power move is to make the giving visible but not overwhelming. Lucas: Yes. And sometimes the best thing you can do is refuse a favor. If you say no to a small request, the other person's respect for you often increases because you're not a pushover. Then when you do say yes, the favor is more meaningful. Luna: Scarcity increases value. That's basic economics. Lucas: And basic office politics. The takeaway from Sarah's story: give strategically, ask first, keep it small, and never keep score. That's how you build a network of genuine goodwill without creating silent debtors. Luna: It's counterintuitive — you'd think more giving is always better. But the best givers are also the best gatekeepers. Lucas: Exactly. And next time, we'll talk about how to ask for a favor without making the other person feel used. There's a whole art to that too. Luna: Looking forward to it.