Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage a Team Member Who Always Says Theyre Too Busy
Transcript
- Lucas: So you have a team member who says 'I'm too busy' to everything. New project? Too busy. Feedback conversation? Too busy. Career development chat? Too busy. And you're sitting there thinking — are they actually that overloaded, or is busy a shield? Luna: Right. And as a new manager, it's such a hard one to call, because you don't want to be the boss who dismisses someone's workload. Lucas: Exactly. So let's look at a real case. I was talking to a product director at a mid-sized SaaS company — about 300 employees. She had a product manager, let's call her Jen, who had been at the company for about three years. Jen was good at her job — she shipped features on time, she knew the product inside out. But every time the director tried to stretch her — say, 'Hey, could you lead the quarterly planning deck' — Jen would say 'I'd love to, but I'm just swamped right now.' Luna: Classic. And the director probably backed off, because Jen was delivering. Lucas: Exactly right. For months. The director would nod, say 'okay, let's revisit next quarter,' and nothing would change. But here's the thing — the director started noticing that Jen was actually saying yes to things she wanted to say yes to. She volunteered for a cross-team working group on the new pricing model. She took on a side project with engineering that she was excited about. So it wasn't that she had no capacity — it was that she was gatekeeping her time based on interest. Luna: Ah. So 'busy' wasn't the real issue. It was more about motivation or alignment. Lucas: Right. And that's the first trap managers fall into — we treat 'busy' as a factual statement about hours in the day, when it's often a statement about priorities. So the director tried a different approach. She scheduled a one-on-one with the explicit agenda of 'Let's look at your actual workload together.' Not accusatory — just 'Help me understand what's on your plate.' Luna: And what did Jen show her? Lucas: They literally printed out Jen's task list from Jira and her calendar for the last two weeks. And what they found was revealing. Jen had about 30 hours a week of meetings and direct product work. The rest was fragmented — bits of Slack, ad hoc requests, context-switching. But there were also real gaps: two-hour blocks where nothing was scheduled. Jen was using those gaps to recover, not to take on more. So the director's first move was to help Jen protect those gaps as focused work time, and then say 'Okay, if we clear two hours a week from low-value meetings, does that open up space for the quarterly planning deck?' Luna: So she made it concrete. Not 'are you busy?' but 'let's find the time together.' Lucas: Exactly. And that's step one: audit the workload, not the excuse. But here's where it gets more interesting. Because even after they carved out the time, Jen was still hesitant. She said 'Well, I'm not sure I'm the best person for the deck — maybe Sarah should do it.' That's when the director realized this was also about confidence and perhaps a bit of avoidance. Jen was comfortable in her existing responsibilities, and the quarterly planning deck was visible, high-stakes, and involved presenting to the C-suite. Luna: So the 'too busy' was a cover for 'I'm nervous about this.' Lucas: Yes. And this is the second layer. Once you've addressed the capacity question, you have to ask yourself — is this a willingness problem? And willingness can mean a few things: maybe they don't see the value, maybe they're afraid of failing, maybe they're protecting their current identity as the person who does X, not Y. The director asked Jen directly, gently: 'I'm hearing some hesitation beyond the time. What feels risky about taking this on?' Luna: And Jen actually told her? Lucas: She did. She said 'I've never done a deck for the CEO before. What if I miss something and it looks bad?' And just naming that aloud made it manageable. The director offered to pair her with someone who had done it before, and set up a review checkpoint before the actual presentation. Once the fear was addressed, Jen took it on. And she did great, by the way. Luna: So the framework is: first check if it's a real capacity issue, then check if it's a willingness or confidence issue. But what about the manager's own behavior? I feel like sometimes we enable the 'too busy' excuse because we're afraid to push. Lucas: Absolutely. And this is the third step — the manager's own anxiety. If you're a new manager, you might worry that pushing someone who says they're busy makes you the bad guy. You might fear that they'll quit or resent you. So you accept the excuse because it's easier. But that creates a dynamic where the employee learns that 'busy' is an off-ramp from any conversation they don't want to have. The director told me she had to coach herself to stay curious instead of backing down. She'd say 'I hear you're busy. Let's look at the calendar together for five minutes.' That's a script anyone can use. Luna: I love that. It's not confrontational — it's collaborative. And it also surfaces whether the person is actually willing to be transparent about their time. Lucas: Right. If they resist even looking at the calendar together, that's a red flag. It suggests they know the 'busy' claim won't hold up under scrutiny. Then you have a different conversation — more about trust and transparency. But in most cases, people genuinely feel overwhelmed, and they need help prioritizing. One thing the director also did was help Jen rank her current projects by impact. They used a simple matrix: high impact / low effort, high impact / high effort, etc. And they found that Jen was spending 40% of her time on a low-impact project that was just easy and familiar. Once they deprioritized that, she had room for the strategic work. Luna: So the 'too busy' person might actually need help seeing the big picture — they're so deep in the weeds they can't see what to cut. Lucas: Exactly. And as a manager, that's your job. Not to magically give them more hours, but to help them see which hours matter most. So let's recap the three-step playbook. Step one: audit the workload. Don't accept 'busy' as a fact — look at the actual calendar and task list. Step two: explore willingness. Ask what feels risky or uncomfortable about the new task. Step three: examine your own reluctance as a manager. Are you avoiding the conversation because it's uncomfortable? If so, name it and move through it. Luna: And the fourth step might be: reconsider if the person is in the right role. If someone consistently says 'too busy' to the core responsibilities of the job, that's a different problem. Lucas: That's a great point. In Jen's case, she was in the right role — she just needed a nudge and some structure. But if an employee is always too busy for the work that matters most, they may be misaligned with the role entirely. And that's a harder conversation, but a necessary one. For today though, the takeaway is: don't let 'busy' end the conversation. Treat it as the start. Luna: Before we wrap up, I want to say something. You know, we do this show every week, and we don't run ads. We keep it ad-free because we want it to be genuinely useful, not interrupted by sponsors. But that only works if people who find value in it decide to support it. Lucas: Yeah, and we've heard from so many of you that these episodes have helped you navigate real situations at work. If today's episode — or any episode — was worth a coffee to you, that's literally the link: buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's the smallest way to keep this going. Luna: And we really appreciate it. Okay, back to Jen — one thing I loved was how the director framed it: 'I'm not trying to overload you, I'm trying to make sure your best work gets seen.' That reframes the whole thing. Lucas: That's a beautiful reframe. Because the employee often doesn't realize that by hiding behind 'busy,' they're also hiding their potential. So as a manager, you're not just pushing work — you're pulling their talent into the light. That's the real job. Luna: And maybe you're also teaching them a skill: how to say no to the right things, so they can say yes to the right things. Lucas: Exactly. So next time a team member says 'I'm too busy,' try the calendar audit, ask about the reluctance, check your own fears — and see what emerges. You might find it's not about time at all. Luna: Thanks for listening, everyone. We'll see you next week. Lucas: Take care.