Latest / The Talent Trade / Being Yourself, FAST
Transcript
- 0:00Stephanie Maas: Hi, and welcome to The Talent Trade. I'm
- 0:03Stephanie Maas, partner with ThinkingAhead executive search.
- 0:07Today I am super excited to bring to the talent trade a
- 0:12guest. Today's guest has one of probably, I think one of the
- 0:17most non traditional backgrounds before joining the world of
- 0:22recruiting, which I will let him share with us. And then also
- 0:26from a topic perspective, he is going to share with us a little
- 0:30bit about the value of being yourself as soon as possible
- 0:33when you start out in executive search. So before I bring him on
- 0:37a couple of fun little nuggets that you should know, Jonathan
- 0:40has been with our firm seven years, one of my favorite
- 0:44stories about Jonathan, because we went through training, and
- 0:47after gosh, probably about six months, he came to me and said,
- 0:50hey, you know, I really promise I was paying attention. I was in
- 0:54tune to your training. But I just need some clarity about the
- 0:57timing behind this marketing plan that we had put together.
- 1:01Because Jonathan, he was so incredibly teachable, he was
- 1:04executing our drip marketing plan incredibly well, with one
- 1:08exception, the exception that he missed was the timing. So this
- 1:12is a seven step drip marketing plan that when executed
- 1:16accordingly, should happen over about a four month period with
- 1:20Jonathan and his eagerness to get things rolling. He was doing
- 1:24it over the course of about seven days. So he'd gotten a
- 1:26little feedback from the market that it was a smidge much. So he
- 1:31came back and said, I don't think this was a response we're
- 1:34going for anyway, I really appreciate his humility in
- 1:38approaching and asking what he was doing wrong. But I also
- 1:41really the enthusiasm to which he wanted to get started and do
- 1:44things the right way speaks a lot to his character while at
- 1:48thinking ahead. So without further ado, I'd like to welcome
- 1:52Jonathan McIntosh. Welcome to The Talent Trade.
- 1:55Jonathan McIntosh: Thank you, Stephanie. Great to be here.
- 1:56Stephanie Maas: So I alluded to this interesting background that
- 2:00you had, I would love to hear just a little bit of your story
- 2:03how you found your way to thinking ahead.
- 2:06Jonathan McIntosh: I actually responded to I remember now and
- 2:09indeed posting I had been in professional ministry for 20
- 2:14years. That's all I knew. I didn't know the world of sales
- 2:18at all. I didn't even know there was such a thing as a
- 2:20headhunter. I needed to make a midlife career change. And I'm,
- 2:24I'm living proof that you can do that even at 3035 4045 5055. And
- 2:30a friend said, Hey, have you ever considered becoming a
- 2:32headhunter? And I didn't even know what that was. And I said,
- 2:35people get paid to help make connections professionally for
- 2:38people. She said, Yes, I think you'd be good at it, or
- 2:40responded to an ad in indeed, for a nonprofit headhunter. And
- 2:43because I knew the world loosely of nonprofits having worked in
- 2:46ministry for 20 years, I felt like it'd be a good fit. And
- 2:49thankfully, thinking ahead, belts think it would be a good
- 2:52fit to so I'm very grateful to have, as I say, washed up on the
- 2:55kind shores of thinking ahead executive search.
- 2:59Stephanie Maas: Well tell us a little bit about the niche that
- 3:01you serve now.
- 3:02Jonathan McIntosh: So we have a boutique team under 10
- 3:05recruiters at any point in time, that works solely with nonprofit
- 3:08organizations across the country, Health and Human
- 3:12Services, environmental conservation, the performing
- 3:15arts culture museums, we do it all primarily director level and
- 3:18above primarily C suite roles. Now I'm going to be speaking to
- 3:22areas of success I see across different niches and thinking
- 3:26ahead, but really what I know most are most well as the
- 3:30nonprofit industry.
- 3:31Stephanie Maas: Okay, so Jonathan is a partner with
- 3:34thinking ahead consistently, one of our top performers, what has
- 3:37been your best year to date billings wise?
- 3:40Jonathan McIntosh: 2022; somewhere between that and cash
- 3:45in half a million somewhere near there.
- 3:47Stephanie Maas: So for many of our listeners, the idea of being
- 3:50a consistent 350 to 550, a no revenue producer would create
- 3:55quite an incredible career and lifestyle. So we've got one live
- 3:59here. So Jonathan, again, the idea here is we could talk about
- 4:03a lot of the different things that have made you successful,
- 4:06but there's one in particular you brought to the table for our
- 4:08time today. And this was the idea of being yourself as
- 4:13quickly as possible. So put some legs under that table for us.
- 4:17Jonathan McIntosh: Yeah, thank you, Stephanie. Our trainings
- 4:20and thinking ahead, I think are excellent. And any new recruiter
- 4:24is going to come on to any new team. And they're going to have
- 4:26a book of scripts that we're always refining, and
- 4:30specializing for each practice and niche, but I like to remind
- 4:34recruiters early on that they're not robotic script machines,
- 4:38that they're a human being on a phone or a zoom call with
- 4:43another human being. And don't forget to be a human. And when I
- 4:46think about and I don't know if you've seen this in your niche,
- 4:49but when I think about the nonprofit team, there's a lot of
- 4:51churn and a lot of turnover through new hires, and you
- 4:54always want everyone to make it but not everyone makes it
- 4:57sometimes that's a that's a work effort issue. Sometimes that's a
- 5:00phone aversion issue. But I've seen often, people with the
- 5:05right work habits, they're making the number of dials every
- 5:10day that they should, but somehow they're not able to put
- 5:13it together. And I think they still, when it comes to making
- 5:17connections with people, whether that's a bizdev, or marketing
- 5:21approach, or if that's a candidate recruiting approach,
- 5:25they still are very bound by their scripts and don't know how
- 5:29to find clothes that fit, they don't know how to find language
- 5:33that feels like them. They don't know how to stop and recognize,
- 5:36hey, I'm actually talking to another human, I'm actually
- 5:39listening to another human and they're giving me wonderful
- 5:43things about their life that I should be curious about. And I'm
- 5:46just moving on to the next question here on my outline. So
- 5:49that's kind of the overall thing I if I can emphasize anything to
- 5:52new recruiters that thinking had or and I don't know how helpful
- 5:55this will be across the industry, it's a stop and be a
- 5:58human being on the phone.
- 6:00Stephanie Maas: Any backdrop that led you to this kind of
- 6:03realization? Or can you remember when this became your aha
- 6:06moment?
- 6:07Jonathan McIntosh: I think it started initially from I have
- 6:10ADD, and a lot of the high performers and thinking ahead,
- 6:14are very process driven. You are Stephanie, a lot of members of
- 6:18my own team that I respect the hell out of. For me, though, I
- 6:21needed to find my own voice, first and foremost, just so I
- 6:24wasn't bored all the time. Like, I'm literally leaving the same
- 6:28voicemail 30 times in one day, if that's my life, I want to
- 6:32kill myself. But if I can find my own way, if I can find my own
- 6:37voice, if I can make it unique, then it becomes fun, and it
- 6:40becomes a game. So that was kind of one Aha. Number two was after
- 6:44I'd had some success and hearing from people like, Hey, this is
- 6:48not like the standard recruiting call that I get, or hey, that
- 6:51wasn't like the standard cold call that I get. This felt real
- 6:55different, unique. Three, the third kind of aha, I was
- 7:00thinking about pattern interrupt, and we can talk about
- 7:02Pattern Interrupt in a minute. And then for it was watching
- 7:05people on my team, with great work habits, not put it together
- 7:11and not make it work. And we go on, they were doing all the
- 7:13right things that leadership was telling them to do. They went
- 7:16through the training, they had the scripts, why weren't they
- 7:18able to make it work in our business. So it was those kind
- 7:21of four pieces that came together.
- 7:23Stephanie Maas: So for you, and again, you came from a
- 7:25background where you know, public speaking, talking to
- 7:28folks, etc, that that came pretty natural. So when you
- 7:31joined thinking ahead, you talk about hey, I had to find my own
- 7:35voice. And yet you still talk about using scripts. So how did
- 7:38you mesh those worlds together? I think that's something that
- 7:42for a lot of our listeners, that is the challenge is, hey, I know
- 7:45I need to be scripted. But I also need to use my own
- 7:48language. I need to be professional, but I want people
- 7:51to see me as a human. Talk to me about your journey with that.
- 7:54Jonathan McIntosh: That is such a delicate balance. And that's
- 7:56one reason that this job requires such high emotional
- 7:59intelligence, EQ. And I think about the the high performers in
- 8:03any team, I think an ad they're off the charts when it comes to
- 8:05emotional intelligence, because you're reading the person on the
- 8:09other end of the phone all the time, and you're making
- 8:12adjustments. As I think about scripts, to me a script is a
- 8:15recipe. And if you've cooked or if you've made cocktails, you
- 8:19need to stick to the recipe as closely as possible, until you
- 8:24start to learn the basics. Until you you really become
- 8:29proficient. For example, I had a friend once who said, Hey, I'm
- 8:32gonna, I'm going to start to make cocktails, I'm gonna buy
- 8:34some stuff and start to throw some stuff together. But he
- 8:37didn't know any of the classic recipes. And why citrus works
- 8:42with a bitter and you need a sweetening agent. And then you
- 8:45need a base spirit. He didn't know any of these classic
- 8:48combinations that bartenders for 150 years had been proving out.
- 8:54And so he was trying to break rules before he even knew the
- 8:57rules and why the rules worked. So yes, absolutely, to the new
- 9:01recruiter go by the scripts, that the people who have been
- 9:06successful in this business for 20 years are using, learn why
- 9:10they work, learn the basics, and that's the same thing with any
- 9:14cooking recipe. But then as you start to become proficient in
- 9:19the kitchen, you know why Saul, fat, eat and acid work together?
- 9:23And then you know how to adjust those dials. You can start to
- 9:27break the rules only after you learn why the rules work.
- 9:30Stephanie Maas: Super insightful. I have never heard
- 9:33it put that way. I love that scripture recipes. That's a
- 9:36great example. Talk to us a little bit about this idea of
- 9:39high emotional intelligence. Is it something that you have and
- 9:42develop? Can you be taught it?
- 9:44Jonathan McIntosh: I think it's both. I think at the end of the
- 9:47day, it is a trait that not everybody has. I think everybody
- 9:52can get it better. But we all have an indifferent amounts.
- 9:55There are these amazingly charismatic people rule that you
- 10:00just meet. And when you run into them like I want you in my life,
- 10:06your smile lights up whatever room that you're in, you make
- 10:09everyone feel like they are the most important person in the
- 10:13world. But you don't have to have that off the charts. This
- 10:17off the charts charisma in order to make it work in search. There
- 10:20are plenty of people that are just pay, I'm a good listener, I
- 10:23bring a lot of empathy to the table. I'm kind. And then I know
- 10:27my work. I work my routine. I work my my daily calls. But
- 10:31yeah, I think you can I think to answer your question more
- 10:34bluntly, I think you can we all can get better at emotional
- 10:37intelligence. I think that the entry point to that is
- 10:39listening. I think when I'm distracted, when I'm my mind is
- 10:43somewhere else. When I have another app pulled up. And I'm
- 10:47not fully invested in the call, I miss opportunities to
- 10:50interject to ask a clarifying question to double click on
- 10:54something to go tell me more about that.
- 10:56Stephanie Maas: And again, I like your phraseology here, you
- 10:58said you miss opportunities.
- 11:00Jonathan McIntosh: I think the key especially on the recruiting
- 11:02side, when we're talking about candidate recruiting calls, the
- 11:05key to being yourself, and sometimes you may need to go off
- 11:08script is when the person you're talking to on the other end of
- 11:12the line, this i This certainly works for marketing bizdev, as
- 11:14well gives you this wonderful, beautiful thing. They've
- 11:18entrusted you with something, they're opening up. They're
- 11:21divulging something either about themselves or about their
- 11:24company. And it's in a requires, it's asking of you a certain
- 11:28response to go, Wait a second, that's really curious. Wait a
- 11:33second, what did you mean by that? Wait a second, can we
- 11:36circle back do you mind, you just said something very, very
- 11:39interesting to me. And when we're in this call with a person
- 11:43is this almost sacred space, and you're navigating these very
- 11:47interesting waters, where you're talking to them about some of
- 11:51the most personal items in their lives, their interests, their
- 11:55passions, what they make on a yearly basis, what they think
- 11:59they should make, why they are undervalued in the market.
- 12:02Sometimes you're talking about racial dynamics, sometimes
- 12:06you're talking about office culture dynamics, sometimes
- 12:09you're you're working through the most difficult and painful
- 12:12things of their lives right now this toxic thing that I had to
- 12:14deal with at work, and should I leave? Should I be looking for
- 12:17something else, but I've given this company or this
- 12:19organization my entire life? And now I've got a boss that doesn't
- 12:22see my value? And what should I do in that situation? Jonathan,
- 12:26it's not like what we do is super difficult. I'm not trying
- 12:30to overinflate the recruiters role. But human beings are
- 12:33important, and their stories are important. And do we treat them
- 12:36as such?
- 12:37Stephanie Maas: Okay, so with that talk to me about this idea
- 12:39behind pattern interrupt.
- 12:42Jonathan McIntosh: The basics of pattern interrupt is, first of
- 12:44all, let's be honest, we are at least the way we set up our
- 12:47practice that thinking and we cold call people. And I think I
- 12:50believe in the cold call, I believe one. My opinion is no
- 12:54one loves making cold calls, and no one loves receiving a cold
- 12:57call. But I will tell you, some of my best clients, most of my
- 13:00best clients, and some really close friendships have come from
- 13:06a cold call, I believe in pushing through the fear. And
- 13:08there can be beauty on the other side. But as soon as someone
- 13:12picks up the phone, and they did not let it roll to voicemail,
- 13:16whether it's a bizdev or recruiting call, the very first
- 13:20thing they're thinking when they hear Jonathan McIntosh thinking
- 13:24I had executive searches, how the hell can I get off this
- 13:27call? As soon as possible? The only thing they're thinking is,
- 13:31gosh, this was not the number I thought it was right. Oh, I was
- 13:36expecting call from a donor colleague, friend, board member
- 13:39boss. I was not expecting a cold call today. And so you got to
- 13:44realize they're like a scared horse because they're just like,
- 13:48they're in their amygdala at that point in time. And all
- 13:51they're thinking is, how do Why hang up and not seem like an a
- 13:56hole right now? And you've got to come in and be like, sheesh,
- 14:00it's okay. It's gonna be alright, we're gonna get through
- 14:03this together. Let me just calm you down for one second. I'm not
- 14:07a salesperson. I'm not here to try to sell you something. I'm
- 14:11not really right now trying to even recruit you for anything.
- 14:14You can tell me to go pound sand anytime you want. Can I just
- 14:19tell you why I'm reaching out today. And generally people are
- 14:22like, okay, I can listen, you sound like a human being. You
- 14:27sound like you know that this is potentially awkward for me to
- 14:31calm people down bringing them out of their amygdala so they
- 14:33can pause long enough to actually hear what you're
- 14:36saying. Because all they want to do is go nope, not for me. Nope,
- 14:40not at this time. Note. We don't hire recruiters. No, I'm not
- 14:44looking right. And so pattern interrupt is any way that you
- 14:48can kind of stop that. Hey, I'm a recruiter. No thanks. Click.
- 14:51That's the pattern. How do you interrupt?
- 14:53Stephanie Maas: Okay, so show us how you do it. What do you say?
- 14:56Jonathan McIntosh: I had someone that we're potentially
- 14:58recruiting to our team A nonprofit shout me the other
- 15:01day. And I was expecting to leave a voicemail because I just
- 15:04wanted to show like, hey, it's easy. You just leave these
- 15:06voicemails let me show you. And the person picked up the phone.
- 15:10And it was a surprise to me. I was not call I was planning on
- 15:13making that day, I was making it just to literally show someone
- 15:16in an interview setting how we do it. And I found myself saying
- 15:19Jonathan McIntosh thinking I had executive search, I could hear
- 15:23you know, you could sense these things like you can feel someone
- 15:26tensing up over the phone, and I said, Look, I'm not trying to
- 15:28sell you anything. In fact, I'm going to tell you, I'm calling
- 15:31if that's okay. And you can tell me afterwards to go pound sand
- 15:34if you like, is that okay? And she laughed. He said, Yeah, I
- 15:37said, I'm gonna I'm gonna Headhunter This is a cold. So
- 15:40I'll say that, like, I'm a headhunter. This is a cold call,
- 15:42no one likes to get these. But here we are. But my point is,
- 15:45don't take my phraseology, experiment with what sounds good
- 15:50coming out of your mouth. Once again, be yourself on the phone,
- 15:54I'm not going to apologize for making a cold call. In fact,
- 15:58sometimes I will say, I'm sorry, I'm just now reaching out to
- 16:02you, man, we've been in the same circles for five years. And I've
- 16:06never called you, I'm sorry, I don't apologize for it's taken
- 16:09me this long to call you. But however, in your voicemail, feel
- 16:13free to be just a little bit weird. I'm not saying be
- 16:17completely off the charts goofy, and unprofessional. But at the
- 16:21same time you're talking to a human being, maybe they're at
- 16:24home, wearing something professional of top in their
- 16:28underwear, and they're about to jump to a zoom call, you can
- 16:32acknowledge just kind of the craziness that just is all of
- 16:36this, like everyone is just playing pretend and anything
- 16:39they do. And just kind of take the mask off for a second. And
- 16:43let some of your your humaneness come through. I think that's
- 16:46attractive. I think that's what people respond to.
- 16:51Stephanie Maas: What do you think, causes people hesitation
- 16:54from being themselves getting to that point where they'll risk
- 16:59being goofy or a little weird? Or going off script a smidge?
- 17:04What's the mental hurdle there for folks?
- 17:08Jonathan McIntosh: That's a fantastic question. I think
- 17:10there's a handful of mental hurdles, at least for me, one,
- 17:13especially when I'm calling someone high up like a CEO of an
- 17:15organization, big nonprofit that I really respect, I want to
- 17:19appear buttoned up professional, I want them to respect me, a lot
- 17:24of that is on the ladder in my head. And the ladder is a phrase
- 17:28I got from some therapists one time, it's when you are in
- 17:30constant comparison, and ranking yourself and where you think you
- 17:34stand either above or below others based on wealth, social
- 17:40status. And so I can put myself mentally on the ladder below the
- 17:44CEOs. And so I've become either totally obsequious meaning like,
- 17:50whatever you want to become a Yes, man, or they become almost
- 17:53too cold, you do have to read people, that high EQ thing is
- 17:58you've got to be a bit of a social chameleon. So when I'm
- 18:00calling into the New York market, I know that most of
- 18:04those people that I'm reaching out to talk fast, don't have
- 18:08time for BS, and the moving really quickly. And my syrupy
- 18:12southern charm can be lost on them. So I can boom, get right
- 18:17down to business when necessary. And you're trying to like, hey,
- 18:20how much tolerance can't even tell this person has written
- 18:23for? So yeah, we want to look good. We want to look
- 18:26professional, we want to look buttoned up. Also, when you're
- 18:29New Earth is you want to do it, right. I mean, I go through most
- 18:32of my life, as far as work, parenting and marriage, how am I
- 18:35doing it right? Am I failing? Or not? How do I even know. And so
- 18:39the scripts and the familiarity feels good, because it provides
- 18:42us with a sense, like, Hey, I made my calls, and I did it on
- 18:45script. And I can check the box at the end of the day, and
- 18:48that's fine. But I think if you want to grow your billings, and
- 18:51you really want to make a memorable impression in the
- 18:53markets, it's not did I make my calls ended up follow the
- 18:57script, it's to make a meaningful connection today.
- 19:00Stephanie Maas: Correct me if I'm wrong, a lot of what I'm
- 19:02hearing is, hey, in the beginning, get your recipe and
- 19:05thinking ahead, we give it to you, hey, this is what it's
- 19:07gonna take from a work perspective to be successful.
- 19:09Put the work in, and then as you do the work and start applying
- 19:14these things, again, the best chefs in the world, they all
- 19:17have something unique. They make the same dish. What makes their
- 19:21dish outstanding, isn't that it tasted exactly like everybody
- 19:25else's. It's that they put their twist on it. If I hear you,
- 19:30right, that's where you go from connection to meaningful
- 19:34connection.
- 19:34Jonathan McIntosh: Yes, that's it, Stephanie. But that does
- 19:37take time. You can be patient with yourself and it takes lots
- 19:41of repetition. To go back to our our volume piece. You know,
- 19:44you've heard the story many times about the photography
- 19:48students, one group of students had to go out and by the end of
- 19:52the semester, produced 500 photographs, the others only had
- 19:55to produce one really high quality photograph, but the
- 19:59students who worried about volume You more than quality, by
- 20:02the last set of photographs are making, their quality was
- 20:06higher, your quality only gets better as you practice as you
- 20:10get into it. That's why what we say around here is, and I remind
- 20:14myself of this because I make bad bizdev and marketing calls
- 20:17all the time. They're awkward, they can't, I try to not make
- 20:21them awkward intentionally. But I mean, I remember the first
- 20:25marketing call I made to someone in the nonprofit space in a, in
- 20:29a performing arts organization that I wanted to work with. I
- 20:33was nervously reading back my script and and I said, and give
- 20:36me a call and I read, I read the number aloud. And I was like,
- 20:40Oh, I'm sorry, that's your number that I just couldn't
- 20:44practice you. I am a professional, I promise. I will
- 20:47tell you later, I ended up placing that person at another
- 20:50organization. And I've worked with them since so it wasn't the
- 20:54end of the world. My point is a good marketing call is one that
- 20:58is made good marketing call is one that's made, it can be
- 21:02perfect. And over time, with volume, you get better and you
- 21:05learn to become yourself.
- 21:08Stephanie Maas: Any thing else from your perspective, tips,
- 21:11tricks of the trade, etc. that help you kind of push past the
- 21:15fear of not sounding professional. The concern of
- 21:19again, I love the latter reference, anything else that
- 21:22you would recommend to our listeners just to help bridge
- 21:24that gap from, you know, hey, we know you have these concerns,
- 21:27but just get there anyway or counsel on developing their
- 21:31emotional intelligence?
- 21:33Jonathan McIntosh: Well, once again, lots of fantastic
- 21:35recruiters that really do follow scripts really closely. And a
- 21:39lot of them bill a lot more than me. And they're, they're
- 21:41wonderful. I would ask them, when's the last time you you
- 21:44freshened up your scripts, because for me, it's like, hey,
- 21:47or do the words coming out of my mouth for me, they got to feel
- 21:50authentic. One of the best things I heard about sales early
- 21:52on is that it's this transference of energy. That's
- 21:56what's happening. It's more than the words being said, it's the
- 21:59feeling and the emotional freight and weight of that the
- 22:03energy that's coming through. That's why we are phone people
- 22:06more than than email people. Because you can have those,
- 22:09those that delicate interchanges of energy on the phone, so much
- 22:14better than you can be email, it's got to feel authentic. In
- 22:17order for me to feel like I'm actually doing something of
- 22:21good. And to leaving voicemails or making calls that matter.
- 22:24It's got to feel authentic. So when's the last time you freshen
- 22:26up your scripts? You know, one thing right now that we're doing
- 22:30our team, basically, we set dream target lists for
- 22:34marketing, our fantastic assistant put together
- 22:37basically, a vision board for each of us with these target
- 22:40organizations. And I've been leaving voicemails telling
- 22:43people at those organizations like, Hey, I just want you to
- 22:46know, I may not be on your dream list to work with, but you're on
- 22:49my dream list to work with. And, you know, that may not mean
- 22:52anything to you or not. But I'm gonna keep keep calling me
- 22:55because I really do want us to work together at some point in
- 22:58time
- 22:58Stephanie Maas: That is awesome. This has been incredibly
- 23:01insightful and helpful. And I think whether you're just
- 23:04starting out or if you've been in it for a while, again,
- 23:08whether your next level is just learning the practice or
- 23:12learning to get to the next level. I think this is some key
- 23:15information. So thank you so much for your willingness to
- 23:19share and bring us along on this idea of finding your way to
- 23:23being yourself and making meaningful connections.
- 23:26Jonathan McIntosh: Yeah, thank you, Stephanie. What an honor. I
- 23:27really am grateful to be here.