Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / The Murder That Started Rome’s 50-Year Free Fall
Transcript
- 0:00It is March in the year 235 AD We're on the banks of the Rhine
- 0:04River, near an outpost of Mogenatiom, what you and I would
- 0:08call Meintz Germany. The air is freezing, the ground
- 0:12is hard. And inside the imperial tent, a
- 0:14young man is crying in his mother's arms.
- 0:17His name is Severus Alexander. He is the emperor of Rome, and
- 0:22he's about to die. History often feels like a slow
- 0:25slide. We talk about declines as if
- 0:28they happen over centuries, invisible to people living
- 0:31through them. We think civilizations rot from
- 0:34the inside out, slowly, like wood and damp soil.
- 0:39But sometimes the rot explodes. Sometimes the end of an era
- 0:43doesn't take 100 years. Sometimes it takes a single
- 0:47morning. What happened outside that tent
- 0:49in 235 AD wasn't just a mutiny. It wasn't just an assassination,
- 0:55it was the trigger for the most terrifying period in western
- 0:59history, the Crisis of the 3rd century.
- 1:02For the next 50 years, Rome would not know peace.
- 1:06It would burn through 26 emperors.
- 1:09It would see its currency debased until the silver washed
- 1:12off the copper coins in your hand.
- 1:15It would see hyperinflation hit 15,000%.
- 1:19It would see the empire split into 3 rival states.
- 1:24It was a 50 year free fall into anarchy, 1/2 a century where
- 1:28civilization almost turned the lights out for good.
- 1:31And it all started because one leader, faced with a border
- 1:34crisis, tried to buy his way out of a problem he should have
- 1:38fought. Welcome to the Roman pattern.
- 1:59Welcome back to the Roman Pattern.
- 2:01I'm your host, Jeremy Ryan Slate, CEO of Commander Brand.
- 2:05We have our clients to appear on some of the biggest podcasts in
- 2:09the world. Check us out via the link in the
- 2:12description. And now our story.
- 2:15To understand the murder, you have to understand the victim.
- 2:20Severus Alexander was not a bad man.
- 2:22In fact, by the standards of the time, he was a decent 1.
- 2:26He was moderate, he respected the Senate.
- 2:29He wasn't a psychopath like Nero or a gladiator cosplayer like
- 2:34Commodus. But in the Roman pattern,
- 2:36decency is not a survival trait. Competences strength is.
- 2:42Severus had come to the throne at just thirteen years old.
- 2:45For his entire reign, the real power lay with his grandmother
- 2:49and after she passed, his mother, Julia Mamaya.
- 2:53Now, having a dominated mother isn't a crime, but when you are
- 2:57the commander in chief of the most lethal military on earth,
- 3:01perception is reality. Legions didn't see an emperor,
- 3:05they saw a mama's boy. Rome was a shark.
- 3:09It had to keep moving, keep conquering, or at least keep
- 3:12winning to survive. The soldiers respected strength
- 3:16above all else. They tolerated Severus because
- 3:19the pay was good and the borders were relatively quiet.
- 3:23Until they weren't. In the East, the Persian Empire
- 3:26was rising again, aggressive and organized, Severus went to fight
- 3:31them. The campaign was a mess.
- 3:35Not a total defeat, but hardly a triumph.
- 3:38He returned to Rome claiming victory, but knew the soldiers
- 3:42also knew the truth. They had bled for a stalemate.
- 3:46But the real threat wasn't in the desert.
- 3:48It was in the north. The Alimony, a confederation of
- 3:51Germanic tribes, had realized something terrifying.
- 3:55Rome was tired. They poured across the Rhine and
- 3:58the Danube, burning forts, sacking villages and threatening
- 4:02the very heart of the western provinces.
- 4:05This was the moment, the pattern moment.
- 4:08A civilization under pressure faces a binary choice.
- 4:13Do you project strength and enforce your borders, or do you
- 4:17try to manage the decline? Severus Alexander marched N to
- 4:21Magantiacom with the mighty Leggio 22 Primogenia.
- 4:26The legionaries were sharpening their swords.
- 4:29They were ready for payback. They wanted to cross the river
- 4:32and burn the alimony heartland. They wanted blood.
- 4:36But Severus Alexander, well, he looked at the logistics, he
- 4:41looked at the cost of war, and he made a fatal calculation.
- 4:45Severus decided that war was too expensive.
- 4:48Why risk the legions? Why risk a defeat?
- 4:52He opened diplomatic channels with the barbarian chiefs.
- 4:55He offered them gold, lots of it.
- 4:58He essentially offered to pay them to go away.
- 5:01In a modern diplomat, this might sound like de escalation.
- 5:05It sounds like smart power. Why fight when you can pay?
- 5:09But to the Roman soldier, to the men of the 22nd legion who had
- 5:14seen their families threatened by these tribes, this wasn't
- 5:17diplomacy. This was treason.
- 5:20You have to understand the psychology of the Roman legions.
- 5:24They were the engine of the state.
- 5:26They believed in the Invicta, the unconquered Rome.
- 5:30When they saw their emperor handing over Roman gold, gold
- 5:33that should have been their pay, their bonuses to the very
- 5:37savages who have been burning Roman farms, well something
- 5:41snapped. They looked at Severus and they
- 5:43didn't see a God Emperor. They saw a weakling paying
- 5:47protection money, and in the background a giant was watching.
- 5:51His name was Gaius Julius Varus Maximinus, but history knows him
- 5:56as Maximinus Thrax. If Severus Alexander was the
- 6:00establishment soft, educated elite, Maximinus was raw,
- 6:05brutal, and the reality of the frontier.
- 6:08He was a Thracian peasant. He had risen from the absolute
- 6:11bottom ranks purely on his ability to inflict violence.
- 6:16Ancient sources claim he was over 8 feet tall.
- 6:19This is likely an exaggeration, but it tells you how people saw
- 6:23him as a monster of a man, a force of nature.
- 6:27The soldiers looked at Severus cowering his tent with his
- 6:30checkbook. Then they looked at Maximinus,
- 6:33who's wearing the same armor. They were eating the same bad
- 6:37food and hated the barbarian insults just as much as they
- 6:41did. The choice was easy.
- 6:43On roughly March 18th or 19th, the troops of the 22nd Legion
- 6:47stopped taking orders. They marched to the parade
- 6:50ground. They threw off their allegiance
- 6:52to the Emperor and hailed Maximinus as Augustus.
- 6:57Maximinus. The peasant giant accepted the
- 7:00purple cloak, and then he gave the order.
- 7:03The end was pathetic. When the soldiers surrounded the
- 7:07imperial tent, Severus didn't fight.
- 7:10He reportedly clung to his mother, weeping and blaming her
- 7:13for the decision to pay off the Germans.
- 7:16It was her idea, he cried. The soldiers didn't care whose
- 7:20idea it was. They butchered them both, mother
- 7:24and son, and cut them down in the mud of a foreign camp.
- 7:28At that moment, the soldiers cheered.
- 7:30They replaced a weakling with a warrior.
- 7:33They got what they wanted. Maximinus immediately crossed
- 7:37the Rhine and slaughtered the alimony.
- 7:40He restored Roman pride, but they had opened a door that they
- 7:43could not close by murdering A lawful emperor simply because
- 7:48they didn't like his policy. They established a new
- 7:51precedent. The emperor is not chosen by the
- 7:53Senate. He is not chosen by the gods.
- 7:57He's chosen by the army. If the army can make an emperor,
- 8:01the army can unmake him. This was the spark for the
- 8:04crisis of the 3rd century. Over the next 50 years, the
- 8:08Roman Empire tore itself apart. Maximinus lasted 3 years before
- 8:13his own troops killed him. The next guy, well, he lasted
- 8:16months. In the year 238 alone, there
- 8:19were six different emperors. Every general in the frontier
- 8:23looked at Maximinas and thought, if that peasant can do it, why
- 8:27can't I? Civil war became the permanent
- 8:30state of the empire, and civil war is expensive.
- 8:34To pay for these constant wars, to buy the loyalty of the
- 8:37troops, each new emperor did the only thing that they could think
- 8:40of. They debased the currency under
- 8:43Severus Alexander. The gold coin, the antoninianus,
- 8:47was about 50% pure. It was real money.
- 8:50By the time the crisis ended 50 years later, that coin was 5%
- 8:55silver. It was a copper slug dipped in a
- 8:57silver wash. Imagine your savings account
- 9:00losing 95% of its value in a generation.
- 9:04Prices in Egypt, Rome's bread basket, went vertical.
- 9:08We have records of wheat prices skyrocketing by the year 284.
- 9:13We are looking at inflation calculations hitting 15,000%
- 9:17compared to the start of the century.
- 9:19The economy ceased to function. People stopped using money and
- 9:23went back to barter. The complex trade networks that
- 9:26bought pottery from Gaul to Syria or oil from Spain to
- 9:31Britain, well, they collapsed. Rome became a collection of
- 9:34walled cities. Afraid of the dark, afraid of
- 9:37the roads, afraid of their own armies, The empire literally
- 9:41broke into three pieces. It took the superhuman efforts
- 9:45of Aurelian, the restorer of the world, to stitch it back
- 9:49together. But the Rome that survived the
- 9:50Crisis of the 3rd century was not the Rome that entered it.
- 9:54The optimism was gone. The civilian government was
- 9:58dead. Rome was now a military
- 10:00dictatorship, forever looking over its shoulder, forever
- 10:04waiting for the next general to March on the capital.
- 10:07So why does the murder of a 26 year old man in a tent in
- 10:11Germany matter to you today? Because the Roman pattern is
- 10:14clear. Severus Alexander tried to solve
- 10:17a hard reality, a border crisis, with soft solutions.
- 10:21He thought money could be a substitute for strength.
- 10:24He thought he could pay the Barbarians to be nice.
- 10:27Well, he was wrong. Weakness is provocative.
- 10:31But the reaction to his weakness, the embrace of the
- 10:34strong man, the rejection of the rule of law in favor of raw
- 10:38force, was indefinitely worse. We live in a time of currency
- 10:42and stability. We live in a time where borders
- 10:44are suggestions rather than lines on a map.
- 10:47We live in a time where the political center is seen as weak
- 10:51and the fringes are sharpening their knives.
- 10:54The crisis of the 3rd century teaches us that civilizations
- 10:58are fragile. It takes centuries to build the
- 11:00trust, the trade, and the currency that makes a society
- 11:04work. But it only takes 1 morning, 1
- 11:07bad decision, and one sharpened blade to bring it all crashing
- 11:12down. Rome survived the freefall, but
- 11:14it never fully recovered its soul.
- 11:17The question is, when our freefall starts, will we even
- 11:21notice the moment that the knife goes in?
- 11:24This has been the Roman pattern. I am Jeremy Ryan Slate.
- 11:27Remember to like this video, leave us a comment, and smash
- 11:30that subscribe button if you want more of the Roman pattern.