Latest / Cables2Clouds / When AI Deletes Production: Guardrails, MCP Risks, And The Surveillance Creep
Transcript
- 0:13Tim: Hello and welcome to another monthly episode of the Cables to Clouds newscast.
- 0:18Tim: And right on time, my cat is on is is here.
- 0:21Tim: She's here right on time.
- 0:22Tim: I told you this was gonna happen.
- 0:24Tim: She's very good at this.
- 0:26Tim: Um anyway, I'm your uh host uh Tim for this week.
- 0:30Tim: Chris is nowhere to be found.
- 0:32Tim: He's busy doing Chris things, and so I was uh we have our good friend, both of ours actually good friend Katherine McNamara, who's joined us to do the news with us, and uh maybe more.
- 0:44Tim: So um, Catherine, hello.
- 0:47Tim: How you doing?
- 0:48Tim: Hey, nice to see you guys.
- 0:49Tim: Excellent.
- 0:50Tim: And your cat.
- 0:51Tim: Yeah.
- 0:52Tim: Don't worry.
- 0:53Katherine McNamara: By the end of this episode, mine will will uh come uh dancing around as well.
- 0:57Tim: Well, she's yeah, I see Luna in the background there, so yeah, Zelda's she literally waited until I hit the record button and then jumped up here.
- 1:04Tim: Anyway, uh okay, so let's jump right into the news.
- 1:08Tim: So we have some fun, we have some really interesting and some very fun episode uh um articles for us tonight, and Catherine's gonna help us go through them.
- 1:16Tim: So I'm gonna start off with uh one that probably has been everybody's probably heard about this by now, but just in case, Amazon has had a second uh sorry, Amazon, AWS has had a second outage now caused by Kiro, their um their kind of code coding agent thing.
- 1:34Tim: And what's interesting about this is this is now the second time that Kiro has essentially brought everything down by deleting deleting an environment and rebuilding it, deciding that that was the best way to solve the problem that that it was tasked with.
- 1:48Tim: But what I find particularly interesting about this time is that now remember that Kiro is a uh a product, right?
- 1:56Tim: So so AWS is selling this product, this Kiro product to its customers is like, hey, you can use this for your production, you know, uh systems and everything.
- 2:04Tim: So in order to basically solve the problem of how do I how do I give a uh an after-action report about this outage being caused by Kiro, but make sure that Kiro is not to blame, they've decided that what actually happened was that Kiro was given too much uh leeway, too many permissions to so so it was able it was able to do this deletion and recreation when it basically shouldn't have been able to.
- 2:27Tim: And that's not a problem with the AI, that's a problem with uh permissions.
- 2:31Tim: So nothing to see here, folks.
- 2:34Tim: Um I don't know.
- 2:35Tim: You you you took a look at this uh as well, uh Catherine, I think.
- 2:38Tim: What what what do you think of this ridiculous story?
- 2:41Katherine McNamara: Yeah, so I I think uh my understanding is basically the AI agent was like, I don't like this code, it's bad.
- 2:48Katherine McNamara: So it deleted it, it thought that the solution was let's just delete it all and we'll work on uh nuke it and work on it later or recreate.
- 2:55Katherine McNamara: And obviously uh it didn't bring the services right back up.
- 2:59Katherine McNamara: Um I know that a lot of companies right now, like Microsoft, AWS, like any major tech company is trying to look for a massive like use case and like you know, something that they can consumerize and sell uh for you know AI agents, uh AI in general.
- 3:17Katherine McNamara: Um but you know, in this case where you know you give it too much, you know, this is one of those cautionary tales where if you give it too much permissions and it's not perfect you know perfected or ready for prime time, these kind of things can happen.
- 3:30Katherine McNamara: And this isn't just the only time it happened specifically with this Ciro agent, it's the second time.
- 3:35Katherine McNamara: Um AWS is kind of that place where everyone's paying, you know, uh, you know, a large amount of money.
- 3:42Katherine McNamara: You know, they're they're paying paying for you know the five nines because it's you know having it on pr off-prem, it's supposed to be reliable, and then you get a third a 13-hour outage that's you know pretty damaging for the brand, but not only one outage, but two outages that were completely preventable.
- 3:59Katherine McNamara: Uh we always make a joke that it's always you know, these big outages for like a cloud provider, it's always DNS or uh or BGP.
- 4:06Katherine McNamara: This time around, it's I guess the the three we're gonna have to start looking for is is it AI, DNS, or BGP?
- 4:13Tim: AI has entered the chat.
- 4:14Tim: Yeah.
- 4:15Katherine McNamara: AI has entered the outage, uh outages, that's for sure.
- 4:19Katherine McNamara: I and that's not me to disparage all AIs um by any means, but you know, it it's costing a lot of money to uh and development to create these these tools.
- 4:29Katherine McNamara: And I think that right now we're trying to put the cart in front of the horse with like giving it so many responsibilities because we want like large all these large companies are trying to get some money back from these projects that they're doing.
- 4:41Katherine McNamara: I think it's amazing.
- 4:42Katherine McNamara: These tools are amazing, like Claude, Kiro, all that stuff.
- 4:46Katherine McNamara: But um, you know, I don't think it's it, you know, you know, it's one of those things where you can give it all all the permissions and give it the you know, take the wheel and drive yet.
- 4:55Katherine McNamara: It we're still far off from that, I think.
- 4:57Katherine McNamara: But we're getting there.
- 4:58Katherine McNamara: It just uh the these these kind of you know stories though remind us that you know we need to kind of ramp up into it.
- 5:04Katherine McNamara: We can't just give it full control yet.
- 5:07Tim: Yeah.
- 5:07Tim: Reminds me of the uh the ClaudeBot thing from the from our last episode, like this idea of taking an agent, giving it access to all of your life, like your calendar and your and all this other stuff, and then how it kind of went crazy and did things did all sorts of crazy stuff.
- 5:23Tim: But yeah, no, I couldn't agree more.
- 5:24Tim: The the whole giving AI too many permissions and then you know, shocker think bad things happen.
- 5:30Tim: Uh I think this one's particularly funny because again, this is a product.
- 5:34Tim: Now, I guess kudos to Amazon for eating their own dog food on this one.
- 5:38Tim: Um, but yeah, I couldn't agree more that it's it's not quite a prime time ready to be doing whatever they gave it to do.
- 5:46Katherine McNamara: So this kind of actually reminds me of another story that um I'm sorry if I'm gonna take this a little in a little bit of a different direction, but um, one that we just saw yesterday.
- 5:54Katherine McNamara: Uh it's very similar.
- 5:55Katherine McNamara: Like even smart people can fall and be susceptible to this.
- 5:58Katherine McNamara: So um the person who's uh the director of like uh in charge of Meta's AI safety uh recently gave access to ClaudeBot to her, you know, gave her uh her ClaudeBot full access to her mailbox.
- 6:12Katherine McNamara: And it was really it was advertised uh just yesterday that like it wiped her whole mailbox and you know completely without like she was like ClaudeBot, stop like the whole chat was like published.
- 6:22Katherine McNamara: And this is somebody who is entire like career is AI and AI safety and and putting guardrails, and even she was susceptible to you know giving too many permissions to an AI, uh, an AI uh essentially an AI uh uh agent, and then you know, fell victim to it very quickly.
- 6:41Tim: Yeah, I mean even the people that are are supposedly good at this or supposed to be responsible for this stuff can very quickly fall into the trap, right?
- 6:49Tim: Because uh I've noticed, you know, I've been using clawed code for something that I'm building for Cisco Live, and uh it's very easy after the first few successes that like, oh, it's doing what I want to do, and it's it's it's things are going well uh to let it kind of snowball.
- 7:06Tim: But yeah, these things can very, very quickly get away from you.
- 7:08Tim: So in the case of the case.
- 7:11Katherine McNamara: I mean, these are cautionary tales not to say don't use AI, but to understand that you should have guardrails and checks in place and pr you know permissions restricted to you know, essentially at least privilege, um, and always always be prepared for an AI failure or AI doing something that you don't expect and have a contingency plan in place.
- 7:34Tim: Um, one last thing before we move on, that what was particularly interesting about that one with the uh uh I for the meta uh safety person, you look at the chat, and in the chat apparently she actually said like look at my email and and well no, but even before that, she said like her instructions were look at my email and then let me know what you think should be you what you think you should be deleted, right?
- 7:58Tim: Don't delete the email, but like let me know.
- 8:00Tim: And it just still just like yeah, okay, delete it all, right?
- 8:05Tim: So even even the guardrails of just telling it what you want it to do may not be enough.
- 8:10Tim: So definitely you should be you should be treating data as uh a very uh ephemeral thing when you were we're dealing with AI.
- 8:18Katherine McNamara: So anyway, um okay, so let's uh and that's not to say that we won't get there at one point in the future.
- 8:23Katherine McNamara: We won't get there to the point where we will be able to trust these tools a little bit more.
- 8:29Katherine McNamara: But you know, I I think most of the security researchers out there and people in InfoSec in general are are quick to say don't don't you know ClaudeBot or any of these like age, you know, AGNI AI tools are great, but don't give it too many permissions.
- 8:44Katherine McNamara: Don't give it, you know, don't give it the full run of the house.
- 8:48Tim: Yep.
- 8:48Tim: Or Moltbot, I think it is now.
- 8:50Tim: Is it is it Multbot this year or is it?
- 8:52Tim: It's open claw now.
- 8:53Katherine McNamara: It's open claw.
- 8:53Tim: It's open flaw.
- 8:54Tim: Open claw, open flaw, something like that.
- 8:56Tim: Right.
- 8:58Tim: Yeah, yeah.
- 8:58Katherine McNamara: I'll just call it open flaw for now.
- 9:01Tim: Excellent.
- 9:01Tim: All right.
- 9:02Tim: Speaking of uh speaking of uh cybersec and uh you know other AI tools.
- 9:08Tim: I promise the whole show is not about this, but this just happens to go with it.
- 9:11Tim: Um so Cisco has kind of gone on uh recently weighed in on this thing about uh the AI's quote, what it's calling connective tissue, but we're really talking about like MCP model context protocol.
- 9:23Tim: And we've talked at at length on the show about MCP, you know, the S the S and MCP stands for security.
- 9:30Tim: Um it's interesting to see uh Cisco itself weigh in, and Cisco is a big pretty big proponent of you know the use of and and advancement of AI tooling, so uh, you know, around agentic ops and other stuff.
- 9:44Tim: So it's interesting to see that Cisco actually weighs in on this as Cisco saying basically, hey, MCP is vulnerable for many of the reasons we've speak spoken about on this uh show before, but it specifically uh you know points out that MCP is while it's become kind of a de facto standard, and this is now remember the MCP now is is being supplanted or at least not supplanted, sorry, it's the wrong word, it's being extended or or kind of like made to be more of a tooling now for agents, now that agentic is now the new darling of of of how we we do AI.
- 10:18Tim: Uh, but MCP is still there because it's there as a as a tool extension now for agents.
- 10:24Tim: So, but it's still MCP and it's still insecure, which is kind of the point that Cisco is making here, saying organizations should treat MCP servers, agent tools, context brokers, treat it just like you would with an API gateway or a database or or any other tool that you would be accessing.
- 10:41Tim: You know, hard figure out how you can harden it to the best of your knowledge.
- 10:45Tim: Um, I think so this is interesting because I wonder if MCP so MCP is a quote unquote standard.
- 10:51Tim: I mean it's it is a standard, I guess, but the security piece of it really hasn't been standardized or or even really pushed in.
- 10:57Tim: You know, we they have basic security like OAuth to, I think, or so just like really, really basic, almost.
- 11:03Katherine McNamara: Yeah, just getting the the front the authentication in the front door essentially.
- 11:07Tim: Exactly.
- 11:07Katherine McNamara: I I think the the other issue which uh uh as uh a pretty good uh like an awesome security researcher brought up on uh Twitter is the other issue is once you're fra passed the front door, which there's ways to social engineer o authentication out of you know like out of people or or servers, but you know, let's say even if it's a legitimate one, after it's past the front door, by default it has you know the the that connection has too many permissions and it's pretty much you've opened the whole house to them.
- 11:37Katherine McNamara: And so like there's not really a concept yet of like least privilege access when you're sharing via MCP.
- 11:43Katherine McNamara: Um eventually they will hopefully get there and be able to secure it a little bit more.
- 11:49Katherine McNamara: But as you said, it's there's kind of like you know, the industry is moving in other directions as well, like AGN, you know, AG AI and stuff.
- 11:57Katherine McNamara: So we will see, but like um, you know, it right now it's it's it's still uh it's a cool, you know, it's a cool concept, and I you know, I think that there are uses for it, but there's a lot that still needs to be worked out uh worked out and secured.
- 12:13Katherine McNamara: Um we're at this weird pivotal point in the in you know tech where the uh the protocols, the tools are advancing at a rate where security hasn't caught up yet for them.
- 12:27Katherine McNamara: Yep.
- 12:28Katherine McNamara: So we're like deploying this stuff.
- 12:30Katherine McNamara: Like I think when MCP first came out, like there was really no authentication, really.
- 12:34Katherine McNamara: It's like it was it was really easy to just bypass, but people are pushing it out so fast because it was the new hot thing.
- 12:40Katherine McNamara: Um same with OpenClaw.
- 12:41Katherine McNamara: Like OpenClaw still has a lot of like uh uh you know old BenClaw, mold bot clawed bot, whatever you you say, but like uh you know it it's a new hot thing, and people are like installing it root on their actual work computers and stuff.
- 12:54Tim: Um it's nuts.
- 12:56Katherine McNamara: But uh, you know, the security still hasn't caught up.
- 12:59Katherine McNamara: Like, you know, there's malicious skills that people can download off of these uh, you know, skills.sh, uh you know, uh and uh there's uh you know, like even OpenCloud itself, like if you don't lock it down, like you have to read a really thick security guide, like online security guide, to be able to like lock it down.
- 13:15Katherine McNamara: It's not security by default when most commercial products or enterprise products are are the exact opposite.
- 13:20Katherine McNamara: They're built for secure, you know, security defaults are to lock everything down first and then allow access to the code.
- 13:26Tim: And then allow a little bit at a time.
- 13:27Tim: As you can figure.
- 13:28Katherine McNamara: But what you know, a lot of these products are you know, as they're being code vibe-coded or or put out, they're not being put out by people who have security in mind or not or aren't really security-centered.
- 13:38Katherine McNamara: So we're having to go like they take off, these tools take off, and then we're running to catch up, like secure, you know, to secure them.
- 13:45Tim: Yeah, I mean, well, and with the you know, not to get too far off the MCP thing that this article's about, but because it is the same thing ultimately, which is you know, you're it's that it's it's the uh hardened outside Chewy Center, barely hardened outside, to be honest with you.
- 14:02Tim: You know, like everything MCP provides access to, or, or in this case, you know, agentic, like with uh Moltbot Claw Open Claw, whatever the hell they're calling it this week.
- 14:13Tim: Um, you know, the the whole thing's predicated on giving it making it maximally useful by and in order to do that, you have to give it pretty much all of your logins and all of your permissions and everything.
- 14:24Tim: And so API keys to everything.
- 14:27Tim: API API keys, right, exactly.
- 14:30Tim: Exactly.
- 14:32Katherine McNamara: Yeah, that's so there's a couple problems.
- 14:33Katherine McNamara: Obviously that one, it doesn't decrypt it doesn't encrypt it locally.
- 14:37Katherine McNamara: A lot of these tools, uh they um they also use you know potentially can use an exorbitant amount of tokens and stuff, uh just running through sit like all tasks through it.
- 14:47Katherine McNamara: Just yeah, there's a lot of little issues there.
- 14:49Katherine McNamara: Yeah.
- 14:50Tim: Absolutely.
- 14:51Tim: And and so these tools, like you said, they're they're they're I don't know, created however they're created at the end of the day, whether they're vibe coded or otherwise, they're being created in a way that maximizes utility but minimizes any kind of guardrail for the users of that product.
- 15:08Tim: Because and then, you know, oh well it's a it's a hobby product or it's a you know uh it's a ba basic uh you know sandbox type product, but then you got people out there not treating it like a sandbox.
- 15:19Tim: What what should have happened is that the all this stuff should have been sandboxed, you know.
- 15:23Tim: Hey, this works, it's great, it's a good proof of concept type of thing, you know, but instead people are just like rushing out and buying MacBooks and plugging all their all their accounts and API keys into it, you know what I mean?
- 15:34Katherine McNamara: Yeah, and but even like MCP, like people took off like running with it and like integrated with everything they could without really like before like even OAuth was like introduced, and uh you know, like s you know, people were like testing out like malicious MCP servers and able to connect them and do crazy stuff because there really wasn't like security in mind for like with the creation of the lateral authentication of any kind.
- 15:59Tim: Yeah.
- 15:59Katherine McNamara: Yeah, and once you have access, you have full access.
- 16:02Katherine McNamara: It's it didn't have any concept of least privilege access.
- 16:05Katherine McNamara: Once you're connected, you can start you know getting access to everything.
- 16:09Katherine McNamara: And that I mean that's the point of it, but at the same time, like you know, generally speaking, when you have data sharing or tools, you you try to lock it down, you know, as much as you can to provide least privilege access.
- 16:21Katherine McNamara: Again, goes back to our tools are f are are being thrown out so fast and and pushed so fast by the industry that security is running to catch up.
- 16:30Katherine McNamara: Yep.
- 16:31Katherine McNamara: And I'm glad that Cisco has like said something about like MCC CP servers and and uh and I think a lot of other security researchers have also spoken up about it, but people don't tend to listen sadly until uh all the big companies kind of shout out.
- 16:48Tim: Absolutely.
- 16:48Tim: Um and so one last thing on this on this specific article, uh they they basically and this is a great analogy, I think.
- 16:55Tim: They liken MCP to like a supply chain, like the supply chain attack that uh got solar winds, right?
- 17:02Tim: Because I mean MCP is kind of like a supply chain type of thing where it's you know it's not that necessarily the thing you're doing that's being uh that that ends up being exploited, it's the underlying packages and tooling and and whatnot.
- 17:18Tim: So it's a really good, I think it's a good analogy to say it's you know, MCP, this MC lack of security with MCP is similar to like the way that SolarWinds was exploited with uh with the their supply chain attack.
- 17:30Tim: So pretty cool.
- 17:31Tim: Uh we've got uh I've got one more and Catherine has a few, but uh this one's pretty much I think I only have two.
- 17:36Tim: Uh yeah, that's true.
- 17:37Tim: Well, we'll see.
- 17:38Tim: Well, actually, no, I've I've got three.
- 17:40Katherine McNamara: I've got like a like an ad hoc one that's not really a news on the news story, but it's kind of fun internet news.
- 17:46Tim: Yeah.
- 17:46Tim: Yes, okay.
- 17:48Tim: Uh okay, so this one is uh the government.
- 17:50Tim: So the govern the government now is using Grok, specifically the military is now using Grok, and they deployed it as a nutrition advisor like bot, I guess.
- 18:01Tim: And so I guess the idea is that if you're in the military, you can ask Grok questions about nutrition and it will give you answers.
- 18:08Tim: And it took exactly zero seconds for someone to just ruin the day for everybody, I guess, and just ask Grok uh, well, I I I'm an acetarian, I eat food by shoving food up like vegetables are good for this.
- 18:27Tim: And Grok just like completely went with the bit.
- 18:31Tim: Like it just no no questions asked.
- 18:33Tim: Uh, and it started giving advice on the best vegetables to um insert into your rectum.
- 18:39Tim: So obviously, I mean, I don't know if you would call this specifically uh a failure or an attack or anything like that on the part of AI, but I mean, come on, we're talking about like we're giving this to the official, you know, US military for the purposes of you would expect there to be a little bit of rapper around this thing, but there's absolutely not.
- 18:58Tim: Like you just ask Brock whatever you could ask it, I guess.
- 19:00Katherine McNamara: Well, it's actually funny.
- 19:02Katherine McNamara: Um, I actually think I understand why that happened.
- 19:04Katherine McNamara: Um, I there was actually a news story that came out today, uh, specifically today, um, uh about um what's his name?
- 19:12Katherine McNamara: Uh Hegs uh Hegzor's Hex Hegseth.
- 19:16Tim: Pig Heggseth beat Hegseth, yes.
- 19:18Katherine McNamara: Yeah, Hegseth.
- 19:19Katherine McNamara: So apparently he's threatening to con uh so it seems like what he's doing is wanting to have all of these AI tools without guardrails.
- 19:28Katherine McNamara: So he's threatening to cancel the contract for Claude unless the military gets it fully without any guardrails.
- 19:34Katherine McNamara: So it's very possible, and and this is me just speculating, um, but it's very possible that he basically said install Grok without any sort of guardrails at all.
- 19:46Katherine McNamara: And that could be why it's kind of taken this wild turn.
- 19:49Katherine McNamara: Because I mean, that that's very similar to what the like what they're trying to do with uh Claude right now, and you know, for the US's uh instance of it, US military's instance of it.
- 19:59Katherine McNamara: So if I had to guess, and this is again speculation, I I'm you know, this is just speculatory, but the reason why probably Grok uh went in this direction is if it was similar and it didn't imply, you know, they didn't uh give guardrails to it like they're trying to do with Claude, uh it's very possible that it can do whatever they ask them to do.
- 20:20Katherine McNamara: Hopefully not with too many permissions.
- 20:22Katherine McNamara: Hopefully not without too many permissions.
- 20:24Katherine McNamara: Well, I don't know if I I necessarily necessarily trust the uh uh government to be uh you know to do to deploy internal AI correctly.
- 20:33Katherine McNamara: So who knows?
- 20:34Katherine McNamara: We may have like this whole you know all all of our social security data deleted tomorrow.
- 20:39Tim: Well, I'm just kidding, but Doge or Doge already has all that anyway.
- 20:43Tim: So backup.
- 20:46Katherine McNamara: So I think it's a decentralized backup at this point.
- 20:49Tim: Yeah, uh probably yeah, I would that we'll call it that.
- 20:52Tim: Um so yeah, no, the uh I did see that story.
- 20:55Tim: There was a yeah, so Pete Hegseth wants anthrop wanted anthropic to supply for Claude to be supplied to the US military, specifically with no guardrails around um using it for combat or um surveillance, if if I remember those are the two big ones.
- 21:12Katherine McNamara: Uh yeah, because one of the things that recently got reported is apparently when we went to get Maduro, uh they use claw uh clods to help it.
- 21:20Katherine McNamara: Uh so it's very possible that like everything they're deploying in the military, they're just like, we're gonna be you know badasses, we're gonna have nothing with guardrails.
- 21:28Katherine McNamara: You're all adults.
- 21:30Tim: Uh it's terrifying.
- 21:31Tim: Truly, truly terrifying, if I'm being honest.
- 21:33Tim: And then oh, it was uh about the other one was about they want it to have uh no guardrails against um autonomous action.
- 21:41Tim: So like if they want a drone to kill somebody, like they didn't want to have to they didn't want the AI to have guardrails around that or something.
- 21:49Tim: It was pretty crazy.
- 21:50Tim: It was honestly pretty, pretty terrifying.
- 21:52Tim: This article I was reading about what what Hagseth wants from Anthropic.
- 21:56Tim: Uh and and like you said, they're using the the power of the Government purse to try to force uh Anthropic to remove these guardrails and somebody'll do it.
- 22:05Tim: Probably I'm sure Elon Musk will do it all day.
- 22:07Tim: That's probably exactly what happened with Grok.
- 22:09Tim: So yeah, terrifying.
- 22:11Katherine McNamara: Yeah, but I I think that Claude is kind of the state what people Claude and Gemini are p are tend to be the favorites for like code-based stuff.
- 22:18Katherine McNamara: So I I'm that's true.
- 22:20Katherine McNamara: I can't speak to like Grok because I haven't used it as much for code, but like I it doesn't seem like it's the favorite there, which is why they probably want Claude to do whatever they want.
- 22:30Tim: Yeah, for sure.
- 22:30Tim: For sure.
- 22:31Tim: Okay.
- 22:32Tim: So yeah, I'll uh hand that over to you, Catherine.
- 22:37Tim: I think uh it's a great time.
- 22:38Tim: Great time to hand that over to you and uh take us home.
- 22:42Katherine McNamara: So I have a couple news stories.
- 22:44Katherine McNamara: Um again, this is kind of uh on the like the uh a little bit of uh government uh uh for a couple of them, government uh line and surveillance and security.
- 22:54Katherine McNamara: So um I I'm sure if anyone has been on the internet or have read the news, they've heard about the Nancy Guthrie case.
- 23:01Katherine McNamara: Um Nancy Guthrie case is, you know, for those who don't understand know about it, it's basically an elderly woman who was kidnapped uh in air in air, like in Arizona, I think it was Tucson.
- 23:10Katherine McNamara: And uh it's been this ransom like kidnapping going on for over 20 days now.
- 23:17Katherine McNamara: It's a really sad story.
- 23:18Katherine McNamara: It's 84-year-old woman.
- 23:19Katherine McNamara: That, you know, nothing like, yeah, I don't want to disparage or uh minimize that terrible thing that is going on.
- 23:27Katherine McNamara: But um one of the things that we discovered during this case that kind of got public is um so this woman, uh Nancy Guthrie, had a ring camera outside of her door, but she didn't have a subscription.
- 23:39Katherine McNamara: For anyone who uses ring, um, you know, they should know that they they have the ability to have like a subscription model where the it's saved in the cloud and they can access anytime.
- 23:49Katherine McNamara: And there's local, like where you're just not paying for the subscription and you're able to view it locally.
- 23:54Katherine McNamara: So the thought was that, you know, since she wasn't paying her subscription, you know, it was probably, you know, she probably didn't believe anything was being recorded.
- 24:02Katherine McNamara: But apparently uh there is some terms and conditions that uh basically says that uh if you uh you if you don't have a subscription, you still may uh it still may connect to the cloud servers and may store uh footage.
- 24:18Katherine McNamara: It doesn't actually confirm whether it does or not, it just says it may.
- 24:21Katherine McNamara: Well it turns out it did, and we were able to get a good picture of the um of the actual kidnapper, which uh good.
- 24:28Katherine McNamara: I I hope they're caught, but uh it has raised concerns among privacy advocates because uh you know everyone has kind of uh a lot of people probably heard about the uh the uh you know rings uh back end deal with the government and palantir uh palantir.
- 24:44Katherine McNamara: And um, and uh, you know, people have been canceling their ring ring subscriptions or or canceling or throwing out ring because they don't want to be sharing information with the US government or ICE or uh other places.
- 24:58Katherine McNamara: So uh it's really brought a spotlight to um to the privacy concerns around ring.
- 25:04Katherine McNamara: People thought that if they didn't have a subscription, they'd be fine.
- 25:07Katherine McNamara: It'd be like you know, you know, it'd be just on local, uh, local mode and they didn't have to worry about their information being shared.
- 25:15Katherine McNamara: And they assumed that it wouldn't be recording.
- 25:17Katherine McNamara: And and obviously there was something vague in the terms and conditions, so it's not like they were doing anything you know illegal, but now people know for sure that their stuff is being recorded in the cloud and they have to, you know, you know, protect their own their own privacy because some people use these not just for the front door, but for actual security, like cameras inside.
- 25:37Katherine McNamara: So you know, God knows what's in the cloud, and you know, there's no way that they have to access it and delete it if they don't have a subscription.
- 25:44Tim: Yeah.
- 25:44Katherine McNamara: So that that's that's one uh one of the puzzling news stories that uh that came up recently.
- 25:50Katherine McNamara: And you know, again, I don't want to minimize this whole um this whole uh kidnapping of Nancy Groot 3.
- 25:57Katherine McNamara: Like obviously something good came out of it here, but we would have never known that this was happening unless, you know, this is one of the very corner cases where something good came out of it, but you know, we basically found out that ring has been collecting all this data and all these these streams that are connected to the internet potentially, uh, without the consumer knowing.
- 26:19Tim: Yeah.
- 26:19Tim: I I was at some point I was gonna get a ring camera, and then I and then I had that exact fear, basically, that like, oh well, yeah, okay, I can see who's at my door, but so can everyone else, basically, the government or whoever this gets shared with.
- 26:33Tim: Um the other thing was, and uh uh if you install the ring or any other Amazon devices, uh there was there was an opt-out feature a few years ago uh that was basically, oh well, we can use your Wi-Fi to to basically build like a you know uh a throttled Wi-Fi uh service, you know, so people walking by can connect to the Wi-Fi.
- 26:59Tim: It was like the weirdest thing, but I quickly opted out of that because I have echoes.
- 27:03Tim: I don't have the I don't have the ring, I have echo.
- 27:06Tim: So I have the I have the voice version of it of a ring, I guess.
- 27:10Tim: Uh I'm sure it's listening to me and recording everything I say uh, you know, about about things, so uh not much better.
- 27:17Tim: But yeah, I mean this is this is this is it.
- 27:19Tim: Like all my neighbors, if I go up and down my street, I would say seven of ten neighbors have a ring camera as their as their doorbell or whatever.
- 27:28Tim: And you know, when you think about police, that that's good and bad, like you just pointed out, right?
- 27:33Tim: Like, you know, it could help police identify vandals or or crime being committed, but just as easily it could be used by ICE to track people's movements or whether they're you know at a certain location or the you know, or not just ICE, but the government in general.
- 27:48Tim: So yeah, I I don't know.
- 27:50Katherine McNamara: I think that's true.
- 27:52Tim: Yeah, yeah.
- 27:52Katherine McNamara: I think that it's something like we we're recorded, you know, without our knowledge, somewhere between 70 to 300 times a week.
- 28:00Katherine McNamara: You know, just walk like you said, walking down the street.
- 28:02Katherine McNamara: Um now I don't have I've never had a ring camera.
- 28:05Katherine McNamara: I almost got one like years ago, but I never did, thank God.
- 28:08Katherine McNamara: Um but you know, I wonder if like you know, you could do true, like yeah, I I don't know if it will function or not without any connection to the internet because you know, you and I we've both been network engineers in the past.
- 28:21Katherine McNamara: I wonder if you can completely segment it, you know, where it's all local in terms of like it only is able to access a local VLAN that's like sandboxed, only like your phone or something can connect to.
- 28:32Katherine McNamara: That would be like the only way I could see it potentially being safer, but the average consumer isn't gonna know to how to like put a like a segmented VLAN and you know, and block it.
- 28:43Katherine McNamara: And that's even if the camera the ring cam will allow it to uh to do it.
- 28:47Katherine McNamara: For all we know, it may require an internet connection even without a subscription.
- 28:51Katherine McNamara: So someone with the ring cam will have to test that out.
- 28:54Katherine McNamara: Um but yeah, it's it's it's it's uh I mean and I think that ring has tried, and since that came out, ring has been trying to like do PR to like fix uh you know their perceived issues, like uh the like their back end deals with the government and stuff.
- 29:09Katherine McNamara: So they're like, hey, now there's a new feature.
- 29:11Katherine McNamara: We can find your dog if you have a missing dog and stuff like that by using your neighbor's cam.
- 29:15Katherine McNamara: But it made everyone even more paranoid.
- 29:17Katherine McNamara: And I think uh at this point, uh Amazon recently announced that they're ending their partnership with uh with uh ring.
- 29:24Katherine McNamara: So that's that pressure did work.
- 29:26Tim: Okay, cool.
- 29:27Tim: That's good to know.
- 29:28Katherine McNamara: And then speak and that's a good segue into my next story, actually, about how pressure works.
- 29:33Tim: Yeah, I love it.
- 29:34Katherine McNamara: So I I think about I'm trying to think, like what today's the fourth 24th.
- 29:39Katherine McNamara: So about 15 days ago, uh Discord uh almost nuked itself um by announcing that uh it would launch a teen by default setting for its global audience.
- 29:50Katherine McNamara: So uh basically uh anyone who was, you know, uh, you know, going to any mature content or assumed can mature content, it was very vague, uh, you would have to identify yourself.
- 30:02Katherine McNamara: Like uh, you know, basically show your face and potentially an ID to verify your age.
- 30:08Katherine McNamara: And so um, and this was you know, there's certain states or uh or countries that require like ID now.
- 30:15Katherine McNamara: So like, you know, we understand that those those countries or those states may require that, and that's that's part of the law there.
- 30:22Katherine McNamara: But doing it globally and forcing everyone to identify, show their face, have that information taken was uh was uh disturbing to a lot of people.
- 30:32Katherine McNamara: And a lot of people got angry and were like, uh, well, I guess we gotta find a Discord alternative back to IRC.
- 30:38Katherine McNamara: There's a lot of jokes about IRC.
- 30:39Katherine McNamara: Um, it really pissed a lot of people off.
- 30:41Katherine McNamara: And it made a lot of people even angrier to know that um the company that was doing it, uh that was gonna be doing backending the the facial recognition and the the age verification was a company called Persona.
- 30:54Katherine McNamara: Uh Persona uh is a Peter Thiel uh funded company, uh, from my understanding.
- 30:59Katherine McNamara: So a lot of people were like, wait, what?
- 31:02Katherine McNamara: It's it's a startup uh in out of San Francisco.
- 31:05Katherine McNamara: It had ties to Peter Thiel, uh, and a lot of people uh and so security researchers decided, okay, I'm gonna look into this company because like what the heck?
- 31:14Katherine McNamara: Uh so uh security researcher, her name is Celeste.
- 31:18Katherine McNamara: Uh, I believe her username uh uh online is VM Funk.
- 31:23Katherine McNamara: Uh so VMF U N C.
- 31:26Katherine McNamara: Uh uh, she started digging into this and um and started looking, and they found a bunch of open APIs on on uh with persona.
- 31:36Katherine McNamara: They saw like there was a parallel instance with uh the US government potentially giving access to the government, and people were just like, wait, what the heck?
- 31:45Katherine McNamara: Uh like it, you know, there was a you know immediately spurred fears that uh that um you know that this information was gonna be shared with ICE with the government.
- 31:54Katherine McNamara: And it also didn't make sense why you would want to verify everyone, regardless of the law, if you knew that people are getting uncomfortable with with online ID laws or online ID uh IDs being forced in in most locations.
- 32:07Katherine McNamara: So uh, you know, there was a lot of rage about that.
- 32:10Katherine McNamara: That security researcher uh published their data without they didn't hack into anything.
- 32:16Katherine McNamara: They were able to like find uh date, like I think they found um 2,456 publicly accessible files, uh uh extensive surveillance uh software platforms that parallel like uh a government platform that you know seems to imply that there might be some information sharing with the US government and potentially ICE.
- 32:36Katherine McNamara: So she took that to Twitter and published a blog with other security researchers.
- 32:41Katherine McNamara: And um the uh CEO of the company, Rick Song, uh actually went to Twitter and also tried and you know engaged with Celeste via email.
- 32:51Katherine McNamara: There was some there's a little bit of tension at first, but Rick is seems like Rick is uh you know kind of an end of the story.
- 32:58Katherine McNamara: Uh Rick is now willing to meet with the EFF thanks to some uh awesome anonymous security researchers who kind of uh uh hook them up online.
- 33:07Katherine McNamara: And we'll see where that goes.
- 33:09Katherine McNamara: But since that that the public outrage, this, you know, finding out about persona and their their gut potential government uh contacts and how just insecure their back end was, Discord has kind of backed off of their uh their uh plans for you know you know global uh identification and definitely like sounds like they're also not planning on working with persona any further.
- 33:32Katherine McNamara: And this is where you know it comes in, where like uh public pressure does work uh sometimes.
- 33:37Katherine McNamara: If it hits their bottom line and people are willing to leave a platform en masse, uh at that point, you know, they they have to, you know, they'll they either like the company crumbles or or you do the best thing for uh for your business.
- 33:51Katherine McNamara: So I mean it was a goodish end of the story.
- 33:54Katherine McNamara: It sounds like the persona CEO might work with the EFF on some transparency and help.
- 34:00Katherine McNamara: Uh it doesn't sound like Discord is necessarily going to move forward with this global like ID ID thing, you know, knock on wood.
- 34:08Katherine McNamara: They definitely does sound like that they are backing off of using persona for that if they do move forward.
- 34:14Tim: Yeah.
- 34:15Tim: So I mean it's it's always the case.
- 34:18Tim: And it's in shittification, and and but now with the extra added flavor of you know the the surveillance state that's being built um right around our notices, it's right in front of our faces, really.
- 34:32Katherine McNamara: It's amazing how quickly this has kind of started to sp you know snowball into like uh more and more like private companies sharing consumer data with with uh governments or taking stuff that might be a little too uh, you know, seems a little too invasive and and uh you know, and and changing their policies unilaterally with re no real you know reason or rhyme.
- 34:57Tim: Well, I mean there's always a reason.
- 34:58Tim: I'm sure there was a boat boatload of money in in the pot somewhere like that with not being disclosed, right?
- 35:03Tim: Usually that's where where it starts.
- 35:06Tim: Um people are okay.
- 35:07Tim: So well, go ahead.
- 35:09Katherine McNamara: I was gonna say, and and the other thing is that like people were like the way that Discord was originally gonna roll this out as far as what's adult, they're really vague on what they defined as adult.
- 35:18Katherine McNamara: Like, is it adult if it's like you know, rated X, you know, adult like pornographic material, or is it like if it's a you know hacking or tech uh you know like uh Discord uh that might talk about security vulnerabilities that could be potentially adult, not child, you know, for children.
- 35:36Katherine McNamara: So no one really knew what was gonna what was really gonna be considered as adult uh for and requiring identification or not.
- 35:45Katherine McNamara: It was just written so vague that they could unilaterally enforce it at any time.
- 35:49Tim: I'm sure that was you know on purpose as well to to keep it vague so they could do that.
- 35:54Tim: But um So we are coming up on time.
- 35:58Tim: Did you have any was there another one?
- 36:01Tim: Was there anything else you want to talk about?
- 36:03Tim: I think so, right?
- 36:04Katherine McNamara: Okay, so this this one's was just more of a fun story.
- 36:06Katherine McNamara: Probably the hardest, uh probably the hardest zero-day disclosure I've ever seen.
- 36:13Tim: That's great.
- 36:14Katherine McNamara: Am I allowed to cuss on this?
- 36:15Katherine McNamara: Like a little like this ASS.
- 36:17Tim: Fuck yeah, fuck yeah, you can.
- 36:19Katherine McNamara: Okay, cool.
- 36:20Katherine McNamara: So we've heard about people irresponsibly disclosing before.
- 36:24Katherine McNamara: We've I've heard about people disclosing zero-day vulnerabilities via meme.
- 36:28Katherine McNamara: I don't think I've ever heard about people disclosing via throwing ass in a song.
- 36:33Katherine McNamara: But that happened this last Friday.
- 36:35Katherine McNamara: Uh so a uh Twitter group of like a non-researchers named UNU Underground.
- 36:40Katherine McNamara: Uh so if you go search for UW underscore underground, they published a song that was written by them with like an AI-generated video that was really actually good, where they walk through like they basically annihilated.
- 36:56Katherine McNamara: I lost count of how many zero-day vulnerabilities they found in uh Mauerbytes uh software.
- 37:02Katherine McNamara: Um, they talked about hard-coded credentials and they showed them.
- 37:05Katherine McNamara: They talked about uh memory leaks, uh you know, uh misconfigured permissions, uh hard-coded drive uh uh driver issues.
- 37:15Katherine McNamara: Like it just it went on and it was a really catchy song.
- 37:19Katherine McNamara: It went and got so much traction.
- 37:21Katherine McNamara: The C the CEO of uh Malware Bytes actually reached out to them and they actually prepared a formal report for them.
- 37:27Katherine McNamara: But it is really funny to think that uh that it was probably the hardest zero-day disclosure I've ever seen of just like a catchy, amazing song uh throwing out and like you know, their employees probably had to like watch like this video of like these anime you know waifus like throwing ass to like catch it all and slow it down.
- 37:45Katherine McNamara: And it was really hilarious, but uh, you know, it it they wrote they wrote an actual like formal report for them.
- 37:53Katherine McNamara: Uh they didn't put enough, they put enough in the song to like where they knew there was real stuff, but they actually prepared a formal report that actually like was very specific so they can improve their product.
- 38:04Katherine McNamara: And I will give props to Malware Bytes for actually like taking the feedback and asking for the report and and uh and working with them to actually get this corrected.
- 38:13Katherine McNamara: Because at the at the end of the day, funniness aside, I think everybody like responsible, like everybody wants to see product these products get better.
- 38:22Katherine McNamara: And so uh the fact that they were able to make a catchy song and make the product better and do the responsible thing was pretty awesome.
- 38:29Katherine McNamara: So if anyone wants to actually go and look up the uh the song, it's uh it's uh uh I think it's pinned on their Twitter right now.
- 38:36Katherine McNamara: It's uh uh it's it's the song title is Malware uh Bytes uh front machine.
- 38:43Tim: Yeah.
- 38:43Tim: No, I think it's great.
- 38:44Tim: And and what's good about this is that uh you know, malware, so the whole point of malware bytes from years, everybody should know probably about this, but just in case they never did, malware bytes was like this kind of um malware removal tool, kind of like a free malware from years ago.
- 39:00Tim: It's been out for an A B tool.
- 39:02Katherine McNamara: I mean it it's still on the Yeah, okay.
- 39:05Katherine McNamara: It's still I think it got it's still on Ninite.com, like back when I was doing like uh like tech repair and stuff like that, way like over 15 years ago.
- 39:15Katherine McNamara: Uh one of the easiest ways to download a bunch of tools at once was to go to nineite.com and that's where it kind of got a lot of popularity because it was just like the first AB you can uh anti-malware you can grab.
- 39:25Katherine McNamara: Yeah and it it it went from an anti-malware to like trying or antivirus to trying to be like an anti-malware, and I think it's kind of trying to dig into the EDR space.
- 39:34Katherine McNamara: It's not it's like more like small business and consumer still though.
- 39:38Tim: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 39:39Tim: More like a person running it on their computer than any kind of like an enterprise product for certain still or like a small business, from my understanding.
- 39:48Tim: Okay, that's fair.
- 39:49Tim: But yeah, it's I mean, but but good for them for because you think about the who's the user of this product, and they're they're not they're not gonna be a team.
- 39:57Tim: Nobody's using malware bytes that has a team of security researchers at their own organization, right?
- 40:03Tim: The people using this product are home users, small business, like you said.
- 40:07Tim: These people are not gonna know any better.
- 40:09Tim: So if malware bytes uh, you know, any of these zero days were used or a supply chain attack or whatever, and the it was compromised, you know, that now you have all these people running essentially malware on their on their machines, uh trying to as well.
- 40:23Tim: Or bypassing in a scent, yeah.
- 40:24Tim: Right.
- 40:24Katherine McNamara: Yeah, it was basically like, or you could basically take over the malware with all those, you know, uh those hard-coded credentials.
- 40:30Katherine McNamara: Yeah, yeah.
- 40:31Katherine McNamara: Malware malware bites becomes your, you know, you're you're now the god of malware bytes.
- 40:35Katherine McNamara: Um yeah.
- 40:37Katherine McNamara: So I mean it's a good thing.
- 40:39Katherine McNamara: Uh whenever these like things are discovered, sometimes there's two routes I tend to see like companies go.
- 40:44Katherine McNamara: Uh, you know, one outrage and threatening people because like they, you know, they're like, how dare you?
- 40:50Katherine McNamara: Or there's the ones who are responsible and and try to fix it.
- 40:56Katherine McNamara: Um and and so I will give malware bites credit for actually like you know taking the uh gracious approach and uh and doing so.
- 41:05Katherine McNamara: And hopefully they take the bug bounty for it and donate it to something good.
- 41:08Katherine McNamara: I think uh I think last I checked they were uh hoping that if they're if they choose to do you know uh pay out the bug bounty, just donate to to a charity or something.
- 41:18Tim: Yeah, okay.
- 41:19Tim: Excellent.
- 41:20Tim: Yeah, yeah, that's bug bounty.
- 41:21Tim: Uh I mean I hopefully yeah, I don't know what the numbers on that are, but uh something like 30,000 for the amount of uh of zero days that were in there.
- 41:30Tim: Oh wow, that's incriminally low, but alright.
- 41:33Tim: That's uh it's not like they got lots of money.
- 41:34Tim: So all right, well um yeah, I guess we'll we'll cut it there.
- 41:38Tim: Um thanks for joining uh thanks for joining me on this uh wonderful journey, Catherine.
- 41:43Tim: It's been it's been a pleasure as always.
- 41:46Tim: As always.
- 41:48Tim: Any as always, and uh we will um yeah, we'll stop right there and uh we'll have all the links in the in the show notes, including the ones, the stories we didn't get to cover.
- 41:58Tim: So check that out.
- 41:59Tim: And uh we'll see you next time on the uh on the podcast.
- 42:03Katherine McNamara: Yep.
- 42:03Katherine McNamara: See ya