Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Psychopathy & Forensic Treatment: Can You Really Rehabilitate a Dangerous Offender?
Transcript
- 0:00So imagine you have two identical patients, right?
- 0:03And they both have the exact same severity of
- 0:05schizophrenia. OK, like profound delusions, that
- 0:07kind of thing. Exactly. Profound, totally debilitating
- 0:10delusions. But one of them shoplifts the candy
- 0:13bar, and the other one gets into a physical altercation
- 0:17with the security guard. Right. So the crimes
- 0:19are completely different. Yeah. But medically
- 0:21speaking, Treating their brain chemistry should
- 0:23take the exact same amount of time, right? I
- 0:25mean the illness is identical. Yeah, you would
- 0:28think so So why does the justice system lock
- 0:30the violent offender in the psychiatric hospital?
- 0:34For years or you know, even decades longer than
- 0:37the shoplifter. It's a huge paradox It really
- 0:39is anyway, welcome to the psychology undergrad
- 0:42pretend you're sitting right here with us in
- 0:44the library Highlighters in hand just staring
- 0:47down our massive final exam on Canadian forensic
- 0:50psychology. Yep the dreaded chapter five? Yeah,
- 0:52today we are doing a deep dive into chapter five,
- 0:55which covers forensic treatment. And we're just
- 0:58trying to make sense of how the system handles
- 1:00offenders with severe mental health issues. And
- 1:05that paradox you just described, that is like
- 1:07the perfect entry point. It really exposes the
- 1:10massive contradiction at the heart of this whole
- 1:13field. Totally. The textbook basically outlines
- 1:15what is a three -tier triage system for mentally
- 1:20ill offenders. Right, the three buckets. Exactly.
- 1:23Bucket one is the primary focus. That's where
- 1:25the mental illness is so severe it completely
- 1:27eclipses the crime. It's the only thing that
- 1:29matters. Right. Then bucket two is the secondary
- 1:31focus, where the offender is legally responsible.
- 1:34but their disorder is like a massive contributing
- 1:37factor. Okay, and then bucket three. Bucket three
- 1:39is the minor focus. That's where mental health
- 1:41takes a backseat to simply, you know, preventing
- 1:45recidivism, stopping them from reoffending. But
- 1:48like using the word triage implies an organized
- 1:52functioning medical system, right? Which a jail
- 1:55definitely is not. Exactly. A jail isn't a hospital.
- 1:58It's an institution inherently designed to punish
- 2:00people. So how does a medical triage model even
- 2:03survive inside a punitive environment? It's a
- 2:06really good question. Especially when you look
- 2:08at the history of like morality and religion.
- 2:12Justice is almost always tied to ideas of free
- 2:15will, culpability, retribution. Eye for an eye.
- 2:19Yeah. If someone commits a crime, society wants
- 2:22them to pay. But if their brain chemistry literally
- 2:25forced them to do it, the whole moral concept
- 2:28of sin or guilt just It completely shatters.
- 2:31It really does shatter. And the legal systems
- 2:33attempt to sort of glue it back together. brings
- 2:36us to that first triage category, the primary
- 2:39focus. The ones where the illness eclipses the
- 2:41crime. Right. And for the exam, you need to firmly
- 2:44separate the two distinct legal designations
- 2:47here. There's unfit to stand trial and there's
- 2:50NCRMD. Not criminally responsible on account
- 2:53of mental disorder. Exactly. People constantly
- 2:55confuse them, but they focus on entirely different
- 2:57points in time. Right. I actually made a mnemonic
- 2:59for this, the UN bucket. U is for unfit and N
- 3:02is for NCRMD. That's a good way to remember it.
- 3:05Yeah. And unfit is about the defendant's brain
- 3:07right now, you know? In the present tense, sitting
- 3:09right there at the defense table. The textbook
- 3:11gives us that really tragic case study of Mr.
- 3:14Smith. Oh, yeah, the 37 -year -old with paranoid
- 3:17schizophrenia. Yeah. He barricaded his elderly
- 3:20mother in a bathroom because he was suffering
- 3:22from this severe, terrifying delusion that she
- 3:26was going to bite him and infect him with rabies.
- 3:28Which is just awful. And the stress of it caused
- 3:31her to suffer a nonfatal heart attack. So when
- 3:33Mr. Smith is brought into a courtroom, the judge
- 3:36is looking at a man who fundamentally cannot
- 3:38comprehend the proceedings. He has no idea what's
- 3:41happening. Right. He doesn't understand what
- 3:42a judge does. He doesn't understand the charges
- 3:45against him. And he certainly can't, like, instruct
- 3:47a lawyer to defend him. Because you can't put
- 3:50a person on trial if they aren't mentally present
- 3:52for it. It totally violates the most basic tenets
- 3:55of a fair trial. Exactly. So the legal machinery
- 3:59just hits pause. And the treatment in this phase
- 4:01is Like, intensely aggressively medical. Very
- 4:06medical. They aren't putting Mr. Smith in bucadural
- 4:09therapy to talk about his feelings toward his
- 4:11mother. They're administering psychotropic medications
- 4:14to chemically stabilize his brain. Just trying
- 4:16to restore his cognitive functions enough so
- 4:18he can actually stand trial. And the scale of
- 4:20this is way larger than people realize, isn't
- 4:22it? Oh, massively. There are approximately 5
- 4:26,000 fitness evaluations conducted annually in
- 4:29Canada alone. Wow, 5 ,000. Yeah. And if the unfitness
- 4:33is caused by a treatable condition, like acute
- 4:35psychosis, the medical intervention actually
- 4:38works quite well. So they do get better. Most
- 4:40of them do. Most individuals are restored to
- 4:43fitness within six months, and nearly 82 % are
- 4:46restored within a year. OK, but that leaves like
- 4:4918 % who aren't. What happens to the people whose
- 4:52brains simply do not respond to the medication?
- 4:55And that is exactly where the system gets totally
- 4:58bogged down. Truly. Yeah. Because if the unfitness
- 5:01stems from chronic Irremediable cognitive disorders,
- 5:05say like a severe intellectual disability, or
- 5:08a traumatic brain injury, or treatment -resistant
- 5:10schizophrenia restoring fitness might be scientifically
- 5:13impossible. Oh man, so they're just stuck. Yep.
- 5:17The state cannot legally try them, but they also
- 5:20can't release them if they're deemed dangerous.
- 5:22So they basically end up in this legal and medical
- 5:25purgatory. That is so bleak. Okay, let's contrast
- 5:28that present tense unfitness with the N in my
- 5:32mnemonic, NCRMD. Right, the past tense. Yeah,
- 5:35this is for someone who might be perfectly lucid
- 5:37today, sitting quietly in the courtroom, but
- 5:40who is completely detached from reality at the
- 5:43exact moment they committed the crime. Right.
- 5:45The textbook uses Mr. Cook as the example for
- 5:47this one. Yeah. He had a history of schizophrenia.
- 5:50He was off his medication, got highly agitated
- 5:52outside a grocery store, and punched a police
- 5:54officer. And demographically, the profile of
- 5:57an NCRMD case is highly specific. You definitely
- 6:00need to know this for the exam. Oh, right. The
- 6:02stats hit me. It is 84 % male. 84 %? Yeah. Almost
- 6:0570 % are under the age of 40. The vast majority
- 6:08of these cases involve violent offenses. OK.
- 6:11And the clinical correlation is pretty staggering.
- 6:13Nearly 69 % of violent NCRMD cases involve a
- 6:17diagnosis of psychosis, predominantly schizophrenia.
- 6:20Which is wild. But the public outcry against
- 6:22NCRMD verdicts is always deafening. People view
- 6:25it as a loophole, like a get out of jail free
- 6:27card. They really do. But morally speaking, if
- 6:29you look at major religious and ethical systems,
- 6:33from Thomas Aquinas all the way to modern secular
- 6:36ethics, they all agree that an action can't be
- 6:39considered a sin or a moral failing unless it's
- 6:42chosen freely by a rational mind. Right. Intent
- 6:45matters. Exactly. If a person's brain is literally
- 6:49hallucinating demons, they aren't choosing to
- 6:51assault a police officer. They're fighting for
- 6:53their life in an altered reality. And the Supreme
- 6:56Court of Canada actually codified that exact
- 6:58moral stance in the 1999 ruling Winko v. British
- 7:02Columbia. Winko v. British Columbia, writing
- 7:04that down. Yeah, underline it. The court basically
- 7:07mandated that if an NCRMD accused does not pose
- 7:10a significant threat to public safety, the review
- 7:13board must grant them an absolute discharge.
- 7:15Wait, like totally free? Yep. No parole, no conditions.
- 7:18They walk free. The court explicitly stated that
- 7:22the system cannot hold mentally ill individuals
- 7:24indefinitely simply to satisfy society's desire
- 7:27for retribution. Wow. I mean, on paper, that
- 7:31sounds like a pure, compassionate medical model.
- 7:33It does. But this brings us right back to that
- 7:36paradox we started the deep dive with. Eric Silver's
- 7:391995 research on confinement lengths for insanity
- 7:42equities kind of blows a hole in the idea that
- 7:45this is purely about treatment. Yeah, Silver's
- 7:48data is pretty damning. He analyzed it and found
- 7:51a glaring inconsistency. Which is what? The length
- 7:53of time an NCRMD individual spends locked in
- 7:56a psychiatric facility correlates much more strongly
- 7:59with the severity of their crime than with the
- 8:02severity of their mental disorder. Which is the
- 8:04ultimate tell, right? If it were truly a medical
- 8:06model, the treatment timeline would be dictated
- 8:09entirely by the pathology of the illness. Exactly.
- 8:12The illness should dictate the stay. Right. So
- 8:14the fact that a violent delusion results in a...
- 8:16year hospital stay, while a nonviolent delusion
- 8:19results in a six month stay, proves that the
- 8:22system is secretly operating on a punishment
- 8:24paradigm. Yep. Society is still extracting its
- 8:28pound of flesh. We've just changed the building
- 8:30from a prison to a hospital. Which forces us
- 8:32to look at the people who don't qualify for those
- 8:35medical exemptions. And that brings us to the
- 8:37second triage category, the secondary focus.
- 8:41Okay, bucket two. Right. These are individuals
- 8:43who are fully, legally, criminally responsible
- 8:46for their actions, but whose mental illnesses
- 8:49are massive contributing factors. So mentally
- 8:51disordered offenders, sex offenders, high -risk
- 8:53individuals. Exactly. And when we look at where
- 8:56these individuals are housed, we really have
- 8:58to distinguish between jails and prisons. I've
- 9:00got a mnemonic for this, too. The JP split. Let's
- 9:03hear it. J is for jails. Just waiting, right?
- 9:05Pre -trial or for short provincial sentences
- 9:08under two years. And P is for prisons. prolonged
- 9:12federal institutions for sentences over two years.
- 9:15That works perfectly. And the distinction matters
- 9:18because jails are the immediate bottleneck. How
- 9:21so? Jails act as massive, completely unintended
- 9:24mental health triage centers. Up to 90 % of inmates
- 9:28arrive with substance use or personality disorders.
- 9:3190 %? That's insane. Yeah, and between 15 to
- 9:3440 % suffer from acute depression or anxiety.
- 9:37And the guards aren't trained for this, the facilities
- 9:40aren't built for this, yet they are housing the
- 9:43highest concentration of acute mental illness
- 9:45in the entire country. But because they are criminally
- 9:47responsible, the primary goal shifts, right?
- 9:50from just stabilizing them to actually changing
- 9:53their criminal behavior. Yes. And for the exam,
- 9:56you absolutely must understand the R &R model.
- 10:00Risk, need, and responsivity. Oh yeah, the R
- 10:04&R model. The textbook calls it the absolute
- 10:06gold standard for correctional treatment. It
- 10:08is the gold standard because it abandons the
- 10:11one -size -fits -all approach to rehabilitation,
- 10:13which statistically just fails. The R &R model
- 10:16is highly individualized. Right. It's like tailoring
- 10:19a suit. Okay, I like that analogy. Run with it.
- 10:22So the risk principle dictates how much fabric
- 10:24you use. If you have a high -risk offender, you
- 10:26have to dedicate massive amounts of time and
- 10:29intensive therapy. They get a lot of fabric.
- 10:31Right. And low -risk offenders actually get worse
- 10:33if you over -program them. Wait, really? They
- 10:36get worse? Yeah, because placing a low -risk
- 10:39offender in intensive daily group therapy with
- 10:42highly entrenched violent offenders It exposes
- 10:46them to anti -social networks. They literally
- 10:49learn new criminal behavior. Oh man, that makes
- 10:52sense. Okay, so then you have the need principle.
- 10:54That dictates the shape of the suit. You have
- 10:57to target what the textbook calls criminogenic
- 10:59needs. The specific things causing the crime.
- 11:02Exactly. You don't spend time treating offenders'
- 11:05low self -esteem if, like, poor impulse control
- 11:08is what's actually causing them to rob houses.
- 11:10You target the specific traits driving the behavior.
- 11:14like anti -social attitudes. Right. And finally,
- 11:17responsivity. This is keeping with your analogy,
- 11:20making sure the suit actually fits the specific
- 11:22wearer comfortably. Ah, OK. You have to match
- 11:25the therapeutic intervention to the offender's
- 11:27specific learning style, their IQ, their cultural
- 11:30background, and their motivation level. So like
- 11:32putting an offender with a severe reading disability
- 11:34into a therapy program that requires them to
- 11:37write daily journal entries. Exactly. That is
- 11:39a total failure of responsivity. Right. And the
- 11:42empirical proof that this RNR mechanism actually
- 11:45works comes from Bergen and Armstrong's 2005
- 11:48study on cognitive behavioral therapy, or CBT.
- 11:52Yeah, that study is crucial. They quantified
- 11:54the risk processing power, basically. Right.
- 11:56They found that to functionally change the entrenched
- 11:58neural pathways of a high -risk offender, you
- 12:01need to administer 300 hours of CBT. 300 hours.
- 12:04Yeah. And when they did that, recidivism dropped
- 12:07from 59 % down to 38%. But if those high -risk
- 12:10offenders only received 100 hours of CBT, the
- 12:13needle barely moved, the intervention simply
- 12:16wasn't depth enough to overwrite a lifetime of
- 12:18antisocial cognition. That's wild. But 100 hours
- 12:21was highly effective for medium -risk offenders,
- 12:23right? Yep. It cut their reoffending rate from
- 12:2628 % down to 12%. It completely proves that the
- 12:30dosage of therapy must match the risk level of
- 12:32the patient. Now, applying this intensive therapy
- 12:35to sex offenders opens up a really fascinating
- 12:37debate about the mechanics of behavioral change.
- 12:40The pharmacological debate. Yeah. The textbook
- 12:43discusses pharmacological treatments, basically
- 12:46administering drugs that chemically suppress
- 12:48testosterone and severely reduce the sex drive.
- 12:52It's essentially a form of chemical castration.
- 12:54And while it is highly effective at immediately
- 12:56suppressing the physiological urge, it doesn't
- 12:59solve the underlying cognitive problem. Right,
- 13:02it puts a heavy lid on a boiling pot, but it
- 13:04doesn't turn down the heat. Exactly. Which is
- 13:07why the long -term data heavily favors cognitive
- 13:09behavioral therapies over purely chemical interventions.
- 13:13CBT actually attacks the cognitive distortions
- 13:16that allow an offender to justify their actions.
- 13:19Right, because a sex offender often operates
- 13:21with deeply ingrained beliefs that normalize
- 13:24their behavior. Right, like convincing themselves
- 13:26that the victim somehow consented or wasn't really
- 13:28harmed. Yep, and CBT meticulously dismantles
- 13:32those distortions. It forces the offender to
- 13:34recognize the physiological lead up to their
- 13:37urges and teaches them to deploy active coping
- 13:40strategies. Exactly. That transition from external
- 13:46control to internal cognitive control is critical,
- 13:49especially when we move to the final triage bucket,
- 13:52the minor focus. Okay, bucket three. Right. This
- 13:55category deals with the vast majority of the
- 13:57prison population, where mental health is considered
- 14:00secondary to the primary goal, which is stopping
- 14:02general recidivism and managing substance abuse.
- 14:06But, you know, the environment required to foster
- 14:09that internal cognitive control is currently
- 14:11disappearing. Yeah, it's pretty sad. Howard Sapers,
- 14:14the former correctional investigator of Canada,
- 14:16published findings showing a drastic shift toward
- 14:19punitive conditions in Canadian prisons. Record
- 14:21levels of double bunking. Overcrowding and the
- 14:24use of administrative segregation, which is basically
- 14:27solitary confinement. And a punitive, highly
- 14:30stressful environment is neurologically incompatible
- 14:32with deep cognitive therapy. Because they're
- 14:35in survival mode. Right. If an inmate is locked
- 14:37in segregation for 22 hours a day, constantly
- 14:40operating in a state of hyper vigilance, their
- 14:42prefrontal cortex, the part of the brain responsible
- 14:45for complex reasoning, is essentially shut down.
- 14:49You cannot conduct effective CBT in a war zone.
- 14:52Exactly. But when they do get access to CBT,
- 14:55the mechanism revolves around disrupting a specific
- 14:57behavioral chain. I use the ABC mnemonic for
- 15:00this. Action, belief and consequence. Yes. So
- 15:04an offender experiences a trigger Say, severe
- 15:07financial stress. That's the action. Their ingrained
- 15:11belief is that consuming alcohol will alleviate
- 15:13that stress and lower their inhibitions. And
- 15:16the consequence is they get drunk, lose their
- 15:18temper, and assault someone. So CBT intervenes
- 15:21right at the belief stage. It teaches the brain
- 15:23to recognize the trigger and intentionally substitute
- 15:26a pro -social action. Right. Stress hits. But
- 15:29instead of the ingrained neural pathway leading
- 15:31to alcohol, the new pathway leads to calling
- 15:34a support network or going to the gym. By changing
- 15:37the belief about how to cope, you alter the consequence.
- 15:40And this mechanism explains one of the most shocking
- 15:42revelations in the entire textbook. Oh, the 1995
- 15:46Miller study. Yes. Miller conducted a massive
- 15:49methodological analysis of alcohol treatment
- 15:51outcomes. And what did they find? They found
- 15:53that the two most heavily utilized methods in
- 15:56North America, educational lectures, and Alcoholics
- 15:58Anonymous, have the absolute lowest empirical
- 16:01support for reducing substance abuse. Wait, really?
- 16:05AA has the lowest support. Yep. It is a profound
- 16:08failure of evidence -based practice. The approach
- 16:11with the highest empirical success rate is actually
- 16:14relapse prevention training, which uses the very
- 16:17CBT mechanisms we just discussed. That is mind
- 16:20-blowing. Yeah. But think about the psychological
- 16:22difference between the two approaches. The foundational
- 16:25step of AA is admitting absolute powerlessness
- 16:28over the eviction and surrendering to a higher
- 16:31power. Right. It's a deeply moral, almost religious
- 16:34framework. Yeah. But relapse prevention training
- 16:36does the exact opposite. It empowers the individual.
- 16:38It teaches them that they aren't powerless. They
- 16:41simply lack the cognitive tools to handle specific
- 16:43physiological triggers. It arms them with coping
- 16:46skills to actively combat the urge rather than
- 16:49asking them to just surrender to it. Yet society
- 16:52defaults to AA. Why? Because relapse prevention
- 16:56training requires highly educated clinical psychologists,
- 17:00extensive funding, and massive systemic infrastructure.
- 17:03While AA is free, it's peer -led, and it operates
- 17:06in church basements everywhere. We are fundamentally
- 17:08choosing the cheapest, easiest path over the
- 17:11one scientifically proven to rewire the addictive
- 17:14brain. It is infuriating, especially knowing
- 17:17that almost everyone in these three triage buckets
- 17:20eventually finishes their sentence. Right. Unless
- 17:23they are serving life without parole, they are
- 17:25coming back to our communities. So how do we
- 17:27manage that transition? Community -based treatment.
- 17:30Right. Which relies heavily on the structures
- 17:32of parole, which is an early conditional release
- 17:34from prison and probation, which is a sentence
- 17:37served in the community instead of a cell. OK.
- 17:39Heilobren and Griffin established three absolute
- 17:42requirements for this to work safely. First,
- 17:45centralized responsibility. There must be one
- 17:47primary authority making decisions so the offender
- 17:49doesn't slip through the cracks of competing
- 17:51agencies. OK, that makes sense. What's the second?
- 17:54Second is uniform treatment. The conditions set
- 17:57by the parole board must perfectly align with
- 17:59the goals of the community therapist. Right.
- 18:02If the parole officer is demanding one thing
- 18:04and the therapist is focused on another, The
- 18:07offender is caught in an impossible bind. Exactly.
- 18:10And third is a robust network of community services.
- 18:14Housing, employment assistance, mental health
- 18:17clinics. Without that safety net, recidivism
- 18:20is practically guaranteed. But this integration
- 18:23requires a massive moral compromise, doesn't
- 18:25it? How do you mean? Well, the clinical ideal
- 18:27is to treat patients in the least restrictive
- 18:29environment possible, granting them dignity and
- 18:32autonomy. But the state's primary obligation
- 18:34is the physical safety of the public. Right,
- 18:36and the mechanism they use to bridge that gap
- 18:39is the behavioral contract. Which is pretty intense.
- 18:42It really is. When a high -risk individual is
- 18:45released, their freedom is heavily conditional.
- 18:47They sign a binding legal agreement that dictates
- 18:50their daily existence. Like what kind of conditions?
- 18:53It mandates strict medication compliance with
- 18:55frequent blood testing to ensure they haven't
- 18:57stopped taking their antipsychotics. It dictates
- 19:00where they can live, implements curfews, restricts
- 19:03who they can associate with, and random drugs.
- 19:05alcohol screenings, right? Yep. It is a razor
- 19:08-thin tightrope, one missed appointment, one
- 19:10failed drug test, and the contract is violated,
- 19:13sending them immediately back to a secure facility.
- 19:16Wow. Okay, so let's pull all of this together
- 19:18for the exam. Let's do it. We have the three
- 19:21tiers of triage. Bucket 1 is the primary focus
- 19:24dealing with unfitness and NCRMD, where the mental
- 19:28state eclipses the crime. The UN bucket. Exactly.
- 19:31Bucket 2 is the secondary focus, where we apply
- 19:34the RNR model to mentally disordered and high
- 19:36-risk offenders, tailoring that suit to their
- 19:39specific criminogenic needs. And Bucket 3 is
- 19:41the minor focus, where we utilize CBT and relapse
- 19:44prevention to break the behavioral chains of
- 19:47general recidivism and substance abuse. The action,
- 19:50belief, consequence chain. Yep. If you can articulate
- 19:53the underlying mechanisms of why those treatments
- 19:55work, not just what they are, you are going to
- 19:58absolutely destroy this exam. Awesome. I'm feeling
- 20:01way better about this now. Good. But before we
- 20:03close the books tonight, I want to leave you
- 20:05with a philosophical problem that the data kind
- 20:08of demands we answer. Oh, a provocative thought
- 20:11to end on. I like it. We've spent this whole
- 20:13session looking at the empirical evidence, and
- 20:15the research definitively proves that cognitive
- 20:18behavioral therapy, relapse prevention, and the
- 20:20strictly applied R &R model successfully reduce
- 20:23recidivism. Right. The numbers are undeniable.
- 20:26Rehabilitation works. They fundamentally change
- 20:28human behavior, and in doing so, they make our
- 20:31streets and communities drastically safer. So
- 20:34if we know as an empirical, scientifically proven
- 20:36fact that behavioral rehabilitation works better
- 20:39than raw punitive confinement, what is our moral
- 20:42obligation? If the goal of the justice system
- 20:45is truly to protect society, do we have a moral
- 20:48imperative to tear down the traditional prison
- 20:50model entirely? Should we transform every single
- 20:53jail into a mandatory, intensive cognitive therapy
- 20:57and skill building center, even if it completely
- 20:59denies society that deeply human, visceral desire
- 21:02for retributive justice? Do we value a safer
- 21:05future or do we value making them suffer for
- 21:08the past? It's the ultimate tension between evidence
- 21:12-based science and human morality. Exactly. Well,
- 21:15chew on that while you review your notes. Look
- 21:17past the acronyms and try to really understand
- 21:19the psychological mechanisms we discussed today.
- 21:22Get some sleep and good luck on the final.