Latest / Neon Protocol / Eyes of a Stranger
Transcript
- Gene Feldman: Tonight on Neon Protocol, we're diving straight into the system shaping what comes next. I'm Gene Feldman joined by Lucky Gobindrom, Mark Grove, Damon Shackelford, and Mike Vann. We're the Neon Protocol team exploring XR, AI, spatial computing, and the infrastructures that make them real. There's no hype in demo theater here. We're here to break down what's working, what's changing, and what's about to break open. And on tonight's show, have Courtney Harding, someone who's been shaping the conversation around immersive tech, ethics, and the future of human centered design for years. So this is going to be a really fun one tonight. And we're excited to bring her in, introduce herself, and jump right into the conversation. So Courtney. Cortney Harding: Yeah, well, thank you again so much for having me. My name is Courtney, and I have worked in the XR space for 10 years now. I have worn many hats, but my main hat that I wear is my company friends with holograms. We're a full service VR, AR agency, and consultancy. So we've worked with clients like Accenture, Walmart, Lowe's, PWC, et cetera, et cetera, building award-winning training projects for them. ⁓ I spent some time at Metta on the Metta Immersive Learning Fund, had a really great time there, was an executive producer on the JFK Memento project, which is available on Quest, ⁓ produced by a fantastic company called Targo. ⁓ That was one of the most award VR pieces of 2023 and 24, including being nominated for an Emmy, so that was a huge honor. In addition to all of that, I do a lot of teaching, so I have a course actually launching this week with New Mexico State University. I've taught there before, and this course is focused on smart glasses and design. So it's the first of its kind as far as we've been able to tell with our research. So that's really exciting. I've taught at NYU, Caltech, Barnard, North Carolina State. I teach now as part of a program called Fast Future Executive, which is an executive program. And I have a book that came out last year called The Spatial Race. Gene Feldman: Very nice. Absolutely outstanding. I actually want to attend your class because I'm excited that AI and these type of conversations are getting past co-pilot conversations and now getting into the heart of OK, what AI can and can't do. So ⁓ no, absolutely fantastic. ⁓ which kind of gets into this whole conversation. ⁓ we want Courtney to come because really kind of the. One of the big topics right now is AI powered glasses, smart glasses, however we want to refer to them. But the problem is it's eyes of a stranger. It's what happens when AI starts watching back, but also it gets into, I Courtney, I think you could expand much greater than I could, but just a deeper ethical level of what is AI capturing and redefining our privacy expectations? Lucky Lance K Gobindram: you Gene Feldman: To me, just, where I kind of start thinking about it is I go to Comic-Cons a lot. And nowadays at Comic-Cons, you can't take pictures past a certain point. If they see your phone out, they take it, and you have to pay about $50 to $80 for a selfie. Whereas with these glasses, nobody knows you're even recording, even with now that you can get privacy covers for the smart glasses. So I think that's a really great place for us to start on this whole privacy. question and ⁓ what happens when these glasses really start kind of watching us back? I think it's fair. Cortney Harding: Yeah, I mean, I think there is a lot to unpack there. So I've been writing also for Forbes for the last several months, and I've written several columns recently on this exact topic. And the thing that really sparked that was Metta announcing name tag. And if you're not familiar, name tag is a feature that Metta has not actually deployed. ⁓ But it's basically facial recognition on the glasses. ⁓ My sense of that leak or announcement, whoever leaked it, was that Gene Feldman: Yeah, please. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: you Cortney Harding: it was a way for them to sort of announce the worst possible thing they could do. And then they have to, right? And then they walk it back a little bit. People were like, oh, well, at least they didn't do that, right? So I think it was a split week. I have no actual evidence of that, but I think strategically that's kind of how they were thinking. But yeah, I mean, there's a lot of, so there's a lot to unpack there. So first of all, we are being surveilled all the time anyway, right? Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Hahaha Gene Feldman: Yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah Mike: Intentional, yeah. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Makes sense. Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. Cortney Harding: You know, I live in New York City. There are CCTV cameras on every corner, right? Every time I go to a store, there's cameras. ⁓ If I'm visiting my folks who live in a residential neighborhood in Portland, ⁓ everyone has a Ring camera, right? And we saw some pushback against Ring when they announced the find your lost dog feature, which was really like the share your footage feature. And everyone has their phone out all the time, right? you know, everyone is kind of recording everyone else anyway. The glasses add another dimension and layer to it, right, which is the notion that you're recording from your eyes as opposed to your phone. But there's also like people record surreptitiously on their phones constantly. So I just want to sort of level set the idea that we're going to be recorded a lot is not a new idea. And I think if you look back at the pushback against the original Google glasses 10, 12 years ago now at this point. Gene Feldman: Mm-hmm. Cortney Harding: there's a different comfort level to the amount of recording in public that we accept, right? Back in 2013, 2014, 2015, I mean, people had phones, but this notion of like everything is on TikTok all the time, that did not even, TikTok didn't exist, right? So I think there's a general comfort with being recorded, but, you know, and then it gets into the issues of, ⁓ you know, your recording content and then the content is potentially being shared. Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. Cortney Harding: ⁓ That was something that happened recently. this is a bit of a strange story because it's based off like translated reports. ⁓ But the idea was basically meta, you would film content in your glasses and that content would be shared with a third party service in Kenya that did like tagging for AI. ⁓ Meta did not technically break any rules. mean, the glass, you when you were filming, you had to tell the glasses to start filming, stop filming. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Cortney Harding: ⁓ so it wasn't like Metta was filming without your knowledge, right? Yeah. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: That was consent. Gene Feldman: Yeah, as well. Cortney Harding: Yeah, and it's in the form of the difference. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: It is. It is, Mark. Gene Feldman: Yeah, because they have to get by, especially in the 50 different states. Each state has different rules and regulations, whether it's a single party knowledge or single informed consent, whatever. Cortney Harding: Right. Right. But that's only for specific, that's all, right, so like that's for legal cases, you know, but like anyone can take a photo and just have it on their phone, you know, so like. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Oh it's a P-Tombat, right? Look what Pokemon Go was able to achieve, right? Like they were able to like take all that information to string it together and they're creating these crazy world maps from it because everybody's uploading it because they're catching Pokemon, but they didn't realize what they were feeding to the engine, what they were creating by doing that, right? And so like, MetaG going to get bad rap, honestly. I agree with you Courtney. I think the world's changed, right? We lived in a world where you use your device, you query the AI, right? Now it's flipped, right? The device observes you, AI initiates. Cortney Harding: Yeah. Yeah. Right. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: It's not just responding, it's interpreting, right? So like. Cortney Harding: Yeah. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Cortney Harding: And that's the vision that I kind of laid out in the book and that I've laid out in other places, which is the ideal version or the better version for me of these glasses with the AI is like the glasses learn what I want, what I need, and it can deliver it to me. So all of a sudden I'm getting information that is contextual and relevant if when... Sorry? Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Building a live model, right? It's building a live model, right? What you look at, who you talk to, your tone, stress, hesitation, habits. Gene Feldman: Yeah, well... Cortney Harding: Yeah, where I'm at, what I'm doing. like a really good example that I was talking about actually yesterday is, you know, I'm a runner. That's my kind of big hobby outside of work. And when I'm on a run, you know, I'll get texts on my phone, on my watch, then I have to like stop my run and look and potentially respond. And the texts are not filtered in any meaningful way. So I can get a text about like something that's a true emergency, right? Lucky Lance K Gobindram: You Cortney Harding: Then I can also get a text from my husband being like, hey, can you go to the store later today and buy broccoli, which I need to do, but it's not like a true emergency. And then I get like spam texts, junk texts, whatever. And there's no filtering mechanism, right? Same with emails, same with a lot of notifications. So the idea is if you have AI in the glasses and AI is really good, it will contextually know, okay, Courtney's running, right? It can tell the motion of the glasses and where I'm going. So, okay, we're only gonna serve her life or death emergency notifications, right? And we can later, yeah, workout mode. Mike: Workout mode. Cortney Harding: Right? If it can tell that I'm like sitting on my couch, scrolling my phone, relaxing, then it might give me more. Right? you know, that's, like, it'll serve me products. So rather than having ads everywhere, right? Huge billboards and, you know, ads for things that I don't want or need. It'll serve me. Okay. It's 7 a.m. You want coffee or tea or whatever at 7 p.m. Like you want a glass of wine. Here's like a wine that you will probably like based on everything we've learned about you. And here's where you can go. And then even bigger picture. This is an example that I gave it. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Cortney Harding: MIT when I did a talk there. And this kind of comes back to the idea of data gathering in the glasses. So if you live in New York and it's a Friday night and you decide last minute you want to go to dinner, in a lot of neighborhoods that's actually very challenging because a lot of places are really packed. So you wind up just wandering around and getting frustrated. It's kind of a bad experience. So now what you can do, or in future theoretically what you could do is put on your glasses and say, OK, I want to go to dinner. I want Thai food. I want know, 20 block radius, like whatever your parameters are. And because everyone in the restaurant is wearing the glasses, it won't give you individuals, but it'll give you a heat map, right? So you can tell like, is the restaurant really busy? Is there atomic people there? That's, and then that restaurant won't get recommended to you because there's no point in you going because it's full. So then it kind of has that extra layer of intelligence and, and really getting rid of that friction kind of built in. So that's where I see it going potentially in a way that is like useful. ⁓ Gene Feldman: Yeah. It's like we're giving AI human context. So in other words, we're giving it more variables that the human mind, I guess, is usually interpreting. As you were talking, I keep reminding myself that even in 2022, when Japan started initiating all of this in their airports, that they have, was it NeoFace that will take them? It'll take you from check-in Cortney Harding: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah. Gene Feldman: to boarding without ever pulling out a driver's license. Cortney Harding: Yeah, that's timely example today, given the four hour, but there's a four hour wait at the Houston airport right now to get through security. It's insane. like, one of the, and this is a little bit of tangent, but there's something that frustrates me so much in this moment is that we have technical solutions to so many problems and we are actively choosing not to implement them because we as a society have this really deep fear of technology, I think. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: which is amazing. Gene Feldman: I know. Mike: you Gene Feldman: Yeah. Cortney Harding: And I'm talking in the US. Yeah. Gene Feldman: I Well, we grew up with Skynet and Terminator and all these things. And one of the things that I've really been trying to harp on to people, I mean, I think to a point where people are annoyed with me, but that we picked the wrong word. It's not artificial. It's assisted. And for me, I think of R2D2 and C3PO. Sorry, George Lucas for the copyright steal. But okay, they're droids, but why don't we think of them as AIs because they're in their own vehicle. Cortney Harding: Yeah. Yeah. you Damon Shackelford: You Lucky Lance K Gobindram: You Gene Feldman: They are taught how to do tasks, but they also have analytical skills to be able to cross-apply. But they help us to do our job where it's not threatening, but then we do. think the US has a very ⁓ hard view of it. And part of me even thinks the generations, because you get the older generations with Cortney Harding: Well, it's also... Mark G.: I disagree. I don't think Americans actually have a hard view on it. I've lectured to European labor, who are part of my job, sorry, bro. Americans are welcome. They're happy to let it fly until they get hit by a car because they're looking at their phone and not looking where they're going or something like that. And then they want to call a foul. But you know. Cortney Harding: ⁓ yeah. Gene Feldman: No, please. Mike: Ha They are more. Yeah, they are. But I mean, we're still voting with paper ballots and, all this stuff that just should be gone. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Mark G.: Hey, well, you know, ⁓ but from the standpoint of the platform, ⁓ I just don't agree that I don't think people are as scared as other cultures, ⁓ but. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: I have his benefits to that, Mike. Cortney Harding: Yeah. That's fair. Yeah. Europe is like, Europe is way behind. you know, the U.S. is kind of rolling out at this really strange pace. ⁓ I think Europe is going to be the furthest behind. think developing markets, and this is historically the case. Yeah. Asia's way ahead. Japan's way ahead. China's way, way, way ahead. Right. So, but I think it's like, you know, you look at Waymo, like people have big, mad feelings about Waymo. Gene Feldman: Yeah, I'm just happy I had the first hot take. Damon Shackelford: Hahaha! Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Hmm. Asia's just way ahead in general, right? Singapore all of its way ahead. ⁓ Cortney Harding: And yet look, it will disrupt industry and it will disrupt jobs. I'm not saying it won't, but Waymo statistically is like 80 % safer than human driven cars, right? And somebody said something really interesting to me, which is Waymo is the most dangerous it will ever be today because every time it encounters an edge case, learns, right? Humans don't do that. So, you know, there were two articles that both came out of San Francisco very recently that I thought were really interesting because the first one was, and this is, really horrifying. People will attack way most on the street with human passengers in them. Right. The same day I saw that article, there was an article about a woman who 75 year old woman going 75 miles an hour on a 30 mile an hour street ran into a bus stop, killed a family, parents, two children dead, just a family out going to the zoo for a day. Right. She got probation. Now we have a solution in San Francisco. There are cars that are 80 % safer. Right. And people are attacking those cars. And yeah, people are upset that this woman essentially scammed her way out of any punishment. But this happens all the time. This happens all the time. People are killed by cars. They're killed by delivery cyclists, whatever it is. We have solutions. The delivery robot hit a bus stop in Chicago today and broke some glass. OK, fine. Who cares? It's a robot. Meanwhile, every time I tried to the street near my house, there's some guy on a moped going 50 miles an hour in the bike lane doing, you know, Deliveroo or Grubhub or whatever. You know, it's like, we just are in this weird place where, you know, we have all these great solutions that we could be implementing and we could be making our lives better. And we are actively choosing not to. And that's something that I cover a ton in the book. And I think that plays into the really visceral reaction to the glasses discourse too, because like, People are so weird about the glasses and I'm like, but yeah, sure there are some issues, but I think the outrage is really outsized at this point. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: I think people forget the huge upsides and they always look at the slippery slope, right? The darker version of things, right? Like, think about glasses, obviously, in the right context, it's insanely powerful, right? Like, it give you all types of superhuman skills, like memory augmentation or soft skill feedback or real-time coach, whatever you want, right? And those types of things. But then there's the darker side of things, right? Cortney Harding: Yeah. Gene Feldman: Mm-hmm. Damon Shackelford: Thank you. Mike: Mm-hmm. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Employers are tracking tone, right? Engagement, compliance. Oh my God, I'm being watched. Just productive these scores. I'm like, based on gaze and activity or social scoring, right? Like how present are you really, right? You're not just doing the job. You're being evaluated continuously or whatever it is, right? like, people feel, even worse, think about like, okay, all of a sudden, I'm for it, but like. Cortney Harding: Yeah. Yeah. Damon Shackelford: So. Yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Identity drift, right? Is AI constantly suggesting what to say? Is it reminding you what to think? Is it nudging your behavior? Oh my God, is it assisting you versus shaping you? Where's the lines? This is, think, where fear becomes, right? Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Right. Right. Well, Cortney Harding: Yeah, and there's also like ups and downsides to all of that. So, you know, my uncle got the meta glasses and he's, you know, in his early eighties, he was a combat veteran in Vietnam. has pretty bad hearing loss and, you know, he didn't really want to wear hearing aids. It's like a pride thing. It's like a, you know, people are weird about it, but he got the glasses because my cousin got them for him as a gift. She thought they would be cool. And he uses the closed caption feature and it has changed his life. He came to my father's birthday party recently. And he was more engaged than I'd seen him in years, right? Because he can talk to people now. has the glasses on, they look cool, he gets the captions, he can tell what everyone's saying, he can be involved in presence. So like, there's that. If you are somebody who struggles with social anxiety or you're neurodiverse and it's hard for you to know what to in conversations, like the glasses prompting you can be really helpful and beneficial. The downside is then you have these conversations where the glasses are just telling you what to do and you're just going through the motions and that kind of... Gene Feldman: Yeah. Cortney Harding: You know, so it's, it's really, I, again, it's just one of these things where there's no, like, for every action, there's an equal and opposite reaction or counter case, I guess. Sorry, I didn't mean to cut you off. Gene Feldman: Yeah. It's almost like that with all technology. To me, I always come back to it's the Jurassic Park question. Just because we can, should we? But for me, getting into, you alluded to a good thing. So I, over the past couple of years, I've really been trying to figure out how to bring in AI into just work settings, like in the sales scenarios and conversational settings. And the one thing that as I reached out to all test users, Cortney Harding: Yes. Gene Feldman: You know, they did, they hated, you know, the, you know, the screening of, you know, whether I'm engaged or not, but the one thing that they all loved was it overcame their public speaking because they were able to pull up a transcript of their speech on the glasses and be able to read it. So now they're maintaining eye contact or what is a, you know, alluded to eye contact and being able to be more confident in delivering. Mark G.: Is it really eye contact? Are they focused forward on the teleprompter? Gene Feldman: Well, but now you see there gets to a thing like as an old teacher, one of our teaching methods, if people had where new teachers had issues, public speaking, we would say pick three spots on the back of the wall right above the students heads and stare and rotate from those three spots. And it will always look like you're looking at all the students in the classroom. And it, but it, you gotta remember public speaking is what they say is the number one fear over death. Now, none of us have that. Damon Shackelford: What does it say about us that we all like? Yeah, that's what I was getting ready to say. Way more. Mark G.: Yeah. Cortney Harding: Yeah, I know, like, I fear spiders way more. Mike: So we're... Gene Feldman: Yeah, we- Yeah, I'm watching everybody's face and we're like, yeah, public speaking is fantastic for us. Mike: So we're all working with enterprise. I we're all working with enterprise. I mean, literally had a client this last week ask me for a full deck on wearables and AI smart glasses because they were getting ready to pass their policy of no cameras anywhere in the organization. ⁓ So they were doing a quick evaluation of things. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Hmm. Mike: How are you? How is everybody seeing this rolling out? I I have some people that have put policy in place against any camera or any hearable devices, pins or other things in the workplace. And I think they're doing that out of risk and legal first. And then they're trying to understand how they can kind of roll these things out and test and demo kind of ways. But it's, you know, I think it's just first they're afraid of it, but they really do see value out there? I mean, is anyone seeing glasses being rolled out in enterprise at this point? Cortney Harding: Yeah, but it's like specific use cases. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: testing not in scale. Makes sense for what you're doing at the big brown box. So you know I see people doing it man and I don't know if Mark you probably see it more than me but I see it happening. Mark G.: I can't talk about it at this time. Damon Shackelford: perspective. Mike: Yeah, testing, testing. Damon Shackelford: There's a reason that box is brown. Mike: Well, not you, Mark. Yeah, well, that's true. Mark G.: ⁓ But from stick that from Yeah, I mean, it's a case where certain partners in the organizations that we deal with are seeing the benefits of wearables, right? Specifically, AI glasses. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Mark G.: but also those customers dictate what their comfort level is with that product in specific enterprise settings, right? A defense customer is not going to let this go. It's no bueno, right from the start. But a, you know, a customer that may be socially or marketing based, right? They are more accepting to a traditional say electronics company that uses a fruit for their symbol where, you know, in their environment, the no Damon Shackelford: Bingo. Yep, that's right. Right, there you go. Mark G.: bueno again, right? So I would say a lot of the topic also relates to the customer dictates the rules, right? ⁓ And if you're now out on the street, right now you get real interesting, because now different customers, different perspectives. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Right. Right. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: So what I've heard is like, you know, the real risk isn't data, it isn't just a data collection. It's like who owns the model, right? Where does that data live? Who can access it? Those are the questions I'm seeing at enterprise more so, right? The trust fracture, right? Like where does that all draw the line, right? Because this isn't search history anymore. Mike: Yeah, that's tough. you're out in the... Gene Feldman: Yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: This is behavioral telemetry of your life or of your business, et cetera. So it's a little bit different of a question, right? And that's where I see them more questioning, how does this become part of our ecosystem, right? Gene Feldman: ⁓ yeah. Mark G.: Yeah, and that questioning is called guard railing, right? And that's the big challenge. And hopefully Courtney has additional items from her book on guard railing. you know, it's like, but that's the thing is that C-suite level people, right? They understand now the importance of guard railing of AI and that technology in the enterprise space. And my experience has been even Qualcomm doesn't get it. You know, like they're deploying open models on their Gene Feldman: ⁓ absolutely. Yep. Yeah. Damon Shackelford: This is Mark G.: devices and we can't have that in an enterprise. We need solutions where we can control it, define which environment, so on, so on, so on, Gene Feldman: Yeah. And, and even why I've even noticed to even take it to another level is between, let's say if you're a manufacturing company, you have HQ and the factory. The factory used to kind of be against this HQ was for it. And now it's kind of switching because you're seeing these AI analytical tools being able to capture factory process very quickly. like there's a new company out there called Rambler that's able to take a Damon Shackelford: flipped. Gene Feldman: Video recording, so if you're using the smart glasses, capture recording, load it into its engine, and the AI will spit out the standard operating procedure for that machine. that's where you're also getting that shift of that our biggest critics for a while are now kind of becoming our supporters because it's becoming easier for them to document. Cortney Harding: And I think that's the really critical thing, especially about enterprise. So there's a lot already. mean, the OG Google Glasses were 100 % flop as a consumer product, but they actually did have a pretty decent afterlife as an enterprise product. Now they're sunset completely, but people were using them in enterprise. Like, Vuzix has not a huge adoption rate, but they've got customers. And I'm getting more and more interest from folks who are wanting to use this. I mean, some of it is just the glasses needing to be tethered is a non-starter for a lot of folks. That will get solved, I imagine, pretty quickly. But yeah, I mean, think your example is a really good one where it's like, you can use the data for the, you're collecting with the glasses to create a model of, you know, here's all the processes. And then that becomes a really interesting and useful training tool. A bigger picture though, I think companies are just completely have no idea what to do. Right? So my friend shared with me this example a couple of weeks ago, I wrote about this as well, where somebody in her office wore the Meta-ray bands to work one day and everyone was panicking. And I was like, okay, let's unpack that a little bit, right? Because people already bring their phones to work. Everyone has a phone. This is just an insurance company, right? It's not like a top secret clearance type of thing. And so people already have their phones. If you want to record, you can, right? I've gone into plenty of meetings with my phone, tucked in my pocket, recording everything for different reasons. So I think like, okay, people are recording. People are taking photos. People are taking videos. Mike: Yeah. Cortney Harding: What exactly are they going to catch here? And what is, again, what is the incentive for them to do anything with it? Now, people are also idiots a lot of the time, right? Right? So like they catch something that they don't know. But this happens constantly. I mean, there's a great sort of infamous story about, you know, this guy is on the Acela train from Boston, coming back to New York, or from like D.C. back to New York. And he's like on his phone, he's a lawyer, and he's like on his phone yelling about this deal. And every fifth word, he's like, this is confidential. This is confidential. It's like... Lucky Lance K Gobindram: You Cortney Harding: Bro, you're in a train. And sitting behind him was a legal blogger who was just live tweeting the whole thing. And yeah, people do ridiculous stuff like that all the time. So the glasses might increase that a little bit. But at the end of the day, most people are not going to leak their work information, because why would they? And who would care? Your insurance company's contract is not the Pentagon Papers. I think there's a weird inflated sense of, my God, my face is somewhere. It's like, yeah, so what? Your face is in the background of two full videos everywhere. People were upset about the training data that was being shared with this Kenyan company. there was like, ⁓ well, someone was naked. It's like, yeah, humans have bodies. Woohoo, right? Who cares? And obviously, I... Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. It already is. Yeah. Mike: All right. Cortney Harding: Revenge porn is illegal, nudes is bad, all of that stuff. it's like, literally also, whatever, like some random Kenyan guy saw two seconds of you, okay, and not your face, just like, you know, chest or whatever, it's like, ⁓ okay, I guess if you want to be that concerned about it, go for it. But I think people, people just have this weird inflated sense of like over-importance of certain things. And I remember talking to somebody who's like, I would never let anyone wear glasses around my child. was like, girly pop, I've seen your Instagram. All you do is take photos of your kid. Like, I'm like, you're, you know, I'm like, you're not doing anything that people aren't doing already. And, you know, I can see a world where, you know, someone is in a, and this has happened with phones and it's going to happen with glasses real soon if it hasn't already. Mike: Yeah, right. Mark G.: You're just using the camera on your phone, okay? You know? Gene Feldman: Well, it... Yeah... ⁓ Mike: Right. Damon Shackelford: Exactly. Cortney Harding: There was a guy who would go to a park and work out and he'd sit and look at his phone and parents in this playground were like, ⁓ my God, he's videotaping our children, blah, and he was just reading his phone. People were freaking out about it. I guarantee somebody is gonna walk into a playground with their glasses on and people are gonna lose their minds. But again, why? Mike: Yep. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Mike: Yeah. Gene Feldman: Well, and I think you're seeing that too. So I have a very, love in my pop culture, I love watching, know, ⁓ I guess freak out videos. It's the best way to put it. And one of the things that you see quite often is people forgetting about the expectation of privacy. That when you're in a public place, the expectation of privacy does not exist. And, you know, and realizing that, you know, I think people kind of, like you said, it's almost like, Cortney Harding: Yeah. Yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Done. Cortney Harding: Exactly. Gene Feldman: The bubble from the pandemic, that six foot bubble, now exists for everything. Cortney Harding: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Public Freak God is amazing. Damon Shackelford: Well, part of what you're addressing here though is just basic human psychology in a modern world where the Gartner hype cycle is because we all individually have one of those in our head. That's why it works. That's why that cycle works with market segments, communities, know, small groups, large groups, test groups of all sorts, because we each have one in our heads. We all now have a Gartner hype cycle. Gene Feldman: You Mike: Ha ha ha ha. Cortney Harding: Mm. Damon Shackelford: based on both positive and negative, both input and the refusal of input, the lack of input ⁓ in our modern society that's growing around social media. So you have a number of people who are overly self-important. They think they're gonna be the next TikTok influencer. You have people that are overly paranoid. They think they're gonna be captured by, I don't know, Nigerian pirates, who knows? You know, they're there is likely to be captured by aliens from Mars, but they don't think that way. And so everybody has this hype cycle with everything in their life, whether it's glasses or new food or a new venue or anything new. We have a fear of the new. And once people get through that hype cycle and their disillusioned because no, I wasn't that important and my glasses didn't cause me to be kidnapped. Cortney Harding: Yeah! Damon Shackelford: Then they begin to build, oh well, now I can use this to record my kid on stage. And as I said to one friend who asked about, suppose somebody's watching our security camera footage. And I said, well, anybody in Asia who's getting anything out of our footage, good luck to them. They deserve what they get. Gene Feldman: Well, yeah, I think a lot of people don't remember when laptops became standard. Everybody freaked out about the laptop cameras. I remember there were even other, yeah. Well, but there was that school district that actually tapped into all the cameras. Cortney Harding: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. And they taped, I still know people who tape their cameras. It's like, what the heck? Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Wild. Mike: Ha ha. Damon Shackelford: Is that you, Mark? You tape your camera? Gene Feldman: But, you and I think. Mark G.: I played the fifth. I played the fifth. Damon Shackelford: Yeah, that's true. There are always going to be nefarious people out there. Gene Feldman: Yeah, but I think it also comes down to it is that we have gone through a huge change and a change of culture and we haven't realized it. We went from a, we do not take pictures unless we have to because to develop 12 pictures, you had to do a second mortgage on your house. You had to wait three years to get them back and you were hopefully that at least one of them wasn't your thumb over the camera. ⁓ Mike: here. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Hehehehe Damon Shackelford: versus the eight year olds who are like snapping everywhere. Snap, snap, snap, snap, snap, snap, snap. Mark G.: codec it's still an hour about digital right now I just want to mention that they're down the street codec you know this agrees yeah Gene Feldman: Yeah, so, but we went from a culture that did not take a lot of pictures to now we video everything. And so, yeah, and I think. Damon Shackelford: Hahaha Cortney Harding: Mm-hmm. Damon Shackelford: pictures everywhere, Scatter data. Cortney Harding: Yeah. Yeah. And it's really Mike: Right. Right. And that happened quickly. That happened quickly. And within the next two or three years, every earring, necklace, ring, pendant, they're all going to be recording. You know, you're going to have you're going to have AirPods with cameras, you're going to have all this. So people are just going to get used to it. Because when there's 400 million pairs of glasses deployed, it's just going to become normal. Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. They'll be recording something. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Right. And so you're then you're on that incline of, know, where you pull out of the trough of disillusionment and now you begin to actually build actual use. Cortney Harding: Yeah, it's gonna be like a... Yeah. Yeah. And I think, you know, the glasses are going to be become just more and more useful. Right. So I mean, I've seen the Google glasses. I think they're amazing. I really am hyped on those in particular because the maps are so good. Right. And just think of, mean, I live in New York City. I'm on the subway. I'm walking around all day long. And the idea of not having to like look up at my phone, look down at my phone, look up at my phone, look down at my phone. And everyone else is doing that. And it drives me insane, even though I do it as well. But the idea that you can just like have this heads up and move through the world in that way, like that's so much safer. It's so much less annoying. ⁓ The idea that your consumption will be really private is really cool. The idea of like, you're not gonna overhear everyone's TikToks on the train because it's bone conduction as opposed to people just blasting their phones like animals. ⁓ That's really cool. So I think it's, for me, it's like, how do you tell a good story about this technology? And I think that is where the biggest point of failure has happened. And I'm gonna call Meta out on this. Like Meta has done some cool stuff. They've done some cool use cases. really like some of the advertising they've done, but they have not gotten to a point where they've kind of overcome the negativity to tell a compelling story, right? And they think... Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. Actually, they've done damage to a compelling story. In my humble opinion, they've fumbled the ball multiple times. I'm sorry, I just gotta call a spade a spade. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Cortney Harding: Yeah, but I think, yeah. Yeah, no, they have. No, they have. So I think Google coming to market is gonna be interesting. Again, you see like these independent brands, know, Mentra, even realities, even realities glasses don't have cameras, ⁓ which I think is a limitation because, you you need a camera for like object recognition. So I think that's gonna hold them back a little bit, but they're cool glasses. Mentra, think is really, Mentra is just starting. They're really interesting. Mike: It'll help. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Thank Gene Feldman: Yeah. And then you have like. Cortney Harding: Google coming to market. mean, whatever, Apple's gonna probably come to market in a couple of years and that's gonna be huge. Although, yeah. Gene Feldman: I know. Mark G.: 2027. Damon Shackelford: but it's gonna be full of ads. Just kidding! Gene Feldman: Yeah. But then you have these. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: HAHAHAHA Mike: Okay. Mark G.: Hey, by then, ChatGPT will have ads. Who knows? Gene Feldman: Yeah, but then you have the smaller companies like. Cortney Harding: Thanks. Mike: ⁓ They're going to bring back ⁓ IAD. It'll be IAD. Damon Shackelford: Wait, chat GPT isn't had. I see what you did there. Cortney Harding: Yeah. Well, Chad's the Walmart thing. So are people up on this Chad GPT Walmart thing? Like the Walmart, they were doing a partnership with Walmart. I guess it's over very quickly. Yeah, that I thought was kind of interesting. Um, cause I think we're also, so to get back to the hype cycle comments, cause I think there's a lot to unpack there, right? We're at this crazy space or stage with AI in particular, where people have such inflated expectations that people that run these companies have Gene Feldman: But I need to Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Hahaha It is. Yeah, that fumbled. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Yes. Cortney Harding: I mean, talk about fumbling. my God. You know, I'm like, stop going on TV and saying it's going to take everyone's job guys. Like just shut up. Like just don't say that. I don't know what their particular like fetish for that is. Yeah. Like, ⁓ my God. It's like, it's just, they're all weirdos. They're all nuts. mean, whatever. I'm not gonna, they're, all crazy people. Damon Shackelford: ⁓ yeah... Every day. Hahaha! Gene Feldman: Yeah, it's a... Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Because it's not, it's not gonna take everybody's job. That's not happening, Damon Shackelford: I know you're a founder, but please stop talking. Gene Feldman: Yeah, but it's. Yeah. Well, it's the instant gratification. It's like, all right, you know, like I'm sure you guys have also experienced this, especially in change management that you're like, all right, here's my plan. Oh, we can't do that right now. No, this is like a five year plan. All right, let's stop looking at tomorrow and let's look at the landscape. Let's look at the forest through the trees. And I think what happens a lot of times, they're making these very split second decisions. Damon Shackelford: Yeah, yeah. Cortney Harding: Yeah. for Gene Feldman: without thinking about the longevity of what's gonna happen because. Damon Shackelford: sometimes right in the middle of an interview too. It's like, holy smoke, somebody pit tape over that guy's mouth. Gene Feldman: Yeah, absolutely. Well, it's like the number of companies that are saying we digitally transformed. No, you've adopted Copilot. Mark G.: Yes. Sustainability is a thing. Cortney Harding: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Or you bought Office 365. Big deal. Courtney, did we just give you an out coronary? And you're like, da! Cortney Harding: ⁓ my god, this is like, just- Gene Feldman: Yeah, no, you have not digitally transformed. Courtney, saw your face. I can't wait to hear it. Cortney Harding: No, so I, okay, so. Gene Feldman: The hair's going back, she's ready. Damon Shackelford: I know, right? Cortney Harding: So, okay, a friend of mine works for a bank, like a big bank. I won't say which one. Big bank. I'll, know, bleep out the name or something. Anyway, big bank. So she, so I was hanging out with her and she was watching the town hall, right? The, you know, end of year town hall that the CEO was doing. And I was like, all right, I'll watch this a little bit. And a lot of it was kind of boring, but then it got to the AI part. I was like, ⁓ this is going to be good. So this guy's up on stage and he's like, we're an AI first and we're transforming and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Damon Shackelford: ⁓ We can edit it later. A friend who works for a bee... Yeah. Cortney Harding: And then he's like, and everyone has Copilot. I was like, okay. Like, mean, Copilot's fine. I don't think it's the best product out there, but like, it's not bad, but it's kind of functionally not much. And what was that interesting? Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Woohoo! Mike: Did they cheer? Did they cheer? Gene Feldman: It's not digital transformation. It's a system adoption. Damon Shackelford: was very kind of him. Cortney Harding: Right. So what was interesting after that was like, there were actually some good use cases that this person highlighted. So there was one team that was like, ⁓ we're using Chad GPT to create like custom personas. Fine. Great. Good use case. There was another comp, there was another part of the business that was using like, you know, really good data analytics powered by AI and kind of that was saving them time. And so there were some good, interesting little use cases scattered throughout, but none of them were scaling in a meaningful way. was like, ⁓ this team kind of figured out how to do this. This team kind of figured out how to do this. there was no sort of like top-down vision, right? It was just co-pilot and then a bunch of random projects. And I think that's, and that's not, mean, like I'll rag on this one because I thought it was funny, but that's like most companies, like most companies now are using, you know, really, they have a handful of really basic tools, which are quite useful and fine, but like nothing earth shattering. And then they kind of have random people doing random projects here and there, but there's no kind of grand overall vision. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Cheers. Mike: That's where they are. Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Cortney Harding: And I think that's where a lot of people are getting stuck with AI is because they want it to do more than it can. And it really isn't. And I think there's part of it too, is like the walled gardens of everything. So I'll give you an example. When I was traveling last month, I was on the road and I was supposed to fly home to New York and the big blizzard hit. So Delta sends me a note, my flight has been canceled. I was like, okay, and? So I should have just been able to have my own agent be like, rebook me on the next day. Here's the seat I want. Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. Cortney Harding: do it and get it done in 10 minutes or two minutes, right? Instead I'm like on the chat thread trying to navigate whatever terrible screening feature AI they have and then waiting and waiting and waiting. And like, why? Why couldn't I just like send my agent into Delta to rebook me? Because Delta won't let me, right? This Walmart chat GPT thing falling apart I think is probably an example of like how the walled garden of a Walmart couldn't quite adapt to AI, right? I would love to have, I mean, you know, Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. Cortney Harding: There's so much stuff I would love to have AI do that it functionally cannot because other things won't let it. like LinkedIn, you know, I would love to have AI go through my LinkedIn messages and be like, find every message that ends with just kind of like, let's get a coffee sometime. Right? Because everyone has those exchanges. It's like, yeah, let's catch up. And then somebody goes, whatever. Right? Lucky Lance K Gobindram: It dies on the vine. ⁓ Damon Shackelford: Totally. Mark G.: Courtney, didn't do open claw yet on that? Come on, that was last week. Open claw, know, just LinkedIn, open claw. Bam, done. Happy birthday, Courtney, right? Lucky Lance K Gobindram: OpenClaw is amazing. I set up a cloud to go to market and it's amazing things. Cortney Harding: Open! Yeah, I- I've heard enough horror stories about Oak and Claw to like be a little skeptical of it, right? Like I've just, I mean that's, maybe that's just me. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: If you said it, we're correct, it works, Corb, for real. Enterprise equals a controlled upside, right? And then consumer is uncontrolled exposure, right? And you're showing examples where the consumer meets the enterprise, right? enterprise is limited, because they're going to wall the garden and they're going to control your upside internally and externally. And then the consumer has this untethered, unchanged thing. You use things at a much more rapid pace and you don't have limitations because Mark G.: It's a miracle. It's a miracle. Cortney Harding: Okay. to. Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: You can do whatever you want as a consumer, right? As much as you want to feed and give it. Gene Feldman: it. As well as I think to tack on to that Lucky, one thing we forget about too is not only are consumers ahead of enterprises on a lot of this, but even on just operating systems for PCs. I mean think of how many enterprises now are still running Windows 10 or Windows 11 and all these new software, these new solutions like ⁓ Space Top, they require AI machines. Companies aren't buying them. So now we're not only asking for them to spend money and invest on this new technology We're asking them to re outfit all of their existing technology because I mean The last company I was at if Windows update came out IT had to have it for at least six months before it was even thought about rolling out You know, I think that's another thing that we we forget about is that that Mike: Yeah, it's slow. Gene Feldman: I think sometimes we chalk it up to being, ⁓ it's the powers that be or the decision makers, but sometimes just the system, the way it's set up is inherently a roadblock against us. Cortney Harding: Yeah, there's a lot of legacy systems out there that are really, I mean, kind of absurd, right? you know, checking into hotel is a good example. You know, the fact that somebody's sitting there typing and typing for 15 minutes while I'm like, can I just have my room key, please? Right? Like, that's because their systems are ancient and they... So I think there's like all these incentive mismatches, right? Because I would love to just have AI do so much of my life. But if everyone has that, then that... Mark G.: Yeah, those are legacy systems. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Mike: Mm-hmm. Cortney Harding: you know, that's hard for like airlines, right? Like I use airline miles a lot. I'd love to have AI just like find my flights. But part of the barrier that the airlines have put up is like, no, you really have to work to find these flights to book them with miles, right? If everyone can all of a sudden do it, then they're disincentivized from doing that. You know, so I think there's like a real like a lot of incentive mismatches that we're going to start running into. And like, you know, I'd be curious to see if people are applying for like government assistance with AI. Because I think that's Damon Shackelford: Hmm. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: There is somebody who created a program that does this, that literally is helping people do this right now and they're getting much higher throughput. I'll dig up the name. It's kind of amazing to see what it's capable when you use the technology for good and in the right way. It's superhuman performance, right? Cortney Harding: Amazing. Amazing. Yeah, because that's like the best use case I could think of. So when I was in graduate school, I went to graduate school for public policy, a degree that I have never really used professionally, but I have to pay for for many years. Thank you NYU. Go violence. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: You Gene Feldman: That sounds like a good policy to share with the public then. Cortney Harding: Yes. But like, you know, one of the things that I did was I volunteered at a center that helped people who were, you know, struggling apply for like public assistance. And those forms are hard. Like I was a graduate student at a top 10 program, right. And I was having a hard time figuring out how to do it. So if you're 19 years old and dropped out of high school or English is your second language and you're struggling, right. It's set up to be hard, right. These programs are set up to be hard to get. Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Cortney Harding: So if all of a sudden chat GPT is doing everything for you, like that's actually a or whatever AI system, like that's actually a huge, incredible benefit. But then that kind of messes things up because the whole point is like, well, we offer aid, but we're actually not giving it to anyone. Right. And so how do you kind of, yeah, they want people to fail. There are a lot of systems that are set up to make things difficult for people. Right. And what AI can do is like overcome that pretty quickly. But then how do those, how do people push back on that? Lucky Lance K Gobindram: They want people to fail. They do. Gene Feldman: Yeah, and I think this comes down to ⁓ part of the human condition that AI, sorry, I harp on that the AI can't ever understand the human condition. Because one, we love adversity. You know, like I was actually just talking with my sister last night. grew up, my sister and I grew up very dysfunctional. When it's hitting the fan, we are in our element. You know, and, but the thing is, is that in order to have learned that, we have to learn how to fail. Mike: Yeah. Cortney Harding: Mm-hmm. Gene Feldman: And if AI never allows us to fail, do we ever truly learn from a true educational standpoint? Damon Shackelford: That's tough. Mark G.: Yeah, and that's a really important thing in training, right? Is you need to fail. So AI does it for you. Damon Shackelford: Right. Right. Mike: Right. Gene Feldman: Yeah, because I mean the most basic definition of learning is anything that changes behavior as a result of experience. If we remove experience, know, I mean, it's almost like when we have a child, you know, you have your kid and it's going to do something. You question, do I stop them or do I just let it happen? Damon Shackelford: You Mike: Without getting myself into any trouble here, two things. So Courtney, I'm gonna try not to. ⁓ There are absolutely government agencies on the state level that are now using AI systems to help streamline processes that are just horrible, including Mark G.: Spit back at the popcorn. Watch it happen. Damon Shackelford: ⁓ come on. Come on, Mark G.: Come on, Mike. Let's go. Cortney Harding: Yeah, good. Damon Shackelford: That's good to hear. Mike: A big one that is growing in importance and that's labor and the ability to get back to work some type of work. ⁓ Things that, you know, the DMV, but the things that are just, they're overwhelmed. They don't have the resources and you can cut out 80 % of the process of when you walk into one of these locations through this technology. So there's so much opportunity. Think about all the ways that we touch just services that we need. And so I think just as in our industry, there's so much opportunity there. And then the other one is training. ⁓ I mean, we're involved in some ⁓ live role playing sales enablement training that is just getting early, tremendous feedback. And this is from people that were very skeptical and didn't really want to talk to the AI, but then came out of it, throwing out a hundred ideas about how to make it better and how they will use it more. Damon Shackelford: Mm. Mike: with better features. So, I mean, think humans will enable this. Cortney Harding: Yeah, I worked on that. I worked on a similar project. Yeah, I worked on a similar project in 2024 and 25 with AI-powered virtual human avatars for training. And like phenomenal how well it went. mean, really, really, really good stuff and huge performance improvements, right? I think that's not shocking to anyone. But yeah, I think once people sort of get over that initial queasiness about it, then they get into it very quickly. And I think that a lot of... Damon Shackelford: That's all. Cortney Harding: What people are seeing is kind of negativity around AI because again, these CEOs won't shut up about how it's going to take everyone's job. But also, you know, there's a lot of like water usage and data centers and it's all sort of not very well informed, but I think people just have this weird anger about it. And Mark G.: Humans like to focus on the negatives, not the positives, by nature. Cortney Harding: Yeah, they like that. we have not done a good job communicating all the upsides and benefits. And if I look at where I'm using AI the most, it's pretty basic, simple stuff for me, but it's so helpful. I use it to build all my decks. It's still my ideas, my intellectual property. I'm just not a great deck builder. I hate Google Slides. It makes me miserable. I just dump everything in Genspark. Again, it's all my ideas. I dump it in Genspark, and it spits me out like a... Gene Feldman: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Yeah, yeah, we believe bad news first. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Thank Mm-hmm. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Cortney Harding: decent looking deck that's 80 % of the way down. I'm like, great, 25 bucks a month. Love it, right? Gene Feldman: Yeah, but the nice thing about that is, I've noticed I've started doing that with a lot of my writing. And it's changed me from either being a writer or being a designer to a producer. That was the difference between me telling an intern, okay, this is what I need you to do, and double checking the intern's work, or telling the AI co-pilot, this is what I need you to do. ⁓ Damon Shackelford: funny. Cortney Harding: Take my money. Yeah. Yeah. Damon Shackelford: ⁓ I know what the difference is. The difference is someday you could hire the intern. Gene Feldman: Absolutely, because the skills. Mark G.: It's accountable. The intern's actually accountable for it versus the AI. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Is it? You think the internet's more accountable than the AI? Damon Shackelford: you Gene Feldman: Cough. Cough. Mark G.: AI is not accountable. Someone will get blamed for what the AI does. 100%. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Cause even in our conversations, we've talked about the hidden man behind the curtain, you know, of the programmer, whoever has the keys to the kingdom of the code. know, and, but it gets into that thing that, like I said, going back to that, even I've noticed in my writing, it's allowing me to actually take more time to be more creative in my writing because I don't have to worry about the rules of grammar. I'm allowing AI to take care of that so I can have more free thoughts. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: but I may do a better job. Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. Cortney Harding: Yeah. I mean, I think there's an idea of like, everyone has their quote unquote zone of genius, right? And everyone has things they like doing, don't like doing. And there's a lot of variation across that, right? Like I think about when I was visiting my folks recently, they're retired. They've been retired for 20 years now at this point. Like they're just, they're just chilling all day. So like they love just going to the grocery store and walking around and like they'll chat with the lady at the bakery and they'll, they're like friends with the woman at the Starbucks. And for me, that's like, like I am in and out of the grocery store in 10 minutes. Gene Feldman: I don't know. Damon Shackelford: Wow. Cortney Harding: And I'm like, done. Right. So for them, some sort of AI solution to that problem would not be great. Whereas for me, I'd like, love it. I was just saying to my husband earlier tonight, cause we were having that, you know, 5 PM, what are we going to do for dinner conversation that we have every day? And I was like, ⁓ my God, I just, wish I could just be like, here's my, here's my nutrition profile. Here's the macros I to hit. Here's this. just, Chad GPT make it happen. Right. Whereas other people like love. Gene Feldman: You Damon Shackelford: Make it happen. Yeah. Yeah. Cortney Harding: farmers markets and food. And there's stuff that other people would find boring that I love to do. So I think the idea is really how do we build these solutions to kind of get all the negativity, not all the negativity, because I think their negativity builds growth, but all of that just kind of like, I don't want to go to the grocery store. just have something else can do it for me. And how do we build those solutions and make sure that then I can spend more time doing what I actually enjoy doing, whether that's the work I work on or reading a book or watching a movie or spending time with friends. Because I think people are like, stressed, they're overbooked, they're overworked. So can this technology solve those problems? And I think right now, unfortunately, it really can't. And this is born out, and research has come out recently. it's creating more work than it's saving, right? Now that's going to level off. But I think that's, again, where people are sort of in this trough of disillusionment, is they're like, I was promised something amazing, and it's giving me something with a lot of ⁓ dashes. Damon Shackelford: Yeah, I was also promised flying cars by now in my life and I don't have those either. Cortney Harding: I ain't not flying, self driving, not flying yet. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: It's coming, Dan, it's coming. Mike: Ha ha ha. Gene Feldman: What we. Mark G.: How much do you feel this feels similar to like the initial hype of VR? Like, do you guys feel the same sort of vibe? Like AI right now versus the vibe of... No? It's just corporate greed. Corporate greed's just pumping it. Damon Shackelford: No, this is intensified. This is intensified. Yeah. And the amount of money being thrown at this. don't know that it's corporate greed, but there's crazy amount of money. Cortney Harding: No, it's crazier. They are never held like that. Vera never had like that big of a negativity around it. Gene Feldman: yet. To me, VR could never get over the final hump to get people truly excited. You're watching enterprises now pulling back on XR pretty good. I think the form factor is what set it apart. Mark G.: So the intrusion, the intrusiveness of the technology is really what hinders that platform. First, AI, it's sort of that ambient intelligence, sort of, ⁓ I just talk to it like it's my friend and hope it's right. Gene Feldman: Yep, and then when we get the display glasses and the AR glasses, we're going to sneak XR back in like an aspirin for a dog. Okay, we're using the AI and the form factor to bring you in. Now we're going to show you the really cool stuff and we're going to get back to it. But it's going to be different than the full immersion. It's going to have to adapt. But right now, it's one of those things that... Damon Shackelford: Well. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: the convergence. Gene Feldman: Do we fight AI, for those of us that have been in the XR field for years, we truly have to ask ourselves, do we fight XR? Or do we fight AI or do we ride its coattails to the finish line? Mark G.: No, because of XR, you're an enabler, right? Because you see the platforms that it can go to, right? From the humanistic side. Gene Feldman: Yeah, absolutely. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah. AI's the beachhead. Cortney Harding: It's also going to like supercharge content creation, right? So if you can do like right now, it's still very early, but Google has genie and there's world labs out of Stanford, Feifei Li's project and other people are starting to build this as well. So, you know, one of the biggest barriers to entry for training was the cost of the headsets and the hardware, but it was also the cost of content creation, right? So now you're at a point where like, I mean, I can do 360, I do 360 stuff all the time and it's great. And my little camera's here and I've, that's what I do a lot of now is upskill people in enterprise. Mike: Mm-hmm. Damon Shackelford: ⁓ yeah. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Content. Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm, that's right. That's exactly right. Mike: No. Cortney Harding: to be content creators on their own. So with the 360 stuff, that's easier to do once you know what you're doing. There's plenty of platforms we can interactive, there are no code, low code, but the stuff that now, otherwise you need the Unity developer to build and that's time and money and challenging. If you can just, again, do the prompt based stuff, I mean, that's bad for Unity devs, cause that'll cut their workload, but it's great for enterprise because then again, it's like, the problem with VR is there just wasn't enough content. And this is, I've been saying this for years and it's gonna go on my gravestone or whatever, but like. Mike: Yep. Damon Shackelford: You Cortney Harding: Courtney Harding, she yelled about VR content, RIP, know, 100 years or whatever. don't know, we're like, 50 years. ⁓ But like, you know, the thing is now that we can, so the reason we're like addicted to these freaking things all the time is because there's so much stuff on there. There's never an end of it, right? I have a Vision Pro sitting next to me that was not cheap. I've watched every single piece of content that exists on the Vision Pro. And it's a great headset and I love it to bits, but... Mike: You Damon Shackelford: Ha ha! Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Yep, and they're so easy. Cortney Harding: there's just there's not enough to do, right? It's like the early days of the internet where you could like catalog every website, you know? So I feel like the content creation once it gets supercharged with AI is gonna like, I think be hugely beneficial for VR. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Mm-hmm. Gene Feldman: Yeah, well it- Damon Shackelford: I agree. Yeah. Gene Feldman: Absolutely, and Courtney, to your point, you brought up Unity. mean, with Unity coming out with Unity Studio over the past couple of months, which is a low-code, no-code Unity, that it's going to allow people to even... The full Unity certification is only going to be now for those people that are really deep into it, but it's giving everybody the chance to do this. Mark G.: For the record, I'm Matt at Matt from Unity, the CEO of Unity because Studio does not work with OpenClaw. Just saying. Matt, we need to have a coffee. Gene Feldman: Nice little plug for Unity. Mike: Has anyone? Go ahead. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Not yet, it's coming, it's coming. mean they've done some of their... They've done some things with good AI pipeline, they're working towards it. Gene Feldman: Okay. Damon Shackelford: Like the juice. Gene Feldman: So Matt has been called out personally to fix this. Damon Shackelford: ⁓ that'll put us on the radar. ⁓ Mike, did you start to say something intelligent? Did you start to say something? What was, what were you going? ⁓ Mark G.: He's the Unity CEO, he better get going. Anyway. Mike: not intelligent, but I just was curious, has anyone had any experience with lenses with the actual? I mean, I haven't seen them. But I keep hearing that, that immersive, you know, contact lenses are coming, that, that we're gonna that we're gonna be able to and then then where are we? I mean, then people are really gonna have things going on inside of their view that others don't know about, right? Damon Shackelford: NASA. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: A lot of contacts kind of got it. Damon Shackelford: I haven't seen anything. No. I've seen some process applications for micro deposition to get the stacks inside of the lens space, but I've not seen anything real beyond a few patent applications. Gene Feldman: Yeah, I've heard it. Mark G.: I can't comment on that. I can't comment on that, Mike. Mike: Offline. Gene Feldman: Yeah. Mike: Yep, I think that's where we are. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Mark knows something he doesn't want to Gene Feldman: And I'm still, but I mean, I'm still waiting for the feature that was promised years ago that these glasses will be able to adapt to our vision. I mean, that was one of the early promises that was a, I can't remember the name of the company, but they were acquired by one of the other bigger companies, the Metaverse company. ⁓ Damon Shackelford: Do what? Mike: We'll talk offline. Damon Shackelford: ⁓ like- Mark G.: No, no. Remember there was the whole Intel glasses that would ⁓ take lasers and splash them into your retinas of your eyes? Whatever happened to that? Whatever happened to that? It was low power too. It was green light. It arc in from your sides and reflect. And it was really cool stuff. It was really cool stuff. Whatever happened to stuff like that? The reality is this. Big companies acquire the innovation, and they stomp it out. Gene Feldman: It was lasers being splashed into your eyes, I think. Cortney Harding: See you on. Gene Feldman: It's well. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Kill him. Gene Feldman: Yep. It happens more times than I think a lot of us care to count. Mark G.: That competitive advantage word, it's terrible. It's terrible word. It's curse word in innovation. Yeah. Gene Feldman: Yeah. And that's why I think, and I think that's why one of the things that we really want to try to do with this podcast too, is also bring a lot of these early innovators on. I mean, like the guys from Ditty Lens. I mean, I'm glad they're still going strong, you know, but we, you do, you watch a lot of these companies that just kind of disappear or some of these companies that had such a great idea, but it just never got the traction it needed. So. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: The product you're talking about is Vaunt at Intel and they shelved it but it was definitely influential. It was retinal projection, also known as laser scanning displays. The other company that was doing this was North or they were making Focals by North. Google acquired them. They were amazing. They had that shop in Brooklyn Heights and they were like when they launched it was so sweet. Google shelved that after their acquisition. ⁓ Damon Shackelford: Yeah. Cortney Harding: ⁓ love those. Love those. Damon Shackelford: That got Courtney going. Cortney Harding: Yeah. Damon Shackelford: Wow. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Magic Leap was doing some stuff, but not pure retinal, but similar Wave Guy innovation. There was Microvision early on, but that technology was really, really, really cool. Right? But like, ⁓ yeah, big companies buy things, they eat innovation, the shellbone happens. Candy for breakfast. Mike: Uh-huh. Damon Shackelford: Yeah, that was one of the things that bit Enterprise early on when they were going through their digital twin phase in the factories and process industry. They would buy a promising little piece of software and then Unity would snap up and acquire that software company and shut the whole thing down. And there was Enterprise left empty-handed. What happened to our twin? Sorry, that's not supported anymore. Mark G.: It ⁓ was actually Siemens, it wasn't Unity, just for the record. Gene Feldman: Well, it. Damon Shackelford: No, the one that happened to my free-risk company was Unity. Gene Feldman: look at what just happened with Ready Player Me and Netflix. So many early companies were dependent on Ready Player Me for their infrastructure because they were willing to provide it and now it's Lucky Lance K Gobindram: did some dope shot of it netflix did some cool stuff with it though jane have you gone to netflix and like gone and played games on there actually and built avatars Gene Feldman: No, no, no, I don't doubt it's going to be cool. really, yeah, I'm excited to, mean, I don't necessarily go to Netflix to play games, but for me, it's the hoarding of a great resource for something like that. so for me, I mean, do they have the right to do it? ⁓ absolutely. Do I agree with it? It kind of rubs me the wrong way sometimes, but that's just the nature of it. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: My kids love it. Damon Shackelford: You ⁓ well. So how do we wrap this back around to ⁓ A, the title? I think Mark dropped that into our chat. And then ⁓ B, give Courtney the last word because we're coming up on our witching hour and I don't know about you guys, but I'm an old man and I need to go to bed. Gene Feldman: ⁓ absolutely! Mark G.: This is why I liked hanging out with Damon when he was my co-chair. Wrap it up. Gene Feldman: No. Damon Shackelford: He's like, alright, we're done here, come on. Gene Feldman: Yeah, no, absolutely. ⁓ no, I have to say I've been watching the clock profusely. We're at an hour and yeah, it's right in front of me an hour and four minutes. Mike: Thank Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Got a roof down there, you know, little bar. Mark G.: So with that, me. Lucky Lance K Gobindram: ⁓ Damon Shackelford: Profusely? Profusely? Are you sure? Gene Feldman: Yes, I like that word, just deal with it. Damon Shackelford: ChatGPT, tell me about Perfusely. Cortney Harding: you Gene Feldman: You know what? I am from the Midwest. I can't help it that people from the Midwest don't speak our lingo. Okay. Mike: Thank Damon Shackelford: haha Lucky Lance K Gobindram: Yeah Damon Shackelford: I'm gonna get meme-memed later. Gene Feldman: Yeah, you know what? Us Midwestern people are just a different folk out here. Anyways. So, ⁓ but no, so this, think the conversation's really, I think, really circled around that whole idea of eyes of a stranger, that whole concept of what AI can do. I think even though we kind of went off tangent, I think we hit a lot of the key questions that either enterprises or people entering this that are having. And our hope is that if you're listening in from an enterprise, this gives you some food for thought. Damon Shackelford: You a- Gene Feldman: But if you're also a change leader, if you're in this world, you're not alone. We are all kind of fighting this fight and trying to figure out the solutions together. ⁓ But before we end, Courtney, with our NEOM protocol, what's the final protocol you wanna leave us with? Cortney Harding: I would say, you know, embrace curiosity. If you're in this space, like there's a lot out there. There's a lot of negativity out there right now. It's understandable why given everything, but I would say the more you can be creative and curious, ⁓ the better off you're going to be as you start building. ⁓ if you are interested in, I'll just do my little pitch and then we can wrap it. you're interested in learning more, ⁓ the spatial race is available on amazon.com now. ⁓ I'm, you know, it's, it's, I'm happy with it. I've gotten some great reviews. My mom wrote a really nice review of it. So, you know, find the book that my mom liked. And if you know my mom, which many of you do, but if you did know my mom, you would know that she really, she has to really like something to actually write a good review of it. So I was just like, she would have super coded it if she didn't like it. So yeah. And you can find me on LinkedIn, Instagram. Damon Shackelford: Ha Cortney Harding: all over the place and Friends with Holograms is my company and I love talking about this stuff. This is really fun despite everything kind of crazy happening. So thank you guys so much for having me. This has been a real blast. Gene Feldman: No, we absolutely loved having you. if there's ever a time that you want to be that you've that there's something good in the headlines, you're like, you know what, I would love to come back to share. There will always be a chair open for you. So we would love to have you back. Damon Shackelford: I don't know. Cortney Harding: Thank Damon Shackelford: Great, thank you.