Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 16)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:03Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to pick up
- 0:06where we left off with the Alex Acosta OIG interview. Question.
- 0:11This is where there is a mention of computer equipment.
- 0:14There is a provision later in that in that same
- 0:17paragraph that provides that the federal grand jury investigation will
- 0:21be suspended and all pending federal grand jury subpoenas will
- 0:25be held in abeyance unless and until the defendant violates
- 0:29any term of this agreement. The defendant likewise agrees to
- 0:32withdraw his pending motion to intervene and quash certain grand
- 0:36jury subpoenas. Both parties agree to maintain their evidence, specifically
- 0:40evidence requested by or directly related to the grand jury
- 0:44subpoenas that have been issued and including certain computer equipment
- 0:49in violate, until all the terms of the agreement have
- 0:52been satisfied. Do you view that disagreement to suspect at
- 0:57least certain aspects of the federal investigation to have been
- 1:01an appropriate concession? Answer? You know, again, my focus was
- 1:05on certain points. I would have assumed reading this that
- 1:08this was thought through. Question. Okay, question, all right, there
- 1:13is what's been criticized as a confidentiality provision. Answer, yes,
- 1:18question right, And that's on the same page, page five,
- 1:21paragraph number thirteen, which provides that the parties anticipate that
- 1:26this agreement will not be made part of any public record,
- 1:30and then there is an exception for FOYA or a
- 1:33compulsory process from a court in which the government will
- 1:36provide notice to epstein. That seems to be limited to
- 1:40the placing of this document on the public record right
- 1:43as opposed to sharing it or disclosing it for whatever
- 1:46purpose to individuals. Is that a distinction that makes sense? Answer,
- 1:51that's a fair distinction. Upon reading this, I'm not sure
- 1:54that it's a distinction that was I mean, I'm basing
- 1:58that on my reading currently and not as a recollection question.
- 2:03And in fact, the party's both Defense Council and even
- 2:06the US Attorney's Office took the position that this should
- 2:09have never been or seen the light of day, even
- 2:12to be disclosed to you know, victims or other parties
- 2:15and interest except for filing it or accept for sharing
- 2:19it on a limited basis with law enforcement. I think
- 2:23there were emails that talk about if we share it,
- 2:25we'll tell them not to disclose it. Answer mm hmmm.
- 2:30Question is that the sort of overstating what this paragraph requires? Answer? Possibly,
- 2:37I can, you know, we can get into that and
- 2:39we can discuss it. I would need to understand a
- 2:41little bit more. I know there was litigation around disclosure
- 2:45on this, and I need to understand much more the
- 2:48position that we took and the why before commenting on
- 2:51them question. In Exhibit twenty three, there's a discussion of
- 2:56whether the NPA is after it has been signed, could
- 2:59be revealed, the existence of it could be revealed to
- 3:02the police chief or even the FBI or the girls
- 3:06and redacted in the middle of the page one or
- 3:09two thirds of the way down on page one of
- 3:11Exhibit twenty three proposes that if we tell anybody about
- 3:15the NPA, you just asked that the recipient of that
- 3:19information not disclose it. And you then at the top
- 3:22of the page to Laurie and to redacted and redacted
- 3:25who is going to take over Lurie's position as a
- 3:28managing a USA and West Palm Beach should talk with
- 3:31you about it on Wednesday. You should talk about who
- 3:36will tell and how much do you remember that conversation? Answer?
- 3:39I don't. I know that there were several concerns about
- 3:42leaks and media, and I imagine that we had a
- 3:46conversation quite literally about who to tell and how much?
- 3:50Question and how did you feel that this at the time,
- 3:55as best as you recall, did you feel that this
- 3:57clause bound you to not tell anyone? Answer? So my
- 4:01recollection of the clause, whether it was whether it was
- 4:04this clause or whether there was a discussion, I was
- 4:08aware of this provision, and my recollection of this provision
- 4:11is at some point it was raised as something that
- 4:15was the subject of negotiation. Question okay, answer that the
- 4:21office policy was that these types of deferred prosecution agreement
- 4:25is not just made part of the public record. Therefore,
- 4:29this is not a substantial concession because in the typical
- 4:32course of business, this would not be part of the
- 4:35public record. Question and that's because its non prosecution as
- 4:40opposed agreement as opposed to a deferred prosecution agreement. Answer, So,
- 4:45deferred prosecution is not you know, if the non prosecution
- 4:49is not typically part of the public record, the deferred prosecution,
- 4:53it makes sense that it follows the same. And so
- 4:56it seemed that it seemed a concession. I understand how
- 5:00was perceived publicly after the fact. At the time, it
- 5:03seemed that we weren't giving up much because the typical
- 5:06policy is this is not part of the public record,
- 5:09and individuals need to file a FOYA. And so by
- 5:13saying it's not part of the public record and individuals
- 5:16need to follow FOYA, if that is viewed as a concession,
- 5:19it really isn't question. So how would I mean? Did
- 5:24is it? Is it understandable that Epstein would not want
- 5:27this document to see the light of day because it
- 5:29describes the existence and nature and scope of the federal
- 5:33investigation and also his concession to liability under twenty two
- 5:37to fifty five answer, it's understandable. It was also my
- 5:41impression at the time that it would see the light
- 5:43of day because if victims have twenty two to fifty
- 5:46five the ability to get twenty two to fifty five,
- 5:49they obviously have to hear about it from somewhere, and
- 5:52given the press interest, eventually this would be FOYA. And
- 5:56so from my thinking at the time, rightly or wrongly,
- 5:58this is a concession that's basically saying we'll follow off
- 6:01his policy and we're likely going to be foyed on
- 6:04this anyhow, and it can play out in the FOYA
- 6:07and so is this really a concession question? All right?
- 6:12Another piece of the agreement is something that is absent
- 6:16and that sort of typical language that you find, I
- 6:18think in pretty much any federal plea agreement, which is
- 6:21this agreement only the defendant understands that this agreement only
- 6:26binds the US Attorney's office for whatever district he or
- 6:29she is in answer right, you know? And that and
- 6:34that truly what you would call global dispositions are unusual
- 6:38answer right for the federal government answer and I would note,
- 6:42you know, and this is after the fact that it
- 6:45does say this district agrees question okay, understood, And it's
- 6:49also has you as a party, not the Department of
- 6:52Justice answer right, question. But it does omit that standard language.
- 6:57And you know whether that was done sort of by
- 6:59mistake or consciously answer. I can't speak to that question,
- 7:04all right. Another piece is phrasing that you injected when
- 7:07you addressed the first where was it was towards the
- 7:09end where you talked about injecting the best effort language
- 7:14answer yes, question, okay? Does it what I believe you
- 7:19made clear why you did that? That is to avoid
- 7:22the appearance of having the federal government be dictating anything.
- 7:26But why rely on the best efforts and to what
- 7:28extent is that even enforceable? Answer? So, first, let me
- 7:33let me say that it was not to avoid the appearance.
- 7:36It was to avoid the actual legal discovery dictating. But
- 7:40so Epstein understands that he has no authority to require
- 7:44to undertake discussions and to use if he did not plead,
- 7:48then there was no agreement. Question No, no, no, no, no, sorry,
- 7:53I don't mean to. It appears in paragraph number eleven,
- 7:56Epstein shall use his best effort to enter his guilty
- 7:58plea and be sentenced later than the set date. And
- 8:02then in the first paragraph after numbered clause eleven, he
- 8:05will use his best efforts to ensure compliance with certain
- 8:08procedures and best efforts to convince the Judge of the
- 8:11Florida Court to accept as binding recommendation. So best efforts
- 8:16kind of become a sticking point an enforcement, didn't it,
- 8:20Because what does it mean? What does best effort mean? Answer? So,
- 8:25I think it's fair to say that one of the
- 8:26issues that came up after this was entered into the
- 8:29US Attorney's office at least from My perspective was in
- 8:33a little bit of a bind because we had agreed
- 8:36to this, yet he wasn't turning himself in, and so
- 8:39how do we deal with that? And so that's not
- 8:41a phrase that I focused on at the time. But
- 8:44I understand your point. All right, I'm going to move
- 8:47on from those question. Is there anything else on those
- 8:51NPA clauses? Answer? Finally, let me let me just say,
- 8:55you didn't ask. We had an incredibly experienced attorney in
- 8:58the office assumed, rightly or wrongly, that the language had
- 9:02been thought through and vetted. And you know, sitting here
- 9:05twelve years later, I understand the issues that have arisen
- 9:08from it, but at the time these were not issues
- 9:11that were folk that we were focused on. Question, to
- 9:13your knowledge, who was involved in the drafting other than
- 9:16redacted and redacted on your side? Answer right, question and
- 9:21LORI and you to some extent answer So I can't
- 9:25say twelve years after the fact, but again, redacted, LORII,
- 9:28very experienced head of the Palm Beach Office, has prosecuted
- 9:32any number of cases. Question. Again, just to keep respective
- 9:37and context. The final week that this was being negotiated,
- 9:40redacted LORI was in Washington, and bouncing back and forth
- 9:44on the weekends because he was in transition to the
- 9:47front office there in the criminal division in this building.
- 9:50And that's a factor in terms of being able to
- 9:53give attention to some detail. Would you agree with that
- 9:55it could be a factor? Answer, So, it could be
- 9:58a factor. On the other hand, I'd say that Redacted
- 10:02wasn't leaving the department. He is professional. He knows his stuff,
- 10:06and you would expect a professional if they're reviewing a document,
- 10:09whether they're on vacation, whether they're looking to move from
- 10:12one part of the department to another, that you would
- 10:15expect them to review it, you know, fulfilling their responsibility
- 10:18to sort of focus in and make sure that that
- 10:21is that it encompasses what it should. And that's not
- 10:24a criticism of Redacted that saying, well, that might be
- 10:28a factor. That doesn't lessen, from my perspective, reliance on
- 10:31his expertise. Question understood. After the MPa was signed and
- 10:37Redacted came back answer, yeah, question right about that same time,
- 10:43he quite quickly identified a potential problem, and that was
- 10:46about the commitment for or the agreement that the US
- 10:49Attorney's Office would identify the representative for the victims. Do
- 10:53you recall him raising that? Answer? I don't recall him
- 10:56raising that as an issue, but I know it was
- 10:58an issue. Question all right. It was an issue, and
- 11:02it was one that was raised as soon as he
- 11:04came back. So there was an effort which he conducted
- 11:07then in Redacted's absence, to craft an NPA addendum to
- 11:11address that issue. Are you aware that Redacted received a
- 11:15copy of the NPA in November when ken Starr wrote
- 11:18a letter to Redacted asking her to review the twenty
- 11:21two to fifty five portion of it. Do you remember
- 11:24the issue? Answer? I remember that the issue was appealed
- 11:27to CEOs. Question. Well, it was. It was appealed initially
- 11:32by the letter to redacted, raising an issue that was
- 11:35new to Redacted that had not been raised with you,
- 11:38and that is what led to your letter to ken
- 11:40Starr on December fourth. Answer. I'll accept that timeline. Question, okay.
- 11:47And at that time Redacted saw the NPA. He sent
- 11:50a message to Redacted about about his view of the NPA,
- 11:54and you didn't see it. But I just wanted to
- 11:56name some problems that he identified with the disposition and
- 12:00get your reaction. So first, he says, I'm not thrilled
- 12:04about the agreement, but he acknowledges that's out of his hands.
- 12:07He says, in terms of the charging and sentencing provision
- 12:10he's getting, Epstein is getting a much better deal than
- 12:13the average defendant. With the exception of defendants who have
- 12:17done physical harm to their victims or abused very young children,
- 12:21we haven't seen more egregious conduct because of its serial nature.
- 12:25The area we need to be more careful about relates
- 12:28to the victims. The US should seek to ensure that
- 12:31the plea, which is not giving them serious jail time,
- 12:34provides the best means possible to address the harm. He
- 12:37calls to the victims. That generally means restitution and or therapy.
- 12:42While the agreement provides facility for the victims, the irrelevant
- 12:46terms still seem pretty advantageous for the defendant and not
- 12:49all that helpful for the victims. They get an attorney
- 12:52who will be paid by the defendant, which involves at
- 12:54least some conflict of interest, or they could hire their
- 12:57own attorney on a contingency basis, and they get waivers
- 13:00from the defendant when his plea would facilitate their civil cases.
- 13:04In any event, then they still have to sue them
- 13:08to get anything. Most times with wealthy defendants we make
- 13:12them agreed to restitution fund and then still provide the
- 13:15victims can sue the defendant independently if they choose. We
- 13:19always make them clearly admit their guilt. No nolo, please,
- 13:24this is incredibly important to the victim. If I would
- 13:27have taken the guid to trial unless the victims were
- 13:29clearly against it, and I don't think most of them
- 13:32are here. He then says to Redacted, who by this
- 13:35time is working for redacted, so there is context in
- 13:39which he's addressing it. Redacted specifies that Redacted wouldn't and
- 13:44shouldn't address the agreement, so that the issue that was
- 13:48then before Redacted put there by ken Starr was whether
- 13:52the twenty two to fifty five scheme or scenario set
- 13:55out and the NPA was appropriate. It appears that she
- 13:58then sent that back you at the address. But as
- 14:02far as commentary on the NPA, if you had been
- 14:04aware of this perspective at the time you were that
- 14:08you and your people were fashioning the NPA, would you
- 14:11have been helpful to you in deciding how to proceed? Answer? So,
- 14:15may I question, yes? Answer, Okay, I assume you've read
- 14:21the whole thing, but let me just take well, I
- 14:24have a few comments. First, let me say he was
- 14:26part of the September meeting, and to my recollection, these perspectives,
- 14:32so at least the outline of the agreement were disclosed
- 14:34at the meeting, and I don't recall this type of
- 14:37communication at this time. Question okay, answer. I also recall
- 14:41that there was a lot of back and forth around
- 14:43this restitution fund concept, and our perspective was that the
- 14:47restitution fund puts the victim at a disadvantage. Because let
- 14:51me try to recreate I don't recall the details, but
- 14:54I recall that there was a perspective that the restitution
- 14:57fund put the victims at a disadvantage. And there's some
- 15:00reference to was it an Alaska case question, it's called
- 15:04the redacted case witness. I'm sorry. Then the whole bunch
- 15:09of redacted parts here back to Acosta. And so to
- 15:13the extent that there were better ways of crafting this,
- 15:16that certainly would have been been highly relevant, because to
- 15:19my recollection, we were not wed to any particular way
- 15:22of crafting it. The intent of twenty two to fifty
- 15:25five was to come as close as possible to putting
- 15:28the victims in the position they would have been had
- 15:32they tried and convicted federally. And so to answer your
- 15:35question is yes, answer it would have been helpful. All right, folks,
- 15:41We're gonna wrap up right here, and in the next
- 15:43episode dealing with the topic, we're gonna pick up where
- 15:45we left off. All of the information that goes with
- 15:48this episode can be found in the description box.