Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Why Your Team Has a Feedback Deficit
Transcript
- Lucas: You know that moment when you finally get honest feedback and your first thought is, 'Why didn't anyone tell me this six months ago?' Luna: Oh, I've been on both sides of that. It's painful. And it usually comes too late to actually do anything about it. Lucas: Today we're talking about what I'm calling the feedback deficit — the gap between the feedback people need and what they actually get. And let's start with a case that really stuck with me. A marketing team at a mid-sized B2B SaaS company lost two junior hires in the same quarter. Both exit interviews cited the same reason: they had no idea how they were doing. They got praise in annual reviews, but zero real, specific feedback on what to improve. Luna: And I bet the managers thought they were being nice by not giving critical feedback. But that kindness backfired. Lucas: Exactly. The managers thought they were protecting morale. Instead, they created a fog. And when people can't see where they stand, they leave. And look — before we go deeper, a quick honest thing: this show stays ad-free because a small group of listeners chips in monthly at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's literally what funds making this many episodes. If the show has helped you think through a career move or a management challenge, that link is in the show notes. No pressure, just wanted you to know how it works. Luna: Yeah, and it's a small community that really cares. Which actually ties back to feedback — when people care enough to tell you the hard thing, that's a gift. Lucas: Right. So let's stay with that marketing team. Why did those managers avoid giving feedback? I think it's a mix of fear — fear of hurting feelings, fear of conflict — and a lack of a simple framework. Most managers never learned how to deliver feedback in a way that lands. Luna: And there's also the time factor. Writing thoughtful feedback takes effort. It's easier to just say 'good job' and move on. Lucas: So what do we do? I've been using a framework I call the Feedback Fist. It's four parts: situation, behavior, impact, ask. You describe the specific situation, the behavior you observed, the impact it had, and then ask a question or make a request. Luna: Give me an example. Let's say I keep interrupting you in meetings. Lucas: Okay. Situation: 'In yesterday's sprint planning meeting when we were discussing the Q3 roadmap.' Behavior: 'You interrupted me three times before I finished my point.' Impact: 'It made me feel rushed and like my input wasn't valued, and the team didn't get to hear the full analysis.' Ask: 'In the future, could you let me finish before jumping in? I want to make sure we hear all the details.' Luna: That's specific. It's not 'you're a bad listener' — it's about a moment. And the ask is actionable. Lucas: Exactly. And the research backs this up. Culture Amp did a survey and found that 57 percent of employees actually prefer corrective feedback over praise. Because praise feels good, but corrective feedback helps you grow. The problem is most managers reverse those numbers. Luna: Fifty-seven percent want the hard stuff. That's a higher number than I would have guessed. So the discomfort is mostly in the manager's head. Lucas: It is. And the fix is to make feedback a habit, not an event. If you only give feedback during annual reviews, you're a year late. The best teams I've seen have a norm of giving small, frequent feedback — like two minutes at the end of a one-on-one. 'Here's one thing you did well this week, and one thing you could adjust.' Luna: That micro-feedback loop is powerful. It also makes the big conversations less scary because you've built trust over time. Lucas: Right. And if you're a first-time manager, start with one behavior you want to give feedback on this week. Pick a low-stakes situation. Use the Feedback Fist. And then just do it. The first time is the hardest. Luna: And if you get it wrong, apologize and try again. People forgive sincerity. Lucas: That's the whole show this week. The feedback deficit is real, but it's fixable. Start small, be specific, and make it a habit.