Latest / Politics with Paul / Is America Really on the Decline? | Politics with Paul #95
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:05political science and civics.
- 0:07I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:10Today tackles the question, is America really on the decline?
- 0:15In pretty much every point in human history and not just in America, you hear laments about how
- 0:21society is going down the tubes, that everything is becoming worse, and it's very
- 0:26common to hear rhetoric in American politics and political discourse that the country is
- 0:32getting worse, and that belief can take a lot of different forms.
- 0:35But while it's not
- 0:36a new sentiment, it does feel like this pessimism is increasing.
- 0:41We need to be able to honestly talk about the flaws
- 0:45of this country to be able to critique these issues, to have a way to make things better,
- 0:50and some level of grievance is absolutely justified.
- 0:55But too much pessimism and anxiety can lead to further problems for the country and become a
- 1:01self fulfilling prophecy where the country does enter a state of decline or things just get
- 1:08worse.
- 1:09And it's especially important in light of the two hundred and fiftieth anniversary of the
- 1:13United States of America.
- 1:15So how should we talk about the flaws of this country?
- 1:18What are the biggest threats that can lead to the decline of America?
- 1:22And how do we approach the very question of whether this country is on the decline and how
- 1:27we can fix it?
- 1:29Let's talk about it.
- 1:31So I think it first makes sense to talk about this specter of declineism.
- 1:38Much of these pessimistic opinions about whether America is is going down the tubes,
- 1:47it's rooted in this common bias called declinism, which is this cognitive bias that
- 1:52society or an institution is heading towards decline.
- 1:56Everything's just getting worse.
- 1:58It's similar to that rose tinted glasses idea that the past was better regardless of, you
- 2:07know, whatever actual facts of the matter there are because we tend to romanticize what
- 2:14happened back in our childhood when we had a lot fewer problems, that everything else seemed
- 2:20right in the world, never mind the fact that what were your best years were somebody else's
- 2:25worst years, what you thought was the greatest time to be alive, some people felt was the
- 2:30worst time to be alive, And sometimes we don't really have that level of self awareness to
- 2:37think about that.
- 2:38And I mean, sometimes it happens to me.
- 2:41I think about late nineties, early two thousands to mid two thousands when I was
- 2:46growing up and some aspects of that I thought were really cool and some things have gotten
- 2:50worse.
- 2:51To some extent,
- 2:52I do legitimately believe that, but I'm also talking about an era when I was a
- 2:57kid and I had a lot fewer responsibilities.
- 3:00It's something that we all do.
- 3:01And so this bias has existed for arguably all of human history.
- 3:06You can look in some very old, hundreds of years old documents and see something along the
- 3:13lines of, You know, kids these days are just ruining everything.
- 3:17Why is everything changing?
- 3:18Everything sucks now.
- 3:22But the actual coining of
- 3:24the term declinism is often traced back to German historian Oswald Spengler in his book,
- 3:31The Decline of the West, which basically speculates that the decline of every
- 3:34civilization is inevitable.
- 3:38And there are some other types of biases that work in tandem with declinism, things like rosy
- 3:44retrospection, which we basically just talked about.
- 3:47The tendency to remember the past more fondly and think times back then were more positive
- 3:54than they actually were and that they were better than they are now.
- 3:59It's also there's this negativity bias.
- 4:02We are wired to dwell more on negative experiences versus the positive experiences,
- 4:07though it's more so looking at the present day.
- 4:10But it's we're constantly looking for threats and the negative stands out more in our
- 4:17minds than the positive does.
- 4:19And then there's confirmation bias where we seek information that confirms preexisting
- 4:24beliefs.
- 4:24So if we think that things are on the decline now, we tend to look for all those reasons why
- 4:31things are on the decline now and push aside things that say, Well, you know what?
- 4:36Might not actually be as bad as we think it is.
- 4:39And this declineism permeates so much of our political discourse, really just discourse in
- 4:44general, but especially how we talk about politics and especially in these terms or these
- 4:51times, excuse me, of heightened polarization.
- 4:55And surprise, our political views can greatly influence our belief in whether America is in
- 5:01decline, whether we think we're entering this golden age where America is going to be the
- 5:05best it's ever been or we think it's going the complete opposite direction and it's gonna be
- 5:10the worst that it's ever been, or at least one of the worst it's ever been.
- 5:14And people's opinions on this can completely turn on a dime and suddenly somebody thinks
- 5:19everything is hunky dory.
- 5:20And conveniently, a lot of times those change when a new person is elected from a different
- 5:27party and the people who are on the one party who had the office of president and maybe
- 5:33Congress thought, oh, everything is fantastic.
- 5:36And then all
- 5:36of a sudden, there's a new person in charge,
- 5:40a new party in charge, and all of a sudden, those people think everything sucks.
- 5:43And the people who used to think everything sucks now think everything is going to be
- 5:46great.
- 5:47Conveniently, partisan support or opposition of the current president or party in power can
- 5:54drive a
- 5:54lot of this belief in declinism.
- 5:58And there's
- 5:59a bunch of ways that this tandem of partisan bias and declineism can manifest together, but
- 6:06we only have time to highlight several of them.
- 6:08So a few of the ones that I want to highlight are political ads and messaging, the harnessing
- 6:13of fear in voting, which has some relation to that first bullet point, and then pulling
- 6:19questions on whether people believe the country is heading in the right direction or the wrong
- 6:25direction.
- 6:26And so in these political ads and messaging, you often see, even though they don't actually
- 6:30use the word declinism, they might not even use the word decline, they still have something
- 6:38along those lines with these scare tactics that people use.
- 6:42Either depending on who the ads are for, I'd say the current office holders are ushering in
- 6:49the decline of America, the only way
- 6:51to stop them and their evil agenda is to conveniently elect the people that we like.
- 6:56Or if you are in power,
- 7:00you would say that these challengers are going to usher into the cline of America if they took
- 7:04over.
- 7:05That all these terrible things are going happen, that people are going to die, that
- 7:08people are going to lose their jobs Regardless of the validity of those concerns, it's mostly
- 7:16rooted in political biases and the fact that these people really want to win at all costs.
- 7:22And so it's why people tend to see predominantly negative ad campaigns.
- 7:29But even though we all say that we really hate negative political ads and that we wish we
- 7:35didn't see so many
- 7:36of them and that we wish people were more positive.
- 7:39A, it can be hard to define exactly in terms of legal
- 7:48rules or anything like that, what exactly makes a negative campaign ad?
- 7:53If you really were going to try to change things to say, Hey, we can't have negative
- 7:57campaign ads.
- 7:58It's kind of one of those things where you know negative ads when you see them, but how to
- 8:02actually define it in law or discussion can sometimes be a little bit challenging.
- 8:10And also, even though we say we hate negative campaign ads, they're the things that we
- 8:15respond most to.
- 8:17If we didn't respond as much to them, then campaigns would run
- 8:20them a lot less.
- 8:21But the problem is they are very effective.
- 8:26Then there's also this tendency of fear in voting and in a related note, incumbency bias.
- 8:34Fear is the most powerful motivating emotion in voting.
- 8:39We want to prevent threats to ourselves, and sometimes it's even more powerful a lot of
- 8:43times it's more powerful than anger is, although those two can often and often do work
- 8:49side by side.
- 8:50And it's not always fear that drives who people vote for because some people, if they're gonna
- 8:56vote, they are only gonna vote for one person anyways, but it can drive people as to whether
- 9:03they vote at all.
- 9:04So somebody might have been staying home because they just didn't feel enthused or
- 9:09interested in any of the candidates, but this one particular tactic by this one campaign
- 9:18really lit a fire under this voter because they were so scared about what would happen if this
- 9:25other person won that they thought, you know what?
- 9:27I have to go vote.
- 9:29And then, of course, the most partisan voters who are already going to vote anyways, they
- 9:34respond very much to fear tactics, and they engage in fear tactics a lot of the time saying
- 9:39how if we don't vote for our candidate that everything is gonna go down to the down the
- 9:45gutter.
- 9:47And on a related note, you see incumbents often win at rates of 85% or more, especially in
- 9:55Congress.
- 9:56And part of that is that fear of the unknown because we might not necessarily like
- 10:01everything that the incumbent is doing, but unless we really don't like what the incumbent
- 10:05is doing, we're probably not going to vote for somebody that we don't know because a lot of
- 10:11times that challenger is much lesser known than that incumbent is.
- 10:15And how can we say that this person is better if we don't really know enough about them?
- 10:20But for a lot of people, they have to be so fearful that the incumbent is going to further
- 10:24ruin things that it drives them to vote for something new.
- 10:28And what's declineism's role in all this?
- 10:30Well, you're driven to vote by fear because you are worried that the option you don't vote for
- 10:36would cause a decline, whether it's in that district, whether it's in the state, whether
- 10:42it's in the whole country.
- 10:44We also tend to like our member of congress, but think the rest of congress sucks, which
- 10:49highlights the Fenno paradox where we basically think the problems of congress are not at the
- 10:54fault of our particular congressperson.
- 10:57So it's the rest of congress that's driving this decline.
- 11:01And so even though it doesn't necessarily explicitly come up with this role of declinism
- 11:10in this tendency of fear, it is there.
- 11:15Fear what this other person could do if we don't get out and vote.
- 11:21And then lastly, there's this polling question that you'll often see is called right direction
- 11:27or it asks, would you say things in this country today are generally headed in the right
- 11:33direction or the wrong direction.
- 11:35Might be a little bit of tweaks in how that question is worded, but that's generally how
- 11:39it's stated.
- 11:42And whenever camp whenever results for these campaign questions come out, it's a favorite
- 11:50talking point of a lot of partisan campaigns and media outlets because it's a quick and easy
- 11:56way to dunk on the current president or the current party in power and say that they suck
- 12:01at their job.
- 12:02Look how many people say that we're heading in the
- 12:04wrong direction.
- 12:06And conveniently, the president and the party in power typically don't showcase those polls
- 12:13unless they
- 12:14can find one that happens to say, oh, actually, all these people say we're heading in the right
- 12:18direction.
- 12:19But a lot of times, those are not reputable polls because here's the kicker, it's virtually
- 12:26always a majority of people that say we are headed in the wrong direction.
- 12:31Does not matter the party in power, does not matter presidential approval, does not matter
- 12:35the economic situation.
- 12:38Almost every single time that question is asked,
- 12:42at least for reputable national polls, people say that we are headed in the wrong direction.
- 12:49Now might not always be a huge number of people that say that, but it is fairly common to see
- 12:56over 60% of people say that we are headed in the wrong direction.
- 13:01But conveniently, belief in that right and wrong direction of the country is often driven
- 13:06by partisanship and polarization because usually
- 13:13people will say that it's the right direction if it's their president in power or their party
- 13:17in power.
- 13:18And if it's not their president or party in power, then they'll say that things are heading
- 13:21in the wrong direction.
- 13:22Republicans loved using these polls against Joe Biden when he was in office, and now Democrats
- 13:27love using it now that Donald Trump is back in the White House.
- 13:32Now what's declineism's role in all this?
- 13:35Well, the fact that the wrong direction sentiment is virtually always a majority is a
- 13:41clear indication of the bias of declineism because we tend to have this idea that
- 13:49everything is going in decline, especially if it's not the people that we like who are in
- 13:54charge.
- 13:55But all that said, these biases do not mean that pessimism is inherently wrong or that we
- 14:04can't think negatively about something that's happening.
- 14:07That is not at all what I'm trying to say.
- 14:09And the quote unquote toxic positivity is not the answer either where you can't just you just
- 14:15can't say anything bad about what's happening right now.
- 14:18That's ridiculous.
- 14:20We just have to be careful with how our perspectives skew reality, how we can be
- 14:28manipulated by political movers and shakers, and whether we are on the same page as to what
- 14:36we are talking about when we say, is America in is America in decline?
- 14:42Because when we say America's in decline, what exactly about it are we saying is in decline?
- 14:50It's very easy to just say, oh, the country is is just it's going it's getting worse and
- 14:54worse.
- 14:55Whether that's true or not, it's very easy to say that.
- 14:58But what exactly is declining?
- 15:00Is it society in general?
- 15:03Is it economics or relationships, our abilities to talk to each other, morals, democratic
- 15:11ideals.
- 15:13Because you could find five different people that agree that America is declining, but they
- 15:17give different answers as to what parts of America are declining that they're talking
- 15:24about and why.
- 15:25I think in most cases, people typically mean society in general, morality, and democratic
- 15:32ideals because we can be in decline in some ways but not in others.
- 15:37Maybe economics are doing fine but we're sliding back when it comes to democratic ideals
- 15:41and the ability to say our peace, our freedom of speech.
- 15:49There's a difference between saying certain aspects of America are declining and that the
- 15:54nation in general is in decline.
- 15:57Because personally, I would argue the following things are declining, and this is not a
- 16:01comprehensive list and some
- 16:03people may have disagreements with this list, and not necessarily wrong.
- 16:11Yes, obviously, have my opinion, but I'm
- 16:13not gonna say people are inherently wrong because they disagreed with me.
- 16:16But
- 16:17there are a lot of things that you can very much argue are in decline in this country.
- 16:25And even then, only possibly in certain aspects.
- 16:29But again, there are some you can it's important to discuss these things as to whether
- 16:37things are declining as much as we think they are.
- 16:39But our understanding of civics and even basic political knowledge, I mean, how many times
- 16:44have we seen civics questions about basic things like what are the three branches of
- 16:51government and people don't know them?
- 16:53Now, some
- 16:54of these basic questions have seen a little bit more of an uptick in how many people know the
- 17:00answers.
- 17:02Three branches of government being executive, legislative, and judicial, or who their local
- 17:10elected congressperson is.
- 17:14But a lot of those things are not nearly as well known as they should be.
- 17:21The ability to have honest conversations with people across the political aisle.
- 17:27There's so many people that just don't know how to have a conversation, not even that they
- 17:33don't know how to have a conversation.
- 17:35It's like they don't even want to have a conversation because they've got it all figured
- 17:39out.
- 17:39That it's other people who need to come over to their side, not them going over to this other
- 17:45person's side.
- 17:47And similarly, we've seen the decline in the ability to have relationships of various kinds
- 17:54across the political aisle, whether it's just a simple friendship, even mere acquaintances, or
- 17:59even romantic relationships.
- 18:02You see people say, Oh, I can never marry a Republican.
- 18:05I can never marry a Democrat.
- 18:06I can't marry a conservative or a liberal.
- 18:09Or parents who say they would not want their kids to marry somebody in the opposite party or
- 18:15of the opposite ideology.
- 18:19That is a very serious problem that we have, and that is something that has declined over
- 18:23time if you look at public opinion of how many people have answered that they can't possibly
- 18:28marry somebody of a different political view or that they don't want their kids to marry
- 18:34somebody of an opposite political view.
- 18:37Fewer and fewer people are tolerant of that, and then people moving into neighborhoods that
- 18:42are more homogenous in terms of their party and ideology.
- 18:50These there's a disturbing lack of
- 18:52self awareness and ability to reevaluate our political beliefs.
- 18:58So many people think that everything they've they've figured everything out, that they don't
- 19:03need anybody to challenge their views and that they are just gonna go to their specific
- 19:08trusted source for news.
- 19:11However,
- 19:12you know, quotation marks around the the word news in that regard, but they can't possibly
- 19:22fathom that they might have something wrong.
- 19:26Even though if you would question them about that, they
- 19:28would say, oh, yeah.
- 19:29Sure.
- 19:29I could have something wrong.
- 19:30Well, sometimes they might,
- 19:32but their actions say otherwise.
- 19:35And then in a similar vein, quality unbiased media coverage of political topics has gone
- 19:41down.
- 19:42You and you've seen this fragmentation of mass media
- 19:48where there's a greater prevalence of echo chambers that tell you how smart you are
- 19:53because you have the correct opinion about things all the time.
- 19:57There's too much one party rule in certain areas of The US.
- 20:01There are some states that no matter what you do, if you are not the party in power or you're
- 20:07not the majority party, you are not going to compete.
- 20:11Places like California and Maryland.
- 20:17It's extraordinarily difficult for a Republican to compete in those.
- 20:20Or places like Wyoming and Texas where it's very difficult to compete if you're a Democrat.
- 20:29Now there can be some fluctuations in that, but in a lot
- 20:32of cases, you are just not going to compete if you are not that majority party.
- 20:39You might be able to win a few state legislative seats or maybe one congressional
- 20:44district, but to actually like have a real chance at influencing a lot of public policy in
- 20:52that state, very unlikely, if not impossible.
- 20:59And then there's, in a similar vein, increasing voting by the party lot party line where
- 21:05Republicans just will not vote for anybody that's a Democrat, and Democrats just will not
- 21:09vote for anybody that's a Republican.
- 21:11And there's just this unwillingness to hold our quote unquote, our team
- 21:16accountable.
- 21:18Because we cannot we our identity comes too much from who we support politically.
- 21:27And we cannot tolerate anybody from quote unquote, the outside to we can't tolerate them
- 21:38criticizing people that we support because then we take it as a threat to ourselves.
- 21:44And so,
- 21:45I think there are plenty of things that you can argue are declining.
- 21:51Some people might disagree on those fronts and that's fine.
- 21:55But the overall idea that we are a nation in decline, that is a different question than
- 22:03saying, are these particular aspects in decline?
- 22:08Because we can be skeptical of the idea that we are a nation in decline while still recognizing
- 22:14that there are imminent threats to the nation or that we have serious problems right now.
- 22:20Whether we agree that America is on the decline as a whole, there are always going to be
- 22:26threats.
- 22:27And each of these threats can lead to decline and can, funny enough, also be caused by
- 22:34decline as thought, can have this reciprocal effect where we think things are in decline and
- 22:40so these problems become worse and then when these problems become worse, it makes us think
- 22:46more in a declineist manner.
- 22:49Things like polarization being the
- 22:52most obvious one.
- 22:53Division is nothing new, but these are arguably one of
- 22:58the more polarized times in our nation's history and it's everywhere.
- 23:03You sometimes think something that's not even related to politics that you see online and
- 23:08some comment involves politics in it and it's usually something divisive.
- 23:14And this level of polarization can lead people to throw up their hands and lament how much
- 23:19worse America is getting and once again, a lot of the perception of America's decline or lack
- 23:27thereof is driven by this partisan polarization.
- 23:31You also have the issue of political apathy.
- 23:34Talked about it for several episodes specifically on this podcast, how much of a
- 23:40problem political apathy is.
- 23:42To some extent, it is understandable because of how very frustrating politics can be.
- 23:48But when people don't get involved in politics and civics or when a wide swath of them don't
- 23:54get involved, it leads to a lack of accountability for government officials because
- 23:58they are not hearing from these large swaths of the populace.
- 24:05They are just listening to the loudest voices which tend to be the most polarized.
- 24:09And so when too many people are apathetic, it lets polarized people have an outsized
- 24:16influence on the political process.
- 24:20You also have decreasing trust in political institutions, Institutions like Congress, the
- 24:27Supreme Court, executive agencies, and state governments have seen plummeting trust by
- 24:34Americans.
- 24:35And that's not
- 24:35to say that they haven't brought some
- 24:37of it on themselves, sometimes they have,
- 24:40but a lack of trust
- 24:45is a threat to the legitimacy of these institutions, to the legitimacy of our
- 24:49political system and that can lead to violence and has led to violence, and it can lead to
- 24:55further
- 24:55polarization because if we only trust these institutions when people we support are in
- 25:03them,
- 25:04then that's not very democratic.
- 25:08That means we just want people who think like us to run the show and only care about what we
- 25:13think instead of what the citizenry as a whole thinks.
- 25:18And then lastly, one of
- 25:20the other major threats to decline or that can cause more decline as thought is our media
- 25:29consumption habits.
- 25:32And there's a lot of ways that this can
- 25:37increase this idea of declinism.
- 25:40How much we trust everything we read and see on the internet when it comports with what we
- 25:44believe.
- 25:47We are disturbingly, and you know, I am no exception to this either, when we see
- 25:52something, especially on social media that's neatly crafted into these AI videos or these
- 25:59very heavily edited sound bites or some other way that they prey on our biases and we just
- 26:10accept them as fact because we are inclined to accept them as fact because they support what
- 26:15we believe in.
- 26:16That is
- 26:16a very serious problem.
- 26:18That is a way that America can decline.
- 26:23And it's one of
- 26:24those facts that we all know is a problem and makes us think that America's on the decline
- 26:31even further.
- 26:32So it's once again that reciprocal effect by America's in decline, we perceive it's
- 26:37in decline, and then it's declining even further.
- 26:40There's
- 26:41also those social media grifters that we see all the time, left, right, somewhere in the
- 26:46middle, that find their niche and they manipulate it, they take advantage of it by
- 26:55pandering to that niche's opinions on everything and purposely incites people.
- 27:01Obviously, in previous generations, we didn't have that ability, at least not to the extent
- 27:07that we have it now.
- 27:10Echo Chambers in a similar fashion because of how much mass media has been fragmented and how
- 27:15much it's become not only from a political it's not only become politically incentivized for
- 27:24people to do that, to
- 27:25just pander to their particular
- 27:29group of the population that's going to just gobble up anything they say.
- 27:35It's also economically the wisest course of action.
- 27:40Because if you try to appeal to too many people, they're not going to listen.
- 27:44And you're spending a lot of time trying to reach people that you may or may not be able to
- 27:50reach out to.
- 27:50So that is using up money and therefore you have less money on hand.
- 27:56You are profiting less if not losing money by doing that.
- 28:00So it's a political incentive and an economic incentive, which is another way that you can
- 28:06argue a certain aspect of America is in decline.
- 28:12But all that being said, we do need to be careful that we don't get wrapped up so much in
- 28:17this idea that America's getting worse and that this whole world is getting worse and that life
- 28:22is just sucking more and more and that we filter everything through that lens.
- 28:28Because talking too much about what's wrong with America can actually make people more
- 28:34pessimistic and susceptible to decline as thought, and it can also lead to more
- 28:40polarization and division and echo chambers and so on.
- 28:45So it can actually have that opposite effect of what you're looking for, which is to fix these
- 28:49problems and to get people to think, hey, this is a problem.
- 28:53Let's come together and find a solution for this.
- 28:56Some people will actually just become even more mired in decline as thought and become more
- 29:03polarized if all you do is talk too much about how America's on the decline.
- 29:10But if talking about problems in America can ironically also influence people to be
- 29:15more declineist, then how can we honestly talk about our grievances?
- 29:22Because if just talking about them just makes people get even worse or think even more
- 29:30pessimistically, then what's the point?
- 29:34It's not that we can't talk about these things because we need to talk about these
- 29:39problems.
- 29:41It's just
- 29:41that we have to be more honest with ourselves and each other and hear each other out because
- 29:48some people, surprise, have different opinions than you do about what's wrong with America.
- 29:54The things I just said earlier, you might not think that those are as much of problems as I
- 29:59think they are and that's okay.
- 30:01We need to
- 30:02be able to have these conversations with each other because some things have to be declining
- 30:09and getting worse.
- 30:10There's always something that could be made better.
- 30:15Nothing is perfect, and putting our heads in the sand and acting like everything is great
- 30:19just makes the situation worse.
- 30:22And for as problematic as thinking everything is awful and terrible can be, it's just as
- 30:30problematic to think that, Oh, everything's going great, just because the people that you
- 30:33support happen to be in power.
- 30:37So we also can't just have our thoughts about America's decline be largely based on whether
- 30:43we support or oppose the current president or the party with the most power.
- 30:47We can't think that our team is the only defender of democracy and the only route to
- 30:53prosperity for the nation.
- 30:55And if we elect somebody else, everything's just going to go down, just gonna go into the
- 30:59gutter.
- 31:01But we also have to always, always give voice to people with grievances because just shutting
- 31:08people out only makes them bitter and lash out even more.
- 31:14And we see it all the time.
- 31:17And that can lead them to further believe that the country is in a state of decline and
- 31:21they're going to act on that a lot of times violently.
- 31:26Now giving voice to these people doesn't mean we always agree with them.
- 31:30You shouldn't just agree with people outright.
- 31:33And it doesn't mean that you can't push back because there are some
- 31:36opinions that really deserve to be pushed back on, especially very bigoted ones.
- 31:42But you
- 31:44can't just silence them either.
- 31:47They need to be educated on why said bigotry is not okay, why it's wrong.
- 31:54But even if it's not bigotry, no matter how much you don't support what they believe, if
- 31:59you're just going to try to suppress what they think, then when they get in power, they're
- 32:06going to try to suppress you.
- 32:07We can't just pick and choose whose freedom of speech we are protecting, especially when it's
- 32:16just based on whether we agree with them or not.
- 32:21We can have grievances about current and coming issues without thinking everything is just
- 32:28going down the drain.
- 32:31And even if we believe the country is declining, we must take care not to be too
- 32:35mired in those feelings or else we become too pessimistic and we lose hope and become
- 32:41disengaged.
- 32:43Just look at how many would be voters cope with politics.
- 32:47Instead of going to vote, they just sit at home because they're just tired of it.
- 32:51They don't know where to turn.
- 32:53They just think that everything is that they can't have any sort of impact.
- 32:59Their political efficacy efficacy is low.
- 33:02They think they can't understand politics, that they can't make a positive impact on politics,
- 33:08and so they think, Why bother?
- 33:10And if we really think that we are in that serious decline, then how can we believe that
- 33:15things can get better?
- 33:17What's even the point of fighting for what we believe in if we think that, well, the
- 33:22country's just
- 33:24declining anyways?
- 33:28I say these things as much for anybody out there who will listen, and thank you very much
- 33:35for those of you who do listen.
- 33:37But I don't just say it for you, I also say it for myself because believe it or not, despite
- 33:43all the things I've said here, I'm often a pessimist and not just from a political
- 33:48standpoint.
- 33:49I often am very pessimistic personally too.
- 33:52I've become more of one as I've gotten older, which I guess is a fairly common thing as as
- 33:58people get older, older.
- 34:00So I'm not saying all these things to rag on other people's decline as thoughts and think,
- 34:04Oh, well, you you're just dumb, or you're, you're just too pessimistic, you need to think
- 34:09more positively, positively.
- 34:12Just saying telling people to think positively is not helpful.
- 34:16It doesn't actually lead them to thinking more positively.
- 34:19Believe me, I know.
- 34:21That's because people told me that before too.
- 34:25So I definitely don't just tell other people to think more positively too.
- 34:29You got to give people a reason to think positively.
- 34:35Tell them why things can become better.
- 34:38Because I'm not even necessarily saying that some aspects of America aren't declining
- 34:41because I certainly would not say that.
- 34:43In fact, I just told you some things that I personally think are on the decline in America.
- 34:48And I try not to talk too much about personal opinions, but I don't think there is any way at
- 34:55any point in time that you can look at everything in America or the rest of the world
- 35:00for that matter and say everything is going smoothly.
- 35:03There's always going to be something wrong, and that's not inherently pessimist, and it's not
- 35:08inherently against optimism.
- 35:10You are just recognizing that when human beings get involved in something, something's
- 35:17going to go wrong.
- 35:19It doesn't mean everything's going wrong or that the end is imminent or that civilization
- 35:26is going to collapse at any moment, but we do have to recognize our tendency towards decline
- 35:34as thought and how that can severely skew our perceptions of everything.
- 35:40For all of America's flaws, we have
- 35:42a unique capacity to reverse problematic trends and make things better.
- 35:47For example, many states allow for citizen initiated ballot measures so that people can
- 35:54almost basically the citizens make their own laws.
- 35:57Now, of course, you still need to vote on it in the ensuing election, but citizens do still
- 36:05have some power to make laws themselves.
- 36:08Now some state governments have tried to manipulate that system for their own gain, but
- 36:14it is one of those direct democracy methods that we do have.
- 36:17And not every state has it, but a lot of states do.
- 36:21And for two fifty years, we have improved in various ways.
- 36:25We have, in a lot
- 36:27of respects, more accessible government.
- 36:30We've extended voting rights to racial minorities and women.
- 36:34We've eliminated slavery and most of the vestiges of Jim Crow.
- 36:38You can't say that racism is completely eliminated because that's just not true.
- 36:43We've had integration of schools.
- 36:46We have easier ways to research information than at any point in human history, though
- 36:51there's still a lot of
- 36:52room for improvement in that regard, both in terms
- 36:57of who's providing that information and those of
- 36:59us who are consuming that information.
- 37:03But you also have to think about how in basically every point in America's history,
- 37:11especially in the last fifteen to twenty years, but pretty much every point in history, there's
- 37:18been a sizable number,
- 37:20a sizable proportion of the populace that thinks that America's getting worse and that if
- 37:26we don't turn around
- 37:27soon, that's the end is nigh.
- 37:31And
- 37:33two hundred fifty years on, that hasn't quite happened yet.
- 37:37No.
- 37:38Nothing lasts forever, but we
- 37:42have demonstrated an incredible capacity to improve things.
- 37:47And there's still a lot that can be improved, but it is very worthwhile work.
- 37:53And if we fall too much into this trap of decline as thought, it really hinders our
- 37:58ability to do those things because we start to think, well, what's the point of of all
- 38:02of this?
- 38:03We we're not going to fix anything or that we can't fix enough things to make things better.
- 38:14So to quote the two presidents held as standard bearers for our two major parties because I
- 38:22don't wanna just quote one party's presidents and not another's, but I think they
- 38:28are very relevant to this
- 38:31discussion.
- 38:33And on the democratic side, Franklin Roosevelt once said that the only limit to our
- 38:38realization of tomorrow will be our doubts of today.
- 38:43And then on the Republican side, Ronald Reagan said that freedom is never more than one
- 38:47generation away from extinction because we have to constantly fight for our freedoms and fight
- 38:56to make America a better place than it's ever been.
- 39:01It's not easy work and it's not an upward trajectory.
- 39:06Sometimes it's ups and downs, but at the same time, there is a lot of good in this country
- 39:16despite all its many flaws, and we're a flawed people.
- 39:23But here we are two hundred fifty years later still finding a way to, for the most part, get
- 39:31along and improve things.
- 39:33There's a lot that needs to improve, but as we've shown time and time again, we are capable
- 39:38of doing so as long as we actually give voice to other people that don't necessarily agree
- 39:45with our opinions because we don't have everything figured out and sometimes they'll
- 39:52have ideas that you never considered and might come up with a better fix to what's ailing
- 40:00America than you thought you ever would.
- 40:03It's not that decline can't happen
- 40:04in this country because it most certainly can
- 40:09and certain aspects have declined.
- 40:12But we can prepare against it so that it doesn't happen further or we can fix it when it
- 40:17does happen.
- 40:19And so my challenge, not just to you but to myself, is to just be careful with this
- 40:28assumption
- 40:29that America is on the decline and that we can't fix anything.
- 40:34But also, not just that.
- 40:38If your president that you support or your party that you support is in power,
- 40:45don't go the opposite way where you just assume that everything is now great and now
- 40:50conveniently now that your policies are being heard, now we're entering this golden age of
- 40:56America because that's the other side of the coin.
- 40:59Decline of thought can be incredibly problematic,
- 41:05but not entertaining the idea that things could be getting worse is just as bad and perhaps
- 41:13even more so.
- 41:15So
- 41:17I think we need to
- 41:18have a more honest appraisal or try to more honestly appraise what's going on in this
- 41:26nation, how our biases are affecting things, how our tendency towards negativity affects how
- 41:34we see things.
- 41:36I don't believe that America is on the decline as a whole.
- 41:42There's definitely a lot of things that could be better, and there's definitely a
- 41:45lot of things that are getting worse, but
- 41:49there's a lot of good in this country, and there's a lot
- 41:51of good people in this country.
- 41:53And when we wanna go look for those things, we can find them and we can make things better.
- 42:02But that's gonna do
- 42:03it for today's episode of the politics with Paul podcast.
- 42:06As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 42:07Please like, comment, and subscribe to the podcast on YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts.
- 42:14Please share with your networks.
- 42:18My links in the show notes, Facebook, LinkedIn, websites, medium.com profile where I write on
- 42:24politics from time to time, my five day educational email course about how we can more
- 42:28effectively mitigate polarization in this country, because sometimes we can actually
- 42:34accidentally make it worse, even though we're not trying to.
- 42:38And my book on Amazon is on ebook and paperback format on independence in politics.
- 42:46So that is gonna wrap things up here.
- 42:48So once again, thank you so much for listening, and we'll
- 42:51see you next time.