Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Bullying in the Legal Profession: Its Impact on Lawyers and Recommendations for Change with Roberta Liebenberg, Stephanie Scharf
Transcript
- 0:06Welcome to today's program, Bullying in the Legal
- 0:09Profession, Its Impact on Lawyers and Recommendations
- 0:13for Change. I'm Alapoli Castro, CLE advisor for
- 0:16the Beverly Hills Bar Association, and I am delighted
- 0:19to introduce today's speakers, Stephanie Scharf
- 0:22and Roberta Bobby Liebenberg. Stephanie is well
- 0:26known for innovative work in the areas of organizational
- 0:29excellence, diversity, quality, and inclusion,
- 0:32strategic growth, talent development, and enterprise
- 0:34management. Her consulting work is enhanced by
- 0:37over 30 years of practice working with national
- 0:40and global corporations as a partner at Kirkland
- 0:43Ellis, a partner at Jenner & Block, and most
- 0:45recently, founder of Sharp Banks Marmor LLC,
- 0:51a nationally prominent women -owned law firm.
- 0:53Stephanie has designed and co -authored many
- 0:56studies about the factors that impact long term
- 0:59professional careers. Bobbi is a senior partner
- 1:02at Fine, Kaplan & Black in Philadelphia, and
- 1:05also a principal at the Red Bee Group, a woman
- 1:08-owned consulting group that helps businesses,
- 1:10organizations, and law firms achieve their goals
- 1:12and use data -based strategies with diverse and
- 1:15innovative solutions. She focuses her practice
- 1:18on antitrust, class actions, and complex commercial
- 1:21litigation. She has written and spoken extensively
- 1:24about many issues of importance to lawyers, including
- 1:27co -authoring groundbreaking reports about bullying
- 1:30and the legal profession. And we cannot wait
- 1:32to hear what you both have to share with us today.
- 1:36Thank you, Olive. Thank you, Olive, really for
- 1:38your very kind introduction. And on behalf of
- 1:43Bobby as well, we are very pleased to be able
- 1:46to share the results of our research on bullying
- 1:48and what the research means for lawyers going
- 1:51forward and for companies and law firms and all
- 1:55the places where lawyers work. So the problem
- 1:58of bullying lawyers has been around ever since
- 2:02I've practiced law. In the old days, the prevailing
- 2:06advice was, well, just suck it up and don't complain.
- 2:10Or it's the way lawyers do their job. You'll
- 2:13just have to take it. And if you don't like it,
- 2:15you can leave. And in the 35 years I've been
- 2:19practicing law, Many aspects of the practice
- 2:23have changed, but bullying continues to be an
- 2:27all too frequent way of, let's say, managing
- 2:31work, as people put it, or managing people. And
- 2:36when asked, some lawyers say they've never been
- 2:39bullied, but a large and really large, increasingly
- 2:43large number of lawyers today say otherwise.
- 2:46And whether they practice in law, or companies
- 2:50or not -for -profits. Bullying has a lot of harmful
- 2:56impacts. It can create a workplace culture where
- 2:59individuals are threatened or demeaned or belittled.
- 3:04Lawyers who are bullied can be afraid to come
- 3:06forward. Employers may not even know about it,
- 3:10but when they do, they may not know how to address
- 3:13that kind of conduct. And it's not only individual
- 3:19lawyers who suffer from being bullied. Bullying
- 3:21tolerated by a workplace can have negative effects
- 3:26on the business itself, such as lower productivity,
- 3:31harm to reputation of the company or firm, and
- 3:35people leaving because of the culture of bullying
- 3:38that they don't want to work in. So if we can
- 3:42turn to the first slide, please. With all of
- 3:49that context in mind, we are gonna focus today
- 3:53on the research we did, bullying in the legal
- 3:56profession, and the big picture questions that
- 4:01come out of it. And we really also would like
- 4:05to thank the Illinois Supreme Court for sponsoring
- 4:09this research. It's the biggest and first of
- 4:12its kind in the U .S. and it focuses in on Big
- 4:17picture questions. What types of bullying occur
- 4:20in the workplaces where lawyers practice? What
- 4:26happens after bullying occurs? What do employers
- 4:30do about it? And what is the long -term impact
- 4:34of bullying on people, on workplaces, and on
- 4:38the profession as a whole? As I mentioned, this
- 4:44is the largest wide scale research ever conducted
- 4:48in the US on this topic. We used a very interesting
- 4:53multifaceted technology or methodology for the
- 4:57research. We conducted a survey of all lawyers
- 5:02registered to practice and actually practicing
- 5:05in the state of Illinois. And as a result, We
- 5:09got a survey participation of over 6 ,000 Illinois
- 5:13lawyers. We also conducted focus groups throughout
- 5:18the state of Illinois. We wanted to do some in
- 5:23-depth discussion about how the problems come
- 5:27up and what solutions people think there are
- 5:31for bullying. We wanted to have a diverse state
- 5:36And we did have a diverse group of response to
- 5:39the survey, but we also had a really diverse
- 5:43group by all sorts of criteria of attorneys and
- 5:46judges who served on a research advisory council
- 5:51as thought leaders for the research. So we certainly
- 5:56received many. frank and astounding comments
- 6:01in the course of our research, both in the survey
- 6:04itself and in the focus groups. And people really
- 6:08spoke from their souls. I mean, it was quite
- 6:11touching to actually do the analysis and read
- 6:15the results of the survey, because people spoke
- 6:18about their experiences and their reactions,
- 6:21and it really made the statistical results come
- 6:25to life. Why don't we go to the next slide, and
- 6:29Bobby, I'm turning it over to you. Thanks, Stephanie,
- 6:32and thank you to the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 6:36We're really delighted to present this research.
- 6:40So it's important to remember that bullying is
- 6:44more than incivility, being rude or disrespectful.
- 6:48And so as set forth on this slide, the definition
- 6:53that we used in our survey was inappropriate
- 6:57behavior intended to intimidate, humiliate, or
- 7:01control the actions of another person. And that
- 7:05conduct can include both verbal and non -verbal,
- 7:10as well as physical acts. And the reason we chose
- 7:14to define bullying like this is because workplace
- 7:21anti -harassment laws and policies apply only
- 7:26to abusive conduct that is targeted at someone
- 7:31due to a protected characteristics, such as gender,
- 7:36sexual orientation, or other personal characteristic.
- 7:40Therefore, bullying that cannot be proven to
- 7:44be motivated by such a characteristic may not
- 7:48be illegal and may not be subject to an organization's
- 7:53anti -harassment laws. Given that bullying, there
- 7:59is really no set standards and there was really
- 8:05no database until we conducted the survey about
- 8:09the extent and impact of bullying. This research
- 8:13was very important and indeed, As you look at
- 8:17the slide, I think one of the most surprising
- 8:20statistics was how often bullying takes place.
- 8:24So while the Illinois Supreme Court sponsored
- 8:27this research, we believe bullying exists everywhere.
- 8:31It is not confined to Illinois. And in fact,
- 8:34when you look at the data, one in four lawyers
- 8:38reported that in the past year, they had been
- 8:42personally experienced, had been personally bullied
- 8:46at work, and 13 % experienced bullying on multiple
- 8:50occasions in that year. And we chose to look
- 8:55at, in terms of the survey, how did bullying,
- 8:58when did it occur? And we wanted a temporal scope
- 9:02that was close in time so that people's, these
- 9:06experiences would be fresh. And in the open -ended
- 9:11questions, that Stephanie described, people did
- 9:15talk about the trauma of being bullied at times
- 9:20more than a year ago. But again, our temple scope
- 9:23was in 2023, 2024. And when you extrapolate this
- 9:29result to more than the 55 ,000 active Illinois
- 9:34lawyers, it meant that over 13 ,000 lawyers in
- 9:38Illinois had experienced some form of bullying.
- 9:41in the course of one year, which is really astonishing
- 9:46and sad, and I think really emphasizes the importance
- 9:51of understanding the prevalence, the impact,
- 9:55and the steps to combat bullying. Next slide,
- 10:00please. Stephanie. So in the past year, what
- 10:09we did is we looked at who was more likely to
- 10:14be bullied at work. And this is not to say that
- 10:19only certain groups of people are bullied at
- 10:23work, but it is to say that certain demographic
- 10:27groups are much more likely to be bullied at
- 10:30work. So that 38 % of women lawyers compared
- 10:35to only 50 % 15 % of male lawyers reported that
- 10:40they were bullied at work. 38 % of lawyers with
- 10:44an impairment that substantially limits a major
- 10:48life activity were bullied compared to 23 % of
- 10:52lawyers without that level of disability. Regarding
- 10:56race and ethnicity, 23 % of white lawyers reported
- 11:02being bullying in the last year, but lawyers
- 11:06of color really ranging depending on your racial
- 11:09or ethnic group from 28 % to 35%, a much higher
- 11:14percentage of lawyers of color were bullied in
- 11:18the past year, at least once. And by the way,
- 11:21these statistics are bullied in the past year
- 11:24at work at least once and sometimes multiple
- 11:28or very frequent times, like weekly. Even older
- 11:34lawyers get bullied. While it's true that the
- 11:38youngest age cohort, age 25 to 35, in that group,
- 11:4439 % of young lawyers reported bullying and the
- 11:48likelihood of bullying decreases with each age
- 11:52group, each older group, but even much older
- 11:55lawyers are bullied. And sexual orientation is
- 11:59another factor that enhances the frequency of
- 12:04bullying. 29 % of lawyers who are gay, lesbian,
- 12:08or bisexual were the target of verbal bullying
- 12:11related to their sexual orientation, compared
- 12:15to 3 % of heterosexual lawyers. And Stephanie,
- 12:19I want to just add with respect to age, especially
- 12:23in this cohort of lawyers ages 66 to 75 who were
- 12:28bullied. We really found that that had to do
- 12:32with comments and about they were past their
- 12:37prime. It had issues to do with succession and
- 12:40really trying to ensure this transition. But
- 12:46we also found that especially with younger lawyers,
- 12:51we got a number of comments that talked about
- 12:55how ingrained it was in the legal profession.
- 12:59to haze and to mistreat and overwork young lawyers.
- 13:04I think we really received a ton of comments
- 13:08that this was about hazing, that this type of
- 13:12conduct was, as Stephanie said at the beginning,
- 13:15was really something that was normalized in legal
- 13:18organizations. Let's go to the next slide. We
- 13:26asked about many different types of bullying.
- 13:28But there are seven most common types of bullying
- 13:33experienced by lawyers in the past year. The
- 13:38most commonly experienced type of bullying was
- 13:40verbal intimidation, insults, name calling, shouting,
- 13:46heart, but the second most common form of bullying.
- 13:48And by the way, people can reported more than
- 13:51experiencing more than one type of bullying.
- 13:54But the most common type was verbal intimidation.
- 13:58The second most common type was harsh, belittling,
- 14:03or excessive criticism. You know, you idiot,
- 14:06you don't know what you're doing. You'll never
- 14:08be able to be a lawyer and I could go on and
- 14:11on. Demeaning nonverbal comments. Sometimes that's
- 14:17hovering, sometimes it's violating body space,
- 14:21and there are all other sorts of ways of demeaning
- 14:24nonverbal behaviors. The fourth most common was
- 14:28routinely subject to unrealistic, unreasonable
- 14:32work demands. Calling you up on a Saturday night
- 14:35and saying, I need this done Sunday morning.
- 14:37That's a very common example that people complained
- 14:40about. Another type of bullying that was common
- 14:44was behind the back false accusations, malicious
- 14:48rumors. And then improperly taking credit for
- 14:52your work was another form of bullying. And the
- 14:57seventh most common form was not receiving important
- 15:00work information, like not getting deadlines
- 15:03from your partner and then you don't make the
- 15:06deadline and then the partner complains, or not
- 15:09being invited to core meetings when matters of
- 15:13substance and importance are being discussed
- 15:15that impact the work you do. Now, these are the
- 15:19reports from people who were bullied. If we do
- 15:23a click here, If we click the screen, we'll see.
- 15:31We also heard from people who admitted they bullied
- 15:36others. In fact, 150 respondents said, yes, I've
- 15:42bullied people in the last year. And the types
- 15:46of bullying they reported doing, the seven most
- 15:51common types of bullying reported by lawyers
- 15:54doing the bullying were a matchup to the seven
- 15:58most common bullying experiences reported to
- 16:02us by the targets of bullying. So this type of
- 16:06reporting about the frequency of this behavior
- 16:09has a real validity, a basic reality to it. because
- 16:14when you ask victims and when you ask the bullies,
- 16:18they tell you, yes, that's exactly the behavior
- 16:21that happens. And Stephanie, I wanted to add,
- 16:24I mean, given the times, one of the types of
- 16:28conduct we also found was cyberbullying. That
- 16:32was something that many people experienced. And
- 16:37again, something that was at least shocking to
- 16:39me was that 26 % of lawyers who were bullied
- 16:44said that they had been bullied to say or do
- 16:48something unethical or improper in the past year.
- 16:54So again, when people talk about what is bullying,
- 16:57it's really crossing that line and crossing over
- 17:01beyond cell zealous advocacy to being bullied
- 17:05to do something that is improper. And finally,
- 17:09again, While we know that bullying impacts all
- 17:12lawyers, as we've gone through in the statistics,
- 17:17underrepresented groups actually do get bullied
- 17:20more. And what was interesting to me was, with
- 17:24respect to gender, 40 % of women lawyer respondents
- 17:29experienced verbal bullying, such as negative
- 17:34innuendos, jokes, or even threats. related to
- 17:39their gender as compared to just 17 % of men.
- 17:46Bobby, I think you have the next slide. So we've
- 17:57talked about who is bullied, who are the bullies.
- 18:01And as we found in our report and in the data,
- 18:07Bullying is really the result of an imbalance
- 18:09of power. When you look at who were the bullies,
- 18:14this definitely explains why this conduct goes
- 18:17on. It's generally a more senior lawyer who uses
- 18:22their power to control, intimidate the person
- 18:26they're bullying. We found that in one -on -one
- 18:30bullying, the bullying is often a lawyer in the
- 18:33same firm or company who is more senior. 31 percent
- 18:38of those lawyers were in a different, more powerful
- 18:42level. We also found that in many cases, as demonstrated
- 18:47in the comments that we received, it was a rainmaker
- 18:52or a real leader in the legal organization like
- 18:56the general counsel. which made it very hard
- 18:59for the people who were the victims of this conduct.
- 19:03Less frequent was bullying by a lawyer at the
- 19:06same or a more junior level. But when you look
- 19:10at 33 % of lawyers were also bullied by someone
- 19:15who didn't work in the same workplace, such as
- 19:19opposing counsel, or as you see in the bullet
- 19:22above, even 7 % reported that clients. might
- 19:26bully them. And that was particularly demonstrated
- 19:31by comments where clients wanted lawyers to do
- 19:35something that bordered on this unethical improper
- 19:39conduct, which they determined or thought would
- 19:42be more zealous advocacy. It was also disturbing
- 19:50to see the number of lawyers who were also bullied
- 19:53by judges. Again, by the types of conduct that
- 19:57Stephanie described, excessive criticism, demeaning
- 20:02comments, conduct such as that. But as we said,
- 20:08it is definitely as a result of this imbalance
- 20:10of power and it is important, again, we feel
- 20:17for organizations to really understand and collect
- 20:20the data about who is being bullied, but importantly,
- 20:24who are those bullies? Stephanie. Thank you.
- 20:29Next slide, please. So we want to talk for a
- 20:34few minutes about what lawyers do after they
- 20:37are bullied. And there's actually two types of
- 20:40after. One is in the moment. and the other is
- 20:44one is over and they've left the scene. We asked
- 20:49people in the moment, what did you do when you
- 20:52were bullied? Again, this is all reactions about
- 20:56bullying in the past year. Over 50 percent, really
- 21:02over 60 percent of lawyers said their immediate
- 21:06response to bullying was just to ignore it or
- 21:09to walk away. didn't want to have to deal with
- 21:13it. Now, sometimes you can't walk away. If you're
- 21:16in court being bullied by opposing counsel or
- 21:19the judge, you can't walk away. But in those
- 21:22situations, when bullying occurred, the most
- 21:26common reaction was to basically ignore it and
- 21:29or walk away. And then another reaction, which
- 21:34was most of the remaining people was to verbally
- 21:39defend themselves. or sometimes just get upset
- 21:43and angry in the moment. There's no question
- 21:48that people get upset about it, but what they
- 21:52do about it right away is not always the same.
- 21:56Now, it really begs the question also about what
- 22:00do lawyers do, not just immediately after they're
- 22:04bullied, but when they leave the scene of it?
- 22:08A majority of lawyers told a friend or family
- 22:14member or a colleague about the incident. Only
- 22:2320 % reported the bullying to their supervisor
- 22:27or an upper level attorney or an HR manager.
- 22:31And we think there are a lot of reasons why that's
- 22:34so. including in many situations, there's a sense
- 22:38that nobody will help them anyway. So they have
- 22:40to kind of just take it. Another 20 % took no
- 22:45action at all. They may have felt bad, they may
- 22:50have been angry about it, but they didn't tell
- 22:52anyone and they didn't report it to anyone. There's
- 22:56also other reactions. Sometimes people took personal
- 23:00time off. Sometimes... If the bully was in the
- 23:05workplace, targets of bullying ask their employer
- 23:09to remove them from working with the bully. That
- 23:12has its own issues as well. Very few lawyers,
- 23:16only 2%, file any kind of report to a legal authority.
- 23:23And interestingly, 8 % said, they contacted the
- 23:28bully and complained directly to the bully about
- 23:31their behavior. We had a small percentage of
- 23:34bullies saying, yes, they were contacted by the
- 23:38person they bullied and they talked about it,
- 23:41but that's not a very common result. In the course
- 23:50of our survey, we actually did We didn't just
- 23:53have close -ended questions. We, along the way,
- 23:57solicited responses from people who were bullied.
- 24:01And very often, you have very poignant reactions,
- 24:05like, I stood there and I froze. I just couldn't
- 24:07do anything. Or, what's the point of reporting
- 24:10it? Nothing ever happens. So one of the hallmarks
- 24:14of the type of research we do, yes, we have statistics.
- 24:17But if you read our report, It's filled with
- 24:20individual comments and reactions for each of
- 24:24the things that we're discussing today. Bobbi?
- 24:29And I just want to add to something, if you go
- 24:34back to that slide, and that is about bystander
- 24:38bullying and an important data point that Stephanie
- 24:41just emphasized. So I think especially where
- 24:45you see that 62 % of lawyers reported they were
- 24:50bullied with others present, and 79 % of bystanders
- 24:56who witnessed bullying either, as Stephanie said,
- 24:59either took no action or walked away. Only 19
- 25:03% who witnessed the bullying took any action
- 25:08to defuse the situation. and less than five percent
- 25:13took any action to actually stop the bully. We're
- 25:18going to talk about steps for recommendations,
- 25:21but we think it is really important with respect
- 25:24to bystander when they've witnessed bullying
- 25:27to intervene because somehow when bystanders
- 25:31see bullying and they don't do anything, it leaves
- 25:35the bully with more room to continue that conduct.
- 25:40type of behavior can go unchecked. Again, we're
- 25:45going to be talking about bystander bullying
- 25:48and training, but I did want to raise that, Stephanie.
- 25:53If we go to the next slide, what do employers
- 25:58say or do when bullying is reported to them?
- 26:02Which would not be atypical. Most employers express
- 26:06concern about what happened. But then what happens?
- 26:11They took really no action at all. Some employers
- 26:16threatened or ignored the problem. Some suggested
- 26:20that the victim was actually at fault. Some dismissed
- 26:24the complaint as not important. There were 7
- 26:29% who told the victim they'd be better off not
- 26:32making a complaint and not telling anyone about
- 26:36it. or suggesting that the victim rather than
- 26:40the bully switch departments. Again, this type
- 26:44of conduct re -traumatizes the individual who
- 26:49has been bullied. As I said, in the open -ended
- 26:53questions, a lot of the comments were about what
- 26:58happened when bullying conduct was ignored. And
- 27:02many times when they had to report the bullying
- 27:06under HR procedures, they actually had to report
- 27:10the bullying to the bully himself or herself,
- 27:14which again was ineffective. Stephanie. Okay,
- 27:19let's go to the next slide. And we also ask people,
- 27:23and this is consistent with the last slide, to
- 27:25rate their employer's response to bullying. And
- 27:30given what employers, many have told us employers
- 27:35fail to do when someone reports an incident of
- 27:38bullying, it shouldn't be a surprise that the
- 27:42majority of respondents were not completely satisfied
- 27:45with their employer's response. 18 % rated their
- 27:51employer's response to a report of bullying as
- 27:54excellent, but we can see in this chart, and
- 27:58another, 30 % rated their employer's response
- 28:03as good, but 52 % of respondents rated their
- 28:09employer's reaction as either not sufficient
- 28:13or totally unsatisfactory. And again, only 18
- 28:18% rated their employer's responses excellent.
- 28:21Now, what does a good employer do? We received
- 28:26a lot of comments from lawyers about what a good
- 28:30employer did. They took the matter seriously
- 28:33and took action. Someone bullied from opposing
- 28:38counsel told us, my employer defended me and
- 28:42responded to opposing counsel's email appropriately.
- 28:46Another report was my employer took immediate
- 28:50action to ensure the bullying would not happen
- 28:53again. I was very impressed and felt my concerns
- 28:58were properly addressed. But on the other hand,
- 29:02there were many more lawyers. who were very disappointed
- 29:06in how their employer reacted. And a sampling
- 29:10of comments, the head of HR failed to address
- 29:13my concerns and seems to foster an environment
- 29:17conducive to bullying within that department.
- 29:21And we heard that repeatedly, by the way. We
- 29:25heard repeated disappointment with what HR does,
- 29:29what the human resources or the equivalent office
- 29:34in a workplace does when they learn about bullying,
- 29:37and that was reflected in the 77 % who kind of
- 29:41said, oh, no, that's terrible, but how few employers
- 29:44do anything. Other reactions from lawyers, my
- 29:49employer said that was how the bully got things
- 29:51done, or it's happening to others, nothing is
- 29:55being done, and I'm told I cannot do anything.
- 30:00Someone else told us, well, the excuse was the
- 30:03bully has a history of this action. And my employer
- 30:07said they verbally reprimand him, but nothing
- 30:10changes. So consistent with this level of disappointment
- 30:16is what we found from reports from people who
- 30:19told us they had been bullied in the past year.
- 30:23And 96 % of bullies I'm sorry, I may have misspoke.
- 30:29These are reports from bullies, the ones who
- 30:32we told you about before. So of the 150 people
- 30:36in the survey who said they had been bullied,
- 30:39the vast majority, 96%, told us they experienced
- 30:44no consequences at all from their bullying behavior.
- 30:49Only 3 % got a verbal warning from their employer,
- 30:53and only 1 % got a stricter consequence from
- 30:58a verbal warning. And I've seen incidents like
- 31:01that. I remember one incident when a bully was
- 31:05not allowed for one year. He was a partner to
- 31:09serve on a firm committee. That was the extent.
- 31:12But then a year later, there he was back on the
- 31:15committee, and he continued to bully. So employers,
- 31:21lawyers know what's going on. And as Bobby discusses,
- 31:26how employer response really has consequences
- 31:30for individuals and for the workplace itself,
- 31:34both short -term and long -term. If you go to
- 31:38the next slide. And I think what's again, what
- 31:40comes out of these comments is that individuals,
- 31:45victims of bullying are afraid to report it because
- 31:48they don't want to be viewed as a troublemaker.
- 31:51They don't want to be viewed as someone who is
- 31:57causing some kind of tension or conflict within
- 32:01the organization. Therefore, there's also the
- 32:05subtle message, as Stephanie said, that you just
- 32:08need to deal with this. This is part of all of
- 32:12the type of conduct that older lawyers have been
- 32:18exposed to and now it's your turn. uh to deal
- 32:22with this kind with this type of behavior and
- 32:26go ahead and in fact we heard that many times
- 32:31in the open ended comments whether the senior
- 32:34person was a woman or a man very often their
- 32:37reaction was well i had to do it you it's part
- 32:40of becoming a lawyer you just have to suffer
- 32:42that And I think, again, when we get into, there
- 32:46are certain areas of the law where we really
- 32:49received a great deal of comments about bullying.
- 32:53In litigation, for example, and Stephanie and
- 32:56I are both litigators, and we can tell some stories.
- 32:59I will tell one, which especially, again, this
- 33:03age differential, where older lawyers or more
- 33:06experienced lawyer may use bullying and abusive
- 33:10conduct really as a tactic. So I recall when
- 33:15I was a young lawyer and I was scheduled to take
- 33:18a deposition and the opposing lawyer was sort
- 33:23of the dean of the class action bar in Philadelphia
- 33:26and he was known to hover over the lawyer defending
- 33:32their witness and he would do other sorts of
- 33:35tactics that would intimidate you and sort of
- 33:39get you off your game. And so knowing that, before
- 33:44I went to defend this deposition, I did some
- 33:50research on him. I took with me the name and
- 33:53phone number, not the name, but the phone number
- 33:56of the clerk for the judge and the judge so that
- 33:59if it happened, I could report that behavior.
- 34:02And definitely, that's what happened during the
- 34:05deposition. He got up. He tried to intimidate
- 34:09me. I was able, it was on video, so I was able
- 34:12to make a comment for the record so that if we
- 34:17wanted to bring additional motions afterward,
- 34:20I would have laid the foundation. And I tried
- 34:23to call the judge who was not available, but
- 34:25the conduct did stop. And I think, again, when
- 34:28we talk about recommendations for training, that's
- 34:32definitely something that we're going to advise
- 34:34younger lawyers to do, almost role play the types
- 34:37of situations where they may encounter bullying
- 34:41and what would be the types of conduct that they
- 34:43could take to offset that behavior. But again,
- 34:47going back to the slide. I think our data is
- 34:51a wake -up call for all leaders in all legal
- 34:55organizations in terms of what happens when bullying
- 34:59is allowed to exist. Because you'll see 54 %
- 35:03of bullied lawyers report a negative change in
- 35:07their emotional well -being, anxiety, loss of
- 35:10self -confidence, and other negative feelings.
- 35:1339 % of bullied lawyers felt less productive
- 35:17at work. 20 % actually had a physical reaction
- 35:22to being bullied and their physical health actually
- 35:26did decline. And as a result of this, there is
- 35:30an impact to the bottom line to employers because
- 35:33they are going to lose employees. And again,
- 35:37our data shows what happens. So 18 % of the lawyers
- 35:42who were bullied reported that they left a job
- 35:46practicing law because of workplace bullying.
- 35:49And again, extrapolating that number means that
- 35:5310 ,000 lawyers in Illinois who currently practice
- 35:57in Illinois had left one job due to bullying.
- 36:01In addition, 9 % of our respondents said that
- 36:04they were looking for a new job because of bullying.
- 36:09And again, if you extrapolate that number, that's
- 36:12over 5 ,000 lawyers in Illinois. And again, Bullying
- 36:18has a disproportionate impact on underrepresented
- 36:22groups and it results in bullying with women,
- 36:32LGBTQ plus lawyers, lawyers of color and lawyers
- 36:35with a disability looking for a new job due to
- 36:40bullying. And as a result, this is going to impact
- 36:43our profession. It is going to impact the pipeline
- 36:47we want to establish to ensure that we have a
- 36:51wide array of talent going through our legal
- 36:55organizations. And importantly, this is a group
- 37:00of lawyers that employers have spent substantial
- 37:04time, investment of money to train. And again,
- 37:08they are going to vote with their feet and walk
- 37:12out the door. And let me just supplement that
- 37:16for a minute by saying, while we did do this
- 37:19study in Illinois, Illinois is actually a very
- 37:23interesting state from which to think about other
- 37:26states as well. It's demographically diverse.
- 37:30In fact, its demography probably mirrors generally
- 37:33the demography of the country. It has a very
- 37:37broad array of practices. It has big city, suburban,
- 37:44and rural lawyers across the state. And it has
- 37:49very active bar association groups. So it's not
- 37:54like it's a state that's only rural, or it's
- 37:56not like it's a state where the majority of litigation
- 37:59is about drug use. It's not an area like that.
- 38:04It's really a very multifaceted group of lawyers.
- 38:08And it has implications, we believe, for many
- 38:11other states in the country. And just going back
- 38:15again to these underrepresented groups, nearly
- 38:18three times as many women lawyers, so 28 % of
- 38:22women compared to just 10 % of men, had left
- 38:26the job due to bullying. And again, 25 % of LGBTQ
- 38:31plus lawyers, 28 % of disabled lawyers, and 24
- 38:36% of lawyers of color. reported that they had
- 38:40left the job due to bullying. And when, again,
- 38:43you think about those numbers and the impact
- 38:45of that in a legal organization, it is really
- 38:49important, we think, for all legal organizations
- 38:52to understand what is going on in their culture
- 38:56and to really have a culture survey where they
- 39:00measure and they look at this and what they're
- 39:03going to do once they find if they do find that
- 39:07bullying has infected the culture of the organization.
- 39:11Stephanie? I think we're turning to the next
- 39:17slide at this point. Bobbi? Again, we wanted
- 39:23to give you some of the examples of the open
- 39:27-ended comments that we received. Again, you
- 39:31can really tell how heartfelt These comments
- 39:36were not only in the written survey, but also
- 39:41in the focus groups. I think talking about the
- 39:46impact on emotional well -being, bullying compounds
- 39:51itself. After being bullied, you begin to worry,
- 39:54then you have trouble sleeping. You come to work,
- 39:56but you aren't working at your full capacity.
- 40:01comment which shows that nothing changes. He
- 40:04has a history of bullying. The employer claims
- 40:07they verbally reprimand him. Nothing changes.
- 40:11My senior partner treated me in a pathologically
- 40:14harsh manner. My employer said that was how the
- 40:18bully got things done, justifying the behavior.
- 40:21Again, where the bully is a rainmaker or in a
- 40:25position of real power, since the bully was the
- 40:28GC, no one. no one was interested in what that
- 40:32occurred. And we've really found that a lot of
- 40:35comments, as I said before, about rainmakers.
- 40:40The sort of yin and yang, especially law firms,
- 40:44that they're dependent on rainmakers, but at
- 40:47the same time, even though the culture that is
- 40:51created could be deleterious. could be harmful,
- 40:55they're not gonna do anything to stop it, deleterious.
- 40:59There you go. Go ahead, Stephanie. All right,
- 41:03let's go to the next slide. And we always like
- 41:10to do research that ends up with best practices,
- 41:13with really database best practices. And what
- 41:18we ended with in our report is what can we, and
- 41:23that we as a lot of different people, what can
- 41:26we do to stop bullying? And the very first thing
- 41:30we spoke about in the report is what workplaces
- 41:34can do to develop and implement and enforce anti
- 41:39-bullying policies. Now, how does a firm or company
- 41:44go about doing that? We have a phrase that we
- 41:48often use, it comes from the top. You can't expect
- 41:53change, once in a while it happens, but you can
- 41:56expect change to take place from the HR department
- 42:01or from one practice group or from an entity
- 42:06that's like the administrative chief of staff.
- 42:10You really have to have the senior people or
- 42:14the senior person in charge of the workplace
- 42:18say, you know what? We're not going to tolerate
- 42:21this. This hurts lawyers. It hurts our business.
- 42:25It hurts our reputation. We have to do things
- 42:28differently. And we lay out in the report a set
- 42:31of steps that law firms and companies or agencies
- 42:36can take to do things differently. Now, there
- 42:39isn't a one size fits all. So one of the first
- 42:44things that we suggest is an informal I don't
- 42:49want to call it an informal, open door. Tell
- 42:53me what you think about bullying and what's happening
- 42:56here and what we can do about it. A leader should
- 43:00do that under a pledge of, it's just going to
- 43:05be between you and me. I'm not going to tell
- 43:07your name. I mean, you can ask people in groups
- 43:11what they think, but part of finding out about
- 43:15the culture in ways that you may not know about
- 43:17as a leader, are to have an open door invitation
- 43:20for lawyers and staff to reach out on the subject
- 43:23of bullying and private conversations that can
- 43:26lead to very unexpected but very useful information.
- 43:31Now turning to the framework of an effective
- 43:35policy, we also outline that. And an effective
- 43:41policy should be written and distributed to all
- 43:45employees with regular updating and annual redistribution,
- 43:50really an annual training session. And the first
- 43:53part of such a policy is a definition and examples
- 43:58of bullying. You could use examples like the
- 44:02ones that are in report, but the policy should
- 44:05also include a statement about where bullying
- 44:08can occur, such as one -on -one meetings or group
- 44:11meetings, interactions with clients, and other
- 44:14places. and other gatherings of lawyers, so people
- 44:17are sensitive to what the chances are of that
- 44:21kind of activity. The second thing in an effective
- 44:24policy is procedures for confidential and retaliation
- 44:30-free reporting. Both are important. Confidentiality,
- 44:35retaliation -free. And certainly, our research
- 44:39shows the importance of implementing safe and
- 44:44confidential and effective ways to report bullying.
- 44:48In fact, many respondents, many survey, many
- 44:52response to the survey and focus group members
- 44:55told us that they have felt and they have had
- 44:59friends who felt completely inhibited because
- 45:03there's a pressure in the culture. Just be a
- 45:06good team player or don't make waves or just
- 45:09suck it up, that famous phrase. And But what
- 45:14they are looking for and what can be effective
- 45:16are prompt methods and procedures for reporting
- 45:20and making it retaliation free. And the way to
- 45:24report is to designate two people, not one, because
- 45:29you could be hitting the person, as Bobby mentioned
- 45:32earlier, who actually is the bully, but to designate
- 45:35two people to be the persons to report to. and
- 45:39to communicate with the individuals involved.
- 45:44And you don't want the reporting policy to prohibit
- 45:48even covert or subtle forms of retaliation by
- 45:53people in power, like a partner saying, OK, that
- 45:57person reported bullying, not going to give him
- 46:00any more work. So confidentiality and designated
- 46:04people to report to and discretion are very,
- 46:08very important part. of an effective policy.
- 46:11And then, of course, you need procedures for
- 46:14prompt investigation and follow -up communication.
- 46:18And the investigation should lead to a report
- 46:22or a written record of the process and findings.
- 46:26And both the person making the charge as well
- 46:29as the person accused of bullying should be informed
- 46:32of the results. And there needs to be implementation
- 46:37of appropriate remedial actions. Not all misconduct
- 46:43and consequences are the same. And although we
- 46:46think it's infrequent, there are situations when
- 46:49a report of bullying may not be viewed that way
- 46:52by others. But for the most part, if it gets
- 46:55to the point where someone is kind of having
- 47:00the courage to report bullying, you have to investigate
- 47:04it and look at what the consequences should be.
- 47:11And depending on the nature of the misconduct,
- 47:14maybe it's a verbal reprimand, maybe it's a formal
- 47:17written reprimand, maybe it's mandatory training
- 47:21or change in leadership position or demotion,
- 47:25either temporary or permanent. termination is
- 47:28even a possible act. It really depends on how
- 47:32serious the problem is. And remedial actions
- 47:36may also include changes in an organization's
- 47:39policies or practices. Because if there's a set
- 47:43of bullying incidents or a series of events,
- 47:48that really begs the question, do we have a policy
- 47:51that's working? And what do we need to change
- 47:54it? Does there need to be changes in the policy
- 47:58or better training or other organization wide
- 48:01actions. And the last thing about an effective
- 48:06workplace policy is once there is a resolution,
- 48:12a solution of beginning, a middle and end of
- 48:15a specific bullying activity, it's good to check
- 48:22in three months later, let's say. with the person
- 48:26who reported the bullying and see how that person
- 48:29is doing and whether there's any additional information
- 48:33that would help a leader decide if this policy
- 48:38is effective and what it means. And Stephanie,
- 48:42I would say three quick points with respect to
- 48:45establishing these policies. One, I'm going to
- 48:48emphasize again, it's really important to understand
- 48:52what is going on in your organization. If you're
- 48:56going to implement a policy, you have to know
- 48:58whether or not this type of conduct exists in
- 49:02your organization so you can really address and
- 49:06you can frame your policy in terms of what is
- 49:09happening in the organization. Two, the lack
- 49:14of consequences, the lack of any accountability,
- 49:18I would say is the major theme that came out
- 49:22of the comments in our survey. in terms of this
- 49:26is what happens. If there are no consequences,
- 49:29it is going to perpetuate this type of conduct.
- 49:34And third, it is really important when you have
- 49:37these policies to ensure that there are, as Stephanie
- 49:40said, these touch points where you go back to
- 49:43the victim and you really ensure again, if you
- 49:47want to make sure that they're not going to be.
- 49:49in that statistic of people either looking or
- 49:54leaving a job that they feel that they're being
- 49:57heard, that this conduct is being addressed,
- 50:01and importantly, being remedied. So that takes
- 50:04us to our second recommendation, which is the
- 50:07importance of training. Once you have that policy,
- 50:10then you have to conduct the training specific
- 50:13to what, as Stephanie said, it's not going to
- 50:15be a cookie cutter policy, we hope. We hope it's
- 50:19going to be specific to the organizations. And
- 50:23the training should include, one, it should take
- 50:27place at least annually. Two, it should include,
- 50:31as we say, not only the definition and examples,
- 50:35but really giving scenarios. What is the difference
- 50:39between zealous advocacy and where it crosses
- 50:42the line to intimidation and abusive conduct?
- 50:45And also importantly, this training should include
- 50:49what happens when you are bullying? What are
- 50:52the types of steps that an individual lawyer
- 50:55can take? What are the types of steps that the
- 50:58leader or group practice leader should be taking
- 51:01in terms of ensuring that this conduct is not
- 51:04happening? Again, this is going to impact the
- 51:08bottom line, so people should be incentivized.
- 51:11to one, understand the policy and participate
- 51:16in this training. And we also recommend that
- 51:20this training occur even before lawyers start
- 51:23in their jobs. Law schools have a responsibility,
- 51:28knowing the types of highly competitive hierarchical
- 51:32organizations that many of their students will
- 51:35be entering in practice, to really teach them
- 51:39about bullying. Again, steps to combat it when
- 51:44they are in practice, whether it's within their
- 51:46firm, whether it's in court, whether it's in
- 51:50a deposition or other types of conduct that they
- 51:57may have to experience. Again, training is critical
- 52:01to our recommendations. Stephanie. Thank you.
- 52:08Bobby and I may not have been so surprised, but
- 52:11a lot of the people on the advisory camp, so
- 52:14really a lot of people who read the report have
- 52:17told us they were surprised about how many complaints
- 52:21there were in the survey about judges and lawyers
- 52:25bullying in the courtroom and how bullying is
- 52:29kind of flagrant in many settings in litigation.
- 52:34Sadly, really, there were more than a few reports
- 52:38of bullying by judges. You recall that 14 % of
- 52:43our respondents complained about bullying from
- 52:46judges. And we feel like the data are very clear
- 52:51that the time is right for greater guidance from
- 52:56judges and litigators alike about what is acceptable
- 53:00and what is not. And certainly with respect to
- 53:03the courtroom, and the common view was, and the
- 53:08common statements that were made to us, well,
- 53:11if it's in the courtroom, it's on the judge.
- 53:14This is from a judge himself. Other judges have
- 53:17said, I set the tone. this minimizes inappropriate
- 53:21behavior. Another judge said, shooting it down
- 53:25right away is generally effective. And I remember
- 53:28another judge in one of the focus groups says,
- 53:31I don't tolerate it. If I see somebody bowling,
- 53:35if I hear about it, I tell them the next move
- 53:37they make, they're going to get reported to the
- 53:40ARDC. So these were judges who had firm, clear
- 53:45views about what they should be doing. But that
- 53:48wasn't always the case. And a lot of judges felt
- 53:52like where they weren't sure what to do. Or they
- 53:56weren't sure. Judges don't sit in standalone
- 54:00courtrooms. They're part of a circuit or a division.
- 54:04There are guidelines that they have to follow
- 54:06as well. And many of them said it would be really
- 54:10useful to have a set of, let's say, circuit -wide
- 54:14guidelines about what to do about bullying. So
- 54:17that is certainly one of our recommendations
- 54:20that we recommend that there be standing orders
- 54:27regarding bullying and incivility in the courtrooms,
- 54:31because far too many lawyers and even judges
- 54:33said they have nowhere to turn when that happens.
- 54:38And judges and litigators alike can benefit from
- 54:41written guidance about what's acceptable and
- 54:43what's not acceptable. And in Illinois, we have
- 54:47very strong judicial training. It's going to
- 54:50be supplemented even more now with anti -bullying
- 54:54material. But certainly, any kind of continuing
- 54:58judicial training, which I think takes place
- 55:00in the large majority of states, have to have
- 55:03something about bullying in the legal profession.
- 55:06So we do look to judges to set the standard and
- 55:10to make sure that people know there are standards,
- 55:13and they have to be that. And again, going back
- 55:17to judges, we think judges should receive training
- 55:20so that they can recognize they also have steps
- 55:23to take when bullying that they intervene. And
- 55:27again, going back to this bystander training,
- 55:30we think it is really important when someone
- 55:32in power, like a judge or a leader, intervenes
- 55:36when they witness bullying, because that is the
- 55:39quickest, best way to stop that condom. Of course,
- 55:44one of our recommendation, and we thank the Beverly
- 55:46Hill Bar Association because they're implementing
- 55:50that recommendation to continue to educate about
- 55:53this important topic and to advance programs
- 55:57so that we talk about coming up with anti -bullying
- 56:03set of standards, coming up with tactics, establishing
- 56:07a mentoring group where someone may be reluctant
- 56:12to talk about because they don't want to be labeled
- 56:14a troublemaker within their organization, but
- 56:17that they could reach out to someone within the
- 56:20Bar Association to talk about what is the best
- 56:23way to handle the situation if they are being
- 56:26bullied. So again, Bar Associations play an important
- 56:30role, and again, we thank you for sponsoring
- 56:32this program. Yeah, and I would like to emphasize
- 56:36the Safe Space Role that bar associations can
- 56:41play for victims of bullying to receive guidance
- 56:44Especially as Bobby point out when they feel
- 56:47they have no other place to turn We have one
- 56:50group in Illinois called Lady Lawyers Who Lunch,
- 56:54and it's actually a resource group formed by
- 56:57a group of women lawyers that serves as a safe
- 57:01place where lawyers who have been bullied in
- 57:03the course of litigation can discuss their experiences
- 57:07and receive guidance and really feel that they're
- 57:10being heard and that there is something that
- 57:13can be done about it. So it can be a small group
- 57:17within a bar association that also really is
- 57:20effective for this process. That may be a good
- 57:26segue to our final topic here, which is how can
- 57:30individual lawyers react to bullying? And as
- 57:35Bobby mentioned before, one of the first pieces
- 57:39of advice that we give about that is to be prepared,
- 57:42to practice. Now, it was interesting because
- 57:46we both have been in this experience of litigation.
- 57:50And one of the pieces of advice we give is when
- 57:53you're in the room with someone who's trying
- 57:55to bully you, who's hovering over you, who's
- 57:58pounding the table, who's getting red in the
- 58:00face, who's pointing his finger, put that on
- 58:03the record. You can say right on the record,
- 58:06Mr. Smith, you're hovering over me, step away
- 58:09and go back to your seat. Mr. Smith, you're pounding
- 58:12the table. Mr. Smith, you're beet red shouting
- 58:15at me. Please calm down so we can continue with
- 58:18this deposition. A lot of times, a lawyer will
- 58:21say, let's go off the record. No, the reporter
- 58:25won't go off the record unless both people agree.
- 58:28Say no, we're staying on the record. So everything
- 58:32is there if you decide. you need to do something
- 58:35about it after the fact. There are, of course,
- 58:38local rules and federal rules about what to do
- 58:41when someone is being disruptive in a deposition.
- 58:44Know the rules and cite them, and if you have
- 58:48to, use them right on the spot. You know, rehearsing
- 58:53is another technique that we're very fond of,
- 58:57just like when you have a hearing. for when you
- 59:00have an oral argument or when you have an opening
- 59:03statement, you rehearse it. If you anticipate
- 59:06a problem, think about how you're going to handle
- 59:09it. Talk to somebody else about it, a friend.
- 59:13What do you think about this? If he does that
- 59:15or she does that and I say this, how does that
- 59:18work? So rehearsing can be really, really effective.
- 59:22And if you're in court, you may decide to recite
- 59:25to the judge what the bullying is doing and putting
- 59:29that on the record, or to recite to the judge
- 59:32the cursing that the bully just did before the
- 59:36case was called and say, this should not be taking
- 59:41place. And I believe that most judges are likely
- 59:44to agree to that. So there are lots of other
- 59:48ways that you can prepare individually, talking
- 59:52to people especially is a really good way about
- 59:54whatever you want to talk about. But again, we
- 59:58have a whole set of information in the report
- 1:00:01that we wanted to get on the record and to share
- 1:00:04with people. I would just add with respect to
- 1:00:08individuals, if you are being bullied, obviously
- 1:00:11chronicle what is going on. so you can decide
- 1:00:14what type of action you may want to take, but
- 1:00:18it'll be contemporaneous. And two, again, I would
- 1:00:22identify a mentor or someone who is a trusted
- 1:00:27advisor. that can help you really talk about
- 1:00:31and talk through what are some of the solutions
- 1:00:35to this type of conduct that you may be encountering.
- 1:00:40And clearly, if your mental or physical health
- 1:00:43is being jeopardized, you really have to take
- 1:00:46immediate action. What is so important about
- 1:00:50this research is that we believe it is up to
- 1:00:55everyone in the legal profession to ensure that
- 1:01:00we have respect, civility, and that we have those
- 1:01:05who are in authority and who can set policy enforce
- 1:01:10anti -bullying in our workplaces and in our courtrooms.
- 1:01:19So I don't know if we have questions, but I think
- 1:01:24we may be out of time. We may be out of time.
- 1:01:28I guess one of the things I would add is if anyone
- 1:01:34here is interested in finding out more about
- 1:01:38the research or has an interest in having research
- 1:01:42done where they are through a bar association,
- 1:01:45through another group, please feel free to reach
- 1:01:48out to us and we'd be happy to talk to you about
- 1:01:51it. I would just add why data is so important
- 1:01:55is that it provides the empirical validation
- 1:01:58of the conduct we know that is going on. Everyone
- 1:02:02has experienced bullying probably starting back
- 1:02:05when they were in elementary, middle, and high
- 1:02:09school. Unfortunately, it continues in law school
- 1:02:13and then in practice. But actually having that
- 1:02:16data and understanding what the data means, is
- 1:02:20really the first step in formulating the types
- 1:02:23of effective policies that will address that
- 1:02:26conduct. So thank you again so much for this.
- 1:02:33All righty, then this concludes today's presentation.
- 1:02:36Thank you so much, Bobbi. And thank you so much,
- 1:02:38Stephanie, for your time. And thank you to our
- 1:02:41audience. Have a good morning, everybody. You
- 1:02:45may be eligible for CLE credit in your state.
- 1:02:48visit bhba .org slash podcasts for more information.