Latest / Ask the Lawyer / 01/04/2024 Ask the Lawyer with Harvey Peyton

Transcript

01/04/2024 Ask the Lawyer with Harvey Peyton · Ask the Lawyer

0:00
Our area's most beautiful properties deserve the finest Wilters Meeks Realty Group. We focus
0:05
on buying and selling residential and commercial properties throughout the Tri State area. Contact
0:09
Meeks Realty Group online at Meeks dot us or call three oh four four four
0:13
zero one, one zero one. The views and opinions expressed on this program
0:18
do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of five eight whs It's employees or
0:23
WVRC Media. Put the power of Payden on the side. We have the
0:30
court room experience that you need. We never give up. We're prepared to
0:37
fight for your rights. When you need action, count on us. Put
0:45
the power of Paton on your side, the power of beage. It's a
0:58
twenty two and it's fivechs the Voice of Charleston. And this is the first
1:03
Thursday of twenty twenty four. I'm Jeff Jenkins and joined by Harvey Payton of
1:07
the Peyton Law Firm in Nitro. And as always when Harvey's here, the
1:11
lines are open three oh four three four five fifty eight fifty eight three oh
1:15
four three four five fifty eight fifty any questions about the law. And this
1:19
is beginning the twenty sixth year on the air on Thursdays on five ADWCHS for
1:26
the Peyton. That is true. I've just dawned on me this morning.
1:32
It goes last week. Tom and I were both on the road. We
1:36
had got separate vehicles to Charlotte to see the Mountaineers triumph in the Bowl game
1:42
and literally get this oriented about your days of the week during the holidays.
1:49
And so my wife and I are flying back up I seventy seven out of
1:53
Charlotte in the express lane, and it just dawned on me, Well,
1:57
what about the radio. I didn't because he's Tom and I will just text
2:00
to yeah, email or talk to each other in the office. Well,
2:07
nothing to be done now. So and you know, actually when I got
2:10
back to the office, I forgot to ask Tom about it, and uh,
2:16
yeah he was on called in Yeah, in basketing in the victory.
2:21
Well it was a victory to basket It was great. It was Actually I've
2:24
been to some of the what's it appropriate because they had the ESPN money making
2:30
Bowl games, of which there are proliferation now. I can remember the first
2:35
time when I was in school at Morgantown, the Mountain. Here's got a
2:38
bull bid of the Peach Bowl to play South Carolina, And it was a
2:40
big deal because they were only there are ten bowl games in the country.
2:46
Uh so to get a bid, really it was a big deal. And
2:51
they had to beat Pitt remember on a last minute field goal, but Bill
2:54
McKenzie to get themselves into the Peach Ball next time, get beat on NC
3:00
State. Yeah, the odious low holes. But no, there was a
3:05
real I mean they're literally in the stadium. There were forty two thousand people
3:09
there, which is a big crowd for an off bowl game. I would
3:14
estimate thirty thousand were dressed in gold and probably the probably thirty five thousand of
3:24
the forty two thousand were Mountaineer supporters. It was a big deal. And
3:29
the crowded around the stadium and crowded in the restaurants. And then I actually
3:32
had the feeling of a bowl game. Yeah, how about that? How
3:35
about that? And said and has Brad Howise sat on sports Line the last
3:38
couple of days. You know, maybe at some point the people who run
3:43
this whole thing will realize how regionalism is important. It is important even I
3:49
mean the last closest game we had was in Memphis at the Liberty Bowl.
3:53
But yeah, that's a twelve hour drive, that's all. That's a long
3:57
haul to make it in one day. And if you want to break it
4:01
up into two days, that means you're going to be staying somewhere between Nashville
4:04
and Memphis. And it's not a part of it. You're driving into Sea
4:06
Again, it's like going to an away game. It's only going to a
4:10
bowl game. So West Virginia fans know Charlotte's nothing. They drive to Myrtle
4:14
Beach. That's just you know, it's just like, wow, he's Charlotte
4:17
Buck. You know. Yeah, well, mean there people in Backley in
4:19
President have little vacation homes of Lake Norman. They just zip down there every
4:24
weekend. So we got back. You know, it was a nice New
4:26
Year's Uh, not much to do. Starting off yesterday. You know Matt
4:30
Roorbach is in the House of Delicate Doctor. Well he's my doctor from Capple
4:34
County. So yesterday was well, Monday was New Year's Day. Tuesday was
4:40
my prep day for my colonoscopy exam, which you should have if you get
4:46
to the age where your doctor says do it. Because I put it off
4:48
like six years ago and ended up had colon cancer. Right, I had
4:51
to have part of my colon taken out, and you know, you never
4:56
know if you beat it the bad The thing about cancer is a psychological where
5:00
is on you? So this was my follow up colonoscopy. Well is it
5:08
going to be oh okay or is it going to be Harvey? I need
5:11
to see in the office Friday, which was the last time. So we
5:14
came in the recovery room and put up two fingers at hey, I'll see
5:17
you in two years. Everything's final. It's like somebody saying you're going to
5:21
live two more years. It's like I'm giving you two years. Which I
5:26
immediately started looking, well, who's going to who are the Mountaineers a week?
5:29
Next football opponents? I know who they are nextra years that is our
5:31
Western game in Colorada of the year after Yeah. Yah, So now I
5:35
can make the plans for twenty twenty five. And then I thought, wait
5:38
a minute, if this is the start of twenty twenty four. We started
5:45
on the air the first twenty or nineteen ninety nine, that's twenty five years,
5:53
so that's a quarter century. That's a long time to do anything.
5:56
That is and that is just yeah, I mean what a great I mean,
6:00
you've been here, Harvey, longer than you've been on the air longer
6:04
than and in this building longer than any employee. But two, okay you
6:13
said that, Well, well, well I came to this building, came
6:16
from I came to this building in two thousand. I worked in Morgantown fourteen
6:19
years before that. So but uh, Joe Parsons our general manager, and
6:26
Anthony yeah, maybe Steve Bishop with Stephen Jenny to Stephen Jenny so for so
6:32
yeah, there you go, and that'd be you know, so where's my
6:35
cap? Right? That's right? Well, you know that comes in in
6:40
line with the fact I got a letter before the first of the year from
6:44
the State Bar saying in that congratulations because they look at the admissions and the
6:51
membership information, and once you practice law for fifty years, they honor you
6:56
at the State Bar convention. Oh you know that's that's not you know they
7:00
have him with the greenbrier. I was I was imagining myself, you know,
7:03
in a tuxedo, get an award and standing under those black and white
7:08
marble floor towels and in front of the big mirrors under the chandeliers now.
7:12
But this year our convention is at the Embassy Suites in Charleston. There's no
7:17
rip on Embassy Sweet so that's where the trial lawyers we have already no meeting
7:21
the Mathena. I get to drive eighteen miles. It's sort of like and
7:28
here's your or you can just drop by the front desk and pick up your
7:30
certificate. I'll give you a pat on the back and a warm man shape.
7:34
I'm looking forward to it. You know, there are a lot of
7:38
unfortunately a lot of members of my class a little you know, people who
7:41
started pretty much twenty one, twenty two years old was the age when you
7:46
would start lost. It's an all star cast. Your your class is well,
7:51
you know, we've got well John McCosky will be there. He is
7:56
my class. And Margaret Workman at one time of course l it he's gone.
8:01
Uh but Mike Farrell, and Mike's been dis acting president of Marshall University.
8:05
He's head of the Higher Education Control bunch got Tom Flaherney who represented us
8:13
in the rich Rod case, and Stuart Callwell with Calwell Practice. A lot
8:18
of us around. Tom Catle was a judge, Rust Claudus was a judge.
8:20
I think at one time there were like ten members of my class who
8:24
were judges. How I'm eager to see who all Chambers? Right, Well
8:28
her from Chambers yesterday? Well did you really you have on the LG announcement.
8:33
Well, yeah, you're part of it. He came, I came
8:35
on video. I think, okay, Skype, Yeah, I haven't seen
8:37
Chambers. Yeah really since we lost him, I've seen him. I mean
8:43
you think, well, Chambers, that's just how I know him law school.
8:46
He wouldn't know me from Adam. It's been fifty years. But proud
8:50
of that, you know, he's he's gone a long way in the States.
8:54
Would be proud of him. It's so look what happens in April.
8:56
I will get to see. I mean, I don't know where they take
9:01
the pictures in the m six weeks. Just stand in front of the little
9:03
fountain of Judge Claudgers was in your class too. Restaurants and has had a
9:07
son that was a really good ball player for the Mountaineers. Yeah yeah,
9:11
and well Catle was up in Yeah. Judge Cannon, yeah yeah, No,
9:16
federal judges. I don't not that I can think of. I don't
9:20
think we even had a magistrate judge. Well, I see yesterday a magistrate
9:24
judge is ruling on some detentions. Was going from yeah, it was judge
9:28
good Ones, So judge good Ones. So they so these are these Federal
9:31
court's always really interesting. You and I've been in federal court together, and
9:35
obviously, uh so these are the correctional officers. Was a total six charges,
9:41
but really and in total of eight you had two have already plaid and
9:45
they're kind of working with prosecutors on these others with these other six, uh
9:48
in the case and these are the they're charged in connection with the inmate's death
9:54
in March twenty twenty two. Uh and and they were and they've been arrested,
10:00
they've been and died, they've been arrested and uh and you have said
10:03
on this there it's a very rare not to get bond in most cases in
10:07
federal court, right, I mean you're well, yeah, I mean there's
10:11
a bit of a dichotomy between the state court practice in West Virginia and the
10:15
federal courts. I personally favor the federal court system in West Virginia so often
10:20
where it's a matter of the discretion of the magistrate exclusively, you'll see put
10:24
what I call punishment bonds. You'll get some you know, penniless, single
10:31
mom, maybe got a drug problem, who leaves her child in a car
10:35
while she goes in the store, and which that shouldn't happen, it's too
10:39
and so they charge her with the child abuse with the risk of the child.
10:43
Well, we're going to impose a five hundred thousand dollars bond. Well
10:46
why if bond is not you're not You're not a magistrate to punish people.
10:50
You're a magistrate to administer justice, and a bond is meant to just assure
10:56
that someone will appear. Well, where is that poor person going to go?
11:01
If they had any money, they wouldn't have anywhere to go. The
11:05
child's been put in protective custody. I mean, you see somebody charged with
11:11
possession of pornographic materials. Well, let's make the bond a half million dollars.
11:15
So they ate fourteen grapes. Remember that happened during the hostage crisis,
11:20
the Iranian hostages. Some guy ate some grapes while he was shopping at I
11:24
think it was the Kroger that closed down up in up above London and so
11:31
like, well, your bond's going to be fourteen thousand dollars one hundred and
11:35
eighty some thousand and one thousand for every hostage. That's wrong. I mean,
11:39
that is an overreach. Our Supreme Court has never done what they should
11:43
have done and addressed those situations. It is, in my opinion, judicial
11:50
misconduct, whis just trying to be quote a part of law enforcement. You're
11:54
not. You're a judge. Now in the federal court, almost exclusively,
12:00
first default for bond is ten thousand dollars personal recognizance, which means that you
12:05
individually sign a document on undertaking saying I promise that if I do not show
12:11
up, I will pay the federal government ten thousand dollars where they can pursue
12:16
my assets for that amount. No surety, no security. In West Virginia
12:22
you can have a personal recognizance bond. It's very seldom the magistrates award it
12:26
because prosecutors don't like it. Magistrates tend to do what the prosecutors tell them
12:30
to do. In the district court, it just just what it is.
12:35
The magistrate judge sets generally a ten thousand dollars PR bond. Now it can
12:45
be a higher bond if the government asks for it and can establish a reason
12:48
for a higher bond, or the situation with these individuals under the Crime Safe
12:54
Streets Act, which was passed, I believe under the Nixon administration, the
13:05
government could ask for pre trial detention. In other words, they can tell
13:09
the judge or the magistrate judge, look, this person is like a flight
13:11
risk, a risk crime. It's a risk to be left at large because
13:18
of possible intimidation of witnesses or participation of the criminal activity, and therefore they
13:22
should be detained indefinitely pending a trial of this case, kept in jail.
13:28
Well, that's completely the reverse what we do in stakehoard, and it's really
13:37
it was quite controversial when the idea of pre trial detention was first introduced,
13:41
because you're in title lebon I mean, the Constitution says you're entitled le bond.
13:48
But the burdens on the government to establish by substantial evidence that they conditions
13:56
exist to keep a person deprived of their liberty pending trial because they're resumed innison.
14:01
Well, in this case, these are individuals and if you read what
14:05
the government is alleged happened it's disgusting. I mean, it would be individuals
14:13
who took a person who was handcuffed, who was helpless, who was in
14:18
their custody because of the government characteristic and was then just beaten to death,
14:26
taken from police to place and in a penal facility where they knew there were
14:31
dead spots in the security cameras. Just beaten to death. Well, that's
14:35
mean to start with, it's deceitful, and it's it indicates a deep character
14:41
flawed. May be the first time for everyone, I mean, I understand
14:45
the testimony was that these folks are otherwise parts of the community. Well they
14:52
weren't that day. And apparently Judge Goodwin, who's been around the wyoming Judge
14:58
Goodwan has been on the bench. Lord, I've been on this show.
15:01
He've gone there. Awhile uh. He was a Clinton appointee from back in
15:05
the nineties and heard all the testimony and looked at everybody testifying from the witness
15:11
stand. This wasn't like a zoom hearing. This was a hearing. They
15:13
were all there. They each attorney had so he took two hours to hear
15:18
from each attorney. So there are four attorneys for the four defendants, and
15:22
he went over all the charges individually. He heard from each attorney individually,
15:28
and they had offered some testimony earlier in the earlier hearing before Joe jo Abahassen
15:33
metress Joe Jarjoboffs, who they didn't really rehash that because he's read the file.
15:37
He said, he'd read the file and so he came down to it,
15:39
saying, listen, it weighs in your favor that you guys are your
15:45
property owners, you grew up in you know, never left Raley, counting
15:48
your your community ties. But he said, I'm just very concerned about these
15:52
intimidation of witnesses charges, you know, he says, I'm just he said,
15:58
and he's concerned about the the alleged crime. He said, I can't
16:02
think of a more serious, well it is charge. And part of the
16:04
charges are that, number one, there was a cover up and that there
16:08
was some pressure exerted by these individuals against other people not to tell the truth.
16:14
And that's probably the deciding factor, I mean had but for that,
16:18
even though the charges of a heenus and violent nature, but for the fear
16:22
of potential for witness intimidation or interference, I would think Judge good. I'm
16:27
going to turn them loose, probably on some sort of home confinement. That's
16:32
that's what they were asking for, home confinement. Yah, Which in the
16:34
federal system, it's I don't think they used monitors in the federal system.
16:38
You're just subject to random visits by the Federal Probation and prolog. Yes.
16:44
He even went on to say, which kind of interesting, Harvey, that
16:47
he thought the government's case was strong. I mean he said that the evidence
16:52
because he's considering the evidence there in his decision. Oh yeah, it wasn't
16:55
a trial obviously, it's not a trial. It's just a review hearing on
16:57
bond. But he said he thought the evidence. He said that a couple
17:00
of times. Well, and that's always a factor. That's even if that's
17:03
a factor in state court as well. If you if you have a person
17:07
who's confined and you believe the magistrate has set excessive bond. Now in a
17:11
murder case in west Ron, Genitay, the magistrate can't set bond in capital
17:15
case. It's only a circuit court. So they're going to be confined to
17:18
jail till you can get to a circuit court and ask for bond and they
17:21
grant bonds here in murder cases. On occasion, I actually had the Supreme
17:26
Court ran a bond to a klan of mine circuit Dunts wouldn't do it,
17:29
went up to the Supreme Court and they bonded him out. You can consider
17:34
there's an old famous Western in the case State Ex Royal Gizz v. Johnson.
17:40
Pete Johnson was the sheriff of Knack County. He had a man named
17:42
Ghiz in jail with an exceptionally high bond for a leslie robbing a pharmacy what
17:48
at that time was Charleston General Hospital. And the Supreme Court set standards and
17:55
with the violence of the crime, the probability of conviction, community contacts,
17:59
and ability risk of the public Dependsy's been other crimes and that check. Let's
18:06
pretty well apply to the common sense standard. To the federal courts apply.
18:11
Here's the interesting I mean, it's a really tough call because people are constitution
18:17
entitled to bond unless under this violent crime state street sack the government, and
18:23
I can tell you the government sometimes just does that to show off. I
18:27
mean, I've had a case with a young kid that got charged with a
18:30
drug case down in Williams and anything to do with it. He didn't even
18:33
know why he was there. He was down there with his cousins, right,
18:37
and they're all yuch, yuk yuk. And then he end up on
18:38
a street in Williamson where drugs are changing hands and he's standing there and he
18:42
may have had some weed on him. They pick him up and it's like,
18:48
you know, can we get him out of here today? Well,
18:52
of course the DA agent show up say well, we want to file attention
18:55
on this guy. So the US attorney does what they say, and they
18:56
just did it to keep him in jail for a couple over the weekend.
19:00
It's just one of those little crummies that the federal government can do did do.
19:04
Of course, as soon as it came up for the detention hearing,
19:07
the US Attorney said, we don't have any evidence, let him go,
19:11
which Judge caben Abor did and then sentenced him to a period of confinement significantly
19:15
less than the guidelines, which also drove them nuts. But I don't care.
19:21
It's not my job to do their job. I mean, it's a
19:25
really I gotta certainly understand how the families feel. You see other people uh
19:30
charged with violent, heenous crimes, who are out on bond. You know,
19:33
you see here in Kannall County. How often do you see someone charge
19:36
with a murder or stabbing who's out on bond from another offense those committed while
19:40
they were out on bond from a first offense. Uh, And now they
19:45
have then they all live in Rowley County. They're not going any place.
19:48
They're saying, I didn't do this, no matter how bad it was,
19:52
and they think, you know that they got a highway. The jury's going
19:56
to turn them loose. I mean, jury's turn police officers loose pretty often
20:00
when you think the evidence would support a conviction. Civil cases, I had
20:06
one yesterday sucided by the Fourth Court of Appeals where an officer had a lot
20:11
of trouble with the charges of unlawful excessive force was let off the hook by
20:18
civil jury. Everything they found out that both the lawyer, but the deputy
20:22
and his lawyer lied about the fact that they were prior lawsuits and cases penning
20:30
against the guy. Of course, the circuit judge district court judge here wouldn't
20:34
set the case aside. The Court of Appeals did, said, you know,
20:37
you can't get a whole lot worse than number one, sitting and listening
20:44
to your client give perjury testimony. Number two allowing it. So they just
20:51
said the lawyer who was representing the deputy or the policeman was the same lawyer
20:55
who was representing them in the power lawsuits, because it was the same law
20:57
firm on the dole for brim to do it. And it just developed that
21:03
culture, which is the culture that we saw at the Southern Regional Jail.
21:07
Same group involved the same circle of lawyers to which this Attorney General completely abdicates
21:15
responsibility for what gos on and they got in trouble. Cost to state three
21:18
million bucks Southern Regional Jail, and I suspect this one at the Court of
21:22
Appeals says size is going to cost another chunk of change, but it's a
21:26
forty two. We're going to take our break. Harvey is here. Year
21:30
twenty six is underway. Your way underway underway, so the lines are open
21:34
and questions about the law. Harvey's here to take your calls. Three oh
21:38
four, three four five fifty eight fifty eight. Three oh four, three
21:41
four five fifty eight fifty eight lines are open. Three oh four, three
21:45
four five fifty eight fifty eight back in the moment on five eight WCCHS.
21:48
I'm sure you're ready for retirement. That's understandable, After all, you only
21:52
retire once. Make the smart choice and call Fourth Avenue Financial. If it
21:56
deals with retirement planning, you can be confident they the experience you need.
22:00
Retire right with Fourth Avenue Financial. Good to Fourth Avenue Financial dot com or
22:04
call three oh four seven four six seventy nine seventy seven to book your free
22:10
introductory meeting today. Security Office you, j nib Co Financial Corporated, Remember
22:12
Finnacific Advisory Services officg you, jib CoA Advisors Incorporated, JWO Financial, jnw
22:17
Co Advisors and Fourth Avenue Financial or unaffiliated entities Elevators You take them for granted
22:21
until they let you down. If you're working to maintain a cellar reputation,
22:23
then let me introduce you to DC Elevator. We want to work with you
22:27
to make sure your people get where they are going. What could be better
22:30
than a new company coming to the area and already having forty five years of
22:34
experience. DC Elevators bringing the new culture of elevator maintenance, repairs, monernization
22:40
and installation to West Virginia. Don't leave your people hanging for a free consultation
22:45
called DC Elevator at three zero four three four five seven two two two.
22:51
What is the power on the side? We have a court room experiences that
22:57
you need give up. We're prepared to fight for your rights. When you
23:06
need action, count on us. What's the power of pison on your side?
23:14
The power of bag It's a forty five on five eighty whs the Voice
23:25
of Charleston Jeff Jenkins with Harvey Payton and the Peyton Law Firm in Nitro lines
23:29
are open three o four three four five fifty eight fifty eight. Any questions
23:32
about the law three oh four three four five fifty eight fifty one. Thing
23:34
we've talked about on and off over the last couple of years, or something
23:37
you heavily support. Oh yeah, is e filing and that is coming.
23:42
The new chief Circuit judge in Kanna County's Mayor, Claire Akers for this calendar
23:47
year, and she said, she put out a little news release said,
23:49
one of the transitions we'll be making this year is e filing in the clerk's
23:53
office that begins in April. That's wonderful. I mean, the public will
23:57
begin to immediately see in the lawyer will immediately see a more efficient and more
24:03
timely administration of justice and interaction of the public with the court system immediately.
24:11
It is. It's been the rule in federal courts for over a decade.
24:15
Two decades. It's been the rule in most circuit courts. It's sort of
24:19
a rolling process to implement. Kinnall County is sort of the big way over
24:22
because it's the biggest circuit court docket in the state, and it's an e
24:29
filing process. The lawyers, you sign up, you get an account,
24:33
and if you want to file a lawsuit, let's start at the beginning filing
24:40
a lawsuit. You sat at your desk and you prepare the complaint with your
24:45
client, get it in form to be filed. You prepare a civil action
24:51
cover sheet, and then you convert it from word to PDF, and then
24:56
you go to your computer. You open your account, send that to the
25:00
clerk's office. You already have a use a credit card or a debit card
25:04
on file, and then cases filed that day. The clerk then does the
25:10
does the whatever the instructions are as far as service on the civil action cover
25:14
sheet that the circuit clerk implements that and booms filed. You want to file
25:22
an answer, you do the same thing. You prepare depleting, you review
25:26
it, you convert it to a PDF, which I don't know what that
25:30
stands for, but it's something other than word. It's an image, and
25:36
file it. You don't file the papers, right, you know, you
25:40
do file those papers, but for instance, there after comes discovery interrogatory's requests
25:45
for production, those things are not filed anymore. It's just an electronic certificate
25:51
of service and all that the public will be able to see. Oh yeah,
25:53
you can look at it. Yeah, all right, it's great.
25:56
Bill's on the line, Bill on with Harvey. Bill first called twenty twenty
26:00
for with Harvey. Morning Belle, good morning, good morning, Happy new
26:03
year. Happy to you yet, Good morning, Bill, Happy new year,
26:07
sir. Have a question for you on these new electric vehicles coming out,
26:15
where does the liability or the responsibility of ensuring that vehicles stand well?
26:25
Uh, I mean, my son has a has a tessel of the insurance
26:32
of State Farm under a semi conventional policy of liability insurance is the standard State
26:40
Farm form auto policy. I've got a Toyota hybrid, which is not an
26:45
EV, but it's an electrically assisted vehicle that I insure with the EERIE under
26:49
the same terms. Well, let me let me ask you this. Uh
26:55
say, for instance, that it is driverless. We're just being driven by
27:00
the computer on board. There is an accident, I'm injured. Where do
27:11
I go to get satisfaction for that? Do you mean there's no driver in
27:18
the vehicle. It's completely remote, yes, right, Well with some of
27:22
them though, that can be remote with the drivers in the vehicle, they
27:26
drive themselves with the driver obviously, Well, who owns the vehicle? It
27:30
has to fall to the owner of the vehicle primarily, or whoever leased the
27:36
vehicle and put it into service on the highway, whoever's responsible for putting that
27:38
vehicle on the highway, it would be primarily liable for that injury, and
27:44
secondarily, perhaps if there's a defect in the system, it would be the
27:48
manufacturer, either the guidance system or the overall vehicle or both. So,
27:52
in other words, you're turning your legal liability over to whoever the manufacturer or
27:57
the leasing agent or whoever might be. Yeah, but yeah, really,
28:03
in practice, that's not a whole lot different from the standpoint of serious injury
28:07
than we have right now. You have a trucking company, let's say Acme
28:11
Trucking signs a freight contract with the Widget Incorporated to deliver widgets to West Virginia.
28:18
Well, they hire a driver, put him behind the wheel, and
28:22
he drives the vehicle and a vehicle lose control and injrew someone. Well,
28:27
where's the liability falled. Of course, it falls technically on the driver,
28:32
who generally has no assence. We're very limited assens It then falls on the
28:37
back to the common carrier, who, under the law is required to have
28:40
a million dollars in liability coverage, which is pretty expensive because it's you know,
28:47
it's out of sight line conduct. You can't suit. You know,
28:51
most companies now have good GPS, they can tell what the driver's doing.
28:53
But I mean the liability is falling back on the person who caused that vehicle
28:57
to be placed on the highway and operate, because they have a duty to
29:02
see that that vehicle is equipped and manufactured to operate within certain parameters. That
29:06
is, stay in its own lane, not speed, not make turns across
29:08
traffic. So in that regard, I mean you're looking at the person who's
29:14
financially responsible for that conduct. And while a truck driver or a driver of
29:21
a uber or a taxi or a delivery truck is technically also a responsible party,
29:26
seldom are they. Sometimes they don't even sue them because it just gets
29:32
another party and another lawyer involved in the case. Do you see this really
29:37
clogging up the court system? You know, I don't think so. I
29:42
think I think Congress may have to take a Congress or the Service Transportation Board
29:47
may have to take another look. You know, the idea of a million
29:49
dollars in and minimum coverage for interstate carriers has been in a e fact for
30:00
decades, and it needs to be increased. Obviously it hasn't been. The
30:07
Federal Transportation Administration rules and regulation need to be amended. And I think Congress
30:12
probably needs to take some action with regard to the insurability and limits of insurance
30:18
on driverless vehicles because to me, Bill, I don't care what Elon Musk
30:22
says. I don't care what Elon Musk says. Been a lot of things,
30:26
but about a Tesla or everybody else about a vehicle if you don't have
30:30
any human being in there to override this system listening. It's a mechanical system
30:36
where it's a digital system created by men. It is going to fail sometime.
30:40
I mean, they have autopilots and airplanes, but you don't fly on
30:44
a plane coast to coast without a pilot and co pilots sitting in there.
30:48
So they're gonna have to be some changes made. Those aren't fun things to
30:52
talk about for Congress or for the administrative agencies, but their practical matters.
30:57
And you bring up a really good point. Insurance law and autoliability and rules
31:02
of the road need to be looked at and modified an in view of what's
31:07
happening right now. I mean, you've got artificial intelligence. Maybe they can
31:11
Maybe the computer on the dashboard of my vehicles, I'm sure it's powerful enough
31:18
to simply or make out a route and view symbols along the road and figure
31:25
out in its own mind when it should turn left, when it should turn
31:26
right, and what's safe and what's not. Until we're firmly convinced of that
31:32
one hundred percent human being ought to be everywhere, they don't have any business,
31:36
you know, you can down here to sell Charleston, and you've got
31:38
to see that sign where the railroad tracks across mccorkill Avenue that these vehicles may
31:42
not have an operator. That means the engines, the railroad engines may be
31:48
operated by somebody on the ground. Instead of having an engineer and a conductor
31:52
and maybe a brake went over there switching cars. They've got one person with
31:56
a remote control running an engine across the major highway. But the other factors,
32:01
you know, that really concerns me. You know when you when you
32:06
get talking about the liability of this situation, what is this going to do
32:15
to cost to the public out here. Well, it may well increase it.
32:22
However it will increase it drastically. Yeah, that's the that's benefit of
32:27
insurance. That's the benefit of a viable, economically sound system of property and
32:36
liability and all risks insurance, which we have in the United States because you
32:40
have a good solid rule of law, We've got an investment market for insurance
32:45
companies to invest in. I mean, life insurance pretty simple. You're writing
32:47
against your underwriting against very well established mortality tables. You to take somebody like
32:53
State Farm or Yerie or All State or Nationwide, all really good solid companies.
32:59
They underwrite the risk. They look across the whole country and see what
33:02
the risk is, it paint it out, and then they spread it among
33:07
theoretically three hundred and thirty one million people that live in the United States,
33:10
so that the burden doesn't fall excessively on any one personal group of persons.
33:15
Now, that's not always going to be the case if you want to buy
33:19
a If today you want to buy insurance on a newly built ocean front home
33:23
on the east coast of Florida, you're probably going to pay as much in
33:29
insurance as you do in a full year's payments, because underwriting says so.
33:34
But generally, operating on the system of highways, I think the insurance industry
33:39
has a pretty good grasp on that. Now, it's my experience hunder insured
33:45
drivers. You know we've got under insurance. It's now steps in. It's
33:49
a part of policies. Voluntarily everybody has uninsured coverage because it's mandatory. The
33:53
limits probably are high enough, but you know, if you deal with a
33:58
major company, you're going to find a true rates are and should fall pretty
34:01
well and in conformity. But they are in the rest of the country.
34:06
So I think that's one that we need the light hand of the government to
34:10
get in there and say, well, here's what you have to do in
34:14
order to comply with basic reasonable conduct. And then let the insurance industry,
34:19
which here the four has done a pretty good job, let them take the
34:22
first crack at it. Then it becomes a problem, then we can look
34:24
at it again. All right, and nitro your resetting first of the year
34:29
twenty twenty four. You guys continue to do what you do. Well,
34:31
we do what we do. You know. I want to say one thing.
34:34
Our offices in Putnam County, and I picked up the pavement this morning.
34:38
It's just heartbreaking. There's a family that suffered a tremendous loss in Putnam
34:44
County. I mean, I'm going to say what the name is. I
34:45
saw the story last week. A young man who's the same age as my
34:50
oldest granddaughter. You know, he's killing the car accident right here around the
34:53
holiday season. I mean, I had a nephew, my sister's boy got
34:58
killed in the car wreck. And you get that call in the night.
35:01
It's just horrible and heartbreaking. And wherever those members of the family are,
35:06
and they're al mostly right around in Putnam County, and we keep in mind
35:08
to Putnam County has a big heart, and it's the hearts and the prayers
35:13
of everybody down there with you. It's never never easy. I mean,
35:16
my dad died suddenly. That's one of the things I don't ever want to
35:20
do. I'd rather linger in pain, and so saved my kids the agony
35:27
of getting the call in the middle of the night than tap out right because
35:31
it's just not a good thing. But moving on. Yeah, we are
35:37
in Nidro Putnham County. We have a lice office. We've been in the
35:38
same buildings as nineteen ninety four. We do primarily automobile accidents injuries. We
35:45
do insurance questions such as bills, talking about who has coverage, who should
35:51
pay. We do some property damage litigation. Tolm does a significant bit of
35:57
a social security ability. He does some criminal work. I primarily, I'll
36:04
be honest, can find myself what we call transitional work right now. I
36:07
mean I serve us families. I mean I've been representing some people for four
36:12
generations, right, it can't be in one place almost fifty years. But
36:17
we work together, so two heads are always better than one, even if
36:21
one's an old head and can I give us a call? The gray hair
36:25
wisdom it is and old age and stress. But if you get a Peyton
36:30
Law Firm dot com you can see who we are and you can read about
36:32
us. We don't do any television advertising or a big deal billboards, or
36:38
we don't have William Shatner. We certainly don't set ourselves in front of a
36:44
private airplane walking down the street in Florida and ask you to sign up and
36:47
let us be your lawyer. But just give us something. I mean,
36:51
if you have some issue, got a lot of experience, a lot of
36:53
successful experience, come in and talk to us, give us a thought,
36:58
and if we can help you, we are here to help you. To
37:00
leave here to the theory that the law, the case is as big as
37:04
the lawyer thinks it is, and it's the most important to the client at
37:07
any given time and the period. And we look forward to them maybe another
37:10
I don't think. I don't think Matt Roorbock can get me twenty five more
37:14
years, but I'm looking maybe for five or ten seven five five five five
37:17
five six or Peinton Lawfirm dot Com seven five five five five five six or
37:22
Peton lawfirm dot com, See Harvey, see it all right. ABC News
37:25
is next. This is five eighty dou w c HS