Latest / Journey to the Fringe / Canada's Official UFO Report
Transcript
- 0:03From the unexplained to the mundane, come join
- 0:06us on a journey to the fringe. Hello and welcome
- 0:13to Journey to the Fringe. Your mileage may vary,
- 0:16but I do like to think that that's because everybody's
- 0:19journey to the fringe is an individual endeavor.
- 0:22Ah, that was beautiful. We are your unique and
- 0:27special podcast hosts, Taylor and Chelsea here
- 0:29today. Chelsea, we're going over, it's hard to
- 0:32explain, I think. But Canada just came out with
- 0:37a UFO report and this was published in June of
- 0:402025 By the office of the chief science advisor
- 0:45Wow, I don't think the chief science advisor
- 0:48actually wrote it She did have a forward for
- 0:50it But my guess is is that it was written by
- 0:53her office But basically it was written to kind
- 0:55of talk about the status of UAPs in Canada as
- 0:58of today I can't complain with those that Canada
- 1:03has generally as a whole over the world towards
- 1:07UFOs. We seem pretty liberal to it and accepting
- 1:12of it. And we have declassified UFO files for
- 1:17Shake Harbor for one. We've done tons of research
- 1:20on it. We had that one guy, Hellier, I can't
- 1:23remember his name right now. He was a part of
- 1:26the government that really loved to talk about
- 1:29UFOs. I just love our - Yeah, we've put out coins
- 1:34with with famous UFO sighting and that does come
- 1:39up in this episode i just i can't you gotta love
- 1:42the canadian government for the stance they take
- 1:44on it i don't really think they're trying to
- 1:46refresh and you know what i do find this very
- 1:49interesting i do think this shines a great light
- 1:51because we're always looking at it from the conspiratorial
- 1:54the the what if true side of these stories yeah
- 1:58i do find it interesting to look at what is the
- 2:00government saying about this stuff though they
- 2:03did a full report it's going to explain why they
- 2:05it as we get going but we're just gonna read
- 2:07through quite a bit of it I did had to cut down
- 2:09significantly which did include cutting out potential
- 2:13communications with ET societies which was an
- 2:16entire thing this went down a rabbit hole this
- 2:19entire paper went down why would you see we might
- 2:24do it in a separate episode later on as well
- 2:26as I hope you make note of it other countries
- 2:29responses to UAPs so to keep this episode to
- 2:32a reasonable level we had to cut those parts
- 2:35out and we might talk about them in the future.
- 2:37Other than that, I basically just edited it down
- 2:40for keeping it to a reasonable length. I'm so
- 2:43excited now. So without much more, we're gonna
- 2:46be reading the report of the Sky Canada Project
- 2:49from the Office of the Chief Science Advisor
- 2:51of Canada titled, Management of Public Reporting
- 2:53of Unidentified Aerial Phenomena on Canada. I
- 2:56kept this first sentence of the first like three
- 2:59paragraphs in here just because I wanted you
- 3:01to understand how they wrote this. Since the
- 3:04dawn of humanity, the sky has been a profound
- 3:07source of fascination, wonder, and inspiration.
- 3:11It went on that way for three paragraphs. I had
- 3:13to cut that out. It also ends with that too.
- 3:20In Canada, as elsewhere in the world, people
- 3:22are intrigued by what are now referred to as
- 3:25unidentified aerial phenomena, UAPs, which sometimes
- 3:28arouse considerable curiosity and debate. While
- 3:30many UAP reports can be attributed to optical
- 3:33illusions, atmospheric phenomena, or human activity,
- 3:36a minority remain unexplained for a myriad of
- 3:39reasons, including a lack of reliable data that
- 3:41prevents rigorous scientific analysis. Yet these
- 3:45unexplained sightings generate interest and can
- 3:47be the source of misinformation or disinformation.
- 3:50One of the primary issues with misinformation
- 3:52and disinformation is their impact on public
- 3:54trust. When people are repeatedly exposed to
- 3:57false narratives, they may become skeptical of
- 4:00credible sources, including scientists, journalists
- 4:03and government institutions. In early 2023, several
- 4:06incidents in Canada caught the public's attention.
- 4:09Over a two week period, four unidentified flying
- 4:11objects flew over North America. The first and
- 4:15most widely reported in the media was a balloon
- 4:17which flew across Alaska, Western Canada and
- 4:20easterly across the United States from January
- 4:2328th to February 4th. the U .S. eventually shot
- 4:25it down over the U .S. waters off South Carolina.
- 4:28From the recovered debris, it was identified
- 4:30as originating from a foreign country and carried
- 4:32sophisticated equipment. One week later, on February
- 4:3511, 2023, the North American aerospace defense
- 4:38NORAD ordered the downing of a smaller balloon
- 4:41over Yukon. These incidents highlighted the importance
- 4:44of government investigations of what appears
- 4:46in the sky and how complex it is to distinguish
- 4:49between natural occurrences, common technological
- 4:51devices and potential security. concerns. This
- 4:54report aims to set a milestone in Canada's pursuit
- 4:57of a better approach to the management and study
- 5:00of UAPs. And Chelsea, those are the events that
- 5:02spurred this paper to be written. The weather
- 5:04balloons from China. After you said that, that
- 5:07kind of sparked within myself that that's probably
- 5:10what was the cause of it because that was a big
- 5:12thing that happened within recent history. So
- 5:15now I'm very excited. Do they talk about what
- 5:18it was? They actually don't, but it was a weather
- 5:20balloon. I don't think there's any dispute over
- 5:24being a weather balloon. Yeah. God damn it. I
- 5:26hate that explanation, but okay. And I should
- 5:29say the Office of the Chief Science Advisor in
- 5:32Canada shortens to OCSA. It comes up right here.
- 5:34In 2023, the OCSA announced the creation of the
- 5:39Sky Canada Project. At the outset, its main objectives
- 5:42were to review current UAP reporting methods
- 5:44and and propose improvements as needed, to enable
- 5:47Canada's federal government to optimize the collection
- 5:49and analysis of UAP observations in a transparent
- 5:52manner, to provide insight for better tools to
- 5:54combat misinformation and disinformation, which
- 5:57I find very interesting, and to encourage participatory
- 6:00science and public understanding of aerial phenomena,
- 6:03and to support monitoring of Canada's airspace.
- 6:05See, this is my tax money going to good use,
- 6:10I feel like. Yeah, and I think you actually are
- 6:13gonna like what happens from here as well. They've
- 6:16done a good job over these two years. This is
- 6:18just like heartwarming because I was getting
- 6:21really pissed off at things. OCSA established
- 6:27boundaries on what Sky Canada project did not
- 6:30intend to address. It is not meant to prove or
- 6:33disprove the existence of ET life or ET visitors.
- 6:36Collect or analyze firsthand data such as photos,
- 6:39videos, or individual UAP siting reports. be
- 6:41seen as an endeavor to make the Office of the
- 6:44Chief Scientific Advisor the primary point of
- 6:47contact for reporting UAP sightings, or position
- 6:50the OCSA as the lead organization for initiating
- 6:52or managing internal collaboration related to
- 6:55UAP research for investigation. Oh, okay. Yeah,
- 6:58it's set in the parameters for the paper, and
- 7:00it moves on to the story of UFO to UAPs from
- 7:03here. Okay. Until recently, the term UFO was
- 7:06used to describe aerial phenomena that could
- 7:08not be conclusively identified. Those are definitionally
- 7:12unidentified, but this does not imply that they
- 7:14are extraterrestrial, that they define natural
- 7:16or scientific explanation, or that they would
- 7:18not be identifiable with access to additional
- 7:21or better data and tools. The abbreviation UAP
- 7:23is a newer and increasingly more prevalent term.
- 7:27UAP includes a broader set of movements, such
- 7:30as being stationary in the air, falling or floating
- 7:32and submerging in water, as well as phenomena
- 7:35that are not material objects such as gases and
- 7:38lights. The terminology shift reduces the historical
- 7:41stigma associated with the UFO sightings. Witnesses
- 7:45were often met with skepticism and ridicule leading
- 7:47to a negative perception and arbitrary judgments
- 7:50being cast upon them. Stigmatization can have
- 7:53significant consequences such as discouraging
- 7:55witnesses from coming forward and hindering scientific
- 7:58inquiry. The new more encompassing UAP terminology
- 8:01can help promote greater transparency, credibility,
- 8:05and acceptance of research in professional and
- 8:08scientific circles and in the wider public. While
- 8:10the term UFO continues to be used, governments
- 8:13and other organizations are gradually adopting
- 8:15the more comprehensive term UAP. This report
- 8:18will use the abbreviation UAP when describing
- 8:21more recent activity and UFO when dealing with
- 8:23more historical ones. Most UAP sightings can
- 8:26be explained through careful investigation and
- 8:29analysis, given sufficient reliable data. For
- 8:31example, France's group who collects information
- 8:35on their behalf, it's called the Gaipan United
- 8:37Airspace Phenomenon Research and Information
- 8:40Group, which investigates UAP settings in France,
- 8:42reports that 3 ,188 cases collected by 2025 had
- 8:46only 3 .2 % of cases remaining unidentified after
- 8:50investigation. Furthermore, 31 .4 % of cases
- 8:54could not be explained due to insufficient data.
- 8:56Similarly, MUFON, Canada reports that of the
- 8:59321 sightings that investigated in 2023, 31 %
- 9:03could not be conclusively explained due to the
- 9:06information being too vague. Most UAP observations
- 9:09can be attributed to relatively simple explanations,
- 9:12including conventional aircrafts, weather phenomena,
- 9:15which includes atmospheric conditions that can
- 9:17create unusual visual effects, crystal, ice crystals,
- 9:20storms, clouds, or temperature inversions can
- 9:23sometimes make lights or objects appear unusual.
- 9:25hard -to -identify ways. Astronomical objects
- 9:28such as planet stars or meteors. Man -made objects
- 9:30such as weather balloons, drones, satellites,
- 9:33sky lanterns or experimental aircrafts. These
- 9:35objects may have unusual flight patterns or lighting
- 9:38that can cause confusion. Optical illusions such
- 9:41as reflections, lens flares or other optical
- 9:44effects can create the appearance of something
- 9:46unusual in the sky. And human error. Misinterpretation
- 9:49of everyday objects or phenomena such as aircraft
- 9:51lights seen from different angles can lead to
- 9:53UAP reports. I could see and I think this is
- 9:56a good time to bring up as well. I think that
- 9:58I brought this up to you. Not while we were recording
- 10:01once, Taylor, but I did see posted just a week
- 10:05or two ago a video from someone in Alberta capturing.
- 10:10ball lightning yeah you did and that's the first
- 10:14recorded video of it yeah so just something to
- 10:18throw in there when you're talking about meteorological
- 10:21events and stuff like that ball lightning has
- 10:23actually been captured on video by now someone
- 10:26in alberta which is one of those things that
- 10:29everyone always says a ufo is ball lightning
- 10:31so yeah it does exist Nonetheless, some UAP sightings
- 10:36for which data exists remain unexplained even
- 10:38after investigation. That's the end of that section.
- 10:41We're going to move on to tackling the puzzle.
- 10:43New technologies can contribute to UAP reporting
- 10:45and analysis. For example, the tech startup Enigma
- 10:48Labs launched a real -time iOS app for phones
- 10:51in 2023. This application captures sightings
- 10:54and compiles them into a standardized searchable
- 10:57database that can be analyzed. The Enigma app
- 10:59includes over 14 ,000 UAP sighting reports from
- 11:02Canva. app, some of which cover historical sighting
- 11:05reports downloaded from other sources. Interestingly,
- 11:07the survey by Earncliffe's Strategies for the
- 11:10Sky Canada Project found that two in five respondents
- 11:13are interested in using a phone app to document
- 11:15UAPs. The use of artificial intelligence in this
- 11:18context is particularly promising. With growing
- 11:20volume of data enabled by smartphone technologies,
- 11:24such as an incomeal ads application, AI could
- 11:26significantly streamline and standardize the
- 11:29process of examining and assessing UAP sightings.
- 11:31AI can assist in sifting through vast amount
- 11:34of data from various sources, such as databases,
- 11:37tracking airplane locations, satellites, stars,
- 11:39planets and weather conditions. This capability
- 11:42could aid in interpreting visual data from UAP
- 11:45sightings more accurately and identifying trends.
- 11:48Such initiatives could be crucial in transitioning
- 11:51from anecdotal evidence to more scientifically
- 11:53rigorous analysis and may contribute to enhancing
- 11:57the quality of UAP research. So that's the end
- 12:00of that section, it was really short. And then
- 12:02we move on to breaking the stigma, the challenges
- 12:04of academic research on UAPs. Despite a valid
- 12:08scientific rationale for studying UAPs, many
- 12:10academic research communities seem to fear stigma
- 12:13associated with pursuing research on this topic.
- 12:16A recent survey of 1 ,460 tenured and tenure
- 12:19-track faculty members in 144 research -intensive
- 12:22universities in the United States revealed that
- 12:2453 % believe that UAP -related research would
- 12:27jeopardize their tenure or promotion, even though
- 12:30only 7 % had a negative opinion of this type
- 12:33of research. A review by the OCSA of two of Canada's
- 12:37main federal research funding agencies found
- 12:39very few funded projects related to UAPs. For
- 12:42example, over the last 25 years, there have been
- 12:45no grants or funding applications directly related
- 12:49to UAPs at the Natural Science and Engineering
- 12:51Research Council of Canada. and only seven applications
- 12:55and two grants of scholarships from the Social
- 12:57Sciences and Humanities Research Council. Consistent
- 13:00with this, the OCSA only found a dozen graduate
- 13:03-level dissertations related to UAPs in Canada
- 13:06over the same 25 -year period. Among those was
- 13:09Matthew Hayes' research at Trent University that
- 13:12gave rise to a comprehensive book titled, Search
- 13:14for the Unknown, Canada's UFO Files and the Rise
- 13:17of Conspiracy Theory. The book explores the history
- 13:20of UAP sightings in Canada, the response from
- 13:22the government and the resulting perception from
- 13:24the public. I found that really interesting.
- 13:26They're actually looking at this and saying like,
- 13:28there's no funding going to this educationally,
- 13:31and there's a big stigma attached to it. So there's
- 13:34something that needs to be done here. So that's
- 13:36the end of that section. We're moving on to empowering
- 13:38discovery, the role of participatory science
- 13:40and engaging communities. Participatory sciences,
- 13:42and I do have to say this section got cut from
- 13:45significantly because it had a lot to do with
- 13:47finding other alien life and the cosmos. I really
- 13:50want to know what it said. Participatory science,
- 13:53historically called citizen science, involves
- 13:56engaging the public as research assistants in
- 13:58projects. It allows researchers to collect vast
- 14:00amounts of data over large geographical areas
- 14:03and longer periods than would be feasible from
- 14:05a small team of scientists and a limited number
- 14:07of instruments. This approach accelerates scientific
- 14:10discovery and strengthens public confidence in
- 14:12science. Additionally, participatory science
- 14:14fosters scientific literacy by providing new
- 14:17opportunities for individuals to actively participate
- 14:20in research. collaborating with scientists in
- 14:22data collection, analysis and interpretation,
- 14:24while learning about the scientific method. As
- 14:26noted in the House of Commons Standing Committee
- 14:28on Science and Research report on citizen science,
- 14:31these initiatives are particularly valuable for
- 14:33addressing data gaps and informing public policy,
- 14:37especially in the health and environmental fields.
- 14:40Such contributions demonstrate the vital role
- 14:42citizen scientists can play in advancing knowledge
- 14:44and supporting evidence -based decision -making.
- 14:47We're moving on to UAPs and the public. Like
- 14:51I said, there's a lot of words I need to get
- 14:53through, so I came in this script with a mission.
- 14:55The way reports of UAP sightings are framed and
- 14:58disseminated significantly influence public perception.
- 15:01Some sightings gain widespread attention, fueled
- 15:04by compelling eyewitness accounts, documented
- 15:06evidence, or extraordinary circumstances. Media
- 15:09coverage and pop culture have further shaped
- 15:12these narratives, embedding certain cases in
- 15:14the collective memory. In particular, well -documented
- 15:16Canadian sightings, such as the Falcon Lake encounter,
- 15:19or the Shag Harbor incident have become cultural
- 15:21touchstones commemorated not only in local lore
- 15:24but also through initiatives like the Royal Canadian
- 15:27Mint's UAP -themed coins. Despite the intrigue,
- 15:30the discourse around UAPs is often fragmented
- 15:33with inconsistent reporting mechanisms and varying
- 15:36levels of credibility among sources. The rise
- 15:38of conspiracy theories, disinformation, and sensationalism
- 15:41can further muddy the waters, making it harder
- 15:44for the public to discern fact from fiction.
- 15:46With growing fascination, complexity, and uncertainty,
- 15:49the UAP field has also experienced a rise in
- 15:52misinformation and disinformation. The Sky Canada
- 15:55Project examined current government reporting
- 15:57practices on UAPs to determine the extent to
- 15:59which these practices could address two types
- 16:01of information related problems, misinformation
- 16:04and disinformation. Misinformation refers to
- 16:07any inaccurate or false information that circulates
- 16:11unintentionally in the public sphere. often long
- 16:14after the information has been proven wrong.
- 16:16Well, disinformation involves false information
- 16:19deliberately intended to mislead people. In recent
- 16:22years, disinformation, misinformation and conspiracy
- 16:25theories have increasingly caught the attention
- 16:27of researchers from various fields. One key insight
- 16:31from this research is the importance of rapidly
- 16:33offering clear explanations to counter or at
- 16:36least reduce the spread of misleading ideas.
- 16:39In today's world of information overload, gaps
- 16:41in information are often quickly filled by disinformation
- 16:45or misinformation. When people experience uncertainty
- 16:48or fear, they are more likely to seek explanations
- 16:51to regain control over their situation. Disinformation
- 16:55provides false, but sometimes comforting explanations,
- 16:59which can be appealing even if they are not based
- 17:01on fact. People may seek explanations that confirm
- 17:04their existing beliefs, potentially leading to
- 17:06them accepting biased conclusions or conspiracy
- 17:09theories. Research has shown that conspiracy
- 17:11theories This is a cognitive bias that people
- 17:18tend to believe the first piece of information
- 17:20they hear even if it's later proven false. Reactive
- 17:23strategies like debunking or striking back tend
- 17:25to be less effective than preventative strategies.
- 17:28Such preventative, also called pre -bunking,
- 17:31appears to be the most successful approach. This
- 17:34involves providing correct information ahead
- 17:36of time to prevent the spread of falsehoods.
- 17:39An open and transparent dialogue with the public,
- 17:41especially from trusted figures such as scientists,
- 17:43is essential in reducing information gaps and
- 17:46building trust in institutions. When people trust
- 17:49the source of information, they are less likely
- 17:51to embrace conspiracy theories. This highlights
- 17:53the need for a reliable, credible source of information
- 17:56on UAPs, one that can quickly and accurately
- 17:59provide explanations to the witnesses, the media,
- 18:02and the broader public. Another major concern
- 18:04is the role of technology in accelerating the
- 18:06spread of false information. Social media platforms.
- 18:09The recommendation algorithms and deep fake technology
- 18:12make it increasingly difficult to distinguish
- 18:14between fact and fiction. Ultimately, combating
- 18:17misinformation and disinformation requires a
- 18:19combination of media literacy, responsible technology
- 18:22use, and proactive fact -checking efforts from
- 18:24both individuals and institutions. For this to
- 18:27happen, a clear and transparent framework for
- 18:30data reporting and analysis needs to be in place.
- 18:33So that's their conspiracy section, which I found
- 18:35very interesting what they focused on. It is
- 18:37very interesting. It seems really like they're
- 18:40trying to foster openness. Yes. That is a great
- 18:46word that I wasn't going to say. Okay. I just
- 18:50feel like they're really saying, hey, if you
- 18:51actually just comment on these things immediately,
- 18:54you can get this debunking you have to do later.
- 18:57harder out of the way. It's almost like they're
- 19:00trying to make it so there's less of a stigma
- 19:03for people to report UFOs. I know we've had this
- 19:06conversation a lot too, how there's a very weird
- 19:08pipeline of fringe groups who extreme far right
- 19:13political beliefs, which seems to come from the
- 19:16conspiracy side. And I do think that what they
- 19:18just described is something that happens within
- 19:20these groups. Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. And
- 19:24it's also saying that people are less willing
- 19:26to do things around it because of the stigma
- 19:29behind it. So it sounds like they're trying to
- 19:32combat that as well, which is refreshing. Public
- 19:36sightings of UAPs can be perplexing to individuals
- 19:39who experience them, prompting a search for information
- 19:41and answers. While this search can open people
- 19:43to scientific reasoning, it can also make the
- 19:46public vulnerable to misinformation, disinformation,
- 19:48and conspiracy theories, especially if they do
- 19:50not know which trusted organizations can help
- 19:52them. Although most reports of UAP sightings
- 19:55attract little attention, some become famous.
- 19:57When reported sightings fuel media coverage,
- 19:59prompt government action or scientific research,
- 20:01or permeate pop culture through movies or books,
- 20:04they can embed themselves in collective memory.
- 20:07The following five sightings are among the best
- 20:09-known UAP cases reported in Canada over the
- 20:11past decades and have been commemorated by the
- 20:14Royal Canadian Mint on coins. May 20th, 1967,
- 20:17Vulcan Lake, Manitoba. We've done an episode
- 20:20on that. October 4th, 1967, Shag Harbor, Nova
- 20:24Scotia. We've done an episode on that. October
- 20:2626th, 1978, near Clarenville, Newfoundland in
- 20:29Labrador. Never even heard of this one. Several
- 20:32witnesses, including a constable of the Royal
- 20:33Canadian Mounted Police RCMP, reported seeing
- 20:36an oval -shaped object over the harbour. No material
- 20:38evidence was found. November 7, 1990, Montreal.
- 20:42A large oval -shaped luminous phenomenon was
- 20:45observed in the evening over the rooftop pool
- 20:47of the Bonaventure Hotel by about 40 witnesses,
- 20:50including journalists and police officers. Air
- 20:53traffic control confirmed there was no radar
- 20:55activity in the area. On December 11, 1996, at
- 20:59Yukon, at least 31 people in four different areas
- 21:02of Yukon reported seeing a row of lights in the
- 21:04sky, which many described as resembling a spacecraft.
- 21:07The phenomenon was later observed by several
- 21:09others in different locations. Wow. So many that
- 21:12I didn't know. I mean, I know the first two are
- 21:15renowned. These ones didn't really have a name.
- 21:18But even to identify those as big cases in a
- 21:21government report, I think was huge. Oh, yeah,
- 21:24absolutely. I think we need to look into those
- 21:27three. Given the ephemeral nature of UAP sightings,
- 21:31reporting and analyzing them can bring together
- 21:33very different people and institutions, often
- 21:35in a half -hazard way. UAP sightings can come
- 21:38from a variety of sources, including ordinary
- 21:41citizens, airline pilots, and military personnel,
- 21:44and can be reported to different authorities
- 21:46depending on the circumstances. The incidents
- 21:48of UAP sightings have been analyzed over the
- 21:50years by various survey organizations and researchers.
- 21:53In 1974, Gallup conducted what may have been
- 21:55the first survey of the Canadian public regarding
- 21:58UFOs. The results showed that 67 % of respondents
- 22:00had heard of UFOs while 8 % believed that they
- 22:03had seen one. By 78, 81 % of Canadians had heard
- 22:06of UFOs while 10 % thought they had seen one.
- 22:09In 2024, Ernst Cliff survey for the Sky Canada
- 22:12project found that 27 % of 1 ,008 respondents
- 22:15reported having observed an object or phenomenon
- 22:18in the sky that they could not identify, with
- 22:2011 % claiming to have made such an observation
- 22:22in the past year. That seems ridiculously high.
- 22:26Do you think? Like, just a little over one in
- 22:28four people has seen something in the sky they
- 22:30could not explain. Damn it, why am I the three
- 22:34of those people? I know. We got two of the four
- 22:38here who did not fall into the one of the four.
- 22:42Yeah, what are the odds? Not likely, pretty much.
- 22:46That is high. Especially Canada is such a huge
- 22:50country. Most of our population is to the southern
- 22:53end of Canada. And the crazy thing is one in
- 22:56four people said they've seen something in the
- 22:58sky they couldn't explain. One in 10 said they
- 23:01saw it in 2024. Those are crazy numbers. Yeah.
- 23:05And all our populations are pretty much in big
- 23:08cities. We have such a small population for how
- 23:11big of a country we have. That's a huge... number
- 23:14for how many people are in Canada versus how
- 23:17much land we have. Because what are the odds
- 23:20of where these UAPs, pardon me, are going to
- 23:23be sited? Well, where the people are. Yeah, exactly.
- 23:27Exactly. And that amounts for so many more that
- 23:31could potentially be being seen. No, they're
- 23:34not flying over the uninhabited parts of Canada.
- 23:37They're just sticking to the cities. That would
- 23:40actually explain a lot, so forgive me. Keep going.
- 23:45Okay. Based on data published by a number of
- 23:47organizations, it can be estimated that between
- 23:49600 and 1000 cases of UAP sightings are reported
- 23:52each year in Canada. In the absence of a single
- 23:54data collection organization, the number and
- 23:56nature of these observations cannot be established
- 23:58conclusively for many reasons, including the
- 24:00possibility that the same sighting is reported
- 24:03separately by more than one organization. This
- 24:05makes it difficult to get a precise idea of the
- 24:07scale of the phenomena. In Canada, the long is
- 24:09the most recognized collection of UAP sightings.
- 24:12is the Canadian UFO survey, produced by a group
- 24:15of Manitoba -based volunteers called Ufology
- 24:17Research, directed by Mr. Chris Rakowski. In
- 24:202023, they tallied 570 UFO reports. Since 1989,
- 24:25over 24 ,000 Canadian UFO reports have been catalogued.
- 24:28The major sources of this collection include
- 24:31other UFO organizations. Of note, data from another
- 24:34organization, MUFON Canada, was not available
- 24:36to Ufology Research in 2023, suggesting that
- 24:39the list may be incomplete. A survey conducted
- 24:42by Ernst Collect in 2024 also suggests that that
- 24:44number of sightings may be higher. While advancement
- 24:47in technology and scientific inquiry may have
- 24:50improved our ability to investigate UAPs, the
- 24:53lack of standardized reporting mechanisms, fragmented
- 24:55data collection, and the spread of misinformation
- 24:57complicate efforts to correctly evaluate the
- 25:00number of UAP cases in Canada every year. And
- 25:03that's the end of that section. We're going to
- 25:04move on to methodology and findings. The history
- 25:07of UAP reporting within the federal government
- 25:10spans several decades but includes extended periods
- 25:12with minimal or no activity. In 1950 the Department
- 25:16of Transport granted one of their engineers,
- 25:18Wilbert Smith, permission to do part -time research
- 25:21to investigate whether some UFOs could use the
- 25:24power of Earth's magnetic field as a source of
- 25:26propulsion. They called this project Magnet.
- 25:28Smith gradually expanded its scope to include
- 25:31investigations of the validity of UFO observations.
- 25:35Unable to convince his colleagues of the merits
- 25:36of his research, Smith had to continue his work
- 25:39privately after the Department of Transport terminated
- 25:41Project Magnet. In 1952, the Department of Research
- 25:46Board, DRB, within the Department of National
- 25:48Defense, DND, established a committee called
- 25:51Project Second Story to examine the occurrences
- 25:54of flying saucers passing over Canada territory
- 25:57as reported by different branches of the armed
- 25:59services. The committee did not investigate UFO
- 26:02sightings, but it developed a standardized form
- 26:04to facilitate the reporting of UFOs across various
- 26:07government departments. This form was never broadly
- 26:10adopted or used, so this group was fairly useless.
- 26:13The committee held six meetings between 52 and
- 26:1554 concluding, quote, UFOs pose neither a security
- 26:20threat nor were of scientific interest, end quote.
- 26:23It recommended ending all investigations by the
- 26:25Canadian military. Between 54 and 67, public
- 26:28reports continued to be submitted to various
- 26:30federal departments and agencies, including the
- 26:33RCMP, Transport Canada, the Department of National
- 26:36Defense, as well as at local police departments
- 26:38and non -federal entities. These organizations
- 26:45In 1967, on the recommendations of the Minister
- 26:49of National Defense, the responsibility for overseeing
- 26:51UFO reports was transferred to the NRC. which
- 26:54then became the main service for receiving public
- 26:57UFO reports. This transfer responsibility includes
- 26:59the classification of D &D's Project Second Story
- 27:02and the Department of Transport's Project Magnet,
- 27:05as well as taking over the management of previous
- 27:07UFO reports. According to the NRC, until 1995,
- 27:10they were officially tasked with collecting information
- 27:12on UFOs from the public, municipalities, and
- 27:15other federal departments such as the RCMP and
- 27:17D &D. Most, but not all, UFO reports received
- 27:20by the NRC were compiled into what became known
- 27:22as the Non - meteoric sightings file. In 95,
- 27:26the NRC stopped collecting UFO reports. All related
- 27:28material was transferred to what is now known
- 27:31as the Library and Archives of Canada, LAC, which
- 27:34presently holds these records. LAC's collection
- 27:37of UFO documents, estimated at 15 ,000 pages,
- 27:40of which 9 ,500 have been digitized, is open
- 27:43to the public and provides valuable information
- 27:46on the history of UFO sightings and the Canadian
- 27:48government's responses to them. The history of
- 27:51UAP reporting within Canadian federal government
- 27:53reflects a fluctuating level of interest and
- 27:56responsibility over time with various departments
- 27:58and agencies intermittently engaging in investigations.
- 28:02The government's approach evolved but often lacked
- 28:04continuity and consistent focus. The limited
- 28:07adoption of standardized reporting mechanisms
- 28:09and the eventual cessation of formal investigations
- 28:13in 95 marked a decline in federal involvement.
- 28:16And I cut this part out because it's going to
- 28:18be in another episode at some point. consultation
- 28:20with federal departments and agencies. I'm just
- 28:22going to do the brief part I kept in. The Sky
- 28:25Canada Project sought to gain insight on the
- 28:27domestic front by identifying organizations in
- 28:30Canada that typically receive witness reports
- 28:32of UAP sightings and examined whether and how
- 28:35they collect, investigate, and follow up on these
- 28:37reports. While some departments such as Transport
- 28:39Canada have established mechanisms for collecting
- 28:42and analyzing UAP -related data, most organizations
- 28:45do not investigate sightings unless they intersect
- 28:48with their specific The lack of centralized data
- 28:51compilation and standardized reporting processes
- 28:55make it challenging to identify trends to conduct
- 28:58comprehensive analyses of UAP reports. So that's
- 29:01what we get from that. Okay. Citizen led UAP
- 29:04groups and organizations. While government efforts
- 29:06to study and catalog UAP sightings have fluctuated
- 29:09over time, citizen led investigations have remained
- 29:12steady. Today, Canada has several citizen driven
- 29:15organizations dedicated to receiving, investigating
- 29:17and discussing. reports of UAPs. MUFON Canada
- 29:20is a non -profit organization that relies on
- 29:23civilian volunteers to study reported UAP sightings.
- 29:26There are numerous groups at the provincial level
- 29:27as well. For example, within the province of
- 29:29Quebec, there is the, I'm not gonna try to say
- 29:31it, it's the UFO Alert Network, AQU, also known
- 29:35as GARPAN. Okay. UFOBC investigates BC and Yukon
- 29:41sightings, which I'd never even heard of before
- 29:42reading this paper. I don't know that I know
- 29:44them off the top of my head. Such organizations
- 29:47and initiatives provide platforms for reporting
- 29:49sightings, conducting some investigations and
- 29:51sharing information. Their existence is indicative
- 29:54of a gap in the way UAP sightings are treated
- 29:57by both the authorities and the scientific community,
- 30:00but their lack of financial resources limits
- 30:02their actions, prevents them from offering a
- 30:04full suite of services. And from here was supposed
- 30:07to get into the global perspective on UAP reporting,
- 30:10but that's going to be its own episode sometime
- 30:12in the future. So I left this one paragraph from
- 30:15it. The recent global development in the study
- 30:18and investigation of UAPs demonstrates an increasing
- 30:22commitment to scientific inquiry and national
- 30:24security. Some countries have established formal
- 30:28governmental bodies to investigate UAP sightings
- 30:30while others have relied on non -governmental
- 30:32organizations or citizen science groups to collect
- 30:35and analyze reports. The growing recognition
- 30:37of the need for robust data collection and international
- 30:40cooperation reflects a shared interest in understanding
- 30:43these phenomena and and a global shift towards
- 30:46a more systematic and open approach to the study
- 30:49of UAPs. And Chelsea, this is really why we're
- 30:52reading this. We are now at the recommendations.
- 30:56Okay, good. I need some. The Sky Canada Project
- 30:59highlights a significant gap in Canada's approach
- 31:02to UAP phenomena. As most federal entities lack
- 31:05the capacity, mandate, or resources to address
- 31:08this issue systematically, public interest in
- 31:10greater transparency and improved reporting mechanisms
- 31:14underscores the need for coordinated action.
- 31:16Insights from non -governmental organizations,
- 31:19citizen -driven groups, and independent journalists
- 31:21reveals the enduring public fascination with
- 31:23UAPs and the potential value for establishing
- 31:26a more robust framework for data collection and
- 31:28investigation. The survey by Ernst Gliff found
- 31:30that interest in UAPs is generally moderate.
- 31:33However, half the respondents felt that the Canadian
- 31:35government should do something about UAP sightings
- 31:38and devote funds to the effort, including for
- 31:40investigation. The majority of respondents felt
- 31:43that the government should set up a service to
- 31:45enable Canadians to report their sightings and
- 31:48attach importance to transparency of information
- 31:51on the subject. Moving forward, the Sky Canada
- 31:54project serves as a crucial foundation for discussions
- 31:57on enhancing federal oversight and public engagement
- 31:59regarding UAPs. By fostering collaboration across
- 32:03departments and with civilian organizations,
- 32:05Canada can develop a more cohesive and transparent
- 32:08approach to understanding and addressing these
- 32:10phenomena. To enable thorough scientific studies
- 32:13of UAP sightings, a range of data collection
- 32:16and investigative activities would be required.
- 32:19For instance, standardized protocols should be
- 32:22established to ensure data are comparable in
- 32:24their content and format. The fragmented nature
- 32:27of UAP reporting across various departments and
- 32:29agencies in Canada complicates the application
- 32:32of scientific principles. This lack of coordination
- 32:34results in inconsistent information collection
- 32:37across the government, making it onerous, if
- 32:39not impossible, for researchers to access and
- 32:41compile data for rigorous science -based analyses.
- 32:44Additionally, the fact that investigations of
- 32:47reportings are not easily available contributes
- 32:50to distrust and disinformation. During the Sky
- 32:52Canada project, the Office of the Chief Science
- 32:55Advisor received about 250 inquiries about Canadians
- 32:58regarding various aspects of the project, including
- 33:00inquiries about where to report UAP settings
- 33:02and requests for government assistance to interpret
- 33:05photos and videos despite the Sky Canada website
- 33:08clearly stating that the office was not offering
- 33:10that service nor collecting such information.
- 33:13Which I just find hilarious that people are in
- 33:15that position. Yeah. I don't know where to report
- 33:17this. It clearly says I don't report it here,
- 33:19but I'm going to ask you. Canada would benefit
- 33:24from an improved process for reporting, collecting,
- 33:26and studying UAP sightings. The approach should
- 33:29be more rigorous, transparent, and coordinated
- 33:30than is currently the case. The following actions
- 33:33are proposed for consideration by the Government
- 33:36of Canada in order to 1. Improve coordination
- 33:38and analyses of UAP reports in Canada 2. Promote
- 33:41public trust and mitigate disinformation 3. Enhance
- 33:44scientific rigor and science literacy surrounding
- 33:47UAPs and 4. Position Canada for greater collaboration
- 33:50with other countries on a topic that has no geographic
- 33:53borders. And here are their points. Reporting
- 33:56and data oversight. One, identify a lead. A federal
- 33:59department or agency responsible for managing
- 34:02public UAP data should be identified. The lead
- 34:04should be a trusted and recognized scientific
- 34:07organization. Have the capacity to communicate
- 34:10with the public and an already established international
- 34:13scientific network. For example, Canadian Space
- 34:16Agency. Establish a dedicated service. The service
- 34:19would collect testimonies, investigate cases,
- 34:22and post its analyses publicly. It would proactively
- 34:25inform Canadians about UAPs. To achieve these
- 34:28goals, it would convene a network of government
- 34:30and academic partners and experts to conduct
- 34:33scientific analyses and follow up with witnesses.
- 34:36Enhance reporting capacity in civil aviation.
- 34:39Transport Canada should encourage pilots, cabin
- 34:42crews, and air traffic controllers to report
- 34:44UAP sightings without fear stigmatization. In
- 34:47collaboration with NAV Canada, they should analyze
- 34:50UAP reports to track trends and provide pilots
- 34:53with explanations helping to reduce distractions
- 34:55during flights. These reports could be correlated
- 34:58and merged with those submitted by the public
- 35:00on similar sightings. Next, in communications,
- 35:03support public dialogue. A proactive strategy
- 35:06to increase transparency and communication with
- 35:09the public regarding UAPs should be developed.
- 35:11Such a strategy should bring together trusted
- 35:15publicly facing organizations, including science
- 35:18centers and museums, as well as public libraries.
- 35:21Promote intra -governmental collaborations, an
- 35:24internal directive to ensure collaboration among
- 35:26all federal agencies with relevant expertise
- 35:29or data would aid the lead organization in providing
- 35:33explanations to witnesses and correlating recent
- 35:36observations with previous reports. Additionally,
- 35:39since some departments would continue to receive
- 35:41reports under these mandates, like the RCMP,
- 35:44Trans Canada. They should be encouraged to forward
- 35:47their data as appropriate to the lead organization.
- 35:50Improve media relations. The lead organization
- 35:53should play a significant role in mitigating
- 35:55misinformation and disinformation by responding
- 35:58to public and media inquiries related to UAPs
- 36:01and by documenting and communicating common misinterpretations
- 36:05of observations. Examples of such approaches
- 36:07include interactive digital tools are found in
- 36:11other countries and promote application of up
- 36:13-to -date evidence to effectively address misinformation
- 36:17and disinformation. Among others, a multidisciplinary
- 36:20expert panel should be set up to advise the lead
- 36:22organization on effective approaches to countering
- 36:25misinformation and disinformation. Research.
- 36:28Facilitate open access and open data. Data related
- 36:31to UAPs should be made available to the public
- 36:33for transparency and to support research. Conduct
- 36:36surveys. Periodic surveys of Canadians should
- 36:39be carried out to gauge their perception of UAPs
- 36:42and assess the impact of the dedicated services.
- 36:45Support citizen science. Participatory science
- 36:48initiatives and programs should be developed
- 36:51to enable volunteer participation in the study
- 36:53of UAPs, among other benefits such as activities
- 36:56tend to increase the likelihood of informed citizenry
- 36:59and enhance interest of youth in science and
- 37:01technology careers. Provide tools for data collection.
- 37:05The development and deployment of publicly accessible
- 37:07digital and portable tools should be supported
- 37:09such as bilingual applications for smartphones
- 37:12and interactive platforms to provide information
- 37:15including for data collection and ongoing research
- 37:17programs and build on Canada's strength in astronomy
- 37:20and aerospace research. Canada has a superb talent
- 37:23pool and physical research infrastructure and
- 37:26is part of major international initiatives aimed
- 37:28at understanding our planet and the universe
- 37:31and developing tools for space travel and exploration.
- 37:35Interesting. The sector should be further supported
- 37:38and given opportunities to be part of the public
- 37:40dialogue. And lastly, international collaboration.
- 37:44Information sharing. The lead organization should
- 37:47establish partnerships with international entities
- 37:49dedicated to UAPs such as AARO and NASA, CAPAN
- 37:54in France, and SAFA in Chile to share data methodologies
- 37:58and best practices in UAP research and investigation.
- 38:01Cooperation in research and communication. Canada
- 38:04should actively engage with international partners
- 38:07for research collaboration and public awareness
- 38:10efforts. And the conclusion. If enacted, the
- 38:13recommendations given in this report can drive
- 38:15progress in several key areas. Their first goal
- 38:18is to increase government transparency on UAPs,
- 38:22potentially reducing related conspiracy theories
- 38:25and misinformation. Second, setting up clear
- 38:28and efficient reporting systems for UAP observations
- 38:31will greatly simplify the process, encourage
- 38:34more public participation, and support citizen
- 38:37-driven science. Improved data from public reports
- 38:40will enable more comprehensive and accurate research
- 38:43analyses. Investigating UAP reports may also
- 38:46enhance airspace security by identifying threats.
- 38:50threatening national security through the proactive
- 38:52mitigation of risks from UAPs. Finally, these
- 38:56measures will enable Canada to eventually join
- 38:58international groups. Efforts concerning UAP
- 39:01sightings fostering a comprehensive global approach
- 39:04to understand and address the UAP issue. Canada
- 39:07can ensure that UAP mysteries inspire future
- 39:10generations by fostering curiosity, critical
- 39:13thinking, and open -minded investigation. The
- 39:15investigation and study of UAPs does belong to
- 39:18humanity's quest for knowledge and understanding.
- 39:22Adopting more transparent communications and
- 39:24robust scientific methods will be a significant
- 39:27step forward in promoting public understanding
- 39:29and combating misinformation. It is in the spirit
- 39:32that the recommendations in this report have
- 39:34been formulated. And Chelsea, that's the end
- 39:37of the paper. The first thing I want to ask is
- 39:40you're the one that put this episode together
- 39:42and you cut a lot out of it as well. What do
- 39:45you think? I think this is an incredible paper.
- 39:48There's really good suggestions in here. We will
- 39:51see what actually gets through. But how candid
- 39:54they are with the topic at large and just talking
- 39:58about like these mystery cases that we are well
- 40:01aware of saying, yeah, they're really interesting.
- 40:03It's very impressive. It was shocking, basically,
- 40:06to see a government body openly say, yeah, these
- 40:09cases are crazy. Do you think that it's shocking,
- 40:12though? Because like I said, kind of at the beginning,
- 40:16Canada has kind of been very liberal about the
- 40:19whole UAP phenomenon, typically throughout not
- 40:24throughout history, but as far as Canada has
- 40:27had a comment on it. They've been better than
- 40:29other countries. They haven't been perfect. Like
- 40:32we've looked at. It's basically jumped around
- 40:35from one government body to another with nobody
- 40:37ever wanting to actually take it. The fact that
- 40:40it just ended up with the National Library at
- 40:42the end is, I think, just a sheer coincidence
- 40:45that makes you think that they are fairly liberal
- 40:47with the topic. Is it that or is it just that
- 40:50nobody kind of knows what to do with the topic?
- 40:53It's a fair point because I have found they have
- 40:56in any of the topics that we've covered We've
- 40:59covered a few of the major ones in Canada to
- 41:02be more Obviously because there is a few things
- 41:06that we didn't know about them They're the most
- 41:07renowned cases in Canada But I did find when
- 41:11we covered them that the government actually
- 41:14Did a lot a lot of the stuff that we got is documentation
- 41:18was directly from the Canadian government Yeah,
- 41:21which is abnormal but as far as what i do just
- 41:24think it's because everything ended up with the
- 41:26national library in 95 and got digitized that's
- 41:30true but you compare it to other cases like roswell
- 41:35which i don't know if that's a fair comparison
- 41:38but the united states government roswell will
- 41:41be area 51 which you're talking about an actual
- 41:44government location like a secret that's true
- 41:48As opposed to some guy coming across something
- 41:50that's not government information. That's very
- 41:53true. And I'm trying to think of another example
- 41:55right now when I can't. I know it's always hard
- 41:57off the top of your head. But I mean, especially
- 42:01for me, anything that I'm thinking of right now
- 42:03is government involved. But you don't really
- 42:07see that with Canada is the point that I'm trying
- 42:10to make. And anything that we've covered, which
- 42:12are renowned cases in Canada, I mean, it's a
- 42:15little different with the United States, because
- 42:17yes, most most of those are government cases.
- 42:20For instance, what I'm talking about is for one,
- 42:22Roswell, where we see all these grifters come
- 42:27into play and start making their own narrative.
- 42:30And it's the same. Oh, yeah, just a completely
- 42:33different story. It's the same with Paul Benowitz,
- 42:35where the government is intervening and planting
- 42:40things for Paul Benowitz to think that there's
- 42:43underground bases. And this is the government
- 42:46doing that. So it's a completely different role
- 42:48that you're seeing from what Canada is involved
- 42:51with. And I will include myself with this. We're
- 42:53actually being forthcoming with it, I think.
- 42:56And I will very happily say after the conclusion,
- 42:59they put a list of organizations and individuals
- 43:02that were consulted for this report. And Richard
- 43:05Doty's name did not make the list. OK, good.
- 43:08I thought you were going to say that it did.
- 43:10And I was like, oh, no. My next point that I
- 43:16would like to make, how do I get a government
- 43:19job looking into Canadian UFO keys? And here's
- 43:23the sad thing that I have to say. I don't think
- 43:25it's actually going to happen because the government
- 43:28right now is cutting budgets for everything and
- 43:31chopping jobs. So unfortunately, I don't think
- 43:34they're going to follow through on much of this.
- 43:36I feel like I could have done some good contributions
- 43:39to this report that they've put out there. But
- 43:42overall, I'm very impressed by what they've put
- 43:45together. I feel like it's forthcoming. I feel
- 43:49like it's trying to combat the stigma. Yeah,
- 43:53and that was one part of it I found really interesting.
- 43:56was they really focused on that right wing pipeline
- 43:59conspiracy part of it, which is like, we need
- 44:03to get out there immediately with information
- 44:05so that people's minds can't be hijacked from
- 44:08what actually happened here. I am very impressed
- 44:11by it. I'm very proud as we have been with our
- 44:15wave of Canadian pride the last little bit. I
- 44:18think it's amazing. And I think it's on the forefront
- 44:21of things that are looking at UFOs because they
- 44:24want to be more open. that more people are reporting.
- 44:27They want it to improve safety even. And I can
- 44:32get behind that. They don't even care if it's
- 44:34real or not, just - Just report it so that there's
- 44:37no stigma. Yeah. Not only no stigma, but if you're
- 44:40a pilot and you're seeing something that you
- 44:42can't account for, you should be reporting it
- 44:45for safety issues. Not because you don't want
- 44:48to, because it's a UAP and you're afraid of what
- 44:51people are going to say. I am a little worried
- 44:53about Daryl, the pilot who's to be reporting
- 44:55all these airplanes he's seeing at night. Yep,
- 44:59that's just an airplane, Daryl. Again, it's the
- 45:02fifth one you've seen on this flight. I love
- 45:05it. I think this is amazing. They did not at
- 45:09all address. Maybe you cut it out. I would be
- 45:12very offended if you specifically edited out
- 45:14the weather balloons that were so big. What was
- 45:18that? Two or three years ago now? Two years ago,
- 45:20yeah. I briefly cut that part out and it's really
- 45:23because like those are fully addressed. They
- 45:25were just like, hey, we should take a look at
- 45:28our UAP reporting schematics system within Canada.
- 45:31So they didn't actually have to address the weather
- 45:33balloons. It was like three sentences I cut out
- 45:36with regards to the other ones because they were
- 45:39very clearly established what they were. Big
- 45:41fan of this. I was super impressed too that they
- 45:44talked about like getting people's stigma changed
- 45:46about this could actually get more people involved
- 45:48in the STEM fields because kids love this stuff
- 45:52so them learning about it might naturally bring
- 45:54them into astronomy. I love that. I think this
- 45:57is a feel -good, good news and it's not even
- 46:00a mini. But of course ending with Canada is going
- 46:04into a budget cutting time. So I don't think
- 46:07they're going to follow through with this any
- 46:08time soon. I'll keep an eye on the Hansard in
- 46:10the next little while. You know what? I can accept
- 46:13that given what is facing us currently. Why would
- 46:17I expect them to pursue something like this that
- 46:21would need funding? So I'll forgive them. Yeah,
- 46:25and it definitely needs funding. It is very clear
- 46:27that it needs funding. But as soon as we have
- 46:30the room. for the funding, I fully expect that
- 46:34I will be paid for doing this. We better get
- 46:37called up. The thing is how we just gave you
- 46:39guys all this publicity. Exactly. Yeah. And what
- 46:43a feel good episode. I really like that. And
- 46:46with that, I have been Taylor, here with Chelsea.
- 46:48We are Journey to the Fringe. Thank you all for
- 46:50listening and we'll see you next week. Bye. Thank
- 46:55you for listening to Journey to the Fringe. If
- 46:57you have liked what you have listened to, please
- 47:00like, share, subscribe, or follow, depending
- 47:04on what. venue you are listening to us through.
- 47:06Also, please, if possible, leave a five -star
- 47:09review as that really helps us in the algorithms.
- 47:13Should you wish to interact with us, please check
- 47:15us out on your social media of choice. I bet
- 47:18you we are there. And if you really want to communicate
- 47:21with us and give us ideas for new episodes or
- 47:24tell us that we're wrong and terrible, either
- 47:26way, please send us an email at journeytothefringe
- 47:29at gmail .com. For now, I'll see you in the next
- 47:32episode.