Latest / Worldview Matters With David Fiorazo / Jason Jimenez: Progressive Christians Hijacking Jesus & the Church!
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to World View Matters, discussing controversial issues, discerning current events,
- 0:10defending biblical Christianity.
- 0:13No topic, off limits.
- 0:16And now, here's your host, David Fierazzo.
- 0:19Hey friends, thanks for tuning in, thanks for sharing the podcast, can't wait to talk
- 0:23to Jason Yemeniz of Stan Strong Ministries.
- 0:27He's got a couple great books out.
- 0:29He's an author and apologist, his website is standstrongministries.org.
- 0:33The author of challenging conversations, parenting Gen Z, and the brand new, and we're going
- 0:40to talk about today, hijacking Jesus, how progressive Christians are remaking him and
- 0:47taking over his church.
- 0:50Let's dive into this with Jason.
- 0:52Welcome brother, good to see you.
- 0:54Happy New Year.
- 0:55Yeah, happy New Year to you David, thanks for having me man.
- 0:57Good, good, it's good to have you.
- 0:59We can still say happy New Year right even though we're, yeah, it's always, it's always
- 1:02a new day.
- 1:03So it's a new year.
- 1:04Maybe once it hits February 1st, we can get back on it.
- 1:07Hey, I've been watching some of the videos, I love the topic because this is such a cancer
- 1:13in the church.
- 1:14I've written years ago about the emergent church and all the gurus and all the conversationalists
- 1:20and basically it's liberal Christianity, right?
- 1:23So I want to just quote from your website, it says hijacking Jesus unravels the controversial
- 1:30narrative painted by progressive Christians about Jesus and reveals how progressive Christianity
- 1:37not only uproots the fabric of historic Christianity, but overhauls the very identity and integrity
- 1:44of Jesus and pushes the boundary of biblical theology and quote, there's a lot in there
- 1:50Jason and you've got referrals or recommendations, endorsements from J. Warner Wallace, at least
- 1:58the shoulders, Frank Turk, I've been blessed to talk to each one of them and great people
- 2:04that you've also been interviewing with on their shows, including got questions.
- 2:08I just saw that one last night as watching you talk with Shay.
- 2:12That was a great conversation, bro.
- 2:13So let's get right into this.
- 2:15This has been a problem in the church for a long, long time.
- 2:18Why did you decide to write about this now?
- 2:21Yeah, I mean, Dave, I mean, there's a lot there, obviously, you know, when you think about
- 2:26why did you write something like this?
- 2:28And to be honest, I would have to say to this point in my ministry for 25 years, this
- 2:34was definitely something that God laid on my heart that as I was just doing my own personal
- 2:40deep dive into what certain attacks, if you will, that were happening in our culture
- 2:45today, or you talked to young people who deconstructed their faith or they de-converted
- 2:50from Christianity, and inevitably the road tend to lead to progressive Christianity.
- 2:57So it wasn't like they were abandoning it completely, saying, I'm an atheist now.
- 3:00Yeah, I run into that in my ministry from time to time.
- 3:04But there was this new narrative, this new speech, this new belief system.
- 3:10And I've known a progressive Christianity as you and many of your listeners.
- 3:14And you know, our friend, Alisa Childers, and reading another gospel, and there was other
- 3:17books that I got my hands on that I dove into.
- 3:21But I never intended to write a book exposing what progressive Christianity is.
- 3:26And as I met with my team, and I traveled, and I was actually speaking on progressive Christianity
- 3:31in some audiences, I started to develop an outline.
- 3:35And one of the things that I found, this is really the driving point of writing hijack
- 3:40in Jesus, was that Christians themselves don't understand what it is that we believe.
- 3:45And as a result of it, they are way more likely to get sucked into something that presents
- 3:51itself as true as Christian, and yet it isn't.
- 3:55And so what I wanted to do is I wanted to sit down and show a compare and contrast to
- 4:02what biblical Christianity is versus what this new movement that is known as progressive
- 4:10Christianity that is taking over many of these churches.
- 4:13These are churches that you've talked a lot about on your show about the wokeness, right?
- 4:18Woke Jesus' aspects.
- 4:20And that's why I wanted to write the book.
- 4:23So is Seeker's sensitive Christianity or Seeker's sensitive churches, is that, for lack
- 4:30of a better word, a gateway to progressive Christianity, because you've got to water
- 4:34down the truth of the gospel, and is that how Satan gets in there?
- 4:41Well, absolutely.
- 4:42I mean, that's an aspect of what Satan does.
- 4:44Now, what I did, and this had really been done, was I say, you know what, let's focus
- 4:50on the person of Jesus.
- 4:51So when you talk about a water down church, when you talk about an emergent church,
- 4:54when you talk about a woke church or an all-inclusive church, really if you think about
- 4:59it, it is what their narrative or their portrayal of Jesus is.
- 5:03And as such, thus goes Christianity, right?
- 5:07And so in the housing of progressive Christianity, they do believe that Jesus essentially was
- 5:12like the first Christian, well, we don't believe that, right?
- 5:15Jesus was not the first Christian, the savior of the world.
- 5:19He's the centrality of Christianity.
- 5:23And so what I wanted to do is I said, okay, if you look at some of these, because you're
- 5:26right.
- 5:27And say, well, you know, this pastor teaches this, is this true, right?
- 5:32And it's like, well, let's go back to the person of who Jesus is.
- 5:35And so I just built it around, and this is helpful for your listeners.
- 5:39When they do go into a church that they say, oh, it's secret-sensitive, or they say
- 5:43it's all-inclusive, or they're getting really soft, or they have, you know, some things
- 5:48like CRT, some things are coming out that they don't really like.
- 5:51Well, ask yourself these six fundamental questions when it comes to the person of Jesus
- 5:56where this church in this pastor stands.
- 5:58Number one, do they believe that Jesus is not just the son of God in a generic sense.
- 6:04Do they believe that Jesus is the second person in the Trinity?
- 6:08Number two, do they believe that Jesus Christ came into this world through a virgin birth?
- 6:14Number three, do they believe that Jesus himself, the second person in the Trinity who took
- 6:18on a second nature was fully God and became fully man in the incarnation?
- 6:24Do they believe that he performed miracles, supernatural acts of God?
- 6:29Number four, do they believe that Jesus Christ died on the cross for our sins?
- 6:32And it's only through the death and burial and resurrection of Jesus that one could be saved.
- 6:37That leads to the fifth question.
- 6:39Do they believe that Jesus Christ died physically, bodily, and literally on the cross for you and for me?
- 6:47Lastly, do they believe that Jesus Christ will literally physically,
- 6:51embody, return someday?
- 6:55And that will help your listeners, David, I'm telling you, it will really give them direction
- 7:01when it comes to some of these issues socially or circumstantially that sometimes are brought
- 7:07up and on an ethical line.
- 7:10What you want to do is you want to measure everything on account of who Jesus is.
- 7:14So you're saying, get back to the essentials of the faith.
- 7:19And when you, I think in one of your interviews that I was watching recently, you were saying
- 7:24progressive Christians don't even agree with some or all the essentials.
- 7:30They are off on other things and they, they have different doctrines, different beliefs.
- 7:35That's how they tend to stray so far from the, the biblical worldview.
- 7:39Is that, would that be a good way of putting it?
- 7:41I think it's a good way to put it and I would even go a step further just to be kind and
- 7:45respectful, you know, to progressive Christians that you don't want to put words in their
- 7:49mouth, right?
- 7:50I mean, you want to be able to evaluate what they're actually saying.
- 7:53And one thing that you will find, which is very difficult, by the way, to do.
- 7:56And many of them will admit this off camera, you know, away from, from printing their name
- 8:01in a book.
- 8:03But you will find that when you are postmodern in your thinking, so let's take a step
- 8:07back, shall we?
- 8:08And let's say this, a progressive Christian, because that term progressive implies that
- 8:12they're enlightened, that it's a like Christianity 2.0, and it's actually very misleading.
- 8:18You know, progressive is just somebody who does not take the Bible literally.
- 8:22They take it metaphorically.
- 8:24They are anti super naturalists.
- 8:26They don't believe in actual miracles occurring in the Bible.
- 8:29They believe that the Bibles fill with a bunch of errors.
- 8:32They believe that their experience and their faith derived by other means and other experiences
- 8:37and religious beliefs is what they themselves experientially and personally can live out.
- 8:43So when it comes to progressive Christians' faith, they don't necessarily hold to pillars
- 8:50or doctrines.
- 8:52So when you said the word earlier, essentials, as we were talking about, the deity of Jesus,
- 8:56his virgin birth, his miracles, his death and resurrection, the atonement, and the second
- 9:01coming, they don't hold to these pillars or these essentials.
- 9:05They think that that's too rigid, you know, that we've evolved from that, that Christianity
- 9:10and the love of God is far greater than these doctrines and these dogmas that we put
- 9:14in books.
- 9:16So they say those are too restrictive.
- 9:19So they don't have, quote, beliefs, right?
- 9:21You see that all over the place.
- 9:23And as a result of it, in their post-modern thinking, they don't have certain tenets
- 9:31of their faith.
- 9:34So your experience as a progressive Christian may be different than my experience as a progressive
- 9:38Christian, but as a collective, we are evolving into this oneness of God or this manifestation
- 9:45of whatever God, quote, is that's so it's very hard to nail it down as a result of it.
- 9:51So ultimately to the biblical Christian listening who holds to the essentials of the Christian
- 9:56faith, I would then say a actually more accurate way to describe a progressive Christian
- 10:02according to their own definitions, by the way, is that they are metaphorical Christians
- 10:08or they are religious, modern, nostics.
- 10:12They hold to a form of tradition and religiosity.
- 10:17They're modern in the fact that they hold to the enlightenment period and they're nostics
- 10:22because most of them will substitute the canonical gospels for the nostic gospels.
- 10:29So when I'm taking them at their word then, David, they are religious, modern, nostics.
- 10:35Interesting.
- 10:36And that's accurate to put that way.
- 10:39How big of a problem is the abandoning the inerrancy of the scriptures.
- 10:46I mean, this is nothing new.
- 10:47This goes way back.
- 10:48I mean, in the church in America, I mean, there was a fight a hundred years ago.
- 10:53I think it was a Presbyterian church that split over some of these essentials and then
- 10:58decades later, fuller seminary among others started to back off from the inerrancy
- 11:04of scriptures.
- 11:05How big of a problem is that?
- 11:08And obviously that leads to some of the progressive thinking, doesn't it?
- 11:11Oh, absolutely.
- 11:12So what I do in the book, and this will be very helpful.
- 11:15People are very interested in engaged on this because as you and I know, more and more
- 11:19people are coming to us saying, I'm not progressive, but I definitely have family members
- 11:22right?
- 11:23Friends who are progressive.
- 11:24And so to your point, going back to a period of time known as rationalism in the period
- 11:30of enlightenment.
- 11:31So we're talking about the 17th and 18th centuries.
- 11:34And what I do in the book is I chart the course of where we're at today because a lot of
- 11:39people said, I never knew this.
- 11:41Where did this come from?
- 11:42I never saw this coming.
- 11:43I said, well, this has been evolving for quite some time.
- 11:45I mean, if we want to, we can literally go back to the guard of Eden when Satan used
- 11:50what God said and twisted it and became relativistic to Adam and Eve, right?
- 11:55And you see this, this view point of postmodernity that is spring out as a result of original
- 12:02sin.
- 12:03But there's an interesting character, David, that that came out, he's known as the father
- 12:08of modern biblical criticism.
- 12:12And this goes back to the time period, he was born in 1638 people think, who cares?
- 12:18This is 2024.
- 12:20The reason why this matters is because he's known as the father of modern biblical criticism.
- 12:25His name is Richard Simon.
- 12:27He was one of the first people who attacked the Bible.
- 12:32He wrote a book called the critical history of the text of the New Testament.
- 12:35And he began to show, remember, this was an appeared where everybody was embracing super
- 12:40naturalism and everybody was embracing the Bible.
- 12:42I'm not saying they're living as a Christian, but they believe that the Bible was a source
- 12:47of knowledge in religion.
- 12:50It was accepted in the culture.
- 12:52Well, Richard Simon ravely came out and began to attack and expose a parent, okay?
- 12:59These are apparent contradictions of the Bible.
- 13:02And over time, people began to use it, David, human, right?
- 13:06The father of skepticism.
- 13:08Then you had a guy named Immanuel Kant, who came in known as he was the father of agnosticism
- 13:14in which eventually led people to say the Bible isn't true.
- 13:19There are errors in the Bible.
- 13:21So yes, fundamentally, if you believe that the Bible is filled with errors,
- 13:26and you can't believe it, and we are not to take it literally,
- 13:29but take it metaphorically, then what is the outcome?
- 13:32There is no authority that the Bible holds.
- 13:36Wow. Excellent point.
- 13:37And thank you for mentioning those men that would be good to look into in the timeline of this.
- 13:43We've got to take a quick break.
- 13:44We're with Jason Yamenez, standstrongministries.org.
- 13:47The book is called High Jacking Jesus.
- 13:51We'll be right back on World View Matters.
- 13:53Today's show is brought to you by Harbinger's Daily.
- 13:56World news biblically understood.
- 13:59Stay informed at harbingerstaley.com.
- 14:02So Jason, I love the true historical account of Jonah, who actually lived and preached to the men of Nineveh,
- 14:21that a lot of progressive Christians, I would guess, might say that didn't actually happen.
- 14:28There's no way a big fish or a whale could swallow a man and let alone him being able to survive three days and three nights.
- 14:34So they're already putting God into box, but Jesus affirmed Jonah.
- 14:40He mentioned it several times.
- 14:41In fact, he said just as Jonah was three days and three nights in the belly of the whale or the great fish,
- 14:48the son of man will be three days and three nights in the heart of the year.
- 14:51So he actually said just as that happened, this is going to happen.
- 14:56Share your thoughts on that because it's not just Jonah, I'm sure Noah and the flood.
- 15:00There are other things that they could say, no, that was that didn't actually happen.
- 15:03It's just a metaphor.
- 15:05Well, exactly.
- 15:06So then if you trace, and this is what I like, by the way, in the in the terms of apologetics is actually,
- 15:12I use what progressive Christians give me.
- 15:14So let's actually look at a famous individual, Richard Roer.
- 15:18Now, it's important for your audience to also understand, David, that not all progressives as we said in the last segment are equal.
- 15:26So in the category, and this is what I want to do to be very consistent in looking at progressive Christianity through the standpoint or through the lens and the perspective and the interpretation of certain progressives.
- 15:39Some of them are more mystical than others.
- 15:42So identify these specifically in the category of a mystical progressive Christian.
- 15:47Others are more historical nature.
- 15:51OK, so that would be, you know, people that I mentioned before in the last segment, you would derive them as progressive Christians, but like a guy like Colby Martin, who's a progressive pastor, you know, he holds to more experience, OK, than anything.
- 16:07So what they do actually, whether it be a mystic like Richard war or someone like a Colby Martin or a David Gushy, OK, who's written extensively on the new path of evangelicalism.
- 16:20They will actually use portions of the canonical gospels to make a point.
- 16:27So what they like to do is they'll say, OK, well, yeah, David, you're right.
- 16:31You know, we have those in the canonical gospels that Jesus refer to Jonah.
- 16:36But what you guys fail to understand is the spiritual significance.
- 16:41The point is whether or not Jonah existed is irrelevant.
- 16:44You guys always make the case based on historicity that it is relevant that in order for the spiritual mood or the parabolic teaching, right, or the moral teaching of it.
- 16:57You say in order for it, that to be true, it has to be historically true.
- 17:02That's not that's that's not the point they'll they'll say to us, we don't know whether or not it's true.
- 17:07Because the BIOS filled a bunch of errors.
- 17:09But what Jesus was just saying is he was just using it as an example about newness of life.
- 17:14So for example, many of them deny a literal resurrection.
- 17:17But what they say, no, the spiritual overtones of what Jesus was teaching was about forgiveness and about how we always have to be renewing our minds and always looking for something that benefits peace and prosperity, right.
- 17:31So they're always looking at these spiritual overtones and they're neglecting the significance of it historically speaking.
- 17:37So when you say, what about Jesus referred to Jonah or Jesus referred to Adam and Eve in Matthew chapter 19, they'll say, again, we don't even know if Adam and Eve existed.
- 17:46The point is Jesus was just referencing certain people, but we don't really know if he did or not.
- 17:51And I like this in the case of talking to an average progressive Christian.
- 17:56I said, I like how you, or I say this, it's interesting that you always pick and choose when you want to rely on something that Jesus said to make your point.
- 18:06Like the sermon on the mount.
- 18:08Most of them don't discredit that because I'd like to use the sermon amount as the sermon of social justice, the way they interpret it.
- 18:16But then immediately following, like you said, they'll discredit the Jonah narrative.
- 18:21They can't have it both ways.
- 18:23Okay. And that's important for us to understand.
- 18:25So yes, progressives like to pick and choose along the way as long as in their mind, the way they interpret it is making Jesus that all
- 18:35inclusive teacher, like love is love.
- 18:39But then the moment you say, well, that's interesting that you believe that about Jesus.
- 18:42But what about when Jesus called out sin in Mark chapter eight or Matthew chapter 15 and then all of a sudden now it's like, oh, well, that was a spiritual, right?
- 18:51You need to, you can't take that literally.
- 18:53So I hold them to that, right?
- 18:55And that's an important measured approach, respectfully speaking the truth and love.
- 18:59And so, you know, when Jesus called out sin in Mark chapter 15, that would be helpful for your listeners to do when they're engaging somebody who identifies as a progressive Christian.
- 19:08So you brought up one of their slogans, love is love and whatever that you notice how they never say truth is truth.
- 19:17It's always love is love.
- 19:19You have to define love. They're defining in a different way, first of all.
- 19:23But how do you respond to that? We know more people are being duped by that because it sounds good. It feels good. It's emotional.
- 19:30It's inclusive, supportive of everybody because everybody should love everybody. God said we should love everybody.
- 19:36But they're using it to justify something that the Bible considers sinful behavior.
- 19:43And Jesus, he's the one that defined marriage between one man and one woman.
- 19:50And here they are saying, well, no, no, no, love is love.
- 19:54It's hard for me to understand the leap that a progressive Christian would take to defend that. Can you explain for us?
- 20:02Yeah, I mean, and so what we need to do as a biblical Christian, somebody who is renewing our mind with critical thinking and a measured approach as I like to say succinctly is understand that love is God.
- 20:15God is the measure of all things, not man.
- 20:19So it's not to be arbitrary or capricious to the individual.
- 20:23So we're not what we're not doing is we're not crafting individualized sexual ethics.
- 20:29The standard of how we live to know what love is comes from God. That's the standard.
- 20:35So let's case in point that debunks that very we call it, you know, kind of a promo or a tag.
- 20:44But what they're saying, and this is a philosophy, love is love.
- 20:49And I say to them, my love to you is that you're wrong and the error of your ways can lead to destruction.
- 20:58They said, that's not love. So notice now they're not only rewriting love, but love is measured by their experience or their sexual desires in this case because most of that slogan came out of what LGBT.
- 21:12Yep.
- 21:13So that's how they're defining it when they say love is love.
- 21:17They're not saying when a mom loves a child or when a husband loves a wife or when a wife loves her husband.
- 21:23So notice it's restricted in the context of their individualized sexual ethic that is primarily propagated through not just romanticism, but through sexual desires.
- 21:36Which again speaks to their sexuality, whether it's their identity sexually or their orientation.
- 21:43So that's when we address those kind of things in that restrictive sense and knowing that they're actually restricting themselves when they say love is love because when you look at love and other contextualized in, you know, situations and relationally,
- 21:58then notice how they start responding to say, well, no, that's not love.
- 22:02So when I say, well, love isn't between a man and a man, right, romantically, they say it is.
- 22:09But when I say God loves his children there, if he disciplines them, they say, no, you think that's love, that's not love.
- 22:15So it's okay that we can push back on it because again, our ultimate standard is God who is love and created us to love.
- 22:24But we have to also admit, which again, in this camp, they don't seem to do is that we don't love the way that God has called us to love.
- 22:36And that's something that I think, instead of dealing it on the sexual side oftentimes, we can do, we can do it in a way to approach a progressive and say, how are you loving me and the exchanging of ideas?
- 22:49If you and I have different, you know, viewpoints of what love actually is or what a relationship ought to be in terms of a marriage and a union between a man and wife, you think that marriage is more than that.
- 23:00And because you think that I'm being restricted between two genders and you, you think there's 72 different genders, right, you think that's more love because you're loving more people that supposedly have different lifestyles, orientations or identities.
- 23:15You know, you see on my point, so that's how they see it. That's what they say all inclusive love is far greater. We're all inclusive.
- 23:25You're not, you're exclusive. Therefore you love less. So when it came to the mask or, you know, COVID during that time and vaccines, if somebody didn't, if they, if they freely chose not to take the vaccine.
- 23:38People in that camp that believe love is love, they're saying, you want to kill society. Right. So you're not showing love.
- 23:47So notice how love is love becomes way more judgmental and way more restrictive actually than when you do measure and define love by God.
- 24:00Wow. And we could talk more about that. But I want to get to one more question because we're running out of time, Jason.
- 24:06In your introduction, you say sometimes doctrinal debates, not a cramonious disputes.
- 24:14Doctoral debates and divisions are fitting even healthy for the church to experience. Why? And you say it forces Christians to pay closer attention to the teachings around them and learn to stand up for their beliefs.
- 24:29And then you say we must be more like the Berean Jews who searched the scriptures daily to ensure that what they were taught aligned with the word of God. That's back to the word back to our standard back to our foundation.
- 24:42Your final thoughts before we need to wrap it up.
- 24:46Yeah, I mean, I think this is a good point to actually in the conversation. I appreciate it, David, because what Christians need to understand is first and foremost, in house, we need to have open debates.
- 24:56If you look back at our church fathers, if you look at councils and creeds and as they are not formulating doctrines that again, we're hijacking the Bible.
- 25:06They were taking the Bible at its word through canonization that we had a measured approach to ensure what we had in scripture came from prophets of God and apostles of Jesus Christ.
- 25:19And with that as our standard, we move forward to ensure that doctrinally, theologically as we unpack the incarnation, the Trinity, that it coincides to the truth that we see in scripture.
- 25:33And those were debated over time. And that was a good thing. Now we are not to divide. We are to remain united. We are to be like-minded. But there are disputes we're told in Romans 14 that we can have that are actually very healthy to have these type of disagreements to work through things and get people to consider on the other side of the argument, maybe I'm wrong.
- 25:56And as we do that, we actually preserve Christianity. We can defend it more critically and more winsomely. And it also prepares us then to leave our home, to leave the church, to debate greater issues of people who actually try to hijack Jesus, hijack the Bible and hijack Christianity.
- 26:16So the more we can actually disagree with Christians, it prepares us to debate people out there in the world.
- 26:21Yes. And as you said, it's healthy and it's necessary. I mean, some of the debates that took place in past centuries were necessary for the church.
- 26:32But Jason Yemenis, standstrongministries.org, the book is called hijacking Jesus, how progressive Christians are remaking him and taking over the church.
- 26:41Brother, I appreciate your ministry. I don't know how you do all that you do. And take care of your family as well and go into two separate fast food restaurants.
- 26:50Anyway, God bless you, brother. We'll stay in touch.
- 26:53All right, buddy. God bless you.
- 26:55All right. Thanks. All right, guys. Tomorrow, Heidi St. John, the busy mom is on the show and Monday, Mike Gendron.
- 27:03Just thank you so much for supporting World View Matters. I love the people I get to talk to and glean from and learn from.
- 27:10And I hope you do as well. God bless you. And as always, keep speaking the truth about things that matter.