Latest / The MaineHealth Podcast / WTKE: Lowering the Cost of Care -- From Strategy to Execution
Transcript
- 0:09Hello, and welcome to Working Together with Kelly Elkins. I'm your host,
- 0:12Kelly Elkins, your Chief Operating Officer for MaineHealth.
- 0:15In this podcast series, I will be joined each episode by guests who are participating
- 0:20on teams focused on how we can support and enhance how we work together across Maine Health
- 0:26so that we can achieve our vision of working together so that our communities
- 0:30are the healthiest in America.
- 0:32In particular, we will highlight work we are doing in further development of
- 0:35our operating model for Maine Health and how we are creating structure and processes
- 0:39that make it easier for you to do your work.
- 0:42Today's episode is titled, Lowering the Cost of Care, From Strategy to Execution.
- 0:48Today's episode focuses on one of the most important challenges and opportunities
- 0:53facing our system, lowering the total cost of care while building a sustainable
- 0:58path forward for FY27 and beyond.
- 1:02This isn't just about budgets or financial targets. It's about how we redesign
- 1:06care to be more accessible, more efficient, and more aligned with what our patients
- 1:11and frontline teams truly need.
- 1:13Today, we'll explore what it really takes to lower cost while improving care,
- 1:18and how we translate strategy into meaningful everyday change across our organization.
- 1:24To join me in the conversation today is my guest, Rich Bayman,
- 1:27Chief Financial Officer for MaineHealth.
- 1:29Welcome back to the podcast, Rich. Thanks for having me, Kelly. Excited to be here.
- 1:34Well, it's a very exciting topic. It's a challenging topic, one you and I spend
- 1:39a lot of our time together thinking about.
- 1:42But maybe before we jump in and to how we are thinking about navigating where
- 1:47we are from a cost perspective and how we reduce that cost in the right best
- 1:53way, I'd love your perspective on.
- 1:57What do you think lowering the cost of care really means in practice?
- 2:00Because cost is kind of in the
- 2:03eye of the beholder. And we have a lot of stakeholders with MaineHealth.
- 2:09So, great question. I think, from my perspective, there's three main drivers.
- 2:13And, you know, the first one is just lowering the cost to deliver care in what
- 2:19I would call as a, you know, per unit of service basis.
- 2:23We need to become really, really efficient in how we deliver our services.
- 2:27When you look at our payer mix, our trend is right now where it's almost 72%
- 2:33government pay, and that's only going to increase. And I'll get back to why
- 2:38that becomes really important in a couple minutes.
- 2:42So that's point number one. Point number two is it's reducing the avoidable care,
- 2:48whether that be an avoidable ED visit or ensuring that a patient that can be
- 2:53appropriately discharged on a Friday and that we're doing the things we need
- 2:57to do prior to the discharge.
- 3:01So we don't wait until Monday and we just carry the patient for the next two
- 3:05days. That's not good for us. That's clearly not good for the patient.
- 3:08Right, exactly. So all that avoidable care, I think, is the second thing.
- 3:11And then the third thing are the prices that we charge.
- 3:15As I mentioned, we're rapidly becoming highly, highly dependent the government. And for all
- 3:23of our government patients, we're price takers, which means we don't negotiate that price.
- 3:28It's generally set by CMS or by the government, and we just have to take those prices.
- 3:34So what we, for us, you know, what we want to make sure that we're doing is
- 3:39appropriately balancing the price we charge to the value that we deliver that
- 3:46is also, that's on one hand.
- 3:48And on the other hand, it's also affordable for our patients and our communities.
- 3:52And I think those are the three main drivers of the total cost of care that we can control. Right.
- 3:59I think it's a really important distinction because I was talking with a group
- 4:04about this recently, and they said that feels like we're boiling the ocean,
- 4:08like lowering cost of care seems almost unattainable.
- 4:14But it's leaning folks in to what can we control? What do we have the most influence over?
- 4:20And to your point, really focusing on the unnecessary, the avoidable duplication
- 4:27or, you know, replication of care. That's not great for the patient.
- 4:32And all it does is add cost for everyone.
- 4:35So I think that is a space leaning into.
- 4:38But there's some other things, too, right? How we are using our resources in
- 4:43the most effective way, how we're managing really basic stuff like payroll management
- 4:50and the codes you select.
- 4:53It may not seem like a big deal, but those kind of pennies add up.
- 4:56Absolutely. And really aren't supporting care delivery. It's really just,
- 5:02oh, I clicked the wrong thing accidentally, right? So I think leaning into that
- 5:07space, there is a lot we can control in the cost. I agree with you.
- 5:12How do we ensure that some of these areas, you know, that we just chatted about.
- 5:18We can control and we think about putting strategies into place for those,
- 5:24how can we actually engage and enable our frontline to help us with those areas
- 5:31we control rather than it feeling like a burden upon them? Sure.
- 5:36First off, if we can standardize as much of our processes as possible.
- 5:42One, and then two, empower the frontline care team members within a framework
- 5:47So they understand where they are and they don't feel overwhelmed about the
- 5:51decisions they have to make.
- 5:52I think we can, one, is I think we can reduce costs.
- 5:56And two, I think we can have a more engaged care team because they feel more
- 5:59empowered about the decisions that affect them on a day-to-day basis.
- 6:02I am a huge believer that the people that are closest to the work are in the
- 6:07best position to improve it.
- 6:09I heard a terrific example yesterday. It was one of the units at MMC.
- 6:14And they were looking at their staffing and their expenses. And one of the frontline
- 6:18care team members actually got the data, broke it down, and said,
- 6:22these are where we're spending our dollars. This is what I would say is sort of the base pay.
- 6:26This was OT. This was incentive.
- 6:29And this was contract labor. And they were looking at that, and they're going, wow.
- 6:34Like, we have to be intentional in how we make decisions.
- 6:38And every day, now they're going to the charge nurse with the data.
- 6:42And they're thinking about, okay, how do we manage not the, I wouldn't say maybe
- 6:45not the people, but how do we manage the expense of those people in the most efficient way?
- 6:52And that's just, that's a frontline unit that came up with this idea.
- 6:56And they're like, hey, this is
- 6:57great. And now they have taken it upon themselves and they're doing that.
- 7:01That doesn't cost anything. And they're more engaged in it, and they're going
- 7:06to help save money, and it's going to have zero implication on the patient care.
- 7:12I think that's an unbelievable way for them to get engaged. Yeah.
- 7:17Well, and, you know, I know you've been here a little over a year with us,
- 7:23and in my time here, we've been on this journey to bring data,
- 7:28particularly around workforce data, to the hands.
- 7:31Of the frontline leaders so they can do just that.
- 7:34And I think some of the new tools that are becoming available will really help escalate that.
- 7:39I know we recently had a skills workshop for frontline leaders in the coastal region.
- 7:46We hosted it and there were like 130 leaders, I think, who came and attended the event.
- 7:52And yesterday I saw some data and out of that event, Each leader was asked to
- 7:58submit, at minimum, one idea that you're going to take back and execute on,
- 8:02based upon what you learned today in the space of,
- 8:05resource, utilization, supply management, care variation, new ideas, growth.
- 8:11130 leaders, there were 222 action plans submitted with ideas.
- 8:17And that's not a big, grand, strategic plan that you and I and other senior leaders are working on.
- 8:24You know, there are some of those opportunities, but, you know,
- 8:27to me now, it's how they'll quantify that and then, you know,
- 8:31hold everybody accountable.
- 8:33It's their ideas and they're engaging their teams in that work.
- 8:36You know, one of our core values is ownership. Right. And I think these are
- 8:40just two unbelievable examples of where we're having everybody in the organization,
- 8:45take ownership. Yeah. And I think that's, we need that across the board. Yeah.
- 8:49So in my intro, I mentioned, you know, this isn't necessarily about budgets,
- 8:53but budget is a part of our reality.
- 8:55It's one of those accountability tools we utilize to help kind of set a direction
- 9:01and a course. And, you know, we're in that season right now.
- 9:05And, you know, at a system level, we set overarching targets and goals,
- 9:10but it really is those frontline departments and those leaders who help us get,
- 9:16you know, kind of build back into that.
- 9:18You know, when we think about the year ahead and even the next couple of years
- 9:21ahead and where we need to go from an overall financial health perspective, and we,
- 9:27marry that into this process of needing to have budgeting processes,
- 9:33what needs to be different in how we are approaching budgeting or forecasting,
- 9:40to maybe align it more with this work ahead? Sure.
- 9:44You know, I guess first, you know, as a baseline, I think we have to, one, assume that,
- 9:49our rate increases, our revenue increases will be less than historic and that
- 9:56they're also going to be lower than the rate of inflation in our expenses.
- 10:01You know, healthcare costs and inflation and across the country,
- 10:03right, it's outpacing our blended price increases.
- 10:07As I said earlier, we get about 70 plus percent of our reimbursement from the government.
- 10:12On average, they only increase rates about plus or minus two and a half percent
- 10:18a year, which isn't a lot.
- 10:20We have historically tried to keep our commercial rate increases in that 4% to 5% range.
- 10:27And last year it was, or for this year, we increased to 4.5%,
- 10:31and we'll probably look for something similar in 2027.
- 10:34But when you blend that, you know, we're closer to 2.5% than we are 4.5%,
- 10:40just given the relative mix.
- 10:42So that's our ability to raise price is going to be constrained based on our pair mix. And second,
- 10:50we don't really want to continue to cost shift to our communities on the commercial side.
- 10:57We just start. We need appropriate increases and whatnot, but we don't want
- 11:01to overburden that population.
- 11:04Second, our occupancy rates generally across the board are pretty high.
- 11:10And so from a capacity standpoint, we're not going to get a lot of organic growth,
- 11:16especially when you layer that against the population in the state of Maine
- 11:19and our market share and everything else, right?
- 11:21So our ability to grow the top line, I think, will continue to grow,
- 11:28but it's going to be growing at a slower pace, you know, kind of year over year over year.
- 11:33You know, when you combine those two, we really have to be a little bit more
- 11:36conservative in our revenue projections and then understand from a cost perspective,
- 11:42when we put all the inflationary costs and everything else, we've got to just
- 11:45get more efficient out of all of that.
- 11:48So when you think about what's the difference between budgeting,
- 11:51I think we're going to be a little bit more conservative on the revenue side
- 11:55and then ultimately more conservative on what we can do from a cost growth perspective.
- 12:00Instead of saying, hey, we're going to grow at 7% top line so we can grow at 6% on the expense line.
- 12:06That's just not going to work anymore. So I think that will be the big difference.
- 12:11We're going to take a much more conservative approach on the top line.
- 12:13How do you think that will show up for leaders, care team members in terms of,
- 12:20you know, what are going to be some of the hard trade-offs that folks may have.
- 12:26To face when looking at the budget?
- 12:29I think it's across the board. And, you know, we talked about all the little
- 12:33things that we need to do a little bit earlier.
- 12:36You know, for example, I'm going to use an example. So this year,
- 12:38the last two years, so going from 25 to 26 in the whole corporate space, right?
- 12:44We limited our increase. Our increase is going to be year over year about 2%
- 12:48all in, which is pretty good. Yeah.
- 12:50Given what we do for, you know, for compensation and everything else going on.
- 12:55But for next year, what we have set the target is part—and we're pretty much
- 13:00there—where we said in corporate shared services, no new dollars.
- 13:05Right. So not inflation-adjusted, you know, not compensation-adjusted.
- 13:10If you spent a dollar last year, your department gets to spend a dollar in 2027.
- 13:16And we did that. We didn't tell people how to get there. Right.
- 13:19We just said get there. And I think each one of our departments—,
- 13:23went back and looked at their department and they said, okay,
- 13:26how am I going to get there?
- 13:28We're going to fill unfilled vacancies because we're able to do the work more
- 13:32efficiently. We looked at our non-labor spend.
- 13:35I know like in RevCycle, we looked at and we're getting rid of a couple IT vendors
- 13:40and software vendors and things that we really weren't optimizing and weren't
- 13:44using and weren't adding a lot of value.
- 13:46So we're picking up savings there.
- 13:49We just have to have this almost a fanatical approach to efficiencies.
- 13:54And we really need to get there. We don't really have a choice given the payer mix. Right.
- 14:01And the other thing I would say there is it's not like we're trying to go from,
- 14:05a 5% operating margin to an 8% operating margin. We're trying to go from maybe
- 14:09break even to slightly below break even to a 3% margin.
- 14:15And we need to get to 3% given all the investments we have to make into the
- 14:20system over the next five or so years.
- 14:23We're behind our investing schedule because of COVID and the uncertainty.
- 14:28And we sort of made a conscious decision, which was the right decision at the time.
- 14:32But now we've got to catch up. And so if we can't get back there,
- 14:37then our communities are going to suffer and it's not going to be good for anybody.
- 14:41I think the investment commentary is important here because,
- 14:45you know, as I've talked to folks about the work ahead we have to do,
- 14:49there will be trade-offs, like you mentioned.
- 14:52Just because we maybe set a directive for a corporate shared service that you
- 14:58get the same dollar next year to spend, that doesn't mean that they can't do
- 15:01something new and different with their dollar.
- 15:04It's really also saying what do we need to stop doing as a trade-off to doing something different.
- 15:11We will at a time where we're trying to lower the cost of care.
- 15:14We also do need to make strategic investments.
- 15:17Care team's going to see us making investments in spaces outside of the hospital
- 15:22and ambulatory and for access and growth and kind of different business models
- 15:27and reimbursement models.
- 15:28And I know sometimes that can be a challenge for folks because they're saying,
- 15:32hey, wait a minute, you're asking us to be really fanatical over here and managing
- 15:37our resources and you're doing this.
- 15:40We have to do both. And I think it's how do we make sure folks understand when
- 15:45we're doing investment?
- 15:46It's because we are expecting that to contribute to that financial health position, right?
- 15:52It's a balancing act we have to do. One, it's going to contribute to our financial
- 15:57health overall. Two, from an industry perspective, we'll use the example of
- 16:02the Orthopedic Surgery Center, right?
- 16:04You know, there's a lot of talk, and it's coming, around site-neutral payments.
- 16:10And so we've got to find these lower costs where we can deliver the same level of care at a lower cost.
- 16:17Because the government's going to tell us, we're not going to pay you anymore.
- 16:22If we do it in an inpatient setting.
- 16:24Setting at MMC where that cost structure, given all of the things that we have
- 16:29to do there, and you get the low-acuity things out of those high-cost settings
- 16:35into these low-cost settings, we're not going to have a choice.
- 16:38We're just not going to have a choice. So I think there's a little bit of it's
- 16:42going to contribute, and it's
- 16:43also going to be thrust upon us that we do those types of things. Yeah.
- 16:47So, Rich, as we kind of wrap it up, because we could talk about this,
- 16:50obviously, all day long. And obviously, a lot of people are, and it is top of mind.
- 16:57If we get this right over the next 12 to 18 months, even the next 24 to 36 months.
- 17:05What will feel meaningfully different across the system and for MaineHealth?
- 17:10Before I answer that, I do want to say that I think we've got some good momentum going. Yeah.
- 17:14You know, a couple examples are, one, if you look at our hospitals themselves,
- 17:20right? Our cost per adjusted discharge, we're seeing meaningful progress.
- 17:25And it's going up, but it's going up, in my view, at a rate slower than inflation.
- 17:30So I think the core hospital operations are doing well.
- 17:35I think the challenge there is I think we started from a slightly higher baseline
- 17:41than we probably need to be at in the future.
- 17:45So we need to continue that process. But I do think there's good momentum.
- 17:49Second, I'd point to the medical group.
- 17:52And when we look at their increased productivities, you know,
- 17:54consistently month over month, I think we're beginning to meet sort of the productivity
- 17:59benchmarks and whatnot in the RVU stuff.
- 18:02And I know that we don't really want to be in the widget-making business.
- 18:06But there's a certain baseline that we need to get to. And I think the medical
- 18:10group's done a really nice job.
- 18:13The third example that I would show or I talk about is, you know,
- 18:17our first case on time starts in the ORs from where we've improved from like
- 18:21literally like 7% to like 50%.
- 18:24I think it was a huge improvement. And those are just a couple of examples that
- 18:28I would point to. So I think people are doing a lot of great work out there. Absolutely.
- 18:31You know, if we get this right, what it would say is that we would have great
- 18:36confidence in our financial performance.
- 18:38It would be a steady trend in the right direction.
- 18:41Right. You know, I don't know about you, but every month, I don't know what
- 18:44the outcome is going to be a little bit. And so I'm sort of waiting that first
- 18:48week when the month ends that we would be back to this sort of steady state.
- 18:52We can see the monthly or at least trailing couple month progression.
- 18:56On that one hand, we would see that predictability. But two,
- 19:00at the same time, we'd be maintaining our care team member engagement,
- 19:04our patient experience, our quality, and our access goals.
- 19:06Because as Andy always says, right, we can drop the cost of care.
- 19:09We'll just stop doing a bunch of stuff, which is not our intention at all.
- 19:14I would end by something I said a minute ago, right? You know,
- 19:17we need to focus on this not for the sake of focusing on it and becoming more profitable.
- 19:23It's because we need to generate a certain amount of profit, cash flow, savings.
- 19:28Create capital so we can reinvest into the system. That's why we need to do
- 19:33it. We're the safety net provider for the state.
- 19:37And if we're not doing those things, we're not going to be able to have a burn
- 19:42unit that takes care of folks in an emergency like we had last month.
- 19:48And then just our local communities and the physical plants and stuff that are there.
- 19:53We need to do it and we have to hit sort of this minimum baseline,
- 19:57which looks like about 3%. Yeah.
- 19:58Thanks for that. I couldn't agree more. I was doing something recently and somebody
- 20:02asked me, you know, what keeps me up at night? And, you know,
- 20:06I first joked and said everything because, you know, there's always a lot going on.
- 20:11But I said, to me, it's truly, if, to your point, if we don't get this right,
- 20:15we won't be able to be here for our communities. And that's who we are.
- 20:19That's what we're about.
- 20:21And I think if everyone can rally around, we're really doing this for the patients
- 20:26and our communities and lean into the things we can control.
- 20:31And control isn't always necessarily on the expense side. It is on the access
- 20:35side, as you mentioned, the work happening across the system.
- 20:38So, you know, I think it's not just work worth doing.
- 20:42It's must do work and must do can't fail.
- 20:46Big obligation that we have to our communities and to our care team.
- 20:51To your point, I think we've got momentum and, you know, I'm optimistic.
- 20:55There's no reason why we can't do this. I'm very optimistic.
- 20:58Yeah. You know, I think we have, as you said, you know, lean into what we can control.
- 21:03And I think right now, a lot of it is in our control. Yeah. Yeah.
- 21:07I remain thoroughly optimistic. Right.
- 21:10Well, thanks again for joining me and chatting a little bit about this.
- 21:14I think it's important and I hope for our folks who are listening in,
- 21:18some of it resonated or even sparked some ideas and thoughts that they can bring forward, so.
- 21:24Well, thanks for having me and I'm happy to come back anytime.
- 21:26Absolutely, thanks Rich. Thanks everybody.
- 21:29Well, I hope that you found this episode informative and provides a deeper insight
- 21:32into one of our major areas of focus as we continue to enhance how we work together
- 21:38as MaineHealth to achieve our vision
- 21:40of working together so that our communities are the healthiest in America.
- 21:45If you have ideas for topics for
- 21:47future podcasts, please email those to workingtogetheratmainhealth.org.
- 21:53Thank you and have a blessed day.