Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Live Talk: George at Sunday Sangha
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So I'm just going to jump in
- 0:20here, but I do think of myself as a Socratic teacher, so I do
- 0:25like to answer questions if you have them along the way.
- 0:28If some of you are less familiar with attachment theory, then you
- 0:32might need some clarification in the material that I'm talking
- 0:36about. And so please feel free to ask
- 0:41your questions and then we can get into a mainly Q&A period
- 0:45toward the end. I was trained by Shin Zhen Young
- 0:51and by Noah Levine and by Dan Brown to teach material like
- 0:59this. And I think that they all agreed
- 1:02that there was a a synergy between the traditional way of
- 1:08describing meditation experiences and Western
- 1:11psychology. Not that Western psychology
- 1:15leads to liberation particularly, but that we tend
- 1:20to those of us who are in the West and educated in this way,
- 1:23recognize patterns that are described by Western psychology.
- 1:28And then if we can use the recognition of those patterns to
- 1:33recognize the descriptions that traditional spiritual practices
- 1:38talk about, it furthers our ability to investigate the
- 1:44things that we need to know to come to this place of
- 1:49liberation. And what I would guess Dan Brown
- 1:54would describe. That is to be able to hold an
- 1:56enlightened view continuously without it being interrupted by
- 2:03grabbing on to the experiences of this human body and our
- 2:09perceptions of meaning that we cast on to the world.
- 2:17One of the things that's important also to talk about in
- 2:20terms of the conditioning of East and West is that in the
- 2:25West we're really influenced by the original Greek thinkers
- 2:31around this. Aristotle, for instance, thought
- 2:34that we take a a scan of the world around us and that we
- 2:39internalize that and create a working model of self and world.
- 2:43That's quite accurate. And then we operate from our
- 2:48understanding of the self and world that we create internally.
- 2:53A few centuries later, maybe Epicurus modified that by saying
- 2:59if there was a strong emotional state present in the in in the
- 3:03person when they gathered the information, it might affect the
- 3:07working model of the experience of self and world.
- 3:13But it's largely accurate. And if you look at Eastern
- 3:17philosophy and Buddhist philosophy in particular, this
- 3:20is not at all what's happening. What's happening is you're doing
- 3:26a survey of what's around you that interacts with the sense
- 3:31gates that you have. You're gathering that sense data
- 3:36vedna is a term that means ordering of the processing of
- 3:40sense data. Is it urgent?
- 3:42Does it need immediate attention?
- 3:43Is there time for something pleasant?
- 3:46Most experiences just not dealt with at all because it's not
- 3:50deemed important enough. And then it's compared in that
- 3:54ordering to the perceptual database.
- 3:57And if there's a meaning in the perceptual database that's close
- 4:01enough to the pattern of experience in front of you, that
- 4:03whole thread of meaning attaches and it rolls from ultimate
- 4:08reality into conceptual reality, which is the world that we
- 4:13inhabit, that making sense. If there's no entry in the
- 4:18database that's close enough to the sensing experience, then the
- 4:22imagination fills in and creates a meaning for what's happening
- 4:27in the present moment. And so in in Eastern philosophy
- 4:31and Buddhist philosophy, we don't really wander around in
- 4:38what's happening. We wander around in what's
- 4:42happening means to us, if that makes sense.
- 4:46So we take in the information, we compare it to the database,
- 4:50we assign the meanings, and this is from previously experienced
- 4:53things. This is really where the
- 4:55conditioning sets in. And then we create this world of
- 4:59meaning that we inhabit because our conditioning is different
- 5:05from everybody else's conditioning.
- 5:07We are all making up our own meaning set for what's
- 5:11happening. And actually what we're doing
- 5:14when we disagree with somebody is bumping our meaning set up
- 5:18against their meaning set and the match not being particularly
- 5:22integratable. And so the shift, I think, when
- 5:27you really touch into the attachment material is to this
- 5:30position of this is what I think is going on.
- 5:34What do you think is going on? And then that opens up the
- 5:37dialogue, a collaborative dialogue between yourself and
- 5:42other people. John Bovie was an English
- 5:46psychiatrist and Mary Ainsworth was a researcher who was
- 5:50American. And between them, in their
- 5:52collaboration, they came up with attachment theory.
- 5:56I know in our society we tend to value work by men more than we
- 6:01do work by women. And so you'll often hear it's
- 6:04John Bolby's attachment theory. But when you really look at the,
- 6:08the what happened on the ground there, there would be no
- 6:12attachment theory without the contribution that Mary Ainsworth
- 6:16made. And their their work together
- 6:19was very collaborative and I think that they valued each
- 6:23other equally in that collaboration.
- 6:29Attachment theory is a a change in the direction of
- 6:35psychoanalytic thought. I I'm sure you're all familiar
- 6:40with your history of the development of psychoanalytic
- 6:43thought, but maybe not. And it was quite object related
- 6:49in the end of the 18th century into the 19th, into the 1800s,
- 7:01into the 1900s or the 20th century.
- 7:03And, and when World War 2 broke out.
- 7:08So that would be between the wars, a lot of the, the, the
- 7:13people who were involved in analytic thought were Jewish and
- 7:16they had to flee Europe. And there was a rich community
- 7:21that settled in London at the time.
- 7:23So a lot of dialogue about that, but Bobby was always thought
- 7:27that what actually happened was influential, not what you
- 7:33thought happened or your relationship to what happened.
- 7:36After the war was over, he was tasked by the British government
- 7:40to evaluate whether the children that were sent to the foster
- 7:46care in the countryside. If you remember your World War 2
- 7:49history, Germany bombed London and the middle class and the
- 7:53rich were able to send their children to the countryside, the
- 7:57relatives. But the poor were swept up in a
- 8:00government foster care program and sent out into the
- 8:03countryside to be cared for. And the government wanted to
- 8:07know whether those children had suffered harm in that experience
- 8:12that the government would later have to provide services for.
- 8:15And so Bolby was involved in that investigation and
- 8:18determined that it likely called would cause lifelong harm to the
- 8:25children that were sent out, particularly the young children
- 8:29under the age of three. And he wanted to figure out what
- 8:33that was. And so he began to explore that.
- 8:35That's the origin of this particular line of thinking.
- 8:42He put an ad in a paper for somebody to to develop a
- 8:47research instrument. It was Mary Ainsworth who
- 8:50answered that and she developed a testing method called the
- 8:54strange Situation. And that strange situation was
- 8:57how they evaluated children. So we can evaluate using the
- 9:02strange situation what your attachment conditioning is by 10
- 9:06months or or a year old. So I know when I originally came
- 9:14to Buddha's thinking and, and we, we talked about conditioning
- 9:17and it was described in the poetry of the Buddha.
- 9:22You know, is the mind equanimous?
- 9:24Is the mind engaged in craving? Is the mind engaged in aversion?
- 9:31Is the mind restless or agitated?
- 9:33Is the mind slothful? Is the mind engaged in doubt?
- 9:41Were these experiences that didn't relate directly to my
- 9:46experience and and I noticed them more as functions or
- 9:52concepts of experience? But when you begin to say that
- 10:01attachment conditioning is present at that age and that the
- 10:04attachment conditioning precedes the self experience arising,
- 10:10what is your earliest memory? How old were you when you
- 10:14remember that? I would say in thinking back of
- 10:20my own memory that I have some flashes of memory at around age
- 10:294 and then more continuous memory around age 5.
- 10:34And then at around 8/6 I have a, a, a continuous stream of
- 10:42memories that, but you know, what is your experience of that?
- 10:55So all of this conditioning happens when we are unable to
- 10:58remember it, which which is profoundly affecting in terms of
- 11:03how we perceive of ourselves and how we perceive of the world.
- 11:08And actually the conditioning patterns in a way that's
- 11:13recognizable so that you can understand what the conditions
- 11:16of your early experience were based on the way that you create
- 11:20the experience of reality. Now really useful.
- 11:29So imagine this, you're a little baby, you're like ten days old.
- 11:37Your entire world is the way that we, your caregivers come
- 11:43and respond to you have Can you imagine that?
- 11:47Have you been around small children?
- 11:49Have you been around a 10 day old baby and noticed how they
- 11:54are every now and then they open their eyes, they look around and
- 11:57this look of wonder passes over their face and then their eyes
- 12:01closed and they're they're back in this process of developing.
- 12:07We make this expression, I'm waving my arms.
- 12:10But of course the the 10 day old baby is swaddled and they don't
- 12:13even move right, Because that creates a sense of safety for
- 12:17them and they cry out to the world.
- 12:20But but they don't cry out first.
- 12:23First they look cute. That's the thing that they look
- 12:25as cute as they possibly can to try and get somebody to take
- 12:29care of them. And if you're attuned to them,
- 12:31it's overwhelmingly cute and you immediately respond to them.
- 12:34But if you're not paying attention, they'll look
- 12:41surprised that nobody's coming. And then they'll whimper.
- 12:44And if nobody comes, then they'll intermittently cry if
- 12:47nobody comes, and then they'll continuously cry if nobody
- 12:50comes, and then they'll tantrum. If nobody comes, they'll go into
- 12:56anaclytic depression, which is a really bad thing to have happen
- 13:01to a kid. But if you catch them along the
- 13:05way and this it could be fast and you respond to them, you
- 13:09attune to them, you look at them.
- 13:11You know, a baby is like 6 inches from your face and you're
- 13:13looking at them and you're attuning to them and you're
- 13:16reading into the expression that they're making this tiny little
- 13:21body and this little face and you're mirroring back to them
- 13:26what you think is happening. And then you're taking care of
- 13:30them. And if you get it right, it
- 13:33relieves their tension and they settle in.
- 13:35And if you get it wrong, you see immediately that that wasn't the
- 13:39thing that they wanted. And you keep trying with these
- 13:41different things. And that is the the cycle of
- 13:44security that I can express myself authentically.
- 13:48I can express my needs authentically with the
- 13:52expectation that the world will sensitively respond to me and
- 13:57meet my needs. That's what we call security.
- 14:03And that actually creates not only a a working model of self,
- 14:07that I'm capable and competent and that people will delight in
- 14:11me and people will take care of me, and that the world is a
- 14:15place I can go out to and explore and will be responsive
- 14:20to me. That's security.
- 14:23And in adults, what that means is that you're free to be
- 14:26authentic. You don't worry about being
- 14:28banded, particularly you. You expect people to delight in
- 14:32you and be interested in your point of view.
- 14:35And you see the world largely as a place where you can go explore
- 14:40and get your needs met. All of those things, of course,
- 14:44are trackable in meditation. That's what makes them so
- 14:48saliently salient to the practice.
- 14:52How do you experience the sense of self under arises?
- 14:55How do you experience the sense of the world?
- 14:58In Buddhism, of course, the world is other people.
- 15:00What are your expectations of other people when you encounter
- 15:04them? When you walk into a room of
- 15:07people that you don't really know, what is your expectation
- 15:10of them? All of these things are the the
- 15:14experience of reality and the experience of self that are
- 15:18arising that we can use our meditation practice to track and
- 15:23to begin to reflect on how accurate they are, how we create
- 15:30the experience of our meaning based on conditioning.
- 15:37And so we we get this pathway into understanding the nature of
- 15:40conditioning by examining these responses that making sense.
- 15:48So you have the capacity to sense these senses touching,
- 15:52seeing, hearing, tasting, smelling.
- 15:54We have also mind in in Buddhism, which we don't have in
- 15:58the West. Mind is the thing that really
- 16:02selects what you focus on and creates that curation of of
- 16:06experience. Then you have objects that can
- 16:09be sensed, and when their contact, that sensing experience
- 16:12arises. It's undifferentiated,
- 16:17unfixated, completely unconscious, and unknown to the
- 16:20self experience. It's evaluated for urgency.
- 16:23Do we need to attend this immediately?
- 16:25Does it not matter whether we get to it?
- 16:27Is there time for pleasant experience?
- 16:29And we have science on the mind time of this, right?
- 16:33Urgent is 3/8 of a second. Pleasant is half a second, twice
- 16:38the duration, twice the intensity in order for it to get
- 16:41into the queue. And it goes into the queue and
- 16:44we if there's a match, it unfolds and there's the meaning.
- 16:50And if there isn't a match, the imagination fills it in.
- 16:54But you could have a childhood experience that was so painful
- 16:58that you pinched off aspects of your imagination and then you
- 17:01can't fill in the meaning. It's confusing.
- 17:04You don't know what it is. If you have a lot of adverse
- 17:09experiences in childhood, the working model of self that
- 17:13develops is filled with a lot of negative experiences that
- 17:17activated order to create the experience of the self.
- 17:21And in the moment that all of that negativity arises so that
- 17:26you can recognize the pattern of self that's arising, you can
- 17:30become aversive to that experience of negativity over
- 17:34and over again. That is the root cause of self
- 17:37hatred, the sense of self arising and just not wanting to
- 17:43have another intensely aversive experience.
- 17:49Of course, the opposite is through self love.
- 17:51If you, if you've built this working model of self that each
- 17:53time it arises, you enjoy having the experience of you.
- 17:57And that's the origin of self love because each time it
- 18:00arises, you enjoy the experience of it.
- 18:03It's fun, it's light, it's funny, but these things we can
- 18:13know pretty well in in that straight context of Western
- 18:18thought, and then we can begin to use these as the objects to
- 18:22explore the traditional path to liberation.
- 18:28This is how I'm forming the world.
- 18:31We wanna know that in terms of understanding the nature of the
- 18:35human condition, which is this experience of liberation, we
- 18:43want to be able to, at the end of it, of course, touch into
- 18:46this place of sacredness where each moment, every little thing
- 18:52is this sacred experience that's so remarkable.
- 18:59And you come into that view and hold it in relation to
- 19:02everything always. Or does these conditioned
- 19:06responses just get in the way? When you get up in the morning
- 19:13and you trample into the bathroom and you stand in front
- 19:16of the mirror, do you recognize who's there?
- 19:19Or do you have this internal mod of yourself that's quite
- 19:21different than that? Oh my God, who's this stranger
- 19:24staring at me in the mirror? I'm this 30 year old.
- 19:29I'm this, whatever it is. Every time I do a test on
- 19:33Facebook of how old I am internally, I, I don't get much
- 19:36past 13. What do you think of yourself
- 19:43and do you enjoy that? Do you, do you, do you take care
- 19:47of yourself in the thought processes or you're just
- 19:52troubled by it? So we begin to understand that
- 19:57in the nature of things, we, we, the mind goes around and selects
- 20:01things that we prefer and gathers them together and we
- 20:05create this pattern of the experience that's around us.
- 20:10And we roll it into conceptual real.
- 20:12And if we don't pay attention to it, we're simply living in this
- 20:17meaning that we've created. That's conditioned.
- 20:20That's the insight. But if we can see the way in
- 20:25which we create that, we can change the process of curation.
- 20:30So it's actually more accurate. The Holly word for this is Taj
- 20:35Tajapananti, which means to reflect back on the reality that
- 20:40you've created and to tie it into what is the actual sensing
- 20:47experience. In attachment theory, we tend to
- 20:52talk about this in three ways. One is the attachment
- 20:56experience. The activation that seeks causes
- 21:00you to seek proximity to somebody who will protect you
- 21:05and that activates and deactivates.
- 21:09The second one is the the capacity to mentalize and to
- 21:13emotionally regulate. The reason that this is
- 21:15important is because we want to be able to explore.
- 21:20So attachment and exploration, which is based on the capacity
- 21:24to mentalize and emotional regulate, emotionally regulate,
- 21:28primary and secondary exploration.
- 21:30Primary exploration is the place where you derive meaning in your
- 21:34life. If you don't pursue primary
- 21:39exploration to the point where you have enough meaning in your
- 21:42life, then you find yourself despairing there isn't enough to
- 21:49motivate you to continue on. Some of the hindrances you may
- 21:54recall in the Theravada map of enlightenment are the craving
- 21:59for existence and also the craving for non existences
- 22:03really aggravate that. I, I, I don't understand why I'm
- 22:07doing this. Why am I continuing on with this
- 22:10life that I have? Because it, it doesn't provide
- 22:13me with a sense of richness, a sense of fulfilment.
- 22:16That's the primary exploration that we're talking about.
- 22:29How do you do that? How do you shift that to see
- 22:33more clearly? The third one is collaborative
- 22:39relationships. So in attachment theory, it's
- 22:44activations of the attachment system, the capacity to explore,
- 22:49and the collaborative relationship system.
- 22:52In collaborative relationships, you take care of somebody in the
- 22:55way that they need to be taken care of, and they take care of
- 22:59you in the way that you need to be taken care of.
- 23:01And you work together to figure out what that is so that you're
- 23:05both well taken care of. So that you can then go out and
- 23:09explore the things that you need to find out so that you're your
- 23:13life is rich with meaning. And then you can come rushing
- 23:19back and you can tell somebody what it is that you figured out
- 23:23that's so meaningful to you. And if their exploration is in
- 23:26line with yours, it will be really useful to them and
- 23:29they'll be excited and interested in what you have to
- 23:31say. And then they can go out and
- 23:33explore and come back and share with you the things that they
- 23:36discovered. And that synergy between each of
- 23:39your primary explorations will float the relationship.
- 23:47So as you can tell, I'm, I can blab on incessantly for hours on
- 23:52this topic because I really like it.
- 23:55But I do think that we should begin to look at questions a
- 24:00little bit. Is that making sense?
- 24:08All right, these are questions related to the meditation.
- 24:10Visual thinking is the place where you see visual imagery
- 24:15that's associated with thinking. So for most people, it's
- 24:18centered at the eyes, in front of or slightly behind the eyes.
- 24:21A Gray screen that sometimes is modulating, sometimes is a
- 24:25little color in it, and then you see imagery.
- 24:29We talk about domains of visual experience, auditory experience
- 24:33in the felt sense of the body. With visual experience, there's
- 24:37the external sight space, which if you're seeing, you're
- 24:40probably familiar with. But if you close your eyes,
- 24:43there's also an A whole world of internal visual thinking.
- 24:48The five main aspects of that are the mental screen that's
- 24:51usually centered at the eyes. There's a sense of the outline
- 24:55of the body in its current position.
- 24:57It's part of the Propriocepta system.
- 25:00It's how we identify how the body's positioned.
- 25:05There's the body's location in the current environment.
- 25:07If you open your eyes and look ahead of you and close the eyes,
- 25:11maybe you'll notice an after image of the location in the
- 25:14room. There's an image reaction to
- 25:18local sensation in the body and an image reaction exterior
- 25:23sound. Mainly what we're focusing on is
- 25:25the visual thinking aspect, which is this screen centered up
- 25:28here. Oh, examples of humorous labels
- 25:36you might use for repeating thoughts.
- 25:37So I have one that I call Superman, which is where I swoop
- 25:41in and save the day. I have one called Talk Show
- 25:44where I'm pontificating and how brilliant I am.
- 25:47I have one I call the Rancher, which is really mean, just
- 25:49pushing a shopping cart down the road, expressing in expletives
- 25:54my opinion of everyone I see around me.
- 25:56I have terrorists where I'm nearly killed and saving the
- 26:01day, but everyone's gathered around my hospital bed to to
- 26:06encourage me to keep going. So I call that Superman and
- 26:13terrorist and ranter and talk show.
- 26:17These are my samples of Pithy taja.
- 26:35Pannati is the word Taj. Taja means to reflect back, and
- 26:44pannati is the Poly word for conceptual reality.
- 26:56All right, I'm a terrible speller.
- 27:04I'd have to Google it to tell you how it's spelled, but I did
- 27:12subtitle my book on it, so if you look on the website it's
- 27:16there too. Jane Miller.
- 27:21Hey, George, thank you so much. I love the way you're
- 27:24integrating attachment theory and Buddhism.
- 27:28And for me, I'm a psychotherapist, so I'm very
- 27:33familiar with attachment theory and I thank you because that was
- 27:37really very fascinating for me. So thank you.
- 27:44My question is a little off the topic and I'm if you don't wanna
- 27:48answer it, that's fine. I'm just really curious how your
- 27:52practice and Buddhism have influenced your photography.
- 27:57Oh, that's actually still on topic because I use photography
- 28:05as my primary exploration. And actually this is a good
- 28:08topic. I started a magazine called
- 28:11Place. This is a copy of it it which I
- 28:15put out twice a year, which I'm also a visual thinker more than
- 28:20an auditory thinker. And so I use it to create
- 28:23narratives of meaning. Really, the idea with
- 28:28exploration is to create meaning in your life so that you feel a
- 28:35sense of richness in a sense of satisfaction.
- 28:39And then the understanding is, how do you do that?
- 28:42Since your conditioning is unique, it's going to be a path
- 28:46that's unique to you. And then of course, we have the
- 28:48interference of the cultural evaluations of what's meaningful
- 28:54and what isn't meaningful. And what I, what I find quite
- 28:58often is with people is that their primary interest, the
- 29:01thing that really moves them, is not culturally valued very well.
- 29:06And so that there's always creating a, a life of secondary
- 29:10exploration, which is the gathering of time, energy and
- 29:12resources. Then focusing that on the things
- 29:15that really do produce meaning and then having to battle the
- 29:21culture that might think that the thing that you value so much
- 29:25isn't, isn't so valuable, but still figuring that out.
- 29:31And so I really do think of my photography mainly as an
- 29:36exploration. And the thing that really is the
- 29:38most interesting to me and the way that it works is I take a
- 29:42picture and then I look at the picture and I see the parts of
- 29:44the picture that I like. And if it the picture itself
- 29:48doesn't work, I just extract in my mind the aspect that really
- 29:52works. And then I, when I make the next
- 29:53photograph, I try to include that insight into the nature of
- 29:57things that work for me. And over a period of time, as
- 30:01you take one picture after another after another, it
- 30:04gradually distills down into the the things actually in the
- 30:10visual frame that work. So I have one of my books is
- 30:16called Forcing Nature, which is a is a books of formal portraits
- 30:22of trees in Los Angeles. And what was so interesting to
- 30:26me is that as the process distilled, the elements that I
- 30:31really liked in the pictures were a telephone pole, a street
- 30:34lamp and a tree. And as you'll notice over the
- 30:38course of the development of the images that that became the the
- 30:43the elements that were present in most of the photographs.
- 30:46So, yeah, it is this whole this whole process of really noticing
- 30:53what you do, noticing the parts of what you do have real meaning
- 30:56to you, and then moving in the direction of the parts that have
- 31:00real meaning in you until you really create a space where
- 31:06most, well, most of us have to do secondary exploration to get
- 31:11along in the world. That but at least a couple of
- 31:14hours a day, you're spent in the activity that really provides
- 31:18the meaning. And if you can do that, what
- 31:20you'll notice is the whole rest of the stuff that you have to do
- 31:23doesn't matter so much. But if you don't have that hour
- 31:29or two or three each day, then you get more and more bothered
- 31:34by the stuff that you have to do and to the point you just don't
- 31:37want to do it anymore. That's what I that's what I
- 31:41would say. Thank you for sharing, I really
- 31:44appreciate that mine is horseback riding.
- 31:48Awesome, you like danger. Well, for me it's not danger,
- 31:55but OK. No, it's beautiful.
- 31:57It's a. Beautiful dance between a human
- 32:01and an animal. And it's really the place where
- 32:06I probably am in the most centered, grounded and mindful
- 32:14and so present. It's incredible.
- 32:17Yeah. It's really beautiful.
- 32:19Thank you so much. And I my last question real
- 32:22quick, and I know other people have questions, so I wanna shut
- 32:25up. But my question is, do you find
- 32:28that a lot of the folks that end up going towards Buddhism and
- 32:33meditation are people that have gone through trauma or adverse
- 32:37childhood trauma? Because it seems like that's
- 32:42that's what I'm finding. So I'm just curious if that's
- 32:45your experience. I, I would notice two groups
- 32:49that's like a bell curve at one end, are people that hardly
- 32:53function. They're the trauma group.
- 32:55They're the people who have difficulty.
- 32:57They're the people who can't get into the game of life as our
- 33:01culture defines it. And really the motivation there
- 33:04is I'm gonna solve these problems, then I'm gonna get
- 33:06into the game. At the other end of the bell
- 33:09curve are the people that win at the game all the time.
- 33:12It's really simple for them and it doesn't provide any meaning
- 33:15to them. And they're, they, they get all
- 33:17of the goals that are offered and they, and then they're still
- 33:20bereft of meaning. And that's the other group who
- 33:24comes. And they, they, they're really
- 33:26both have the same problem, which is they're primarily
- 33:30focused on secondary exploration and not on primary exploration.
- 33:35So they're not getting enough meaning in the, the, the Super
- 33:39succeeding group. Their problem is that the things
- 33:41that really matter to them have no cultural value, so they don't
- 33:44allow themselves to pursue them. And so they're bereft of
- 33:48meaning. Whereas the other group wants to
- 33:51get good enough to compete. And it's hard to convince them
- 33:55that that there's no point in that competition.
- 33:58It's not where meeting is, but they they want their chance at
- 34:02the going for the gold ring. Once you get the gold ring, of
- 34:07course you see that it's actually plated.
- 34:15Thank you so much. You're Jen.
- 34:17Take good care. Stay well.
- 34:19Thanks sincere. Josh, could you hear me?
- 34:30Yes. Yes, I'm sorry, the camera is
- 34:34off because I'm standing in the dark so I hope this is OK.
- 34:39OK. Yeah, I'm sorry.
- 34:43The question is, I, I was very interesting also in on your talk
- 34:48about attachment theory. And my question is, is there a
- 34:53possibility of healing insecure attachment through this kind of
- 35:01meditation you you offered before SO or at least support
- 35:08your healing to become more being secure, secured, attached?
- 35:17So I think that we're in this unique time in human history
- 35:21where there are now actually effective means of changing your
- 35:25native attachment strategy from insecure disorganized into
- 35:29earned security. I don't think that there was
- 35:32much that was that worked before now and that the process of
- 35:37doing that is about really takes two or three years of focus in
- 35:43order to do it. And it's a combination of
- 35:47working with the ideal parent figure protocol, which was
- 35:50developed by Dan Brown and his group, the mentalizing and
- 35:54emotional Regulation strategies at Medigroup.
- 35:57We're using meditation based training for that and then a
- 36:02psychoeducation around collaborative relationship
- 36:05systems. If you grow up in an insecure,
- 36:07disorganized family system, you don't really understand the
- 36:11dynamics of secure functioning, so you have to learn those.
- 36:14If you do all three of those, then I do think that you can
- 36:19change your attachment strategy. So if you're using me as an
- 36:24example, I had 28 years of psychotherapy with really good
- 36:28people, and it was really useful to me.
- 36:31But my complexly disorganized attachment strategy was
- 36:35completely unfazed by that and remained in the chaotic way that
- 36:40it always was. And 2 1/2 years of doing this
- 36:44work, I earned security. And I can tell you that I did it
- 36:48at 65. It's totally worth doing.
- 36:52I mean, it makes everything so much easier that you should do
- 36:58it at any time. But boy, would I have liked to
- 37:00have done it at 20. Yeah.
- 37:04Yeah. Oh yes, you're you're.
- 37:07You're so. Right.
- 37:09And the meditation you were you were doing before it, it was
- 37:14this kind of meditation to support also to support you on
- 37:20your way. Yes, it's this one is that
- 37:23meditation that I offered as part of a sequence of
- 37:26meditations investigating self generated emotions.
- 37:29Stopping afflictive self generated emotion and
- 37:31quantumizing the pool of poison and pain are the suite for
- 37:35developing mentalization and emotional regulation.
- 37:40The reason that that piece is so important is that if you can't
- 37:44regulate your emotions when you go out to explore, then you,
- 37:47you, you have to limit your exploration.
- 37:51You can't really regulate yourself at all without being in
- 37:53direct proximity to somebody who regulates you.
- 37:57Then you don't have exploration 'cause you can't do it.
- 38:00And then you have a, a life that really is bereft of enough
- 38:05meaning to make it seem worthwhile.
- 38:08It's, that's my experience, most people.
- 38:12So yes, you could do it. And it takes about, you should
- 38:17think two to three years of regular work to get it to
- 38:19happen. And then it does.
- 38:22And it's, it's exponential in a way, you know, like to say you
- 38:29do these rickety meditations that put these little sort of
- 38:32modelings in there. And because we use that
- 38:38perceptual database to create conceptual reality, it doesn't
- 38:42matter whether you've visualized it as part of the meditation
- 38:46practice. If you use that as the source
- 38:50for creating reality, admittedly it it's flimsy, but then you've
- 38:54created this reality and you act in that reality and then that
- 38:58reality is remembered and that's an actual experience.
- 39:01And over time, as you build up more and more of these actual
- 39:05experiences that are based on these visualization meditations,
- 39:10the, the secure response to the present moment becomes more and
- 39:14more robust until you're just always in this process of
- 39:18responding in a secure way. You still have your native
- 39:23brain, but you've you've adapted it so that it can function
- 39:28securely. OK.
- 39:30So this was very helpful and you were very authentic.
- 39:34So you were talking about your own history.
- 39:37This was very helpful. Thank you.
- 39:40Oh good. Yeah, it's imagine the infant
- 39:46that just cries out to the world for care, and there's a
- 39:51sensitively attuned person there that responds with the care.
- 39:55And so you learn that all I have to do is cry out to the world
- 39:58for the care that I needed in the world.
- 39:59We'll deliver it. Imagine walking around like
- 40:03that. That's security.
- 40:07Hello. Thank you a lot.
- 40:17Wendell Oh, I'm sorry, Vic. It's OK, Wendell's in the queue.
- 40:27I, I'm totally confused. I, I've been working really
- 40:36hard. I and I don't even know, it's
- 40:39sort of counterintuitive to even phrase it that way on the idea
- 40:43of no self and, and at the same time sort of that that's sort of
- 40:51my Buddhist trajectory. And then I have been very much
- 40:57involved with a number of modalities of, of psychotherapy.
- 41:02And, and I'm for me there, there, there's, there's, there's
- 41:10sort of a synergy, but, but there's also kind of a
- 41:13contradiction. It seems very paradoxical.
- 41:16And I feel like the key to freedom is through the no self
- 41:24root and not through therapy, even though I, I, I'm a little
- 41:28bit like you, what you just said that I feel like I've spent most
- 41:34of my life trying to, you know, find secure attachment, et
- 41:39cetera, et cetera, et cetera, with all kinds of modalities of
- 41:43therapy. And, and while I feel that I'm,
- 41:47you know, functional, it's, it's, it's very much, it's, it's
- 41:51been a huge time sink. So I relate to what you said and
- 41:56that's why I feel like the, the Buddhist path to me seems, seems
- 41:59sort of clear of, of those. Well, I don't know, I'm, I'm
- 42:04speaking very inarticulately. You can tell I'm confused.
- 42:06So if you could just speak a little bit to the idea of no
- 42:09self and, and, and sort of those 3 principles in Buddhism, how
- 42:17you feel they relate to the work that you're doing and, and, and
- 42:21the more traditional, you know, sort of psychology world.
- 42:26So in, you know, one of the things that when you look at
- 42:30different paths in the Buddhist world, they they come with
- 42:36different sets of kinds of meditation that you do.
- 42:39And depending on what kind of meditation you do, they produce
- 42:43particular responses. So when you're working in the
- 42:45Theravada world, no self is actually one of the goals of the
- 42:49practice. And so you do the techniques
- 42:51that produce the experience of no self.
- 42:54But the idea is not so much to to withdraw entirely into the
- 42:58experience of no self as a way of avoiding the engagement in in
- 43:03the world and in other people. The the idea there is that if I
- 43:09simply withdraw from all of that, I won't have the pain of
- 43:12the experience of it, which is which is true.
- 43:18You also don't have the engagement of it and you're
- 43:21gonna lose it either way because everything is impermanent.
- 43:25So you're not actually saving yourself from the loss because
- 43:28you're gonna have that anyway. But you save yourself from the
- 43:32engagement, which is where the richness and the meaning comes
- 43:35from, so that it can create a, a, an experience of requiring
- 43:40more and more time in the no self to avoid the painfulness of
- 43:44the fully manifests manifested sense of self.
- 43:49So what I would say the real freedom is, is to be able to
- 43:52come and go from the self experience, the manifest, a
- 43:56brilliant sense of self when you need it and then just not care
- 44:00about it and drop it the second you don't need it anymore and
- 44:04come back into the no self experience.
- 44:06And that, that is actually the, the, the, the sense of
- 44:09liberation that just the flow back and forth from that, then
- 44:15you're going to be examining the, the, the nature of the way
- 44:20that you create conceptual reality.
- 44:22And when you really begin to get into that, it is so pernicious
- 44:26how those early conditionings where all of those working
- 44:30models of self and world are, are, are based, how pernicious
- 44:35they are in creating the perception of the world in a
- 44:38particular way. And when you do the attachment
- 44:41work, it changes the way that you create the experience of
- 44:45self and world to where you're not expecting rejection, you're
- 44:50not expecting harm. You're expecting people to
- 44:52delight in you and be welcoming and interested.
- 44:56And it changes everything in that that way.
- 45:00And so that's that's what I would say about that.
- 45:03Yes, I the the no self experience if I could just never
- 45:06have to manifest the self again. But then how would you make
- 45:10dinner? Well, I'm, I'm in the performing
- 45:17arts and that's why me it's a kind of conundrum.
- 45:20It's but where where I've found the the sort of the sweet spot
- 45:26is in what what is popularly called the flow.
- 45:30So it, it is a no self experience where it's no longer
- 45:36I, I, I'm, I'm just a like a transparent vessel through which
- 45:39this, this experience is passing.
- 45:42And, and that's actually the ideal.
- 45:45That's why I find the no self idea appealing.
- 45:49And well, anyway, they're that we're running out of time, but I
- 45:52hope to have an opportunity to talk to you further at some
- 45:55point. Thank you.
- 45:56Thank you. That went down.
- 46:11Hey, George, what's up? How are you?
- 46:13I'm well, thanks. How are you?
- 46:15I'm glad. We've got about two minutes
- 46:17here, so I'm going to hone in on it.
- 46:20OK. You said you had 28 years of
- 46:22psychotherapy, but that made little dent in your disorganized
- 46:27attachment style. That didn't pay.
- 46:30Is it at all? What was what did phase it?
- 46:33What was the adjustment? What was the click?
- 46:36If we were talking about food, I'd say what ingredient did you
- 46:39have to add to the recipe to make it good or proper?
- 46:48The three pillar approach which is the IPF ideal parent figure
- 46:54protocol, meditation to remap the original attachment
- 46:57conditioning, the mentalization and emotional regulation
- 47:01strategy that fosters exploration for primary meaning,
- 47:06and the psychoeducation of how relationships are supposed to
- 47:10work. You need to do all three of them
- 47:12to get it to change. How long?
- 47:17That's a Western question. How long does it take?
- 47:19So I'll say Shinzen would answer that question whenever anybody
- 47:26asks it with five years, but I am saying it takes between two
- 47:31and three years to do it if you do it consistently.
- 47:37All groups of people who come in do it pretty well, except for
- 47:40one group of preoccupied people. So angrily preoccupied people
- 47:46have a tendency to have a hard time completing it.
- 47:53But for most people, you come in and you just go through the
- 47:55process of doing, you know, it's like it's not harder than
- 48:00sitting the meditations you've already been sitting.
- 48:03You just have to sit them over a period of time until it it
- 48:07begins to change. And what you notice happening,
- 48:09which I think is the one of the remarkable things is the self
- 48:13experience doesn't change that much.
- 48:15It's just the way that you make the world that changes the most.
- 48:19So all of a sudden you don't see a rejected world, You see an
- 48:22inviting world. All of a sudden you you don't
- 48:26see a criticizing person, you see a delighting person.
- 48:29It's those are the ways that it changes.
- 48:32And so your experience is just different, but it's not a
- 48:37conscious cognitive process. It's an unconscious process that
- 48:42that changes it. If you think that the the self
- 48:51experience is who you are, you've missed the Wendell Ness
- 48:55of the whole body mind experience.
- 48:57Underneath that. I really think of the self
- 49:00experience as the witness to the George Ness or the Wendell Ness
- 49:06and. That there is a windowness here
- 49:09and I do realize that the window has had a vast amount of life
- 49:12experiences and I do realize that the lens that I have or
- 49:18filter. If you prefer.
- 49:19Has been quite clogged and the unclogging process, as we could
- 49:26say, has left me standing in that place you mentioned, which
- 49:34is either despair and or searching for meaning still.
- 49:40And since I'm not really willing to drag out the razor blades, on
- 49:44we go with our magnifying glass and say what's next?
- 49:47I like the beard. Huh.
- 49:50I like the beard. Thank you.
- 49:53So I'm just trying to, you know, keep the meaning going here and
- 49:57I can thoroughly identify it's the show's not over until the
- 50:00show is over. So I'm looking for and it.
- 50:03Might not be over, we don't know.
- 50:06Yeah, I'm just looking for the link.
- 50:09I'm looking for the adoption. I'm looking for the recipe to
- 50:13get over. The it's a.
- 50:23It's a very close examination of the perceptual database that you
- 50:26use to create reality, and to add to it different versions of
- 50:34experience that you can use to create reality.
- 50:37The mind doesn't care whether you can imagine it or whether it
- 50:40actually happens to you. It can use either to develop the
- 50:44experience of meaning that you're having.
- 50:47A lot of us limit our imaginations and you'll notice
- 50:52this if you attempt to imagine exploring for meaning.
- 50:56We limit our imagination and what we think is possible for us
- 51:00because of the conditioning of early childhood prevented us
- 51:03from having most of the things that we want.
- 51:05So that when the opportunity arises in the present moment to
- 51:09take the thing that we want and we have convinced ourselves that
- 51:13actually we're not entitled to it or we can't have it, we don't
- 51:16take it even though it would be there for us if we could see the
- 51:21an experience the world differently than we do.
- 51:25And that's what this investigation is, to really get
- 51:28in there and see where these limits are.
- 51:31If you've never been treated well, you might not imagine that
- 51:35you can be treated well. And so you accept people not
- 51:39treating you well. Whereas if you change that to
- 51:42where your expectation is that you'll be treated well, then
- 51:44when people don't treat you well, you reject it because it's
- 51:47not what you want. But the choice between being
- 51:50alone and being mistreated is what often people experience.
- 51:54And so they take the mistreatment so that they don't
- 51:57have to be alone. And those are the kinds of knots
- 52:02that we want to be able to examine and to release so that
- 52:05you you have this expectation that people should care about
- 52:09you, should love you, should delight in you, and should take
- 52:12care of you in a good way. And that when they don't, you
- 52:16don't accept it. A lot of people who have trauma
- 52:20and difficulty in life have a a pain tolerance that's way too
- 52:23high. And so we need to lower that so
- 52:27that you object earlier to things that don't go well.
- 52:31A lot of people who had cruel childhood experiences over and
- 52:37over again weep if you're kind to them in the most mundane way
- 52:45because it's to them. Kindness is this rarity that you
- 52:49almost never experience and that needs to be adjusted.
- 52:53So kindness is like air, it's like water.
- 52:57It's just expected to be included in the package so that
- 53:01you don't accept cruel people because it's not how you imagine
- 53:06the world to be. But when we imagine the world is
- 53:08this cold, cruel place where nobody is kind to us, when
- 53:16people aren't kind to us, we accept it as a matter of the way
- 53:19that it is, the matter of of reality, not understanding that
- 53:24we've created that reality, not that that's what the reality is,
- 53:31that making sense. So that's what this
- 53:34investigation is, to see all of those ways in which we create
- 53:39that experience so that we can get rid of them.
- 53:43As the Buddha said, there are 5 levels of suppression of this
- 53:47stuff. The 1st is simply a thought
- 53:49replacement, the 4th is to yell louder the beneficial thought
- 53:56than the afflictive thought, and the 5th level is to annihilate
- 54:00at any cost. The afflictive thought is the
- 54:03last I really liked. Yes.
- 54:12We're. Gonna have to close George.
- 54:14Oh, OK, sorry to interrupt. So thank you for coming Ioffer
- 54:21the teaching freely, but it is a Donna based approach that we
- 54:25have here. So please consider making a
- 54:27donation and if you're interested in some of the
- 54:29programs that we have or some of this stuff and if you're in
- 54:31Europe and want to come to a a short retreat where we'll really
- 54:35go into this stuff the the oh track retreat is open.
- 54:39I think the Poland retreat is sold out, but I haven't checked
- 54:42recently. Anyway, really appreciate your
- 54:46attention, good to see you.