Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul Podcast #1 - The Debate Over Age Limits on Government Officials
Transcript
- 0:01What's going on, everybody, and welcome to the first episode of the politics with Paul podcast
- 0:07with your host That's me, Paul Rater, non partisan political analyst, aesthetically the
- 0:12second episode because I had an intro to the How this whole podcast works, but in any case,
- 0:18Autumn aboard.
- 0:20And today, the first ever topic we're gonna talk about for this podcast
- 0:24is h.
- 0:27It happens to
- 0:27all of us.
- 0:28I actually am gonna be 31 this month, the well, this month as this as of this recording, August
- 0:332024.
- 0:34And, it's not not, obviously that old in the grand scheme of things, even though I joke
- 0:40about it.
- 0:41And, But when I'm talking about age, I've been more about for elected officials.
- 0:48Congress is The meeting the age of congress is one of the oldest it's ever been.
- 0:53And when it comes to the presidential election, we have Donald Trump, who's in his seventies,
- 0:58Biden just dropped out, but he's also in his seventies approaching 80, and with other events
- 1:06like Mitch McConnell freezing up a couple of times during a press conference and Diane
- 1:11Feinstein who recently passed Her mental and physical capabilities also deteriorating
- 1:18towards the end of her life, but she was still in Congress.
- 1:21It's renewed a lot of calls from people to institute a maximum age limit on our elected
- 1:29officials or at least for Congress.
- 1:33And with how many people call for it, it might seem like it's a, very widespread amount of
- 1:40support for it saying, well, However, many people, there's a lot of people it might seem
- 1:45like supported, but it's not a super cut and dry documents like you may think it is.
- 1:52It's not cut and dry, and not everybody agrees on having an age limit.
- 1:56And even if they did, what would that age limit look like?
- 2:00And another, particular development, I am referring to specifically for this is in North
- 2:09Kota, in June 2024, the letters of North Dakota passed a, constitutional amendment to their
- 2:19state constitution.
- 2:21And I'm not gonna read the whole Amendment, obviously, but to read I.
- 2:28Alopaedias.
- 2:29Alright.
- 2:31Summary of that measure, I'll look at it right here on the website.
- 2:36I'll be an an incredible resource.
- 2:37I used to work for them.
- 2:38Obviously, I don't speak for them.
- 2:41Here, but they always have a lot of great content, especially when it comes to ballot
- 2:45measures.
- 2:46So a yes vote supported preventing an individual from being elected or a point to
- 2:51serve in the United States Senate or United States House of Representatives if the
- 2:55individual would become eighty one years old by December 31st the year preceding the end of
- 3:00their term.
- 3:01They supported that.
- 3:02So now that is going to come into effect for the I don't I don't think it's for 2024.
- 3:09I'm not entirely sure.
- 3:09But in any case, That's the 1st, amendments or 1st month of its time that's been instituted
- 3:18for the federal level.
- 3:19At least, we actually do have page limits on on our on on state level judges, which I will get
- 3:31to shortly.
- 3:32But I also read about this on my medium a blog sometime last year as of
- 3:40well, before it was Donald Trump versus Joe Biden, and we had the aforementioned issues
- 3:48with McConnell and Feinstein for Joe Burrows parties, Well, we we what we do see already is
- 3:55we have a minimum age limit for our well, for some elected officials, state level officials,
- 4:02some of them have minimum ages where you've gotta be 20 or 21 or whatever the case may be.
- 4:09But for the federal level, the US constitution just says that representatives have to be at
- 4:15least twenty five years of age or older have lived in the US have been a natural assistant
- 4:20for 7 straight years.
- 4:23US Senate have to be thirty years old and have lived in the US for 9 straight years.
- 4:29And for and for president, yes, for presidents had to be thirty five years old, 14 years
- 4:38naturalized citizen, and you have to have been born in the US.
- 4:41You don't have to have been born in the US for US Senate or US house.
- 4:45Now.
- 4:47Of course, a lot of our elective pixels are way above that.
- 4:52That's not obviously we're not obviously talking about the minimum age limit.
- 4:55We're talking about the maximum age limit or whether there could be one, which, of course,
- 5:00right now, there's not except for now, North Dakota has 1.
- 5:04But what we do see, leach limits in is the state level judges.
- 5:10A lot of state Supreme courts and state intermediate appellate courts have maximum age
- 5:16limits.
- 5:17They usually are about 70, 75.
- 5:20There's something that a little bit more specific like 72 or 73.
- 5:25And I believe it's for months that has 90 years old for their state level judges.
- 5:31And
- 5:33some states don't don't have a maximum age limit, and some of them have a little bit more
- 5:41nuance to their exact age limit.
- 5:45It's not necessarily you hit 75.
- 5:47That's it either they get out of here.
- 5:50In Kansas, I believe it is.
- 5:53You can serve out the remainder of
- 5:56the term as a state judge yeah,
- 6:03I believe it's you who can serve out the remainder of your term as a state level judge.
- 6:09When you'd hit that mandatory retirement age, it's what they call mandatory retirement age
- 6:13for state judges.
- 6:14And as soon as you hit Whatever it is there, 70 or 75, you can finish out the rest of that
- 6:21year.
- 6:22And but then after that, you can't serve another term.
- 6:25I believe that's Kansas.
- 6:27There is at least one state that is like that.
- 6:31Now We also see arguments for term limits which have some level of, similarities.
- 6:39Term limits tend to and to be more applicable to people who are older, elected officials, So
- 6:48there is some similarity to those arguments, but we'll keep away from the term, from the
- 6:55term limits argument.
- 6:56So today, at least, I'll be an argument for another day.
- 6:59Maybe we'll have another
- 7:00episode that, but
- 7:05For besides state level judges, we don't really see maximum age limits.
- 7:13You might might see it for some local level or, excuse me, for some local level officials
- 7:19depends on local laws, local charters, they might have something like that.
- 7:24But overall, though, you don't really see
- 7:27it a whole lot for state level and or federal evidence.
- 7:32You don't see it at all at the federal level and especially with federal judges who have at
- 7:38least the article 3 judges, which is like or for example, that's Supreme Court.
- 7:44We do not see or because they have lifetime terms, we don't have maximum wage limits for
- 7:51them.
- 7:53So let's get into the actual debate about age limits, whether we should actually have them.
- 8:01Or should we see if it the way it is?
- 8:04Again, I am not here to tell you whether we could or shouldn't have them.
- 8:08That's for you to decide.
- 8:09And I'm just going to speak from what people who support having a maximum age threshold
- 8:17would say, and those who don't support it, what they would say.
- 8:22So from the prior age limits side, you're gonna have a lot of people say, Well, if we have
- 8:27younger, officials, they're more energetic.
- 8:31We'll have fresher ideas, and especially for such a grueling job, they need that energy and
- 8:39fresh ideas.
- 8:40And older people, they've had their time, and now it's time for them to go.
- 8:45Also, for older people there, naturally, they're more likely to die.
- 8:49That's just how things work.
- 8:52That's just how life works.
- 8:53And thus you'll need or you're more likely to need special elections for them.
- 8:59And they're, therefore, those cost money.
- 9:02It does everything cost money.
- 9:04You have to actually have election administrators set up those special elections,
- 9:10then people need to actually come out to those special elections.
- 9:14Now now, obviously, that's not to say that Older peep, while passing away are the only
- 9:21reasons for special elections.
- 9:22Some people resign.
- 9:24Younger people can follow that too, but you'll, you know, generally have a lot where you'll
- 9:28have to account for that fact with older people who decided not to retire from office.
- 9:36And then others that support age limits would also say it's better for democracy because it
- 9:41mitigates entrenchment from these long standing, public officials because older people
- 9:48tend to be longer tenured in office and therefore, They've accumulated more power at
- 9:53their disposal, and it's easier for them to stay in power.
- 9:57They have a lot more resources.
- 9:58They have the incumbency advantage.
- 10:02Again, that's just what those who support having.
- 10:06The maximum age limit would say, so you can take it or leave it.
- 10:09But on the visit side, people who would
- 10:12oppose these age limits, some of
- 10:15the arguments you might see are that older people are more seasoned.
- 10:20They've had more experience with tackling the issues that face us, and you need that
- 10:26experience.
- 10:27And also people age differently.
- 10:29So for somebody who is too old, another person that might not be too old.
- 10:36I mean, you've you've seen a lot of eighty year olds or seventy year olds that are they seem
- 10:41like they have a lot of trouble getting around or keeping up with things.
- 10:44And then others are sharp as a deck.
- 10:45They can they can get around.
- 10:47They could play several rounds of pickleball, and you know, that's a police sign.
- 10:53And then they would also say people who are against age limits would also say that it
- 10:58hammers democracy because it's ages.
- 11:00So it's a type of bigotry, laced in their eyes, and it goes against the wishes of people who
- 11:06want to keep those older officials in office.
- 11:08They'll say who's to say that They're too entrenched.
- 11:11That's for the people to decide.
- 11:15What should these sizes right?
- 11:18Back then.
- 11:19It's up to you to decide.
- 11:22But let's go ahead and just get past that and say let's have let's have age limits.
- 11:28If we were to, argue if we were to agree that, okay, we need an age limit.
- 11:35What are the things we need to account for?
- 11:37Because it's all well and good to say we need age limits.
- 11:40We need term limits.
- 11:41We need x, y, and z, but what exactly does that look like?
- 11:45It's very easy to say we need something or that's, something that is a certain thing that
- 11:53needs to change, but how exactly to make that change happen?
- 11:58Not necessarily agreement on what that looks like.
- 12:02So some of the things that we
- 12:04need to account for, not necessarily a comprehensive list, is, like with anything that
- 12:10politicians do, we need to consider
- 12:12political incentives.
- 12:15What what exactly is in
- 12:17it for politicians if they were to support age limits?
- 12:23It might sound, again, might sound like a lot of people support having an age limit on our
- 12:30elected officials And even if
- 12:33that's the case, do they necessarily care a
- 12:36lot about it where, yes, they had the said civil governance supported that would actually
- 12:42change somebody's vote.
- 12:44So if I were to say, if I'm a voter and I'm someone who is I really care a lot about having
- 12:51our officials be young and spry and and energetic and fresh and all that.
- 12:58But I've got candidates a and b to choose between is my vote necessarily gonna be swung
- 13:05by Let those candidates believe about age limits.
- 13:10For most voters, that's not really going to happen.
- 13:14Yeah.
- 13:14They might somebody might be very gung ho and say, we need to
- 13:17have, a major limit of 75, for example.
- 13:24And candidate a supports that candidate b does not support that.
- 13:29But candidate b has a whole lot of other few points that I agree with.
- 13:35So am I going to just change my vote to candidate a because of what they think about
- 13:41age limits?
- 13:42There might be a few people that do that, but that's not necessarily gonna happen for a lot
- 13:47of voters.
- 13:48And also, if we were to have a maximum age limit for our elected officials, are we
- 13:59Would those officials be grandfathered in?
- 14:03Whereas, let's say the official is 75 as well, and the age limit would be 70.
- 14:10So that age limit would apply to that congress person.
- 14:16There's not really an incentive for that congress person to support that because that
- 14:20means they can't run for office again.
- 14:22Unless they were planning on retiring, then It's kind of a moot point, but if they're not
- 14:26planning on retiring, then how do you get them to support having nature limit?
- 14:33They might have to have them grandfathered in when they or as they say, anybody who was
- 14:38serving before, the 2024 election is is exempt from these rules where if you are seventy and
- 14:48you are already serving an office by the 2024 election, This seventy year age limit does not
- 14:54apply to you, for example.
- 14:57Then you might be able to Get these politicians to support an age limit.
- 15:04Still, that's not necessarily the case.
- 15:06So all these political incentives always have to be considered.
- 15:11It's a similar thing with term limits.
- 15:12It's a very easy, sexy thing to say, oh, yeah.
- 15:15I support term limits.
- 15:16Everybody want no no politician wants to look like they're super entrenched, in office, not
- 15:22not to say that everybody agrees with having term limits, but it's a it's sort of a similar
- 15:28concept.
- 15:29Do we all support having or or
- 15:35if you have somebody that supports term limits, it's kinda easy to say that you support that.
- 15:39But if you don't Are they necessarily going to do anything at office to make that a reality
- 15:45where they try to put forth legislation or even a constitutional amendment they try to propose
- 15:50to say, this is what we're going to or we need to have,
- 15:54I don't know, four terms maximum or 3 years max or 3 times maximum, something like that.
- 16:02It's a sort of a similar concept.
- 16:05It's easy to say that she used to put this kind of thing.
- 16:08Or are you actually going to take the steps to do that?
- 16:10You need to be incentivized to do that because we naturally humans act on incentives.
- 16:17That's not necessarily a bad thing.
- 16:18It's just how our psychology works.
- 16:20So with politics, it's something that you need to account for even more so.
- 16:26Also, we've talked about it a little bit already.
- 16:29What exactly?
- 16:30Right.
- 16:31Maximum age.
- 16:32Is it 70.
- 16:35Is it 75?
- 16:37Is it 80?
- 16:38We see at the state levels for state level judges We have a,
- 16:46people have different opinions on or different states have different maximum age limits for
- 16:55their state level judges.
- 16:56They're 70 in some states 75 and others, 72, 73, 90 in Vermont.
- 17:02So what is the correct age limit for that's the correct age limit for members of Congress.
- 17:14Is the right maximum age?
- 17:16I feel for other offices.
- 17:17So do we have it as 70 per congress and an 75 for president.
- 17:22And then if it,
- 17:24if we were extended to Supreme Court judges, of course, that would take a lot more Oh, yeah.
- 17:31There'll be a lot more changes needed there because those are lifetime appointments, but
- 17:37Would those also be 75 or 70?
- 17:40You need to think about whether these are gonna be the same age limits.
- 17:45For across the board, or is it only for office type a is 70 Office type B of 75, Office type
- 17:55Cs is 80.
- 17:57Those are also things that you need to account for.
- 18:00And then there's lots
- 18:01of items on the political agenda, and that kinda goes back to the whole, concept of,
- 18:06considering clerical incentives.
- 18:10There's a myriad of things that are politicians or that are elected officials need to You look
- 18:21to work on to legislate.
- 18:24There's
- 18:24all sorts of healthcare issues, the economy, education,
- 18:32the myriad of different things to accounts for.
- 18:36So where does adding age limits come into play?
- 18:42Even if a lot of
- 18:44like, officials, both Republican and Democrat, even though a lot of them did agree that, hey.
- 18:49We need to have a threshold where as soon as Alex official hits this number they need to
- 18:55leave office.
- 18:57Okay.
- 18:57That's well and good, but do they Or where exactly does that fit on the agenda?
- 19:04They might not even have time to get to that because there's all these other pressing issues
- 19:09that they have to get to.
- 19:12And then if Congress doesn't do it through a law, or state constitution or when states vote
- 19:20on their own state constitutional amendments, not US Constitution amendments, obviously.
- 19:27If that is not going to work, do we then start looking at the process of an amendment with a
- 19:34US constitution.
- 19:35And then that's a whole another can of worms that,
- 19:39you're opening up there.
- 19:41It's a
- 19:42very complex situation, and a lot of times, like with a lot of,
- 19:48policy debates.
- 19:49There's tendency for people, especially when they have a very, I'm sorry.
- 19:57Especially when they have a
- 20:00very strong opinion on a policy.
- 20:04They tend
- 20:05to think that it's a very neat solution, a very straightforward solution that they can that
- 20:13they can enact to make something happen.
- 20:15And rarely is that ever the case for such a big policy, especially something like this.
- 20:22So always keep that in mind whenever there's a debate happening about these kinds of policies,
- 20:27it tends to be a lot more complex than people who are very invested in it.
- 20:35Take it out to be.
- 20:37But is there and also
- 20:40Now if we take a step back and we don't look sorry.
- 20:44Let me I'm trying to
- 20:45think of how to phrase this.
- 20:50If our issue is if the whole reason we want let's look at the whole reason we would even
- 20:57want age limits.
- 20:58If if we're, again, assuming that we agree at age limits are needed for Congress.
- 21:07Is there a different way to address that ultimate concerns?
- 21:09The ultimate concern is ostensibly that A lot of politicians are just not up to the task
- 21:17physically and or mentally.
- 21:20That's the whole basis, but it's not really Well, there might be some people who want to
- 21:26enact an age limit on congress or presidents or or Supreme Court just just because.
- 21:34But generally speaking, the reason that they're moving that is because they're the concern
- 21:39about the mental and physical fitness All these elected officials
- 21:43are in the case of Supreme Court, these alleged officials.
- 21:48So if we take a step back, And look at it that way where we say, okay, a lack of mental and
- 21:55physical capacity is the concern here.
- 21:57Will we address that in a different way?
- 21:59Apart from wage limits, do we have written tests?
- 22:04Do we have exercises.
- 22:06Can they play multiple rounds of football outside, in enough times where we can say,
- 22:14Okay.
- 22:14This person is physically fit.
- 22:16If they ask this test with I don't know.
- 22:20If they get 8% of these questions on a test, correct, Did we say that they're mentally fit?
- 22:27Okay.
- 22:28Now that's that's great.
- 22:29Okay.
- 22:30We we can say if we start thinking about it that way.
- 22:34But then we look at, what was in ministering these tests?
- 22:40There's there's probably gonna be people who administer these tests that have a vested
- 22:44interest in Making some people succeed versus others not succeeding.
- 22:50What if somebody if we have 2 different people look at politician a, elected official a, and
- 22:58they play.
- 22:59And they they they do whatever physical and mental exercises.
- 23:03Person or the eValuator a says that they are, but they're good
- 23:10to go, that they've clearly demonstrated They are mentally and physically fit.
- 23:14But what if person number 2 says, no, that wasn't enough.
- 23:17They need to do more to demonstrate that.
- 23:21So how do you go about that?
- 23:24See, there's all these layers to this issue that need to be accounted for, even if we agree
- 23:32that it's an issue or we agree we need a policy on Having an age limit, how exactly do you
- 23:39enact it?
- 23:40Is there another way to go about it?
- 23:42What exactly is considered fair?
- 23:46All sorts of these kinds of things
- 23:49need to be looked at.
- 23:51Or we talk we talked a little bit about before, and I don't wanna go to into it too much
- 23:55because it is a whole other area to look into.
- 23:59But Would term limits be
- 24:03a better option.
- 24:04Older politicians have been in office for a longer period of time.
- 24:07So then Would we want to say, okay.
- 24:10Now we need term limits.
- 24:11And then what would the term limits look like?
- 24:13There's new basic kinds of those.
- 24:16Again, don't wanna delve too much into it for this episode, but we typically see either a
- 24:22consecutive unlimited or, b, cumulative term limits.
- 24:26Insecutive term limits, you serve let's say the limit is 8 years you go 8 years in whatever
- 24:34office it is, and then you have to sit out for at least a term, then you can come back and
- 24:41price her another 8 years, obviously, as long as you keep getting elected.
- 24:45With cumulative, It's a lifetime thing.
- 24:48So if it's a lifetime of 8 years straight or poor terms or whatever the case may be, you
- 24:54serve that and that's it.
- 24:56You can't serve any longer in that office.
- 24:59I wanna say Oklahoma's state legislature, does that.
- 25:03I can't remember off the top of my head, but there are several state legislatures that do
- 25:09that and also do it for their state executives where You would serve that limit and then you
- 25:14can't ever serve in that office again.
- 25:15There might be another office you can serve in where if you'd serve humans who limit in the
- 25:20state house, you might be able to go to the state Senate, and then you might be able to do
- 25:24it
- 25:24as governor and then as attorney general, or whatever the case may be.
- 25:30But that's just a little bit of a a look into the term limits angle.
- 25:36And then some of the same arguments for term limits or at least similar arguments for term
- 25:43limits you're going to see for excuse me.
- 25:46Some of those same arguments that you we've talked about for edge limits will be made for
- 25:52and against term limits, is it better for democracy to have term limits, or is it
- 25:58hindering democracy?
- 26:00As it's an issue of politicians becoming too entrenched because they're serving a lot longer
- 26:07and they're They have an incumbency advantage and resource advantage, or is it hindering
- 26:11democracy because you're telling people that you that they can't
- 26:15vote for these people because they've been in too long.
- 26:17So, again, it's a very
- 26:21well, one person says, that this is better for democracy, is it better for a country?
- 26:25Somebody else can say Actually, this hinders democracy because of x, y, and z.
- 26:32So that's a general overview of the age limit debate.
- 26:37It may even go on longer and longer, but
- 26:39I wanted to cover the basic aspects
- 26:44of it.
- 26:44But before we go, I like to end off I say I'd like to end off
- 26:49as if there's a, crack record
- 26:52of this, but I wanna do it for all my episodes as I like to necessarily make it about
- 26:57politics, but have random questions.
- 27:00Sometimes it's and they they might
- 27:01have to deal with politics, but they couldn't have nothing to
- 27:06do with it at all.
- 27:07And so I like to end off things with a random question.
- 27:10Might be about politics.
- 27:11Might not be.
- 27:12Might have a correct answer.
- 27:14Might not.
- 27:15And, wherever you can If I have it on this on social media posts, you can, answer the
- 27:23question for yourself down there or on and our records
- 27:27is on YouTube.
- 27:28However, these posts are made about my videos.
- 27:32You answered a question you're saying with whatever answer you think is appropriate.
- 27:37So, first ever, random question of this podcast for episode 1, the random push of the day is
- 27:46because right now, Olympics are going on.
- 27:49Let's select export that you don't play.
- 27:52Would you most wanna be good at?
- 27:54Now I play basketball, a
- 27:56ton, so I'm not going to include that.
- 27:59Right.
- 28:00If I could choose another Olympic sport to actually be good at, it's one I've never played
- 28:05at all, and that would be handball because Anytime I see handball being played, it just
- 28:11looks like an incredible amount of fun and also to be able to take an object and Wifle it as
- 28:18hard as I can and would be self will do do that?
- 28:21That would be awesome.
- 28:22And handball would really provide that.
- 28:25And just just looks like incredible amounts
- 28:28of fun.
- 28:29So let me know what you think about the question and let me
- 28:32know what you think about the first ever episode of this podcast.
- 28:37So just wanna
- 28:38thank you all so much for watching and listening.
- 28:41And until next time, You all.
- 28:45Take care.