Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Early Childhood Education
Transcript
- 0:04[♪♪]
- 0:11GOOD EVENING.
- 0:11WELCOME TO KENTUCKY TONIGHT.
- 0:12I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 0:13THANKS FOR JOINING US.
- 0:15OUR TOPIC TONIGHT: EARLY
- 0:16CHILDHOOD EDUCATION.
- 0:18KENTUCKY'S FRAGILE CHILDCARE
- 0:20SYSTEM WAS AT RISK OF COLLAPSE
- 0:23BEFORE THE COVID PANDEMIC
- 0:24WORSENED STAFFING AND WORKFORCE
- 0:26DEMANDS.
- 0:27FEDERAL PANDEMIC-ERA
- 0:29STABILIZATION PAYMENTS HAVE KEPT
- 0:31THE DOORS OPEN FOR MANY
- 0:32CHILDCARE CENTERS IN KENTUCKY,
- 0:33BUT AS THEY FACE THE LOSS OF
- 0:34THAT SUPPORT LATER THIS
- 0:36FALL...MANY ARE BRACING FOR
- 0:38TUITION HIKES, WAGE CUTS AND
- 0:40CLOSURES UNLESS THE STATE STEPS
- 0:41IN.
- 0:43KENTUCKY LAWMAKERS ARE NOW
- 0:45CONSIDERING SENATE BILL 203 —
- 0:47THE HORIZONS ACT — WHICH WOULD
- 0:49SPEND 300 MILLION DOLLARS, OVER
- 0:50TWO YEARS, TO RESCUE THE CHILD
- 0:52CARE INDUSTRY IN KENTUCKY BY
- 0:53IMPROVING ACCESS, COSTS, AND
- 0:55ADDRESSING WORKFORCE ISSUES.
- 0:57AND WHAT’S THE FUTURE OF THE
- 0:59GOVERNOR’S UNIVERSAL PRE-K PLAN?
- 1:01TO DISCUSS ALL THIS, WE ARE
- 1:04JOINED BY THE SPONSOR OF THE
- 1:06HORIZONS ACT: STATE SENATOR
- 1:07DANNY CARROLL, A REPUBLICAN FROM
- 1:08BENTON, AND CHAIR OF THE SENATE
- 1:10FAMILIES AND CHILDREN COMMITTEE;
- 1:13STATE SENATOR CASSIE CHAMBERS
- 1:15ARMSTRONG, A DEMOCRAT FROM
- 1:16LOUISVILLE, AND A MEMBER OF THAT
- 1:17COMMITTEE.
- 1:19KATE SHANKS, VICE PRESIDENT OF
- 1:20PUBLIC AFFAIRS AT THE KENTUCKY
- 1:21CHAMBER OF COMMERCE;
- 1:24SARAH VANOVER, AUTHOR OF
- 1:25“AMERICA’S CHILD-CARE CRISIS:
- 1:28RETHINKING AN ESSENTIAL
- 1:28BUSINESS,” AND POLICY AND
- 1:30RESEARCH DIRECTOR FOR KENTUCKY
- 1:32YOUTH ADVOCATES;
- 1:35ANDREW MCNEILL, PRESIDENT OF
- 1:36KENTUCKY FORUM FOR RIGHTS,
- 1:38ECONOMICS, AND EDUCATION;
- 1:41AND BRIGITTE BLOM, PRESIDENT AND
- 1:43CEO OF THE PRICHARD COMMITTEE
- 1:44FOR ACADEMIC EXCELLENCE.
- 1:47SEND US YOUR QUESTIONS AND
- 1:49COMMENTS BY X — FORMERLY TWITTER
- 1:51-- AT K-Y TONIGHT K-E-T.
- 1:53SEND AN EMAIL TO K-Y TONIGHT AT
- 1:56K-E-T DOT O-R-G.
- 1:59OR USE THE WEB FORM AT K-E-T DOT
- 2:00O-R-G SLASH K-Y TONIGHT.
- 2:00OR YOU CAN CALL 1-800-494-7605.
- 2:01WELCOME TO OUR GUESTS.
- 2:09WE HAVE EGOT A FULL HOUSE
- 2:11TONIGHT BECAUSE IT IS SUCH AN
- 2:13IMPORTANT TOPIC AND A LOT OF
- 2:15STAKEHOLDER OPINIONS ABOUT THIS
- 2:16ISSUE.
- 2:17I WANT TO GO TO YOU Dr.
- 2:20VANOVER YOU HAVE A BOOK OUT A
- 2:22SEQUEL TO THE AMERICA'S
- 2:24CHILDCARE CRISIS FOR THE VIEWERS
- 2:25WHO HAVE NOT BEEN FOLLOWING THIS
- 2:27ISSUE AS MUCH AS ALL SIX OF YOU
- 2:29TONIGHT, HOW DIRE IS THE
- 2:32SITUATION?
- 2:32AND ARE CHILDCARE CENTERS IN
- 2:33KENTUCKY FACING CLOSURES LAYING
- 2:35OFF STAFF?
- 2:36WHAT DOES IT REALLY LOOK LIKE?
- 2:38>> WE WERE GIVEN A LARGE POOL OF
- 2:40MONEY DURING THE PANDEMIC TO
- 2:41KEEP OUR CHILDCARE CENTERS
- 2:43AFLOAT.
- 2:44CHILDCARE PROGRAMS HAVE ALWAYS
- 2:45BEEN FRAGILE THIS IS NOT AN
- 2:46INDUSTRY THAT MAKES MONEY.
- 2:48THE GOAL OF CHILDCARE IS TO
- 2:49BREAK EVEN SO YOU CAN PAY YOUR
- 2:51STAFF AND WORK WITH THE YOUNG
- 2:52CHILDREN.
- 2:52BUT MANY OF THEM LOSE MONEY.
- 2:54WE HAD AN INFUSION OF FEDERAL
- 2:56FUNDS DURING THE PANDEMIC
- 2:58TWO-THIRDS THAT HAVE WAS PUT
- 3:02TOWARDS STABILIZATION PAYMENTS
- 3:03THAT ALLOWED WORKERS TO INCREASE
- 3:05WAGES DUE TO THE SHARP INFLATION
- 3:08CREATED AND THEN ALSO TO HELP
- 3:10WITH FIXED BENEFITS.
- 3:11THAT MONEY IS NOW GONE.
- 3:12IT ENDED SEPTEMBER 30TH OF THIS
- 3:14PAST YEAR.
- 3:15WE HAVE A THIRD LEFT THAT HAS
- 3:17GONE TO SUPPORT PROGRAMS LIKE
- 3:18THE CHILDCARE ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
- 3:20AND OTHER MORE FLEXIBLE PROGRAMS
- 3:22THAT ENDS THIS COMING SEPTEMBER.
- 3:25WITH THOSE FUNDS GONE MANY
- 3:27CHILDCARE PROGRAMS ARE BACK TO
- 3:28THE FULL ENROLLMENT IF THEY CAN
- 3:30FIND THE STAFF.
- 3:32HOWEVER CAN ONLY CHARGE WHAT
- 3:34PARENTS CAN PAY.
- 3:35IF PARENTS DIDN'T PAY
- 3:38ASTRONOMICAL AMOUNTS THEY CANNOT
- 3:40BREAK EVEN.
- 3:41BACK TO A POINT WHERE CHILDCARE
- 3:42IS REVERTING IN TO THE WAGES
- 3:45THEY HAD BEFORE THE PANDEMIC.
- 3:46HOWEVER, RETAIL AND HOSPITALITY
- 3:48HAVE INCREASED WAGES
- 3:50DRAMATICALLY AND CHILDCARE CAN'T
- 3:52COMPETE AT $12.39 AN HOUR WHICH
- 3:54IS THE AVERAGE WAGE IN KENTUCKY.
- 3:57EVEN FOR VETERAN CHILDCARE
- 4:00PROVIDERS.
- 4:00WE'RE TRYING TO FIGURE OUT CAN
- 4:01WE KEEP OUR DOORS OPEN IF WE
- 4:03CHARGE PARENTS MORE.
- 4:04HOW MUCH CAN WE CHARGE PARENTS
- 4:06BEFORE THEY DROPOUT OF THE
- 4:07WORKFORCE?
- 4:08IF WE REVERT OUR WAGES DOWN WILL
- 4:10STAFF LEAVE?
- 4:11CAN WE KEEP ENOUGH STAFF?
- 4:13CAN NEW STAFF GET LOWER WAGES OR
- 4:16IS IT NOT WORTH IT DO I CLOSE MY
- 4:19DOORS BECAUSE I DON'T KNOW IF I
- 4:20WILL BE ABLE TO CARE FOR THE
- 4:21CHILDREN I NEED TO AND STILL BE
- 4:23ABLE TO PAY OUR BILLS.
- 4:25AND INITIALLY AT THE BEGINNING
- 4:27OF THE PANDEMIC WE HAD NATIONAL
- 4:28ESTIMATES THAT SHOWED UP TO 40%
- 4:30OF CHILDCARE PROGRAMS COULD
- 4:32CLOSE.
- 4:32KENTUCKY MADE IT THROUGH LOSING
- 4:34LESS THAN 9% OF OUR PROGRAMS
- 4:36COMPARED TO OTHER STATES WAS
- 4:37AMAZING.
- 4:38BUT NOW WE'RE BACK TO THE SAME
- 4:40POINT AGAIN AND MANY CENTERS
- 4:42HAVE TOLD US THEIR SURVEY DATA
- 4:46THAT THEY ARE BACK TO THAT POINT
- 4:48DO I LAYOFF STAFF?
- 4:49DO I REDUCE WAGES?
- 4:51DO I DOUBLE THE TUITION FOR
- 4:53FAMILIES?
- 4:54OR DO I JUST CLOSE.
- 4:56>> Renee: CHAIRMAN CARROLL THANK
- 4:57YOU FOR BEING HERE.
- 4:58DOES YOUR BILL SENATE BILL 203
- 5:01THE HORIZON'S ACT ANSWER ALL OF
- 5:03THOSE CONCERNS AND WORRIES
- 5:05COMING FROM EARLY CHILDCARE
- 5:06PROVIDERS?
- 5:06>> I THINK IT DOES, RENEE.
- 5:08TO WHAT LEVEL, IS YET TO BE
- 5:10DETERMINED.
- 5:11AND THE BILL TRIES TO ADDRESS
- 5:13ALL ASPECTS OF THIS AND TRYING
- 5:15TO GROW PROVIDERS IN DIFFERENT
- 5:16AREAS.
- 5:17AND WE HAVE A FUND IN THE
- 5:19GRANTOR IN THE BILL A GRANT FOR
- 5:22INNOVATIONS AND THESE ARE FOR
- 5:23NEW IDEAS IN DELIVERY.
- 5:25WE'VE SET ASIDE FUNDING FOR
- 5:27THAT.
- 5:27WE'VE SET ASIDE FUNDING FOR
- 5:29TRADITIONAL CENTERS THE FAMILY
- 5:33EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION HOMES
- 5:34GRANT FUNDING FOR THEM.
- 5:35AND WE SETUP A PROGRAM LIKE SEEK
- 5:38DOLLARS FOR K-12.
- 5:39CALLED THE FOUNDATION'S FUND.
- 5:42AND IT'S BASED ON A PER CHILD
- 5:45ALLOTMENT LOOKING AT THE
- 5:47ENROLLMENT THROUGHOUT THE STATE
- 5:49AND WHATEVER MONEY WE END UP IN
- 5:50THAT POT WE WILL DIVIDE THAT
- 5:54INTO TWO SEMIANNUAL INSTALLMENTS
- 5:56AND HOPEFULLY THAT WILL HELP THE
- 5:58CENTERS KEEP THEIR DOORS OPEN
- 6:01AND FOSTER GROWTH OF NEW
- 6:05CENTERS.
- 6:05>> Renee: AN ASSOCIATES DEGREE
- 6:07CAN BE AVAILABLE?
- 6:08>> ASSOCIATEIATES DEGREE IN
- 6:15CHANGES.
- 6:16IT WILL BE PART OF THE WORK
- 6:18READY SCHOLARSHIP I WAS EXCITED
- 6:21TO WHEN I CONTACTED Dr.
- 6:23QUARRELS HIS STAFF WAS ON THE
- 6:24BOARD FOR A MINUTE I SPOKE ON
- 6:27THE PHONE.
- 6:28THIS WILL GROW ENTREPRENEURS AND
- 6:31GIVE THE STUDENTS SKILLS TO OPEN
- 6:32UP THEIR CENTER AND OPERATE IT
- 6:34GOES FROM AHZ IN OPENING A
- 6:37CENTER, OPERATING IT.
- 6:38TEACHING ALL OF THOSE THINGS ARE
- 6:39PART OF THIS DEGREE AND WE'RE
- 6:41EXCITED ABOUT THAT.
- 6:42>> Renee: HOW DO YOU ARRIVE AT
- 6:43THE $300 MILLION NUMBER WHICH IS
- 6:46NOT ATTACHED TO THE BILL.
- 6:48>> .
- 6:48>> SWINGING FOR THE FENCE.
- 6:50THIS ISSUE IS SO IMPORTANT TO
- 6:53OUR STATE TO OUR FAMILIES TO OUR
- 6:55KIDS TO OUR ECONOMY, TO THE
- 6:56SAFETY OF OUR CHILDREN, YOU NAME
- 6:58IT, THIS IMPACTS THAT AND IT'S
- 7:01WORTH EVERY CENT OF THAT
- 7:03INVESTMENT.
- 7:04AND IT IS A GOOD NUMBER TO START
- 7:06WITH.
- 7:06AND WE WILL LEARN AS YEARS GO BY
- 7:08WHERE WE CAN BEST INVEST.
- 7:10EVERY DOLLAR THAT WE SPEND.
- 7:12BUT IT IS A START.
- 7:13AND THAT'S WHAT WE'VE GOT TO DO
- 7:15IS MAKE THAT START AND STOP
- 7:17LOOKING AT K-12.
- 7:19IT'S GOING TO BE BIRTH-12.
- 7:21>> Renee: AND PROFESSIONALIZING
- 7:24THE FIELD OF CHANGES YOU MADE
- 7:27YOUR REMARKS IN COMMITTEE YOU
- 7:30TALKED ABOUT HOW THIS IS NOT
- 7:33BABYSITTING NOT USING CHILDCARE
- 7:34OR DAYCARE, IT'S EARLY CHILDHOOD
- 7:39EDUCATION WHY IS IT SO IMPORTANT
- 7:40TO CHANGE THE LANGUAGE?
- 7:41>> WITH THOSE WORDS IT IS AN
- 7:44AFTERTHOUGHT SOMETHING THAT
- 7:45HAPPENS WHILE MOM AND DAD CAN
- 7:46WORK.
- 7:47AND NOT THINKING ABOUT THE KIDS.
- 7:49AND WE KNOW KIDS START LEARNING
- 7:50AT BIRTH.
- 7:51WE KNOW 85-90% OF THEIR BRAIN
- 7:54DEVELOPS IN THE FIRST FIVE YEARS
- 7:55OF THEIR LIFE.
- 7:56WHAT ARE WE MISSING?
- 7:58WE INVEST $7 BILLION EVERY YEAR
- 8:00OUT OF OUR GENERAL FUND TOWARDS
- 8:02EDUCATION.
- 8:03BUT, YET, WE INVEST DOLLARS FOR
- 8:06EACH CHILD IN EARLY CHILDHOOD
- 8:08EDUCATION.
- 8:09WHAT DIVIDENDS COULD THAT PAY IN
- 8:11THE CAREER THE EDUCATION AT
- 8:12CAREER OF A STUDENT BETTER
- 8:14PREPARING THEM SUCCESS IN THE
- 8:15LONG-RUN.
- 8:16THE DATA IS THERE.
- 8:18THE STACKS ARE THERE.
- 8:20STATISTICS ARE THERE TO SHOW
- 8:21IT'S WORTH THE INVESTMENT AND
- 8:22THIS HAS BEEN GOING ON FOR YEARS
- 8:24WHERE TEACHERS HAVE BEEN
- 8:25DEVELOPING THEY ARE NOT
- 8:27BABYSITTERS.
- 8:27WE HAVE SCHOLARSHIPS FOR THEM TO
- 8:29GET THEIR CDA AND GET THEIR
- 8:33DIRECTOR'S CREDENTIALS TS A
- 8:34PROFESSION AND WE'RE TREATING
- 8:35THEM THAT WAY NOW.
- 8:37AND WE'VE BEEN DOING THIS FOR
- 8:38YEARS.
- 8:40>> Renee: Mr. McNEILL YOU
- 8:40ARE NOT IN FAVOR OF THIS
- 8:42MEASURE, CORRECT?
- 8:43AND WHY?
- 8:43>> SO RENEE I WOULD LIKE TO
- 8:45START OUT BY SAYING I DON'T
- 8:48DISAGREE THAT HIGH QUALITY
- 8:50DAYCARE, HIGH QUALITY CHILDCARE
- 8:52CAN BENEFIT YOUNG CHILDREN.
- 8:55MY DAUGHTER ATTENDED TWO,
- 8:57THREE-STAR PROGRAMS PRIOR TO
- 8:59JOINING KINDERGARTEN.
- 9:00AND IT WAS A GREAT FOUNDATION
- 9:03FOR HER LEARNING.
- 9:05WHERE I DO DISAGREE IS
- 9:07COMMITTING $300 MILLION TO A
- 9:12PROGRAM THAT IS ARRIVING
- 9:14RELATIVELY LATE IN THE SESSION.
- 9:15THERE'S 20 DAYS, 20 LEGISLATIVE
- 9:18DAYS THAT REMAIN.
- 9:24AND WILL REQUIRE A SERIOUS
- 9:26COMMITMENT OF TAXPAYER
- 9:29RESOURCES.
- 9:29I APPRECIATE WHAT Dr. VANOVER
- 9:33SHARED IN TERMS HOW WE'VE
- 9:34REACHED THIS POINT IN THAT THE
- 9:38FEDERAL DOLLARS WERE PROVIDED
- 9:41DURING THE PANDEMIC EMERGENCY.
- 9:44IT WOULD BE HARD-PRESSED TO FIND
- 9:47ANY FAULT WITH THE FACT THAT
- 9:50THOSE DOLLARS WERE NECESSARY TO
- 9:52KEEP THESE CENTERS OPEN AND
- 9:54VIABLE VARIOUS SECTORS OF THE
- 9:56ECONOMY WERE BENEFITING FROM
- 9:59FEDERAL SUPPORTS GIVEN WHAT THE
- 10:02RESTRICTIONS PLACED ON
- 10:04BUSINESSES.
- 10:05THE FEDERAL PANDEMIC EMERGENCY
- 10:07OR THE STATE PANDEMIC EMERGENCY
- 10:09HAS BEEN OVER FOR ALMOST THREE
- 10:10YEARS NOW.
- 10:11THESE PAYMENTS HAVE CONTINUED.
- 10:15THESE PROVIDERS HAVE BENEFITED
- 10:16FROM THOSE PAYMENTS.
- 10:17IT'S MY UNDERSTANDING THAT IN
- 10:21PRESIDENT BIDEN'S BUILD BACK
- 10:24BETTER LEGISLATION ON THE
- 10:25FEDERAL LEVEL A CONTINUATION OF
- 10:27THESE FEDERAL PAYMENTS WERE
- 10:28CONTEMPLATED AND NOT INCLUDED.
- 10:32SO THIS DISCUSSION OF A FISCAL
- 10:34OR FUNDING CLIFF FOR THESE
- 10:37CENTERS IT'S BEEN ON THE ROADMAP
- 10:39NOW FOR SEVERAL YEARS.
- 10:44AND THERE COULD HAVE BEEN BETTER
- 10:45PLANNING AND BETTER PREPARATION
- 10:48COMING TO THE LEGISLATURE AND
- 10:50THE TAXPAYER QUITE FRANKLY AT
- 10:52THIS POINT TO ASK FOR A
- 10:54CONTINUATION OF SUPPORTS THAT
- 10:55THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT HAS
- 10:56PULLED BACK ON.
- 10:57I THINK IS A MISGUIDE ADD
- 11:00APPROACH.
- 11:01>> Renee: SENATOR CHAMBERS
- 11:03ARMSTRONG ABOUT YOUR SUPPORT YOU
- 11:04VOICED SUPPORT DURING THE
- 11:05COMMITTEE HEARING AND TELL YOU
- 11:07WHAT YOU SAID THEN?
- 11:08>> WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT CHILD
- 11:11AND EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION I
- 11:12THINK OF IT AS A MOM OF A THREE
- 11:14AND FOUR-YEAR-OLD.
- 11:15AND I KNOW FIRSTHAND THERE IS A
- 11:18SHORTAGE IN CLINTON
- 11:19ADMINISTRATION AND EARLY
- 11:20CHILDHOOD EDUCATION AND OUR
- 11:21GOVERNMENT ABSOLUTELY HAS TO ACT
- 11:22TO ADDRESS IT.
- 11:23WE DO NOT HAVE THE OPTION NOT TO
- 11:25DO SOMETHING ABOUT THIS.
- 11:26THIS IS A CRISIS.
- 11:27IT IS HERE AND WE HAVE TO ACT.
- 11:29PERSONALLY I BELIEVE THAT THE
- 11:31MOST IMPORTANT THING WE CAN DO
- 11:32IS PASS A PUBLIC UNIVERSAL PRE-K
- 11:35PROGRAM FOR FOUR-YEAR-OLDS.
- 11:37STUDIES HAVE SHOWN THAT THAT IS
- 11:38THE BEST WAY TO MAKE SURE OUR
- 11:40KIDS ARE READY FOR KINDERGARTEN
- 11:42AND THE BEST WAY TO MAKE SURE
- 11:44THAT EVERY KID ACROSS KENTUCKY
- 11:46BENEFITS EQUALLY FROM OUR
- 11:49INVESTMENTS IN EARLY CHILDHOOD
- 11:50EDUCATION.
- 11:50THAT SAID, I BELIEVE THERE IS A
- 11:52ROLE FOR PUBLIC REK THAT LIVES
- 11:56ALONGSIDE THE HORIZON'S ACT.
- 11:58AND WE HAVE TO MAKE THE
- 12:00INVESTMENTS NOW.
- 12:01THIS SECTOR IS IN CRISIS AND WE
- 12:03HAVE TO ACT NOW TO STABILIZE IT
- 12:05AND MY CONGRATULATIONS TO
- 12:06SENATOR CARROLL FOR A THOUGHTFUL
- 12:08BILL THAT ADDRESSES A LOT OF THE
- 12:09NEEDS THAT WE ARE SEEING AT THIS
- 12:11VERY 0 MOMENT.
- 12:13>> Renee: BEFORE I ENGAGE THE
- 12:14OTHER TWO, SENATOR CARROLL DO
- 12:16YOU EMBRACE UNIVERSAL PRE-K
- 12:19ALONGSIDE THE HORIZON'S ACT?
- 12:20>> I EMBRACE EARLY CHILDHOOD
- 12:23EDUCATION FOR ALL KIDS AND WE
- 12:25SAY UNIVERSAL THERE IS THE
- 12:27PUBLIC MODEL AND THEN THERE IS
- 12:29THE ALL THE ABOVE MODEL.
- 12:30AND I FEEL LIKE WE NEED TO USE
- 12:33THE ASSETS WE'VE GOT.
- 12:35SHOULD WE HAVE PUBLIC PRIVATE
- 12:37PARTNERSHIPS WITH SCHOOLS
- 12:39PARTNERING WITH PRIVATE SITTERS?
- 12:40ABSOLUTELY.
- 12:41THAT IS ONE OF THE MODELS THAT
- 12:43WILL WORK THIS BILL ALLOWS
- 12:46FUNDING UNDER CERTAIN SITUATIONS
- 12:47FOR THAT TO HAPPEN.
- 12:49SO WE HAD THE INFRASTRUCTURE IN
- 12:51PLACE.
- 12:52WE IF WE INVEST IN IT PROPERLY
- 12:54THESE NUMBERS WILL GROW.
- 12:56WE HAVE QUALITY IN THE KENTUCKY
- 12:58ALL-STARS THAT HAS BEEN IN PLACE
- 12:59FOR MANY, MANY YEARS.
- 13:01>> Renee: A RATING SYSTEM.
- 13:02>> ABSOLUTELY.
- 13:03IT IS IDENTICAL TO THE WAY OUR
- 13:04SCHOOLS ARE SETUP.
- 13:06WE HAVE GRADES, WE HAVE
- 13:08CURRICULUM.
- 13:08WE HAVE TESTING.
- 13:10IT'S JUST LIKE A SCHOOL.
- 13:12AND WE INVEST IN OUR SCHOOL-AGE
- 13:16K-12, WHY WOULD NOT PIANO NOT
- 13:18INVEST IN OUR YOUNGEST STUDENTS.
- 13:19>> Renee: AND YOU ARE PROPOSING
- 13:21DOWN THE ROAD THERE WOULD BE A
- 13:24DEPARTMENT OF EARLY CHILDHOOD
- 13:25EDUCATION AND A COMMISSIONER
- 13:25THIS IS A DIFFERENT I HATE TO
- 13:27USE THE TERM LEVEL OF
- 13:30BUREAUCRACY?
- 13:30>> IT IS IT IS AN EXPANSION BUT
- 13:32THAT IS THE LEVEL OF IMPORTANCE
- 13:33WE NEED TO PUT ON THIS ISSUE.
- 13:34FOR US TO DO THAT, I THINK THERE
- 13:36NEEDS TO BE MORE EMPHASIS IN
- 13:38KIND OF BRINGING TOGETHER ALL
- 13:40THE DIFFERENT DEPARTMENTS,
- 13:43DIVISIONS THAT DEAL WITH EARLY
- 13:45CHILDHOOD EDUCATION AND PUT THEM
- 13:46UNDER ONE UMBRELLA.
- 13:47I THINK WE CAN BE MORE
- 13:48SUCCESSFUL AS WE MOVE FORWARD IN
- 13:51PUTTING TOGETHER DATA, RESEARCH,
- 13:52ALL THE THINGS WE NEED TO DO FOR
- 13:54OUR FAMILIES IN OUR STATE.
- 13:56AND AGAIN, IT GOES BEYOND THE
- 13:59KIDS.
- 13:59IT'S THE ECONOMY.
- 14:00WORKFORCE.
- 14:01THERE IS A LOT OF OF OF ISSUES
- 14:04INVOLVED.
- 14:04>> Renee: AND BRING IN KATE
- 14:08SHANKS WERE THE CHAMBER
- 14:10CHARLOTTE ALL MADE THE ECONOMIC
- 14:14SENSE.
- 14:14>> WE ARE VERY MUCH INTERESTED
- 14:16IN THE ISSUE BECAUSE OF THE
- 14:17IMPACT IT HAS ON WORKFORCE.
- 14:19WE CARE ABOUT THE YOUNGEST
- 14:21KENTUCKIANS IN OUR STATE AND
- 14:22PREPARING THEM THROUGH EARLY
- 14:24CHILDHOOD EDUCATION THAT IS
- 14:24IMPORTANT AS WELL.
- 14:25BUT WE HAVE A SHORT-TERM ISSUE
- 14:26THAT WE ARE DEALING WITH.
- 14:28AND I AGREE WITH WHAT ANDREW
- 14:30SAID THIS IS YEARS IN THE
- 14:31MAKING.
- 14:32AND WE'RE HERE NOW.
- 14:33WE HAVE TO SOLVE THIS PROBLEM OR
- 14:35WE HAVE TO TAKE STEPS TOWARDS
- 14:37SOLVING THIS PROBLEM.
- 14:38WHEN YOU LOOK AT KENTUCKY'S
- 14:41WORKFORCE CHALLENGES I HAVE BEEN
- 14:42ON THE SHOW SEVERAL TIMES I
- 14:44DON'T THINK YOU WILL STOP ME
- 14:47FROM TALKING ABOUT WORKFORCE
- 14:47BECAUSE IT IS A STUBBORN
- 14:49DIFFICULT PROBLEM THAT WE HAVE
- 14:50IN KENTUCKY.
- 14:51AND I CANNOT STRESS ENOUGH THAT
- 14:53IF WE'RE GOING TO TALK ABOUT
- 14:54ECONOMIC GROWTH AND REACHING OUR
- 14:56TRUE ECONOMIC POTENTIAL WE HAVE
- 14:57TO GET PEOPLE TO WORK.
- 14:59WE HAVE TO KEEP PEOPLE AT WORK.
- 15:01WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT OUR
- 15:03ECONOMY, IT'S LIKE TWO SIDES OF
- 15:04AN EQUATION.
- 15:05YOU CREATE THE JOBS AND YOU HAVE
- 15:07THE PEOPLE TO FILL THE JOBS.
- 15:09AND THERE IS A DIRECT
- 15:10RELATIONSHIP TO CHILDCARE
- 15:11AVAILABILITY AND AFFORDABILITY
- 15:12AND WORKFORCE.
- 15:14IF YOU DON'T HAVE CHILDCARE WHAT
- 15:16IS YOUR ALTERNATIVE?
- 15:18IT'S NOT GOING TO WORK.
- 15:19NOT GOING TO A JOB.
- 15:21NOT BEING ABLE TO KEEP A JOB.
- 15:22AND THAT'S OUR PRIMARY CONCERN.
- 15:24AND WE ARE DOWN AROUND 43,000
- 15:27WORKERS FROM THE END OF 2019.
- 15:33DESPITE WORK DONE AROUND
- 15:34WORKFORCE WE ARE STILL LOSING
- 15:35PEOPLE FROM THE WORKFORCE.
- 15:37>> Renee: AND THAT IS PRIME AGE
- 15:38WORKERS?
- 15:39>> YES.
- 15:40SOME PEOPLE ARE DROPPING --
- 15:42RETIRE THEY ARE AGING OUT OF THE
- 15:43WORKFORCE WE NEED TO BRING NEW
- 15:45PEOPLE INTO THE WORKFORCE.
- 15:46BUT WHEN WE LOOK AT OUR ADVOCACY
- 15:49WORK AROUND THIS ISSUE IT'S
- 15:52ABOUT RETAINING THE WORKERS AND
- 15:54MAKING SURE THAT PEOPLE WHO HAVE
- 15:56CHILDCARE ASSISTANCE NOW AREN'T
- 15:57GOING TO LOSE IT WHEN THE FUNDS
- 15:59RUN OUT IN SEPTEMBER THAT OUR
- 16:01CHILDCARE WORKERS AREN'T GOING
- 16:02TO LEAVE THEIR JOBS FOR A BETTER
- 16:04PAYING JOB AND SO MANY OTHER
- 16:07EMPLOYERS.
- 16:08SO WE'RE VERY MUCH COMMITTED TO
- 16:11ADVOCATING FOR THIS BECAUSE I
- 16:13DON'T WANT TO BE BACK A YEAR
- 16:15FROM NOW AND SAYING THAT 43,000
- 16:17NOW WE'RE AT 55,000.
- 16:19AS WE SEE OUR ECONOMY EXPAND ON
- 16:21THE JOB SIDE WE HAVE TO BE
- 16:23FILLING THOSE JOBS.
- 16:24WE SUPPORT CHILDCARE IN THIS
- 16:27LEGISLATIVE SESSION AND SUPPORT
- 16:28MAKING THE INVESTMENTS AND WE
- 16:29ARE SUPPORTING WORKING FAMILIES
- 16:31AND DOING THAT OUR WORKFORCE AND
- 16:33OUR ECONOMY.
- 16:35>> Renee: YOU ARE WITH THE PITCH
- 16:37ARD COMMITTEE AND THIS IS THE
- 16:38BOLD ASK FOR HOW LONG NOW EARLY
- 16:40CHILDHOOD EDUCATION?
- 16:40>> EVERY BUDGET SESSION FOR THE
- 16:42BIG BOLD ASK.
- 16:43>> Renee: HOW DO YOU WEIGH-IN ON
- 16:45THIS PARTICULAR MEASURE SENATE
- 16:47BILL 203?
- 16:47>> WE'RE INCREDIBLY SUPPORTIVE
- 16:50OF WHAT SENATOR CARROLL HAS PUT
- 16:52FORTH.
- 16:52AND AS HE AND Dr. VANOVER HAVE
- 16:55DESCRIBED THIS IS ABOUT
- 16:58STABILIZING THE CHILDCARE SECTOR
- 16:59AND THINKING NEW ABOUT HOW WE
- 17:02ENSURE INCREASED CHILDCARE IN
- 17:03THE STATE.
- 17:05AND BOTH PARTS ARE REALLY
- 17:07IMPORTANT.
- 17:07THE STABILIZATION SO THAT
- 17:09TUITION COSTS DON'T GO UP.
- 17:11AND THAT CHILDCARE WORKERS ARE
- 17:12NOT GOING TO HAVE TO FIND OTHER
- 17:15JOBS BECAUSE THEIR WAGES GO
- 17:16DOWN.
- 17:18AND ALSO A LONG-RANGE PLAN IS
- 17:19IMPORTANT.
- 17:20YOU CAN SEE THAT IN SENATOR
- 17:22CARROLL'S BILL.
- 17:23WHEN HE SAYS SWINGING FOR THE
- 17:25FENCES I LOVE THAT ANALOGY.
- 17:26MY TEAM AT THE PRITCHARD
- 17:29COMMITTEE WILL TELL YOU I'M
- 17:31TERRIBLE ABOUT MIXING UP SPORTS
- 17:33ANALOGIES I APPRECIATE THAT ONE.
- 17:34BUT THE SWINGING FOR THE FENCES
- 17:36THIS IS A TIME FOR A HOME RUN ON
- 17:41HERBAL CHILDHOOD AND IT'S NOT
- 17:43GOING TO WIN THE WORLD SERIES
- 17:44FOR US BUT IT IS AN IMPORTANT
- 17:46STEP FORWARD.
- 17:46SWINGING FOR THE FENCES, HITTING
- 17:48A HOME RUN, NOW IS THE TIME FOR
- 17:50SOME DEEP INVESTMENT IN
- 17:52CHILDCARE TO STABILIZE AND TO
- 17:53ENSURE THAT CONDITIONS ARE
- 17:56CREATED FOR CHILDCARE TO TAKE
- 17:57ROOT ACROSS THE STATE.
- 17:58>> Renee: AND YOU ARE FOR
- 18:00UNIVERSAL PRE-K?
- 18:01>> YEP.
- 18:0279 OF KENTUCKY 120 COUNTIES ARE
- 18:06CONSIDERED CHILDCARE DESERTS
- 18:07MORE CHILDREN THAT NEED CARE
- 18:09MORE FAMILIES THAT NEED
- 18:11CHILDCARE THAN THERE ARE SLOTS.
- 18:13SO WE HAVE TO DO SOMETHING THAT
- 18:14CREATES THE CONDITIONS FOR THE
- 18:17SMALL BUSINESS OFTEN WOMEN-OWNED
- 18:19SMALL BUSINESS TO TAKE ROOT IF
- 18:21IN OUR STATE AND SOME OF THE
- 18:22PROVISIONS IN THE BILL WILL DO
- 18:24THAT.
- 18:24AS FAR AS UNIVERSAL PRESCHOOL,
- 18:26WE ARE IN FAVOR OF UNIVERSAL
- 18:29PRESCHOOL IF CHILDCARE IS PART
- 18:30OF THE DELIVERY MIX.
- 18:31AND THAT'S AN IMPORTANT REALLY
- 18:33IMPORTANT CAVEAT.
- 18:34IF WE DO IT ANY OTHER WAY, WHAT
- 18:36WE'LL FIND IS ANOTHER DEATH BLOW
- 18:39TO CHILDCARE.
- 18:40SO CHILDCARE HAS TO BE PART OF
- 18:41THE PRESCHOOL DELIVERY MIX.
- 18:44WHETHER IT'S PART OF UNIVERSAL
- 18:47PRESCHOOL OR NOT.
- 18:47WE WOULD VK FOR A LONG-RANGE
- 18:49PLAN MAKING SURE THAT PRESCHOOL
- 18:51DOLLARS FLOW TO HIGH QUALITY
- 18:53CHILDCARE CENTERS.
- 18:54THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS THOSE
- 18:57ENTREPRENEURIAL SMALL BUSINESS
- 18:58OWNERS THE QUALITY RATED ONES
- 18:59ARE ALREADY PROVIDING A
- 19:02PRESCHOOL LEVEL DEVELOPMENT
- 19:04SPACE FOR YOUNGSTERS.
- 19:06AND THEY ARE NOT BEING PAID FOR
- 19:07IT.
- 19:08>> Renee: THIS COMES IN FROM A
- 19:09FELLOW COLLEAGUE IN THE OTHER
- 19:11CHAMBER THE LOWER CHAMBER STATE
- 19:13REPRESENTATIVE JESSYE RAYMOND
- 19:16SAID LOUISVILLE'S MAYOR PROPOSED
- 19:18A UNIVERSAL PRE-K PROGRAM IF
- 19:20THERE IS NO APPETITE TO
- 19:22INTERVENE STATE-WIDE WHY DOESN'T
- 19:24THE LEGISLATURE FUND THAT
- 19:24PROGRAM AND USE IT AS A PILOT TO
- 19:26SEE WHAT WORKS BEST?
- 19:30>> WE YET TO BE DETERMINED WHAT
- 19:34IS GOING TO HAPPEN WITH THIS
- 19:35BILL.
- 19:35I THINK WE HAVE TO LOOK AT ALL
- 19:37THE APPROACHES AND WHAT IS GOING
- 19:39TO WORK AND WE'VE GOT TO FIND A
- 19:42PLAN FOR THE AND TIRE STATE NOT
- 19:43JUST FOR LOUISVILLE.
- 19:44AND THAT'S THE GOAL OF THIS
- 19:47BILL.
- 19:47AND YOU KNOW, AGAIN, THE
- 19:49INNOVATIONS GRANT IS PART OF
- 19:50THIS BILL WHERE WE'RE LOOKING
- 19:52FOR NEW MODELS.
- 19:53IT WILL TAKE EVERY IDEA THAT WE
- 19:55CAN COME UP WITH TO ADDRESS THIS
- 19:57PROBLEM AND IF LOUISVILLE HAS
- 20:00PROGRAMS SETUP THAT WORK FOR
- 20:03THEM, I'M OKAY WITH THAT.
- 20:05>> Renee: SENATOR YOU ARE FROM
- 20:06JEFFERSON COUNTY, WHAT SAY YOU?
- 20:08>> I THINK IT'S IMPORTANT WE
- 20:10GIVE COMMUNITIES THE TOOLS THEY
- 20:12NEED TO MEET THE NEEDS IN THEIR
- 20:14COMMUNITY.
- 20:14LOUISVILLE, I THINK, CAN
- 20:15EXPERIMENT FIGURE OUT WHAT WORKS
- 20:16AND BRING ALL THE RESOURCES THAT
- 20:20IT CAN BRING TO BEAR ON THIS
- 20:24PROBLEM.
- 20:24LOCAL AND STATE DOLLARS IT IS A
- 20:25GOOD IDEA.
- 20:26I LOVE TALKING ABOUT INNOVATION
- 20:27BECAUSE THIS IS A SPACE WHERE
- 20:29IT'S NEEDED.
- 20:30SO BADLY.
- 20:30WE LOOK AT ALL THE DIFFERENT
- 20:32NEEDS OF DIFFERENT FAMILIES.
- 20:34FAMILIES THAT MIGHT WORK SECOND
- 20:36OR THIRD SHIFT.
- 20:37FAMILIES THAT MIGHT HAVE
- 20:38DIFFERENT NEEDS.
- 20:39KIDS THAT HAVE DISABILITIES THEY
- 20:40NEED TO BE SERVED IN DIFFERENT
- 20:42SETTINGS.
- 20:43THERE IS A LOT OF INNOVATION
- 20:45THAT WE CAN DO IN THE SPACE TO
- 20:46FIGURE OUT HOW WE MEET THE NEEDS
- 20:48OF FAMILIES AND MEET THE NEEDS
- 20:50OF KIDS AND HOW WE'RE SETTING UP
- 20:53EVERY CHILD IN OUR COMMUNITY FOR
- 20:55SUCCESS.
- 20:55>> I WOULD SAY THAT KENTUCKY HAS
- 20:57BEEN BLESSED IN THE PAST SEVERAL
- 20:59YEARS TO HAVE COME UP WITH
- 21:01INNOVATIVE IDEAS HOW WE ARE
- 21:02SUPPORTING OUR CHILDCARE FIELD.
- 21:03KENTUCKY WAS THE FIRST STATE IN
- 21:04THE UNITED STATES TO IMPLEMENT A
- 21:06PROGRAM THAT EXCLUDED INCOME FOR
- 21:09CHILDCARE PROVIDERS FROM THE
- 21:10SEEK PROGRAM.
- 21:12>> C CAP.
- 21:14>> THE CHILDCARE ASSISTANCE
- 21:15PROGRAM.
- 21:15>> IF YOU WORK IN A CHILDCARE
- 21:17PROGRAM 20 HOURS A WEEK YOU ARE
- 21:19ELIGIBLE FOR CHILDCARE
- 21:20ASSISTANCE FOR YOUR CHILDREN.
- 21:23MEANING THAT IF YOU ARE WORKING
- 21:25AT TARGET AND MAKING $15 AN HOUR
- 21:27AND THAT IS MORE THAN YOU WOULD
- 21:29MAKE IF A CHILDCARE PROGRAM YOU
- 21:30ARE GOING TO HAVE TO PAY
- 21:32CHILDCARE FOR YOUR CHILD WHAT.
- 21:33DO YOU BRING HOME FROM THAT?
- 21:35IF WE CAN ENTICE PEOPLE BACK TO
- 21:38THE CHILDCARE FIELD AND THEIR
- 21:41CHILDCARE TUITION FOR THEIR
- 21:42CHILDREN IS WAIVED THEN WE CAN
- 21:44SUPPORT THE WORKFORCE IN A WHOLE
- 21:46NEW WAY AND OUR RETURN ON
- 21:48INVESTMENT IS REALLY CLEAR WITH
- 21:49THAT.
- 21:50FOREVER EVERY CHILDCARE PROVIDER
- 21:51WE BRING BACK THEY ARE WATCHING
- 21:54EIGHT TO 10 OTHER CHILDREN
- 21:56HELPING TO EDUCATE THEM AND CARE
- 21:57FOR THEM.
- 21:59MORE WORKING FAMILIES ARE
- 22:01PARTICIPATING WITH EVERY
- 22:03CHILDCARE PROVIDER.
- 22:03THESE INNOVATIONS THAT STARTED
- 22:04IN THE PAST FEW YEARS, ARE NEW
- 22:06IDEAS FOR KENTUCKY AND NEW IDEAS
- 22:09FOR NATIONWIDE.
- 22:10AND WE'VE HAD OTHER STATES GO
- 22:12OUT AND DUPLICATE KENTUCKY'S
- 22:16POLICIES BECAUSE IT SEEMS LIKE
- 22:17IT WORKED IT IS A NO-BRAINER.
- 22:21WHAT WE HAVE TO DO IS CONTINUE
- 22:22TO FUND THE NEW INNOVATIVE
- 22:24PROGRAMS AND KEEP THE PROGRESS
- 22:25WE'VE MADE.
- 22:26HONESTLY, WHEN I TALK TO OTHER
- 22:27STATES ABOUT WHAT ARE YOU GOING
- 22:29TO DO WHEN THE FUNDS RUN OUT?
- 22:31THEY WANT TO KNOW WHAT KENTUCKY
- 22:33IS GOING TO DO.
- 22:34BECAUSE KENTUCKY SET GREAT
- 22:36EXAMPLES.
- 22:37>> Renee: AND OTHER STATES
- 22:38FAULTERED.
- 22:39KANSAS IS ONE.
- 22:40>> KANSAS, IDAHO, NORTH
- 22:42CAROLINA, STATES STRUGGLING
- 22:43BECAUSE WITH THE STABILIZATION
- 22:45PAYMENTS IN KENTUCKY WE SPACE
- 22:47THEM OUT OVER NINE PAYMENTS
- 22:49QUARTERLY TO HELP PEOPLE SAY IN
- 22:51THREE MORE AND I CAN STAY OPEN.
- 22:54SOME OTHER STATES GAVE LIKE ONE
- 22:56LUMP SUM OR A COUPLE LUMP SUMS
- 22:58FRONT LOADED AND THEY'VE LOST
- 23:00THOSE FUNDING SOURCES NOW.
- 23:02AND WE'RE SEEING STATES THAT
- 23:04HAVE HAD AMAZING EARLY CHILDHOOD
- 23:06EDUCATION IN THE PAST LIKE NORTH
- 23:08CAROLINA THAT ARE LOSING
- 23:09PROGRAMS WEEKLY.
- 23:11AND DESERT AREAS THEY'VE LOST
- 23:13HUNDREDS OF CHILDCARE SLOTS.
- 23:15KANSAS LOST 43 CHILDCARE HOMES
- 23:18IN THREE MONTHS AFTER THE
- 23:19PAYMENTS WERE GONE.
- 23:22IDAHO LOST 86 PROGRAMS IN THE
- 23:24FIRST YEAR WITHIN THE PAST YEAR
- 23:25WITH FUNDING DEPLETING.
- 23:28AND WHAT WE DON'T WANT TO DO IS
- 23:31BE IN THOSE POSITIONS.
- 23:32WE HAVE THE 79 COUNTIES THAT
- 23:34WERE CHILDCARE DESERTS BUT WHAT
- 23:35HAPPENS WHEN WE DON'T STEP UP
- 23:37AND DO SOMETHING TO KEEP OUR
- 23:39PROGRAMS OPEN?
- 23:40WE'RE GOING TO HAVE LOTS OF
- 23:41FAMILIES THAT ARE FORCED TO MAKE
- 23:43HARD DECISIONS.
- 23:44AND I CAN TELL YOU AS A WORKING
- 23:46MOM, I LOST AFTER SCHOOL CARE
- 23:49FOR MY ELEMENTARY SCHOOLERS FOR
- 23:50A FEW WEEKS DURING THE PANDEMIC.
- 23:52IT WAS AT THE END OF THE
- 23:54PANDEMIC WE WERE TRYING TO GET
- 23:55MORE STAFF.
- 23:56FOR THOSE THREE WEEKS MY
- 23:59SCHEDULE WAS ARRANGED AROUND THE
- 24:00KIDS.
- 24:00HAD TO LEAVE WORK.
- 24:02NOBODY WHO WORKS FULL-TIME GETS
- 24:05OFF AT 2:30.
- 24:06I COULD NOT TAKE MEETINGS AFTER
- 24:07THAT.
- 24:08AND SOMEBODY IN THE FAMILY HAS
- 24:09TO DECIDE OR A SINGLE PARENT IT
- 24:12AUTOMATICALLY FALLS ON YOU TO
- 24:14REARRANGE YOUR LIFE TO MEET THE
- 24:15NEEDS OF YOUR CHILDREN.
- 24:16WHICH IS YOUR JOB AS A PARENT
- 24:19BUT WE HAVE THE JOB TO PROVIDE
- 24:21STABLE HOUSING, REGULAR FOOD
- 24:24SOURCES, HEALTH INSURANCE,
- 24:25STABLE TRANSPORTATION AND THOSE
- 24:26THINGS WILL COME WHEN OUR
- 24:28PARENTS ARE IN THE WORKFORCE AND
- 24:29THAT IS ONLY GOING TO HAPPEN IF
- 24:31THEY HAVE STABLE CHILDCARE.
- 24:33>> Renee: Mr. McNEILL AT THE
- 24:35COMMITTEE MEETING LAST WEEK
- 24:36THERE WAS A NORTHERN KENTUCKY
- 24:39CHILDCARE PROVIDER WHO TESTIFIED
- 24:40IF SHE CLOSED IT WOULD IMPACT 80
- 24:43FAMILIES, 25 TEACHERS OUT OF
- 24:44WORK AND 120 KIDS WOULD NOT HAVE
- 24:47CARE.
- 24:47WHEN YOU HEAR THAT TYPE OF
- 24:49TESTIMONY AND YOU ARE NOT IN
- 24:51FAVOR OF SENATOR CARROLL'S BILL,
- 24:53WHAT IN YOUR MIND WOULD BE THE
- 24:55SOLUTION TO HELP THIS CHILDCARE
- 24:57PROVIDER STAY OPEN?
- 24:59>> SHE SAID IF SHE DID HAVE TO
- 25:01CLOSE.
- 25:01AND I DON'T KNOW THAT SHE REALLY
- 25:02WENT THROUGH THE RANGE OF
- 25:04OPTIONS IN EARN ITS OF MAKING
- 25:07THAT DECISION.
- 25:07BUT SHE DIDN'T SAY WITHOUT THIS
- 25:10CONTINUED SUPPORT THAT THAT WAS
- 25:13NECESSARILY SOMETHING THAT WOULD
- 25:14HAPPEN.
- 25:16LOOK, THERE ARE CHALLENGES FOR
- 25:18PARENTS FINDING CHILDCARE TODAY
- 25:21JUST AS THERE ARE CHALLENGES FOR
- 25:23PARENTS FINDING CHILDCARE 15
- 25:25YEARS AGO WHEN MY DAUGHTER WAS
- 25:26OF THAT AGE.
- 25:28IT'S A RITE OF PASSAGE FOR
- 25:31PARENTING TO GO THROUGH SOME OF
- 25:33THE STRUGGLES OF IDENTIFYING
- 25:36CHILDCARE, AFFORDING CHILDCARE,
- 25:37MAKING THE SACRIFICE.
- 25:39BECAUSE IF YOU THINK ABOUT IT IT
- 25:41IS A COMPRESSED TIME PERIOD
- 25:43WHERE YOU HAVE THE VERY
- 25:45EXPENSIVE 8, 9, 10 HOUR A DAY
- 25:48NEED FOR CHILDCARE AFTER THEY
- 25:50ENTER KINDERGARTEN YOU MAY HAVE
- 25:52A WRAP AROUND PROGRAM AT THE
- 25:54BEGINNING OF THE DAY OR THE END
- 25:55OF THE DAY.
- 25:56BUT WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
- 25:57HERE IS THE FIRST THREE OR FOUR
- 25:59YEARS OF LIFE.
- 26:00I WANT TO TALK ABOUT THE
- 26:02QUESTION OF THE PRICE AND THE
- 26:04COST OF CHILDCARE.
- 26:06ADVOCATES SAY THAT CONTINUING
- 26:08THIS SUPPORT IS NECESSARY TO
- 26:11KEEP CHILDCARE AFFORDABLE FOR
- 26:13FAMILIES.
- 26:14BUT WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT THE
- 26:16IMPACT OF LONG-TERM SUBSIDIES ON
- 26:19THE PRICE OF THINGS?
- 26:20IF YOU LOOK AT HIGHER EDUCATION
- 26:22IT'S HIGHLY SUBSIDIZED AND THE
- 26:24COSTS CONTINUE TO RISE.
- 26:25YOU LOOK AT HEALTHCARE.
- 26:28ANOTHER AREA SECTOR OF OUR
- 26:29ECONOMY HEAVILY SUBSIDIZED AND
- 26:31THE COST OF CARE IS INCREDIBLY
- 26:34EXPENSIVE.
- 26:36SUBSIDIES MAKE SERVICES MORE
- 26:38EXPENSIVE.
- 26:39SO FOR THE ADVOCATES IF THEIR
- 26:41GOAL IS TO MAKE CHILDCARE MORE
- 26:43AFFORDABLE THE LAST THING WE
- 26:44SHOULD BE LOOKING AT ARE
- 26:46LONG-TERM SUBSIDIES WHICH WILL
- 26:48ULTIMATELY LEAD TO HIGHER
- 26:49TUITION COSTS AND ALSO
- 26:51INCREASING COSTS EVER GROWING
- 26:52COSTS FOR THE TAXPAYERS TO
- 26:54SUPPORT THIS PROGRAM.
- 26:55>> Renee: SENATOR CARROLL IS
- 26:57THAT AN UNINTENDED CONSEQUENCE
- 26:59OF YOUR LEGISLATION?
- 27:00>> I THINK WHAT HE IS STATING IS
- 27:03COMPLETELY UNREASONABLE.
- 27:04WHEN YOU RUN AN EARLY CHILDHOOD
- 27:06EDUCATION YOU DON'T HAVE THE
- 27:09ABILITY TO IMPACT YOUR REVENUE.
- 27:11YOU HAVE "X" NUMBER OF KIDS.
- 27:13YOU HAVE TO HAVE "X" NUMBER OF
- 27:14STAFF.
- 27:15INFANTS YOU LOSE MONEY EVERY
- 27:17MONTH ON INFANTS.
- 27:18YOU LOSE MONEY ON TODDLERS.
- 27:20THE ONLY AGE GROUP THAT YOU
- 27:22GENERATE ANY REVENUE ON ARE THE
- 27:25PRESCHOOL KIDS AND MAYBE THE
- 27:26AFTER SCHOOL KIDS.
- 27:27THAT'S IT.
- 27:28AND THERE IS NO WAY, NO AVENUE
- 27:31THAT A BUSINESS HAS THAT A
- 27:33CENTER HAS OF INCREASING THE
- 27:34REVENUE.
- 27:35YOU COULD FILL YOUR CENTER WITH
- 27:37PRE-K KIDS AND NOT TAKE ANY
- 27:38OTHER AGES.
- 27:40THAT'S IT.
- 27:41THAT'S THE ONLY THING THAT YOU
- 27:42CAN DO.
- 27:43AND THAT DOESN'T HELP OUR
- 27:45FAMILIES.
- 27:45SO THE BUSINESS MODEL STRUCTURED
- 27:48IN SUCH A WAY THAT YOU CAN'T
- 27:50GENERATE MORE REVENUE SO WE'RE
- 27:52STUCK WHERE WE ARE IN THAT.
- 27:56AND IT'S REGULATORY ENVIRONMENT
- 27:57THAT CAUSES THAT THAT IS VERY
- 27:59NECESSARY BECAUSE OF SAFETY AND
- 28:01QUALITY THAT IS NECESSARY.
- 28:03>> Renee: YOU ARE NOT PROPOSING
- 28:04TO CHANGE REGULATIONS AT ALL?
- 28:06>> I AM NOT.
- 28:08THE REGULATIONS THAT WE HAVE
- 28:10SOMETIMES THEY BURDENSOME THEY
- 28:11ARE.
- 28:11BUT THEY ARE THERE FOR A
- 28:13PURPOSE.
- 28:13AND IT CREATES GOOD QUALITY AND
- 28:15IT CREATES SAFETY.
- 28:17I'VE BEEN IN THIS AREA FOR 14
- 28:19YEARS NOW.
- 28:20AND I'VE SEEN IT WHEN IT WAS
- 28:23BABYSITTING AND I SEE WHAT IT IS
- 28:24NOW AND IT IS A DIFFERENCE
- 28:26BETWEEN DAYLIGHT AND DARK.
- 28:28AND SUBSIDIZING IS ONE THING.
- 28:30THE CENTERS DON'T WANT A HANDOUT
- 28:32THEY WANT TO SURVIVE.
- 28:33BUT THE MODEL DOESN'T ALLOW FOR
- 28:36THAT.
- 28:38AND SUBSIDIES MAY CREATE HIGHER
- 28:40PRICES, BUT INVESTMENTS IN THE
- 28:42RIGHT PLACES CREATE DIVIDENDS.
- 28:44THIS IS AN INVESTMENT IN OUR
- 28:46KIDS AND OUR ECONOMY AND OUR
- 28:49FAMILIES.
- 28:49THAT WILL RETURN DIVIDENDS 10
- 28:51FOLD FOR THIS STATE.
- 28:53>> WHAT SENATOR CARROLL
- 28:54DESCRIBED AS FAR AS THE COST
- 28:57BREAKDOWN.
- 28:58AND IF ANYBODY THINKS ABOUT
- 28:59THIS, YOU KNOW IF YOU'VE GOT AN
- 29:01INFANT A TODDLER OR A
- 29:03PRESCHOOLER YOU NEED MORE ADULTS
- 29:05IN A ROOM WITH INFANTS AND
- 29:06TODDLERS TO TAKE CARE OF THOSE
- 29:08LITTLE ONES.
- 29:09SO AS SENATOR CARROLL DESCRIBED
- 29:11IF WE START PULLING PRESCHOOLERS
- 29:13OUT OF CHILDCARE CENTERS IT
- 29:14MAKES IT DIFFICULT FOR CHILDCARE
- 29:16TO STAY OPEN AND THAT IS WHY WE
- 29:17WOULD SAY WE'RE NOT FOR A
- 29:20UNIVERSAL PRESCHOOL EFFORT THAT
- 29:21IS JUST ABOUT PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 29:23THE OTHER PIECE THAT IS REALLY
- 29:25IMPORTANT TO UNDERSTAND IS
- 29:26ANDREW WAS TALKING ABOUT
- 29:27SUBSIDIES WE HAVE TO REMEMBER WE
- 29:28LIVE IN A STATE THAT IS 6TH FROM
- 29:30THE BOTTOM OF THE NATION IN
- 29:32POVERTY.
- 29:33FAMILIES CANNOT AFFORD CHILDCARE
- 29:35THAT RIVALS THE COST OF A
- 29:36COLLEGE TUITION.
- 29:37AND IT RIVALS THE COST OF A
- 29:39COLLEGE TUITION BECAUSE THE
- 29:41PRIMARY DRIVER OF MODEL IS THE
- 29:43PEOPLE THE ADULTS WITH THE
- 29:46CHILDREN.
- 29:46AND SO PEOPLE ARE EXPENSIVE.
- 29:50AND AS Dr. VANOVER DESCRIBED
- 29:51WE DON'T PAY THOSE FOLKS ENOUGH
- 29:53TO COMPETE WITH AMAZON, AND
- 29:57MCDONALD'S AND WALMART.
- 29:58SO THE COST DRIVER IF YOU THINK
- 30:00ABOUT THAT AND YOU THINK ABOUT
- 30:01THE COST OF QUALITY AND THINK
- 30:03ABOUT LIVING IN A POOR STATE
- 30:04THERE IS NO OTHER CHOICE THAN
- 30:06FOR STATE GOVERNMENT TO GET
- 30:08INVOLVED TO ENSURE THAT
- 30:09CHILDCARE IS AN OPTION FOR
- 30:12FAMILIES.
- 30:13>> Renee: SO THIS VIEWER
- 30:14RESPONSE FROM JEFF SIMS IN
- 30:15CALDWELL COUNTY, WHAT COULD BE
- 30:17THE OPPORTUNITY/INCENTIVE FOR
- 30:19SENIOR CITIZENS CENTER PATRONS
- 30:21TO PARTNER IN STAFFING FOR
- 30:24CHILDCARE CENTERS?
- 30:25COULD THIS BE A BEST OF BOTH
- 30:28WORLDS PARTNERSHIP?
- 30:29>> ABSOLUTELY.
- 30:30WHAT A GREAT SCENARIO WHERE YOU
- 30:32HAVE A SENIOR CENTER ASSISTED
- 30:34LIVING HOME, AND THEN YOU HAVE A
- 30:37CHILDCARE FACILITY EARLY
- 30:40CHILDHOOD EDUCATION CENTER RIGHT
- 30:41NEXT TO THAT.
- 30:42TALK ABOUT IMPROVING THE QUALITY
- 30:44OF LIFE OF BOTH GROUPS THAT ONE
- 30:46OF THE INNOVATIVE IDEAS WE HOPE
- 30:48TO SEE HAPPEN.
- 30:50HE IS RIGHT IN LINE.
- 30:51>> Renee: AND THAT IS WHERE THAT
- 30:53GRANT MONEY WOULD GO TO.
- 30:55>> YES.
- 30:55YES.
- 30:56>> Renee: ANY OTHER COMMENT
- 30:57ABOUT THAT IDEA?
- 30:57>> WE SEE THAT HEADSTART HAS A
- 31:00WONDERFUL FOSTER GRANDPARENT
- 31:02PROGRAM WHERE THEY HAVE
- 31:04CERTIFIED TEACHERS THAT ARE IN
- 31:05THE CLASSROOM EVERYDAY BUT THEY
- 31:06HAVE FOSTER GRANDPARENTS THAT
- 31:08VOLUNTEER.
- 31:09THEY GET A STIPEND TO ASSIST
- 31:11WITH BASIC COST OF LIVING NEEDS.
- 31:13BUT THEY ARE VOLUNTEERING IN THE
- 31:14CLASSROOM WORKING WITH THE
- 31:16CHILDREN.
- 31:16ADDING MORE ADULTS TO THE ROOM
- 31:18SO THAT CHILDREN HAVE MORE
- 31:21INTERACTION ESPECIALLY
- 31:22DEVELOPING THEIR VOCABULARY AND
- 31:25TALKING TO THE OLDER ADULTS AND
- 31:28WE SEE GROWTH THERE.
- 31:29WE HAVE LOTS OF MODELS THAT THE
- 31:30CAN BE USED IN AN INNOVATION
- 31:33PROGRAM.
- 31:34CLARK COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 31:35IMPLEMENTED THE EAGLES NEST
- 31:38PROGRAM CHILDCARE JUST FOR CLARK
- 31:40COUNTY PUBLIC SCHOOL EMPLOYEES
- 31:42AND THEY ARE USING IT AS A
- 31:44RECRUITMENT TOOL FOR TEACHERS
- 31:45WHICH WE NEED MORE OF K-12
- 31:48TEACHERS BUT PROVIDING CHILDCARE
- 31:52THERE TO PROVIDE FOR THE
- 31:53TEACHERS AND THEIR FAMILIES AND
- 31:54ALSO GIVE THE KIDS WHAT THEY
- 31:56NEED.
- 31:57WE SEE GREAT PROGRAMS LIKE
- 31:59TOYOTA HAVING 24 HOUR CHILDCARE
- 32:00WHICH I'VE GOTTEN TO BE A PART
- 32:02OF IS A MASSIVE UNDERTAKING.
- 32:06BUT THERE ARE NUANCES WE CAN DO
- 32:08TO SOLVE THE PROBLEMS AND THINK
- 32:10OUT OF THE BOX AND WE HAVE
- 32:12COMMUNITIES LIKE DANVILLE, THAT
- 32:14ARE LOOKING INTO HOW DO WE SOLVE
- 32:16THESE PROBLEMS HOW DO WE THINK
- 32:18OUT OF THE BOX INNOVATION GRANT
- 32:20WOULD ASSIST THOSE PROGRAMS IN
- 32:22MOVING FORWARD.
- 32:23>> Renee: IF YOUR FIRST BOOK YOU
- 32:24TALK ABOUT THE INNOVATIONS AND
- 32:26CO-OPS AND OTHER IDEAS.
- 32:29THIS QUESTION COMMENT FROM
- 32:30LUDLOW.
- 32:31THE MINIMUM WAGE IS NOT
- 32:32INCREASED FOR 15 YEARS WHILE THE
- 32:34PRICE OF CHILDCARE HAS.
- 32:35IS IT POSSIBLE THAT PARENTS
- 32:37TODAY CANNOT AFFORD CHILDCARE
- 32:41NOW BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT
- 32:43STRUGGLING AS WAS INFERRED BUT
- 32:45WAGES STAGNATED.
- 32:46TO YOU KATE SHANKS FOR THAT.
- 32:49>> SEEN SIGNIFICANT WAGE GROWTH
- 32:51IN KENTUCKY RECENTLY AS PART OF
- 32:54SOME OF THE CHALLENGES THAT WE
- 32:55HAVE SEEN IN INFLATION AND
- 32:56ACTUALLY SOME OF THE CHALLENGES
- 32:57WE ARE SEEING WITH CHILDCARE
- 32:59WORKFORCE IN TERMS OF KEEPING UP
- 33:01WITH THE WAGES THAT YOU CAN EARN
- 33:03IN OTHER JOBS THAT AREN'T
- 33:04CHILDCARE RELATED.
- 33:06THAT'S BEEN AN IMPORTANT
- 33:08CONVERSATION THAT WE'VE HAD HERE
- 33:09TONIGHT.
- 33:09AND I WANT TO POINT OUT THE ROLE
- 33:11OF PRIVATE EMPLOYERS.
- 33:13YOU MENTIONED TOYOTA, THERE'S
- 33:15OTHER EXAMPLES.
- 33:19AND BAPTIST HEALTH, EAGLES NEST
- 33:21PROJECT PART OF THE SCHOOL
- 33:23SYSTEM WE ARE HEARING MORE AND
- 33:24MORE FROM EMPLOYERS ABOUT
- 33:25CHILDCARE.
- 33:26I WAS TALKING TO ONE OF OUR
- 33:27MEMBERS A CHARGE MANUFACTURER IN
- 33:29A RURAL PART OF THE STATE AND
- 33:31THE REPRESENTATIVE THAT SERVES
- 33:32ON THE BOARD I MENTIONED
- 33:34CHILDCARE WHEN SHE WAS IN
- 33:36FRANKFORT AND HER EYES GOT BIG
- 33:37AND SHE SAID WHAT ARE WE GOING
- 33:39TO DO ABOUT THIS?
- 33:40I HAVE SOMEBODY THAT DRIVES 45
- 33:43MINUTES ONE WAY TO TAKE HIS KIDS
- 33:44TO THE CHILDCARE FACILITY.
- 33:45IT'S BECOMING A QUESTION AROUND
- 33:48RECRUITMENT HOW AM I GOING TO
- 33:50RECRUIT THE YOUNG FAMILIES WITH
- 33:53YOUNG CHILDREN NOT JUST LIKE
- 33:54WHAT ARE THE SCHOOLS LIKE WHAT
- 33:56IS THE CHILDCARE SITUATION LIKE.
- 33:58AN INDIVIDUAL HAD TO GET UP IN
- 34:005:00 A.M. AND WAIT IN LINE TO
- 34:02GET THEIR CHILD INTO A SUMMER
- 34:03SLOT.
- 34:04WE'RE HEARING FROM EMPLOYERS
- 34:05ABOUT THIS.
- 34:06AND I THINK THE WHEELS ARE
- 34:08STARTING TO TURN IN TERMS OF
- 34:10THESE INNOVATIVE IDEAS THE CO-OP
- 34:14IDEAS MAY HAVE YOU HAVE AN
- 34:15EMPLOYER THAT COMES TOGETHER
- 34:16WITH THE SCHOOL SYSTEM AND THE
- 34:18LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND THEY HAVE A
- 34:20FACILITY WHERE THEY EACH BUY
- 34:21INTO SLOTS.
- 34:22SO WE'RE OUR WHEELS ARE SPINNING
- 34:25TOO AT THE CHAMBER IN TERMS OF
- 34:28SUPPORTING THE EMPLOYERS WHO
- 34:29WANT TO TAKE AN INNOVATIVE
- 34:31APPROACH.
- 34:32FOR THIS PARTICULAR LEGISLATIVE
- 34:33SESSION WE HAVE TO HELP THE
- 34:35PEOPLE THAT NEED IT NOW SO THAT
- 34:36THEY STAY IN THE WORKFORCE AND
- 34:38WE DON'T LOSE THOSE WORKERS AS
- 34:40WE CONTINUE TO DEVELOP SOME OF
- 34:42THE MORE INNOVATIVE IDEAS.
- 34:44AND WE'RE VERY INTERESTED IN HOW
- 34:46WE CAN CREATE MORE OF A ROADMAP
- 34:48FOR KENTUCKY AROUND CHILDCARE.
- 34:49MORE OF A LONG-TERM SUSTAINABLE
- 34:51PLAN.
- 34:52TALKING ABOUT FUNDING
- 34:53STRUCTURES.
- 34:54BUT MAYBE THERE ARE ELEMENTS TO
- 34:55THE DISCUSSION OUTSIDE OF THE
- 34:57GENERAL FUND THROUGH THE
- 34:58INNOVATIONS THAT CAN SUPPORT THE
- 35:00WHOLE PICTURE AROUND CHILDCARE
- 35:03IN KENTUCKY.
- 35:05>> Renee: YOUR COLLEAGUE LAST
- 35:06WEEK HAD SAID CHARLES ALL IF
- 35:10KENTUCKY GETS THIS RIGHT IT PUTS
- 35:13KENTUCKY AT A MUCH MORE
- 35:15COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE OVER OVER
- 35:19INDIANA AND TENNESSEE.
- 35:19WHY?
- 35:20>> YOU KNOW AT THE CHAMBER WE
- 35:22ARE COMPETITIVE AND WE WANT TO
- 35:25SEE KENTUCKY BE THE BEST TO DO
- 35:27BUSINESS.
- 35:27ALL STATES ARE STRUGGLING WITH
- 35:29CHILDCARE ISSUES AND EARLY
- 35:30CHILDHOOD EDUCATION ISSUES AND
- 35:32THEY ARE MANAGE TO GO IN
- 35:33DIFFERENT WAYS.
- 35:34AS WE'VE MENTIONED IT OTHER
- 35:36STATES ARE LOOKING TO KENTUCKY.
- 35:38LEGISLATION WAS PASSED PASSED I2
- 35:41HOUSE BILL 499 THE EMPLOYEE
- 35:43CHILDCARE ASSISTANCE PROGRAM AND
- 35:45OTHER STATES HAVE CONTACTED US
- 35:46SAYING WE'RE INTERESTED IN
- 35:48RUNNING THAT, TOO.
- 35:49AND WE'RE SEEING BILLS FILED AND
- 35:51PASSED IN OTHER STATES.
- 35:52>> Renee: THE PARTICIPATION HAS
- 35:54BEEN LESS THAN STERLING?
- 35:55>> IT'S BEEN A GOOD
- 35:57PARTICIPATION WHEN YOU CONSIDER
- 35:58HOW LONG IT'S BEEN UP AND
- 36:00RUNNING WHICH IT JUST STARTED
- 36:02MIDWAY LAST YEAR.
- 36:03AND I WANT TO STRESS AND TIES
- 36:05IN, IF YOU ARE AN EMPLOYER WITH
- 36:08300 EMPLOYEES NOT ALL OF YOUR
- 36:10WORKFORCE NEEDS THAT CHILDCARE
- 36:11SUPPORT.
- 36:11BUT SOME OF THEM DO.
- 36:13AND WHAT IS IMPORTANT WHEN WE
- 36:14TALK ABOUT SUBSIDIES WITH THIS
- 36:17PROGRAM IT IS A BRIDGE OFF OF
- 36:19CHILDCARE ASSISTANCE.
- 36:20IF YOU ARE MAKING 85% OF THE
- 36:23STATE MEDIAN INCOME AND YOU
- 36:25QUALIFY FOR CHILDCARE ASSISTANCE
- 36:27AND OFFERED A PROMOTION AND
- 36:28THINK I'M GOING TO LOSE THAT
- 36:30ASSISTANCE I DON'T WANT TO TAKE
- 36:33THAT NEXT STEP, THE PROGRAM CAN
- 36:35BE THAT BRICK FOR YOU OFF OF
- 36:37PUBLIC ASSISTANCE WHILE YOU ARE
- 36:39GROWING YOUR CAREER AND GROWING
- 36:40YOUR WAGES AND SALARY.
- 36:42THAT IS A GREAT EXAMPLE OF
- 36:44INNOVATION AND A PUBLIC PRIVATE
- 36:46PARTNERSHIP MODEL BECAUSE YOU
- 36:48HAVE SUPPORT FROM THE EMPLOYER
- 36:49AND YOU HAVE IT FROM THE PUBLIC
- 36:52SECTOR AS WELL.
- 36:52AND THE FUND WE SETUP.
- 36:54SO WE BELIEVE IN THAT PROGRAM.
- 36:56WE ARE EXTENDING THAT PROGRAM.
- 36:58WE HAVE EMPLOYERS THAT ARE
- 37:00INTERESTED IN IT.
- 37:00AND WHEN YOU THINK ABOUT BENEFIT
- 37:03STRUCTURES AN EMPLOYER IS NOT
- 37:04GOING TO CHANGE THEIR BENEFIT
- 37:05STRUCTURE OVERNIGHT.
- 37:06THAT IS SOMETHING THAT WILL TAKE
- 37:08PLANNING AND BUDGETING IN THEIR
- 37:10CERTAINLY EMPLOYERS THAT WANT TO
- 37:11SEE OTHERS DO IT FIRST AND SEE
- 37:13HOW IT GOES WORKOUT CHALLENGES.
- 37:17BUT IT'S GOT INTEREST IN THE
- 37:18PRIVATE EMPLOYER COMMUNITY.
- 37:21AND I THINK WE'RE GOING TO SEE
- 37:23GROWTH IN THAT AND IT IS A GREAT
- 37:24PROGRAM FOR THAT BRIDGE.
- 37:27>> Renee: 15 MILLION
- 37:29APPROPRIATED HAS THAT BEEN
- 37:30TAPPED OUT AND ANOTHER
- 37:32APPROPRIATION TO SUPPORT HOUSE
- 37:33BILL 499?
- 37:34>> THERE IS WITH WHAT WE HAVE IT
- 37:36WOULD BE $2 MILLION.
- 37:38AND AGAIN, RENEE.
- 37:40>> Renee: IT DOESN'T SOUND LIKE
- 37:42A LOT.
- 37:42>> IT DOESN'T.
- 37:43BUT THIS IS THE FIRST STEP WITH
- 37:47THESE POTS OF FUNDS TO TRY TO
- 37:49GROW CENTERS AND PROVIDERS
- 37:51THROUGHOUT THE STATE.
- 37:52WE'LL LOOK AT IT FROM YEAR TO
- 37:53YEAR AND WE CAN MAKE ADJUSTMENTS
- 37:55IN THE NEXT BUDGET CYCLE LOOK AT
- 37:57WHAT WORKS AND WHERE DO WE NEED
- 37:59TO INVEST MORE.
- 38:00WHAT IS NOT WORKING?
- 38:01AND THIS IS MEANT TO BE A START
- 38:05AND I THINK THAT IS A PROGRAM
- 38:07THAT I FIRMLY BELIEVE WILL CATCH
- 38:09ON ONCE THE EMPLOYERS KNOW THAT
- 38:10THIS IS HERE AND IT'S HERE TO
- 38:12STAY, I THINK IT IS A TOOL THEY
- 38:14WILL TAKE ADVANTAGE OF.
- 38:16AGAIN, WHAT A GREAT WAY TO
- 38:19RECRUIT EMPLOYEES TO RECRUIT
- 38:20YOUR WORKFORCE.
- 38:21I THINK IT'S GOING TO BE
- 38:22NECESSARY IN TODAY'S ENVIRONMENT
- 38:24FOR BUSINESS AND INDUSTRY THAT
- 38:26THAT, TO BE CREATIVE.
- 38:28AND EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION
- 38:29CHILDCARE IS GOING TO BE THE
- 38:30THINGS THAT DRAW EMPLOYER
- 38:33EMPLOYEES TO THE EMPLOYER.
- 38:34AND FOR THEM TO SUCCEED AND GROW
- 38:37THEIR BUSINESSES THEY WILL HAVE
- 38:39TO THINK OUTSIDE THE BOX AND BE
- 38:41INNOVATIVE.
- 38:42>> DO YOU FIND FAULT WITH THAT
- 38:44PROGRAM?
- 38:44>> IT'S SETUP AS A PILOT.
- 38:46IT APPEARS AS IF DOLLARS HAVE
- 38:49BEEN APPROPRIATED TO IT.
- 38:50I BELIEVE IF THE DOLLARS HAVE
- 38:51BEEN TAPPED, YOU KNOW THERE'S
- 38:54SOME CONTINUED INTEREST IN
- 38:56PROVIDING FOR RESOURCES TO
- 38:57CONTINUE TO SEE IF THAT PILOT
- 39:00DRAWS IN INTEREST FROM THE
- 39:01PRIVATE SECTOR.
- 39:02LOOK I'M IN FAVOR OF PRIVATE
- 39:05EMPLOYERS AND INDUSTRY THINKING
- 39:06OF INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS AND
- 39:09EVALUATING THEIR BENEFIT
- 39:10PACKAGES TO PROVIDE FOR
- 39:12CHILDCARE ON-SITES OR SOME TYPE
- 39:15OF STIPEND FOR THEIR EMPLOYEES
- 39:17TO AFFORD CHILDCARE.
- 39:18ONE THING I WANT TO RESPOND TO
- 39:20SOMETHING SAID BY BRIGITTE ABOUT
- 39:23THE PERVASIVENESS OF POVERTY IN
- 39:25THE STATE AND I UNDERSTAND THAT
- 39:26IT'S A CHALLENGE FOR ALL OF US
- 39:28AND A CHALLENGE IN MANY AREAS OF
- 39:29THE STATE.
- 39:31THERE ARE VOUCHERS IN PLACE FOR
- 39:34LOW INCOME KENTUCKIANS TO BE
- 39:36ABLE TO AFFORD AND SUPPORT THEIR
- 39:38CHILDCARE EXPENSES.
- 39:40I THINK THAT THERE'S NOT AN
- 39:42INSIGNIFICANT AMOUNT OF MONEY
- 39:44INCLUDED IN THE HOUSE BUDGET TO
- 39:46MAKE SURE THAT C CAP IS
- 39:49SUPPORTED.
- 39:49SO WHAT WE'RE TALKING ABOUT HERE
- 39:52BEYOND THAT AND I THINK THAT
- 39:53WHOEVER MADE THE POINT I THINK
- 39:55IT WAS KATE, IF THERE ARE TWEAKS
- 39:58IF THERE IS A DISEN SIN ACTIVE
- 40:01FOR SOMEBODY TO TAKE THE NEXT
- 40:03STEP IN THEIR PROFESSIONAL
- 40:05CAREER BECAUSE THEY MAY LOSE A
- 40:07CHILDCARE BENEFIT THAT IS A
- 40:09REGULATION OR A STATUTE THAT
- 40:11CERTAINLY IS WORTH EXAMINING.
- 40:13BECAUSE WE WANT PEOPLE TO BE
- 40:14ABLE TO TAKE THAT NEXT STEP IN
- 40:16THEIR CAREER PATH.
- 40:18THE BULK OF THIS MONEY ISN'T
- 40:20GOING TO PARENTS.
- 40:21IT ISN'T GOING TO SINGLE
- 40:24MOTHERS.
- 40:25IT'S GOING TO CHILDCARE
- 40:26PROVIDERS.
- 40:27AND THAT'S WHERE THE MONEY HAS
- 40:28BEEN TARGETED FOR THE LAST THREE
- 40:31YEARS.
- 40:32AND SO THAT'S WHAT I FIND
- 40:35PROBLEMATIC.
- 40:35THESE ARE BUSINESSES.
- 40:37THEY ARE SMALL BUSINESSES, OF
- 40:39COURSE.
- 40:39THEY ARE NONPROFITS AND
- 40:43FOR-PROFITS.
- 40:44BUT I'VE HEARD THAT THEY ARE
- 40:47FUNDAMENTALLY DIFFERENT THAN ANY
- 40:48OTHER BUSINESS OUT THERE IN THE
- 40:49STATE.
- 40:50WELL, I GUESS IN TERMS OF THE
- 40:52PRODUCT OR SERVICES THEY ARE
- 40:54PROVIDING THERE'S CERTAINLY SOME
- 40:58REASON TO IDENTIFY THAT AS A
- 41:01VERY CRITICAL SET OF SERVICES.
- 41:04BUT YOU KNOW FOR AN INDUSTRY TO
- 41:06COME TO THE STATE OF KENTUCKY
- 41:08AND SAY THAT THINGS ARE
- 41:10DIFFICULT IN THIS INDUSTRY, WE
- 41:13WOULD HAVE TO MAKE HARD
- 41:15DECISIONS ABOUT WHETHER OR NOT
- 41:17TO RAISE OUR PRICES, ADJUST OUR
- 41:20LABOR COSTS, OR DECIDE TO STAY
- 41:22OPEN I THINK IS GOING TO FALL ON
- 41:24EARS OF OTHER SMALL BUSINESSES
- 41:26OUT THERE THAT STRUGGLE TO MAKE
- 41:28PAYROLL, THAT PAY THEIR TAXES,
- 41:30TO SAY THAT THERE'S SOMETHING SO
- 41:33UNIQUE ABOUT THIS SECTOR THAT
- 41:35THEY DESERVE AN APPROPRIATION OF
- 41:38$300 MILLION TO PROP THEM UP.
- 41:41>> Renee: FUNNY HOW DO YOU
- 41:42RESPOND TO THAT.
- 41:43>> I ACTUALLY DO THINK THERE'S
- 41:45SOMETHING UNIQUE ABOUT THE
- 41:46SECTOR THAT MAKES IT WORTHY OF
- 41:48INVESTMENT THAT IS THE FACT THAT
- 41:50THIS SECTOR IS THE SECTOR THAT
- 41:52SUPPORTS ALL OTHER SECTORS T
- 41:54SUPPORTS OUR KIDS OUR WORKING
- 41:56FAMILIES AND OUR COMMUNITIES.
- 41:57WHEN WE SEE THINGS LIKE ONE OUT
- 41:59OF THREE PARENTS MAKING CHOICES
- 42:01ABOUT WORK AND THEIR JOB BECAUSE
- 42:03THEY CAN'T FIND CHILDCARE AND WE
- 42:06SEE 100,000 WOMEN KENTUCKY WOMEN
- 42:08THAT IS ENOUGH TO FILL CARDINAL
- 42:11STADIUM TWO TIMES OVER LEAVING
- 42:13THE WORKFORCE DURING COVID
- 42:14BECAUSE OF CHILDCARE ISSUES THAT
- 42:15SHOULD TELL YOU HOW VITAL THIS
- 42:17IS.
- 42:18AND THAT IS NOT TAKING INTO
- 42:19ACCOUNT THE IMPACT ON KIDS'
- 42:22BRAINS.
- 42:22THEY ARE MOSTLY FORMED THE BY
- 42:24THE TIME THEY REACH AGE 5.
- 42:26AND YET WE HAVE NOT INVESTED
- 42:28ENOUGH MONEY INTO THOR EARLY
- 42:30YEARS TOO MAKE SURE WE'RE
- 42:32SETTING OUR KIDS UP FOR SUCCESS.
- 42:36I AGREE IT'S INCUMBENT ON US TO
- 42:39MAKE SURE WE ARE BEING EFFICIENT
- 42:42AND GOOD STEWARDS OF THAT.
- 42:44BUT WE GIVE TAXPAYER DOLLARS TO
- 42:45A LOT OF BUSINESSES WHEN WE
- 42:46THINK IT'S GOING TO BENEFIT THE
- 42:48COMMONWEALTH.
- 42:49THINKING ABOUT BLUE OVAL AND
- 42:50FORD IS AN EXAMPLE.
- 42:52SO FOR ME, THIS SECTOR IS SO
- 42:54IMPORTANT IT IMPACTS SO MANY
- 42:55THINGS THAT WE ABSOLUTELY SHOULD
- 42:58BE INVESTING IN IT TONIGHT
- 42:59SHOULD BE ONE OF THE FIRST
- 43:00PLACES WE LOOK TO INVEST.
- 43:02>> Renee: ANY OTHER COMMENT ON
- 43:04THAT?
- 43:05I SAW YOU ALL NODDING?
- 43:06>> I THINK THE POINT, ANDREW,
- 43:08YOU WERE MAKING ABOUT VOUCHERS
- 43:11AND TALKING ABOUT THE CHILD
- 43:15CHILDCARE ASSISTANCE PROGRAM BUT
- 43:16THE STATE'S ASSISTANCE THROUGH
- 43:18THE CHILDCARE ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
- 43:20DOESN'T PROVIDE WHAT IS
- 43:21NECESSARY FOR A CHILDCARE
- 43:23PROVIDER TO MAINTAIN A LEVEL OF
- 43:25QUALITY.
- 43:25IF WE GO BACK TO THE COST
- 43:27DRIVERS IN THE SMALL BUSINESS
- 43:28IT'S ADULTS.
- 43:29IT'S THE ADULT TO CHILD RATIO
- 43:32THAT IS THE COST DRIVER.
- 43:34AND SO IF A CHILDCARE PROVIDER
- 43:35IS NOT ABLE TO BRING IN ENOUGH
- 43:37REVENUE THROUGH THE CHILDCARE
- 43:40ASSISTANCE PROGRAM FROM FAMILIES
- 43:41THAT QUALIFY, THROUGH FAMILIES
- 43:44THAT PAY FULL FREIGHT OR THROUGH
- 43:45OTHER MEANS LIKE BEING PART OF
- 43:47THE PRESCHOOL DELIVERY MIX, THEN
- 43:50THE CHILDCARE PROVIDER CANNOT
- 43:52MAINTAIN A LEVEL OF QUALITY,
- 43:53BRING THE RIGHT PEOPLE IN AND
- 43:55KEEP THE RIGHT WORKFORCE IN THE
- 43:57CHILDCARE BUSINESS TO STAY OPEN
- 43:59AND TO PROVIDE THAT CARE.
- 44:01AT THE LEVEL OF QUALITY THAT IS
- 44:03THE RETURN ON THE INVESTMENT.
- 44:05SO I THINK IT'S MARKET FAILURE
- 44:08IS BASICALLY WHAT WE'RE TALKING
- 44:10ABOUT HERE.
- 44:11AND THERE ARE TAX EXPENDITURES
- 44:13THAT GO TO MANY OTHER BUSINESSES
- 44:14IN THE STATE.
- 44:15SO TO SAY THAT THIS IS A UNIQUE
- 44:19ASK BY THE CHILDCARE INDUSTRY,
- 44:25IS PROBABLY NOT ACTUALLY THE
- 44:27CASE.
- 44:27>> Renee: PETE FROM JAMESTOWN
- 44:28MIGHT SIDE WITH Mr. McNEILL
- 44:31HE SAY WHY WASN'T THE FUNCTION
- 44:33OF CHILDCARE A CONCERN A DECADE
- 44:34AGO?
- 44:35HOW DID PARENTS HANDLE IT
- 44:37WITHOUT GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION
- 44:38AND TAXPAYER MONEY?
- 44:39>> YOU IF YOU LOOK BACK A DECADE
- 44:41AGO OR MORE, OUR ECONOMIC
- 44:43STRUCTURE HAS CHANGED A LOT.
- 44:44I WAS PRIVILEGED ENOUGH TO HAVE
- 44:47A PARENT WHO STAYED AT HOME WITH
- 44:49ME WHEN I WAS YOUNG AND SHE
- 44:51WAITED TO ENTER THE WORKFORCE
- 44:53UNTIL WE STARTED KINDERGARTEN
- 44:55AND WE WERE ABLE TO LIVE ON ONE
- 44:57INCOME THAT MY FATHER BROUGHT IN
- 44:59AND THAT WAS FABULOUS I HAD A
- 45:01BLESSED CHILDHOOD.
- 45:02MY CHILDREN HAVE NOT HAD THE
- 45:04SAME EXPERIENCE.
- 45:04I HAVE BEEN A WORKING MOM FROM
- 45:06THE GET GO AND PART IS BECAUSE
- 45:07OF OTHER EXPENSES THAT WE'VE
- 45:09TALKED ABOUT.
- 45:09IF I HAD STAYED HOME AND WE PUT
- 45:12OUR HEALTH INSURANCE ON MY
- 45:13HUSBAND'S PAYCHECK HE WOULD NOT
- 45:15HAVE BROUGHT HOME ENOUGH FOR US
- 45:16TO CARE FOR THE WHOLE FAMILY.
- 45:19WE ALSO ISN'T HAVE TO --
- 45:21DIDN'T HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT WHEN
- 45:22CHILDREN WERE BORN WE HAD 18
- 45:25YEARS TO SAVE FOR COLLEGE AND
- 45:26THAT WAS THE GOAL.
- 45:27I WILL GET A COLLEGE SAVINGS
- 45:28ACCOUNT FOR MY CHILDREN.
- 45:30RIGHT NOW, INFANT CARE IS MORE
- 45:32THAN THE COST OF YOUR FRESHMAN
- 45:34YEAR AT A STATE UNIVERSITY.
- 45:36THE LARGEST EDUCATIONAL EXPENSE
- 45:39IS RIGHT OUT OF THE GATE SIX
- 45:40WEEKS AFTER THE BABY IS BORN.
- 45:42AND PARENTS DON'T HAVE TIME TO
- 45:43BRACE FOR THAT.
- 45:44YOU HAVE TO COME UP WITH OVER A
- 45:46THOUSAND OUT OF YOUR MONTHLY
- 45:48BUDGET OVERNIGHT.
- 45:49YOU GO FROM NOT HAVING TO SPEND
- 45:51IT TO HAVING TO SPEND IT
- 45:52IMMEDIATELY.
- 45:54WE'VE KENT COSTS DOWN BY
- 45:56SUBSIDIZING THE COST OF CARE ON
- 45:57THE BACKS OF OUR CHILDCARE
- 45:59PROVIDERS.
- 46:00WE PAID THEM NOTHING TO OFFSET
- 46:01THE FACT THAT FAMILIES COULD NOT
- 46:03AFFORD TO PAY MORE THAN $200 A
- 46:06WEEK.
- 46:08BUT, NOW THEY ARE LEAVING THE
- 46:09FIELD BECAUSE WE HAVE PAID THEM
- 46:10NOTHING.
- 46:11BECAUSE THEY DON'T HAVE HEALTH
- 46:12INSURANCE.
- 46:13BECAUSE THEY HAVE OTHER OPTIONS
- 46:15AND IT IS MORE LUCRATIVE TO WORK
- 46:17AT MCDONALD'S WHERE YOU CAN HAVE
- 46:19HEALTH INSURANCE AND GET A
- 46:22SCHOLARSHIP TO GO TO COLLEGE
- 46:23WHILE WORKING AT BURGER KING.
- 46:25THERE ARE OPTIONS AVAILABLE AND
- 46:26THE FREE MARKET ALLOWS FOR THOSE
- 46:30OPTIONS.
- 46:30BUT IF WE WANT TO HAVE WORKING
- 46:32FAMILIES PARTICULARLY WORKING
- 46:33WOMEN IN THE WORKFORCE, WE'VE
- 46:35GOT TO FIND A WAY TO SUBSIDIZE
- 46:37THAT COST N KENTUCKY A SINGLE
- 46:39PARENT WILL PAY 23% OF INCOME
- 46:42FOR ONE CHILD TO BE IN
- 46:43CHILDCARE.
- 46:44WHEN MY CHILDREN WERE LITTLE WE
- 46:47PAID $400 A MONTH FOR INFANT AND
- 46:49TODDLER THAN WE DID ON OUR
- 46:51MORTGAGE.
- 46:52THAT WAS 10 YEARS AGO.
- 46:5310 YEARS AGO THERE WAS AN ISSUE
- 46:55IT'S CONTINUING TO EXACERBATE
- 46:57AND OUR FAMILIES ARE HAVING TO
- 46:59MAKE TOUGH CHOICES BECAUSE THEY
- 47:00KNOW THEY NEED TO KEEP OTHER
- 47:03BASICS IN PLACE.
- 47:05NOW, WHAT WE'RE SEEING A LOT
- 47:07WITH OTHER SUBSIDIES, WE HAVE
- 47:09ALL THE DISCUSSIONS SHOULD WE
- 47:13SUPPLEMENT FOR FAMILIES WHEN WE
- 47:14HAVE CHILDCARE SUBSIDY IT IS
- 47:16BECAUSE A FAMILY IS TRYING TO BE
- 47:18INDEPENDENT THEY ARE TRYING TO
- 47:19WORK THEY ARE TRYING TO GO TO
- 47:20SCHOOL SO THEY WILL BE ABLE TO
- 47:22WORK IN A GIVEN FIELD THAT THEY
- 47:24WANT TO.
- 47:24THE FAMILY IS TRYING TO BE
- 47:25INDEPENDENT AND WE WANT TO
- 47:26SUPPORT THEM IN ORDER TO DO
- 47:28THAT.
- 47:28AND WE ALSO WANT TO MAKE SURE
- 47:30THOSE CHILDREN ARE IN HEALTHY
- 47:31AND SAFE PLACES AND GOOD
- 47:33LEARNING ENVIRONMENTS WHILE THE
- 47:34FAMILY WORKS.
- 47:35NO PARENT GOES TO WORK IF THEY
- 47:37ARE WORRIED ABOUT THE SAFETY OF
- 47:38THEIR CHILDREN.
- 47:39THEY LEAVE THEY GO AND GET THEIR
- 47:41CHILD AND THEY STAY HOME WITH
- 47:42THEM.
- 47:43AND THAT'S WHAT WE HAVE TO AVOID
- 47:45BECAUSE WE ALSO KNOW THAT WHEN A
- 47:48PARENT HAS RELIABLE CHILDCARE
- 47:51THEY MISS 30% LESS WORK.
- 47:53IF THEY HAVE ON-SITE CHILDCARE,
- 47:56THE TURNOVER FOR EMPLOYEES IS
- 47:58REDUCED BY 60%.
- 47:59BECAUSE LET'S SAY I'M WORKING AT
- 48:01TOYOTA AND I GET ANOTHER JOB
- 48:03OFFER MAYBE A FEW THOUSAND
- 48:05DOLLARS MORE I'M NOT GOING TO
- 48:07LEAVE IN MY CHILD IS HAPPY
- 48:08BECAUSE AS A PARENT I'M CARING
- 48:11WHAT MY CHILD NEEDS THAN MAYBE
- 48:12MY OWN BOOST IN HAPPINESS.
- 48:14EMPLOYERS HAVE THE ABILITY TO
- 48:16HAVE MORE BENEFITS FOR THEM.
- 48:18AS WELL AS CHILDREN HAVING A
- 48:20SAFE AND CARING AND LOVING
- 48:23EDUCATIONAL ENVIRONMENT.
- 48:24WHICH ALL BUILDS THE FAMILY UP.
- 48:26AND IT'S GOING TO HELP THE
- 48:28CHILDREN BE MORE PRODUCTIVE.
- 48:30>> Renee: SENATOR CARROLL I WANT
- 48:31TO ASK YOU YOUR BILL IS GOING TO
- 48:33BE HEARD HOM TOMORROW IN YOUR
- 48:34COMMITTEE AND VOTED ON TOMORROW.
- 48:37AND I IMAGINE THERE ARE CHANGES
- 48:38AND REVISIONS FROM THE ORIGINAL.
- 48:39CAN YOU SHARE WITH US WHAT WE
- 48:41CAN EXPECT TOMORROW?
- 48:42>> THERE ARE A FEW.
- 48:43JUST SOME OF THE HIGHLIGHTS WITH
- 48:45THE INNOVATIONS GRANT AND THE
- 48:47EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION CENTER
- 48:48START UP GRANTS, WE'VE INCREASED
- 48:51THE MAXIMUM AMOUNT OF THOSE
- 48:52GRANTS FROM 100,000 TO 150,000.
- 48:56ON THE FOUNDATION GRANT WHICH IS
- 48:58MUCH LIKE SEEK DOLLARS, WE'RE
- 49:00GOING TO HAVE THOSE
- 49:03DISTRIBUTIONS WILL BE I'MMY
- 49:05ANNUALLY.
- 49:05AND REQUIRING THAT ANY CENTER
- 49:07THAT RECEIVES THE FOUNDATION
- 49:09FUNDING THEY HAVE TO BE AT A
- 49:11MINIMUM OF THREE STAR CENTER
- 49:13WITHIN THREE YEARS OF THAT FIRST
- 49:15ALLOCATION.
- 49:16AND WE'RE PUTTING LIMITS ON
- 49:18PUBLIC SCHOOL ACCESS TO THESE
- 49:20FUNDS TO MAKE SURE THERE'S NO
- 49:21DOUBLE DIPPING GOING ON.
- 49:23THOSE ARE THE MAIN THINGS THAT
- 49:25WE'RE LOOKING AT.
- 49:25AND I WANT TO ADD TO SOMETHING
- 49:28THAT Dr. VANOVER SAID.
- 49:29I WAS TALKING TO ONE OF THE
- 49:31PARENTS AT OUR CENTER THE OTHER
- 49:33DAY AND SHE WAS HAVING A
- 49:34CONVERSATION ABOUT HER AND HER
- 49:35HUSBAND ABOUT HOW THEY PLAN
- 49:38THEIR FAMILY.
- 49:38AND IT USED TO BE THAT WELL, WE
- 49:40WANT TO HAVE OUR KIDS GET ONE IN
- 49:42HIGH SCHOOL, AND THEN HAVE THE
- 49:43SECOND ONE.
- 49:44THAT'S NOT THE CONVERSATION
- 49:46ANYMORE.
- 49:47OUR PARENTS PLANNED THEIR
- 49:48FAMILIES AROUND THE AVAILABILITY
- 49:50OF CHILDCARE.
- 49:51AND IF THEY HAVE A SLOT AT A
- 49:54CENTER AND THEY KNOW THEY GET
- 49:57PREFERENCE IF THEY ARE SIBLINGS
- 49:58THEY WILL HAVE THE SECOND CHILD
- 50:00BEFORE THE FIRST CHILD GRADUATES
- 50:01ON TO SCHOOL FOR THE SAVINGS AND
- 50:03TO MAKE SURE THAT THEY HAVE A
- 50:05SLOT IN THAT CENTER.
- 50:08SO THAT'S THE REALITY OF THE
- 50:09WORLD THAT WE LIVE IN TODAY.
- 50:11THAT MOST PARENTS BOTH HAVE TO
- 50:13WORK.
- 50:14AND THEY ARE PLANNING THEIR
- 50:15FAMILIES AROUND THE AVAILABILITY
- 50:18OF EARLY CHILDHOOD EDUCATION IN
- 50:18OUR STATE.
- 50:19LET THAT SINK IN A LITTLE BIT.
- 50:21THAT IS HOW WE'RE FAILING OUR
- 50:23FAMILIES.
- 50:23WE HAVE ALREADY LOST OVER THE
- 50:25LAST 10 YEARS, HALF OF OUR
- 50:27PROVIDERS.
- 50:28THIS HAS BEEN A CRISIS FOR
- 50:29YEARS.
- 50:30IT JUST CAME TO A HEAD DURING
- 50:32COVID.
- 50:33AND WE'RE GOING TO REACT TO THIS
- 50:35OR FALL IN THE PIT THAT OTHER
- 50:37STATES ARE FALLING INTO OR WE'RE
- 50:38GOING TO BE THE BRIGHT LIGHT ON
- 50:40THE HORIZON THAT IS GOING TO
- 50:42LEAD THIS COUNTRY IN THIS ISSUE.
- 50:45>> Renee: WILL YOUR BILL
- 50:47ACTUALLY CALL THOSE CENTERS BACK
- 50:48INTO BUSINESS?
- 50:491700 OR SO THAT HAVE CLOSED
- 50:51THEIR DOORS WOULD THIS BILL
- 50:53REOPEN THEM?
- 50:54>> RENEE I HOPE THERE'S
- 50:56INCENTIVE TO DO THAT.
- 50:57I HOPE.
- 50:57I DON'T KNOW IF WE'VE GOT THE
- 50:59NUMBERS RIGHT.
- 51:00TIME WILL TELL WITH THAT.
- 51:01IT'S GOING TO LET ENTREPRENEURS
- 51:04KNOW THAT THEY ARE RESPECTED
- 51:06WHAT THEY ARE DOING IN THE
- 51:08SUPPORTS GOING TO BE THERE THAT
- 51:09THEY ARE VALUED AND IT'S GOING
- 51:11TO BE A WAY THAT THEY CAN OPEN
- 51:13UP A BUSINESS AND SURVIVE AND
- 51:14TAKE CARE OF THEIR FAMILIES AND
- 51:16THE SAME WITH ANY OTHER
- 51:17BUSINESS.
- 51:18THAT IS ALL THEY ARE ASKING FOR.
- 51:19I THINK SO.
- 51:21AND MOST ALL THE PEOPLE THAT GET
- 51:23INTO THIS IT'S LIKE Dr.
- 51:25VANOVER SAID THEY ARE NOT IN IT
- 51:26FOR THE MONEY THEY ARE IN IT FOR
- 51:28THE KIDS.
- 51:29AND THEY'VE KEPT THEIR DOORS
- 51:30OPEN AS LONG AS THEY CAN BUT
- 51:33THERE COMES A POINT WHEN ARE YOU
- 51:35HAVING TO NOT PROPERLY TAKE CARE
- 51:37OF YOUR FAMILY AND YOU HAVE TO
- 51:38CHOOSE THAT OR KEEPING YOUR
- 51:40CENTER OPEN, YOU HAVE TO TAKE
- 51:42CARE OF YOUR FAMILY.
- 51:43WE HAVE TO CREATE THE
- 51:44ENVIRONMENT FOR THESE CENTERS TO
- 51:46SUCCEED TO GROW TO GROW NEW
- 51:48IDEAS AND I THINK THE FREE
- 51:50MARKET WILL TAKE CARE OF ITSELF
- 51:52AND WE'LL GET BACK ON OUR FEET
- 51:54AND THE DIVIDENDS FROM THIS
- 51:56INVESTMENT THEY ARE GOING TO BE
- 51:58ENDLESS AND OUR KIDS BEING
- 52:00BETTER EDUCATED.
- 52:01OUR FAMILIES BEING ABLE TO WORK
- 52:02WHEN THEY WANT TO WORK.
- 52:04SCHOOL CHOICE THEY CAN GO TO A
- 52:07CHURCH-LED EARLY CHILDHOOD
- 52:08EDUCATION CENTER OR A PRIVATE
- 52:09CENTER THEY CAN GO TO A PUBLIC
- 52:10SCHOOL.
- 52:11THE CHOICES ARE THERE.
- 52:12SO THERE'S SO MANY DIFFERENT
- 52:14FACETS OF THIS.
- 52:15AND ONE THING WE HAVE NOT
- 52:17TOUCHED ON IS THE SAFETY OF THE
- 52:18KIDS.
- 52:19THE MORE KIDS THAT WE CAN GET
- 52:21INTO THESE CENTERS THAT ARE IN
- 52:24CHILDCARE EARLY CHILDHOOD
- 52:25EDUCATION EVERYDAY, LOOK AT THE
- 52:27NUMBERS OF ABUSE AND NEGLECT WE
- 52:28HAVE IN OUR COMMONWEALTH.
- 52:29LOOK AT THE IMPACT THAT WE CAN
- 52:31HAVE ON THAT.
- 52:33I SEE AT LEAST ONCE A MONTH ONE
- 52:35OF OUR TEACHERS IS COMING TO ME
- 52:37CAN YOU LOOK AT THESE BRUISES.
- 52:39LOOK AT THE EARLY INTERVENTIONS
- 52:42WE CAN MAKE AND LOOK AT THE AID
- 52:44THAT WE CAN BE IN THAT AREA TO
- 52:46LOWER THOSE NUMBERS TO BETTER
- 52:48PROTECT OUR CHILD.
- 52:49THAT IS ANOTHER REASON WHY WE
- 52:51NEED TO EXPAND PROVIDERS AND
- 52:53NEED TO HAVE KIDSES MANY KIDS AS
- 52:56WE CAN GET IN THE CENTERS WITH
- 52:57THE PARENTS MAKING THOSE
- 52:59DECISIONS WHERE THEY WANT THE
- 53:01KIDS TO BE.
- 53:01>> Renee: ONE ISSUE WE HAVE NOT
- 53:03TALKED ABOUT AND NOT SENATOR
- 53:04CARROLL'S BILL, BUT IT'S
- 53:08REPRESENTATIVE HEF RIN'S, HOUSE
- 53:09BILL 561 THAT DEALS WITH ZONING
- 53:11AND LAND USE.
- 53:12PEOPLE ARE THINKING THAT HAS TO
- 53:14DO WITH CHILDCARE BUT IT DOES.
- 53:16TELL US HOW.
- 53:17>> WE SUPPORT THIS LEGISLATION.
- 53:21THIS GETS AT LAND USE
- 53:23RESTRICTIONS RELATED TO
- 53:24CHILDCARE.
- 53:24AS WE WORK ON AFFORDABILITY
- 53:25ISSUES THE OTHER PIECE OF THE
- 53:28EQUATION ARE HE WE REMOVING
- 53:30BARRIERS THAT MAY EXIST IN A
- 53:32LOCAL COMMUNITY TO STARTING NEW
- 53:33CHILDCARE SERVICES WHETHER IT'S
- 53:35IN YOUR HOME, OR IN A BRICK AND
- 53:37MORTAR FACILITY, AND IT CREATES
- 53:40THE CHILDCARE READY COMMUNITY
- 53:41PROGRAM AND IT'S MODELED AFTER A
- 53:44POPULAR RECOVERY READY COMMUNITY
- 53:45PROGRAM AND IT EMPOWERS LOCAL
- 53:49GOVERNMENTS TO BRING LOCAL
- 53:49COMMUNITIES TO BRING TOGETHER
- 53:51STAKEHOLDERS TO LOOK AT THEIR
- 53:53LAND USE RESTRICTIONS THAT MIGHT
- 53:55EXIST AND REMOVE ANY BARRIERS TO
- 53:57CHILDCARE AND ALSO TO CREATE
- 53:59RESOURCES FOR PEOPLE IN THE
- 54:01COMMUNITY WHO MAY WANT TO START
- 54:03CHILDCARE FACILITIES.
- 54:04>> Renee: THEY MAY NOT KNOW THE
- 54:06BARRIERS EXIST.
- 54:07AND THEY TONIGHT'S KNOW HOW TO
- 54:10GET AROUND THEM AND THERE'S BEEN
- 54:11CHANGES.
- 54:12IT IS A A PROACTIVE BILL TO DEAL
- 54:15WITH THE CHILDCAREDERS EARTHS.
- 54:18WHEN I THINK ABOUT THE EMPLOYER
- 54:20TALKING TO ME ABOUT THE EMPLOYEE
- 54:23TALKING 45 MINUTES EACH WAY.
- 54:26AND THAT IS A STRONG MESSAGE THE
- 54:28COMMUNITIES CAN SEND TO
- 54:31BUSINESSES WANTS TO STAY IN
- 54:32THOSE COMMUNITIES THAT THEY ARE
- 54:33SERIOUS ABOUT ADDRESSING THESE
- 54:34PROBLEMS.
- 54:35IT IS A COMPETITIVENESS ISSUE AN
- 54:38ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT ISSUE AND
- 54:39SOMETHING THAT I THINK WE NEED
- 54:41TO SEE THOSE LOCAL COMMUNITIES
- 54:43COMING TOGETHER AND TALKING
- 54:44ABOUT AND WORKING ON IN ADDITION
- 54:45TO WHAT WE'VE TALKED ABOUT.
- 54:47>> Renee: ANY ISSUES WITH THAT
- 54:48Mr. McNEILL?
- 54:49>> NO, IT SEEMED LIKE A GOOD
- 54:52DISCUSSION AND COMMITTEE ON
- 54:53THURSDAY.
- 54:53I POINT OUT THAT THE
- 54:55REPRESENTATIVE ALSO BROUGHT A
- 54:56JOINT RESOLUTION OUT OF
- 54:58COMMITTEE LAST WEEK TO
- 54:59REESTABLISH THE CHILDCARE TASK
- 55:02FORCE.
- 55:03SHE SEEMED TO INDICATE THAT A
- 55:07BILL LIKE SENATE BILL 203 MIGHT
- 55:09BE FACED WITH HEADWINDS IN THE
- 55:10HOUSE.
- 55:11SO SHE DIDN'T WANT TO
- 55:13SHORTCHANGE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
- 55:15CONTINUE THE CONVERSATION DURING
- 55:16THE INTERIM.
- 55:17I THINK THAT THAT IS SOMETHING
- 55:18THAT IS VALID AND THE
- 55:21OPPORTUNITY FOR THAT
- 55:23CONVERSATION TO CONTINUE IS
- 55:24SOMETHING THAT IS IMPORTANT FOR
- 55:25THE STATE.
- 55:25WE RECOGNIZE THAT.
- 55:27>> Renee: WE'LL KEEP OUR EYES ON
- 55:28IT AND TOMORROW 9:00 A.M. IS THE
- 55:31COMMITTEE HEARING?
- 55:32KET WILL BE CARRYING THAT YOU
- 55:33CAN WATCH THAT ON-LINE AT
- 55:35KET.ORG.
- 55:36AND ALSO ON THE KENTUCKY CHANNEL
- 55:38WE WILL BE CARRYING IT THERE AS
- 55:41WELL.
- 55:41WE THANK YOU FOR A GREAT
- 55:42DISCUSSION ABOUT THIS VERY
- 55:44IMPORTANT ISSUE.
- 55:45AND WE HAD A SPECIAL REPORT THAT
- 55:47DEBUTED LAST WEEK CALLED SMART
- 55:49START AND IF YOU DID NOT GET A
- 55:51CHANCE TO SEE THAT Dr. VANOVER
- 55:53WAS IN IT AND OTHERS KATE WAS IN
- 55:55IT.
- 55:55WE WOULD LOVE FOR YOU TO GO
- 55:58ON-LINE AT KET.ORG AND IT TALKS
- 56:02ABOUT THE IMPORTANCE OF EARLY
- 56:04CHILDHOOD EDUCATION.
- 56:04WE DON'T TALK POLICY WE TALK
- 56:06ABOUT BRAIN DEVELOPMENT.
- 56:08AND THE WORKFORCE ISSUE
- 56:09SURROUNDING IT.
- 56:10WE HOPE YOU WILL CHECK THAT OUT.
- 56:12WE ARE BACK IN TWO WEEKS AND
- 56:14WE'LL TALK ABOUT SCHOOL SAFETY.
- 56:15THERE IS A BILL FROM SENATOR
- 56:17WISE THAT DEALS WITH THAT AND
- 56:19WE'LL BREAK THAT DOWN IN TWO
- 56:21WEEKS ON "KENTUCKY TONIGHT".
- 56:22MAKE SURE YOU JOIN US TOMORROW
- 56:24NIGHT 6:30 EASTERN FOR KENTUCKY
- 56:26EDITION AND WE'LL TALK MORE
- 56:28ABOUT SENATE BILL 203.
- 56:30THANKS FOR WATCHING.
- 56:31I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 56:32TAKE GOOD CARE.