Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Demons on Motorcycles: When Psychiatric Breaks Meet Civil Responsibility
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment Legally Speaking, joined as always by barrister and solicitor with Mulligan Defence Lawyers.
- 0:05Adam Stirling: Morning, Michael Mulligan, or afternoon I should say Michael Mulligan, force of habit.
- 0:09Adam Stirling: How are you doing this week?
- 0:11Michael Mulligan: Hey, good afternoon.
- 0:12Michael Mulligan: I'm doing great.
- 0:12Michael Mulligan: Always good to be here.
- 0:14Adam Stirling: A really interesting story off the top today because it deals with a phenomenon that you and I have discussed any number of times during recent segments, and that is the intersection that can happen with unlawful behavior that is motivated by a person who may be suffering from some sort of psychiatric disorder, and how the legal system deals with that in different situations.
- 0:33Adam Stirling: I'm reading here it says driver who believed a motorcyclist was a demon liable for accident.
- 0:39Adam Stirling: What happened?
- 0:41Michael Mulligan: Well, it's a tragic case from 2018 in Vancouver and it's particularly interesting because it deals with the issue of how severe mental illness or episode interfaces with civil liability rather than criminal liability.
- 1:00Michael Mulligan: Context right, we don't punish people if they're not criminally responsible as a result of a mental disorder, which involves an assessment of things, including whether they're able to, you know, understand the nature and quality of what they're doing or what they're doing was wrong.
- 1:13Michael Mulligan: Right, because a criminal law is interested in punishing, you know, intentional wrongdoing, not, you know, accidents or people that think they're fighting off demons right Now, as we've talked about, being found not criminally responsible does not mean you go free.
- 1:28Michael Mulligan: It usually means you're in a mental hospital, in a secure facility, until there's a determination made that you're not a danger to the public, which could be for the rest of your life, but that's criminal, and what we're dealing with here is civil.
- 1:40Michael Mulligan: Back in the days before, we had no fault and no one's responsible for anything.
- 1:44Michael Mulligan: Back in the days before we had no fault and no one's responsible for anything.
- 1:50Michael Mulligan: The case involved a civil claim brought by a motorcycle rider who was intentionally run into on the Lions Gate Bridge, and it happened, as I said, in 2018, september.
- 1:58Michael Mulligan: The motorcycle rider and a friend were out for a pleasant motorcycle ride in North Vancouver.
- 2:04Michael Mulligan: They're coming across a bridge and, very unfortunately for them, behind them was this fellow who had no previous history of any psychiatric issues at all, which was important to the case fellow over a period of three days.
- 2:25Michael Mulligan: As a result, it sounds like of sort of a combination of various stressors and a dangerous job and finding out about the death of a neighbor and a workplace injury and lack of sleep, various things.
- 2:33Michael Mulligan: He had this complete break with reality where he had these paranoid delusions eventually, where he thought that there were demons that he needed to protect people from and he thought these two people on two motorcycles were demons that he needed to protect people from.
- 2:45Michael Mulligan: And he thought these two people on two motorcycles were demons.
- 2:49Michael Mulligan: And so he decided to ram his Audi not his Audi, actually, that's interesting too.
- 2:54Michael Mulligan: It was his ex-girlfriend's Audi, now ex-girlfriend's Audi into the back of one of them, throwing one of the men off his motorcycle who went skidding along the road.
- 3:04Michael Mulligan: It caused all kinds of it caused various things torn rotator cuff and sprained, wrinkle, wrist and ankle Described.
- 3:11Michael Mulligan: You know, going along the sidewalk with belts flying off or sparks, flying off of a metal thing on his belt Awful, I must say.
- 3:19Michael Mulligan: Very fortunate it wasn't worse, yeah, but that fellow wound up making a civil claim suing both this man, the driver of the Audi and the owner of the Audi the man's then-girlfriend.
- 3:33Michael Mulligan: And there's provisions in the Insurance Motor Vehicle Act that make the owner of a vehicle liable when they allow other people to use it, which is also important to know.
- 3:42Michael Mulligan: Yeah, now the claim involved claims for, you know, non-pecuniary, like pain and suffering, but also for lost future earnings, which is often a big thing.
- 3:53Michael Mulligan: The man was described as a voice actor who does animated productions, commercials and video games.
- 3:58Michael Mulligan: So you know, maybe he's the voice of Super Mario Brothers, who knows.
- 4:00Michael Mulligan: But he alleged that his income went down as a result of the injuries that he suffered that night.
- 4:07Michael Mulligan: Now here's why it's a really challenging problem to get your head around in terms of how does mental illness and this kind of a clear?
- 4:16Michael Mulligan: Everyone agreed this man had this breakdown.
- 4:19Michael Mulligan: He genuinely thought there were demons and flames coming out from under the bridge and he thought he was saving people.
- 4:24Michael Mulligan: You know, earlier that day he found himself in an Ikea parking lot with an impulse to go up and try to help people he thought were in danger.
- 4:34Michael Mulligan: So clearly the man had this complete breakdown.
- 4:36Michael Mulligan: But the reason it's challenging from a civil liability perspective is well, civil liability is not concerned with punishing people and wrongdoing.
- 4:47Michael Mulligan: It's concerned with compensation for loss.
- 4:49Michael Mulligan: But the basis of the civil claim, really there are two elements to it.
- 4:54Michael Mulligan: One was a claim in what's called negligence, and negligence involves there being a person who has a duty of care to somebody else.
- 5:00Michael Mulligan: Like when you're driving your car, you've got a duty of care to be careful, so you don't like to somebody else.
- 5:04Michael Mulligan: Like when you're driving your car, you've got a duty of care to be careful, so you don't like run into people.
- 5:07Michael Mulligan: Well, at least you did, and so there's that.
- 5:09Michael Mulligan: And then, if you establish that you have a duty of care, you have to show that the person was negligent or careless, right.
- 5:15Michael Mulligan: And the reason that is challenging in this context is there are some circumstances in which, let's say, a person with no prior history is driving along and they suffer an aneurysm brain, aneurysm right and they lose control and they crash into somebody, injuring them.
- 5:31Michael Mulligan: Well, there may be no negligence there, right, if the person had no reason to think they were going to have a brain aneurysm, just suddenly just hit them right and they lost control.
- 5:39Michael Mulligan: Well, they didn't have any control over their actions, they weren't like sort of careless leading up to it, nothing, it just happened, right.
- 5:47Michael Mulligan: And similarly the action was also framed in what's called battery, and battery is kind of the civil cousin of the criminal idea of assaulting somebody.
- 5:58Michael Mulligan: Right, and here that was framed that way as well, because the man like it wasn't an accident, he like intentionally drove his car into the motorcycle thinking he was being driven by a demon.
- 6:08Michael Mulligan: And so then the issue there is well, is that captured right, you know?
- 6:15Michael Mulligan: What degree of you know mental capacity do you have to have at the time for that as well?
- 6:20Michael Mulligan: So that's what the judge was struggling with in this just fascinating case.
- 6:23Michael Mulligan: And, as the judge points out, the law about this is all over the map.
- 6:28Michael Mulligan: The judge actually had to attach this is interesting, they had to attach an appendix outlining all the different ways this has been dealt with in different common law jurisdictions, different provinces in Canada, and some of the law is now quite old, and so the judge had to struggle with all of those concepts.
- 6:48Michael Mulligan: Well, what do you do with this?
- 6:50Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 6:51Michael Mulligan: And ultimately, the approach the judge took to it is similar to an approach that can be taken in some cases involving things like heart attacks, where the heart attack causes the car accident.
- 7:02Michael Mulligan: Right, because here's the argument.
- 7:05Michael Mulligan: The argument made was look, you know, clearly at the time the man had no capacity to know that he had a duty of care to anyone.
- 7:13Michael Mulligan: He was just kind of right in a completely different world.
- 7:17Michael Mulligan: But the argument by the plaintiff was well, you shouldn't look at just like what happened in the hour or two before or the few minutes before, and the analogy there would be like, for example, with a heart attack that causes a car accident.
- 7:29Michael Mulligan: You know, if somebody's driving along, no problem at all, and they just have a sudden massive heart attack, they lose control, they're probably not negligent.
- 7:36Michael Mulligan: But let's say, on the other hand, you say to yourself, boy, you know, my chest really hurts, I've got a real pain there, boy, I think I'm in trouble.
- 7:45Michael Mulligan: And you just say, well, I don't really want to get an ambulance, I'll just drive myself to the hospital.
- 7:49Michael Mulligan: And then you in fact lose control driving there.
- 7:52Michael Mulligan: Well, at that very last moment.
- 7:54Michael Mulligan: Yeah, that might be out of your control or capacity right to do anything about.
- 7:58Michael Mulligan: But the judge looked at here the fact that this man had some idea that things were going wrong over the past couple of days, like the previous couple of days, like he left work thinking he couldn't safely operate equipment and he seemed to kind of degrade over a couple of days, eventually getting into this completely psychotic state.
- 8:16Michael Mulligan: A pretty good balancing is, the judge concluded.
- 8:19Michael Mulligan: Look, even though he may have not had any capacity to do anything or recognize the standard of care at the time when he was so deep into this psychosis that he thought there were demons on motorcycles, he wasn't in that state for the whole period of time.
- 8:36Michael Mulligan: He seemed to recognize that he had periods, while his memory as to what was going on over the preceding two or three days was spotty.
- 8:42Michael Mulligan: There was like evidence from his girlfriend at the time that he seemed lucid and fine on the phone.
- 8:47Michael Mulligan: Uh, you know that morning.
- 8:49Michael Mulligan: But then, like shortly before he did this, he had stopped his car and phoned her and she was clearly very concerned that he had, you know, had lost touch with reality to the point where she phoned like nine one one thing, oh my God, and told him don't drive, pulled out and went and did this right.
- 9:10Michael Mulligan: But the idea of the liability here and a similar approach might be taken to somebody who drinks a whole lot of alcohol, right, the idea that, hey, you're drinking, you're drinking, you're getting really drunk, you're getting really drunk and then you're blackout drunk when you hop in your car and go and hit somebody, right, you can also make.
- 9:27Michael Mulligan: Well, I can appreciate at the time you just passed out in your car, but the analysis isn't your obligation or your duty of care extends beyond that last moment when you passed out.
- 9:37Michael Mulligan: From all the alcohol you drank, right.
- 9:39Michael Mulligan: And so that was the approach the judge applied here and found that, even though at that last minute, in the last few minutes, he didn't have that kind of capacity, there was still negligence which is much lower.
- 9:50Michael Mulligan: Punishing him, we're just sorting out liability money really, and so that was sufficient.
- 9:55Michael Mulligan: Also, interestingly, the judge found that the ex-girlfriend is also liable because it's her vehicle and she had allowed him to use the vehicle and, even though she got this final phone call from him, told him you know, my God, don't drive, don't go anywhere, and phoned 911 and called his brother and tried to stop him from driving before this happened.
- 10:16Michael Mulligan: There's a section of the insurance motor vehicle or a motor vehicle like Section 86, that when a person acquires a motor vehicle with consent of the owner and he had, she'd let him use her Audi you become liable for accidents that happen with it and so, even though she tried to do things to intervene, she's also on the hook for it.
- 10:36Michael Mulligan: And so at the end of the day it's a substantial judgment.
- 10:41Michael Mulligan: The voice actor who was seriously hurt.
- 10:42Michael Mulligan: He'd asked for $1.4 million.
- 10:44Michael Mulligan: He didn't get that but the award was for $429,000.
- 10:49Michael Mulligan: And there are going to be some interesting insurance issue coverage issues here, because, for example, your ICBC coverage again back at the time when we were responsible for our actions doesn't cover somebody who engages in battery, like you're not insured for intentionally ramming somebody with your car, not surprisingly, how do you insure that right?
- 11:08Michael Mulligan: So there's going to be a really interesting issue here.
- 11:11Michael Mulligan: The claim was allowed on both that battery and negligence.
- 11:14Michael Mulligan: No doubt negligence would be covered by the insurance, but it may be, at the end of the day, this man who had the psychotic break and, interestingly, no issue since he went to treatment.
- 11:25Michael Mulligan: He took medication no problem for the past six years.
- 11:28Michael Mulligan: This was a one-time thing.
- 11:29Michael Mulligan: By all accounts, he and his ex-girlfriend may wind up personally on the hook on the basis that the judge found there's also liability in battery, which isn't something covered by your insurance.
- 11:40Michael Mulligan: So it's a fascinating case and that's how sort of mental health and so on can interface with not only criminal liability but civil liability.
- 11:50Michael Mulligan: And that was the latest from the BC Supreme supreme court trying to sort out different laws all across the country and all around the world michael mulligan with mulligan defense lawyers.
- 11:58Adam Stirling: Legally speaking will continue right after this legally speaking continues on cfax 1070 with michael mulligan, barrister solicitor, with mulligan defense lawyers.
- 12:07Adam Stirling: Michael up next it says the misapplication of the step-up principle results in a reduced jail sentence for contempt of court multiple times, and it's a matter that we've been following for years now.
- 12:18Michael Mulligan: It feels like that's true, and so it's one of the cases that comes out of those flying squirrel protests where there were a whole bunch of people convicted of criminal contempt.
- 12:29Michael Mulligan: Ultimately and the case is notable for several reasons it's a court of appeal decision dealing with a sentence imposed on a woman, ms Davidson, who is a public figure in the sense that she's a deputy leader of the Green Party and a candidate in the upcoming federal election in the Northwest Territories.
- 12:46Michael Mulligan: And Ms Davidson, in this case, had a trial and was ultimately convicted of seven counts of criminal contempt for breaching court orders restricting the way in which people could protest to try to stop logging.
- 13:02Michael Mulligan: And, as the trial judge and the Court of Appeal point out here, criminal contempt is an offense that they quote strikes at the heart of the rule of law, right.
- 13:11Michael Mulligan: Offense that they quote strikes at the heart of the rule of law right.
- 13:15Michael Mulligan: You don't have the rule of law.
- 13:16Michael Mulligan: People just ignore laws that they don't like, even if they feel strongly about it, which, I must say, is it's rather ironic that somebody convicted of seven counts of criminal contempt is running for election.
- 13:24Michael Mulligan: You wonder why bother if you're interested in participating in making laws, if your position appears to be just ignore them if you don't like them.
- 13:33Michael Mulligan: That's a rather incongruent proposition, and so it's interesting, of course, that so far they're still having her continue in that role, although I suppose influenced by the fact that one of the co-leaders of the Green Party local candidate here, ms May, was also convicted of criminal contempt on other occasions, so maybe that tempers their view of it.
- 13:56Michael Mulligan: But in any case, this woman is convicted of these seven counts of criminal contempt following a trial, and the Crown and Defence have different positions on sentencing at the time.
- 14:07Michael Mulligan: The Crown's asking for, I think, 51 days plus a period of community work service and probation, and Defence counsel is asking for time served.
- 14:16Michael Mulligan: The woman had spent 12 days in custody, I guess, waiting during her various arrests, I guess, and the judge in the case interestingly imposes more than what the Crown was asking for.
- 14:27Michael Mulligan: The Crown wanted 51 days, the judge gives 60 days and the arguments on the appeal they were several, and the appeal was conducted on behalf of the woman by Mr Isset, former city councillor here, who's obviously doing a good job for his client.
- 14:42Michael Mulligan: Lots of interesting legal arguments here, but it flows from a case NAHANE.
- 14:53Michael Mulligan: It's a case that went to the Supreme Court of Canada, which stands for the proposition that where a judge is going to impose more like a longer sentence on what the Crown is asking for, a judge is required to give counsel an opportunity to make further submissions about that, right, okay, well, the Crown is asking for 51, I'm going to give 60,.
- 15:14Michael Mulligan: What do you say about that Anything more?
- 15:16Michael Mulligan: I should take into account, right, so he made that argument.
- 15:18Michael Mulligan: The Court of Appeal found that didn't have merit here because the judge made clear in his interaction with Crown including about that other concept, that step-up principle that made clear that the judge had a concern that the sentence the Crown was asking for is not sufficient.
- 15:34Michael Mulligan: So it wasn't a circumstance where Defence Council didn't have an opportunity to provide more information that might explain why the sentence would be appropriate, or the Crown to provide more information about why they're taking the position.
- 15:45Michael Mulligan: They did.
- 15:46Michael Mulligan: That happened and the problem that was identified was an issue with how the judge applied that thing.
- 15:54Michael Mulligan: You mentioned the step-up principle.
- 15:56Michael Mulligan: Now, the step-up principle is the way it's sometimes expressed is sort of the idea that you know if you keep getting convicted of the same thing, your sentence is going to go up, which probably doesn't need a principle to establish it.
- 16:10Michael Mulligan: I'm sure anyone listening would think, yeah, that kind of how it's how it works, right?
- 16:13Michael Mulligan: You don't usually get lesser and lesser sentences if you just keep doing the same thing, indeed.
- 16:18Michael Mulligan: But.
- 16:19Michael Mulligan: But the reason it was an issue here the Court of Appeal identified is how the judge expressed that in that discussion with the Crown.
- 16:28Michael Mulligan: Remember, the Crown says we say 51 days, crown's like well, hold on a minute.
- 16:31Michael Mulligan: Is that really, taking into account the repeated activity here and the way the judge expressed it is a way that sometimes you do hear it expressed in court but it's not quite right.
- 16:44Michael Mulligan: It is a way that sometimes you do hear it expressed in court but it's not quite right.
- 16:48Michael Mulligan: And what the judge expressed to Crown was the idea that he expressed it this way.
- 16:51Michael Mulligan: The judge said surely she keeps going back, she keeps flaunting the orders of the court, she keeps disobeying them Each time, successively, she does that.
- 16:59Michael Mulligan: Doesn't the step up principle oblige me?
- 17:01Michael Mulligan: Doesn't it oblige me?
- 17:03Michael Mulligan: Doesn't it suggest that for each successive breach I found there has to be an increase in the sanction?
- 17:08Michael Mulligan: That's how the judge asked the question to Crown and this is also an example of why it's important that judges, you know everything in court is recorded.
- 17:17Michael Mulligan: It's public right and judges have to give reasons for what they're doing.
- 17:21Michael Mulligan: So you can, like this, look at it afterwards.
- 17:23Michael Mulligan: Did they do it right?
- 17:24Michael Mulligan: And that concept, the Court of Appeal pointed out, is the way the judge expressed it.
- 17:31Michael Mulligan: The former now retired former chief judge or the chief justice of the province was wrong and the Court of Appeal pointed out, and there's previous authority for this.
- 17:43Michael Mulligan: And the Court of Appeal pointed out, and there's previous authority for this, is that the concept, the step-up principle, does not require a judge to impose greater and greater sentences every time.
- 17:50Michael Mulligan: They might do that, right, they're not obliged to.
- 17:54Michael Mulligan: It's not a requirement, step-up principle.
- 18:00Michael Mulligan: Not only does it not require a judge to increase sentences for each count, like each time somebody does something.
- 18:06Michael Mulligan: It in fact is a way to express the idea that there has to be a measured increase, right, like you know, each time it shouldn't be.
- 18:14Michael Mulligan: Well, you know, last time a person got, you know, two weeks for shoplifting, they shoplifted again and the judge shouldn't just say, okay, this time it's going to be three years in prison.
- 18:23Michael Mulligan: They shoplift it again and the judge shouldn't just say, okay, this time it's going to be three years in prison, right, the idea properly expressed would be.
- 18:27Michael Mulligan: A judge can, of course, take that into account.
- 18:30Michael Mulligan: It might impose a greater sentence, but there should be consideration given to the sentence that occurred on the last occasion and there should be some sort of moderation or measure in terms of how much you're increasing it.
- 18:43Michael Mulligan: And so the Court of Appeals expressed it's not an obligation to make it more, it is a suggestion or a requirement that judges moderate how much they're jumping up each time, which is a very different thing.
- 18:54Michael Mulligan: And so the Court of Appeals found the judge was mistaken when he expressed that idea that he was obliged to impose more than the Crown was asking for on the basis of that principle.
- 19:04Michael Mulligan: The judge just didn't properly understand that principle which, in fairness to the judge, that's a subtle difference, right, but it is a meaningful difference.
- 19:13Michael Mulligan: And it's another example of how there are all kinds of restraints on what a judge is allowed to do.
- 19:19Michael Mulligan: Right, judges aren't just unfettered kind of going off imposing whatever sentence they kind of feel like that day.
- 19:26Michael Mulligan: This is an example of one of the kind of legal constraints, because it's not an emotional process, it's supposed to be a process of reason and logic and consistency and so on.
- 19:37Michael Mulligan: The other thing that's worth pointing out and some people may not be aware of this is that we mentioned that, that idea about giving the lawyers a chance to respond or give additional information if the judge is going to do more than what one of them is asking for.
- 19:50Michael Mulligan: Right, that seems fair.
- 19:51Michael Mulligan: But the other thing people should know about is there's another Supreme Court-accounted case, anthony Cook, that actually restricts a judge's ability to depart when there's an agreement between the two lawyers, like if the defense and Crown make an agreement and say look, okay, my client will plead guilty to criminal contempt if you, crown, would agree to ask for, let's say, 45 days and I'll agree to ask for the same thing.
- 20:14Michael Mulligan: Right, you have a deal.
- 20:15Michael Mulligan: When that happens and it's made clear to the judge that this is a joint submission, both lawyers have agreed and that's the basis upon which the person pled guilty, in that case, a judge has very little discretion to depart from it.
- 20:28Michael Mulligan: They can only be departing from what both lawyers are asking them to do.
- 20:32Michael Mulligan: If imposing what's being asked for there would bring the administration of justice into disrepute, it's completely inappropriate.
- 20:38Michael Mulligan: If people look at that and be well, that's just outrageous.
- 20:40Michael Mulligan: I'm not doing that, right, then they can depart from it.
- 20:43Michael Mulligan: But short of that very high bar, a judge must do what they're being told to do.
- 20:48Michael Mulligan: They can't monkey with it right, and the reason for the law being that way is that otherwise no case would resolve, like everything would just go to trial.
- 20:57Michael Mulligan: If it was just a topsy-turvy world where judges could do whatever they felt like, regardless of whether there was an agreement or not, you would not have cases resolving, and most criminal cases result by a guilty plea, and that's one of the reasons why.
- 21:09Michael Mulligan: So that's another example of how judges can't just do whatever they want.
- 21:14Michael Mulligan: In some cases, the lawyers have much more control over the sentence than the judge would.
- 21:18Michael Mulligan: Now, this was a case where there wasn't a joint submission, so the judge did have authority to depart from it, didn't breach that obligation to give each side a chance to say more, because it made clear there was a problem, but made a mistake in terms of how he did it.
- 21:30Michael Mulligan: The net result the sentence originally imposed was 60 days, reduced by 12 for the time already spent in jail, and the Court of Appeal reduced that to 51 days, what the Crown had originally asked for.
- 21:42Adam Stirling: All right.
- 21:43Michael Mulligan: And so found that she'll need to serve 39 more days.
- 21:45Michael Mulligan: Also, interestingly said, she'll have to start serving that on April the 24th, which will be just before the upcoming federal election.
- 21:52Michael Mulligan: So I guess if she wants to vote for herself she'll need to do that in an advanced poll.
- 21:56Michael Mulligan: Also interestingly, she was given some time to start serving it.
- 21:59Michael Mulligan: Often with these appeals a person has to turn themselves in before the appeal is heard and then would continue serving it if the jail sentence continues.
- 22:06Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from Ms Davison the sentence appeal and the step-up principle.
- 22:11Adam Stirling: All right.
- 22:11Adam Stirling: I believe her counsel issued a press release either yesterday or the day before saying that they intend to appeal the matter to the Supreme Court of Canada and were hopeful to get bail as early as today.
- 22:20Michael Mulligan: Well, you can always ask, but you don't get to go to the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 22:23Michael Mulligan: Because you're keen, you have to ask permission no-transcript.
- 22:34Adam Stirling: Cfax 1070.