Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Alphabet Q3 2025 Financial Analysis
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the deep dive. OK, today we're jumping straight
- 0:03in, really getting under the hood of, well, a giant Alphabet,
- 0:08Google's parent company. That's right, we've got the
- 0:10latest research, including those pretty stunning Q32025 results.
- 0:15Exactly. And our mission today to put
- 0:18Alphabet through its paces. We're talking a classic value
- 0:22investing analysis, like the Buffett Checklist to figure out
- 0:24its real quality, how durable it is, and you know what it might
- 0:28actually be worth. Yeah.
- 0:29And it's crucial, I think, to look past just the big headline
- 0:33figures. I mean, they're impressive,
- 0:34sure, but we need to pull together the recent performance,
- 0:37the strength of its competitive edge, its Moat and importantly,
- 0:41the risks. And there's some significant
- 0:42ones, especially on the regulatory.
- 0:44Front, definitely. And Q32025, wow, what a place to
- 0:47start. Their first ever $100 billion
- 0:49quarter 102 $3 billion in revenue.
- 0:51Incredible scale. And net income up 33% year over
- 0:55year, that's that's huge growth, especially when you think about
- 0:58the wider economy. It was broad based too.
- 1:00Defying the headwinds, yeah. So let's talk about that scale.
- 1:02It's easy to get caught up in the, you know, the futuristic
- 1:04stuff, AI, Waymo, the cloud. But financially, how much of
- 1:10Alphabets income still relies on plain old advertising?
- 1:13What do you think the percentage is?
- 1:14Well. It might surprise some people.
- 1:16It's still the vast majority. We're talking roughly 75%, maybe
- 1:19even 80% of the revenue comes from ads, Google search and
- 1:23YouTube primarily. Wow, so 7580% despite all the
- 1:26diversification. Time exactly.
- 1:28The core engine is still that ad network they've built over what
- 1:312 decades now? Now cloud is growing fast, don't
- 1:33get me wrong, it jumped 34% in Q325 and it's.
- 1:37Profitable now. Right.
- 1:38Yes, profitable in making up about 12 percent of revenue.
- 1:40Plus they have a cloud backlog of $155 billion.
- 1:44So it's significant, just not the main driver yet.
- 1:46And the user base feeding this, it's just staggering.
- 1:49Over 90% of search market share globally, YouTube 2 billion plus
- 1:53monthly logged in users and Android is running on something
- 1:57like 3 billion devices. It's mind boggling.
- 2:00They also mentioned I think over 300 million paid subscriptions
- 2:03now for Google One YouTube Premium.
- 2:05Yeah, that's a growing piece. It shows they're finding other
- 2:08ways to monetize, even if ads are still king.
- 2:10So how does that scale translate into their competitive
- 2:13advantage, Their Moat? Well, it's multifaceted.
- 2:16First, the sheer data scale is immense.
- 2:19All those searches, all those video views they feed, the
- 2:22machine learning, making their products better, that creates
- 2:24powerful network effects. More users need more
- 2:27advertisers. Exactly who then pay more?
- 2:29Which funds more engineering, which improves the product,
- 2:31attracting more users? It's a virtuous cycle.
- 2:35And then there's the ecosystem. Android, Chrome, Gmail.
- 2:38Right, it all works together. Makes switching away a real pain
- 2:40for users. High switching costs.
- 2:43That's a strong Moat. It sounds like an impenetrable
- 2:45fortress, but big fortresses attract big cannons, right?
- 2:51Let's talk risks. What are the major headwinds?
- 2:54OK, near term, the biggest one have to be regulation.
- 2:57Specifically, that September 2025 US District Court ruling
- 3:02finding Google violated antitrust laws in its ad tech
- 3:05business. That's huge.
- 3:06First time for a major US tech firm in decades.
- 3:10Decades, yeah. It's under appeal, of course,
- 3:13but the headline risk alone is significant.
- 3:16And then there's the potential structural risk.
- 3:18What if regulators force changes, break up divestitures?
- 3:22That could fundamentally change everything.
- 3:23That's the immediate fire. What about longer term threats
- 3:27like technological disruption? How seriously should we take
- 3:31things like Chat GT potentially replacing search?
- 3:36Very seriously. I mean, if an AI chat bot gives
- 3:39you the perfect summarized answer, you don't need to click
- 3:41on those 10 blue links. Where?
- 3:43The ads are. Precisely.
- 3:44It cuts off the monetization right there.
- 3:46Plus you see shifts in user behavior, especially younger
- 3:49users. They might search for products
- 3:50on TikTok now or go straight to Amazon.
- 3:52Google gets bypassed. So major legal battles,
- 3:55potential tech disruption, yet they still need to spend
- 3:58massively just to keep the lights on and innovate, right?
- 4:01Yeah. What are the biggest costs
- 4:02pressuring those nice margins besides R&D?
- 4:05The. Big one is TAC traffic
- 4:06acquisition costs. Right, TAC, that's not an
- 4:08internal cost, is it? That's money paid out, correct?
- 4:11It's essentially what they pay partners, Apple being the most
- 4:14famous example to keep Google as the default search engine on
- 4:17phones and browsers. And that number is it.
- 4:20Was huge in 2024. Fifty, $4.9 billion.
- 4:23That's about 22% of their entire Google advertising revenue.
- 4:27And its competition for that default spot heats up.
- 4:29TAC tends to rise, squeezing gross margins.
- 4:32Ouch. And the other big cost?
- 4:34Research and development R&D hit $49.3 billion in 2024.
- 4:39Mostly fixed labor costs. Engineers basically driving AI
- 4:43and cloud development. It's essential spending, but
- 4:45massive but. They did show some cost
- 4:47discipline with those layoffs early in 2023, right?
- 4:49About 12,000 people they. Did it signaled they are
- 4:51watching those fixed costs, which investors probably
- 4:54appreciate it. OK.
- 4:55So we have this picture, a super high quality company gushing
- 4:58cash but facing really significant risks and rising
- 5:01costs. Now before we get to the final
- 5:04valuation puzzle, if you find this kind of deep dive useful
- 5:07and you want a tool to track the overall market's temperature
- 5:10using similar value principles, check out the iOS app Buffett
- 5:13Indicator. You can search for it on the
- 5:15Apple App Store. It gives you daily updates on
- 5:17market valuation levels. Just search Buffett Indicator
- 5:20right? So let's apply that Buffett
- 5:22style checklist to Alphabet itself.
- 5:24High quality business, yes. But is it a good purchase based
- 5:27on those classic metrics where? Does it pass with flying colors
- 5:30well? Pretty much everywhere on the
- 5:31quality side. First balance sheet safety.
- 5:34It's extreme. Debt to equity was just .03 in
- 5:372024. Basically no debt.
- 5:39Rock solid liquidity. Excellent current ratio well
- 5:42above 1.5. Plenty of cash and short term
- 5:45assets but. Does holding so much cash and
- 5:47avoiding leverage maybe hold them back?
- 5:49Missed opportunities, that's. A fair critique so might make
- 5:51capital inefficiency, Perhaps. But what Buffett loves is the
- 5:55next part, cash generation, free cash flow.
- 5:58FCF Alphabet absolutely gushes it.
- 6:00And the margin, FCF margin has averaged around 22% over the
- 6:04last decade. That demolishes the typical 5%
- 6:06benchmark and 3rd profitability. Gross margins consistently in
- 6:10the 5560% range. Returns on equity Roe
- 6:14consistently over 20%, hit almost 31% in 2024.
- 6:18So R. OE of 30.8% in 2024.
- 6:21That screams quality management and a strong Moat or quality
- 6:24established exceptional business.
- 6:26Where does that failed the traditional Buffett test?
- 6:29The sticking point is almost always the price valuation
- 6:32discipline. Alphabets price to earnings
- 6:34ratio. It's PE usually sits in the mid
- 6:3620s. Right now it's around 23 which.
- 6:38Is way above Buffett's preferred ceiling of what, 15X?
- 6:41Way above, it really gets close. Same story of price to book,
- 6:44often 4X to 7X. So it fits that classic dilemma.
- 6:47A wonderful company, but seldom available at a fair price by
- 6:49those strict value standards. OK.
- 6:50But one thing Buffett does like is returning cash to
- 6:53shareholders. How are they doing there?
- 6:54Very aggressively, actually, mostly through stock buyback.
- 6:58They bought back something like $343 billion worth of their own
- 7:01stock between 2015 and 2023. Three. $143 billion.
- 7:06That must have reduced the share count quite a bit.
- 7:08By about 13% over that period and they just keep authorizing
- 7:11more. Another $70 billion plan was
- 7:13announced in 2023 and. Significantly, they started
- 7:15paying a dividend. Didn't.
- 7:17They a big signal of maturity started their first ever
- 7:19quarterly cash dividend in 2023 and they've already raised it U
- 7:23to 121 per share as of Q2 2025. Management is basically saying
- 7:28we're confident in sustained cash flow now.
- 7:31Right. So bringing it all together,
- 7:33quality risks, valuation hurdles, shareholder returns,
- 7:37what does this mean for the actual underlying intrinsic
- 7:40value? We ran a discounted cash flow
- 7:42ADCF analysis right you. Did and look DCFS are highly
- 7:45sensitive to your assumptions, especially growth?
- 7:47We looked at 2 extremes just to illustrate the range.
- 7:50OK. What's the pessimistic view?
- 7:51The really conservative case assumes, well, basically 0 FCF
- 7:55growth forever, which is unrealistic for Alphabet.
- 7:58But if you model that, you get an intrinsic value of only
- 8:01around $68 per share. Which would mean it's massively
- 8:04overvalued today. But again, zero growth seems
- 8:07unlikely. Highly.
- 8:08Unlikely. So then we looked at the other
- 8:09end of a nominal case. What if Alphabet just keeps
- 8:13growing FCF at its historical 10 year average rate, which was
- 8:16about 21% per year? OK, plug.
- 8:18In 21% growth, what value pops out around?
- 8:20$360.00 per share. Wow.
- 8:23So $68 on the low end, $316.00 on the high end.
- 8:27Based on history, that's a huge range.
- 8:29The stocks currently trading around what, 190 dollars?
- 8:32Yeah, about. $190.00 So what does that $190.00 price imply
- 8:35the market is thinking? Yeah, it's just investors expect
- 8:37growth much slower than that historical 21%, but still pretty
- 8:40strong, probably somewhere in the mid teens for FCF growth
- 8:43going forward. So the.
- 8:44Market is pricing in the law of large numbers kicking in.
- 8:47Harder to grow fast when you're already enormous.
- 8:49Exactly that plus a discount for those regulatory risks and
- 8:52rising costs like TAC we talked about.
- 8:54It's tempering the optimism, OK. Let's wrap this up.
- 8:57The summary seems to be Alphabet is an incredibly high quality
- 9:01cash generating machine. Unmatched competitive position,
- 9:04fantastic historical returns like that. 30% + R OE.
- 9:08No question about the quality, but.
- 9:10The price you pay reflects that quality.
- 9:12The core decision for an investor is whether you're
- 9:14willing to pay that premium knowing it comes with these
- 9:16significant regulatory and competitive pressures.
- 9:18Absolutely. I mean, the past decade has been
- 9:20phenomenal growth, hitting $100 billion in net income in 2024.
- 9:25But looking forward, it really feels like a race.
- 9:27Can new revenues from cloud and AI outrun those rising costs,
- 9:30tacking R&D fast enough to maintain the growth needed to
- 9:33justify even the current valuation?
- 9:35Which brings us to a final thought for you, the listener to
- 9:38Mull over that nominal DCF value.
- 9:40The 1, based purely on historical growth, suggests
- 9:43Alphabet could be worth over $300 a share, maybe around
- 9:46$316.00. Yet the stock consistently
- 9:48trades well below that. Why is the market just
- 9:51perpetually skeptical, unable to shake off the fear of regulatory
- 9:54crackdowns or disruption? Or is it simply that the market
- 9:57refuses to believe any company, no matter how dominant, can keep
- 10:00growing at double digit rates once it reaches this kind of
- 10:02planetary scale? Something to think about.