Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / SMCI Q2 2025 Deep Value Analysis: Business, Risks and Growth
Transcript
- 0:00So we often talk about the AI boom, this incredible force, but
- 0:03have you really stopped to think about the massive sort of hidden
- 0:07infrastructure that actually powers it?
- 0:09It's immense, truly. Or you know how fast a company
- 0:11can go from being maybe less known to absolutely central in
- 0:16tech. Right, the shifts can be
- 0:17incredibly quick. Well, today we're doing a deep
- 0:19dive into super micro computer SMCI.
- 0:22Maybe not a household name for everyone, but they are
- 0:25absolutely critical to this whole AI and data center
- 0:28explosion. They're basically, basically
- 0:30building the backbone, the physical stuff.
- 0:32Yeah, Hardware Foundation. Our goal here is really to give
- 0:35you a clear full picture of SMCI.
- 0:38We'll unpack their recent financials, try to demystify
- 0:41their business model, which is pretty unique, and look at the
- 0:44the headwinds and risks they're facing.
- 0:47Both short and long term. Exactly.
- 0:49And we'll dig into the leadership too.
- 0:51Who's running the show? Are their interests aligned with
- 0:54shareholders who actually owns this company?
- 0:56Crucial questions. And just so you know, all the
- 0:58insights we're sharing today, they're pulled directly from SMC
- 1:01is latest earnings reports, business descriptions, corporate
- 1:04info, shareholder data. We're aiming for an unbiased
- 1:08fact based view here, just laying out the.
- 1:10Information, right, sticking to the sources.
- 1:12OK, so to really get this, let's start right at the beginning.
- 1:16What exactly is Super Micro Computer and how do they slot
- 1:20into this huge AI and data center landscape?
- 1:23Well, at its core, SMCI designs and builds high performance
- 1:26server and storage solutions, but they have a real focus on
- 1:30energy efficiency, which is, you know, increasingly important.
- 1:33Especially for AI workloads. Exactly.
- 1:35There are key suppliers for enterprise clients, cloud
- 1:38providers, and yes, especially AI applications.
- 1:41What really sets them apart, I think, is their building block
- 1:44architecture. OK, what does that mean in
- 1:46practice? It means their systems are
- 1:48modular, highly customizable. They can essentially IECE
- 1:52together servers very quickly to meet really specific customer
- 1:55needs. Think tailor made machines,
- 1:58whether for a massive data center or like a specialized
- 2:01research lab running AI models. So flexibility and speed.
- 2:05Precisely, and their product range is broad.
- 2:07You've got complete rack mount servers, blade systems, multi
- 2:11node setups and critically those GPU servers which are just vital
- 2:15for the heavy lifting AI requires.
- 2:17But they also do subsystems like motherboards and chassis.
- 2:20But it. Sounds like the focus is
- 2:21shifting more towards the complete package.
- 2:23Absolutely. That's a key point.
- 2:25In fiscal 23, something like 92% of their net sales came from
- 2:29complete server and storage systems, only 8% from
- 2:32components. Wow, 92%, yeah.
- 2:34It shows they're not just selling parts, they're
- 2:36delivering full integrated solutions ready to go.
- 2:39That's a much higher value proposition.
- 2:41Gives them more pricing power, stickier relationships.
- 2:44Makes sense. And they're global.
- 2:45Over 1000 direct customer 100 plus countries and their
- 2:49manufacturing muscle is pretty significant.
- 2:51They can churn out around 5000 complete server racks a month.
- 2:555000 a month. Yep, including over 2000 liquid
- 2:58cooled racks. And that liquid cooling is
- 3:00becoming super important for handling the heat generated by
- 3:03dense AI computing. So OK, they are literally
- 3:07building the brains, the physical hardware driving the AI
- 3:10revolution. That's a fundamental critical
- 3:12role. It really is.
- 3:13But despite being so central, you mentioned their latest
- 3:16earnings report, Q 425 hit some turbulence, especially around
- 3:21profitability. What's happening there?
- 3:23Is it just a blip or something more?
- 3:25You've hit on the key tension really.
- 3:27So looking at that Q4 ending June 30th, 2025, yes, revenue
- 3:32growth year over year was strong, $5.8 billion in sales up
- 3:357.5%, still growing. And the full year FY20, 25 was
- 3:39impressive, $22 billion total revenue.
- 3:42That's 47% annual growth, explosive by any standard,
- 3:46right? However, the challenge, as you
- 3:48said, was margins. Gross margin dipped to 9.5%.
- 3:51That's down from 10.2% the year. Before squeeze.
- 3:54Management pointed to a few things.
- 3:56Higher component costs, which is a persistent issue in this
- 3:58industry, Increased costs from tariffs and significantly a big
- 4:02jump in operating expenses, up about 22.6% year over year.
- 4:06Ouch. Why the OpEx jump?
- 4:08Mostly increased headcount and salaries.
- 4:10They've been scaling rapidly to meet demand, hiring people,
- 4:13engineers, manufacturing staff. Growing pains maybe?
- 4:16Sort of and all that flowed down to the bottom line.
- 4:19Net income was $195 million, gap EPS that's the standard
- 4:24accounting measure was dollars $0.31 down from 746 seconds a
- 4:29year ago. Even their non GAAP EPS, which
- 4:32often smooths things out, was lower.
- 4:34So how did management explain this drop in profit despite
- 4:37rising sales? Well, they attributed a big part
- 4:40of it to those tariffs we mentioned and also some last
- 4:43minute specification changes from a major customer.
- 4:46Apparently this pushed back when they could actually recognize
- 4:49the revenue for some large orders.
- 4:51Timing issues. Timing issues, exactly.
- 4:53They also mentioned other big orders were delayed simply
- 4:56because of broader economic uncertainty, customers being
- 4:59cautious, but they do expect those orders to close in the
- 5:02coming quarters. OK.
- 5:03So potentially deferred revenue, not lost revenue?
- 5:06That seems to be the message and despite these issues, their cash
- 5:08position looks solid. They generated $864,000,000 in
- 5:12operating cash flow in Q4 alone and ended with a 5.2 billion
- 5:16dollar cash balance. They do have debt, about $4.8
- 5:19billion, but still a strong cash cushion.
- 5:22Right. But the market didn't like the
- 5:23outlook, did it? No, that's what really seemed to
- 5:25spook investors. Their guidance for Hue 1 of
- 5:27fiscal 26 was weaker than expected.
- 5:30Revenue projected between 6.11 and seven point billion dollars,
- 5:34OK, but GAAP EPS guidance was only zero 30 two $7.42.
- 5:40An analyst were expecting. Closer to 0 and a $0.60, so a
- 5:44significant miss versus expectations.
- 5:46And that led to the stock dropping sharply, almost 20%
- 5:50right after the announcement. Yeah.
- 5:52But it's interesting, Despite that guidance in the market
- 5:54reaction, CEO Charles Liang sounds incredibly bullish long
- 5:58term. He actually raised their full
- 5:59year FY20 26 revenue target to at least $33 billion. $33
- 6:04billion. That implies what, 50% growth
- 6:06again? Around that, yeah, the thinking
- 6:08is those delayed projects will come through and the underlying
- 6:11demand remains incredibly strong.
- 6:12That's. Quite a contrast.
- 6:13Strong growth but margin pressure, a weak outlook causing
- 6:16a stock hit yet underlying confidence.
- 6:18It paints a complex picture. Huge potential, clearly, but
- 6:21definitely definite challenges. Absolutely.
- 6:23So what are these bumps in the road?
- 6:25Can we separate the temporary issues from the more you know,
- 6:27structural long term risks? Yeah, that's a good way to look
- 6:30at it. On the short term or maybe
- 6:32temporary side, you've definitely got those US, China
- 6:35trade tariffs hitting costs plus general supply chain cost
- 6:39increases for components and logistics management was pretty
- 6:41explicit about that impacting the recent quarter.
- 6:44OK, external pressures. Right.
- 6:46Then there's the lumpiness of big customer orders, a major
- 6:50client changing spec slate, others delaying due to economic
- 6:53caution that creates quarterly volatility.
- 6:56But again, the expectation is these orders aren't lost, just
- 6:59shifted. So timing again.
- 7:00Timing Again. Another temporary headwind has
- 7:03actually been their own success, demand outpacing their
- 7:06production capacity. They faced some capital
- 7:09constraints in scaling up fast enough, but they are addressing
- 7:12this. Investing in a new factory,
- 7:14expected to come online in 2025 should help ease that
- 7:17bottleneck. Makes sense?
- 7:18Any other short term things? Well, there's the regulatory and
- 7:22legal overhang from those short seller allegations back in
- 7:25August 2024 that led to DOJ and SEC subpoenas some Securities
- 7:31Litigation. Management strongly denies any
- 7:33wrongdoing and importantly, they did catch up on their filings
- 7:36eventually without needing to restate financials.
- 7:39But it definitely created uncertainty.
- 7:41Right, that governance cloud. Exactly.
- 7:43And finally, just the general global economy, high interest
- 7:46rates, currency swings, potential slowdowns, those can
- 7:49always dampen IT spending. OK.
- 7:51So those are mostly temporary or being actively addressed.
- 7:54What about the longer term, more structural risks, the stuff that
- 7:58might not go away? That's where it gets maybe a bit
- 8:00more challenging. Competition is intensifying.
- 8:03You've got giants like Dell, HPE, Lenovo all vying for data
- 8:07center business. And as SMCI targets bigger
- 8:10customers, there's pressure for volume discounts, the risk of
- 8:13commoditization where margins get squeezed because everyone's
- 8:15offering similar. Stuff the race to the bottom on
- 8:17price. Potentially, yeah.
- 8:20Then there's technology risk. This field moves incredibly
- 8:23fast. What if the hyperscalers, the
- 8:26big cloud companies, decide to design even more of their own
- 8:28servers in house? Or what if some entirely new
- 8:31computing approach emerges? SMCI has to constantly invest in
- 8:36R&D just to keep up with new CPU's, GPU's, cooling tech.
- 8:40It's relentless. Constant innovation needed.
- 8:42Absolutely. Geopolitics is another
- 8:44structural risk. Tensions around Taiwan, US,
- 8:47China relations impacting chip exports like GPU's going to
- 8:50China that could disrupt supply chains or raise cost
- 8:54significantly even with their efforts to diversify
- 8:56manufacturing beyond Taiwan to the US and potentially Malaysia.
- 9:00Supply chain vulnerability. Definitely.
- 9:01And related to that is reliance on key suppliers.
- 9:04We saw component shortages hit everyone a few years back and
- 9:07when suppliers like NVIDIA dominate a critical component
- 9:10like high end GPU's, they have enormous pricing power.
- 9:13Squeezing SMCI from the supplier side too.
- 9:16Could happen. And finally, we have to circle
- 9:18back to corporate governance. Those past accounting issues
- 9:21from 20/15/2017, the NASDAQ delisting, the SEC fine that
- 9:26history exists, and the more recent filing delays in 2024,
- 9:31while ultimately not leading to restatements this time, still
- 9:34raise flags about internal controls.
- 9:36So even though they fixed the recent issue, the history makes
- 9:39investors watchful. Exactly.
- 9:41It suggests perhaps control failures or process weaknesses
- 9:45rather than outright fraud, which is a huge distinction.
- 9:48But it means ongoing vigilance is needed.
- 9:51They are working on it, hiring compliance people, expanding the
- 9:54finance team, but it's a risk factor investors track.
- 9:57OK, So a lot of external pressures, internal scaling
- 10:00hurdles and the shadow of past governance issues they're
- 10:03working to fully overcome. Given all that complexity, how
- 10:06does this translate into managing their money?
- 10:08It's let's unpack their cost structure.
- 10:09What does that tell us? Yeah, the cost structure is
- 10:11really revealing about their profitability drivers.
- 10:13The biggest chunk by far is variable cost, specifically
- 10:16their cost of goods sold or COD GS.
- 10:18That's the parts, right? CPU's, GPU's memory.
- 10:21Exactly. Components and materials, this
- 10:25typically makes up somewhere between 85% and 90% of their
- 10:28revenue. And because it's so dominant,
- 10:30their gross margin is incredibly sensitive to swings and
- 10:33component prices and those tariffs we talked about.
- 10:36South managing procurement and supplier costs is absolutely
- 10:39critical for them. Paramount, a small change in
- 10:42component cost has a big impact on the bottom line.
- 10:45They're fixed or maybe semi fixed costs, what they call
- 10:48operating expenses or OpEx are a much smaller slice.
- 10:52That's R&D sales admin. Right.
- 10:55R&D is usually maybe four, 6% of sales, sales and marketing just
- 10:58one 2%, general admin one 4%, so single digits typically.
- 11:02That implies pretty significant operating leverage, doesn't it?
- 11:05It does when revenue grows rapidly like it did between
- 11:07fiscal 21 and 23. When it doubled, those fixed
- 11:10OpEx costs become a much smaller percentage of the total revenue.
- 11:13OpEx dropped from 13.2% of sales down to 7.3% in that period.
- 11:18That leverage effect can really boost profitability during
- 11:20growth spurts. But the flip side is true too,
- 11:22right? But growth slows.
- 11:24Exactly. If growth slows or reverses,
- 11:26those fixed costs don't shrink as quickly and that can hammer
- 11:29margins. Labor costs fit in here too.
- 11:32They have over 4000 employees. Some labor is in Cogios
- 11:36manufacturing, some in OpEx engineering admin.
- 11:39We saw that 22.6% jump in compensation recently, weighing
- 11:43on earnings. While labor can act like a fixed
- 11:46cost short term, over the longer run hopefully existing staff
- 11:49become more productive as volume grows.
- 11:51So the key take away on costs is.
- 11:54Profitability is overwhelmingly sensitive to managing those
- 11:57variable component costs in Coges, and because ALPEX is
- 12:00relatively fixed, SMCI really relies on sustained volume
- 12:04growth to drive profits. It's a volume game for them to a
- 12:07large extent. That gives us a really clear
- 12:09picture of the financial dynamics.
- 12:10OK. So who are the people actually
- 12:12steering this ship through these, you know, high growth but
- 12:15also choppy waters? And crucially, are their
- 12:17interests really aligned with shareholders?
- 12:19Well, leading the charge is the founder and CEO, Charles Liang.
- 12:23He's been at it for over 30 years.
- 12:24Really the visionary behind the company.
- 12:26Decades of experience there. Absolutely.
- 12:28He's supported by CFO David Weigand, who came on board in
- 12:312018, became CFO in 2021, and has been credited with
- 12:34significantly improving financial reporting processes
- 12:37after those earlier issues. Bringing in needed financial
- 12:40discipline. Seems so, and Co founder Wally
- 12:43Liao is also back, focusing on business development and
- 12:45strategic partnerships. Since 2021, the board has 10
- 12:49members, a mix of insiders like Liang and another cofounder,
- 12:52Sarah Liu, plus independent directors.
- 12:55And importantly, remember they appointed Susie Giordano in
- 12:58August 2024 to lead that special committee looking into the short
- 13:02seller claims that signals a move toward more proactive
- 13:05governance. Addressing concerns head on.
- 13:07Right now, track record wise, management has definitely
- 13:10delivered on ambitious growth. They blew past their $10 billion
- 13:13revenue goal, hit $22 billion in FY25.
- 13:16They clearly know how to execute and capitalize on the market
- 13:19opportunity. Operationally strong.
- 13:21Yes, but as we've discussed, the financial reporting side has had
- 13:26those historical blemishes, the 2015 seventeen issues, the
- 13:30recent 2024 delays. While the latest round didn't
- 13:34lead to restatements, which is key, it still highlights the
- 13:37critical need for robust internal controls.
- 13:40They seem to be taking it seriously, hiring compliance
- 13:43staff, building out the finance team.
- 13:46And Ling, while known for being optimistic, has been open about
- 13:49the recent challenges like customer delays and tariffs.
- 13:52So it sounds like maybe a journey from some past
- 13:55operational focus sometimes overshadowing controls towards a
- 13:58more balanced approach now. Stronger controls, more
- 14:01transparency. That seems to be the trajectory,
- 14:03yeah. Addressing those administrative
- 14:05weaknesses seems to be a priority.
- 14:06OK, so how does their own skin in the game, their financial
- 14:09stake, tie into all this? Does it really lock their
- 14:12interest with other shareholders?
- 14:13That's a really important piece for alignment.
- 14:15Charles Lang himself is the largest individual shareholder.
- 14:17He owns about 9.1% of the company.
- 14:19That's significant with billions.
- 14:21Billions. Yeah.
- 14:23And what's really telling is his official salary is just $1.00 a
- 14:26year. His compensation is heavily
- 14:28weighted towards performance based stock awards.
- 14:31His personal fortune is directly tied to how SMCA stock performs.
- 14:35Can't get much more aligned than that.
- 14:37Pretty much. And combined, all insiders,
- 14:39founders, executives own roughly 13.9% of the company.
- 14:44That's a very solid insider ownership block, giving them
- 14:47strong incentive to maximize long term shareholder value.
- 14:50What about their buying and selling activity?
- 14:52Well, historically, insiders including Liang were actually
- 14:56net buyers during dips like back in the 2018 turmoil.
- 15:00Generally, they tend to hold their stakes.
- 15:02Liang hasn't sold significant amounts recently.
- 15:04We have seen some directors take profits more recently, which
- 15:07isn't entirely unexpected after such a huge run up in the stock,
- 15:10but the core founder ownership remains strong.
- 15:12OK. And capital allocation,
- 15:13buybacks, dividends. No dividends, which is typical
- 15:16for a high growth tech company reinvesting heavily.
- 15:18They did have a share buyback program authorized $200 million
- 15:22back in August 2022. Did they use?
- 15:24It. They did.
- 15:25They bought back $150 million worth in fiscal 23 and the
- 15:29timing was pretty fantastic in hindsight.
- 15:32They bought about 15.5 million shares at an average price of
- 15:35around $9.65 post split. Wow, $9.65 compared to where it
- 15:41went later. Great timing.
- 15:42Incredibly well timed. That program expired in January
- 15:452024, though, and more recently, with the stock at highs in March
- 15:482024, they actually did the opposite.
- 15:50They raised capital about $600 million through an equity offer.
- 15:54So opportunistic buy low, issue high.
- 15:56It looks that way. Flexible approach.
- 15:58Prioritize rising growth investment, but willing to
- 16:00return cash via buybacks when the price is right and raise
- 16:03capital when the market's offering attractive terms.
- 16:05And the value creation overall has been immense.
- 16:07About $1.1 billion in retained earnings between 2015 and 2024
- 16:12helps fuel a market cap increase of something like 40, five, $50
- 16:15billion. That implies really high returns
- 16:18on the capital they reinvested. That is a powerful incentive and
- 16:20track record. OK, beyond the insiders, who
- 16:23else owns significant chunks of SMCI and what does their
- 16:26presence tell us? Well, outside of that 14%
- 16:29insider block, the biggest holders are the large passive
- 16:33institutional investors. You know, the usual suspects.
- 16:35Vanguard. BlackRock.
- 16:36Exactly. Vanguard holds about 10.8%,
- 16:40BlackRock around 6.8%, State St. maybe 3-4 percent.
- 16:44These are mostly index funds. So they generally vote with
- 16:46management. Typically yes.
- 16:48Support rates for directors and say on pay are usually very high
- 16:52in the 90s. They exert influence more
- 16:54through quiet engagement, private stewardship rather than
- 16:57public fights, although sometimes you see slight
- 17:00caution, like maybe lower support for increasing equity
- 17:03incentive plans, but generally supportive.
- 17:05What about active funds? Any well known activists or
- 17:08value investors involved That's. Actually one of the interesting
- 17:11parts of the story, there aren't many prominent activists names
- 17:14and for a long time you didn't see super investors like Buffett
- 17:17or Klarman with big positions. Why not?
- 17:20Governance concerns? Maybe.
- 17:21That could certainly have deterred some classic value
- 17:24investors early on, but some did see the opportunity.
- 17:27A firm called Disciplined Growth Investors, for instance, started
- 17:30buying back in 2018-2019 when the price was incredibly low,
- 17:34maybe one $1.50 post split. And apparently they still hold a
- 17:38significant position, having ridden that massive wave up.
- 17:41Incredible return for them. Huge.
- 17:43Another firm, GMT Capital, seems to have bought in early 2023,
- 17:48maybe around 5:00 to $8 post split and then trimmed as the
- 17:52stock soared. But many classic value types
- 17:55likely missed it or stayed away. So the shareholder base has
- 17:58shifted overtime. Dramatically by 2025 after the
- 18:01stocks meteoric rise, many early value investors who got in low
- 18:05have likely taken substantial profits.
- 18:08The dominant holders now besides insiders are those big passive
- 18:11funds and likely more growth oriented or momentum investors
- 18:14who bought in during the AI boom.
- 18:16SMCI essentially transformed itself in the market size.
- 18:19From what to what? From, you know, an overlooked,
- 18:21maybe slightly troubled low PE value stock into a premier high
- 18:26growth, AI driven momentum name. It's been quite the journey,
- 18:29rewarding investors who are patient and willing to look past
- 18:32the initial risks. That is a remarkable
- 18:34transformation. OK, so wrapping up this deep
- 18:37dive, it's crystal clear SMCI is a vital player in the AI
- 18:41hardware space experiencing phenomenal growth.
- 18:44Undeniably. But also, as we've really
- 18:46unpacked, navigating a complex set of challenges, short term
- 18:50things like supply chains, tariffs, order timing and longer
- 18:54term risks like intense competition and the need for
- 18:56constant innovation. And that governance aspect,
- 19:00they're improving. Right management, led by the
- 19:02founder, has shown strong operational skill and
- 19:05critically, they have that massive personal stake aligning
- 19:08them with shareholders. Plus, we're seeing that
- 19:10increased focus on controls and transparency.
- 19:13The stock's incredible run really reflects this whole story
- 19:15from value play to growth darling.
- 19:17A real case study and market perception shifts.
- 19:20Definitely. And maybe a final thought for
- 19:22you, the listener, to chew on as you think about SMCI.
- 19:25In this world where AI demand feels almost infinite right now,
- 19:29how long can the companies building the physical
- 19:32infrastructure the SMC is of the world really sustained that
- 19:36competitive edge and those profit margins?
- 19:39When does commoditization truly bite?
- 19:41Or when might the next technological leap disrupt even
- 19:44today's leaders? What unseen risks might still be
- 19:47hiding on the surface of all this exciting growth?
- 19:50Good questions to keep asking. Absolutely.
- 19:52Keep digging, keep questioning. Thanks for joining us on this
- 19:54deep dive. We'll see you next time.
- 19:57Disclaimer All analysis is based on publicly available sources
- 20:00and may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 20:03The content is for educational purposes only and does not
- 20:06constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 20:09before making investment decisions.
- 20:11Like and subscribe us on Apple Spotify podcast or YouTube
- 20:14channel Deep value investing. Don't forget to take the book
- 20:17list of Valium investing for the episode description and to track
- 20:19total market temperature. Welcome to Search and download
- 20:21iOS App Buffett Indicator from Apple App Store.