I Found Out My Favorite Halloween Memory Was Fake | Oct 28th 2026 | EP 8
Matt shows up dressed as a mime, Jesse barely tries with his Halloween costume, and somehow things only get weirder from there.
Matt tells the story of taking mushrooms at a Halloween party, getting surrounded by people dressed as bananas, then having to survive a Penn State whiteout game the next day.
They get into haunted houses, costumes, why trick or treating used to be better, weird Halloween personalities, Fred Durst, Chick fil A feeling like Get Out, and the greatest Halloween memory Matt ever had.
At least he thought it was.
Matt spent years believing he won Nickelodeon Nick or Treats…
The skinny
The skinny isn't ready yet — notes appear once the transcript is processed.