Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Uptown Girls (2003): A Fairytale
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:31We're standing here in my attic room, just next
- 0:35to my nook. My husband and I finally went through
- 0:39a couple of boxes of papers, making way for a
- 0:42new bookshelf across the room from my desk, so
- 0:45I've been able to move my books upstairs. There
- 0:49are the books that shouldn't be in reach of children,
- 0:53like my complete collection of the comic series
- 0:56Fables in compendium form. And then there are
- 1:00my favorite books. My worn copies of The Lord
- 1:04of the Rings, The Chronicles of Narnia, and Gail
- 1:07Carson Levine's Ella Enchanted. Next, we have
- 1:11my books on writing, including Stephen King's
- 1:14On Writing and Jeff Vandermeer's Wonder Book.
- 1:17Here's a collection of hardback journals I like
- 1:20to use for fun writing projects, like the fantasy
- 1:24retelling of World War II with anthropomorphic
- 1:27wolves instead of Nazis, and my Cinderella retelling,
- 1:30where I leaned into her talking to birds. Finally,
- 1:35here are my reference texts, largely my dictionaries
- 1:40and fairy tale collections, including George
- 1:43MacDonald, Hans Christian Andersen, and the Brothers
- 1:47Grimm. I fell deeply in love with fairy tales
- 1:51around fourth grade, and I don't mean Disney
- 1:55princess stories. I mean fairy tales, like knowing
- 2:00Charles Perrault's Sleeping Beauty has a second
- 2:03half where the prince's mother is an ogre, and
- 2:06she tries to eat the princess and her two children
- 2:09while the prince is on a hunting trip. I really
- 2:12loved discovering the dark and twisted origins
- 2:16to the animated movies I'd enjoyed. It was like
- 2:20my interest growing up with me. I even dipped
- 2:24my toe into fairytale scholarship in college
- 2:27while working on a paper. It was only tangentially
- 2:30related to the topic I was supposed to be covering,
- 2:33but it's the only part of that assignment I remember,
- 2:36and it's the kind of stuff I think about regularly.
- 2:40when analyzing film and television. So I'm not
- 2:44an expert on this subject, but definitely a well
- 2:49-informed fan. Fairy tales are a very specific
- 2:54thing, and it's kind of difficult to pin down.
- 2:59Normally, when we think of the form, we actually
- 3:02just think of the stories themselves, their plot
- 3:05beats and specifics. So Cinderella, Snow White,
- 3:11Sleeping Beauty. But the movies you're thinking
- 3:14about right now, maybe Disney movies, maybe some
- 3:18gritty reboots, are often quite distanced from
- 3:22the actual literary genre of the fairy tale.
- 3:26We talked a little bit last month about something
- 3:29similar when we discussed Robin Hood. A movie
- 3:33might technically be a fairy tale in the story
- 3:36it's based on, but it's far more of an action
- 3:40movie or a romance, which isn't a bad thing.
- 3:44The stories of fairy tales have produced a lot
- 3:48of excellent books and movies that I personally
- 3:52love. But a fairy tale isn't so much a certain
- 3:56plot as it is a feeling, an atmosphere. There's
- 4:02a real embrace of instinctual plot structure,
- 4:06like a plot flow that is more emotional than
- 4:09logical. There's a dreamlike quality to the imagery
- 4:13and the cinematography. A character arc that
- 4:17taps into something more metaphorical than literal.
- 4:21Archetype. Symbolism. There are some highly crafted,
- 4:27well -respected films that fit these characteristics.
- 4:31Some for children, like Spirited Away, Song of
- 4:35the Sea. Some for adults, like Pan's Labyrinth,
- 4:39or The City of Lost Children. We might talk about
- 4:43some of these someday. But today, I want to talk
- 4:47about something completely different. A movie
- 4:50that was largely disregarded by the film criticism
- 4:53community. It currently only holds a 13 % on
- 4:58Rotten Tomatoes. In no small part, because they
- 5:01were judging it as a modern comedy. They found
- 5:05it saccharine, obnoxious, and uneven. And while
- 5:09it's not without flaws, I think that the 2003
- 5:13film Uptown Girls is far less of a modern comedy
- 5:18than a modern, melancholic fairy tale. On face
- 5:24value, this is not the kind of movie that I generally
- 5:27watch. I'm not... much of a chick flick person.
- 5:32I have my favorites, but I doubt I would ever
- 5:35have watched this film if I hadn't lived in a
- 5:38girl's dorm before the advent of quality streaming
- 5:41services. My university library was an excellent
- 5:46resource for prestigious film. They had a great
- 5:49many Best Picture nominees and winners, some
- 5:52nice selections from the Criterion Collection,
- 5:55a healthy representation of international film.
- 5:58But if you just wanted a movie to throw on in
- 6:01the background while you solved problems for
- 6:03applied algebra, you could only rely on DVDs
- 6:06you and the people around you had bothered to
- 6:09bring to college. Which is how I ended up perusing
- 6:12my roommate's DVD collection. I'd picked through
- 6:16her choices alphabetically, and now there was
- 6:19only Uptown Girls left. The title calls to mind
- 6:23the song by Billy Joel, Uptown Girl. where he
- 6:27sings about a rich girl in a white bread world
- 6:30coming to look for an adventure by falling in
- 6:32love with a downtown man, a lower -income guy
- 6:35with a beating heart and big dreams. The music
- 6:39video is a woman in 80s couture echoing Christian
- 6:43Dior's new look, standing and smiling while Billy
- 6:46Joel and his backup singers bop about dressed
- 6:49as mechanics. So you might think that this was...
- 6:52kind of a romance about wealthy women falling
- 6:55for lower -income guys. It is not. Which I discovered
- 7:00as I looked at the cover. With a white background
- 7:03on which is superimposed the New York skyline
- 7:07in faded pastels, there stands Brittany Murphy
- 7:11in a skin -tight, white, spaghetti -strapped
- 7:14dress with a lacy neckline, her blonde curls
- 7:17thrown to the side with sexy bimbo energy. her
- 7:21arms thrown around a young Dakota Fanning in
- 7:25a navy and white school uniform, clutching a
- 7:28folder, her eyes mid -roll. So you might think
- 7:32that this movie is an odd couple comedy about
- 7:35a dumb blonde and a nerdy child. Only, sort of.
- 7:41Uptown Girls tells the story of Molly, the 22
- 7:45-year -old orphan daughter of a rock star living
- 7:48a charmed life in New York City, who wakes up
- 7:51one day to discover that her father's accountant
- 7:54has stolen all of her money and fled, leaving
- 7:57her penniless. Forced to get an actual job, she
- 8:02stumbles on a gig nannying an 8 -year -old girl,
- 8:05a highly disciplined hypochondriac named Ray.
- 8:09Ray's high demands have led to a high turnover
- 8:12of nannies, but Molly desperately needs the income.
- 8:17Plot ensues. And yet, this movie has something
- 8:23that isn't articulated in its title or marketing
- 8:27or plot synopsis. And if you go into it on those
- 8:32obvious terms, especially if that's the kind
- 8:35of story you're hoping to see, you're probably
- 8:38going to be baffled. Because this movie's director,
- 8:42Boaz Yakin, brings the imagery and feel of a
- 8:46fairy tale to what should be, on paper, a mediocre,
- 8:50predictable comedy. And he finds something completely
- 8:54heartbreaking there. You might ask, why would
- 8:59a director randomly pick to turn an odd couple
- 9:02comedy into a fairy tale? Well, the script gave
- 9:06him the idea. The opening lines of this film
- 9:09are as follows. Some fairy tales are true. Most
- 9:15other stories we make up to help us deal with
- 9:17real life. It all depends on your point of view.
- 9:21But here are the facts. There was once a princess
- 9:24who lived in a castle high above the streets
- 9:28of an enchanted kingdom. The king and queen were
- 9:31long gone, but they left her with their treasure
- 9:34so that she could stay a princess forever. On
- 9:37the eve of her 22nd birthday, a great celebration
- 9:40was planned. Now, this kind of monologue opening
- 9:45a script doesn't guarantee that your film is
- 9:48tonally a fairy tale. There was actually a bit
- 9:51of a trend in the late 90s, early 2000s to have
- 9:55movies start with a once -upon -a -time fairy
- 9:58tale monologue, only to undercut that with a
- 10:01tonal shift. This was part of a trend of fairy
- 10:06tale deconstruction, influenced by postmodernism
- 10:09and third -wave feminism. There's Ever After,
- 10:13which, while utterly sincere in its storytelling,
- 10:17is a realistic deconstruction of Cinderella.
- 10:21Then there's Shrek, which is not sincere, and
- 10:24where the opening fairy tale is literally ripped
- 10:27and turned into toilet paper. There are movies
- 10:31like A Knight's Tale, where the once upon a time
- 10:33isn't literal, but is heavily implied in the
- 10:37serious opening scroll. There's Moulin Rouge,
- 10:40where the storybook opening is sung in a cover
- 10:43of Nat King Cole's Nature Boy. I suspect that
- 10:47the screenwriters merely intended this monologue
- 10:51as a device, a juxtaposition for the very modern
- 10:54story that was to come next, especially since
- 10:58the story is about a protagonist stuck in girlhood.
- 11:02Instead, this monologue is the lens through which
- 11:06Joaquin sets the whole film, and it's what takes
- 11:10this movie from being a mediocre, forgettable
- 11:13time waster to a compelling, Interesting, flawed,
- 11:18but good film. One that's actually become a bit
- 11:22of a cult classic. We can tell the difference
- 11:25immediately. Those previous films have an abrupt
- 11:29musical tonal shift shortly after their openings.
- 11:32Shrek goes from fairy tale to Smash Mouth's all
- 11:36-star. A Knight's Tale launches into We Will
- 11:39Rock You in the jousting stands. Moulin Rouge
- 11:42has a narcoleptic Argentinian crash through a
- 11:45wall, shortly followed by Ewan McGregor belting
- 11:48the sound of music. Even a movie like The Princess
- 11:51Diaries goes from sweet strings to an aggressive
- 11:55pop song. This movie never makes that tonal shift.
- 12:01It does move from an orchestral score to a needle
- 12:05drop, but it chooses the softer pop tones of
- 12:09Lee Nash's Charmed Life, whose lyrics specifically
- 12:13reference fairy tales, stories, and magic. This
- 12:18film is choosing to lean into the fairy tale
- 12:21instead of using it as a contrast. So how does
- 12:25a director communicate that his film is a fairy
- 12:28tale? especially without the convenience of a
- 12:32fairytale setting or plot. First, it starts with
- 12:37the cinematography. Early 2000s chick flicks
- 12:40tend to feature very standard, typical shot setups
- 12:44and choices. Wide shots with controlled pans,
- 12:48static, medium shots, close -ups for personal
- 12:53moments. Cameras are pretty static or very stable.
- 12:57They're not showy. or very artful. They don't
- 13:01need to be. The audience is here for the stories,
- 13:05and so the filmmaking doesn't distract from that.
- 13:08This camera is frequently in motion. There's
- 13:13a reoccurring motif of spinning, which is actually
- 13:16emphasizing something about the plot, which we'll
- 13:19get to later. What you need to know is this film
- 13:23is filled with whip pans of varying speeds. There's
- 13:27quite a bit of steadicam use too, not in the
- 13:30documentarian, handheld style explored in action
- 13:34films shortly after this, but in a smooth, whimsical
- 13:38way. Molly is the sort of character who doesn't
- 13:42really walk in a straight line. She almost dances
- 13:45more than walks, and the camera follows her lead.
- 13:49The lighting is really interesting too. Early
- 13:532000s chick flicks tend to feature brightly lit
- 13:56rooms and wide open spaces. They'll often settle
- 13:59themselves in sunlight or mornings, saving night
- 14:03scenes for romantic or contrasting scenes later
- 14:07in the story. This movie waits until Act 2 for
- 14:11sunshine, and it sets the tone in darkness with
- 14:14magical flickering lights. In the opening, these
- 14:18are the shimmering lights of Coney Island. But
- 14:21Molly's apartment doesn't have much overhead
- 14:24lighting, instead having many wall lamps and
- 14:28fairy lights. Early on in the film when her power
- 14:32goes out, we aren't really aware because she
- 14:35fills her rooms with candles and the magical
- 14:38aesthetic continues. Sunshine and bright rooms
- 14:42are sources of conflict in this film. Fairy lights
- 14:47are Molly's happy place. in the fantasy world.
- 14:52The production design plays a bit of a part of
- 14:55this, too. In the plot, Molly is stuck in childhood,
- 15:00like a girl in an adult body. Another director
- 15:04might have picked bright colors to show this.
- 15:07Molly's apartment might have had the pastels
- 15:10of childhood or the pink, orange, and lime green
- 15:13colors of early 2000s girlhood. I can see a version
- 15:17where her apartment is filled with those groovy
- 15:20flower images or the bubble chairs or lava lamps
- 15:24that were everywhere in this era. But instead
- 15:28of depicting her in modern girlhood, production
- 15:31designer Kalina Ivanov leans into a richer, timeless
- 15:35aesthetic. The walls are dark red, the ceiling
- 15:40deep blue with white stars. Molly sleeps in a
- 15:44canopy bed. with a cornice over top, covered
- 15:47with sheer golden curtains. She is a princess,
- 15:51with a princess bed, complete with a set of steps
- 15:56painted pale gold with roses. Figurines hang
- 16:00from her ceiling, well -crafted, old -fashioned
- 16:04acrobats. There's sophistication here, not just
- 16:08tacky childhood. This is again a timeless, magical
- 16:13space. The production design and cinematography
- 16:18work hand -in -hand, too. Eight -year -old Ray's
- 16:22apartment is fully modern, painted dark gray
- 16:25with white trim, all straight lines. In the dining
- 16:29room, the wall is paneled with mirrors. That
- 16:32fits right in with contemporary glam aesthetics,
- 16:35but it isn't filmed that way. It looks more like
- 16:39a cold castle calling to mind the evil queen
- 16:43in Snow White or like some kind of snow queen.
- 16:47Elsa's castle in Frozen is filmed this way. And
- 16:50when Molly first looks down Ray's dark gray and
- 16:54white hallway, we're treated to a dolly zoom.
- 16:58This is one of the showiest camera moves you
- 17:00can possibly put in a movie, accomplished by
- 17:03zooming in the lens as you physically move the
- 17:06camera forward or backward. It's frequently used
- 17:09in horror. Hitchcock used it to achieve the effect
- 17:13of vertigo in that film. Spielberg used it in
- 17:17Jaws during a shark attack while Chief Brody
- 17:20is stuck in a chair. Peter Jackson used it in
- 17:24The Fellowship of the Ring as we first hear the
- 17:27Nazgul scream while Frodo stares down the road
- 17:30and leaves magically blow. In this film, it makes
- 17:35Rey's modern -looking home a source of unseen
- 17:39evil, which we'll talk more about in a bit. The
- 17:44editing also works with the cinematography. This
- 17:48movie is filled with dissolves and crossfades
- 17:52that blur the passage of time and space. In the
- 17:55opening, as Molly leaves her apartment building
- 17:58to take a cab to a club for her birthday party,
- 18:01instead of following her trip, the camera pans
- 18:05up to the lighted apartment buildings and then
- 18:08keeps traveling as the buildings and night sky
- 18:11flip into their reflection in a puddle, which
- 18:15Molly steps in on her way to the club. It's dizzying,
- 18:18spinning again, and it also blurs reality. In
- 18:23order to transition from day to night, this movie
- 18:26opts for time lapses, allowing the sun to quickly
- 18:30track across the sky. These dreamlike transitions
- 18:34pull us out of the modern reality of chick flicks
- 18:38with clear establishing shots and logical cuts
- 18:41from scene to scene to a more intuitive journey
- 18:45for these characters. and the characters themselves.
- 18:49Costume designer Sarah Edwards goes beyond convention
- 18:52to tap into fairy tale and fantasy depictions.
- 18:57Molly is meant to be deeply immature, a little
- 19:00girl in a woman's body. She's also meant to be
- 19:04a sexy party girl. It would make sense to keep
- 19:07her in baby doll dresses or bright colors or
- 19:10to give her lollipops and those red -hearted
- 19:13lolita sunglasses that don't mean what people
- 19:15think they mean. Edwards does not do this. Instead,
- 19:20she dresses Molly like some kind of forest fairy
- 19:24in dresses and skirts that have a flow to them
- 19:27with frequent floral motifs. Molly has skill
- 19:32in clothing design and fashion inspiration, so
- 19:35her clothes often feature embroidery or beading,
- 19:39like she embellished her denim skirt or party
- 19:42dress. So she reads more like a hippie earth
- 19:46mama than a glamorous party girl. It's like she
- 19:50belongs in the woods. Ray is meant to be an adult
- 19:56in a child's body, a 40 -something career woman
- 19:59in a school uniform. But Edwards doesn't dress
- 20:03her in business suits. She wears classic, traditional
- 20:06children's clothes, the aforementioned school
- 20:10uniform, a blue button -down shirt with Peter
- 20:13Pan collar, dark headbands and Dakota Fanning's
- 20:17pale blonde hair, cardigans. This calls to mind
- 20:22British low fantasy aesthetics, Lucy in Pauline
- 20:26Bain's illustrations for The Lion, the Witch,
- 20:29and the Wardrobe, or Alice in Alice in Wonderland.
- 20:33So Rey still looks like a fantasy fairy tale
- 20:38character, even if she's on the page meant to
- 20:42be the down -to -earth practical one. So why
- 20:45do all this? Why choose to film this odd couple
- 20:50comedy through the lens of a fairy tale? I think
- 20:54Joaquin's vision here works to draw attention
- 20:57to the thematic truth of these characters. They
- 21:02aren't actually a girl trapped in the body of
- 21:04a woman and a woman trapped in the body of a
- 21:07girl. They're actually both lost little girls,
- 21:12fairy tale characters from two different kinds
- 21:15of stories. I'm going to get into the plot here.
- 21:20I generally try not to be spoilery when I'm talking
- 21:24about movies I expect you probably haven't seen,
- 21:27but I need to explain the real heart of this
- 21:31story, the reason it's at all worth checking
- 21:34out, what makes it better than all the other
- 21:37early 2000s modern comedies. In the second half
- 21:42of this film, trying to cheer Ray up, Molly takes
- 21:46her to Coney Island. She doesn't realize the
- 21:49season hasn't started yet, and they walk through
- 21:52the empty thoroughfare to the sounds of a haunting,
- 21:55melancholic score by Joel McNeely. On the way
- 22:00home, Molly tells Ray what happened when she
- 22:03learned her parents died. It was such a living
- 22:07nightmare that the faces of the people around
- 22:09her twisted into monsters. She had to run away.
- 22:14So she packed a bag and headed to Coney Island
- 22:16because she thought it was an actual island.
- 22:19The only ride she was allowed to go on was the
- 22:23spinning teacups. Molly tells Ray that she kept
- 22:27spinning and spinning and that really, she feels
- 22:31like she's never gotten off that ride. Molly
- 22:36isn't immature. Molly... is traumatized. In Joaquin's
- 22:45vision, she's a little girl lost in the woods,
- 22:49surrounded by the spinning, twinkly lights of
- 22:52Coney Island. And Ray? Throughout the film, we
- 22:58learn that Ray's father is in a coma after a
- 23:01stroke, asleep in his room in that dark, warping
- 23:05hallway. The beeps from his monitors often filter
- 23:09into the background of scenes there. So of course
- 23:13Ray is obsessed with germs and cleanliness. She's
- 23:18terrified of sickness as it's literally stolen
- 23:21her father away from her. Ray's mother completely
- 23:25neglects her, acting as if she doesn't have a
- 23:28husband or daughter. And so Ray fights for control.
- 23:33She's clean to an inch. She is ordered. She studies
- 23:38ballet and is rigorous in her technique, eschewing
- 23:41free dance. She isn't mature, a woman trapped
- 23:46in a girl's body. She's Rapunzel'd herself, locking
- 23:52her girlhood in a tower of rules and order to
- 23:55deal with her deeply lonely, neglected life.
- 24:00At the end of Act 2, Molly encourages Ray to
- 24:04go talk to her dad in his coma, that it will
- 24:07matter to him. And then he dies. Ray reacts by
- 24:14firing Molly through her mother. Molly is frustrated
- 24:18and very concerned, but her time caring for Ray
- 24:21has let her work through some of her grief and
- 24:24trauma. She makes some practical financial choices,
- 24:28even moving into a one -room downtown apartment.
- 24:31And then Ray's mom calls. She's gone missing.
- 24:38Molly finds Ray exactly where we'd expect, sitting
- 24:43in the teacups at Coney Island. In a devastating,
- 24:48wordless scene brilliantly acted by Brittany
- 24:51Murphy and Dakota Fanning. The two of them grab
- 24:55the hub and spin the teacups round and round.
- 25:00To Molly, this is taking control of her life.
- 25:04She is the one turning the wheel. To Ray, this
- 25:10is letting go, allowing herself to spin and spin
- 25:14until she's literally sick in a trash can. When
- 25:19I see this scene, I cannot understand what could
- 25:24lead only 13 % of film critics to find this movie
- 25:28at all good. It's quality filmmaking at every
- 25:33level by the cast and crew, led by a director
- 25:36who is clearly lending a very particular vision
- 25:39to this story. Of course I understand more when
- 25:44we get to the finale, which doesn't work on almost
- 25:48every level. It's saccharine, obnoxious, and
- 25:52uneven, which is, frankly, a script problem.
- 25:56It's the kind of ending you would expect to an
- 25:59odd couple comedy. And you know what? By that
- 26:03point, I don't care. A finale is not a film.
- 26:09The teacup climax is so satisfying that I can
- 26:15shrug a mediocre ending. And I'm not alone. There's
- 26:22a whole crew of younger millennials and Gen Z
- 26:25girls who grew up watching this movie at slumber
- 26:29parties, which has led to it being a sort of
- 26:32cult classic. As kids and teens watching it,
- 26:37they got what all the grown -up, stuffy, mostly
- 26:41male critics didn't. This is a story of two lost
- 26:47little girls. who help each other to find their
- 26:50way back home. A fairy tale, if I've ever heard
- 26:54one. And if you have the eyes to see it, you
- 26:59might be moved to what you find. Thanks for coming.