Latest / Chatter that Matters / Dr. Amra Sabic-El-Rayess - What the World Needs Now
Transcript
- 0:03You're about to hear from one of the most extraordinary people I've
- 0:07ever chatted with, not just on the podcast, but
- 0:11through my journey. She might have the answer for the
- 0:14future of the human race. And to put her on that
- 0:18pedestal, I have to tell you that as a young girl,
- 0:21she had to deal with the tragedy of losing her older brother. As
- 0:25a teenager, she had to deal with spending 1200
- 0:29days on the wrong side of genocide and
- 0:33all the horrors that came with it. Bosnian Muslims stood in the way of
- 0:36ethnically clean Greater Serbia. So one of Serbia's key
- 0:40military and political goals became the ethnic cleansing
- 0:44of Bosnian Muslims. I was one of
- 0:48those Muslims. She moved to the United States, had an extraordinary
- 0:52academic career. She could have had the most wonderful world
- 0:55on Wall Street because she's exceptional in mathematics.
- 0:59But she's made it her life calling to look at what causes
- 1:03us to hate each other. How can we get to a point where we
- 1:06wanna eradicate not only how somebody believes that their faith,
- 1:11we wanna eradicate their entire civilization.
- 1:15She doesn't come at it from a context of religion. She comes at
- 1:18it from humanity. And I really deeply wanted to hate men on
- 1:22the hills who were bombing us daily. What what I really learned is
- 1:26that it's a destructive feeling, and there's nothing that can be
- 1:30achieved with hate. And so I learned to really
- 1:33redirect negative energy that's targeting me
- 1:37to something that's constructive. And she's written 2 books, The
- 1:41Cat I Never Named and 3 Summers. And we're gonna go back and forth. The
- 1:44Cat I Never Named was when she experienced her time living on the wrong side
- 1:48of genocide as in Bosnia, and 3 Summers, her life
- 1:52before. Her name is doctor Amra Sharvich
- 1:56Eladias. She's an internationally recognized expert in genocide
- 2:00studies, preventing radicalization, and promoting peace through education.
- 2:04This is Chatter That Matters with Tony Chapman
- 2:08presented by RBC.
- 2:12Amra, welcome to Chatter That Matters. Thank you so much, Tony, for inviting
- 2:16me. I wanted to describe your early life in Bosnia before
- 2:19the world began. Your dreams, aspirations, what was family life
- 2:23like? Just to present the context that you were a child like anybody
- 2:27else, thinking that the world was gonna be your oyster. Thank you for asking
- 2:31that question. I actually rarely get, that
- 2:34type of question. Most people are focused on my experience of
- 2:38surviving the Bosnian genocide. But one of the reasons why I
- 2:42chose to write 3 summer Summers is precisely,
- 2:46related to what you had just asked. I wanted to
- 2:50travel upstream in my own life and
- 2:53revisit the three most magical summers of growing up
- 2:57in Bosnia prior to the genocide itself to
- 3:01really humanize those of us who survive,
- 3:06what is the unimaginable,
- 3:10and to really showcase that, a genocide
- 3:13survivor is is a human being as anyone else and that
- 3:17I was a young kid, hoping to change the
- 3:21world one day, that I had hoped to be seen
- 3:24as equal as any any other human being. I had a
- 3:28beautiful family. My father himself,
- 3:32lost his father who who fought fascism
- 3:35against fascism during World War 2, who
- 3:39grew up in my father, Mehmed, grew up in an orphanage,
- 3:43didn't even have a pair of shoes, when he
- 3:47walked into the orphanage for the first time.
- 3:51And then my mom, who was an educator who loved
- 3:54to, educate us about history and geography.
- 3:59I had 2 brothers, Amar and Dino.
- 4:03Dino is my younger brother, one of the main characters in 3 Summers.
- 4:07And, unfortunately, we lost Amar.
- 4:11I won't go into details of that story, but it is in 3 summers.
- 4:15It is in fact the loss of my older brother, Amar, who was brilliant,
- 4:20that ultimately compelled my parents to think
- 4:23about bringing several cousins together to help me
- 4:27overcome the grief. From that point on, I tell
- 4:31the story of these three most magical summers
- 4:34that helped me heal and helped me, transform
- 4:38from a young 11 year old to a much more
- 4:41mature teen in prewar Bosnia. And when you
- 4:45talk about the cousins as coming
- 4:48together and helping you through it, Do you ever get through it, or is
- 4:52it more that at least there's people to help you kind of
- 4:56shoulder what you're dealing with? Is it truly empathy that helps, or is it something
- 5:00internally that you have to somehow figure out that I do have to carry
- 5:03on? It is both. I think there's the role
- 5:07of resilience within ourselves in
- 5:10overcoming difficult moments in our lives, but that
- 5:14resilience is not singular. It's not one dimensional. It
- 5:17does involve community and family. And that's one of the
- 5:21reasons why as a as a scholar now, I study what are the
- 5:24protective factors, against hate and hate
- 5:28fueled violence. And family and the the values that our
- 5:32families instill in us are often,
- 5:35what, becomes a source of that collective resilience.
- 5:39And when I talk about family as those who will read 3 Summers will
- 5:43get to know. And also my first book, The Cat I Never Named,
- 5:46readers will get to know my family as a as a loving,
- 5:50as a resilient, family, and as a large family.
- 5:54In Bosnia, when we speak of family, we don't only think of our
- 5:58parents and our siblings. We, we think of
- 6:01every cousin in the world. And so when we have
- 6:05a picnic as a family, that means 100 people show up,
- 6:09whether you invited them or not. And so that there's that beauty
- 6:13of community and family that I talk about in 3 summers.
- 6:16And you mentioned the book, The Cat I Never Named, a true story of love,
- 6:20war, and survival. You published it in 2020. It's a memoir of your real
- 6:24life experiences. When you move on as this Muslim teenager,
- 6:28you're starting to find who you are and then the Bosnian
- 6:31genocide. And so how old were you when this horror unfolded? So I
- 6:35was an older teen at that time. I was 16, 17,
- 6:3918, you know, really growing up and,
- 6:42becoming deeply self aware. In 3 summers as
- 6:46a as a younger, teen, you actually as reader
- 6:50never get to see, what it feels like
- 6:53to to have your home bombed. And those
- 6:57scenes are in in The Cat I Never Named. But in 3
- 7:01Summers, one does get exposure to
- 7:05my experience of hearing for the first time
- 7:09hateful narratives and and sort of this transition
- 7:12from being an innocent kid who is growing up and and
- 7:16dealing with her body image of being 6 feet tall
- 7:20at the age of 11, which is not comfortable,
- 7:24to then by the end of 3rd summer realizing that I
- 7:27am that other, that the humanized, that
- 7:31subhuman that is about to be targeted, but still not
- 7:35fully comprehending that genocide is about to happen
- 7:39every day, living under the siege, not knowing if we're gonna survive or
- 7:42not, not knowing, what comes next,
- 7:46not only whether I'll be alive the next morning, but what comes
- 7:50next in the next, in the next minute, in the next
- 7:53hour of my life. And so it's it's a it's an intense experience.
- 7:57It's a powerful book, and I was reading some of the critics
- 8:01that said you held nothing back. Rape, torture, murder. You wanted the
- 8:05world to know what was happening. Why did you feel
- 8:08so compelled to share that? You know, when we talk about the most
- 8:12extreme form of targeted violence, and when I say targeted violence, I
- 8:16mean people being targeted for their identity, whatever that identity might be,
- 8:20racially, ethnically, religiously, or some other element element of their
- 8:24identity. Genocide is the most extreme form
- 8:27of that type of hate fueled violence.
- 8:31And I wanted people to understand, not
- 8:35only how awful that experience
- 8:39is, but also how, I
- 8:42received it as a young girl, as a young human
- 8:46being who gets to learn that I am
- 8:49placed on a list to be potentially
- 8:53taken into a rape camp or what it
- 8:56means to for me to decide with my
- 9:00mom, who at that point is already injured and deaf as
- 9:04a teacher, to cross
- 9:07the, what one might call, enemy lines and try to
- 9:11buy food from those who were killing us. And you might wonder, why
- 9:15would one ever, ever want to try to buy
- 9:19food from those who are shooting at them? I mean, those are the
- 9:23situations that are real, when one
- 9:27is trying to survive. But I also wanna highlight
- 9:30that in The Cat I Never Named, I wanted to
- 9:33also showcase the community,
- 9:37the love, amazing teachers,
- 9:41amazing parents, and friends and family that
- 9:45helped me survive, and really inspiring people
- 9:49self reflection to think about if I hate someone or if I
- 9:52feel a bias towards someone or or or if I stereotype
- 9:56people, should we really be doing that? And Macy's
- 10:00the cat who it plays quite a role in your survival story. And I I
- 10:04wish the audience, because this is a podcast, can see the smile that just came
- 10:07on your face. Talk to me about the bond you formed with her
- 10:11and how in many ways she she symbolized
- 10:14this the fact that you survived 1200 days of this
- 10:18horror. So Mattsian Bosnian means kitty.
- 10:22Therefore, the title, the cat that I never named, and I won't go into
- 10:25details of symbolism of of the
- 10:29title itself. But I'll share with you that, the
- 10:33onset of the cat I never named, I end
- 10:37up, meeting refugees who were coming
- 10:40into my hometown, as my dad and I,
- 10:44went, went into into the into the city.
- 10:49In that moment, I begin to realize that something major is shifting and
- 10:52happening, that something will be happening, to us not
- 10:56quite understanding that my city is about to be besieged and that
- 11:00we will be bombed and targeted. I encounter this
- 11:03cat, that follows us back home, and
- 11:07she adopts herself into our family. And I do share
- 11:10that my family did not want to be responsible for
- 11:14another living being in the midst of what we were facing,
- 11:18but Matti didn't care. There are a number of days that we spent in a
- 11:22neighbor's basement at the onset of the military siege of
- 11:25my hometown of Bihej on a beautiful day in
- 11:29June. My younger brother Dino and I decided to
- 11:33leave the basement where we were hiding with a number of other
- 11:36families from from bombs. My home did not have a basement.
- 11:41And we didn't tell our parents, which, of course, I don't recommend any
- 11:44kid to ever do. But we
- 11:48left to go see Motsi because Motsi didn't wanna stay in the basement, and
- 11:52she stayed in our home. We got there,
- 11:56and we heard Motsi crying. And Dino and I called her.
- 11:59I've never heard an animal make that kind of sound before. We thought she
- 12:03was hurt. She wouldn't come to us. So Dino and I,
- 12:07we were talking to 4 of my girlfriends who
- 12:11invited us to walk around the neighborhood. We were very naive. We didn't know
- 12:14that because bombing stopped for few minutes that
- 12:18that we thought and hoped that that means the war is over.
- 12:22So they asked us to hang out with them, walk around the
- 12:25neighborhood. And, because of Monte, Dino and I
- 12:29ran into 2 different directions to see her, to find her because we
- 12:33thought she was injured. She was crying for help. And in
- 12:37that moment, a bomb hit and blew up, to
- 12:41pieces for my friends. I would
- 12:45not be here. My life would have
- 12:48ended on the 1st day of the siege of my city if
- 12:52it were not for an animal. Do you ever think she was there for more
- 12:55than just a stray cat that felt that she's your guardian angel? I mean, following
- 12:59you home with your dad and being part of this whole giving you a beacon
- 13:01of light, do you ever think that there's something much more to her than just
- 13:03the fact that by accident you stumbled on a stray cat? As a professor, I
- 13:06started my career at Columbia teaching statistics. So I'm a math
- 13:14person. I'm a probability person. But there is something that I
- 13:17cannot explain, and that is that this cat
- 13:21saved my life a number of times. And I won't share each and every
- 13:25story, but throughout The Cat I Never Named, she was
- 13:29with me in the moments that were critical that
- 13:33directed my decision making in a way that,
- 13:37enabled me to be here today. I firmly believe
- 13:40that if were if it were not for Mazzi,
- 13:44my as you as you called her rightly called her guardian
- 13:48angel, I would not be here today. How did you manage to
- 13:52preserve your identity knowing that there are so many people
- 13:56out there trying to eradicate it? It's not an easy endeavor
- 14:00to be consistently on this journey of
- 14:04trying to humanize yourself at the time when you
- 14:07are being deeply dehumanized. You know, the
- 14:11and genocide isn't only about destruction of of
- 14:15people in a physical sense, but it's also about
- 14:19destruction of religious heritage. 80% of mosques in
- 14:22Bosnia were destroyed or damaged during the genocide. It is
- 14:26also about destruction and targeting of schools and the libraries because
- 14:29that is what the future of of, a
- 14:33particular group that is being eradicated is or may
- 14:37be. And so I do think that what helped me
- 14:40humanize myself and retain my own sense of self and and
- 14:44identity is actually writing the stories like The Cat I Never Named
- 14:47in Three Summers. I didn't write The Cat I Never Named right
- 14:51after genocide and the war. It took many years
- 14:55of of really working on being able to
- 14:59to verbalize one's own story. When I came to the United States, I
- 15:03didn't speak English. I I spoke English only to the extent
- 15:07of what I could teach myself while living
- 15:10under those conditions. So you can imagine, you know,
- 15:14a a a young girl memorizing English words from an
- 15:18old dictionary that my dad used when he was trying to impress young
- 15:22girls. He would meet on the coast of, Adriatic
- 15:25Sea in Croatia when he was a college student. I mean, that was my source
- 15:29of knowledge when it comes to English, and I was thrown really catapulted
- 15:33into higher education system here, and I had to,
- 15:37learn English on on the go. And so
- 15:41it takes time to master the language, number 1.
- 15:44Number 2, to really self reflect after
- 15:48such, such a trauma on
- 15:52who I wanted to be. And one big question that
- 15:56anyone who is exposed to violence ask themselves is,
- 15:59how do I interrupt this cycle of hate? What is it
- 16:03that I can do? And for me, storytelling,
- 16:07is a powerful way, to
- 16:10humanize the others and and and that cycle. Talk to
- 16:14me about your so in 2020, you wrote that book, you said, many years after.
- 16:18Your dad had shared a lot of the orphanage and not having a pair
- 16:22of shoes, and I I have to imagine a lot of that roared through you.
- 16:25You did the same with your daughter. You had her very involved in writing the
- 16:28book. And how how was that experience? Because the I
- 16:32mean, it wasn't easy reading. It wasn't easy writing. Often when I engage in telling
- 16:36my story and or or I'm invited to a conference or a
- 16:39panel, I might be placed in a panel titled something
- 16:43like Tough Topics. But when those of us who survive
- 16:47difficult things in in our lives, for us, it's
- 16:50it's just our life. It's who we are. I cannot
- 16:54separate or overcome. In my view, there's no way
- 16:58of overcoming something as traumatic as as
- 17:01genocide. You just learn how to live with it because it is what
- 17:05defines ultimately your future journey and trajectory. It's
- 17:09not something that I can separate from who I am today. I
- 17:12don't know who Amra would have been without that experience. And
- 17:16so growing up, my kids, were exposed to
- 17:20my stories of not having food. I've taught them
- 17:23to value each and every piece of food. And, you know, sometimes
- 17:27we would go to restaurant as you do in in, let's say, in New York
- 17:31City where we live, And my kids would ask
- 17:34to from restaurant to take the leftover, and there would be only 2
- 17:38French fries in on the plate left. You know? And
- 17:42someone who who is, who is a service person would would
- 17:45come to us and say, do you really want to take home the
- 17:492 leftover bites of food? But it is because
- 17:53I this has been a part of me. This has been
- 17:56ingrained in me, and my kids understood that from early on. So
- 18:00Dina, my younger daughter in particular, loves writing,
- 18:04loves, loves reading, and she knew many
- 18:08both of my girls, Dina and Janna, know most of the
- 18:11stories that appear in The Cat I Never Name. And she
- 18:15wanted to read them, and she would provide me with feedback and say,
- 18:19mom, I think some of the details you shared with us
- 18:23are not in this version. I think they would be valuable
- 18:26for readers in America. And so she was really
- 18:29critical in helping me
- 18:33get through the process and guiding me on what she thought young adults
- 18:37and and and teens in particular would would, find
- 18:40appealing. So you talked about your math brain and orientation
- 18:44towards statistics, but a lot of you also talk about during that time is your
- 18:48poetry, that you found a way to escape into your
- 18:51words. So it's interesting that you have both sides to your
- 18:55brain. I wish I had my poems. My house was bombed on my
- 18:58birthday. And I think during that bombing, a big
- 19:02part of our house was destroyed. And that's where I lost,
- 19:07many photos, many books. I
- 19:10was unable to find, my poems,
- 19:14which I actually had someone on a typewriter,
- 19:18for me, write during the war and some of my
- 19:22diaries were destroyed. And so, I wish I had
- 19:26them. They were at the time my way of dealing with
- 19:29the hate and violence and loss. So I would write poems about friends I had
- 19:33lost, or I would write poems about emotions and feelings
- 19:36and complexity of what it was to feel
- 19:40subhuman and be treated as subhuman human in those days.
- 19:44And how did the survivors, other survivors of other
- 19:47experiences, react to your book? Were they happy that
- 19:51those thoughts were coming out and you were making the world aware that
- 19:55just what might be sensationalized on the news really is
- 19:58about individual humans and circumstances? One of the groups
- 20:02I was thinking the most when I was writing The Cat I Never Named
- 20:06because there are so very few stories of our survival
- 20:10of Bosnian genocide. It's a, you know, a fairly recent
- 20:14genocide, the only the only genocide that transpired in
- 20:17in Europe post, post holocaust.
- 20:22So many of us are still alive, and many of
- 20:25us have stories that are in us, but
- 20:29many survivors find it very, very difficult
- 20:33to write them, to express them. And it
- 20:36is hard to know that one is
- 20:40sharing the most vulnerable thoughts and experiences that
- 20:44I had with the rest of the world, you know, someone who
- 20:48might make fun of you or ridicule you or hurt you for
- 20:51even sharing those, experiences. And so I didn't know what the reaction would
- 20:55be. And I do have to say that I have
- 20:59been overwhelmed with how
- 21:03Americans and and readers around the world have welcomed my
- 21:06story. The the response
- 21:10has been incredibly positive.
- 21:14And many survivors, in fact, I
- 21:17published a scholarly paper analyzing,
- 21:20thousands of messages that I had received from survivors,
- 21:25who have said, I feel seen. I feel heard. I
- 21:29feel you are telling my story. Daily, I
- 21:32get emails from young kids who say
- 21:37maybe their their parents are not even, survivors of Bosnian
- 21:40genocide, but have survived atrocities elsewhere or
- 21:44have experienced genocide in their lineage who say, it
- 21:48is only now that I read the story that I can visualize and
- 21:51feel what my parents or my grandparents
- 21:55might have gone through. It has allowed me to build a conversation and a
- 21:59deeper connection with them and understand their own behavior, why
- 22:02they why they care about certain things and certain values
- 22:06within our family. So you come to America armed with a few
- 22:10words that your data taught you. From an academic point of view, you
- 22:14go to some of the toughest universities. How how do you do that?
- 22:17I'm always fascinated with somebody coming without the command of the language
- 22:21that's being taught and find a way to command that language and the
- 22:25same time become a stellar student. I was skinny,
- 22:30deprived from food and humanization for
- 22:34for years. So I was terrified of people in men in uniform in
- 22:37particular. I was terrified of, immigration
- 22:41process. And when I got to the immigration window, I
- 22:45remember holding onto it with my hands because I
- 22:49thought I was going to pass out out of fear. I did not think
- 22:53that I would be welcomed, that there was a place, for
- 22:56me in America. And the officer took a
- 23:00long time to go through my paperwork
- 23:05and, at the end, reached out with his hands. And I thought he's going to
- 23:08send me back to Bosnia and say you don't belong here. But
- 23:12instead, he with his fingertips, he touched my hands,
- 23:16and he said, I'm sorry for what you have gone
- 23:19through, ma'am. Welcome to the United States of America. You're safe
- 23:23now. That was the moment where I fell in love with the
- 23:26idea of America. And I, you know, my
- 23:301st semester, in college,
- 23:34I, was taking a course on western
- 23:37history of western civilization. And, one of the
- 23:41first books I read was Leviathan by Hobbes. For anyone who's read
- 23:45that book knows that it's written in old English. And then when I initially
- 23:49opened it, I I, didn't understand a single
- 23:52word. So I spent 3 months, translating,
- 23:56the book, buying dictionaries. I bought the dictionary on my way
- 24:00to America in Zagreb, Croatia, and I,
- 24:05I started with straight a's in my first semester. In fact,
- 24:09the professor of history who taught that class said, if you can
- 24:12do this in your 1st semester, maybe you should do a PhD in history. And
- 24:16I said, thank you, but no thank you. It is,
- 24:20determination. I think anyone and everyone can do it. It's just a
- 24:24question of decisions that we make in life and a choice that we
- 24:28will we will succeed. It sounds like there's a lot of
- 24:31doors that could have opened for you, including mathematics, which is, you know, one
- 24:35of the most coveted anybody has a mathematics degree now is welcomed
- 24:39by almost any of the firms focusing on the new economy, but you're really
- 24:43seemed to shift. And I I unless I have it wrong and realize that you
- 24:47might have a different role, and that is to talk about
- 24:51genocide and do your part to see if we can end the cycle of
- 24:54history repeating. And I'm curious when that
- 24:58happened with you. Sounds to me like mathematics would have been a skip in the
- 25:01park for you in terms of everything, but but really, you have a different calling.
- 25:05You're absolutely right. My career right after college was on Wall
- 25:09Street. I worked in in investment banking, leveraged buyouts,
- 25:12leveraged finance, and then 911 happened.
- 25:16And that was a turning point for me because as
- 25:20a Muslim woman, I got to hear this
- 25:24view of 1.8 or
- 25:289000000000 Muslims in the world are all terrorists.
- 25:32And that was extremely painful for me,
- 25:35to to receive. And it did,
- 25:39raise a question for me. What is really my purpose?
- 25:43And I recognized that because I had access to
- 25:47education, I was able to achieve,
- 25:51achieve what I had achieved at that point, but it was very
- 25:55selfish approach to life. And that my purpose should
- 25:58be to, 1, enable others to access education,
- 26:02and 2, educate educate people
- 26:06about various assumptions that we make about
- 26:09one another that can lead to acts
- 26:13of, violence and all kinds of forms of
- 26:16extremism. So some some of my work today, and I would say really
- 26:20all of my work today, is focused on
- 26:24prevention of hate fueled violence, whether it's through storytelling
- 26:28or, using, you know, quantitative methods to
- 26:31analyze data as a scholar at Columbia and published
- 26:35peer reviewed articles on that work. I've always said if we could
- 26:39just realize that we're all one human race,
- 26:43so much would disappear. But, you know, those who seek power, either
- 26:47through religion or through profit, seems to continually tear
- 26:51it apart. And I think it's just a handful of people. I might be so
- 26:53naive, and that's why I wanted to talk to you. I might be so naive
- 26:56to say somehow or other we let a handful of people
- 27:00capture this power, and in doing so, we
- 27:03suddenly have the narrative that 1,800,000,000 Muslims are
- 27:07terrorists. Why does that happen, and is there anything we can
- 27:10do to stop it from happening? Well, these are excellent questions. I'll
- 27:14tell you that I asked myself those questions when I initially
- 27:18started to work on understanding where does hate come from.
- 27:22You know, how is it possible that let's take as an example,
- 27:26mass shooting in Buffalo, New York where I worked with educators
- 27:30only days after that shooting on violence and hate prevention.
- 27:34It was scheduled, months prior to the shooting itself, but it
- 27:38happened in that moment. Why is it that somebody can be,
- 27:42a kid playing in a sandbox in 5th or 6th grade and then grow up
- 27:46into someone at the age of 17 or 18 and be willing
- 27:49to go into supermarket and target people simply for the color of
- 27:53their skin? People actually don't begin to hate or
- 27:57radicalize because they have this facile
- 28:00desire to just kill or hurt or harm someone.
- 28:04It usually starts with a lacking sense of,
- 28:08belonging, feeling displaced, through narrative, through
- 28:12curriculum, through storytelling in educational spaces
- 28:16or in our mainstream society. So they don't
- 28:20begin with the intent to harm someone else. They
- 28:23begin with desire to to be seen, to be heard, to
- 28:27have their grievances addressed. And just in the last few months,
- 28:31we're actually preparing a paper for a study for publication right
- 28:34now. We have analyzed, more than 518,000
- 28:39student surveys from across 68 countries, all
- 28:43western countries, to actually examine the importance
- 28:47of and and link between access to civil liberties, access
- 28:50to free speech, access to free expression
- 28:54with one's sense of belonging. Because we know when people feel
- 28:58a sense of belonging, they're happy in that community, and they wanna be part
- 29:01of the community, and they're not thinking about inflicting
- 29:05violence on anyone within their community. So if we can build a sense of
- 29:09belonging for everybody, that means we can protect everyone
- 29:13in our society from hate fueled violence. And what we found
- 29:17is that across different immigrant backgrounds, whether someone is a
- 29:201st generation or 3rd or 4th generation, across
- 29:24all 68 societies, the,
- 29:28more of genuine dialogue, the more access to freedom of
- 29:32expression we have, and the more we allow students
- 29:36in our, educational spaces to express themselves
- 29:40and in a nonviolent way address their grievances,
- 29:45the more likely we are to to build a sense of belonging.
- 29:49This is something that we haven't focused on, unfortunately,
- 29:52in education. In media,
- 29:56if if, hypothetically speaking, if I wanted
- 30:00to, to be interviewed by some big,
- 30:03news agency, I would have to come in with some kind of
- 30:07scandalous news, right, to get the attention. But to
- 30:11get the attention by saying, let's build community
- 30:14is is is actually difficult. And I think our
- 30:17society has been structured from education to media to
- 30:21political narratives to to build itself on this
- 30:25narrative of the other, of this narrative of of
- 30:28us versus them because that narrative mobilizes
- 30:32people's emotions. However, it mobilizes people's emotions in a
- 30:36negative way. And I fear that. And I fear the silos
- 30:40we've created on social media, we've created in social
- 30:43spaces. Because if I don't like someone today, I don't have
- 30:47to ever speak with them. And the only remaining spaces
- 30:50where we can engage with someone who thinks differently than we do,
- 30:54who has different experience than we do, is in,
- 30:58education.
- 31:04My whole podcast is about positivity and possibility to counter this
- 31:07growing sense of negativity and impossibility. I don't have your
- 31:11brain power or your data, but my intuition, we're very aligned. But I wanna start
- 31:15with education. To have that kind of conversation,
- 31:19do we not need different educators that are more facilitators, that are more
- 31:23that that leave their biases at the front door and come into a classroom
- 31:27and try to create this conversation and dialogue where everybody
- 31:31feels they have a sense of belonging as opposed to being overpowered.
- 31:35So one of the projects that I have developed that is research based,
- 31:39evidence based on everything we're discussing is called reimagine
- 31:43resilience. And and for those who are listening to us, they can go to
- 31:46reimagineresilience.org. It is
- 31:50a, it was a project seeded through,
- 31:54an innovation research grant by the federal government,
- 31:57by Center For Prevention Programs and Partnerships at the US
- 32:01Department of Homeland Security, who have funded,
- 32:06my effort to create a actually a professional training
- 32:09program for educators and education professionals.
- 32:13Now that has expanded, with us training
- 32:17faith leaders, and really with my team taking a whole of
- 32:21society approach. It is not only sufficient to
- 32:24train educators on how do you better engage with your
- 32:28students. It is not, sufficient to only raise awareness
- 32:32around, how does hate emerge,
- 32:35what does it mean to be making assumptions
- 32:39about people, and and and how does that impact
- 32:43your students' well-being and the well-being of the entire community in the
- 32:47school? We need to work with all stakeholders
- 32:51within the society. But I'm gonna be honest with you, there are
- 32:543,000,000, maybe 3,500,000,
- 32:58educators in the United States. I have been in in
- 33:0158 cities, 47 states, whether in person or virtually over
- 33:05the last 2 years with this program, training thousands of educators.
- 33:09But this is, to my knowledge, the only program that has
- 33:13been very effective in changing people's
- 33:17attitudes and mindsets in how they view
- 33:21whoever is the other in their, in their world. So now
- 33:25move to social media because I I view in the most simplistic
- 33:28sense, social media monetizes by herding us
- 33:32into castles where we exist with like minded people who like like minded
- 33:35content, who validate each other, and learn to love
- 33:39everything they do and hate what everybody else does. The middle ground
- 33:42where society the the great societies were built, the renaissance as
- 33:46we're built, has become a toxic moat. And I see it time and
- 33:50time again that that, as you said, you and we'll talk about the media as
- 33:53well, mass media. If it's not you're not at the
- 33:57hairpin turn waiting for an accident, nobody wants to talk to you. How do
- 34:00we push back against social media? Because I feel like I do
- 34:04belong as a left wing or right wing, as a Republican or
- 34:07Democrat. I really feel I belong there, but I part of my
- 34:11conditions of belonging is I have to hate the other. So we work with young
- 34:14kids. We work with adults. And and one of our studies has showed that
- 34:18only 15% of students feel that they don't
- 34:22have a need to learn information by going
- 34:26to social media. Because in educational formal spaces,
- 34:29if we're not trained or comfortable to discuss a particularly
- 34:33tough topic, we just stay silent on it. But the problem
- 34:37is that those who are curious to learn, if someone wants to
- 34:41learn your story, they will go online and
- 34:44seek information. And so the question for me, for for educators
- 34:48often is we have a choice, and our choice is
- 34:52between either instilling
- 34:55capacities in our educators and training
- 34:59educators and students to have constructive
- 35:03nonviolent genuine dialogues across a range
- 35:07of difficult topics in schools and giving
- 35:11students actionable ways to address whatever
- 35:14grievances they might have so that they build that sense of
- 35:18empowerment and community and belonging across identity.
- 35:22So we're not categorized into these singular groups that
- 35:26are not really true representation of who we are. Identity isn't a
- 35:29category. It's a story. It's my story. It's your story and so on.
- 35:35So if we fail to do that, and I think we're failing to to
- 35:38do that across higher education k through 12 institutions,
- 35:42then it's only natural and expected that people
- 35:46will gravitate towards social media because that is where they will seek
- 35:50answers. And so for those who who
- 35:53are, who might be afraid to engage in genuine
- 35:57dialogue, educators often will say I don't have training or
- 36:00I'm not well versed in certain topics and so on. The question
- 36:04is, would we rather train our educators to be effective
- 36:08in the classroom and build a community, or do we
- 36:11prefer that children, young
- 36:15adults, and students are actually, going to social
- 36:19media and getting information from
- 36:22from whoever, wherever, in a way that we we
- 36:26don't really know if it's reliable or not. Reliable is one issue. The issue is
- 36:30the algorithms that say if you happen to if this moth
- 36:33was attracted to this flame, they're gonna make sure they turn on the flame and
- 36:36bring more moss. Maybe I'm I'm just old, but I think radicalization's
- 36:41happening on social media, not in the sense of maybe,
- 36:45join my gang, but the more I can keep you within this
- 36:49community of like minded people, the more I can monetize
- 36:53monetize your time there. It's about a captive audience. The pathway to
- 36:57radicalization can certainly happen online if
- 37:01one encounters a recruiter online. We've seen that with the
- 37:04number of individuals that we have interviewed who have said,
- 37:08you know, I was silenced, not recognized, not respected
- 37:12in in my classroom, in my school. And I found
- 37:16someone who who educated me, quote unquote,
- 37:20into thinking differently, who who has helped
- 37:23me understand and rationalize my grievances
- 37:27and so on. And so those bonds can be built online
- 37:31and lead to radicalization. Do you think that religion
- 37:35has taken advantage of that? That my sense of belonging
- 37:39that I often might find in a mosque or a church, a
- 37:43synagogue is also an opportunity to fashion a
- 37:46way of thinking that isn't necessarily about a human
- 37:50race, but much more about why Catholics are better than Jews
- 37:54or Muslims are better than Christians? We're working on a number of projects within
- 37:57the Interfaith Lab, which is another initiative that I established,
- 38:01specifically because faith has been neglected in many
- 38:05conversations that we've had. We make a lot of assumptions, and there's a lot of
- 38:09misuse of faith related, narratives.
- 38:13But when you distill many real
- 38:17values, if you will, within faith narratives,
- 38:21there's so much commonality across the different
- 38:25faiths in terms of coexistence, tolerance,
- 38:28respecting diversity. You know? I don't think we have
- 38:32taken the faith related narratives into
- 38:36consideration as a potentially powerful
- 38:40mobilizing tool for bringing communities together.
- 38:44I think faith has been misused has been misused through
- 38:48history to mobilize fear, to
- 38:51mobilize hate towards the other, but we have not
- 38:55built resilience to hate by mobilizing positive
- 38:58aspects, within different faiths. And I think that is something
- 39:02that we need to do better. When I talk about whole society
- 39:06approach, I think it's important to bring in faith leaders
- 39:09who can inspire resilience to hate within their
- 39:13own communities and say these are not the values that
- 39:17represent our faith community, but also can then work
- 39:20on building bridges across different faiths. A last one I will and then
- 39:24I wanna move on, but because it's fascinating. I mean, I could talk to you
- 39:27all day. It's politics. I have never seen politics at a
- 39:31level where it's us versus them. Is
- 39:34that just because that's all I'm seeing, or is that, you think, it's
- 39:38really steeping into what democracy has become, which is about
- 39:42the more I get you to hate the other person, the better my chances are
- 39:45being elected and being in power? I'll give you, an historic
- 39:49example of, understanding the rise and fall of
- 39:52the Islamic empire. During the golden
- 39:56age of Islam, there was this incredible
- 40:00welcoming of all forms of knowledge. There is, there was
- 40:04an institution called House of Wisdom in,
- 40:087th, 8th, 9th 9th century in, Baghdad,
- 40:12present day Iraq. And, House of
- 40:15Wisdom welcomed, scientists of all
- 40:19backgrounds, all faith backgrounds. Didn't matter whether you were
- 40:22Muslim, Jew, or Christian, you were
- 40:26welcomed, to produce,
- 40:30scholarship. And there was an immense focus
- 40:33on advancement through understanding, through learning.
- 40:37And there's a famous, hadith of prophet,
- 40:41Muhammad, peace be upon him, that says,
- 40:45seek knowledge even if it takes traveling to China. So there was this
- 40:48idea that, really, knowledge is power, connection
- 40:52human connection is power, and that led to the rise of
- 40:56golden age of Islam. My favorite subject one of my favorite subjects
- 41:00is math and algebra. Algebra is an Arabic word. Al
- 41:04Khwarizmi was a mathematician in the house of wisdom who was the first to
- 41:07solve some of these algebraic equations, and therefore,
- 41:12the name the name algebra, optics,
- 41:17engineering, and so on, but also translating and
- 41:20preserving during the dark ages in Europe, translating
- 41:24and preserving all of the ancient knowledge was a big
- 41:28important aspect of advancing learning at that time in
- 41:32the Islamic empire. And then there was a period
- 41:35when there was a certain sense of self assurance and
- 41:39confidence that, you know, we've reached the the top. We don't need
- 41:43really this knowledge, what we need. There's a lot of empire got
- 41:46large geographically, so we need actually to make sure people blindly
- 41:50follow their leaders. So we're going to neglect some
- 41:54of this focus on science and knowledge, and we'll
- 41:58focus on more being inward looking, protecting the
- 42:01power that we have. And that's where we saw a decline
- 42:05in publications of books. We saw banning of books.
- 42:09We saw a decline in scientific advancement. And so
- 42:13looking at historic examples really signaled that any
- 42:16time we become
- 42:20limited by this view of us versus them
- 42:24and the world becomes binary, and the world becomes about
- 42:27banning the narratives or banning books or limiting
- 42:31scientific progress. We saw what happened during COVID 19. People who
- 42:34believed in this or not believed in that and believed in
- 42:38science or didn't support science, I think
- 42:42we are walking a very dangerous line.
- 42:47When we come back, doctor Ambre Chadich Alireas
- 42:51shares more of her thoughts on what we can do to make this
- 42:55world a much better place. And then my 3
- 42:58takeaways.
- 43:03Hi. It's Tony Chapman. Investing in Canada? Well, that matters
- 43:07to RBC. $500,000,000,000 in sustainable financing
- 43:11to combat climate change. 500,000,000 for future launch. A
- 43:1510 year program to prepare youth for the jobs of tomorrow, helping
- 43:18to discover the next generation of Olympians, artists monetizing their
- 43:22talents, women entrepreneurs pursuing their dreams, supporting mental
- 43:26health, and so much more. Investing in Canada, well, that
- 43:29matters to RBC.
- 43:33With this question of how does hate emerge, hate is
- 43:37precursors to to violence. So when you have hate narratives that are
- 43:41adopted in various spaces in our society, whether it's social
- 43:45media, traditional media, educational spaces, formal,
- 43:48informal spaces, Thanksgiving dinner tables, that
- 43:52that feeds the actual act of violence. How do
- 43:56you begin to change that narrative? You begin to
- 44:00change it through, interventions in the classrooms.
- 44:03You're listening to Chatter That Matters with Tony Chapman
- 44:07presented by RBC. Joining me today is doctor Amra
- 44:11Sharvich Eladias. And instead of her heart filled
- 44:14with hate because she was on the wrong side of the Bosnia genocide,
- 44:19she's chosen to fill it with love and to use her intellectual
- 44:22prowess in her platform to wake up the world and say
- 44:26we're all part of 1 human race.
- 44:31How do you respond to contemporary genocide denial?
- 44:35Like, that didn't happen. This sense of just lifting
- 44:39up a carpet and sweeping it under the rug. And in doing so,
- 44:43we continue to go to this flywheel of history repeats.
- 44:47I would say as a genocide survivor, I have
- 44:51lost capacity to feel hate.
- 44:54So even if someone denies my existence, my experience,
- 44:58what I feel is deep sense of pain and sadness.
- 45:03And I think of everything that could pain
- 45:06one who has survived,
- 45:10worst atrocities that humankind can inflict on itself,
- 45:16the hardest is is denial. The hardest is denial
- 45:19because it reinforces that pain of not being
- 45:23seen, heard, or see or treated as a human being.
- 45:27Just recently, just days ago, the United Nations
- 45:31have passed the resolution acknowledging specifically Srebrensa
- 45:34genocide, which was really a combination of the Bosnian,
- 45:38genocide where the UN soldiers were present as
- 45:42the, Serb forces entered, the
- 45:46town of Srebrensa and executed almost,
- 45:50all, men and boys under this
- 45:54narrative of we need to fear these men. They are
- 45:59subhuman, and we need to execute them all. I
- 46:02think for those of us who speak out on our own experiences, it's
- 46:06really important to for all of us to
- 46:09demonstrate respect for those who have gone through hardships. And I'm not speaking here
- 46:13just about my own experience, but experiences of millions of
- 46:17other people who have been around the world targeted for who
- 46:21they are. We have to offer a sense of respect
- 46:24and and and view their credibility as
- 46:28equal to our own. You know, as an American now, as
- 46:32someone who's faculty member at Columbia, who is an author, who
- 46:36is successful, I had the privilege of credibility, of being
- 46:39invited to have a conversation with you. Millions of
- 46:43others will never have that positionality. And so we
- 46:46have to rethink that. Why is that why is that that some voices are
- 46:50more credible than than others? And why why is it that we
- 46:54dismiss some experiences versus others? I think each and
- 46:57every human being should be respected for who they are and should
- 47:01never go through what I had gone through or what so many are going going
- 47:05through around the world as we speak now. Have you ever thought of the
- 47:09soldiers that went in and executed people?
- 47:13What their life is like afterwards looking back and thinking
- 47:16about how they got caught up in a moment? Do we
- 47:20know the impact of what happens when a mob
- 47:24suddenly is unleashed? Bandura is a famous,
- 47:28a famous psychologist who, who has studied how
- 47:32is it that people can commit these kinds of atrocities
- 47:35and and, moral disengagement.
- 47:39And what we know at certain parts of the brain
- 47:42that that, a signal empathy light
- 47:46up when we when we engage with someone who we
- 47:50think is part of our in group versus
- 47:54those who are part who we perceive as part of the out group. So
- 47:57we have the capacity as human beings to really turn
- 48:01off this, sense of empathy for one another
- 48:05when, we perceive a person as not belonging to our
- 48:09in group. And I think that is what enables
- 48:13ordinary people. These are ordinary people.
- 48:17Teachers, professors, police officers,
- 48:21army officers, neighbors. In 3
- 48:25summers, I talk about my own uncle who was a Serb,
- 48:28who was married to my aunt, who was a lieutenant
- 48:32in, in Serbia's in former Yugoslavia's
- 48:36army, which became de facto Serbia's army. So it was my
- 48:40own uncle who partook, in
- 48:43the army that ultimately committed genocide. And
- 48:47so I talk about at the end of 3 summers what happened to
- 48:51that, relationship, as we speak
- 48:54now. So I think what we do know based on the data that it
- 48:58is ordinary people who commit these
- 49:02extraordinarily painful acts of violence when they morally
- 49:05disengage from seeing the other as a human being, which is
- 49:09why in a lot of my trainings, I talk about
- 49:13typology of a hate fueled violence. And to me,
- 49:17I see it as a tree. You know, the branches and the leaves
- 49:20is the physical manifestation of violence that we witness,
- 49:24whether it's killing of George Floyd as a black person on an American
- 49:28street, or it's placing a girl like Amra into a
- 49:31rape camp, in Bosnia in 19
- 49:35nineties. But the actual source
- 49:39or or or the root to that kind of behavior,
- 49:43how is that possible? How do we do that? It is possible when
- 49:46we engage in narratives of supremacy, dehumanization,
- 49:50othering, marginalization, racism,
- 49:54because those narratives portray, hypothetically
- 49:57speaking, Amra as someone who is not a human
- 50:01being. So if Amra is not a human being, that means that I can
- 50:04kill Amra, that I can harm Amra, and that is
- 50:08what individuals who commit those acts of violence tell themselves.
- 50:12I'll tell you just quickly that I did engage in
- 50:15research project, specifically working with former soldiers
- 50:19who partook in the Bosnian genocide. And in
- 50:23fact, I was asked to work on a project to help them reintegrate
- 50:27into the society post war. At the time, I reserved,
- 50:32the right to potentially withdraw, you know, if I felt that I could
- 50:36not see them as human beings because I didn't really know. I
- 50:39didn't know until I came face to face with some of these
- 50:44individuals whether I would wanna help them or or,
- 50:48quite frankly, harm them in some ways. And there was one soldier
- 50:51who wanted to become a farmer.
- 50:55He was not highly educated. He wanted to obtain a
- 50:59cow through this particular reintegration program. I
- 51:03tried to help him navigate the the system, and he
- 51:06obtained this cow. And then he called the office
- 51:10that I was in in Sarajevo, and he was
- 51:13falling apart on the other line. And he
- 51:17wanted to know why did I help him. How could I help
- 51:20him? Because the things that he has done to people like
- 51:24me, are are things that that give
- 51:27him nightmares every night, and he cannot sleep. And me helping
- 51:31him made it worse. So he wanted to understand
- 51:35why was I kind to him when he was so inhumane to people like
- 51:38me. And I told him, that is your burden to live with for the rest
- 51:42of your life. It's not mine. And I'm glad that I
- 51:46didn't feel sense of hate. If anything, I felt sense of
- 51:49pity that that is the life you have to deal with.
- 51:53You have to deal with yourself as a human being for the rest
- 51:57of your life and examine your own actions. And
- 52:01so I don't know if that's representative of many people. I think
- 52:04most people continue to morally justify. You know, this
- 52:08had to be done because of this goal, higher goal, because my
- 52:12kind is better than your kind and those kinds of narratives. But
- 52:16ultimately, everybody has to go at night to sleep and wonder, what
- 52:20have I done to another human being, and am I okay with that? Just before
- 52:23I end, I'll just share you this personal thought. Sometimes I try to rationalize
- 52:28how horrific the human race is by believing we're just a
- 52:31reality show of a master race. And this is all for ratings
- 52:35because I just can't believe at times we
- 52:39can commit these acts. And I sadly can't put myself in the shoes of either
- 52:43the victim or the attacker because I just hurt so
- 52:46much. And I just have to believe that this can't
- 52:50possibly be happening. This must be just some fantastic video
- 52:53game that some race has created, and every once in a while, people are getting
- 52:56bored with it. They launch this thing because it's just I'm amazed that
- 53:00people like you are on this planet that have survived it and can and can
- 53:04speak with such passion. I always end my shows with
- 53:083 takeaways. And, again, the first one I'm gonna say is that for
- 53:12people to take things personally, you have to personalize it. And that really is
- 53:15narrative and storytelling. And what I learned from you is how important that
- 53:19storytelling was for you to just survive those 1200 days with your
- 53:23poetry. Later on to sort of compartmentalize it
- 53:26with your daughter in terms of writing your first book. But also the stories can
- 53:30go for or against us based on the narrative. Storytelling
- 53:34and personalizing and feeling and seeing it is so important.
- 53:38The second thing that I really took away is the importance of
- 53:41belonging. It's Maslow's hierarchy of needs. It's one of the most important
- 53:45motivations, but you've really put a lens to belonging
- 53:49and how when somebody doesn't belong, they feel like they're standing
- 53:53on shifting sand, or they're being bullied or attacked, or their
- 53:57skin's not the right color, or their religion's not the right religion. And
- 54:01how that through parenting and through education, there
- 54:04is an opportunity to return to that house of wisdom that you talk
- 54:08about. The third thing is those four words that
- 54:12I think America's blessed with is when that person said to you, you are
- 54:16safe now. And that you could now take everything
- 54:19that you this context, this journey that you have,
- 54:23and decide after 911 to say, this is my life's
- 54:26cause. And I think you are in many ways, and I
- 54:30don't wanna I don't wanna sound like I'm exaggerating or fawning over, but in many
- 54:34ways, you're the house of wisdom from the 7th 8th century that you
- 54:38are collecting all of these points of view. I'm working on
- 54:42this project. I'm working on this interfaith project. I'm working. You're you're opening the door
- 54:45to all these points of view, and I hope you're successful more than
- 54:49anything else because I think you're the first path
- 54:53forward that I feel optimistic that there's still hope for this, this
- 54:56crazy thing we call ourselves as humans. Thank you so much for being so
- 55:00generous and so kind. I think that I did not survive
- 55:04genocide to serve my
- 55:07myself, but really to serve humankind in whatever capacity
- 55:11I can. I think every person that we can reach and touch, touch, and you
- 55:15do that, Tony and I thank you for doing that,
- 55:19is critically important because we all have a role to play. Being nice
- 55:22to someone in a supermarket and asking them how
- 55:26they're they or smiling at them, even
- 55:29if we don't know where they come from and who they are can make
- 55:33a difference in a person's life. So I hope that our
- 55:37conversation can inspire people to be the best version of themselves.
- 55:41Chatter that matters has been a presentation of RBC. It's
- 55:44Tony Chapman. Thanks for listening. Let's chat soon.