Latest / Houselights: A Film Director Podcast / Stargate (1994) - Roland Emmerich | Houselights #187
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the NED Party. Welcome back to House Lights, our director discussion
- 0:23show here on the nerd Party Network. We are speeding through the house of
- 0:27Emeriic as we cover all of his directed works of the nineteen nineties. After
- 0:32our trip to Gaza, we've uncovered his nineteen ninety four film Stargate. I'm
- 0:38Colonel Darren Moser. That's with two rs, and I'm joined again by my
- 0:42friend a new bus guard, John six Pack Mills and Abbados Beast Tamer Tristan
- 0:48Riddell. We've discovered the seventh symbol, so it's time to dial up the
- 0:53Stargate. Excellent, excellent, excellent. First off, are you happy with
- 0:57your assignments? Yes? I am, well there, well done. This
- 1:00is hard to take this, not personally, after the couple of times that
- 1:06you've hosted, like he gets six pack, Yeah, and I'm the beast
- 1:10Tamer who clearly is horrible at his job since the beast ran away that the
- 1:15plot. Furthering the plot, the six pack is not a reference to my
- 1:19abs. It's about what I drink on average during one of these podcasts.
- 1:25So I do I do have to admit that, like I mean, I
- 1:27always knew that these guys had amazing stomachs. But watching it this time,
- 1:32I'm like, good lord, these people were fit. Like, hey,
- 1:37well, you can't look at their face. What do you look at right
- 1:40there? That's right. Even if those helmets were a little top heavy.
- 1:47Yeah, you know, I'm sure they did. I'm sure they never ran
- 1:49into a piece of set dressing or or tumbled down. So there's lots of
- 1:53ramps, very few stairs in the very Yeah, it's it's nice to know
- 1:57that aliens invading Earth through the pyramids where eighty a compliant and they avoided steps
- 2:04where possible. Well, stargate man, this is a nineteen ninety four film.
- 2:09Really interesting watching this after watching a Universal Soldier as it is almost night
- 2:17and day. As far as plot, character development, music, it's gonna
- 2:23be a really fun discussion. I say we start with music. We often
- 2:28don't, but boy howdy, David Arnold is like, this is one of
- 2:36the best soundtracks of the nineties, Like, really, it is so fun
- 2:42it I mean, they mentioned it when they were in production that after placing
- 2:46it in the movie that it really elevated the entire thing up a notch.
- 2:53And I have to agree, Like, action wise, you get a lot
- 2:55of great stuff, but when you throw those, you know, the trumpets
- 3:00and the and the marches and all of that behind it, you just you
- 3:05want to stand up and cheer. It is such a fun score. What
- 3:07are your thoughts on that, Tristan? I I completely agree with you.
- 3:12This one was. I mean, in the previous works that we've had with
- 3:15Emerick, it just there's nothing memorable about it, completely unmemorable. But with
- 3:22this one, it was immediately memorable and it almost it almost felt the way
- 3:25that they opened it, it almost felt like one of those old biblical epics
- 3:31where you really focused on what you were listening to. Like you felt like
- 3:36it was like either one of those old musicals where you hear the medleys or
- 3:40like like like I said, like with ben her ten Commandments where you have
- 3:44that you know that the opening with with just the words and just the music,
- 3:47and uh, it was. I love the reveal too, because it
- 3:52kind of made me think of of eighty nine Batman with uh yeah, you
- 3:58know, with the bad symbol where the camera's going through the curves and you
- 4:00have no idea what you're looking at and then all of a sudden it it
- 4:03tracks back and you're like, oh my god, it was the bad symbol
- 4:06of the whole time. And and this one, you know we see the
- 4:11you know we see the masking raw. Yeah yeah, and so but yeah,
- 4:15I just I love the trumpets are of course amazing, Like it's it's
- 4:17a theme that you can grab onto with both hands where you know exactly like
- 4:23they use it all the time and you don't get annoyed with it. It's
- 4:26kind of like the James Bond theme where like you know, like you hear
- 4:28it and it's used a couple of times, but you really love it.
- 4:30But I also really love Ro's theme. Yeah. I think that's what gets
- 4:33stuck in my head, like string. Yeah. Yeah, it's just like
- 4:38it goes down and down and gets more and more menacing as it goes like
- 4:42hmm, oh that's true. They could do it slower and it's a little
- 4:46menacing and yeah, it's love it so so good. And David Arnold was
- 4:54I think he was working in a used record shop when they came to him
- 4:59and said, hey, you wanted to stargate because I can't remember how they
- 5:02found him, but like I think like he did a few short films before
- 5:06that, and they were really worried, Like Devlin and Emeric were both really
- 5:13worried. They're like, I don't know if this guy can do it,
- 5:14but let's give him a shot. And then like the first thing that they
- 5:16heard from him was like, damn, yes, he's had like a crazy
- 5:19career. He kept working with Emeric for a few more movies, and then
- 5:21he went on to do like five Bond films and some crazy scores. Yeah,
- 5:27I think he's second only to John Barry in terms of number of Bond
- 5:30scores. I could be wrong about that, but I'm pretty sure. I
- 5:32think John Barry's going to be like the number one all time ranking champ,
- 5:36you know, in perpetuity. But I think Arnold's second spot for that either
- 5:41way, you know. All that to say kicks off a heck of a
- 5:44career. Do I think it's an incredible score? I do not. I
- 5:47think it's a very good score, and I think that it I think that
- 5:53the movie would be lesser without it. So but do I ask John That's
- 5:58all we asked, you know. I mean, you know, okay,
- 6:00I'll be the stick in the mud, but this is a score where it's
- 6:04like it does exactly what it needs to do, which is it imbues some
- 6:11sense of epic scale that like it layers on a voice to it that sometimes
- 6:16the film doesn't earn on its own, where I think you could easily make
- 6:19the argument that if you took the music out and it was something a little
- 6:24lesser or not as well matched, then this movie does not get a positive
- 6:29reception like it. You know, obviously they learned their lesson from the two
- 6:33movies we watched before, where it was like, you know, music it's
- 6:38important in film, and so I think it definitely hits there in terms of
- 6:42the opening trists. And I like you you referenced the eighty nine Batman because
- 6:46it is a very similar sort of thing. And that'll get to some of
- 6:49the things that on this rewatch. I sort of like observed about Emeric's style
- 6:56and I suddenly sort of like unlocked something in my brain out Devlin and Emeric
- 7:00in the nineties and sort of what they what they predicted, not you know,
- 7:05not predicted, but what they were pointing toward for the future of film.
- 7:11I mean, one last thing with the music is I just had the
- 7:15memory of this score, specifically like the main track as well as Robin Hood
- 7:21Prince of Thieves were like the go to trailer scores for like the little teasers
- 7:29that you would get where they were just kind of like introducing you to the
- 7:31movie. And they didn't use you know, because they didn't have anything for
- 7:35the movie yet. Like those two were used over and over and over,
- 7:41like if you wanted that kind of a vibe in your trailer. Yeah,
- 7:45they did use them a lot, that's true. That's true with the voiceover
- 7:48guy in a West. Yeah, oh man, trailers were something special back
- 7:54then, weren't they When they when they found a track that worked. When
- 7:57you had to wait ten twenty thirty minute to download that trailer of AOL,
- 8:03then you were a captive audience for sure. Yes, yeah, very much.
- 8:09So yeah. So again, a great score that I think we all
- 8:13agree elevates the picture. Whether it's the best score ever to grace the screen,
- 8:20you know, who are we to judge? But I mean also it
- 8:24was such a well done score that it was used heavily in the later show,
- 8:28which we'll get to a little later. But for the Stargate SG one
- 8:33franchise, a lot of the main themes everything, This is the root of
- 8:39all the score that came from it, which is a bit of transition when
- 8:43you're going to television music where you're composing a lot of music for you know,
- 8:50a specific show, but often again reusing these main themes, ros theme,
- 8:54you know, the bombasticness of it. But yeah, so we start
- 9:00off it's not quite up sad, but this movie definitely starts on a bit
- 9:07of a downer note as we have Jack O'Neill with one l he's his kid
- 9:15has shot himself relatively soon, and it just is a really interesting way to
- 9:22start this event. I mean, this is an adventure movie for sure,
- 9:24we're going far beyond our planet, but bringing it back to emeric for a
- 9:31second. I think one of the best things that he's improved on in this
- 9:35movie is characters. The two main characters, Jackson and O'Neill. And this
- 9:41is again starting O'Neill and starting how where's this character gonna go? How is
- 9:46he gonna grow? How's it going to change? John? What did you
- 9:48think of just not just the introduction, but he goes from long hair to
- 9:54short hair? Who is this guy? Should we care? Is he just
- 9:58another you know? Is he the ununiversal soldier? I it is impossible for
- 10:05me to dislike Kurt Russell in any role. It's it's actually like physiologically impossible.
- 10:11It would be like watching me in you know, uh that movie It's
- 10:18a Running Man with Arnold Schwarzenegger, where like they have the collars that blow
- 10:22their heads off if they if they do something bad. I'm like, if
- 10:26I try to dislike a Kurt Russell performance, I my head will explode.
- 10:30Timpos Man, where you're trying to write out Kurt Russell is can't you can't
- 10:37buy it. So it's hard for me to be completely honest. But with
- 10:43that character in specific, I think that they overcompensate a little with the character's
- 10:50motivation slash psychological state, where I don't know how necessary that bit of backstory
- 10:58really is. Like I think that it works fine if he shows up as
- 11:03a hard ass and then like you find out he has a heart of gold
- 11:07anyway sort of thing, Like the scene of them going and getting him from
- 11:11his house. Is it just it's over much to me. It's a bit
- 11:16far rebuttal please. I think that they needed something more than duty and honor
- 11:26and pledging oneself to one's country in order to be willing to go to another
- 11:31galaxy. And sacrifice yourself in order to destroy the Gate. I feel like
- 11:35there needed to be some sort of personal trauma or some sort of character issue
- 11:41that gave him a little bit more push to leave things behind. I'll just
- 11:46have to agree to disagree, because I think that I think that it works
- 11:50perfectly fine. And we're very familiar with the trope of the military guy who's
- 11:54so dedicated to the mission he doesn't care what happens to him, and then
- 12:00in the course of the movie finding out that he does care whether he lives
- 12:03or dies. And I think that there is basically his arc works without that
- 12:09scene where we meet him when he's in his late son's bedroom. I really
- 12:15I think it works without it just as well. But you know, we'll
- 12:18just be on opposite sides of that one. I don't know why it rankled
- 12:22me. I like, what's odd is with this rewatch? And I saw
- 12:26Stargate more than once in the nineties. I'd completely forgotten that bit about his
- 12:31character. So I would argue that if it were really truly memorably necessary,
- 12:37I wouldn't have forgotten that that was a piece of his character, if that
- 12:41makes sense. I mean, it does drive a lot of aspects, not
- 12:46only the self sacrifice motif, but let's you know, pitch over to the
- 12:52side character of Skara played by Alexis Cruz. So this the pseudo sun you
- 12:58know. Again, there's moments where where Scar picks up a gun and he,
- 13:01you know, O'Neill freaks out. So you do have this weaving story
- 13:07that's I think fairly well told, a bit a bit heavy handed in the
- 13:11beginning, like you said, John, like it's they're making it very clear,
- 13:15you know, how he feels about guns and his trauma. It's you
- 13:18know, right out there on display. But seeing him eventually soften, eventually
- 13:26pull to be to being with Scar and Scarra was played so well the actor
- 13:31actually returned in the show playing the same character. It was one of the
- 13:35few actors that transitioned into SG one. But what did you think about that
- 13:41part of O'Neill's journey Tristan with the kind of like the second son, and
- 13:48you know that's kind of his inlet to bonding with the people of Abidots and
- 13:52kind of becoming the not savior. But he needs you know, we've we've
- 13:58seen that trope before of like well we need to save these people now,
- 14:01you know, and he takes a little convincing to get there. Yeah,
- 14:05I mean it was, it was. It was a little weird to me
- 14:07because you know, like he has this issue towards children and guns and child
- 14:13soldiers, but yet there was nothing at the beginning of the film that really
- 14:16showcased that he had an issue with children and guns, and so I just
- 14:20wish that if we had that at the beginning. I feel like it really
- 14:24would have sold that character arc just a little bit more. But hey,
- 14:28he was the character with long hair. That's what we're forgetting. Oh,
- 14:31the same guy. They buzzed it like a scene later and that was O'Neill
- 14:35with one l Oh, that's what John's complaining about. Okay, Yeah,
- 14:39he's wrong about that one. So so yeah, no, I think that's
- 14:41I think it's you know, I honestly, I'm sorry, I just woke
- 14:48up. What what what what was that detour about? I'm sorry, go
- 14:50on, No, I do I do. I think I think it's a
- 14:52it's a nice it's so heavy handed. It's so heavy handed, but it
- 14:56is like to have that moment later, I I feel like the to him.
- 15:01Okay, so what I will give credit to John is like there was
- 15:07two scenes where where O'Neill is like, get those guns away from the kids.
- 15:13We needed only one of them. That's him, Like like we we
- 15:16had that scene with Scara where he was smoking, you know, that was
- 15:20funny, and then he reaches for the gun and then O'Neill like loses it
- 15:24and we know exactly why he's losing it. And later on when they escape,
- 15:31you know from Raw and all those people, they're back around the campfire
- 15:35and uh Kowaski, which if you're having a military movie, it is cinema
- 15:39law to have a dude named Kawaski. True and uh. And so it
- 15:46was that scene around the fire when he said he's like, get these guns
- 15:48away from these kids, totally unnecessary, Like you could show them have the
- 15:52hesitancy, you know, have them have a conversation with The first scene was
- 15:56better than the second. The first the second scene did not need to be
- 16:00there. It didn't need to be there. I enjoyed the character arc,
- 16:03but it was times there was very heavy handed, heavy handed, and that
- 16:07scene could have been trimmed down or compacted in a much more subtler way,
- 16:12I think without O'Neill freaking out again, I mean, look, it's obvious
- 16:18to me that really what it is is we actually agree it's heavy handed.
- 16:22And I think that probably what I react most strongly to is simply the fact
- 16:29that there is a lot of stuff in here where the structure of things is.
- 16:36There's no art to how it's put together in terms of progression. It's
- 16:41just sort of the feeling of beat beat, beat, as opposed to just
- 16:45a smooth flow of everything. And I think that it's possible that that scene
- 16:52with O'Neill plays better if they find a different way to sort of like have
- 16:56it in or even give it more time to breathe, because the scene where
- 17:00they're talking to his wife right beforehand is very awkward, and you know,
- 17:06so maybe it is just that clunkiness that I respond to with it. But
- 17:10either way, it's one of those things where I can just say it never
- 17:15lands for me. And maybe it's because it's so heavy handed, is like
- 17:18it just there's a lot of stuff such as when when Scara has the friend
- 17:25who's you know, he's he's the kid that has a little trouble with everything,
- 17:29right, He's not you know, he he you know, he needs
- 17:32a little extra help from his friends, he's not as he's the Titalong friend.
- 17:36Yeah, and it's like as soon as he's introduced, Like what feels
- 17:38a lot about this movie is like, Oh, okay, he's he's gonna
- 17:42have to get past his kid and oh that kid's going to be in trouble,
- 17:47and that's where I'm supposed to get my emotion. Like, there's so
- 17:49much about this that feels like it's pulled from other source material and just sort
- 17:55of like crammed together as opposed to flowing in such a way that it's like
- 18:00this is a character story that has to be told. Maybe maybe that's what
- 18:03I'm reacting to more than anything. Well, if O'Neil is the jock,
- 18:10then by far Daniel Jackson is the geek. And I mean from the beginning
- 18:15of him talking about, you know, aliens building the pyramids. We've all
- 18:21seen the History Channel late at night. We know, we know. But
- 18:25James Spader, I think he's been known to say for this movie that it
- 18:30was a paycheck, you know, he wanted to get paid. But I
- 18:33thought he did a great job establishing this character which would eventually be you know,
- 18:40built upon by Michael Shanks. So with with Jackson, though you have.
- 18:48Personally, I feel that they thread the line of he's not a Wonder
- 18:52kid, He's not like, yes, he does make discovery, but it's
- 18:57not likely this man could do it. And you know, it goes to
- 19:03the edge a little bit. But we're gonna look past the plot hole of
- 19:08if you know six numbers in a seven number dialing sequence, you just then
- 19:14dial all the other numbers to get the seventh one. We're gonna ignore that
- 19:18because it's probably the most glaring plot hole of the entire movie. But hey,
- 19:22I have to give it for that sequence of him discovering the seventh symbol.
- 19:29They show him the stargate, they dial it up. Everything's vibrating and
- 19:33shaking like they're making it a big deal, and I get caught up in
- 19:37it. This movie nails Wonder because and it's this guy who two weeks ago
- 19:45was writing on blackboards about aliens and is now opening a door to another world
- 19:51and you you are along for the ride. So so Tristan with Daniel Jackson's
- 19:57character, too many sneezes? Was it a little too dances with wolves or
- 20:03like going native? You know, use of subtitles or some subside titles like
- 20:08all that incup bits, Daniel, Like, how did that character impact you?
- 20:15I think, uh, I think Spider did a fantastic job portraying Jackson.
- 20:18I really do. I think there were they had just enough sneezes,
- 20:22they had, you know, just enough ridiculous moments with him. Like there
- 20:29was like in the in the when he's presenting to to the to Leon rippy
- 20:33himself. Uh, and he's already yeah, he's kind of laughing at himself.
- 20:38He's like he's just like he's like you got two little guys dancing and
- 20:44a little heads coming up and a little little line like that. You know,
- 20:48it's just like like you can tell it's nerves, like he's he's it's
- 20:52a nervous lad. I didn't bring enough copies for everyone, so you have
- 20:55to share. You have to share. Like these generals don't care. They
- 20:59just just give us the fan. But he's like in the middle of his
- 21:02lecture circuit and it's so funny. And I think that's the thing is that
- 21:06like it's not him, James Spader is not playing it as someone who is
- 21:11trying to be funny. And I think that was one like it's one thing
- 21:15that Brian Cranston, I think once said is that like like whenever you played
- 21:21a comedic character, he never played that character like he was trying to be
- 21:26funny. Otherwise that people won't laugh because if that if that character knows that
- 21:32he's trying to get a joke, the joke won't land. And I feel
- 21:36like Spader knew that with Jackson, And I think Jackson does a really great
- 21:41job of walking the line of nerd and imbecile, because that's a common thing
- 21:48in movies, especially in the nineties, where if anybody was nerdy, they
- 21:52were completely socially inept, they would have like they'd have ticks or they'd have
- 21:59you know, you guys have seen it. And I feel like originally they
- 22:03wanted Rick Moranis for Jackson's role, which which I love Rick Moranis, but
- 22:10that would have been a horrible, horrible choice because I feel like they would
- 22:14have asked him to do like his Ghostbuster's character, yes, and and it
- 22:18just like in you know, on Abidots, and that would not have worked.
- 22:22No, it would not have worked whatsoever. And I feel like that's
- 22:26kind of the trope that we that most nerds would get in the eighties and
- 22:30nineties, and I think Spader showed an intellectual who's not the jock but is
- 22:34not an imbecile. And to me, no, I didn't feel like Chances
- 22:40with Wolves, Punkhannas or Avatar or anything like that. No, don't.
- 22:45I don't feel like we went into that like I felt like Spader was.
- 22:48I feel like Jackson was truly trying to learn so that they could go home.
- 22:52It wasn't so much like, oh, you know, like like I'm
- 22:56gonna I'm gonna protect these people, you know, with with all my mights
- 23:00because they've shown me their rich culture culture. It was like, no,
- 23:02like Ro's clearly the bad guy and he's trying to kill us, so let's
- 23:04let's take care of this, you know, like like you know the So
- 23:08that's kind of how I took it. And yeah, I love Spader since
- 23:11his movies in the eighties and nineties and his portrayal as Alan Shore on Boston
- 23:17Legal and the Practice. Uh yeah, this is just another avenue for for
- 23:22for me to love his performance. You gotta go through all those roles.
- 23:25You're not gonna mention Robert California. Come on, come on now, Robert
- 23:29California was cool. In his first scene, and then it's kind of petered
- 23:33out. I don't know. I liked Robert California. Yeah, it couldn't
- 23:37have lasted longer than it did, but I did think it was cute.
- 23:41But Spader, I agree with you. Spader gives some actual like heart to
- 23:48the movie because of the fact that Spader is playing what really a you know,
- 23:53a quote unquote nerd is, which is just somebody who's a bit obsessive
- 23:56about something that they know about, that they really love and they really care
- 24:00about. And so no, we don't have the going native thing because he's
- 24:04just thrilled that his knowledge is applicable. Finally, I'm just so happy to
- 24:08be here. Guys. It's well, it is though, like it's one
- 24:12of those things where like that nothing fills somebody with more joy than you know,
- 24:18Oh I know that. Yeah, okay, I yes, I can
- 24:21do that. Yes, I know what you're talking about here. And I
- 24:23think he he conveys that. What I love about him is at the time
- 24:29this movie came out, the whole idea of the Aliens building the pyramids was
- 24:33such a sort of like an accepted con like out there theory sort of thing,
- 24:42and that theory has grown over time, so it feels so much more.
- 24:47It feels like it's such a simpler time that this movie comes out of
- 24:49where it's like the pyramids were landing beds for ancient aliens, and it's like,
- 24:55ah, that feels right. The thing though, that I come at
- 24:59it from, you know, perspective of who I am today, is I
- 25:03find it puzzling that Raw goes to a desert on another planet, because it's
- 25:10like, wouldn't you go somewhere where there's I don't know, resources and food
- 25:15right, Like, well, you know, the mineral is the resource.
- 25:18He's there, I I guess, But it's one of those things where it's
- 25:22like, wouldn't it have been nice to have it be a different location instead
- 25:26of having it be so obviously it's like, all right, well we're just
- 25:30pyramids can only be in the desert. It's like, ah, well there
- 25:33were pyramids and tropical locales too, you know Zigaraz, but they were there
- 25:37or I mean, he he needed people who could acclimate to that climate and
- 25:41knew how to survive in that climate, and so you know, he took
- 25:45people from the desert and located them to a desert because they know that he
- 25:48knew that they would survive. Okay, sure, I think no, no,
- 25:52no, no, don't dismiss that. That's a really good explanation.
- 25:56Not only did I dismiss it, like it's in the room behind me,
- 26:00I don't even know where I live, it's buried under something back there.
- 26:03That's that's how hard. I just dismissed that because it's more visually interesting.
- 26:07It's more I think it's a more interesting movie if it's like, oh look,
- 26:11and also here, like it's the same sort of thing, this idea
- 26:15of like this this powerful space faring culture going around and sort of like imprinting
- 26:21itself on all of these different planets. I just I think it would have
- 26:23been more interesting to have it be in a different sort of area, because
- 26:27the thing is, okay, you're talking about all he takes these people and
- 26:30moves them around. It's like, well, okay, I know Raw went
- 26:33into a human being in order to live forever, So like, are his
- 26:37henchmen also aliens who implanted their consciousness into humans that then live forever as well?
- 26:45Or were these just guards that were just picked out of you know,
- 26:48etcetera, etcetera, etcetera. It's not really clear, and it's it's the
- 26:52don't blowing eyes. Oh that's true. That's true. They also emote a
- 26:56little bit more than raw does. But hey, you know that's just me.
- 27:00Well I think, yeah, I see what you're saying, John about
- 27:03the location. I think for what they did go with in the desert,
- 27:07it pays off because you have that obviously, it's there to have that moment
- 27:11where you've gone through the stargate, you don't know where you are, you
- 27:15walk out and he turns around and there's a pyramid and that is in one
- 27:19shot, validating his entire theory. And you got the triple moon and it's
- 27:26like, oh my gosh, like, well, I'm on another planet and
- 27:29it was I mean, he says it. He's like, I was right,
- 27:30you know, I knew it. Yeah, I freaking love alien sky
- 27:40I do. I absolutely love alien skies. Like when we have we see
- 27:44like a purple planet real close, so we see multiple moons or two suns,
- 27:48everything shot with a giant red filter. Like I am a sucker for
- 27:52that. When I'm like, oh my god, it's different than ours.
- 27:55Guy, Like that's that's totally me. When I'm watching a movie, there's
- 27:57three moons that are exactly the same as our Earth moon, but there's three
- 28:00of them, are you That's what I wanted, That's what I wanted to
- 28:03talk about. I was like, really, this is a this is a
- 28:06You had fifty million dollars to make this movie. You earned two hundred million
- 28:11dollars, and you're telling me you couldn't have spent five minutes just looking making
- 28:17a different looking moon the Titanic sky, right then, I don't want to
- 28:21hear no, yeah, no, you're totally right. And it's like it's
- 28:25very obviously Earth's moon three times at slightly different sizes over the pyramid. But
- 28:30hey, uh Ra's not a miracle worker. He just does what he can.
- 28:33But uh yeah, so we were moving through the story again. This
- 28:41movie will lay the groundwork for a lot of my favorite elements in the SG
- 28:47one show, where you're looking into mythology, like it's kind of running along
- 28:52with the theory of everything we thought was myth is actually aliens, which is
- 28:56a little bit of a pill to swallow. But but you were mentioning,
- 29:02you know, the budget, Tristan and the special effects and your hate of
- 29:04moons. But let's talk about the Horus and Anubis guards and that awesome very
- 29:12early nineties morph effect of the helmet rolling back, which is I mean it's
- 29:19iron Man wishes it was that cool. You know, it's an important step
- 29:26between it is Batmobiles shields in nineteen eighty nine and ninety two much and iron
- 29:33Man, like this is a bridge. This is a step that we're coming
- 29:37across here where we can see where the technology is pointing. And I think
- 29:41it's really neat. It is really neat. I remember thinking it was really
- 29:45neat when I first saw it, and I think that the like the visual
- 29:49those types of visual flare are sort of what keeps the movie interesting at parts
- 29:56where it lags because it's like, oh that's neat. Oh cool, I
- 29:59like that, and you can sort of then go through and say, oh,
- 30:03okay, we were just misinterpreting what they were saying when we saw these
- 30:07paintings. It wasn't that they were talking about these gods that came down there
- 30:12talking about these were the guards that like, you know, blew up things
- 30:17when when Raw got mad and stuff like goes okay, I get it,
- 30:19I gotcha. It's theatric theatrical and showmanship from a dictator to instill fear in
- 30:29the masses. And and I mean the animatronic heads are awesome, like the
- 30:33bird looks around, the flexing of the crest. Uh and yeah, yeah,
- 30:40it's not just like a helmet. They just plopped on their head like
- 30:42it. It actually does movie money, not show money, because it gets
- 30:48a little simpler in the show. But I imagine so. But I when
- 30:53I was a kid, I absolutely loved that, like the idea that it
- 30:59just kind of went over way into some smaller piece of technology, Like I
- 31:03every bit of that and distinguishable from magic as it were. Yeah, I
- 31:08remember I had the toys when I was a kid, like when this movie
- 31:11came out, Like I had the ship, the the the glider, the
- 31:17glider, yeah, the fighter. Yeah, that that that flew around,
- 31:18I had that. I loved it. The attack croissant, you're not you're
- 31:23not wrong. Uh yeah. But that that morph technique was so cool because
- 31:29they would basically shoot the actor twice. They would shoot him doing the motion
- 31:33because it was also moving. It wasn't like they were static. They were
- 31:37turning, which it's like, hey, let's double down guys and make it
- 31:40really hard. But they would shoot them without the helmet and then they would
- 31:42shoot them with the helmet and then they would literally computer animate morph like oh
- 31:48well this part should kind of go here, and it's just this crude kind
- 31:52of like projection mapping that's reverse animated away. Uh, but it sold it.
- 32:00You know. We were all like, I've never seen anything like that
- 32:04before, and it, like you said, John, it kind of you
- 32:07know, picked it up a notch for a second, like okay, okay,
- 32:08that's that's really interesting. I mean, as long as we're talking about
- 32:13it, I thought that, uh, Jimon Hansu, who in the movie
- 32:16is just credited as Gemon, he didn't have his last the credits, like
- 32:22I either forgot or never realized it was him, And like when they revealed
- 32:27him, I was like, oh wow, my gosh, this is early
- 32:30on, but like like this is pre Amistad. Oh yeah, this is
- 32:36was a three years before Amistad. Yeah. Yeah. Emeric likes to take
- 32:40credit even though Jimon has been in a few things before this. Emeric likes
- 32:45to take credit of discovered just well, you know, I mean it was
- 32:51Stargate, you know, I mean, this is the thing right as we're
- 32:55talking about the effects and everything, and like you know, and then Jimon
- 32:59Hansu is in there. I'm curious because we've talked about the main characters and
- 33:04everything, Like, I think we all agreed that one of the strengths in
- 33:07Universal Soldier was obviously Emeric is a director able to convey to the supporting cast
- 33:15who they're supposed to be and how they're supposed to behave. And I will
- 33:19go out on a limb here that Spader is is doing a good job.
- 33:22He's but it's it feels a little effortless for him. And I'm not saying
- 33:27that in a negative way. I'm saying like, this is this is not
- 33:30James Spader showing up in campaigning for an oscar. This is James Spader showing
- 33:34up and having a good time. That's a good thing, okay. And
- 33:37Kurt Russell is showing up and just again, Kurt Russell just walks on screen.
- 33:43It's like, okay, hey, what's up, bro. But I
- 33:45think that this is another supporting cast where like Emeric really kind of shines in
- 33:51getting good performances from his supporting cast. I mean, even I would argue
- 33:55that this is one of French Stewart's best on screen performances you're not wrong,
- 34:00You're not wrong. I mean the bar is not high on that, not
- 34:06terribly high, but it's still notable. But you know, there are actually
- 34:09a couple of things. And I will even you know, I'll even say
- 34:14the actress his name is Milli Avatol, like, yeah, she does a
- 34:19good job, like she's really she's. And the thing is, that's not
- 34:23it's easy for that to be a thankless, phoned in role. But obviously
- 34:29the director was able. Emeric is able to convey to her, here's who
- 34:32I need you to be on screen, and she delivers. And I think
- 34:36Emeric deserves whatever anybody thinks of any of his movies on the whole, I
- 34:42think this is going to be a consistent theme and all the stuff we look
- 34:44at, he gets really good supporting performances from his actors. I think this
- 34:50is another one in that in that line proves it. No, I think
- 34:52you're absolutely right, John. I mean we were chatting beforehand about, you
- 34:57know, Richard kind this tiny, you know, thankless role of like the
- 35:01guy to first translate it, who gets schooled by Jackson, and it's hilarious.
- 35:07It's like just enough that like, okay, this world feels real that
- 35:10there to be a guy and he's already done it and he did it wrong.
- 35:15But you have, you know, like Catherine, you know, who
- 35:17has to portray again that sense of wonder of my father found this and and
- 35:23I'm kind of in charge, but then the military is kind of taking over
- 35:27very cliche kind of role, but she handles it well. I want to
- 35:32talk about, though, is Eric Avari, who is the leader, the
- 35:37tribal leader, probably the largest, like the mainest character of the sub characters.
- 35:44I would always say, at least for abidots. And I mean he
- 35:47talks in you know, native language the entire time. He does a lot
- 35:52of communication with just his face and mannerisms. Yeah, body always remember that.
- 36:00But uh, there's there's been a few times I've had a chocolate bar
- 36:05that's been really good, like Bunny Way. That's what you got to say.
- 36:09It's what you have to say. Uh. But no, Eric Ivari,
- 36:15he he's he's one of those talents that elevates everything he's in, like
- 36:21great character actor. Yeah, whenever he's in something, he makes it better
- 36:24than if he wasn't in it. He's you know, like he's been in
- 36:30so many things, Like I mean, he's lately, he's he plays Nicodemus
- 36:32in The Chosen, I love him in The Mummy with uh with Fraser and
- 36:37and and Weiss and or vice excuse me? And yeah, he's all over
- 36:43the place and just really elevates everything. I think he's great. Uh well,
- 36:47yeah, I mean he's so expressive, like Darren saying is like he
- 36:51he is an actor who was always meant to be on camera because his expressions
- 36:58play so well on set, and he like he knows basically he knows how
- 37:05to play an expression without a coming across as mugging for the camera. But
- 37:08even though he does these very big reactions, it doesn't feel like that sort
- 37:13of old school vaudevillian break the fourth wall, like can you believe? I
- 37:16had a candy bar? But it's that vibe without being out of the moment.
- 37:22It feels authentic to the character he's playing. And that's so important because
- 37:28again it's a it's a native character that does not speak English. He has
- 37:31to convey and he conveys, you know, hey, everybody, we should
- 37:37be afraid, and hey everybody, we should attack, and you know,
- 37:42why did we do what we did? And like he conveys all of that
- 37:46so let's let's shift a little bit to the use of subtitles and not use
- 37:52of subtitles, because I think that is also a strength of this movie,
- 37:55where there's a lot of times where you don't get any subtitles. You could
- 38:00get it from the very first moment, but you don't, and as Daniel
- 38:04is learning the language, eventually you get you get it in key moments when
- 38:08you need it. But I like the fact that at the beginning of the
- 38:12movie, or the beginning of being on Abbidots, you're just just as just
- 38:16as they are. As far as who are these people, what are they?
- 38:20What's going on? There's no universal translator. Not everybody speaks English.
- 38:24Again, we'll change that for the show, but I mean it's a show.
- 38:29But so not only that. With the Abodozians, I don't know if
- 38:32they have a name, but for those of you at home who have no
- 38:36idea what Abodots is from just watching the movie, it's the name of the
- 38:39planet. Name of the planet. Should have said that, yes, I
- 38:45just assumed, But I will say that the what ended up being the best
- 38:50use of subtitles is for raw because apparently when yeah, let's talk about that,
- 38:57Yeah, when he did raw. He did not feel he did a
- 39:00very good performance, and he did not know actually that they were going to
- 39:04dub and pitch shift and redo and subtitle his performance. And after he saw
- 39:10the film, he went to UH To America and said, like, you
- 39:15saved it. You saved my role, like because what I gave was was
- 39:20not what was delivered in in that change. But yeah, what did what
- 39:24did you think Tristan of the use of I mean, it's a it's a
- 39:28clever tech technique we've seen before of exposition through subtitle. When you realize,
- 39:34oh, we need to explain what his motivation is. It's not there and
- 39:38we never said it, so here it is in the subtitles. How did
- 39:43that come together? Yeah? I think it was h I would have.
- 39:45I feel like watching it this time, I feel like they modulated his voice
- 39:52a bit too much. Okay. I was like, I was like,
- 39:57let's tone it down because it's it's distracting. We're like an alien. But
- 40:04like when when Sara or Shari or Kassouf, you know, when they speak
- 40:08the language, you can understand what certain words are, what certain syllables are.
- 40:15But they affected Ro's voice so much. It was just it was very
- 40:21nutty, It really was, and so it was it was really hard,
- 40:25like he definitely gave him a presence. It was clearly a presence. And
- 40:30I really like Jay Davidson's performance. And I'll talk more about that, but
- 40:35I it was the one of the reasons, like you said, one of
- 40:37the reasons was is like during a during a test screening, people hated the
- 40:44movie because they were absolutely confused. They had no idea what was going on.
- 40:47They had no idea what Ro's motivations were, nothing like that, and
- 40:52so they had to throw in more exposition. And one of the ways they
- 40:55did that was through modulating Jay David's voice and then putting in stuff that he
- 41:01didn't actually say. And it's it saved the picture. It saved the movie.
- 41:05And so for that, I applaud them for doing it. Uh So,
- 41:08yeah, I liked I liked it when we when we got subtitles and
- 41:12when we didn't get subtitles, because it's it's it's it was of a perfect
- 41:15separation of what we needed to know, what we needed to guess, and
- 41:21what we absolutely just needed to be blind to. And I love Jay Davidson
- 41:29is raw. I love everything that he does. I think he's phenomenal in
- 41:34this. When I was a kid, I I when I when I was
- 41:38because he's done two movies he did. I tried to remember what else he
- 41:43did. He did Crime Game, which got him, uh a supporting actor
- 41:47nomination in the Oscars, which is insane. That was his first movie and
- 41:52he got an actor and he got an Oscar nomination, and and then uh
- 41:57they American and Devlin came to and said that they wanted him for this one
- 42:00because he's fresh off, fresh off of that Oscar nom and he's like,
- 42:04okay, I want a million dollars and they're like, yeah, sure,
- 42:06and he's like, oh wait, really okay. And I didn't want to
- 42:10do it, so I put out a big number and you said yes,
- 42:14and now I gotta do it. Yeah, and and and and he quit
- 42:19acting pretty much after after this movie because he said that he hated the attention.
- 42:23But when I was a kid and I watched this, I was so
- 42:27fascinated by his performance. I swore that Jay Davidson was a woman. I
- 42:32absolutely thought. I fought my parents tooth and nail. I was like,
- 42:37no, Raw is far too pretty. Raw is a woman. And they're
- 42:42like Tristan. No, his name is Jay Davidson. He's in my liner,
- 42:47but like he's we see him at the beginning of the movie. He
- 42:52is shirtless. He is clearly a man. I'm like, no, he's
- 43:00too pretty. No, I had very confusing feelings at eight years old.
- 43:06But yeah, So I love Raw, and I love the presence and the
- 43:08glowing eyes and the I love when he snatches off the necklace from Jackson's even
- 43:14though it's not the eye of Raw, it's the eye of Horace because it's
- 43:16pointing the wrong way. But yes, I love all that. The thing
- 43:22is, I feel like I'm gonna get kicked off of house lights pretty soon,
- 43:25because especially this time. I mean even when I first watched it,
- 43:30Raw was always the weakest part of the film for me ough and he remains
- 43:35the weakest part of the film for me. I get absolutely no sense of
- 43:38menace from Raw. I have absolutely no fear of Raw. I think that
- 43:45the movie with the overmodulation, even if it's not intentional, the overall sense
- 43:52is that they're trying to Darth Vader up his voice, and it doesn't.
- 43:58It's it's one but but it's one of those things where I'd never got any
- 44:01sense of power or menace from Raw that made me fear him, and I
- 44:07didn't. I just think that it's one of those things where it's like some
- 44:13other things in the film, where the concept is right. This is the
- 44:16right concept, it's just the execution falls flat. From my perspective. I
- 44:22heard you say that you'd be so dead John, and he'd just take the
- 44:25little glowy hand thing and like scramble your right there. As long as you
- 44:30as long as you sat there and didn't move, you'd be in trouble.
- 44:36That would be That would be a very difficult forty five seconds. I have
- 44:38trouble sitting still, so that would be very, very tough. But I
- 44:44this really is one of those things, as much as I hate to say,
- 44:46it's like this, this very much, especially with its success, I
- 44:52think is one of those things where it winds up in a way pointing Hollywood
- 44:57in a direction that just snow balls as time moves forward, of the idea
- 45:04of instead of creating something that is completely fresh and new, grab some stuff
- 45:13off the shelf that you've seen before and put it together like a jigsaw puzzle.
- 45:16And as long as the concept is there and there's you know that,
- 45:20and the effects aren't like Star Trek five, you know what, You're gonna
- 45:23make some money on this, and the birth of a formula as basically,
- 45:29I mean, Hollywood's always followed formulas. Sequels have always been there, regurgitation
- 45:34has always been there, remakes have always been there, And at the minimum,
- 45:37American Devlin deserve credit for just going whole hog and embracing what was at
- 45:44the time considered just an absolutely crazy, insane idea that the Aliens built the
- 45:47pyramids. That's just stuck with it and been around forever. I think it
- 45:53was. It was probably like Chariots of the Gods, like Eric Voan Danakin's
- 45:58book is probably the one thing really pularized it, but that was like late
- 46:00seventies, early eighties or something like that. But like, it just embraces
- 46:05it, like most movies would dance around it and be like, oh,
- 46:07it's kind of a crazy idea, and they're like, Nope, this is
- 46:09the concept. And I'm like, they deserve credit for that, right,
- 46:13they pinned it to that, But I think at the expense of a couple
- 46:16of other things, and I think that they did not cast their villain well,
- 46:22I just never got a sense of not just menace. But I never
- 46:25got a sense of did you hear the strings John when he walked out of
- 46:30the room day? But that's why. But that's why I give credit to
- 46:32Arnold of saying like, yeah, he completed his mission, because if you
- 46:37took his score out, oh, I agree, whoa a complete dud.
- 46:42And it's like I would like to think that it can work without you just
- 46:47as well without it, but like I just it's just something where there's just
- 46:52something where the magic is missing and a great villain is necessary for this to
- 46:59really really work as well as it should, and I just don't have that
- 47:01great villain here. I want to chime in, please by all means and
- 47:09say I feel like John, I can say this is respectfully as possible.
- 47:16Please by all means, no personal attacks dress if you got your head out
- 47:22of your app No, I'm just kidding. Uh oh no see I was
- 47:25finally interested in what you had to say, but you got That's why I
- 47:29go ahead, go ahead, go ahead, No, okay, okay,
- 47:31Like I'm getting this, and tell me if I'm wrong. I'm getting this
- 47:34underlying sense from you, like with with referencing, you know, Darth Vader
- 47:39and great villains and showing menace and things like that. Is I feel like,
- 47:45especially in Western cinema, that a lot of the times when we have
- 47:51huge menacing great villains, they have to be physically imposing, nop and not.
- 47:57They have to be the ones that like can snap the dude neck with
- 48:00his telekinesis or his muscles and everything like that. Am I getting that sense
- 48:07from you? No, not at all. You're actually dead wrong. I
- 48:10think that an actor of any build could have portrayed the raw that I'm envisioning
- 48:15in my head. I honestly think that some of the body language and movement
- 48:21of Jay Davidson just doesn't sell it as somebody who feels confident that they have
- 48:25power, that they have that within themselves to throw somebody around with their mind
- 48:31and stuff like that. It feels more like an actor who is moving his
- 48:35arms because my arm has to go this way because the effect is going to
- 48:37go that way, and I put my hand over here. Because of this,
- 48:40I get more of a sense of indication rather than acting, and so
- 48:45that it doesn't have anything to do with his body type or anything like that.
- 48:50Has everything to do though, with how he moves but yes, we
- 48:54talked about the moneiness with the sound and the overmodulation, and the sense to
- 48:59my ear is that they were like, yeah, yeah, we're gonna make
- 49:01it sound like Darth Vader, and that's what's gonna be scary. And it's
- 49:05like, you know, Vader has an imposing sound, but with it it's
- 49:08not just that they had a bodybuilder in that soup, but they had a
- 49:12bodybuilder who they either told or knew instinctively how to move in such a way
- 49:17as somebody that was confident that they had this mystical power that nobody else could
- 49:22unlock, this sureness of presence. And that's just that's one of the key
- 49:28things missing from Davidson's performance. And I think also facially, I don't get
- 49:34like the glowing eyes seem to be trying to do a lot of heavy lifting
- 49:37for a lack of expression in certain scenes is what I'm saying. I've felt
- 49:44with Raw the way the character kind of comes across is yeah, he's a
- 49:52villain, but he's really defeated by his hubrists, like he almost cannot believe
- 49:58that anyone would ever try to fight back, Like my technology and my forces
- 50:04are so much you know, superior to this slave group. That. Yeah,
- 50:09so he so his kind of malice is, Hey, everything is status
- 50:15quo. I'm the top dog. I'm here on top of my pyramid.
- 50:19I can do what I want, you know. So he never he never
- 50:23has a moment where he really has to flex. And I see what you're
- 50:29saying, John, And yeah, that would have brought more menace to him.
- 50:32They just never took the character that direction. No, I mean,
- 50:36then, you know, I then blame on all sides, I guess,
- 50:40But it's you know, I think that that is one of the magical things
- 50:44that's missing from the film. So and that's just where I land with its
- 50:50film of magic. Yeah, all right, well, as we say it,
- 50:54here, we're we're circling the third chevron. No wait, that's and
- 51:00again we're looking past the one point nine billion possible combinations of a dialing sequence.
- 51:06But no, let's do our favorite guest star star of the movies,
- 51:13Lance Reddick. Where are we placing him? Not a ton of roles,
- 51:17it's actually relatively small cast. But like we've said, a lot of great
- 51:22supporting characters. Are they worthy of being usurped by Lance Tristan? Let's start
- 51:29with you where did you place Lance? I wanted to put him on the
- 51:34planet with everybody else that we could get more screen time with him, but
- 51:38I was kind of struggling on who he would be in that, so I
- 51:45kind of went with my first choice, which was we'd only get one scene.
- 51:51But I feel like it'd be a great scene. And even though I
- 51:52like Leon Rippy, I feel like he would make a great General West,
- 51:57Like he'd be a great no nonsense general, throws down the law, throws
- 52:01down the history, throws down the rules, totally impatient and like doesn't want
- 52:07to be there. I feel like I feel like Reddick would probably give a
- 52:13little bit more sarcasm and humor into the scene than Rippy did his West.
- 52:19And so that's my answer. I'm just picturing Daniel like passing out the rolled
- 52:22up part paper and Wes is just sitting there like Lance is just like what
- 52:28are you? What are you doing? Son? Just come on, because
- 52:30keep keep going, keep going? All rightly? All right? So we
- 52:32have a General West John, are you placing him on Abbido's the planet or
- 52:38are you placing him before we go through the stargate. Well, one of
- 52:44my instincts was actually impossible I could not place him as Colonel O'Neill because that
- 52:50would require replacing Kurt Russell, and that it's actually that's forbidden within the the
- 52:54John Mill's Code of Conduct. You know, like if Lance Reddick was Jack
- 53:00O'Neill, that son would still be alive because because throughout this entire practice good
- 53:09gun safety. He would have practiced good, good gun safety. Because throughout
- 53:14this movie, every single trained military officer who handled a gun handled it like
- 53:21a rank amateur. I have never seen such worse trigger discipline or from the
- 53:29truth from an entire movie, and especially Kurt Russell's character. And Kurt Russell
- 53:34has done so many military roles. He pointed that gun at everybody and everything
- 53:38while his finger was on the trigger. Very true. Also, whoever put
- 53:44the you know, the sound mixed together, they sure loved the sound of
- 53:49chambering around because every time somebody ran it a corner, it was like,
- 53:52chick, chick. I was like, you already, you already, you
- 53:57don't want to do that again. Don't do that Because I chambered every round
- 54:00because I went around It's like they're just ejecting shells as they go, and
- 54:04I'm like, God, you didn't even fire the gun. Yet what it
- 54:06was like he's doing the gun was even off screen. I noticed that they
- 54:09did that like it was off screen. His hands weren't even moving, and
- 54:12you heard it. Yeah, it drove me nuts. Me so glad that
- 54:15you noticed it too. It was such a huge destruction to me too,
- 54:20absolutely drove me up the wall. But since I cannot, per my own
- 54:24personal guidelines replace Colonel O'Neill, I'm swinging for the fences and I'm making Lance
- 54:30Radick Raw because I think that I'd at least get a performance out of that,
- 54:35and that is that is who I would go with. Wow. Well,
- 54:39I mean I would ask you to expand, but you already talked about
- 54:43Raw for ten minutes, and I think we know exactly where you're you're coming
- 54:45from, So all right, there you go, all right, I I
- 54:51mean we this isn't a replacement to make it better. This is a replacement
- 54:55because I think it would be a good role for Lance. So I put
- 55:02him as Kessef, as the as the leader of the tribe, which does
- 55:07make things a little tricky because he's also meant to be the father of Shari
- 55:12and Sokka. But I think you could you know, you could meld that
- 55:16where their children of the tribe or something like that, or blindcast. It
- 55:21doesn't matter, Yeah, it doesn't matter matter. But I just think,
- 55:27you know, I keep thinking of seeing him in the role as the professor
- 55:31in Young Sheldon, which I know is not probably the number one role you
- 55:34think of when you think of Lance Reddick, but he gives He has some
- 55:38scenes where he's giddy and some scenes where he's you know, emoting a lot
- 55:44in that way, and it just made me think, like, here's this
- 55:46tall man who is just he is charged with protecting this tribe, and I
- 55:52think Lance would just excel at that. All right, so we got three
- 55:58for three with Lance. As we go into our final thoughts and ratings,
- 56:02I'll start I even I think I tipped my hand a little bit that I
- 56:07absolutely love this movie. I love the SG one franchise. It's one of
- 56:14those elevator pitches that is meant to be on television. Dial up a new
- 56:19planet every week and take the adventure where you want to go, and they
- 56:24expand on the plot. They you know, keep some characters, change some
- 56:30characters. This I'm not trying to review the show, but where the movie
- 56:36I think succeeds, and I've said it from the beginning, is it's a
- 56:40wondrous ride. It's in the music, it's in the characters, it's in
- 56:45the story. You know you're going to a far off planet. And I
- 56:51remember, Yeah, I don't remember the exact year I saw this. I
- 56:53think I might have been a shade too young in ninety four to see it
- 56:58in theaters, but I remember loving this movie from the get go, loving
- 57:02the score, loving the characters and all of that. So I'm giving it
- 57:08a four plus one for launching a billion dollar franchise, for being such a
- 57:15good seed that it created a whole universe, it created cosplayers, it created
- 57:22movies, and not that that has to be Well, hey, it's my
- 57:25rating. I can do it however I want. So I'm going to give
- 57:29it five from the get go. And it's been a really fun discussion though
- 57:34going going into this, I've really enjoyed that. So John, take us
- 57:39down a notch with your no, with your rating and final thoughts that you
- 57:45might have on Stargate. My final thoughts are that it pretty much is launched
- 57:51where it was many moons ago, at least three moons ago, where it's
- 57:58harmless, good fun. It really defined at the time a popcorn movie.
- 58:04You know, a phrase that we still love to throw around where your brain's
- 58:07not gonna work over hard during this thing. It's not asking a lot,
- 58:10it's just saying, you know, for two hours, sit in the air
- 58:14conditioning, we'll throw a little razzle dazzle at you. There'll be some spectacle.
- 58:17Tristan will just absolutely be in love with everything about it. And that
- 58:22counts a lot for me too. So you know the score is good,
- 58:27that there are pieces there that just never quite gel for me. I'm not
- 58:30going to belabor all of that stuff, and just some of the boy I
- 58:37mean, just to take another extra second and say that whoever put the sound
- 58:42together with that gun cocking sound, that just absolutely it didn't drive me as
- 58:46nuts back then as it did this time, where I was like ready to
- 58:50throw something at the screen because I was like, that's not how they work.
- 58:53Do some research anyway. I come in at what I would consider to
- 58:59be a generous three. But at the very least it indicates a step forward
- 59:04for Emeric because we go from a one to a two to a three,
- 59:08so we're sort of like building as we go along. So at a boy,
- 59:14Emrick, that's what we want directors to do, trend upward. Yeah,
- 59:16and you know what I can see this. What's interesting is you I
- 59:22can see the trend of this is a director getting more confident in what he's
- 59:29putting together as he goes. And is it pointing us toward great success next
- 59:35time? I don't know, but this time it points us at a three
- 59:37where it's like, I don't regret watching it. I liked it. I
- 59:42didn't love it, but I liked it well enough. And you know,
- 59:45yeah, this is I have fond memories of it. So yeah, you
- 59:47know it's all right. So three stars from me? All right, Tristan
- 59:52uh, I think Redell family favorite. It sounds like it. Yes,
- 59:58we usually we didn't. We go through our when we first saw any any
- 1:00:01other final thoughts on on stargate now that this was a certified Ridell family favorite,
- 1:00:07and we would watch the vhs over and over again, and it was
- 1:00:12one of our first DVDs ever. And I think it was double sided,
- 1:00:16not wide screen and full screen. It was double sided as in part one
- 1:00:21and then part two of it film. That is how old The early LaserDisc
- 1:00:27version of DVDs. Yeah, yeah, a lot of crush. Wherever there
- 1:00:31was black on screen, there was always that pixelated crush everywhere with that.
- 1:00:37I missed those days. The clamshell. It was so simple, but no,
- 1:00:42I yeah it was. I was. I was too young to see
- 1:00:44it in theater, but I think my parents sought in theaters and they're like,
- 1:00:46oh, yeah, we're getting that. We're buying that trists and don't
- 1:00:49worry, we're going to watch it at home. And we were. We
- 1:00:51were so in love with it that we were like, oh my god,
- 1:00:53they're they're doing a TV show. We need to watch that as soon as
- 1:00:57it comes out on video because we don't have show time. So we'll just
- 1:01:00wait for it to come out on cassette. We'll watch it as a family,
- 1:01:02bring over Grandma and uh. As we're as we're watching the first episode
- 1:01:10and then we get to a scene where a poor, poor woman is stripped
- 1:01:15down violently, we get full frontal nudity, and then she gets literally thrown
- 1:01:23on a slab and assaulted violently with with an an alien that's eating into her
- 1:01:31back. And we're let and we turn it off and we're like, you
- 1:01:35know what, maybe this Stargate show isn't really for us, and I never
- 1:01:40watched another episode. Oh okay, so now it's Darren's goal to uh start
- 1:01:47after episode one of SG one and give some great best of episodes to uh
- 1:01:53to rest and but no, I totally see. I would appre I would
- 1:01:59appreciate that I've seen I've seen bits and pieces through there, and I know
- 1:02:02it's completely different than what happened in the first episode. And I know that
- 1:02:06there's so many great hours of television because of of what this movie spawned.
- 1:02:09I just thought that was a that was my first You're giving a blank slate,
- 1:02:15Tristan, having not seen any episodes. You're gonna get some You're gonna
- 1:02:19get some gems. But yeah, this so with this film and the the
- 1:02:23the phenomenal performance from Raw, you know, like just the really just we're
- 1:02:29talking about it's raw. Then con then Vader, I think, ra ra
- 1:02:35ra. Okay, I can't take it seriously any more, Tristan, I'm
- 1:02:45sorry, No, this this movie, this movie is a lot of fun.
- 1:02:47It's a really I think it's a great movie. And it's it's like
- 1:02:53John said, it's a popcorn film and you can shut your brain off and
- 1:02:58just have a good time, because there are you know, there are things
- 1:03:00that don't quite make sense, Like why in nineteen twenty eight would you bring
- 1:03:06up an artifact that's five thousand years old and immediately put its on its side
- 1:03:09so that the majority of its weight is at one point. I don't see
- 1:03:15the problem. What are you talking about some sort of fragility or you know
- 1:03:22it has been sitting in its place, oh in one time, that that
- 1:03:24material changes over time. It looks cool Tristan for the shot. But yes,
- 1:03:30you're absolutely right. And also one thing that we didn't talk about was
- 1:03:32that we watched the director's cut of Stargate. That's right, and I don't
- 1:03:37think it added anything to it. In fact, I think the theatrical is
- 1:03:42much better than the director's greet. The act goal was better. But I
- 1:03:47still think that even with the actri goal, there's a there's an assembly problem.
- 1:03:53I wouldn't have started where I started. I would have had that be
- 1:03:55a flashback and started with more mystery. But you know that's just me.
- 1:04:00I think I think that's definitely up for argument. I'm not gonna I'm not
- 1:04:02gonna tell you that you're wrong on that one but I will agree with you.
- 1:04:08Tell me I'm wrong. Oh this is good, this is good,
- 1:04:11it's good night now, thank you. No, I was I was surprised
- 1:04:13that there was a director's cut because it was completely unneeded. Like that was
- 1:04:16cut for a reason. All the scenes that were in there were completely unnecessary.
- 1:04:19They either took away the mystery or made O'Neill and quals you look like
- 1:04:24absolute dumbasses. Uh yeah, no, there's just completely unneeded. So but
- 1:04:30even though I even though I think this is a very entertaining film, it's
- 1:04:32not a perfect film, and so I'm giving it four stars. All right,
- 1:04:35Well, that was a lot of fun going through the stargate. Yeah,
- 1:04:40like you said, the popcorn movie. You can watch it and it
- 1:04:45just bask in the nineties sound effects for sure. Definitely those guns. All
- 1:04:49right. Well, as we are at the halfway point of our trip through
- 1:04:55the House of Roland Emerick. Next week we jumped two more years and a
- 1:05:00little bit of budget as we go to nineteen ninety six with Independence Day here
- 1:05:05on house Lights, join the Revolution, join the nerd Party.