Latest / Adventures Through The Mind / The Conscious Intelligence Of Fungi | Nicholas P. Money ~ ATTMind 193
Transcript
- 0:33- Hello everyone and welcome back
- 0:35to Adventures to the Mind podcast.
- 0:37This is a show that explores topics relevant
- 0:40and related to psychedelic culture, medicine,
- 0:44spirituality, and research.
- 0:46And I'm your host as always, James W. Jesso.
- 0:49Today's interview is with Nicholas P. Money,
- 0:52who is a science writer and mycologist
- 0:55and a professor of biology at Miami University
- 0:58in Oxford, Ohio.
- 1:00He's the author of the 2024 book,
- 1:04"Molds, Mushrooms, and Medicines."
- 1:06But I've got him on the show predominantly
- 1:09to talk about the thesis he presents
- 1:11in his 2021 paper, "Hyphal and Mycelial Consciousness,
- 1:15"The Concept of the Fungal Mind,"
- 1:17published in Fungal Biology.
- 1:19Now I can assure you that although the title
- 1:22of that sounds very complex,
- 1:23the conversation itself is very progressive
- 1:26in the topics we cover,
- 1:28as I really wanted to get a full picture
- 1:30of fungi, of funguses and mushrooms as organisms,
- 1:35before him and I started to explore
- 1:38what denotes intelligence generally,
- 1:42and is it such that mushrooms are intelligent
- 1:45and as to the thesis that he presents in his paper,
- 1:50exploring the very tips of the mycelial network,
- 1:55what are called heifei,
- 1:56as having their own consciousness,
- 1:58each one of them even as a part of a larger organism.
- 2:03To me, super interesting stuff.
- 2:05I hope you find it interesting as well.
- 2:07A note is that having just come out of an interview
- 2:11with John Seed and stuff around climate
- 2:14and ecology being really top of mind for me
- 2:16when I interviewed Nicholas Money here,
- 2:20we ended up going into that for a bit,
- 2:21somewhat accidentally, right at the beginning,
- 2:23talking about ecology and the climate,
- 2:27and kind of debating the value of human beings as a species,
- 2:32the value of human beings as contributing in some way
- 2:38to the larger ecosystem of the planet,
- 2:42the larger sort of meta ecosystem
- 2:44that is the whole planet Earth.
- 2:46And Nicholas and I, we take very different stances.
- 2:50So there's definitely some discussion specifically
- 2:53about that peppered throughout,
- 2:54but mostly in the beginning,
- 2:56before we get into the larger discussion about fungal,
- 3:00excuse me, fungi and fungal intelligence.
- 3:04And that's all for the intro.
- 3:05And I hope that you enjoy this interview
- 3:08with Nicholas Money here on Adventures Through the Mind,
- 3:10episode 193.
- 3:13Dr. Nicholas Money, welcome to Adventures Through the Mind.
- 3:16- Thank you for inviting me.
- 3:19Looking forward to a vibrant conversation.
- 3:21- Well, fingers crossed at least.
- 3:24- Thank you.
- 3:25- On your end, I assume, but we'll see how I show up.
- 3:27Now you are the author of the new book,
- 3:30"Molds, Mushrooms, and Medicine," that just came,
- 3:33actually, would you hold up?
- 3:34Would you hold up, do you have a copy there?
- 3:35I don't have one at home, so.
- 3:38- This stellar contribution to the mycological literature.
- 3:41I've written about a dozen books,
- 3:44so this is the most recent.
- 3:45- Yeah, and it looks quite exciting.
- 3:50- It's very exciting,
- 3:51and it deserves far more interest from popular readers
- 3:55than it's received so far.
- 3:56But I could probably say that
- 3:58about most of my back catalog,
- 3:59but it is a work of heartbreaking genius.
- 4:03And I'd recommend everyone on planet Earth
- 4:08try and read this before it's too late.
- 4:11- Wow, just going for the big ones right from the get-go.
- 4:19We don't have a lot of time left as a species,
- 4:21and I think people would be ill-advised
- 4:24to ignore the truth about our relationship with fungi.
- 4:29That's what I'd--
- 4:31- There's actually--
- 4:32- That's my niche.
- 4:33I think I wanna learn as much about things
- 4:35before I and the rest of Homo sapiens exit.
- 4:39- There's a man who I'm not gonna mention,
- 4:43'cause he has since become quite maligned, I'd say,
- 4:46started adopting and promoting some worldviews that,
- 4:51well, I just don't wanna promote them any further.
- 4:53But at one point,
- 4:55I went to a lecture that he gave,
- 4:58and it was all about mushrooms.
- 5:00And it was all about basically the many times
- 5:05in which the larger planetary ecology
- 5:11was jeopardized by mass cataclysm or dramatic change
- 5:16and how in the midst of all of that,
- 5:17it seemed like mushrooms were the predominant player
- 5:21that helped maintain stability long enough
- 5:25for stability to find its way.
- 5:26Essentially, the fungi kingdom played very important roles
- 5:31in sustaining life in the midst of every one
- 5:33of these cataclysms or extinction-type events.
- 5:36I don't know how true that is,
- 5:38but one thing that really stuck with me,
- 5:40and I feel personally true, may be objectively true,
- 5:44which is like, if you wanna make your way through crisis,
- 5:47align yourself with the fungi.
- 5:48So I've taken that to personal heart,
- 5:51even if it may not end up being scientific truth.
- 5:54- Yeah.
- 5:57What, sorry, so do I think there's something to it?
- 6:00I mean, I guess I'm skeptical about all worldviews
- 6:05in which we're placing humans
- 6:07at the center of our concerns.
- 6:10So the fungi don't give a flying
- 6:12about, fuck about whether we survive or not,
- 6:17but we can get into that perhaps a little later.
- 6:22But of the fungi played a role in sustaining life on Earth?
- 6:26Yeah, certainly.
- 6:27You could make a very significant case
- 6:30that planktonic organisms,
- 6:33particularly the photosynthetic ones,
- 6:34have also played what a massive role
- 6:38in making the planet habitable for animals, including us.
- 6:43- Yeah, a previous guest I had on the show,
- 6:47actually just interviewed him yesterday.
- 6:48I don't know if it's a previous guest,
- 6:49depends on when it all comes out,
- 6:51but he was mentioning about the shift in geology,
- 6:56or like the planet's sort of presence of life
- 7:01from predominantly anaerobic bacteria
- 7:04to these oxygen producing species,
- 7:06and how much of a crisis that was at the time
- 7:09for the anaerobic life forms.
- 7:12- I mean, oxygen is, from that viewpoint,
- 7:15is an extremely poisonous chemical.
- 7:18And there wasn't a lot of it around before
- 7:21there was oxygen producing photosynthesis.
- 7:25Yeah, it's really interesting.
- 7:28What we're engaging in now, though,
- 7:31is our own experiment in reorganizing planet
- 7:36and planetary chemistry.
- 7:38And so that's obviously,
- 7:39that is the source of my bleak assessment of our future,
- 7:44whether or not the fungi are here.
- 7:47And they'll be here long after we're gone.
- 7:49- Something will prevail.
- 7:52It'd be nice if it was more of us for longer,
- 7:56but something that probably prevails.
- 7:58- I don't know.
- 7:59I don't think so.
- 8:00I think we're a rather unpleasant,
- 8:03I think the bad outweighs the good
- 8:05when it comes to Homo sapiens.
- 8:06So the sooner that we're swept away,
- 8:08the better, I think.
- 8:12The planet would be a place of less suffering.
- 8:15There will be less net suffering in the universe
- 8:18if we were whipped away, which we surely will be.
- 8:21- Respectfully, I disagree.
- 8:24I do believe that we are doing incredible harm
- 8:29and orchestrating a lot of suffering.
- 8:32But it's not as though nature without us
- 8:34is this Disney world that doesn't include suffering
- 8:37and death and destruction and all that.
- 8:39- Absolutely.
- 8:40I mean, I don't know whether, can I use the F word?
- 8:43I mean, zoology is a fucking nightmare.
- 8:47I mean, that's the truth.
- 8:48Darwin knew this and he edged around that issue,
- 8:51issue of suffering in nature.
- 8:52So yeah, whether humans are here or not,
- 8:55we're, yeah, sentient life,
- 8:58consciousness is a bad thing when it comes to,
- 9:01well, it provides the option to suffer,
- 9:05the option, the ability to suffer.
- 9:08The difference is though with us is that we can make,
- 9:11we might not believe in free will,
- 9:13but we have the fantasy of being able to make decisions
- 9:17and the decisions that we do make,
- 9:19for example, in what?
- 9:22Industrialized agriculture, for example,
- 9:25that's a net source of suffering that is avoidable.
- 9:28And so we deserve to be, the aliens are watching us
- 9:31and yeah, they're not gonna, we're not gonna get out of,
- 9:34we won't get a get out of jail free card
- 9:37because we also see that other species of mammals
- 9:40are attacking one another.
- 9:43- I mean, certainly not.
- 9:45- We're particularly nasty.
- 9:47We're probably not the smartest organisms on the planet.
- 9:50There are recitations, there are whales
- 9:52with immensely larger brains,
- 9:56but yeah, they don't engage
- 10:01in any industrialized forms of suffering.
- 10:04- I mean, have yet to evolve the capacity to do so perhaps.
- 10:08- Flippers, I mean, this was very,
- 10:09Huxley recognized this in the 19th century.
- 10:12Here's the problem, it's the hand.
- 10:13- You just got rid of those pesky thumbs.
- 10:17- We do a lot of batshit with our hands
- 10:19and with our brains and yeah,
- 10:23a whale can't build a prison.
- 10:27- Yeah.
- 10:28- I am almost, I'd say like too often
- 10:31have the tendency to lean into a more sort of bleak outlook
- 10:36on how this is all going.
- 10:38And also again, I respectfully disagree around humanity.
- 10:43I think if we can't get our stuff together
- 10:46and make some serious positive changes,
- 10:50then we've got what's coming down the pipeline
- 10:53is what we deserve.
- 10:54And still, I think that,
- 10:59and this is a quote that I read even just today actually,
- 11:04it was something to the effect of like,
- 11:08how we perceive the world has a big influence on how we act
- 11:11and how we act has a big influence on the impact
- 11:13we have on the world and thus the sum total of those impact
- 11:18really matter.
- 11:19And that when the choice is between sort of like pessimism
- 11:23or optimism, optimism tends to be a better choice,
- 11:26not because it's like woo or naive to like eliminate the bad,
- 11:30but because it just seems like a sort of pessimistic outlook
- 11:35doesn't create, certainly won't create a better world.
- 11:39And an optimistic one might if we choose to.
- 11:43And so I just don't wanna throw the baby out
- 11:44with the bathwater.
- 11:45I think humanity has a lot of potential
- 11:47and some beautiful things have come through us.
- 11:49And if we could start sort of shifting the ratio
- 11:53between the beautiful things that we can create
- 11:56and the harm that we're being, that's been done
- 11:58and that we are doing,
- 12:00I think it would be worth us sticking around.
- 12:01And if we can't, like I said,
- 12:03then we've got coming down the pipeline
- 12:05as we're gonna get what we deserve.
- 12:07- I mean, I think the, for me as a teacher, as a professor,
- 12:15I don't project an entirely pessimistic view of the future.
- 12:20I think that would be unethical toward people that are,
- 12:28I'm 62, that students that I'm teaching are teenagers.
- 12:32I think what I would like to do though,
- 12:37in the years that remain for me as a teacher
- 12:41is to at least engender a love of nature
- 12:44and particularly among a love of microscopic forms of nature.
- 12:49I mean, there is still what tremendous joy to be had,
- 12:55irrespective of age, in collecting and looking at pond water
- 12:59and looking at the effusion of life in freshwater ponds.
- 13:04I mean, this is something that I've enjoyed doing
- 13:08throughout my life.
- 13:09I inherited this from one of my grandmothers.
- 13:14So even so what?
- 13:15So even though my view of the future is very pessimistic,
- 13:20that doesn't mean I can't be extraordinarily happy
- 13:22in looking at slices of nature now.
- 13:25That is what gives me joy.
- 13:28Hope?
- 13:29No, I think in that sense,
- 13:31I'm a very hopeless person, but I'm not depressed.
- 13:36I'm not depressed.
- 13:41Yeah, how does that work?
- 13:42I'm convinced that we're on the way out much sooner,
- 13:44sooner rather than later.
- 13:46And yet I'm a fairly happy person.
- 13:50And some of that happiness comes from where we go,
- 13:52whoa, there we go.
- 13:53- I have no idea why that's happening.
- 13:54- I thought you did.
- 13:55- That wasn't me.
- 13:56Okay.
- 13:59- I didn't do anything.
- 13:59Wow, somebody's watching this.
- 14:03Wow, what did that happen?
- 14:05- For listeners, some weird video effect happened.
- 14:09- Key words within this that's set off,
- 14:11I could try it again, I suppose,
- 14:12and use the happiness word and then I'm so happy.
- 14:16No, it didn't work.
- 14:17- Anyway, it seems like you found a good balance
- 14:21or a way of navigating the sort of...
- 14:24- It's a work in progress, right?
- 14:26I mean, it's a work in progress.
- 14:27It's some, yeah.
- 14:30- See, 'cause when I think about it,
- 14:31you talked about looking at slides from freshwater pools
- 14:36or looking at things and being like finding joy
- 14:40and seeing beauty and I don't know, right?
- 14:44Like I don't think we could properly divine so far
- 14:49an experiment to prove that other animals
- 14:52like look upon things and say,
- 14:54wow, that's absolutely beautiful.
- 14:56Look at how beautiful that is and be moved by its beauty.
- 15:00We know humans do.
- 15:01So under the assumption based on the data that we have
- 15:04that presently humans are the only organisms on planet earth
- 15:09and expression of planet earth's larger life cycle
- 15:13that have the capacity for beauty as a sense perception,
- 15:18then it would seem to me that that itself might be,
- 15:21if possible, worth preserving both in the capacity
- 15:25and the objects upon which the capacity can flourish
- 15:30as in like that humanity, there's a value in the fact
- 15:33that humans can perceive and express beauty
- 15:36and such there is a value in ensuring
- 15:39that our actions can start to align with preserving
- 15:42and maintaining a world that has beautiful things in it.
- 15:45Not just beautiful because I like this piece of art
- 15:48or this architecture, but beauty in the sense
- 15:50that we're preserving the natural world
- 15:52and caring for our fellow kin, human and non-human alike,
- 15:57building beautiful social structures, all of these things.
- 16:00I think all of that is possible and worthwhile
- 16:03and believing as possible while simultaneously
- 16:06I do also accept the fact that it isn't looking good presently.
- 16:11- Right, I think there's a lot in what you say.
- 16:14It does edge towards sort of a quasi religious viewpoint
- 16:19though, which is probably beyond the scope of this.
- 16:24You know, I'll chat today, but you know,
- 16:29the idea of an objective good,
- 16:32is there an objective good on planet earth?
- 16:37You don't know, I don't know.
- 16:41There's an objective bad in the sense that the experience
- 16:45of suffering is something that no organisms
- 16:50have evolved to what, enjoy.
- 16:55The objective bad without an objective good.
- 17:01That's like kind of believing in the devil,
- 17:03but not in Christ our savior.
- 17:08Maybe that's true of me though.
- 17:10Yeah, I see the devil everywhere.
- 17:12- I mean, it's interesting to be able to look upon the world
- 17:17and say, oh, there's evil, but then look upon the world
- 17:20and be like, well, can we prove that there's good?
- 17:22Who knows?
- 17:23There might be a--
- 17:26- It puts the people with religious faith,
- 17:28true believers that yeah,
- 17:32the sense of comfort that comes from that,
- 17:36external to me, absolutely,
- 17:40there's such a thing as good and evil.
- 17:44- Yeah, I don't think I was trying to make a proclamation
- 17:48about good and evil objective,
- 17:50at least I wasn't consciously aware of doing this.
- 17:53It was more along the lines of,
- 17:57I can, to the degree to which I am able to be awake
- 18:02and aware of myself as a person of consequence,
- 18:07consequences good and bad, consequences known unknown.
- 18:11And to the best of my awareness and capacity,
- 18:15act in accordance with what I believe
- 18:17to have more positive consequence than negative consequence,
- 18:22as far as I can see it,
- 18:24that that at least as far as I'm concerned
- 18:27would be acting good.
- 18:29But the ability to know what is good
- 18:31and act upon that good at all times
- 18:34beyond the individual self is what I believe
- 18:36what Socrates said was beyond the realm of the human.
- 18:39It's the realm of the gods
- 18:40or the only ones that could do this.
- 18:42The best that we could do is our best
- 18:44and know that it will always fall short of perfection.
- 18:47And so when I said that, that's what I meant like,
- 18:50that we could choose to start increasing our capacity
- 18:53for acting in alignment with what is good
- 18:55without trying to draw any particular sort of like
- 18:58religious divides between good or evil and good or bad.
- 19:02- Yeah, I mean, do unto others is a good rule for life.
- 19:06- Human and non-human alike.
- 19:09- Absolutely, absolutely.
- 19:11- So now that we went into that incredibly engaging Eddie
- 19:15about mushrooms, right?
- 19:17So what I initially had you on the show today
- 19:21to talk about is fungi in particular.
- 19:26And especially, you know, I haven't read
- 19:30molds, mushrooms and medicine yet anyways,
- 19:33but what called me to your work was a paper
- 19:35that you wrote around basically the consciousness
- 19:40of fungi, particularly hyphae.
- 19:43Now I'm gonna ask you about that in a minute,
- 19:45but I think what would make sense for people listening,
- 19:48you know, they might see on the video screen,
- 19:50you got a fruiting body, a mushroomed fungi model
- 19:54in the background, I got a mushroom on my shirt.
- 19:56So people have a sense that mushrooms are a thing.
- 19:59They might be thinking about a number
- 20:01of different configurations biologically
- 20:03when they think of fungi.
- 20:04But maybe start us off with a basic overview,
- 20:09like a quick rundown of the fungi as an organism,
- 20:14like the configurations of its body.
- 20:18Right, the fungal body.
- 20:20So mushroom forming fungi, a few tens of thousands
- 20:26of species of fungi actually form big visible fruit bodies.
- 20:31These are the base to the amisete fungi.
- 20:37Let me get too technical here,
- 20:39also ask amisete fungi that produce things like morels.
- 20:43The mushrooms are the sex organs,
- 20:47the reproductive organs produced by,
- 20:49usually by larger organisms.
- 20:52The larger organism exists as a feeding colony
- 20:56or mycelium that's penetrating wood or soil
- 21:00or other kinds of, or even the tissues of animals.
- 21:05And then after they've generated enough biomass
- 21:13by feeding on those organic food sources,
- 21:17they can then reproduce by producing this,
- 21:20a mushroom for example, releasing clouds of spores.
- 21:24When those spores germinate,
- 21:26they have the potential to generate new feeding colonies.
- 21:29And so that's in essence,
- 21:31the life cycle of those fungi
- 21:33that produce macroscopic fruit bodies.
- 21:38So we got a feeding phase
- 21:41and a reproductive phase.
- 21:44You do it with hand movements.
- 21:45I mean, that's the fungal life cycle you've got.
- 21:47So I don't know.
- 21:49This is the feeding phase, actually two mycelia,
- 21:53two colonies here, filamentous cells called hyphae
- 21:56penetrating their food sources, extracting out nutrients.
- 22:01And then what's the other thing then?
- 22:02They'll produce a fruit body
- 22:04and then the spores are dispersed from the fruit body
- 22:08and move away on the breeze.
- 22:09So penetration, spore.
- 22:14- So that's a mushrooming fungi,
- 22:18but there are other forms of fungi.
- 22:20- Absolutely.
- 22:21The mushrooms are sort of the least part of the fungi,
- 22:24at least in terms of the diversity of the fungi.
- 22:28Most fungi exist in holy microscopic forms
- 22:31as also with filamentous cells that we call,
- 22:34filamentous fungi called, that we refer to as molds.
- 22:39Or in the form of budding yeast cells.
- 22:41So these are microscopic.
- 22:44We just don't see these,
- 22:45unless there's a lot of them masked together
- 22:47in the form of like a film of yeast growing on a surface,
- 22:51for example.
- 22:53We also find molds, molds reproduce by producing spores,
- 22:56but they don't produce these large fruit bodies.
- 22:58They'll produce microscopic or tiny stalks
- 23:02and form spores at the tips of those stalks.
- 23:05And then there's this vast, really undocumented diversity
- 23:09of fungi.
- 23:10We really know very little about them.
- 23:12We know they're there because we see their genetic footprints
- 23:17pretty much everywhere we look.
- 23:20And these are probably aquatic.
- 23:21Well, the soil organisms,
- 23:25but they also grow in freshwater and marine ecosystems.
- 23:28We wouldn't really know much about those.
- 23:30What's that?
- 23:31I got a thumb up now next to me.
- 23:33- I don't know why that's happening.
- 23:35It's my new computer though.
- 23:37I'm not a big fan of Skype, but anyway,
- 23:39that's what it's doing here.
- 23:40God knows what it'll do next.
- 23:42It'll put a hat on me and I'll...
- 23:43- Well, as long as it's a funny hat,
- 23:46I think we can accept it.
- 23:47- Do we? - It's all right.
- 23:47None of these boring hats.
- 23:49- The answer to the leprechaun or something,
- 23:50I don't know what it's gonna do next.
- 23:52Mind boggling.
- 23:53- But anyways, you were saying there,
- 23:56these other forms of fungi that we don't know much about,
- 24:00but we see their genetic footprint in various places
- 24:05aquatic environments, soil environments.
- 24:07But from what I understand, there's also maybe some evidence
- 24:10of certain forms of fungi that exist in like,
- 24:12above the earth as well,
- 24:16like in various places in the atmosphere.
- 24:17- Well, there are certainly fungal spores that are,
- 24:22I mean, millions of tons of fungal spores
- 24:24that are circulating in the high atmosphere.
- 24:28Well, actually on lower elevations too, but yeah.
- 24:30So there are fungi that are airborne,
- 24:33but there's not any good evidence
- 24:36that they're really doing much in the form of growth
- 24:38in that form, but if they circulate
- 24:41and then they're deposited on a propitious food source,
- 24:46then they'll grow.
- 24:48But yeah, the fungi are everywhere.
- 24:51- Just waiting to attach themselves to one of our spaceships
- 24:53to recolonize another planet maybe.
- 24:56- Maybe that's it, without intent,
- 24:59but indeed we might carry them.
- 25:03I mean, the furthest we've ever carried,
- 25:05the furthest that the fungi have ever traveled
- 25:08is the surface of our satellite, the moon.
- 25:12- As far as we know, I guess.
- 25:14- I guess so they may be clinging to the surface
- 25:18probably in a freeze dried form at this point
- 25:21for spacecraft that have traveled beyond the moon.
- 25:25But we know they've made it to the moon
- 25:27in the sense that the astronauts on the Apollo missions,
- 25:30they left jettison bags with their poop and urine in them
- 25:35on the surface of the moon.
- 25:38And so some of the fungi that were present
- 25:42in their guts at that time
- 25:43were left there on the surface of the moon.
- 25:47So that's the furthest extension of the microbiome,
- 25:52the fungal part of life on Earth.
- 25:55- I will later try to remember to ask you
- 25:59why it is that you might consider hyphae as conscious,
- 26:03but mushrooms or fungi without intent,
- 26:05but that might be a different question for later
- 26:08after we get some definitions.
- 26:09- Absolutely.
- 26:10- Before we get there,
- 26:12can you verbally descriptively as best you can?
- 26:15'Cause most people engage in the show or listening.
- 26:18You might get, you don't want that top hat after all,
- 26:22right, funny hat or the leprechaun dance or what have you.
- 26:25Can you explain to us a little bit around
- 26:28like what, you talked about the sort of larger
- 26:32mycelial body of the fungi.
- 26:36What does that look like?
- 26:37What's the configuration look like?
- 26:39- Well, you can see it with the unaided eye,
- 26:44at least if you could do this.
- 26:47If I was with students in the woods,
- 26:49you could roll over a log under moist conditions
- 26:52and you'd find lots and lots of hyphae
- 26:55that are growing underneath that rotting wood
- 26:59and just the masses of cells that are present,
- 27:02you might see that in the form of this usually white
- 27:06sort of cottony growth.
- 27:10And often there, it's actually not individual hyphae
- 27:13that you're looking at, what it isn't really.
- 27:15It's structures called cords that are made from,
- 27:18these are tubular structures that are formed
- 27:20from hundreds or thousands of hyphae
- 27:22that are bundled together.
- 27:23And those are really important in moving water
- 27:25from one place to another.
- 27:28They're these, yeah, water pipes.
- 27:32No, they're not.
- 27:33Anyway, they're called cords.
- 27:35There's another form called a rhizomorph
- 27:37that's a root-like structure that's formed
- 27:38from hundreds or thousands of hyphae.
- 27:42And those are also visible without a microscope.
- 27:46But the individual hyphae, I mean, they're what?
- 27:48A 10th of the width of a human hair.
- 27:50So you need a microscope to see them.
- 27:54- And in a mycelial body, if you were to look at its
- 27:58sort of structure under a microscope,
- 28:01from what I understand, it looks like a three-dimensional
- 28:06web or a net.
- 28:08Like when I envision the many visualizations I've seen
- 28:12of what the interconnection of the human brain looks like
- 28:15of all these different nodes and these patterns
- 28:18and so on and so forth.
- 28:19Like a mycelial body, if you were to see all its connections,
- 28:24it would look something like that, is that correct?
- 28:25The sort of highly complex three-dimensional
- 28:28interlinking web?
- 28:30- Absolutely.
- 28:32Although, and in fact, the number of filaments is not,
- 28:37let's think about this.
- 28:38I did a calculation once where I was looking
- 28:40at a very, very rich mycelium in a very productive grassland
- 28:45trying to calculate just how many hyphae might be present.
- 28:49This actually wasn't my original work,
- 28:51but I did some of these back of the envelope calculations.
- 28:54And you can come up with these figures for
- 28:56the individual number of filaments being not dissimilar
- 29:01from the number of nerve cells in the human brain.
- 29:04I mean, we're on the order of billions of these filaments.
- 29:08What's different though about the brain,
- 29:10I mean, you mentioned that it is the mycelium,
- 29:13these connections, the individual hyphae, these filaments,
- 29:16they do indeed interconnect.
- 29:18But when we think about the synaptic connections
- 29:21in our brains, the way that an individual nerve cell
- 29:25can branch into hundreds, thousands of these dendrites,
- 29:30they're called, then interact with other nerve cells
- 29:33through synaptic connections,
- 29:35that capacity for networking is vastly beyond anything
- 29:39that a mushroom mycelium can do.
- 29:42But in terms of the number of cells
- 29:44and the density of those cells, yeah, it's not,
- 29:47we're dealing with a similar order of magnitude
- 29:50to kind of massive, massive, what elongated filamentous cells
- 29:55that we'll find in a brain.
- 29:57- Can you tell me a little bit more about hyphae
- 30:00and their role in the organism?
- 30:03I mean, in particular, like what makes them unique,
- 30:07say from the roots of plants?
- 30:10- That's a great question, because indeed,
- 30:13there are actually one thing is that fungal hyphae
- 30:16are tip growing.
- 30:17The only way, predominantly, they grow,
- 30:21they extend at their tips and that's how they elongate.
- 30:24Now we're talking about growth on the order
- 30:26of what, a few millimeters a day.
- 30:30This isn't a very, very fast rate of growth.
- 30:33It's actually a pretty good clip for a microorganism.
- 30:36But there's other kinds of tip growing cells
- 30:37that we find like pollen tubes that are involved
- 30:40in sexual reproduction that deliver the sperm cells
- 30:43in implant reproduction.
- 30:45And there's other kinds of cells
- 30:46that also grow at their tips.
- 30:49And so what makes a fungal hyphae a unique structure
- 30:53is the fact that it combines that tip growth with feeding.
- 30:58And so a pollen tube isn't really doing that.
- 31:01A pollen tube is growing inside a plant flower.
- 31:05It's delivering the male gametes, the sperm cells,
- 31:09to the eggs in the flower.
- 31:11But it's not really a feeding structure.
- 31:13Fungal hyphae are feeding structures.
- 31:15They're penetrating solid materials.
- 31:19Well, they could be our own tissues
- 31:21and I write about a lot about that in the new book.
- 31:26But it could be wood.
- 31:27We talked about rolling over a log.
- 31:29Well, they're feeding on plant debris in that case.
- 31:33But yes, that combination of tip growth and feeding.
- 31:38And the feeding happens in the following way
- 31:42that these hyphae, these filaments,
- 31:44they release enzymes from the tips of the cells.
- 31:47Those enzymes break down macromolecules,
- 31:51so complex carbohydrates,
- 31:53but also proteins and fat molecules.
- 31:57And the action of those enzymes
- 31:59solubilizes, releases smaller molecules
- 32:03from those polymers, those larger molecules.
- 32:06And then the fungus feeds on them.
- 32:08So it's feeding on sugars, for example,
- 32:11that fuel its metabolism.
- 32:13So it's doing this continuously.
- 32:15It's releasing enzymes, breaking down large molecules
- 32:20in its surroundings, absorbing low-moleculoid things
- 32:24like sugars and fatty acids and amino acids.
- 32:27And it's using these to actually fuel its metabolism.
- 32:31So there are some other organisms,
- 32:33some of the microorganisms that work in a similar fashion.
- 32:36Water molds do this.
- 32:38There it's a kind of protest.
- 32:41But that really is the best shot I've got there
- 32:44at explaining what makes a fungal hyphae different
- 32:46from most other things.
- 32:49But it's got some, in terms of the cellular makeup
- 32:52of that structure, there's some very distinctive features
- 32:56of the structure of a hyphae.
- 32:58And also the things pressurized.
- 33:00Many years ago now, that was one of the research areas
- 33:07that I explored was actually measuring the pressure
- 33:09inside fungal cells.
- 33:10It was just, for me at least,
- 33:11it was fantastically interesting
- 33:13that we can actually measure the pressure
- 33:15of those cells directly by puncturing them
- 33:18with a little, with a glass micropipette,
- 33:21a little tube and actually measuring the pressure
- 33:23inside those cells.
- 33:25And they're pressurized to a few atmospheres of pressure,
- 33:28you know, four, five, six atmospheres of pressure,
- 33:31which means if a fungal hyphae is damaged
- 33:33while it's growing, it'll explode.
- 33:37Although it also possesses
- 33:40what I suppose a simple form of clotting mechanism
- 33:46that actually prevents the cell from hemorrhaging,
- 33:49from the whole mycelium from hemorrhaging.
- 33:51But yeah, it's under pressure and that's interesting.
- 33:56You know, the individual cells in our bodies
- 33:58are not under pressure.
- 33:59We have blood pressure, but these pressures in fungal hyphae
- 34:04are much higher than those, you know, 10 times higher
- 34:07than human blood pressure.
- 34:09And so, you know, they spurt their contents
- 34:11if they're damaged.
- 34:12What else about hyphae?
- 34:14The other thing is that they branch highly.
- 34:17Pollen tubes don't do that, other tip growing cells.
- 34:19So as a hyphae extends, it forms branches
- 34:23and the branch is branched.
- 34:24And that's how you get this very complex,
- 34:28geometrically complex three-dimensional network
- 34:30of filaments.
- 34:32And that's the feeding phase of the fungus.
- 34:34- And root structures of plants,
- 34:38although they on a macroscopic level
- 34:40have a similar kind of like winding networking thing,
- 34:44they're serving an entirely different function
- 34:47to the organism.
- 34:48From what I understand, the mycelium, that is the organism
- 34:53and the mushroom is the fruiting body
- 34:55where with trees, you know, the tree is the whole organism.
- 34:58The root is a part of its feeding,
- 35:00but it's not the whole organism.
- 35:02- That's a good observation.
- 35:04So that actually distinguishes the fungi from plants
- 35:07or the following distinguishes the fungi from the plants
- 35:09is that fungi are absorbing food from their surroundings.
- 35:13Plants are making their own food, right?
- 35:15They use the energy, solar energy to manufacture,
- 35:20well, to fix carbon dioxide and manufacture
- 35:22manufacture sugars and other other macro molecules.
- 35:27So plants make their own food.
- 35:29Fungi steal from plants and actually other fungi
- 35:33and then also from us and other organisms
- 35:36on which they grow.
- 35:38The root system of plants is absorbing water and minerals,
- 35:42but it's not, I wouldn't, you know,
- 35:45if we're using feeding in terms of actually a carbon source,
- 35:48something we can burn, that comes from the leaves
- 35:51and the photosynthetic activity of the plant.
- 35:54Whereas the fungi have to absorb all of their food
- 35:56through there.
- 35:58You know, I mean, we refer to it sometimes
- 36:01as or people have referred to it sometimes
- 36:03as a fungal equivalent of a root system.
- 36:06Well, not so much.
- 36:07It is in terms, as you said,
- 36:08of its sort of some of its three dimensional structure
- 36:12that through forming very fine filaments,
- 36:16it's able to explore a very large volume.
- 36:21That's exactly what fungi are doing
- 36:23when they penetrate wood, for example.
- 36:27- And so this is one of the ways from what I understand
- 36:30that the fungi kingdom is closer to the animal kingdom
- 36:33than the animal kingdom is to the plant kingdom.
- 36:35Is that correct?
- 36:36Like for example, plants make their own food,
- 36:39animals and fungi consume food from their environment.
- 36:43And there's other similarities between animals and fungi
- 36:49compared to animals and plants too, is that right?
- 36:51- Absolutely.
- 36:52I mean, there's a lot of them,
- 36:53but one of them, the one that interests me a lot
- 36:56is some was actually identified
- 36:58sort of in the pre-molecular age of biology
- 37:02because now we can compare the genomes
- 37:05of fungi and animals and plants and everything else.
- 37:07And we can actually calculate their degree of similarity
- 37:11and evolutionary relatedness.
- 37:15But I think this was really interesting observation
- 37:19that was made first in the 1980s,
- 37:23was that the only organisms that produce a cell
- 37:27with a flagellum, a cellular tail
- 37:30that I'm doing all these hand movements in this,
- 37:34this interview today,
- 37:35but there aren't many things you can do as a fungus.
- 37:38Anyway, a tail that undulates, that vibrates
- 37:41and actually pushes the cell through fluid.
- 37:44So animal sperm cells do this,
- 37:48but also the cells of aquatic fungi called chytrids.
- 37:52And there's actually other kinds of fungi
- 37:54that live in aquatic environments.
- 37:57They produce swimming cells too,
- 37:58that swim in exactly the same way
- 38:00with a tail that pushes the cell through the water.
- 38:03There's nothing else like that in nature.
- 38:05So me with my obsession with pond water,
- 38:08I see cells that are swimming around all the time
- 38:11using cilia or flagella.
- 38:15These are the terms that we use.
- 38:17Then they're arranged in a fundamentally different fashion
- 38:20where they're not acting as an outboard motor
- 38:22that pushes the cell through the water.
- 38:25They may be pulling the cell through water.
- 38:26They're working in different ways,
- 38:28but that particular arrangement
- 38:31of the single flagellum on a swimming cell
- 38:35is something that we only find in animals and fungi.
- 38:38So that in itself is a structural characteristic
- 38:43that unites these organisms.
- 38:45On this very smart,
- 38:47although tremendously annoying scientist
- 38:49pointed this out in the 1980s,
- 38:51he just recognized that.
- 38:53I thought that was a really brilliant insight.
- 38:57Before we'd done the genetic analysis
- 39:00that showed the similarity between fungi and animals.
- 39:05Yeah, so fungi and animals exist in
- 39:09what we call a supergroup.
- 39:10It's something larger than a kingdom.
- 39:11So we might regard the animals as a kingdom,
- 39:14kingdom animalia and the fungi as their own kingdom.
- 39:17But they exist in this super grouping
- 39:20where they're united and separated
- 39:22from many other forms of life.
- 39:24- So that if we go back evolutionarily,
- 39:29there was a common progenitor between fungi and animals.
- 39:32- There must have been, yeah.
- 39:35I mean, that's evident from the structure that I mentioned,
- 39:40other kinds of cellular structures
- 39:42that are in common between fungi and animals,
- 39:45and also this profound genetic similarity.
- 39:49I mean, it's profound, and yet,
- 39:51we're talking about separation
- 39:52that occurred a billion years ago.
- 39:54So there's a lot of evolutionary history
- 39:56through which we've been separated,
- 39:58but nevertheless our base,
- 40:00there we are with far more like fungi
- 40:02than we're like brown algae kelps, for example,
- 40:07or plants or diatoms or dinoflagellates,
- 40:12all of these other beautiful forms of eukaryote life.
- 40:16Yeah, we're united with the fungi,
- 40:18which is interesting.
- 40:21- Interesting.
- 40:23- It's inspiring.
- 40:24- I have a less scientific reason
- 40:27to state the same in my own life,
- 40:28but we can leave that aside.
- 40:31- Well, we can go to that.
- 40:32The other thing is though too,
- 40:33is that this has been discussed for years,
- 40:38is that when we develop very serious fungal infections,
- 40:45they're very difficult to treat.
- 40:47So the most serious fungal infections,
- 40:49usually we develop those
- 40:51because our immune systems are compromised
- 40:56for one reason or another, and we could discuss that.
- 40:59But it's because of the profound similarities
- 41:01between the biochemistry of the fungi and us,
- 41:04it's difficult to develop a drug
- 41:07that kills these fungi without damaging our tissues.
- 41:10And that's the reason why
- 41:11most of the most powerful antifungal agents are very toxic.
- 41:17We have to take them in quite high doses
- 41:18to deal with a fungal infection,
- 41:21and they lead to kidney and liver damage and so forth.
- 41:25So even there, we're seeing traces
- 41:28of our evolutionary heritage and what?
- 41:32Close affinity to the fungi.
- 41:38- I didn't have this question in mind,
- 41:40but I'm gonna ask it now.
- 41:41I mean, medicine is in the title of your new book.
- 41:44From what I understand,
- 41:45I'm hearing you talk about the similarity
- 41:47between animal cells and fungi cells
- 41:49and this complexity with treating invasive
- 41:52or damaging fungal infections.
- 41:55And there's also, from what I understand,
- 41:58historically traditionally has been used,
- 42:01but increasingly more science
- 42:03around the consumption of particular fungi
- 42:06for health benefits.
- 42:08What the industry is calling so-called functional mushrooms,
- 42:12where the consumption of beta-glucans
- 42:15and other acids and other components of different fungi
- 42:19have these incredible effects on our immune system.
- 42:23What's your read on that?
- 42:26Is there something around the similarities
- 42:28between the fungi organism and the animal organism
- 42:32that enables this kind of sharing of, yeah, I'll let you take
- 42:37from there.
- 42:38- I don't know whether we,
- 42:40so you've actually hit upon one of my areas,
- 42:42probably my main claim to infamy and hate mail
- 42:47is that I've written a good deal actually
- 42:48about medicinal mushrooms.
- 42:50And often when I'm interviewed actually,
- 42:52this is the primary topic of discussion,
- 42:55but I'm very skeptical about the health claims
- 42:59that are made for the majority
- 43:01of medicinal mushroom products.
- 43:04We might talk about psilocybin,
- 43:06I think that's in a different category
- 43:08of potentially very, very useful compounds
- 43:13within that category.
- 43:14But a lot of the claims that are made indeed
- 43:16for beta-glucans and so forth,
- 43:19I believe have been hyped into absurdity.
- 43:22I talk about this in the book,
- 43:24but if anybody cares to search,
- 43:28search up a little, look around on the internet,
- 43:31you'll find articles and papers
- 43:33that I've written on this topic.
- 43:36I'm actually optimistic about the future of fungal medicine,
- 43:41but I'm requiring a lot higher level of proof before.
- 43:46I think I would recommend most medicinal mushroom products.
- 43:51There's a great deal of wishful thinking that goes on.
- 43:54- Unfortunately, there's also a great deal
- 43:56of sort of deceptive marketing that goes on as well.
- 44:00I mean, that's implicated in anything
- 44:04that poses any benefit to anyone ever.
- 44:07Deceptive marketing will come in
- 44:08to try to profit off at that.
- 44:09- That's true.
- 44:10That's true.
- 44:11- I see it explicitly quite often
- 44:14with mushroom-based products.
- 44:15- Yeah, yeah.
- 44:17And so as a scientist,
- 44:20I want to see the evidence
- 44:23and these are unregulated products.
- 44:27Buying these products, you don't really know
- 44:29what you're consuming.
- 44:31The consumer has few, if any, rights in this area
- 44:36of alternative medicine.
- 44:41And any attorneys that are interested
- 44:44in hiring me as an expert witness,
- 44:48I'd be delighted to engage in, delighted to consult with you
- 44:53on some of the avenues for litigation within this industry.
- 45:00- Again, that's another topic.
- 45:02- And a hot topic in Canada, but let's leave that aside.
- 45:05It is fully far beyond the scope
- 45:07of what I did have you on here for,
- 45:09but I do appreciate hearing that sort of like vignette
- 45:12into your perspective.
- 45:13So in the paper that got me excited
- 45:18about having you on the show,
- 45:20you proposed that fungi may have consciousness
- 45:25and hyphae in particular may themselves be conscious
- 45:29if I read that right.
- 45:30And I want to get your perspective on how and why,
- 45:34but first maybe we can,
- 45:37I could get some working definitions
- 45:40for conscious and consciousness because I could say that
- 45:44and I could say that word and some people could be thinking
- 45:47about like, oh yeah, the awareness that emerges
- 45:51as a consequence of brain functioning
- 45:54as a random happenstance of material evolution
- 45:56and other people could hear that and think like, oh yeah,
- 45:58the divine force of creativity that moves through our life
- 46:01and manifest in human awareness, same word, right?
- 46:04So maybe you could give us the definitions
- 46:08you're working with when you use terms
- 46:11like conscious and consciousness.
- 46:13- Everything hinges on language in this discussion.
- 46:19Rather than defining consciousness,
- 46:26I think what I point to or I do point to the fact
- 46:29that it's almost impossible to define consciousness
- 46:33in a way that it becomes a privileged characteristic
- 46:40of organisms like ourselves that nobody would,
- 46:46we know we're cogito ergo sum,
- 46:51I think therefore I am.
- 46:55It's impossible to when we look at consciousness in nature
- 47:00to actually find any sharp dividing line
- 47:04between organisms like ourselves
- 47:06that we would regard as conscious
- 47:08on those that we regard as unconscious
- 47:11or lacking consciousness.
- 47:14So if you go back to, if we go back in our time machine
- 47:18to the 17th century, we were regarded,
- 47:22the philosophers including Descartes,
- 47:25we were regarded as the only conscious organisms.
- 47:29Other organisms, well in his view other organisms
- 47:32were almost beneath contempt
- 47:37when it came to their sensitivity
- 47:40and their capacity for suffering,
- 47:42going back to that earlier theme.
- 47:45But we have a much more sophisticated view,
- 47:48animal behaviorists, ethologists
- 47:50have a much more sophisticated view of animal behavior now.
- 47:54And we see versions of consciousness as we look,
- 47:57I'm sort of going back here,
- 47:58not looking at organisms that maybe most people
- 48:01would regard as simpler.
- 48:03So we indeed, many ethologists would say
- 48:07that all brained animals are consciousness.
- 48:10I think that I'm part of a movement
- 48:14and there's many other philosophers and psychologists
- 48:19and some biologists that have looked at this issue
- 48:22of consciousness and said that,
- 48:25hey, I got a thumb up again.
- 48:26Maybe it's my, I'm doing a Trump there, aren't I?
- 48:30I got to know that anti-diluvian thumbs up, right?
- 48:34Nobody's thumbs up, come on, 21st century.
- 48:37Now I'm getting distracted.
- 48:40Somebody on the internet is agreeing with me
- 48:45or the internet.
- 48:47- Okay, fun, tunnel vision, tunnel vision.
- 48:50- Being with me, thank you.
- 48:52- Thank you so much.
- 48:53If we look back in, if we look at cells, for example,
- 48:58individual cells, we find perhaps
- 49:01versions of consciousness there.
- 49:03We can certainly find, what?
- 49:08Versions of consciousness in non-brained animals.
- 49:12So we could talk about that.
- 49:13And I'm taking it back and looking at individual,
- 49:16the individual cells of fungi and saying,
- 49:19based upon this more liberal definition of consciousness,
- 49:23which really is difficult to separate from what?
- 49:26Sensitivity, sensitivity to one's surroundings,
- 49:29responsiveness to one's surroundings.
- 49:32We see this throughout nature.
- 49:34And Arthur Reber is the psychologist that's responsible
- 49:39for the original idea here, which is that consciousness
- 49:43was really birthed with the origin of life,
- 49:46with the origin of the first cells.
- 49:48Because we see sensitivity there.
- 49:51There's a good reason for this,
- 49:53because a lack of sensitivity is, you know,
- 49:55you're not gonna survive without being sensitive
- 49:57to your surroundings.
- 49:59But it's rather than trying to define consciousness.
- 50:02It's recognizing that it's very, very difficult
- 50:04to sort of set sort of a threshold for consciousness
- 50:09in nature.
- 50:10I've become really interested in,
- 50:12well, I should get a model of that too,
- 50:13I could bring it over.
- 50:14Become very interested in Hydra or Hydras.
- 50:18These are very simple animals that are related to jellyfish
- 50:23and they live in freshwater ponds all over the globe.
- 50:28They're actually, I find them surprisingly difficult
- 50:30to collect, but that's one of the reasons I spend so much
- 50:32of my time splashing around in ponds.
- 50:35But they're absolutely beautiful organisms.
- 50:38They're like jellyfish with the hand movement.
- 50:40Again, they've got tentacles that spring up
- 50:44or that they extend from their tubular bodies.
- 50:49They're about a millimeter or so in length.
- 50:52They don't have brains, but they got a nervous system.
- 50:55They're extremely responsive to their environment, you know,
- 50:58hot and cold temperatures, the presence of other organisms.
- 51:03There's even, there have even been reports
- 51:06that they suffer from depression,
- 51:07which is just mind boggling.
- 51:10I found this absolutely fascinating.
- 51:12When you take Hydras, sometimes when they're taken
- 51:15from a natural setting, a pond,
- 51:18and they're put in the lab in a glass container,
- 51:21there's a phenomenon that was described
- 51:23in the 1970s or '80s, I think,
- 51:27first by a couple of Indian scientists
- 51:30where the Hydras actually retract their tentacles.
- 51:33They quit feeding.
- 51:35And in some cases, they'll even starve themselves to death.
- 51:40If you transport them, if you transfer them to a container
- 51:44that has other Hydras that are already habituated
- 51:47to life in the lab, they almost immediately extend
- 51:50their tentacles and start feeding.
- 51:53I mean, when I read these papers,
- 51:55I was so struck by the similarities there
- 51:58between the behavior of these non-brained animals
- 52:01and what happens to,
- 52:02I don't know whether you've ever seen the movie "Blackfish,"
- 52:07but about killer whales that are brought into captivity
- 52:10in marine parks.
- 52:14And they have to be force-fed when they're collected
- 52:16from when they're taken from the wild
- 52:19and put in essentially fish tanks.
- 52:21They have to be force-fed.
- 52:23They'll starve themselves to death.
- 52:25They're depressed.
- 52:26They've got huge brains.
- 52:28Probably they're much smarter than us.
- 52:31Hydras don't have brains and they do the same thing.
- 52:34So there's a very long-winded explanation here
- 52:36of how I think we find evidence of consciousness
- 52:40right through nature, including the fungi.
- 52:44And that's what this essay that was published
- 52:48in the journal "Fungal Biology,"
- 52:50that was its claim then,
- 52:53that we find perhaps simple versions of what?
- 52:58Even a mind in the fungi.
- 53:01And that doesn't mean that they're thinking
- 53:02and feeling like us,
- 53:06but I see this throughout nature
- 53:07and the fungi are part of this too.
- 53:10So I'm sorry for that very long-winded explanation.
- 53:13- No, no, no, it was good.
- 53:14- It doesn't provide a definition of consciousness.
- 53:17You know, we might swear consciousness,
- 53:20you've got to be able to look at a sense,
- 53:23sense and smile.
- 53:24So a hydra and a fungus aren't going to do that.
- 53:27- Well, we can't send a fungus to the Turing test.
- 53:30- The hydra will respond to the sunrise though.
- 53:34I mean, absolutely, they'll move position in there.
- 53:37If you keep them in a little aquarium,
- 53:39they'll move towards the light.
- 53:40I mean, they're responsive.
- 53:44I mean, they're whole-
- 53:44- So if I get this right,
- 53:46you're saying that we can see
- 53:51something's consciousness being expressed,
- 53:58not trying to define what it is,
- 54:00but we can see it being expressed
- 54:02through its sensitivity and responsiveness
- 54:05to its environment.
- 54:07Is that right?
- 54:07Or what did I get wrong there?
- 54:09- I think that's, yes,
- 54:10that's, I would agree with that statement
- 54:14that it is evident in that response.
- 54:17I mean, if you, I mentioned, didn't I,
- 54:20measuring pressure from fungal hyphae
- 54:23from these individual cells,
- 54:25putting a needle into the cell,
- 54:27the cell doesn't react to that passively.
- 54:29It actually responds to that in a very negative fashion
- 54:32by actually trying to seal the,
- 54:34I mean, it's being punctured.
- 54:36And there's a response on,
- 54:37you can see this actually under the microscope,
- 54:39that the cell is actually responding
- 54:41by sending down these little membrane-bound,
- 54:44we call them vesicles,
- 54:46membrane-bound structures to the site of injury.
- 54:49You see this in individual cells.
- 54:51If you take an individual cell,
- 54:53like take a blood sample
- 54:57and actually look at some of the white blood cells
- 54:59that actually crawl around in an amoeboid fashion,
- 55:02you'll see that same kind of sensitivity in those cells.
- 55:05If you start poking them with a needle
- 55:06or expose them to some noxious chemicals.
- 55:11And so I think we see the origins
- 55:13of sensitivity and consciousness
- 55:16in the simplest unit of biology,
- 55:19which is indeed a single cell.
- 55:23The syncs, yeah, right.
- 55:25So organisms of cells, one or more cells.
- 55:28Support for this podcast comes from you,
- 55:31the listeners via patreon.com/jameswjesso.
- 55:35If you're finding value in the show or entertainment
- 55:40or even just a kind of engagement
- 55:43that gets you through the day from time to time,
- 55:45I invite you to please head over to patreon.com/jameswjesso
- 55:50and become a patron of the podcast here.
- 55:52You can do so for as little as a cup of coffee,
- 55:55once a month and everything is something.
- 55:57And it all collectively adds in to me being able
- 55:59to earn an income producing this podcast
- 56:02because this podcast is my job.
- 56:05This is how I earn an income.
- 56:06And it's something I love to do.
- 56:08It's something that I love to do
- 56:09because it gives me an opportunity
- 56:12to not only just read about and explore
- 56:14and wonder about interesting things,
- 56:16but to then do so with the explicit knowledge
- 56:20that I get to then talk about these things
- 56:22that I find interesting with the people that wrote them
- 56:26in a way that's not just for me,
- 56:28in a way that sort of helps to showcase
- 56:31how interesting or inspiring or positive
- 56:33I find these things to be to listeners
- 56:36who share those interests.
- 56:38So it's this beautiful opportunity I have
- 56:41to do something that I love in a way
- 56:43that I get to benefit from because I love doing it
- 56:45and that I get to feel as though I'm contributing
- 56:48to something positive in the lives of others.
- 56:52And I get to do so as a fully independent creator,
- 56:55which also feels really beautiful.
- 56:59With that said, with my gratitude alive in this moment,
- 57:02thank you to the people who are my patrons on Patreon,
- 57:05especially the people whose names are listed
- 57:07in the screen here on YouTube
- 57:08or in the description to this episode,
- 57:10wherever you're checking it out.
- 57:12These are people who give significantly,
- 57:13some of which for a really long time.
- 57:16So the credits are an extra thank you for that.
- 57:19So again, please do become a patron
- 57:20if you're finding value in the show.
- 57:22And if you don't have money right now
- 57:25to contribute to the show,
- 57:27then just listen to it for free.
- 57:29Don't worry about it, enjoy.
- 57:31There are people who give financially
- 57:34so that people who cannot can still enjoy the podcast.
- 57:37So everybody gets a podcast and I get to earn a living.
- 57:41It's a win-win.
- 57:43And so thank you in advance for becoming a patron.
- 57:45And if you do, be mindful not to do it
- 57:48through the Apple App Store because Apple
- 57:51is gonna take 30%.
- 57:52They're either gonna charge you 30% on top of your pledge
- 57:55or they're gonna take 30% from your pledge,
- 57:57which only Apple is doing and it's an Apple thing.
- 58:00Apple takes that money.
- 58:02So you can just head to patreon.com/jameswjesso
- 58:06on a regular web browser and sign up there.
- 58:08And you'll still have all the benefits of using the app
- 58:11on your iPhone or your iPad if you want,
- 58:14but you won't have to pay the 30%.
- 58:15And I encourage you to do so 'cause I don't know.
- 58:18I just felt like that was kind of a shitty move
- 58:20on their end.
- 58:21So I don't recommend they deserve your 30% every month
- 58:24on whatever pledge you offer.
- 58:26And that's it, thank you.
- 58:28And now back to the interview.
- 58:29You said you're a part of, I think you said something
- 58:34around the phrase, something like a wave
- 58:37or a movement of scientists embracing this sort
- 58:40of different view on unconsciousness.
- 58:44Are there by your observation, any implicit biases
- 58:49in, well, to say science writ large,
- 58:53but whatever domain of science you're most familiar with
- 58:56as a member of the community of scientists,
- 58:59any of these implicit biases that you feel being
- 59:03about consciousness or intelligence that obscure
- 59:06our ability to recognize these things in non-human
- 59:11or non-animal organisms?
- 59:14- Great question.
- 59:14So you absolutely among other scientists,
- 59:17this is, but politically too,
- 59:20I mean, that actually does go back in full circle.
- 59:22We're brilliant, too brilliant on your part.
- 59:25If you stimulated these questions, we were talking about,
- 59:28I mentioned sort of industrial agriculture, didn't I?
- 59:31When we started chatting on animal suffering,
- 59:34yeah, there's a huge investment and among scientists
- 59:38in terms of vivisection, animal experimentation.
- 59:42We have a huge investment in actually not regarding
- 59:46other animals as what, as sentient.
- 59:50That because we do this for commercial
- 59:55and for medical purposes, we're torturing animals
- 59:58and then producing meat on an industrial scale.
- 1:00:03Yeah, if we recognized how smart the rest
- 1:00:05of nature really is, nothing like as smart as us, of course.
- 1:00:11We're clearly the pinnacle of evolution.
- 1:00:14We're God's singular creation.
- 1:00:17So the other religious viewpoint here too, again,
- 1:00:22positioning ourselves as separate from the rest of nature.
- 1:00:25And it does go back to sort of what you were saying
- 1:00:27about your more optimistic view of the future,
- 1:00:30our future, is the crucial part of recognizing
- 1:00:35that we're not above the rest of nature,
- 1:00:38that we're part of it.
- 1:00:39Such a simple message.
- 1:00:41It was something that, I mean, it never even occurred to me
- 1:00:43that we were really particularly brilliant
- 1:00:46when I was a child, but obviously others are much smarter
- 1:00:48than me and they saw this, but yeah, what?
- 1:00:51I've forgotten what the question is.
- 1:00:58I'm just, I'm thinking back, I'm British in origin
- 1:01:02and I went to a church of England school as a kid
- 1:01:05through, you know, before I went to college
- 1:01:08and yeah, I never took any of the religious messages
- 1:01:13or the messages about the superiority of humans
- 1:01:17that we want, certainly the superiority of the English,
- 1:01:22in particular, white Anglo-Saxon males.
- 1:01:27I mean, I always, you know, these were maybe
- 1:01:29strange metaphors, but I never took them seriously
- 1:01:32as truths.
- 1:01:35Yeah, I've always-
- 1:01:37- Certainly they were, ended up being deadly serious
- 1:01:41with respect to impact.
- 1:01:43Yeah.
- 1:01:44- Absolutely.
- 1:01:45And that's what we've done.
- 1:01:48I mean, I live close to Cincinnati
- 1:01:51and we've got a fantastic zoo, the Cincinnati Zoo
- 1:01:54and Botanical Gardens.
- 1:01:57And I get very frustrated that when I see parents
- 1:02:01and they have some captive primates there,
- 1:02:06including great apes and the way that,
- 1:02:08I mean, I see children sort of making your parents,
- 1:02:11making mirth of the activities of these primates.
- 1:02:13And I'm thinking, well, does it,
- 1:02:17is it really not much of a leap of imagination
- 1:02:21to see ourselves when you look into the eyes
- 1:02:23of some, you know, poor captive animal?
- 1:02:27- If anything, I say it requires quite a great,
- 1:02:33quite a great leap of assumption and arrogance
- 1:02:37to not see ourselves in the eyes of these animals.
- 1:02:40- Absolutely.
- 1:02:41I agree with that completely.
- 1:02:42Arrogance is a great word.
- 1:02:44Yeah.
- 1:02:45Solipsism, egotism, narcissism.
- 1:02:49Yeah, absolutely.
- 1:02:50- I mean, not necessarily intentional
- 1:02:52on behalf of most of us that do it.
- 1:02:54Of course, you know, we're brought up to believe that
- 1:02:56as much as we, you know, might otherwise intend
- 1:03:00or desire to be different.
- 1:03:02We don't always know that there's another way
- 1:03:04of looking at the world because the confinement
- 1:03:08of the paradigms that we have been brought up in.
- 1:03:11- No, I find that really, I find it surprising.
- 1:03:15I'm, I think about,
- 1:03:20turn off my, excuse me,
- 1:03:25turn the ringer off my phone there.
- 1:03:27You know, I think about what Shakespearean,
- 1:03:30Shakespearean England and the way that bear baiting
- 1:03:35and badger baiting and other kinds of, you know,
- 1:03:39ritualistic maltreatment killings of smart animals.
- 1:03:44You know, this was entertainment.
- 1:03:47Of course, you go back to Rome.
- 1:03:50Or I just don't know why it's taken us so long
- 1:03:54to begin to recognize this.
- 1:03:57Why were we ever in such denial?
- 1:04:00- From an evolutionary standpoint, you know,
- 1:04:04the whatever 10,000 years, you know,
- 1:04:08you just mentioned Rome, that was only what, 2,000 years ago?
- 1:04:11It's 3,000, something to this effect?
- 1:04:13- Yeah, higher, yeah.
- 1:04:14- So like, I mean, from a geological evolutionary timeframe,
- 1:04:18I mean, it hasn't taken us that long.
- 1:04:20- You're right.
- 1:04:21You're right.
- 1:04:22We got there and that's the great irony.
- 1:04:24We finally figure things out as we exit,
- 1:04:27we bring things out.
- 1:04:30I think a lot about, I'm not gonna solve this,
- 1:04:32but nobody else has.
- 1:04:35They're thinking about the origin of life,
- 1:04:37but there's some really interesting science going on
- 1:04:40in studies on life's origins.
- 1:04:43And when I read these papers, I think,
- 1:04:45well, could they be edging closer to the truth?
- 1:04:47And there is the irony of finally understanding
- 1:04:50what happened on this 4.6 billion year old planet?
- 1:04:54How did life get a start here?
- 1:04:57You know, just as we're actually destroying the human
- 1:04:59form of life that gets to actually figure this out.
- 1:05:05Anyway.
- 1:05:06- Well, if Dr. Bruce Dahmer's theories are similar,
- 1:05:10had to do with the emergence of these multicellular
- 1:05:14organisms out of the drying, hydrating,
- 1:05:17and redrying over and over again of like small ponds
- 1:05:21or like bodies of water.
- 1:05:23I mean, maybe we're coming into a knowledge
- 1:05:28about the beginning as we start to cycle back
- 1:05:30as a larger organism of planet earth to a drying out
- 1:05:34of the flourishing of life before the next rehydrating
- 1:05:37to the next iteration of life on this planet.
- 1:05:40I mean, again, I personally, you know,
- 1:05:43I would like to see some incredibly positive changes
- 1:05:46in humanity's relationship to the living world
- 1:05:49such that we could make a, we could turn this bus,
- 1:05:52you know, like we could take a wider angle towards the cliff
- 1:05:57than the 90 degree, like the straight ahead one
- 1:05:59that we got now.
- 1:06:00So I would like to see that.
- 1:06:03And also, I mean, even if we don't,
- 1:06:05life continues, will continue.
- 1:06:08- Yeah.
- 1:06:11- So let's get back to Fonjay.
- 1:06:12- Yeah, get back to Fonjay.
- 1:06:14So you've given us a sense of, you know,
- 1:06:18consciousness is in every living creature, cellular,
- 1:06:23all the way up to multicellular and so forth,
- 1:06:27some expression of some kind of consciousness.
- 1:06:30And in, and it has to do with sensitivity
- 1:06:35and responsiveness to environment,
- 1:06:37expressed through various means of behavior,
- 1:06:40which my sort of inter injection here
- 1:06:44so that it requires some form of perception.
- 1:06:46And you present in this paper,
- 1:06:50that I don't remember the name of now, what was the name?
- 1:06:54Oh, Hypho and mycelial consciousness.
- 1:06:58I think that's what it was called.
- 1:06:59You propose Fonjay Hyphae in particular as being conscious.
- 1:07:06Can you give us some examples of what it is
- 1:07:09about Hyphae, I hope I'm saying that right,
- 1:07:12behavior that you observe as being
- 1:07:15sort of expressions of consciousness behaviors?
- 1:07:20- Yeah, sure.
- 1:07:21I mean, because they're, I mean,
- 1:07:25they're not mobile cells in the sense
- 1:07:27that they move from one place to another like an amoeba,
- 1:07:30but they, as we discussed a few minutes ago,
- 1:07:35they extended their tips and they produced these
- 1:07:39larger colonies or mycelia,
- 1:07:41they extended their tips and branch.
- 1:07:44But as they're doing that,
- 1:07:45they're acting in an exquisitely sensitive fashion
- 1:07:50to their surroundings,
- 1:07:52such that if the tip of a Hyphae,
- 1:07:55if the tip of one of these cells actually touches a solid,
- 1:07:59it will make a decision about whether to grow above it
- 1:08:07or around it or to keep pushing
- 1:08:09and try and actually penetrate that structure.
- 1:08:12But you can see this cellular sensitivity
- 1:08:16in the responsiveness of those individual Hyphae tips
- 1:08:21as they're exploring their environment.
- 1:08:24They're also, their sensitivity is also expressed
- 1:08:28at the biochemical level in terms of the changes
- 1:08:31in the material, the enzymes that they're releasing
- 1:08:35as they're growing on different food sources,
- 1:08:40different materials.
- 1:08:42And so it really is this,
- 1:08:44and also the way then the three dimensional structure
- 1:08:47of the mycelium emerges.
- 1:08:51And each time this is a totally unique structure
- 1:08:55because of the decision making that's actually gone on
- 1:08:58at those Hyphae tips and about the determination
- 1:09:01of the timing when they branch.
- 1:09:04And then when those branches form other branches.
- 1:09:08And so that's the,
- 1:09:09its consciousness in those terms,
- 1:09:13in terms of the sensitivity of the cell
- 1:09:15to its surroundings and its interactions
- 1:09:19with its surroundings.
- 1:09:21And we see this in all cells,
- 1:09:25but in the paper that I wrote then,
- 1:09:27I was looking at the,
- 1:09:29what, the fungal manifestation of this kind of sensitivity.
- 1:09:34There are also examples of learning within mycelia.
- 1:09:39For example, experiments in which fungi
- 1:09:43given different food sources treated in different ways.
- 1:09:46And we see some evidence of sort of these
- 1:09:49conditioned responses to their environment.
- 1:09:52So again, they're not growing in a,
- 1:09:55they are growing in a mindless fashion.
- 1:09:56They don't have a mind in the form of a brain
- 1:10:01as fabulous as ours.
- 1:10:03But nevertheless, they're engaging in individual behavior.
- 1:10:06They're responding to their environment
- 1:10:09with this exquisite level of sensitivity
- 1:10:13that we can observe in the lab.
- 1:10:16That's the basic argument.
- 1:10:21- So what I hear you describing
- 1:10:23is these individual Hyphae,
- 1:10:25they have, as a part of this larger organism,
- 1:10:28they have the ability to perceive something,
- 1:10:33make a decision around sort of like making a decision
- 1:10:38to change and alter its behavior.
- 1:10:41And even in the midst that is the possibility of learning
- 1:10:44and any kind of learning would suggest
- 1:10:46that there's a kind of memory that's unfolding.
- 1:10:49And yet earlier you described,
- 1:10:51if the spores did find their way onto the space shuttle
- 1:10:55out, freeze dried and off riding with Cassini
- 1:11:00or whatever it is, offwards beyond the soul system,
- 1:11:05but you described it as not being with intent.
- 1:11:10So what is it like if these creatures,
- 1:11:13this organism has a kind of consciousness
- 1:11:16that includes perception and decisive response
- 1:11:20that alters behavior in a context of learning
- 1:11:23and even memory, why is it that intent
- 1:11:25can't be a part of that equation?
- 1:11:28- I suppose that gets to the problem with intent
- 1:11:35in that do we even have intent?
- 1:11:39So decision-making appears,
- 1:11:46there are experiments that shows this with us,
- 1:11:52that we actually, our brain is simplifying it,
- 1:11:54that we're making decisions long before we're conscious
- 1:11:57of doing so.
- 1:11:58That if you're, I don't know,
- 1:12:02you're running through the woods
- 1:12:04and the water in the creek has risen a bit
- 1:12:09and you can see some rocks that you can jump on.
- 1:12:14Subconsciously, you're actually working out
- 1:12:17where you, which rock you're gonna jump on
- 1:12:19first and second before you're conscious of saying,
- 1:12:23yeah, I'm gonna go to that big one there
- 1:12:25and then this little one and then I'm gonna see
- 1:12:26if I can get to that log.
- 1:12:28That I suppose it gets to the idea that,
- 1:12:33we don't have free will either,
- 1:12:35it's just that we've got a very complicated nervous systems
- 1:12:40that give us the impression of free will.
- 1:12:45Now we've gone to free will, where do we start with this?
- 1:12:48- Well, I mean, I guess like I, when I hear intent,
- 1:12:52I don't think free will.
- 1:12:54They're closely related, but intent infers
- 1:12:58that there's a conscious sort of inclination
- 1:13:02in what I'm gonna do.
- 1:13:04So like my perception and decisive response
- 1:13:06is led by some sort of particular direction
- 1:13:10or goal or desire.
- 1:13:13Like I have intent towards that thing.
- 1:13:16Now, whether or not my intent, that desire,
- 1:13:20those goals, its outcome and all of that
- 1:13:23is led by free will, to me, that's a separate discussion.
- 1:13:28- Right, right, right.
- 1:13:30So take me back to the question that we're--
- 1:13:35- So the question was, if these fungi,
- 1:13:39the hyphae have this ability for perception,
- 1:13:42decisive response, learning memory,
- 1:13:44altering behavior based on environmental context, et cetera,
- 1:13:48why is it that you would perceive
- 1:13:50as though they don't have intent?
- 1:13:52Now, maybe a remapping of what intent means
- 1:13:55changes, you know, I would say there,
- 1:13:57but yeah, do you still feel like they don't have capacity
- 1:14:00for intent with this new definition?
- 1:14:01- No, I think, well, I would suggest
- 1:14:04that it's a matter of scale, you know, that we've got
- 1:14:13our information processing system is a lot more complicated
- 1:14:18than a mycelium, but nevertheless, we're, what?
- 1:14:24Do we have intent any more than a fungal mycelium?
- 1:14:33Perhaps not.
- 1:14:34When we make decisions, I mean fungal hyphae and fungal
- 1:14:42mycelium, lots of branch hyphae,
- 1:14:45they go through a decision-making process.
- 1:14:47We'll do that too, and we would have poured ourselves,
- 1:14:54you know, greater intelligence than a fungal mycelium
- 1:14:57when we decide what to eat for dinner
- 1:14:59or what to pick out in a grocery store,
- 1:15:03but in the end, it's all the same stuff.
- 1:15:06Just lots more of it.
- 1:15:09I'm not sure that's a good answer,
- 1:15:12'cause I'm not sure what question I'm opposing myself.
- 1:15:16- No, this is good.
- 1:15:17I always appreciate when the interviews get to the edge
- 1:15:20of what is knowable, like when we get to a place
- 1:15:23where the sort of delta of what's possible starts to--
- 1:15:26- But fundamentally, fundamentally,
- 1:15:29everything has to come down to the cellular activity
- 1:15:34in our brains, and those mechanisms are very, very similar.
- 1:15:40They're the same as those, really, on a basic level.
- 1:15:43They're the same as those on a biochemical level
- 1:15:47to what we see in a fungal mycelium,
- 1:15:51in lots of fungal hyphae,
- 1:15:54taking in information from our surroundings,
- 1:15:57and that decision-making is there,
- 1:16:00and we could regard the fungal mycelium as more robotic,
- 1:16:03but I think we are at base.
- 1:16:05It's just that we're drawing on a lot of information
- 1:16:08and biases and a much greater capacity for memory
- 1:16:13than a fungal mycelium,
- 1:16:15but at base, at a cellular level,
- 1:16:18the difference is probably not, or definitely not.
- 1:16:22I mean, otherwise you've gotta
- 1:16:24posit some kind of quasi off-board memory.
- 1:16:30Anyway, that's starting to sound a bit star-trucky for me,
- 1:16:36but yeah, yeah.
- 1:16:37- And you can't see it, but I literally have
- 1:16:3925 Star Trek books on my bookshelf right here,
- 1:16:41so the listeners of the show might almost roll their eyes
- 1:16:45at how often Star Trek comes up, so you--
- 1:16:47- Yeah, no, I've got a great love for the original
- 1:16:52William Shatner Star Trek, which was a huge part
- 1:16:56of my childhood growing up in Britain.
- 1:16:59- Also an incredible work of social commentary at the time.
- 1:17:04Anyone who's like, "Star Trek is too woke," right now,
- 1:17:07they're like, "Well, obviously you weren't alive
- 1:17:08when it came out because it was pretty,
- 1:17:10pardon me, but pretty fucking woke back then too."
- 1:17:13But let's leave that aside.
- 1:17:15- We got into consciousness in one episode, didn't we,
- 1:17:18with something about a giant amoeba or something.
- 1:17:21Anyway, one of the original Star Trek episodes.
- 1:17:24- Is this the one where it was like
- 1:17:25the silicone-based life form that was killing miners,
- 1:17:30and then they found out that the reason it was doing that
- 1:17:34is because of what they thought was a crystal
- 1:17:36they were mining was actually the eggs of this organism,
- 1:17:40and they had to reconsider the whole mining operation
- 1:17:43because they were basically murdering this other life form
- 1:17:47that was conscious.
- 1:17:48Anyways, Spock mind-mells with it.
- 1:17:51- It was a lot to that original.
- 1:17:53There was a lot that went in there,
- 1:17:54a lot of philosophical work that went into
- 1:17:59the original Star Trek, absolutely.
- 1:18:04And I mean, considering the conundrum
- 1:18:09of how our beliefs or assumptions
- 1:18:14about another organism's level of awareness,
- 1:18:19consciousness, sentience influences our behavior
- 1:18:22or treatment of that organism and/or its environment,
- 1:18:27that's obviously incredibly relevant
- 1:18:29to the conversation we're having here.
- 1:18:32But I wanna shift again back on track with the hyphae,
- 1:18:37and for hyphae, what I understand
- 1:18:41from what you're saying here is that
- 1:18:43it's as though every individual piece,
- 1:18:46every individual hyphae is on its own accord
- 1:18:50making decisions, it's perceiving and making decisions
- 1:18:53about what it's going to do.
- 1:18:57And I assume that's what informs the quote
- 1:19:01I'm about to read from your paper,
- 1:19:03Hyphae and Mycelial Consciousness,
- 1:19:05where you ask, quote,
- 1:19:07"If individual hyphae are conscious,
- 1:19:09"what happens when an interconnected colony or mycelium
- 1:19:13"of thousands of these cells form in the soil?
- 1:19:16"Is a mycelium more than a sum of its parts?
- 1:19:20"Can it be regarded as an integrated conscious entity?"
- 1:19:23End quote.
- 1:19:25So I bring that up 'cause I wanna ask you,
- 1:19:27where is your thinking presently
- 1:19:29on these questions you pose in the paper?
- 1:19:32Like, do you have any answers
- 1:19:36for those questions at this time?
- 1:19:38- So certainly if what I was doing there,
- 1:19:42looking at and saying there in that quote,
- 1:19:45then looking at the sensitivity of individual cells,
- 1:19:48and then when we begin to think about a larger mycelium,
- 1:19:51when we've talked about an interconnected mycelium,
- 1:19:56maybe with as many individual threads as a human brain,
- 1:20:00the decision-making that's occurring
- 1:20:04at the individual hyphal tips at some point
- 1:20:06is actually influenced by what's going on
- 1:20:08elsewhere in the colony.
- 1:20:10So perhaps another part of the colony
- 1:20:12is running out of food.
- 1:20:14And indeed we see examples of this
- 1:20:17where the mycelium decides to actually shuttle resources
- 1:20:22for that area of itself, of the larger organism
- 1:20:27that's actually starving.
- 1:20:28And then in other cases,
- 1:20:29actually just shutting down parts of the mycelium.
- 1:20:33So I think these are all, what?
- 1:20:37I mean, they're really, most of them are philosophical
- 1:20:40rather than scientific questions, frankly.
- 1:20:43The devil is in the details of our use of language.
- 1:20:52But I think given that it's exceedingly difficult
- 1:20:55to actually come up with the definition of consciousness
- 1:20:58that separates brain animals from other organisms,
- 1:21:03I'm just asking for fungi to be a part of this inquiry,
- 1:21:06this area of research,
- 1:21:11that just when we do experiments on fungi
- 1:21:14to actually look at their decision-making activities
- 1:21:18and there's a, why do we treat them as more robotic,
- 1:21:23for example, than a brain animal?
- 1:21:28I don't think there's any philosophical reason
- 1:21:30for doing so.
- 1:21:31- I mean, one thing I often think about is that,
- 1:21:36what animals do we find ourselves most aligned with?
- 1:21:43There are animals that we tend to look at
- 1:21:47and we are more likely to care about that animal's welfare.
- 1:21:51Those are ones that, especially mammals in particular,
- 1:21:55but there are ones that seem to be able to trigger
- 1:21:58our sort of like social connection,
- 1:22:00social engagement system.
- 1:22:02So dogs, they literally evolve,
- 1:22:05we co-evolved with dogs in order for them to like,
- 1:22:08co-evolve slash selectively bred, et cetera,
- 1:22:13for them to be more expressive of their feelings
- 1:22:16such that we can empathize with them better.
- 1:22:18We can see on their face,
- 1:22:19we can relate with their feelings,
- 1:22:20same with higher primates.
- 1:22:23And I mean, there's all sorts of things
- 1:22:27that happen with other animals,
- 1:22:29but then when we look at sort of feedstock animals,
- 1:22:31there's a sort of extra leap required to recognize them
- 1:22:34as animals with feelings and so forth.
- 1:22:37And I think sometimes pigs actually trigger us
- 1:22:39and we're less likely to care about them
- 1:22:41because we see too much of ourselves in their behavior.
- 1:22:45But the point is,
- 1:22:47is like the further we get away from mammals
- 1:22:50and particularly mammals that express
- 1:22:53their limbic expressions,
- 1:22:55manifest as facial expressions that we can look at
- 1:22:58and be sort of have a mirror neurons,
- 1:23:00social engagement system triggered,
- 1:23:02the more of a sort of,
- 1:23:03the more of a leap it takes for us to recognize
- 1:23:07that being as having a legitimate interior world
- 1:23:11that requires our empathy,
- 1:23:13that warrants our empathy, our sympathy,
- 1:23:15our compassion, et cetera.
- 1:23:18So once we get out of the realm of animals,
- 1:23:20we get into the realm of plants and the realm of fungi,
- 1:23:22we're so many steps away that,
- 1:23:25they just fall into the category of,
- 1:23:29like it's an objects that serve my needs and desires
- 1:23:34or impede them rather than as living entities
- 1:23:38that require as much consideration as I would a dog.
- 1:23:42Yeah. - Right.
- 1:23:44No, I agree with that.
- 1:23:45I mean, I even, I spent too much time
- 1:23:50perhaps looking at samples of pond water.
- 1:23:54For example, I'm involved in a new project
- 1:23:57and looking at the amazing sensitivity of amoebas
- 1:24:02and ciliates and so forth and pond water and the,
- 1:24:07I don't know,
- 1:24:10entering the arena of the psychically unwell,
- 1:24:14I start to see the sensitivity
- 1:24:18of these single celled organisms
- 1:24:19and the way that they're trying to escape from the,
- 1:24:23the water's beginning to dry under the cover slip
- 1:24:25and the way that they're trying to escape from this
- 1:24:27and think that every part of their being,
- 1:24:30their make of their biology is structured toward survival.
- 1:24:38And is there, there's a growing sense of guilt
- 1:24:44when I flush them down the sink,
- 1:24:46these are not brained anything,
- 1:24:47but it's what, it's just so beautiful.
- 1:24:52I'm sounding, I'm gonna go into some religious arena
- 1:24:58in later life that I would have avoided when I was young.
- 1:25:03- You would be joining once again,
- 1:25:05a movement of scientists that historically have gone
- 1:25:08so deep into science, so deep into their observations
- 1:25:12that they eventually found God in the amoeba
- 1:25:15or the mathematical equation or the fungi, right?
- 1:25:19- That's right, that's right, I've met, yeah, yeah.
- 1:25:24I have discussions with an older scientist
- 1:25:26that works on the origin of life
- 1:25:30and is a great thinker and he's,
- 1:25:38he struggles with understanding obviously
- 1:25:42'cause we don't know how life evolved.
- 1:25:45He struggles sort of against going
- 1:25:47into a more religious viewpoint
- 1:25:48that there are unknown things in this area of it
- 1:25:53that would solve some of the questions that he poses
- 1:25:56in this area of inquiry,
- 1:25:58but it's not really scientific anymore
- 1:26:00and so he struggles with that
- 1:26:02and hey, maybe that's my fight too, yeah.
- 1:26:06- Well, I suppose once, maybe once the requirements
- 1:26:10for funding, once the requirements for funding
- 1:26:14are no longer relevant, it's time to start stepping
- 1:26:16into the religious realm in your outgoing work
- 1:26:21as a scientist or something or like just gets, I don't know,
- 1:26:25so tenured that you could basically say
- 1:26:27almost anything you want.
- 1:26:28So all right, now that we're on the sort of the hyphy tip
- 1:26:35of the hyphy tip is now pushing up against the solid mass
- 1:26:39that is the potential of religion.
- 1:26:42Do we push through or do we reallocate
- 1:26:44our resources elsewhere?
- 1:26:46I'm gonna ask you this following question
- 1:26:49and I'm gonna read it right off as I wrote it
- 1:26:52'cause I feel like it's a bigger question
- 1:26:54so it might be hard for me to hold together.
- 1:26:57Might be hard to hear now that if I read it out loud
- 1:26:59for the first time, so I'll have to forgive me for that too.
- 1:27:02- All right, good for 'em.
- 1:27:04So this is a podcast that explores topics
- 1:27:06that at least loosely are connected
- 1:27:09to psychedelic medicine culture or research.
- 1:27:12And given the growing body of both empirical
- 1:27:15and anecdotal evidence for profound,
- 1:27:18even so-called mystical type experiences
- 1:27:21under the influence of psilocybin,
- 1:27:23which is a fungi metabolite,
- 1:27:25beyond the material alone,
- 1:27:29as so as beyond sort of what's happening in the brain,
- 1:27:33can you speculate on what, if any,
- 1:27:38involvement a so-called fungal mind might play
- 1:27:41in what we humans encounter under the effects of psilocybin?
- 1:27:44- I don't, I think you'd need to
- 1:27:50explain that a little more fully.
- 1:27:57I'm not quite sure what you're asking there.
- 1:28:00Yeah, I mean, great, slightly disorienting
- 1:28:03was a bit of the goal, but I'll bring it in slightly.
- 1:28:08'Cause the reason I'm asking is because,
- 1:28:10so we'll say fungi have some kind of mind, okay?
- 1:28:17- Okay.
- 1:28:18- And this fungi has some kind of mind,
- 1:28:21and part of what any organism does is it is a response
- 1:28:26to its environment, to its survival needs
- 1:28:27and so on and so forth.
- 1:28:29And so any particular metabolite,
- 1:28:32an ant creature has from particular fungi,
- 1:28:35I assume is not accidental.
- 1:28:37It plays some sort of role in the mind of this fungi.
- 1:28:41I'm not saying that psilocybin facilitates
- 1:28:43its consciousness or anything.
- 1:28:44I just mean as a metabolite of fungi,
- 1:28:48it is an expression of this organism that is fungi,
- 1:28:52this mushroom species, right?
- 1:28:55I know it's in a cicada fungi and some other stuff,
- 1:28:57but simplifying it down to just mushrooms.
- 1:29:01So my question is, we consume this metabolite,
- 1:29:05this fungi metabolite,
- 1:29:07and we have these kinds of experiences.
- 1:29:09And there's a very material way to describe this,
- 1:29:12which is, well, it just so happens that this metabolite
- 1:29:17is close enough to this brain chemical that we have,
- 1:29:21such that it creates these changes in the neural firing
- 1:29:27function that creates these changes
- 1:29:30in our subjective experience.
- 1:29:32Check mark, done.
- 1:29:35But beyond that expression,
- 1:29:37that sort of description alone,
- 1:29:40do you feel like there's any involvement there
- 1:29:44between any relationship between this fungal mind
- 1:29:49of this organism that produced this metabolite
- 1:29:53and what humans encounter when they're under the effects,
- 1:29:56the subjective effects of this metabolite?
- 1:29:58- I guess if I understand your question,
- 1:30:03that my answer would be no,
- 1:30:08in the sense that fungi really don't have any,
- 1:30:13the only relationship that fungi have formed with us
- 1:30:20as a species comes through one way or another.
- 1:30:26It comes through what comes through the intimate interactions
- 1:30:29between fungi that live on the human body, on our skin.
- 1:30:34And this is a lot of what I write about in the new book,
- 1:30:38the fungi that grow in our guts,
- 1:30:39the fungi that grow throughout the body.
- 1:30:42Fungi play a far more profound role in human health
- 1:30:47than we've recognized until quite recently,
- 1:30:51and that's because of scientific advances.
- 1:30:55We can really look at the fungi.
- 1:30:57We can look at fungal genetics in a way that we couldn't,
- 1:30:59the genetics of these organisms
- 1:31:00in a way that we couldn't previously.
- 1:31:03But having said that,
- 1:31:05compounds like psilocybin,
- 1:31:12or the pathways that produce these compounds evolved
- 1:31:16long, long before humans were around.
- 1:31:21And so I regard interactions between our,
- 1:31:26not that I've had them personally, we can talk about that,
- 1:31:31but our profound interactions that we experience
- 1:31:36is that we have after consuming psilocybin,
- 1:31:41converted into silosine,
- 1:31:43and then interacts with our serotonin receptors,
- 1:31:47some of them.
- 1:31:51I think it's just part of the noise of nature.
- 1:31:54However, those compounds did evolve,
- 1:31:59I would hazard a guess.
- 1:32:03They evolved with, I'm being very anthropomorphic here,
- 1:32:06the specific intent to interact
- 1:32:08with animal nervous systems,
- 1:32:10because we share,
- 1:32:15and our nervous systems share commonalities
- 1:32:20that we see with,
- 1:32:21commonalities with nervous systems
- 1:32:23throughout the animal kingdom.
- 1:32:25And so if psilocybin,
- 1:32:27or the production of psilocybin evolved,
- 1:32:30for example, as an anti-feedent,
- 1:32:32I'm not putting forth that idea now,
- 1:32:36something that changed the behavior of animals
- 1:32:39that were damaging these fruit bodies.
- 1:32:44The fact that they have a profound effect
- 1:32:49upon our experience,
- 1:32:51our cognitive experience,
- 1:32:53I think is, my guess is,
- 1:32:55my feeling is this is just part of the noise of nature.
- 1:32:58We've arrived too recently
- 1:33:00to have affected the biochemical evolution
- 1:33:02of these fungi,
- 1:33:05of the mushroom-forming fungi,
- 1:33:06and then also you mentioned
- 1:33:08these psychoactive compounds produced in the fungi
- 1:33:12that infect cicadas and so forth.
- 1:33:15So I think actually we see a lot of this
- 1:33:17in terms of the,
- 1:33:19also the poisons that fungi produce,
- 1:33:22that they evolved for their effect upon,
- 1:33:26anti-feedent effects upon invertebrates,
- 1:33:31principally insects.
- 1:33:34I think that that's probably why pathways
- 1:33:38for the production of psilocybin
- 1:33:39and other compounds that are actually a psychoactive
- 1:33:42when they're introduced into our nervous systems.
- 1:33:47Yeah, they were there for the insects, not for us.
- 1:33:50And that's not obviously a universally held opinion,
- 1:33:52but that's my gut instinct,
- 1:33:56is that we're actually being too narcissistic
- 1:34:00if we think that these ancient pathways
- 1:34:03evolved in a fashion to,
- 1:34:05in any sense, deliberately affect human behavior.
- 1:34:10I think they're made for insects.
- 1:34:13That's my guess.
- 1:34:14But there are other,
- 1:34:15you'll find other professional mycologists
- 1:34:18that will disagree with that point of view
- 1:34:20and think that they really did evolve
- 1:34:23for some other purpose.
- 1:34:25But that's kind of where I'm at.
- 1:34:28- I suppose like.
- 1:34:30- Incidentally, where I'm sitting now,
- 1:34:32I could have gotten fired years ago.
- 1:34:35The desk drawer over here,
- 1:34:37I had a student that I loved, a young man.
- 1:34:39And when he graduated, he said,
- 1:34:41"I've got a gift for you, Professor Muddy."
- 1:34:44And he brought me a baggie of Cubensis, I suppose.
- 1:34:49He said, "We could take these together
- 1:34:53with these woods behind the building where I work."
- 1:34:57We got on very well, but that was a bridge too far.
- 1:35:01And I kept them in that drawer for a very long time
- 1:35:04before I woke up one night and thought,
- 1:35:06oh crap, in this conservative environment
- 1:35:10that covers my salary and benefits,
- 1:35:13I better lose those before they find them.
- 1:35:15There was actually a professor that got into a lot of trouble
- 1:35:18that had other psychoactive materials
- 1:35:20that were part of his research actually.
- 1:35:23But in any case, so where am I going?
- 1:35:25So I've actually never had that experience.
- 1:35:27And part of the reason for that is at least,
- 1:35:28especially when I was younger,
- 1:35:30my dreams were so rich and hallucinatory and lucid
- 1:35:35that I always thought if I introduced
- 1:35:37any further stimulant to that,
- 1:35:40that I'd be entering the arena of the unwell.
- 1:35:44So I've never done it.
- 1:35:46- Well, I'll tell you why.
- 1:35:47- But honestly, my dreams have been so crazy,
- 1:35:51especially when I was younger, less so now.
- 1:35:54- Well, I'll tell you.
- 1:35:55- So my experience is limited, that's my short answer.
- 1:35:58- So I'm gonna say a couple of things.
- 1:36:00One, obviously you may have noticed a lack of letters
- 1:36:04at the end of my name.
- 1:36:05So my level of authority here is minimal.
- 1:36:10With respect to the sort of the things I'm about to say,
- 1:36:12which is that, well, can you hear that over the?
- 1:36:17- Yes, it's like a.
- 1:36:19- Oh yeah, it just hit big out there, okay.
- 1:36:22- Yeah, I heard that.
- 1:36:24- Anyway, so.
- 1:36:25- The gods are telling us something here.
- 1:36:28I don't know why, but.
- 1:36:29- Time to pay attention.
- 1:36:31That past mid 30s or so,
- 1:36:36if one has a propensity towards having a psychotic episode
- 1:36:41as triggered by the consumption of a substance,
- 1:36:44if you make it out of your 30s without that,
- 1:36:47the likelihood of it being triggered in later life
- 1:36:49is quite minimal.
- 1:36:52- Yeah.
- 1:36:53- Not zero, but quite minimal.
- 1:36:54So something to hang on.
- 1:36:56And the other thing is,
- 1:36:58from the perspective of the waters
- 1:37:01and how turbulent they can or cannot be
- 1:37:03in certain domains of science,
- 1:37:05leaning into the sort of insecticide perspective
- 1:37:10is definitely much less turbulent
- 1:37:13because it doesn't require the sort of like,
- 1:37:16I heard you not wanting to put on the pedestal humans,
- 1:37:21but for myself, I'm reluctant to take humans
- 1:37:25out of the equation as being worthy of consideration.
- 1:37:29And so when I think to myself,
- 1:37:32is it possible to experience the mind of a fungi?
- 1:37:37And my sense is that the consumption of psilocybin
- 1:37:41is about as close probably as we will get directly anyways,
- 1:37:44outside of maybe other possible circumstances
- 1:37:47that I couldn't really speak to and don't really know,
- 1:37:50because there's something to me,
- 1:37:52there's something to that.
- 1:37:53If we consider, if we don't eliminate,
- 1:37:55don't put humans on a pedestal,
- 1:37:57but don't eliminate humans from the equation.
- 1:37:59If humans say are the planets sense organs for beauty,
- 1:38:04maybe they're also the planets sense organs for suffering.
- 1:38:07I think it was,
- 1:38:08oh, Tic Nhat Hanh, who said something like,
- 1:38:15encouraging us to learn how to hear
- 1:38:19the cry of the earth within us,
- 1:38:21like to hear the pain of the earth as it cries through us,
- 1:38:25maybe we could be sense organs for its pain.
- 1:38:28And when I think about outside of what I assume
- 1:38:32to be the consequence of horizontal gene transfer
- 1:38:35that got psilocybin into this cicada infecting fungi,
- 1:38:40we look at where these mushrooms generally were,
- 1:38:45while they were most flush in areas
- 1:38:47where significant ecological destruction just took place,
- 1:38:50even still in Mexico,
- 1:38:51it's like in the cracks of the mudslides
- 1:38:54and so on and so forth.
- 1:38:55And even now, where do we see them?
- 1:38:57We see them on the edges of grasslands
- 1:38:59where the ground's been all churned up,
- 1:39:01the grass-loving fungi,
- 1:39:02or in the growing in the dung of cows
- 1:39:07that are consuming the grass,
- 1:39:11cows obviously at this point being the consequence
- 1:39:13of agriculture and the discretion wrought onto the earth
- 1:39:16to forward our sort of animal agriculture,
- 1:39:19animal husbandry.
- 1:39:21And on the edges of settlements
- 1:39:22where the wild sort of intersects with humanity,
- 1:39:27where the churning up and the damage is there,
- 1:39:29but it hasn't been completely tamped out,
- 1:39:31then we see the budding of the settlement ciada
- 1:39:34and the cyanescence and the rest.
- 1:39:36And it makes me wonder,
- 1:39:37if we think about the larger ecology of the world
- 1:39:42as having its own kind of mind
- 1:39:43and everything playing its kind of part,
- 1:39:46is there something about why the effects of psilocybin
- 1:39:49seem to directly impact the only creatures
- 1:39:52that we know of capable of perceiving beauty
- 1:39:56and to position ourselves
- 1:39:58as though we could experience the pain
- 1:40:02of the larger organism that is the planet?
- 1:40:04Could there be some sort of evolutionary role
- 1:40:07that they're playing in trying to help the,
- 1:40:09as Dennis McKenna says,
- 1:40:10like help wake up the monkeys or something to this effect?
- 1:40:15I know I'm going way out there.
- 1:40:16I don't expect you to get on board with me here,
- 1:40:19but I think about this quite a lot.
- 1:40:22I don't wanna go, I try to wager on ambivalence,
- 1:40:26but yeah.
- 1:40:27- I think you raised some really provocative ideas.
- 1:40:30I think that for,
- 1:40:32I think perhaps I've gained a great sense of peace
- 1:40:40from the idea that we're not what it's all about.
- 1:40:45That we're late comers to the show.
- 1:40:48We've created immense damage to the biosphere, obviously.
- 1:40:53I don't know, I get some sense of,
- 1:40:58it sounds like a masochism, doesn't it?
- 1:41:00Some sense of elevation from sort of just recognizing
- 1:41:03our limitations and this brief candle,
- 1:41:08what was that?
- 1:41:10It was Shakespeare, but Dawkins used that, didn't he?
- 1:41:14We're here for a while, we flicker.
- 1:41:17It's a tale told by an idiot,
- 1:41:20full of sound and fury signifying nothing.
- 1:41:24What's that?
- 1:41:24Yeah.
- 1:41:25So, yeah.
- 1:41:27- Yeah, I can appreciate that.
- 1:41:29- He's on.
- 1:41:30- See, the piece for me is,
- 1:41:36here's the metaphor, anthropomorphic.
- 1:41:42I grew up in a family.
- 1:41:45At some point I decided to be a man
- 1:41:47and I grew up in a family, at some point I decided
- 1:41:50I was better than that family.
- 1:41:52And I move away and I do a bunch of terribly selfish,
- 1:41:56horrible things and I hurt a lot of people.
- 1:41:59And some were along, including my family,
- 1:42:01and some were along the way I grew up
- 1:42:03and I realized, oh my God, what the fuck was I thinking?
- 1:42:06Like, I'm not better than anyone.
- 1:42:10Why did I make myself so alone?
- 1:42:11Why did I hurt all these beings that are my family?
- 1:42:15And then I turned back towards that family
- 1:42:17and the family says, you're still family.
- 1:42:19Come on back.
- 1:42:24That's the piece for me,
- 1:42:27is that that could still be possible.
- 1:42:30- Yeah.
- 1:42:35I didn't have a falling out with my family like that,
- 1:42:45but I have perhaps an equally profound experience
- 1:42:49at the age of, I'm 62 now, so 60 years old,
- 1:42:52close to my 60th birthday.
- 1:42:54I got an email from a guy in Scotland and he said,
- 1:42:59I hope this email doesn't upset you.
- 1:43:01I'm almost certain that I'm your full blood
- 1:43:04biological brother.
- 1:43:06- Whoa.
- 1:43:07- I had no idea at all.
- 1:43:10And so over the last two years,
- 1:43:13I just met him and his wife in Scotland
- 1:43:18for the third time we've met in three years.
- 1:43:21And we're discovering a whole side to our lives
- 1:43:26that we never knew existed.
- 1:43:28So I've got a new family now in the UK,
- 1:43:31to which I'm related genetically.
- 1:43:34I was adopted as was he.
- 1:43:36And we managed to get through 60 years without ever
- 1:43:42encountering each other.
- 1:43:46- So that is so cool.
- 1:43:48It's so wild.
- 1:43:49- For this, it's really wild.
- 1:43:51And our biological parents have both passed away
- 1:43:56a long time ago, but their story is pretty amazing.
- 1:44:02That doesn't relate to anything you were saying, does it?
- 1:44:06But there you go, I'm getting it off.
- 1:44:07You get to talk about your experience
- 1:44:09of finding your way back to your family.
- 1:44:12I suppose I'm still in that.
- 1:44:13I'm in that process now in a way that I didn't imagine
- 1:44:17possible a few years ago.
- 1:44:19So there you go.
- 1:44:21- I mean, I described it more like a metaphor
- 1:44:23for humanity's departure from the sort of like
- 1:44:26the family of life on the planet.
- 1:44:28And also when I turned about 20, I was like,
- 1:44:32fuck y'all, I'm out travel.
- 1:44:34I do what I want.
- 1:44:34I'm my own person.
- 1:44:35I know better than everyone.
- 1:44:37And then at some point somewhere along the lines,
- 1:44:39I was like, oh, actually,
- 1:44:43that might've been a little youthful hubrants.
- 1:44:45And I mean, the hurting people,
- 1:44:47we all end up hurting people.
- 1:44:49I was trying to directly relate it to sort of as a metaphor
- 1:44:52for humanity and our relationship with the living world.
- 1:44:56But it's still a thing that I share
- 1:45:00because it feels personally relevant.
- 1:45:02And that's cool that you shared what you did there.
- 1:45:05But let's bring it all to a final close here.
- 1:45:09- Yeah.
- 1:45:10- And the final close is effectively,
- 1:45:13this has been great, thank you.
- 1:45:15For people who are listening,
- 1:45:18how do they maybe hold up your book again there,
- 1:45:21"Mushrooms, Mold and Medicine."
- 1:45:23Tell them how they can get more information about it,
- 1:45:26where they could buy it,
- 1:45:27as well as where they might follow your work
- 1:45:31if you have social media, anything like that.
- 1:45:33- Yeah, if you look, I have a website.
- 1:45:37So it's themycologist.com, one word.
- 1:45:42You'll find a lot of stuff there and what?
- 1:45:49Googling my full name,
- 1:45:52you'll find presentations and so forth.
- 1:45:55But I'm anti-diluvian in my lack of engagement
- 1:46:00with social media.
- 1:46:03I don't engage in anything,
- 1:46:06Facebook, Instagram, and so forth.
- 1:46:08Much to my detriment, I'm sure,
- 1:46:10but that's partly how I maintain my psychic peace.
- 1:46:15- Your sanity maybe.
- 1:46:18- My sanity, yeah.
- 1:46:20Yeah, such as it is, yeah.
- 1:46:25- Well, I will be sure to include links to all of that
- 1:46:27in the show notes to this episode at jameswbuJesso.com.
- 1:46:31Dr. Nicholas Money, thank you again so much
- 1:46:33for coming on the show today.
- 1:46:35- Thank you for an totally absorbing conversation.
- 1:46:38I'm looking at the time now,
- 1:46:39we've been talking for three days or something like that.
- 1:46:41(laughing)
- 1:46:42It's fantastic.
- 1:46:43- 100 years last night.
- 1:46:44- Anyway, have a good rest of your week.
- 1:46:47Thank you for inviting me.
- 1:46:48- And cut.
- 1:46:50Okay, so that's all for this episode.
- 1:46:54Thank you for tuning in.
- 1:46:55If you liked Nicholas, please do check out his work.
- 1:46:57Check out Mushrooms, Molds, and Medicine.
- 1:47:00Check out the Mycologist, his blog,
- 1:47:03and check out his paper,
- 1:47:05Hyphal and Mycelial Consciousness,
- 1:47:07The Concept of the Fungal Mine.
- 1:47:09I've made sure to put links to all of that
- 1:47:11in the show notes to this episode at jameswJesso.com.
- 1:47:15And if you like what I do,
- 1:47:17if you're interested in what I do,
- 1:47:19if you're not already subscribed to the podcast,
- 1:47:21please do so, be it on your favorite podcatcher or on YouTube.
- 1:47:26And if whatever app you're on has the option for you to
- 1:47:32star or like or double tap or comment or rates
- 1:47:36or whatever it might be that the app allows for,
- 1:47:40if you have that opportunity,
- 1:47:42please do so to let the algorithms know
- 1:47:44that my podcast is one that people like
- 1:47:47so that it gets recommended to others, much appreciated.
- 1:47:49And if you'd like to follow me,
- 1:47:51you can do so on social media @jameswJesso,
- 1:47:54on Twitter, Facebook, and threads.
- 1:47:57Or you can follow me on @attmindpodcast,
- 1:48:02@minepodcast on Instagram where I share clips,
- 1:48:07thoughts, ideas, stories, this kind of stuff.
- 1:48:11If you don't wanna rely on the algorithm,
- 1:48:13you can sign up for my email newsletter
- 1:48:15or for the Telegram group,
- 1:48:17links for which are in the description to this episode,
- 1:48:20wherever you're checking it out.
- 1:48:21And that's all.
- 1:48:22Thank you so much for tuning in to this episode
- 1:48:24of Adventures Through the Mine.
- 1:48:25I've been your host, James W. Jesso.
- 1:48:27And until the next episode, take care, stay curious.