Latest / Raising Men / The Golden Mean of Courage with Boad Swanson
Transcript
- 0:07Hi, we're back once again with Boad Swanson.
- 0:10I asked Boad to come on and just have an informal chat with me today because I'd like to start going through the virtues that he's identified in his book, Great Souled Men.
- 0:21Link obviously is in the show notes.
- 0:23Boad, welcome back to raising men.
- 0:25Thanks, Shaun Thanks for inviting me back again.
- 0:27I love being here.
- 0:28it's it's great to chat with you.
- 0:29Boad and I, just for the listeners, Boad and I have such a great time talking.
- 0:34We we spend so much more time talking than we actually than we spend recording.
- 0:39It's it's really funny.
- 0:40And we've got a nice little blossoming buddy hood going here.
- 0:44And I just wanted to w just just for this segment, I just wanted to have a discussion about I I am so impressed with
- 0:52the impact that this philosophy has had on your life, just what you've done in terms of where you were, and then, you know, just deciding to get your stuff together and then and
- 1:03then where you ended up as a result of of that focus.
- 1:06It was it's it's a really inspiring tale, just by itself, but it's also a good model for what we can, you know, how we can help our our young men in, you know, transition into
- 1:19Flourishing adulthood.
- 1:21And so with that, the first virtue I wanted to inspect somewhat is the virtue of courage.
- 1:28It's the first, it's the first virtue that you cover in your book.
- 1:31And and so how did Aristotle define courage?
- 1:35Well, great question.
- 1:37He considered courage a as did the Stoics.
- 1:40I'm it's not I'm not to get off and not answering your question directly, but and I will, but it's interesting to compare Aristotle to the Stoics.
- 1:48I agree.
- 1:49popular by Ryan Holliday, right?
- 1:51Who's done such a great job with bringing to light Marcus Aurelius and Seneca and Epictetus.
- 1:57~
- 1:58but the the Stoics and Aristotle both considered courage to be among the cardinal virtues.
- 2:05And I like Aristotle's way of viewing courage.
- 2:09I think we talked about this in one of our other episodes, but courage is kind of
- 2:13This balance between too much courage becomes recklessness, not enough courage becomes cowardice.
- 2:21So courage is knowing what's important.
- 2:25And knowing when to risk yourself, your life, your time, your social capital, or whatever on something that is worthy of your time, of your body, of your life.
- 2:36if you're if if you don't know that anyone is inside your burning house, but you run in any
- 2:40Yeah.
- 2:41That's a really, really interesting way to look at it.
- 2:44And I, you know, I've read I've read the chapter on on courage.
- 2:48I've read a lot of Marcus Relius.
- 2:50I've listened to Ryan Holiday.
- 2:51I've read a bunch of his books.
- 2:52I'm a fan.
- 2:53And yet, this is the first time that that that that that has really been understandable to me, which is that.
- 2:59Okay, courage is the resolution.
- 3:02What I'm hearing, and I'd love for your feedback on this, but courage is the resolution between the two tensions between or b of the tension between I I wanna use the word
- 3:12cowardice, but I would I wish there was a word that that that meant ~ conservativeness, right?
- 3:18You know, like like caution, caution.
- 3:21That's the right term.
- 3:22That's the
- 3:22right term.
- 3:23Yeah, too much caution is cowardice.
- 3:25So cowardice is on on the way left hand side of of that of that tension.
- 3:31And then on the far right hand side of that tension is recklessness.
- 3:36Yes.
- 3:37And so and and the spectrum is about, you know, more or less caution.
- 3:42I think that's probably a good definition there.
- 3:44And
- 3:44I and I think Aristotle would say that it's appropriate to feel fear.
- 3:50When there's something that is creating tension in us and we know that it's probably what needs to be done, it's okay to feel fear, but to go anyway, right?
- 3:59Or to proceed
- 4:01Because y we know that at the other side of fear is an outcome that is gonna put us in a much better situation.
- 4:08We save our family, we
- 4:10we we stand up to the bully or whatever.
- 4:14On the flip side
- 4:15The caution or the or the cowardice comes when we freeze, when we haven't developed the muscle to recognize fear and go anyway, fight through it, but we freeze.
- 4:26That's this overabundance of caution that can hopefully never for any of any of us who are listening or talking here, ever dip into cowardice.
- 4:35That's like I feel like that's the
- 4:38A f a deep DNA level fear that all men have of being a coward, of not being able to stand up for ourselves and do what's needed at the right time in the right situation, right?
- 4:49so the so I think and all of us from the time we're little boys or little girls, like we have these little micro opportunities to develop courage, to develop a sense of when is it
- 5:01appropriate for me to stand up and move past like this.
- 5:04And when is it more appropriate for me to like that?
- 5:06It's not worth it.
- 5:07You gotta develop that sixth
- 5:10sense about it.
- 5:11Yeah, I think that there's in my life, there's there's been this kind of trip this three layered understanding of what courage is.
- 5:18And the in the in the most shallow layer, I think I would have understood it to be I would have thought of courage as absence of fear, right?
- 5:26And and then so the first lesson that I learned when I was younger is no, no, courage isn't an absence of fear, courage is pushing through that fear.
- 5:33You know, that and that's sort of the second one.
- 5:34But then the the realization that I've just had now about the, you know, given your formulation is no, no, courage is the the midpoint or the the the the resolution of the
- 5:46tension between on that on that caution spectrum between
- 5:50cowardice and recklessness.
- 5:52And courage is the sweet spot.
- 5:55And
- 5:55that sweet spot, the way you get to the sweet spot, is what you said just a moment ago.
- 6:00Knowing what you should be choosing, knowing what the
- 6:04right answer is.
- 6:05~
- 6:06you know where I think that comes from?
- 6:08Sorry to interrupt, Sean.
- 6:09It's
- 6:09ahead.
- 6:09it's born I think out of experience.
- 6:12Absolutely.
- 6:13And and so I had a I had a golf instructor one time, a golf pro, teach me at the end of my swing.
- 6:20I'm a terrible golfer, but I picked the I I in basket awfulness.
- 6:26~
- 6:27but he told me like at the end of your swing at the top of it, hold it.
- 6:32Look at where the ball's going and think about your swing.
- 6:35What you do right?
- 6:36that's the training.
- 6:37Right there, right?
- 6:38That's the training.
- 6:38And that's where wisdom develops.
- 6:40Cause then you can go back after you act or don't act in any given situation and say, What is what outcome am I dealing with now that was brought on by my decision, by my emotions,
- 6:54by my fear, by my recklessness or whatever.
- 6:56so we ha I think the more we're kind of tested, we develop this experience which leads to wisdom.
- 7:03And wisdom is the application of knowledge, right?
- 7:07So we have to experience it at small levels, push through at small levels, so that when the time comes we know how to push through, whether it's physical courage or moral moral
- 7:16cou cou courage.
- 7:17Right?
- 7:17Same thing.
- 7:18Yeah.
- 7:19Yeah, I I I had a guest who who was a a former Navy SEAL named Eric Davis and he talked about he talked about fear is actually the raw material for courage.
- 7:30That's cool.
- 7:31And and that there is a point where the fear stops kind of washing off.
- 7:36And and that you know, and that's kind of specific to everybody, but is but but that's like you know, that and that that that's kind of what he said.
- 7:44He he had a book called Raising Men, which is kind of one of the one the inspirations for this whole podcast.
- 7:50And and
- 7:51And that's the way that he described the relationship between fear and courage.
- 7:55I thought that was really helpful.
- 7:56I it it it draws me back to when I was single.
- 7:59One of the most practical examples of fighting through fear is asking a girl on a date.
- 8:07Remember that?
- 8:07Yeah, yeah.
- 8:08I remember when I first asked my wife out on a date.
- 8:12I didn't know.
- 8:13You don't know.
- 8:14And so there's this tension like
- 8:16There's social capital.
- 8:17There's is she gonna am I gonna do it wrong?
- 8:19Am I gonna say the wrong thing?
- 8:20Is she gonna think I'm a I'm gross or I'm a loser or whatever?
- 8:24And so you rehearse in your mind ~ the scenario and what you're gonna say and how she's gonna react and whatever.
- 8:30But then when you actually get the courage to walk to her, you know, and you're face to face and
- 8:35you say, Hey, you know, whatever, we wanna go on a date or whatever, like there's so much build up in that.
- 8:41And I just remember
- 8:42her response and she actually like complimented me.
- 8:45She's like, You did a good job you know, like in the way
- 8:48ha.
- 8:48and and she said yes and she smiled and it just
- 8:54that you needed that.
- 8:55Yeah.
- 8:55Yeah.
- 8:56What a great
- 8:58little microcosm about what, you know, a a a good healthy relationship dynamic, actually.
- 9:04Where,
- 9:05you know, she like like you worked up the courage.
- 9:08You you did the the masculine thing and she and and she played the feminine role.
- 9:14And and and that
- 9:16she's like, I've been asked out many times before and you did a good job.
- 9:19That was fun.
- 9:20It was lighthearted.
- 9:21It was like whatever and it made her made me laugh, made me smile.
- 9:24And ~ but that's
- 9:26like I kinda miss those days, right?
- 9:28'Cause it's like the most exhilarating thing when it works out.
- 9:32I mean obviously I've I've been been at the other end of that too, where it doesn't work out and it's like, gosh, I gotta like look at my golf swing.
- 9:38I gotta like hold it and see what I did wrong or maybe this
- 9:40but that's ~ such a good example.
- 9:42And I don't know how much boys are asking girls out anymore, but boy, it's a lost art and it's it's a great practicing ground to develop these 'cause you need it in business, you
- 9:52need it in life, you need it in you know, it's handling difficult situations in your community and family and everything else.
- 9:58Yeah, the the
- 10:00the the a lot of dating now well and I and maybe we're coming out of this.
- 10:03I don't know because I mean my kids aren't old enough to be in the dating world.
- 10:08but a lot of dating is happening on the apps.
- 10:12And the apps take that away.
- 10:14the apps make it trivial to, you know.
- 10:17Introduce yourself.
- 10:18Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 10:19Stakes are yeah, and and
- 10:21feedback when you when you go to approach a woman and you ask her on a date or whatever, there's you know that like this is either gonna go one way or the other.
- 10:31With the dating app, it's like maybe she didn't read it, maybe she's like, you know, come up with all kinds
- 10:37of scenarios.
- 10:38right.
- 10:38And it lets you it it lets on on the on the on the recipient of the of the of the asking out side, it lets them kind of not be not do the courageous thing, which is actually say
- 10:51what you think and let the if if you aren't interested, you can just ghost the person.
- 10:57And
- 10:57and that's not who you wanna be.
- 10:59th that that that's that's lack of courage, right?
- 11:02Yeah, the courageous thing to do in that circumstance is to say, Man, I really appreciate it.
- 11:07but I'm in a different place and I I'm not interested right now.
- 11:11There's there's a couple examples I use and I'm not gonna give the whole ~ book away, obviously, but there's a couple examples I use of the type of courage.
- 11:20And can I t talk about those just real quick, each one?
- 11:23do.
- 11:23Yeah.
- 11:24Okay, so there's like moral courage, and then there's physical courage.
- 11:28And I think they're kinda
- 11:29They're probably in the first story the same thing.
- 11:33So the story I tell is of Desmond Das.
- 11:35If anyone has seen the movie Hacksaw Ridge, really powerful story, but d Desmond Das is a seventh day adventist and he's a pacifist and he doesn't want to fight.
- 11:44So he's in World War Two, he's a medic, doesn't carry a gun, he gets ridiculed.
- 11:48But right there is where the courage starts.
- 11:50He's like, I'm gonna stand for my faith and I'm not gonna be bullied by these guys, even though even when it's just good natured.
- 11:57And then it gets more serious when he won't carry a gun and all these guys are like
- 12:01What is your problem?
- 12:02we're dying here and you ref so he has to stand up again in the face of that scrutiny.
- 12:07And then at at the actual battle of of Hacksaw Ridge, he goes out into the ambush, into exploding bombs and the gunfire, and he continues to grab injured marines and drag them to
- 12:22the precipice of this cliff and lower down.
- 12:24So so the c through the course of the night he runs back into battle over and over and over without a gun.
- 12:29risking his life just to save his friends.
- 12:33I think seven I I don't remember off the top of my head, but 74 times, I think.
- 12:3674 minutes.
- 12:38Amazing.
- 12:38Amazing that to have, but that's moral courage and that's physical courage.
- 12:43but there's something like when I went went to ask my wife out, there was there was like something in my gut where I just knew I had to do it.
- 12:53And if I didn't do it, then I would feel like a chump.
- 12:56I would feel like a loser and I wouldn't be able to live with myself.
- 12:59There was something that was driving me that that was, and I think that is a part of courage.
- 13:05And that's how we develop the sense as to whether or not it is just for us to risk something.
- 13:11Because it's in our gut and we can't deny it.
- 13:14Like when we know that we have to proceed and ask the girl out, or we have to stand up for.
- 13:19ourself to our boss, or we have to go to our community HOA and and let them know like you can't treat our our section whatever, you know.
- 13:29~
- 13:30so and then there's this other type of courage that I I use which is the person I use to describe this story is the head coach of Oregon, University of Oregon football, Dan
- 13:38Lanning.
- 13:39They're not having great year this year, but he is he's amazing.
- 13:42In the book I tell the story of, you know, he's
- 13:45He's twenty three years old, he's coaching high school football, hates it.
- 13:50He doesn't hate it.
- 13:50He loves coaching but he but he starts to feel in his gut like
- 13:53There's can I be more than can I can I do more than coach high school football?
- 13:58So long story short, he goes he starts on this path where he's denied and he's suffers financially and he has to take steps backwards and he has to go through all of these like
- 14:11Homic level challenges just to become what what he is now.
- 14:15And we see Dan Lanning or any of these other coaches and we say, gosh, like I should have been a coach.
- 14:21how hard could it be?
- 14:22But you don't see the story of he and his wife fighting through bankruptcy and food stamps and cancer and cross-country moves and demotions and pay cuts and all of this.
- 14:38But he this is like courage sustained over 15 years, right?
- 14:43And then he gets the prize.
- 14:45And then even when you have the prize.
- 14:47They stink this year.
- 14:48Right.
- 14:50Right.
- 14:51he will get fired, but it's like it never ends.
- 14:53So you have to have developed ~ this sixth synths muscle in you to like know what's worthy of your courage and to fight for it.
- 15:02Yeah.
- 15:03I
- 15:03There, I had a guest named Dila McCullough.
- 15:06And he had kind of a similar he's he's got a great story.
- 15:08And that's it's one of my one of my favorite discussions what was was with him.
- 15:13But one of the things that really sort of blew me away about his story is I mean this guy this guy grew up in really, really, really tough circumstances.
- 15:24Really tough.
- 15:25And
- 15:26just continued to have everything taken away from him.
- 15:29At every freaking turn, he would build, he would get to the point where he was, you know, building himself up.
- 15:35He got, you know, it was he for example, he was, you know, he finally got to play professional football after all these years of trying and blew out his knee.
- 15:45And then right.
- 15:47And then, you know, so your career's over at at that point.
- 15:50And then basically started from scratch after that.
- 15:53And then, but this guy, I mean, literally five or six times in in his live story, was completely like having to start totally from scratch.
- 16:02And as a result of that, one of the things that and I and I said this to him, I just so admired about him was he has zero trepidation about starting from scratch.
- 16:12If I had to start from scratch right now, I would be terrified.
- 16:16And this guy has done it so many times that, you know, you that's just what you do.
- 16:21And he knows deep down in his heart, the the the he knows deep down in his heart that he'll succeed because he succeeded every single time.
- 16:31And I think
- 16:32I don't know that about myself.
- 16:34I haven't had to start from scratch, except
- 16:37Except, once or twice.
- 16:38And I haven't had everything taken away.
- 16:40And I've I know I've I've, kinda had this lucky run.
- 16:43And I I don't have the the same moral conviction that he has or or the same like you know, sense of of
- 16:52be surprised though, 'cause s cause some of the skills that you're developing or that we're all developing are not called upon in the same way that they are for the guests that
- 17:01you're talking about, I forget his name.
- 17:04Dila McCullough.
- 17:05So
- 17:05so some of the skills that he developed through all of his adversity, w he was called on to use those where you and I might not be.
- 17:14But
- 17:15What I see just for example, d since we're talking a little bit about you specifically and you saying you don't might not have that, the fact that you you know you and I have talked
- 17:23about the rigor that it takes to produce podcasts and
- 17:28and how many podcasts it takes
- 17:30to an hours of editing and social media and marketing and all of that to get to a point where you start to actually ~ hit critical mass.
- 17:40And through all of that you're were developing this level of resilience and just like the Dan Lanning story.
- 17:46Like he knew in his gut that he had to do something.
- 17:50And if Dan Lanning or you or I were to fall on our face and get fired, there's something that we've built coming
- 17:58from that drive and our that fire in the belly kind of gut instinct that
- 18:03has developed resilience in you that I bet if you and I and ninety percent of the men who are listening to this were called upon to start from scratch, we'd do it.
- 18:12Because you got that
- 18:13fire in the belly.
- 18:13I think that's right.
- 18:14And in fact it would be a blessing because you would cut out all the unnecessary stuff.
- 18:19Well it's a blessing none of us are asking for though, right?
- 18:21exactly right.
- 18:21That's exactly right.
- 18:23Well, I think that's a great place to leave this off.
- 18:25again, the the book is called Great Sold Men.
- 18:28You can see the the link in the show notes.
- 18:31I I I have been just really, really enjoying it.
- 18:34And and we'll continue having these discussions to talk about the the specific virtues.
- 18:39And and again, Bo, thanks again.
- 18:41And and to all of you listening, you are a great parent.