Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use the Pygmalion Effect to Boost Your Team's Performance
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's a classic study from the late 1960s — Robert Rosenthal and Lenore Jacobson at a California elementary school. They told teachers that certain students were 'intellectual bloomers,' based on a fake test. The twist? Those students were actually chosen at random. Luna: And I'm guessing those randomly selected kids ended up doing better? Lucas: Exactly. By the end of the year, the 'bloomers' showed significantly larger IQ gains than their peers. The teachers' expectations — communicated subtly through tone, body language, more encouragement, more challenging questions — actually shaped the students' performance. Luna: That's the Pygmalion Effect. Expect more, get more. It's been replicated in workplaces too, right? Lucas: Hundreds of times. In military settings, in corporate training programs, in sales teams. When a manager genuinely believes a direct report has high potential, that person tends to deliver. The mechanism is a cascade of small behavioral shifts: more eye contact, more constructive feedback, more opportunities to stretch. Luna: But the opposite is also true — the Golem Effect. Low expectations become a self-fulfilling prophecy. Lucas: Right. If you signal to someone that you think they're average or worse, they'll likely perform to that bar. And the tragedy is a lot of managers don't realize they're doing it. They think they're being 'realistic' when they're actually capping their team's potential. Luna: So how do you intentionally use the Pygmalion Effect without being fake? You can't just tell yourself 'I expect more' and have it work. Lucas: The key is genuine belief, which sounds like a paradox — how do you manufacture belief? But you can start with what I call the 'two-millimeter challenge.' Instead of asking someone to double their output, ask them to stretch just slightly beyond what they think they can do. A small, credible increase. Luna: Two millimeters — I like that. So you're essentially recalibrating your own expectation to be just above their current self-assessment. Lucas: Yes. And then you back it up with specific, behaviorally anchored feedback. Not 'great job,' but 'I noticed how you handled that objection in the meeting — you paused and let the client finish, then reframed their concern. That's a skill that'll serve you well.' That kind of feedback communicates that you see real competence. Luna: It also signals that you're paying close attention, which itself raises the stakes for the employee. Lucas: Exactly. There's also a verbal cue: use language that implies future success as a given. Instead of 'if you get this promotion,' say 'when you move into that role.' It's a small shift but it plants a seed. Luna: But what if the person genuinely isn't capable? Doesn't the Pygmalion Effect crash against reality? Lucas: Fair question. The effect works best when there's a gap between current performance and potential — not when someone is completely mismatched for the role. So you need judgment. But I'd argue most people are operating below their potential because no one has ever expected more of them in a structured way. Luna: So it's not about delusion — it's about creating conditions for growth. Lucas: Exactly. And there's a fascinating organizational layer to this too. Companies that systematically communicate high expectations — through things like stretch assignments, leadership development programs, even the way they write job descriptions — tend to outperform. It's baked into their culture. Luna: I read about a study at a big tech company — they randomized which junior engineers got assigned to 'high potential' tracks. The ones labeled high potential, even when the label was arbitrary, had higher performance ratings and retention two years later. Lucas: That's the Pygmalion Effect in the wild. And it's one reason why early-career sponsorship is so powerful. When a senior leader publicly backs a junior person, that expectation cascades through the organization. Luna: But there's a dark side, right? If expectations become too high, you can crush someone. Lucas: Absolutely. The Pygmalion Effect has a ceiling. If you set expectations that are wildly unrealistic, you create anxiety and burnout. The trick is to calibrate — stretch, but don't snap. And to combine high expectations with high support. That's the classic high-expectations, high-warmth leadership style. Luna: It's also worth noting that the effect can backfire if it feels manipulative. If an employee senses that you're just 'trying a technique,' it erodes trust. Lucas: That's why it has to be genuine. You can't fake belief for long. But you can actively look for evidence of potential, and then let that evidence shape your expectation. It's a virtuous cycle. Luna: So practically, what's a first step for a manager listening who wants to try this tomorrow? Lucas: Pick one direct report and identify one area where you think they could be just a little better. Then, in your next one-on-one, give them a specific, positive example of something they did recently — and then say something like, 'I think you could be really strong at X. Let's work on that together.' That's it. Luna: And watch what happens. It's almost like a self-fulfilling prophecy, but in a good way. Lucas: Right. And here's a quick honest thing — we do this show ad-free, and that's because a handful of listeners chip in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small group, but it's literally what keeps us going. So if the show has helped you think through a career move or a leadership challenge, that's the way to keep it ad-free. Luna: Yeah, it's a simple model. And we're grateful it works. So back to the Pygmalion Effect — I think the biggest takeaway is that expectations are contagious. If you as a leader raise yours, it ripples out. Lucas: Exactly. And the flip side — the Golem Effect — is just as contagious. So the question to ask yourself is: what expectations am I broadcasting that I don't realize? That's the real office politics move — to become aware of the signals you're sending. Luna: And to intentionally choose to see the potential in others, even when the evidence isn't fully there yet. Lucas: Because the evidence often follows the belief. That's the Pygmalion Effect in a nutshell. Thanks for listening, and we'll be back with another episode soon.